Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010806422015
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3367]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY,THE FIFTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE V SRINIVAS
APPEAL SUIT NO: 876/2015
Between:
1. WIRELESS TT INFO SERVICES LTD.,, REP. BY ITS
NATIONAL HEAD, VIOM TOWERS, PLOT NO.I4A,
SECTOR-18,
MARUTHI
INDUSTRIAL
COMPLEX,
GURGAON - 122 015.
2. WIRELESS TT INFO SERVICES LTD.,, REP. BY ITS
CIRCLE HEAD, A.P.STATE, GOWRA PLAZA, 1-8-304307/308/444, 4TH FLOOR, SARDAR PATEL ROAD,
BEGUMPET, SECUNDERABAD. (PRESENTLY KNOWN
AS "VIOM NETWORKS LIMITED" BY VIRTUE OF FRESH
CERTIFICATE OF INCORPORATION CONSEQUENT
UPON CHANGE OF NAME, DATED 10-08-2010)
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
RADHA KRISHNA CIVIL ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS,
Rep. by its proprietor Maganti Kiran, S/o.Ramakrishna
Prasad, Hindu, 36 years, Business, T-3, Shivashakt; Enclave,
Pragathi Marg, JN Road, Rajahmundry,
...RESPONDENT
to set aside the impugned judgment and decree passed by
the learned IXth ADDITIONAL DISTRICT JUDGE : WEST
GODAVARI : AT KOWUR in 0.S.No.14/2013 dt.12-08-2015 by
dismissing the suit against these appellants/defendants and
allowing the appeal in the interest of justice by awarding costs
throughout and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2015(ASMP 2525 OF 2015
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to permit Sri A.R.Subba Rao,
Manager-Legal to represent in the above appeal on behalf of the
petitioner/appellant company in the interest of justice and equity
and to pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2015(ASMP 2589 OF 2015
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to grant stay of operation of the
decree and Judgment in O.S.No.14/2013 on the file of the
learned IX Additional district judge : west godavari : at kovvur
dt.12.08.2015 including execution proceedings if any as well as
all the consequential proceedings arising pursuant to the said
decree and judgment
IA NO: 1 OF 2016(ASMP 1274 OF 2016
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased vacate the interim stay granted in
ASMP No.2589/2015 in AS No.876/2015 dated 14.12.2015
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
GHANTA SRIDHAR
Counsel for the Respondent:
N SIVA REDDY
The Court made the following:
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE V.SRINIVAS
APPEAL SUIT No.876 of 2015
JUDGMENT:
This regular appeal under Section 96 Code of Civil
Procedure (hereinafter referred to as ‘CPC’) is directed against
the decree and judgment in O.S.No.14 of 2013 dated
12.08.2015 on the file of the Court of learned IX Additional
District Judge, West Godavari at Kovvur.
2.
The
defendants,
before the
Trial Court, are the
appellants herein. The respondent herein is the plaintiff.
3.
The respondent herein instituted the suit against the
appellants for recovery of an amount of Rs.11,53,587/- with
interest @ 18% per annum and for costs.
4.
Before adverting the material and evidence on record
and nature of findings in the judgment of the Trial Court, it is
necessary to scan through the case pleaded by the parties in
their respective pleadings.
5.
For the sake of convenience, the parties hereinafter
referred to as they arrayed before the Trial Court.
6.
The case of the plaintiff in brief in the plaint was as
follows:
i). Since 2008, in and around East Godavari
District, the plaintiff Company has been doing
Civil and Electrical works for the defendant No.2,
which is under the control of defendant No.1. On
12.12.2009, the defendant No.2, entrusted the
work to the plaintiff at Malakapalli site in West
Godavari District to carryout civil and electrical
works for the defendant No.2.
ii).
While the work was in progress, the staff of
the defendant No.2 visited the spot and prepared
RFI Check list dated 25.01.2010 and furnished a
copy of the same to the plaintiff. At that time, the
staff
of
the
defendant
No.2
signed
the
measurement sheets specifying the works carried
by the plaintiff. Then the plaintiff completed the
works, the amount payable by the defendants is
Rs.7,53,668/- and submitted invoice along with
the measurement sheets.
iii).
One A.Ravi Kumar, who is the Cluster
Manager of the defendant No.2 received the same,
verified the calculations, corrected the same and
arrived at an amount of Rs.7,49,813/- as due
amount.
Then
the
plaintiff
requested
the
defendant No.2 to pay said amount. Even after
repeated demands through phone and emails, the
defendant No.2 not paid the same and postponed
the payment.
iv).
On 14.06.2012, the plaintiff got issued a
notice to the defendant No.2 for payment of the
due amount, the same was received by the
defendant No.2, but failed to pay the amount.
There is a practice prevailing in the market to pay
interest @18% per annum on the due amount and
therefore, plaintiff is entitled to the interest @ 18%
per annum from 16.02.2010. As the defendant
No.2 is under the control of the defendant No.1,
both the defendants are jointly and severally liable
to pay the suit amount.
7.
The defendant No.1 denying the allegations in the
plaint and contending in the written statement as follows:
The plaintiff did not complete the work entrusted by
the defendants as per contract and within the time
stipulated; that the check list filed by the plaintiff is
not correct and the amount payable by the
defendant
No.1
is
only
Rs.6,75,015
and
the
defendant No.1 is always ready to pay the said
amount, also obtained cheques for the amount
payable to the plaintiff; that there is no practice of
paying interest in between plaintiff and defendants,
therefore, there is no question of payment of
interest, thereby, prays to dismiss the suit with
costs.
8.
On these pleadings, the Trial Court settled the following
issues for trial:
“1.Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the disputed
suit claim with interest as claimed in the plaint?
and
2.To what relief?”
9.
At the trial, on behalf of the plaintiff, its proprietor was
examined as P.W.1 and got marked EXs.A.1 to A.9 in support
of its contentions. On behalf of the defendants, its Manager,
Circle legal head, was examined as D.W.1 without exhibiting
any documentary evidence.
10.
After evaluating the oral and documentary evidence, the
Trial Court concluded that the plaintiff proved his claim and
is entitled to recover the suit amount, after deducting the
amounts paid by the defendants during the pendency of the
suit, with subsequent interest @ 18% per annum on the
principle due amount of Rs.7,49,813 from 14.12.2013 to till
realization and the plaintiff is entitled for the interest on the
balance principal amount after deducting the amount paid by
the defendants during the pendency of the suit, thus, decreed
the suit with costs.
11.
It
is
against
this
decree
and
appellants/defendants preferred this appeal.
judgment,
the
12.
Heard Sri Ghanta Sridhar, learned counsel for the
appellants/defendants and Sri N.Siva Reddy, learned counsel
for the respondent/plaintiff.
13.
The only contention raised by the learned counsel for
the defendants is that the rate of interest claimed and
awarded by the Trial Court is nothing but erroneous in the
absence of any written contract between the parties to that
effect; that the burden of proof is always vested with the
plaintiff that there is a practice of paying interest @ 18% per
annum or the rate of interest allowed by nationalized banks
at the relevant point of time, but the same is not discharged
by the plaintiff in any manner; that since the defendants have
already paid the amount, the question of payment of any
interest on the balance principal amount does not arise,
thereby, prays to consider the present appeal.
14.
Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the
plaintiff contends that even there is no contract regarding the
interest, when it is a commercial transaction, the interest can
be granted by the Court @ 18% per annum on the due
amount as allowed by the Nationalized Bank on deposits,
thereby, the Trial Court rightly decreed the suit with the said
rate of interest, which requires no interference of this Court
by way of this appeal, thereby, prays to dismiss the appeal
with costs.
15.
It is against this backdrop, the only point that arises for
determination need consideration now; “whether the Trial
Court erred in granting interest @ 18% per annum on the due
amount payable by the defendants to the plaintiff?”
16.
POINT:
It is an undisputed fact that the work entrusted to the
plaintiff by the defendants was completed within the time
stipulated. Thereby, in view of the testimony of witnesses
before the Trial Court, the defendants have to pay the
amount due to the plaintiff. Furthermore, it is crystal clear
that, during the pendency of the suit, the defendants paid an
amount of Rs.4,01,662/- and Rs.3,48,151/- under two
cheques to the plaintiff.
17.
The only dispute is with regard to the rate of interest
claimed by the plaintiff. The Trial Court by relying upon a
pronouncement of this Court in Sri Sinivasa Co., v. Firm
Vitta Dodda Hanumanthappa Anjayya Setti1, categorically
held that since the transaction between the parties is a
commercial transaction, when there is no contract regarding
payment of interest or the rate of interest, in view of the
Proviso to Section 34 of the Civil Procedure Codes enables the
Court to award interest at the current rate allowed by the
Nationalized Banks on deposits, thereby, granted interest @
18% per annum prior to filing the suit as well during the
pendency of the suit and till realization.
18.
However, in the same judgment it was also held that
“The claimant for interest must however adduce acceptable
evidence as to the current rate of interest allowable by such
1 AIR 1985 Andhra Pradesh 21
banks at the relevant time. In the absence of such evidence
the Court has a discretion to allow a reasonable rate of
interest”.
Admittedly, in the present case on hand, no
material was produced before the Trial Court to prove their
claim with regard to the rate of interest. Thereby, to
appreciate the same, this Court being first Appellate Court
has every discretion to allow a reasonable rate of interest to
the plaintiff.
19.
Furthermore, it is more relevant to mention the certain
observations made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in
Secretary/General
Co-
Manager,
Chennai
Central
Operative Bank Ltd. v. S.Kamalaveni Sundaram2, which
are as follows:
“11. Section 34 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 (CPC) empowers the Court to award
interest for the period from the date of the suit
to the date of the decree and from the date of
the decree to the date of payment where the
decree is for payment of money. Section 34 of
2 2011 (2) ALD 91 (SC)
the CPC does not empower the Court to award
pre-suit interest. The pre-suit interest would
ordinarily depend on the contract (express or
implied) between the parties or some statutory
provisions or the mercantile usage…….”
11.
Admittedly, as stated supra, the transaction between
the parties is a commercial transaction, thereby, in view of
the nature of transaction as well by considering the delay in
realizing the payment even though the plaintiff completed the
work within the time stipulated, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the plaintiff is entitled for interest @
18% per annum on the principal amount due prior to filing of
the suit, however, reduced the same from 18% to 12% from
the date of suit i.e., 14.02.2013 till realization on the
principal due amount of Rs.7,49,813/-. As stated supra,
during the pendency of the suit the defendants paid the
amounts, thereby, now it is made clear that as per the finding
arrived by the Trial Court the plaintiff is entitled for the
subsequent interest on the balance principal amount due if
any. Thus, this point is answered accordingly.
12.
It is needless to mention that the other findings
recorded by the Trial Court do not require any interference by
this Court.
13.
In the result, the appeal is partly allowed by modifying
the decree and judgment, dated 12.08.2015 passed in
O.S.No.14 of 2013 on the file of the Court of learned IX
Additional District Judge, West Godavari at Kovvur, regarding
the rate of interest entitled by the plaintiff from the date of
suit
till
realization
only,
consequently,
directed
the
defendants to pay the interest @ 12%, instead of @ 18%, from
the date of suit i.e., 14.02.2013 till realization on the
principal due amount of Rs.7,49,813/-. The other findings as
well directions given by the Trial Court in the judgment
remain intact. There shall be no order as to costs.
Interim orders granted earlier, if any, stand vacated.
Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, stand closed.
______________________
JUSTICE V.SRINIVAS
Date: 05.01.2026
Krs
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE V.SRINIVAS
APPEAL SUIT No.876 of 2015
( JUDGMENT )
DATE: 05.01.2026
Krs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review