Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 41-43
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 59 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 112 of 2022
WP(C) No. 113 of 2022
Date of Decision: 21.09.2023
Shri Hillarton Sangma & Anr.
Shri Samilson Sangma & Ors.
Smti Walchira R. Marak & Ors.
Vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. A.G. Momin, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA
Ms. S. Laloo, GA (For R 1-3)
Mr. P Yobin, Adv. (For R 4)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
in press:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Yes/No
These writ petitions being similar and involving the same
issue are being disposed by this common Judgment and Order. The
WP(C) No. 59 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 112 of 2022
WP(C) No. 113 of 20222
core issue in these writ petitions is the claim of the writ petitioners for
grant of leave encashment and gratuity which they assert, they are
entitled to by virtue of the Judgment and Order dated 04.08.2017
passed in Writ Appeal No. 37 of 2012, and Review Petition No. 9 of
2016. Further, the petitioners have sought to place reliance on an order
dated 02.04.2018 passed in SLP (Civil) Diary No. 35923/2017,
whereby in this SLP filed against the order dated 04.08.2017 in WA
No. 37 of 2012 and Review Petition No. 9 of 2016, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court had observed that the respondent Company would pay
the amount of gratuity to the persons who have sought voluntary
retirement under the Voluntary Retirement Scheme/Golden Handshake
Scheme.
2.
It has been contended that the concerned employees in
these writ petitions, some who are deceased and represented by their
legal heirs having availed of the Golden Handshake Scheme, in view
of the subsequent orders passed by this Court in the Division Bench
and by the Hon’ble Supreme Court would stand covered by these
judgments, and therefore, be entitled to payment of gratuity as has been
afforded to the other employees of the Respondent No. 3.
WP(C) No. 59 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 112 of 2022
WP(C) No. 113 of 20222
3.
This contention has been rebutted by the respondents
firstly, on the ground that the terms of employment and engagement of
these employees which is stated to be under the Agro Custom Hiring
Scheme, a Scheme of which, the respondent No. 4 is only the
implementing agency, are not regular employees of the Respondent no.
3, but were engaged only for the purposes of the said scheme. It has
also been submitted that the said Scheme having since been
discontinued, the services of the employees therein, had been
terminated and the employees paid a onetime settlement which has
been duly accepted by them as far back as in 2001. It has been further
submitted, that the Gauhati High Court, the erstwhile jurisdictional
High Court, in an identical matter of a similarly situated employee, had
dismissed a writ petition being WP(C) No. 157 (SH) 2003 seeking
similar relief, vide order dated 31.08.2006, by directing the petitioner
therein, to receive the onetime settlement in view of the fact that he
was employed under the Agro Custom Hiring Scheme.
4.
It has also been contended that the writ petitioners’
services having been discontinued since December, 2001, these instant
writ petitions being filed only in the year 2022, are severely hit by
delay and laches and do not deserve consideration. On the other aspect
WP(C) No. 59 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 112 of 2022
WP(C) No. 113 of 20222
that the relief claimed will be permissible due to the subsequent
judgments, it has been argued that these judgments will have no
application, as the reliefs given therein, are only with regard to the 95
employees who had approached the Court and further it has been
reiterated that the concerned employees herein were never regular
employees under the respondent No. 3.
5.
Heard the learned counsels for the parties.
6.
The first undisputed fact as admitted by the petitioners
themselves is that these employees were engaged in the Agro Custom
Hiring Scheme, a Government Scheme which was being implemented
by the respondent No. 3. The other fact that is also undisputed is that
the said Scheme was discontinued by the Government which resulted
in the termination of the employees employed therein, who were
offered a onetime settlement. Paragraphs 6 & 7 of the writ petition
which are the statements of the petitioners are reproduced
hereinbelow:“6. That the petitioners were inducted under the Agro
Custom Hiring Scheme under the Border Area
Department for mechanized farming which was
introduced in the year 1978-79 but in the year 1992-93
the State Government considered the Scheme
inoperative because it was incurring huge financial loss
and accordingly proposed payment by way of Golden
Handshake.
WP(C) No. 59 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 112 of 2022
WP(C) No. 113 of 20222
7.
That the Government of Meghalaya, Border Area
Development Department vide order No. BRD.
40/91/Pt/84, dated 06.12.2001 discontinued the Agro
Custom Hiring Scheme due to various constraint,
financial and otherwise on and from the 31st day of
December, 2001 and accordingly the petitioners were
required to take voluntary retirement with a Golden
Handshake.”
8.
The above noted facts clearly show that these employees
were not regular employees of the respondent No. 3, and they stand on
a different footing as far as the terms of appointment and engagement
are concerned, which was under a specific Scheme. As such, it can be
clearly seen that the grant of gratuity and leave encashment to the other
employees who were in regular service under the respondent No. 3,
and the non-consideration in respect of the petitioners’ herein, was a
on the basis of a reasonable classification, due to the difference in their
terms of employment and engagement.
9.
As submitted, an identical matter had come up for
consideration before the erstwhile jurisdictional High Court i.e.
Gauhati High Court in WP(C) No. 157 (SH) 2003 in the case of Shri
Paila Khonghat Vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors. By order dated
31.03.2006, it was held that the petitioner therein had failed to establish
a legally enforceable right for pension and directions were issued for
WP(C) No. 59 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 112 of 2022
WP(C) No. 113 of 20222
the immediate payment of the onetime settlement. Para-6, 7 & 8, which
are relevant are quoted hereinbelow:“6. The above letter dated 17.09.2002 of the Managing
Director, MECOFED, would go to show that the
decision to pay to the petitioners a lump sum amount on
account of one-time settlement instead of gratuity and
regular pension had followed a decision to that effect
taken by the Government. The petitioner was working
under a Scheme which was floated by the Government
and implemented by the MECOFED. The responsibility
of affording certain relief to the petitioner and other
such employees on termination of their service,
therefore, primarily lies with the Government. If the
Government had taken a conscious decision to withdraw
it earlier offer of making available two options to such
employees and instead to adopt a decision to pay to all
such employees a lump sum amount by way of one-time
settlement, it will be difficult for this Court to compel the
Government to abide by its earlier decision. It is not the
case of the petitioner that the aforesaid decision of the
Government was taken for any oblique or questionable
purpose. There will, therefore, be no basis for the Court
to make any such assumption even though the
Government, by not filing any affidavit has failed to
disclose the reasons for the decision in question. In the
aforesaid fact, it is considered appropriate to proceed on
the basis that the decision in question was prompted by
administrative reasons and exigencies. Moreover, the
decision had been uniformly applied to all similarly
situated employees.
7. I am, therefore, unable to hold that the petitioner has
been able to establish a legally enforceable right to
receive pension and that the action of the Government
in withdrawing its earlier decision should be faulted.
8. For the aforesaid reasons, I decline the reliefs prayed
for in the writ petition, but direct the concerned
respondents to forthwith pay to the petitioner the
WP(C) No. 59 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 112 of 2022
WP(C) No. 113 of 20222
amount that would be due to him on account of the onetime settlement.”
10.
The case of the petitioners therefore, is squarely covered
by the above noted judgment and as such after receipt of the onetime
settlement which was received by them in the year 2001, no rights
vested or otherwise exist as on today, to allow them the claim for
gratuity or other benefits.
11.
In view of the discussions and observations made
hereinabove, these writ petitions are accordingly dismissed.
12.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
21.09.2023
“V. Lyndem-PS”
WP(C) No. 59 of 2022 with
WP(C) No. 112 of 2022
WP(C) No. 113 of 20222
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review