Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 165 of 2022
Date of Decision: 24.03.2023
Shri. Wonstar Nongrum
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. V.K. Jindal, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. V. Kumar, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA (For R 1-4)
Mr. K. Kharmawphlang, Adv. (For R 5)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The writ petitioner is before this Court in this second round of
litigation, praying for sanction of monthly pension and other
consequential financial benefits. The case of the petitioner is that, as his
case for regularization was delayed inordinately, he had earlier
approached this Court by way of WP(C) No. 292 of 2018, and after orders
were passed therein for consideration, the services of the petitioner was
regularized from the date of joining service, but however, due to
objections to the date of regularization, the respondents have not till date
finalized his monthly pension. The petitioner is also aggrieved with the
letter dated 13.10.2021, wherein it has been informed that the petitioner is
not entitled the benefit of financial upgradation under the ACP/MACP
Scheme and letter dated 22.03.2022, directing him to refund the amounts
already drawn.
2.
The petitioner had entered service as a peon in the Education
Department on 16.08.1982, as a casual employee and after completion of
4 years from the date of his initial appointment, his case along with 2
others similarly situated casual employees was taken up for consideration
for regularization. Thereafter, it appears though representations were filed
by the petitioner for regularization, the same was not effected and it was
only in 20.07.1997, when the Education Department initiated the process
for conversion of the post of casual employees, that the name of the
petitioner along with 7 others, was forwarded for creation of their
respective posts in the Department. However, due to the re-designation of
the office of the petitioner as the Directorate of Education Research and
Training from the State Council of Educational Research and Training,
Meghalaya, when the names of 6 casual employees was forwarded for
regularization, the name of the petitioner, due to oversight, did not figure
in the said list. The mistake was noticed by the respondents and
subsequently the name of the petitioner was forwarded. The Department
then by letter dated 30.01.2004, conveyed the Government’s approval for
conversion of 8 casual employees into regular employees and
consequently the services of 7 casual employees was regularized with
effect from 30.01.2004, which however, did not include the petitioner, in
view of the fact, that he was earlier appointed as officiating peon.
3.
Though this mistake was realised, and regretted by the respondents
who issued a rectification letter, the case of the petitioner was being
pushed back and forth without any positive development, which made him
approach this Court by way of WP(C) No. 292 of 2018. The writ petition
was then disposed of on 29.08.2018, with the direction to ensure that a
decision be taken on the basis of the recommendations made for
regularization, as per applicable rules and regulations within a period of
2(two) weeks. The respondent No. 1, then vide letter dated 07.09.2018,
conveyed the approval of the competent authority to include the name of
the petitioner in the list along with other similar cases of ad hoc
employees, but however, as no formal order of regularization was issued,
the petitioner through his counsel, issued a legal notice dated 18.02.2019.
The respondent No. 2 then vide office order dated 30.03.2019, conveyed
to the petitioner that his services were regularized from the date of joining.
4.
After the order dated 30.03.2019, whereby the services of the
petitioner stood regularized, the respondent No. 2 vide office order dated
21.11.2019, allowed the petitioner to draw the benefit of extended pay
scale of Rs. 2900-65-3875/- and then by office order dated 05.05.2020,
granted first and second financial upgradation under the Assured Career
Progressive Scheme (ACP), and the third financial upgradation under
MACP, on the basis that the regularization was effective from 23.07.1982.
The respondent No. 2, then forwarded the pension papers to the
respondent No. 5, which however were returned for re-submission after
seeking clarification on the regulation of pay. This was then clarified by
the respondent No. 2, vide letter dated 13.07.2021, that the fixation of pay
had been made in the service roll consequent upon the grant of
ACPS/MACPS. The said letter however, did not meet with the approval
of the office of the respondent No. 4 (Finance, Pay Revision Department),
on the ground that, the petitioner was not entitled to the benefit of financial
upgradation as he was regularized w.e.f. 30.03.2019, which was indicated
in the letter dated 13.10.2021.
5.
Thereafter, the respondent No. 2, clarified vide letter dated
09.11.2021, that the grant of ACP’s to the petitioner was due to the fact
that, he was regularized w.e.f. the date of joining, that is, 23.07.1982, and
not 30.03.2019, since he had retired on 31.08.2018, and that the
government approved his regularization of service, only on 28.03.2019.
The Finance Department however, requested the respondent No. 2 to
cancel the order of grant of financial upgradations under ACP/MACP by
letter dated 10.12.2021 and advised for correction in the entries/regulation
of pay in the petitioner’s service book. By the same letter, the earlier
approved Initial Pay Statements (IPS) were also treated as cancelled.
Consequently, the respondent No. 2, in view of the letter dated
10.12.2021, issued by the Finance Department, informed the petitioner
that he was not entitled to the benefit of financial upgradation under the
ACP/MACP schemes, and directed for refund of the amounts already
drawn. The petitioner therefore being aggrieved has filed the writ petition.
6.
Mr. V.K. Jindal, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. V. Kumar,
learned counsel for the petitioner while alluding to the facts, which have
been narrated above, submits that, the impugned orders denying the
petitioner the benefit of the financial upgradation has resulted in a
stalemate, especially on the point of the date of regularization. He further
submits that, in view of this situation, the amount of pension has not been
finalized, which has caused great distress to the petitioner. He contends
that, the date of regularization having been given by the concerned
department as 16.08.1982, the non-acceptance of the same by the Finance
Department is unreasonable and arbitrary.
7.
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, learned GA on behalf of the State
respondents No. 1-4 apart from placing the affidavit filed by the
respondents, with regard to the eligibility of ad hoc casual employees or
on contract to the Assured Career Progression Schemes (ACP) has
submitted that the grant of benefit of extended scale to the petitioner did
not have the approval of the Finance Department, or any other authority.
He further submits that the respondent No. 2, could not have issued the
order dated 30.03.2019, regularizing the service of the petitioner from the
date of joining, as the same was in violation of the established rules,
executive instructions and procedure, as regularization could have been
conferred only subsequent to the date of recommendation. The counting
of regular service he submits, should commence only from the date of
absorption as a regular employee and earlier service rendered under ad
hoc/casual/contract/regulation 3(f) should not be taken into reckoning.
8.
Mr. K. Kharmawphlang, learned counsel for the respondent No. 5,
submits that the authority for release of pensionary benefits of the
petitioner could not be issued due to the non-re-submission of the pension
papers in the complete form by the concerned pension sanctioning
authority and that the delay in release of the pensionary benefits cannot be
attributed to the respondent No. 5 in any manner.
9.
Having heard the learned counsels for the parties and having
examined the materials on record, the entire dispute can be seen to have
originated from the date of regularization of services of the petitioner. It
is worthwhile to note that, pursuant to the orders passed by this Court in
WP(C) No. 292 of 2018, the respondents in the Education Department
issued orders for regularization, in compliance thereto, however by
granting regularization from the date of joining, that is, 16.08.1982. This
date being taken as the benchmark, the petitioner was then granted 3
financial upgradations under ACP/MACP schemes, and his pay regulated
accordingly. It was only on the objections of the Finance Department that,
the anomaly was detected and questions arose as to the correctness of the
date from which the petitioner was granted regular status, whereafter the
discrepancy was acknowledged and impugned orders were passed
directing for recovery of the amounts already drawn by the petitioner. This
also led to the inability of the respondents to finalize the pension of the
petitioner as his pay would have to be re-calibrated in accordance with the
relevant initial pay statement.
10.
As the matter stood deadlocked, due to the conflicting orders
which were yet to be resolved and rationalized, the result was that the
pension of the petitioner could not be finalized. The submission of the
learned Government Advocate, is noted and accepted that regularization
in normal circumstances could have been granted only after the date the
said post had been converted into a permanent post and that, the period
served on ad hoc basis shall not go towards computation of the length of
service, which would entitle an employee for Career Advancement
Schemes, in this case the ACP scheme. However, what cannot escape the
attention of this Court, is the observations in the order dated 29.08.2018,
passed in WP(C) No. 292 of 2018, wherein this Court takes note that the
proposal for the conversion of the post of casual employees of 8 persons
including the petitioner had been initiated, and their cases forwarded,
which however, due to oversight did not include the name of the petitioner.
The services of the other 7 employees, it is also noted in the order was
regularized w.e.f. 30.01.2004. Para – 3 of the order dated 29.08.2018, is
reproduced hereinbelow;
“3. Government of Meghalaya (Education
Department)
initiated
the
process
for
conversion of the post of casual employees and
forwarded case of 8 casual employees
including petitioner. The Directorate of
Education Research and Training forwarded
names of casual employees for regularization
to the Department of Education but as alleged
due to oversight the proposal sent did not
include name of petitioner which fact was
pointed out by Department of Education vide
letter dated 17th December, 1999. In response
thereto Secretary, Directorate of Educational
Research and Training vide letter dated 18th
January, 2000 regretted the mistake then
forwarded the particulars of petitioner to the
Under Secretary to the Government of
Meghalaya, Education Department. Director
of Educational Research and Training vide
letter dated 1st May, 2001 requested the
Government in Education Department for
regularization. The Department vide letter
dated
30th
January,
conveyed
Government’s approval for conversion of 8
casual employees into regular employees i.e. 7
posts in DERT and 1 post in DSEL.
Consequently services of 7 casual employees
were regularized w.e.f. 30th January, 2004
excluding the petitioner. In view of the fact
that he was earlier appointed as officiating
peon, the mistake was regretted by DERT and
rectification letter was issued. After hectic
correspondences the case of the petitioner was
not finalized.”
11.
The above quoted paragraph would clearly reflect the fact that, the
petitioner was due for regularization along with the 7 other employees,
inasmuch as, government approval was obtained for the conversion of 8
casual employees into regular employees, of which the petitioner was one
of them. However, as has been discussed earlier, due to the other
circumstances, which befell the petitioner, his case inspite of the request
of respondent No. 2 for processing his regularization, the same could not
be resolved until orders were passed by this Court, but even at that
juncture, the petitioner’s case was not well thought through, which
resulted in the regularization being given from the date of joining and
undue benefits being granted thereafter.
12.
This Court has given its anxious consideration to the matter in its
entirety to try and balance the equities, inasmuch as, in the entire sequence
of events, no party can be held solely responsible for the situation as it has
come to pass. In view of these circumstances therefore, this writ petition
is disposed of with the following directions.
(i)
The respondents are directed to re-examine the case of the
petitioner and his entitlements by taking into consideration the
undisputed fact that, his case for regularization had been proposed
and forwarded along with 7 others, as observed by this Court in the
order dated 29.08.2018, passed in WP(C) No. 292 of 2018.
(ii)
On such consideration and consequent fixation of date of
regularization, the pay shall be accordingly fixed as per the
prevalent IPS for that period and finalization of pension, thereafter
be processed and concluded.
(iii)
As the petitioner has been granted amounts for which refund
has been sought by the respondents, which was occasioned not due
to any mis-representation or wrong doing on the part of the
petitioner, there shall be no recovery of the said amounts, and
consequently the letter dated 22.03.2022 is set aside.
13.
The entire exercise as directed above shall be completed within a
period of 3(three) months from the date of this order.
14.
As ordered and directed above, the writ petition accordingly stands
disposed of.
15.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
24.03.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review