Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
LPA No. 161/2021 in SWP No. 296/2018
Reserved On: 25th of February, 2026.
Pronounced On: 10th of March, 2026.
Uploaded On: 10th of March, 2026.
Whether the operative part or
full Judgment is pronounced:
Waheeda Yaseen Khan, Age: 33 Years
D/O Mohammad Yaseen Khan
R/O Housing Colony, Ompora,
Ward No. 8, Budgam.
… Appellant(s)
Through: Ms Sabeena Naveed, Senior Advocate with
M/s Huda Parvez Khan and Kifayat Tasveer, Advocates.
V/s
1. Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir, through
Commissioner/Secretary to Government Department of
Education, New Secretariat Jammu/Srinagar.
2. Director, School Education, Kashmir, Srinagar.
3. Deputy Commissioner, Budgam.
4. Deputy Commissioner, Kupwara.
5. Assistant Commissioner (Revenue), Budgam.
6. Chief Education Officer, Budgam.
7. Zonal Education Officer, Budgam.
8. Executive Officer, Municipal Committee, Budgam.
9. Station House Officer, Police Station, Budgam.
10.Muzaffar Mohi ud Din Mir
S/o Ghulam Mohi ud Din Mir
R/o Batpora, Handwara, District Kupwara,
Shown at Present Ompora Housing Colony, Budgam.
11. Ghulam Mohi ud Din Mir
F/o Muzaffar Mohi ud Din Mir
R/o Batpora, Handwara.
Full.
LPA No. 161/2021 in
SWP No. 296/2018
12. Masrat Mohi ud Din
D/o Ghulam Mohi ud Din Mir
R/o Batpora, Handwara.
13. Principal,
Handwara.
Government
Higher
Secondary
School,
… Respondents
Through: Mr Ilyas Nazir Laway, Government Advocate; and
Mr M. I. Qadri, Senior Advocate with
Mr Tawheed Ahmad, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MS JUSTICE SINDHU SHARMA, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
SHAHZAD AZEEM-J:
01.
This intra Court appeal is directed against the Judgment dated
September 23, 2021 passed by the learned Single Judge [“the Writ Court] in
SWP No. 296/2018 titled ‘Waheeda Yaseen Khan V. State of J&K and
Ors.’, whereby the Writ Petition filed by the Appellant seeking quashment
of Order No. ZEO/R/RT-11/746-48 dated July 28, 2011 issued in favour of
Respondent No. 10 as Rehbar-e-Taleem (ReT) Teacher and Enquiry dated
April 28, 2011, came to be dismissed.
02.
At the outset, it is noteworthy that although the Appellant has
made out voluminous pleadings and submissions, we do not wish to burden
this Judgment with a detailed discussion of each and every plea raised, in
that, most of them being factual in nature and not germane to the
determination of issue(s) involved in the instant appeal. We, therefore,
restrict ourselves to the relevant facts and contentions.
03.
It appears that in the year 2010, precisely on November 11,
2010, a notification came to be issued by the Respondent No.7-Zonal
Education Officer, Budgam for engagement of two ReT Teachers in the
Upgraded Primary School, New Colony, Ompora, Budgam, falling under
LPA No. 161/2021 in
SWP No. 296/2018
Ward No.8. The Appellant as well as the Respondent No.10 had responded
to the said notification by staking their respective claims for their
engagement as ReT Teachers. Accordingly, a panel came to be drawn up by
the Respondent No.7, wherein the Appellant was shown at S. No.3 and the
Respondent No.10 at S. No.2, respectively.
04.
Against this panel, the Appellant filed representations before
the Respondent No.3-Deputy Commissioner, Budgam, besides the inclusion
of Respondent No.10 in the panel list was also objected to by the Welfare
Committee of Government Housing Colony, Ompora, Budgam, mainly on
the ground that the Respondent No.10 is a resident of Batpora, Handwara,
therefore, under the ReT Scheme, he is not eligible, as such, cannot be
included in the panel list. However, the Assistant Commissioner (Revenue),
Budgam held an inquiry and, vide report dated April 28, 2011, returned a
finding that out of the two candidates, the Respondent No.10 has the
Permanent Resident Certificate (PRC) of Village Ompora, Tehsil Budgam,
while as, the Appellant is having the PRC of Srinagar, therefore, the
Respondent No.10 deserves to be considered for selection as ReT Teacher.
05.
Confronted with these circumstances, the Appellant is stated to
have filed a Civil Suit for declaring the Appellant to be entitled to the
appointment as ReT Teacher and also to issue appointment Order in her
favour. The Appellant has also prayed for a ‘Decree of Mandatory
Injunction’ to not issue any order of appointment in favour of Defendant
No.4 (Respondent No. 10 herein).
06.
In the meanwhile, the Respondent No.7-Zonal Education
Officer, Budgam also issued an Order of appointment dated July 28, 2011
in favour of Respondent No.10.
07.
It is also important to note that the Appellant had earlier also
filed a Writ Petition, being SWP No. 1268/2017 titled ‘Waheeda Yaseen
LPA No. 161/2021 in
SWP No. 296/2018
V. State of J&K and Ors.’, on July 06, 2017, wherein she had prayed for
the following relief(s):
“A.] Writ of Mandamus commanding upon the
Respondents 3 & 4 to hold a thorough enquiry vis-à-vis the
PRC and domicile of the Respondent No.8 and to enquire about
the veracity of all the documents of the Respondent No.8,
obtained by him on the analogy of the documents produced by
his father and sister vis-à-vis their PRCs and domiciles
including Qualification Certificates as well; and
B.] A Writ of Mandamus may be passed by this Hon’ble
Court directing Crime Branch Kashmir to hold an enquiry
against all those officers who are involved in providing the
favorite documents to the Respondent No.8.”
08.
The Writ Petition, being SWP No. 1268/2017, came to be filed
by the Appellant much after the issuance of appointment Order as ReT
Teacher in favour of the Respondent No.10, but the Appellant did not call
in question the said appointment. In any case, the SWP No. 1268/2017
came to be disposed of vide Judgment dated February 15, 2018 in the
following terms:
“7. Thus, from perusal of the relief claimed by the
petitioner in the civil suit, as well as issues framed by the trial
court, it is evident that the factum of residence of respondent
no.8 is in issue before the trial court. The petitioner cannot be
allowed to prosecute two remedies simultaneously. It is also
relevant to mention here that enquiry with regard to PRC and
domicile of respondent no. 8 has already been held and in case
the petitioner is aggrieved of same, he is entitled to take
recourse to challenge the same by way of revision. Needless to
state that in case the petitioner is of the opinion that respondent
no.8 has obtained the documents by playing fraud, the
petitioner is at liberty to file first information report against
respondent no. 8 before the concerned official which shall be
dealt with in accordance with law by concerned SHO in view
of the law laid down in Lalita Kumari V. Government of
Uttar Pradesh [2014 Vol. 2 SCC 1]. The petitioner shall also
be at liberty to file the documents before the trial court, if so
advised.”
LPA No. 161/2021 in
SWP No. 296/2018
09.
Despite having failed to obtain relief in SWP No. 1268/2017,
mainly on the ground that the factum of residence is in issue before the
Trial Court in the pending Suit, the Appellant cannot be allowed to
prosecute two remedies simultaneously and the observations made therein
by the Writ Court have attained the finality, yet the Appellant had again
made an abortive attempt to file the second Writ Petition-SWP No.
296/2018, inter alia, questioning the appointment order of Respondent
No.10, dated July 28, 2011 and Enquiry report dated April 28, 2011 held by
Respondents No. 5 and 6, respectively, mainly on the ground that the
Respondent No.10 has secured his appointment as ReT Teacher on the basis
of forged and fraud documents.
10.
The Writ Court, vide impugned Judgment dated September 23,
2021, while dismissing the Writ Petition, held that the Appellant did not
question the appointment Order in earlier Writ Petition, being SWP No.
1268/2017, issued in favour of Respondent No.10, therefore, went onto
further hold that the parties are bound by the decision which is not
challenged, therefore, there is no scope for quashment of appointment of
Respondent No.10 is concerned on whatsoever grounds, unless the Trial
Court decides the issue regarding the factum of residence of Respondent
No.10.
11.
Now, the Appellant has thrown challenge to the impugned
Judgment passed by the Writ Court, on the ground that the factual assertion
raised in the Writ Petition has not been properly addressed by the Writ
Court. This is the bone of contention of the Appellant. Therefore, we do not
wish to go into the details of all the pleas raised in the memo of the appeal,
as same being not only repetitive but also are not relevant for adjudication
of the point in controversy.
12.
The core dispute revolves round the legality of the
appointment Order of Respondent No.10, as ReT Teacher, which inherently
LPA No. 161/2021 in
SWP No. 296/2018
involves disputed question of facts, i.e., the factual controversies around
eligibility regarding the genuineness of residence certificates on the basis of
which the appointment Order was issued and the subject matter is subjudice before the competent court of civil jurisdiction in a Civil Suit.
13.
Having chosen the route of instituting the Civil Suit, which of
course is the proper forum for adjudication of disputed question of facts, the
Appellant is estopped from successively invoking the extraordinary Writ
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for the same
relief and cause of action. This attempt of the Appellant is nothing, but
amounts to forum-shopping. Writ jurisdiction is discretionary and
extraordinary, not available when an equally efficacious and alternate
remedy exists, more particularly when the said remedy is already resorted
to.
14.
It is trite that extraordinary Writ jurisdiction of the High Cout
under Article 226 cannot be converted into a Civil Court under the ordinary
law, particularly when a Suit is pending and remedy of appeal or revision is
available, therefore, where the Civil Court has the jurisdiction to try a Suit,
the High Court cannot convert itself into an Appellate or Civil Court.
15.
It is noteworthy that the cases where remedy is available
before the Civil Courts in terms of the provisions of the Code of Civil
Procedure (CPC), which may involve Suits and other remedies like appeals
and revisions under the provisions of the CPC, same may have to be
construed as a near total bar to the extraordinary Writ jurisdiction of the
High Court.
16.
We are fortified in our view by the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in ‘Virudhunagar Hindu Nadargal Dharma
Paribalana Sabai & Ors. V. Tuticorin Educational Society & Ors.,
(2019) 9 Supreme Court Cases 538’, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court
has observed as under:
LPA No. 161/2021 in
SWP No. 296/2018
“13. Therefore, wherever the proceedings are under the
Code of Civil Procedure and the forum is the civil court, the
availability of a remedy under the CPC, will deter the High
Court, not merely as a measure of self-imposed restriction, but
as a matter of discipline and prudence, from exercising its
power of superintendence under the Constitution. Hence, the
High Court ought not to have entertained the revision under
Article 227 especially in a case where a specific remedy of
appeal is provided under the Code of Civil Procedure itself.”
17.
The attempt made by the Appellant, in the first round of
litigation in SWP No. 1268/2017, did not find favour, as the Writ Court
specifically held that from perusal of the relief claimed by the Appellant in
the Civil Suit as well as the issues framed by the Trial Court, it is evident
that the factum of residence of Respondent No.8 (Respondent No.10 herein)
is in issue before the Trial Court, therefore, the Appellant cannot be allowed
to prosecute two remedies simultaneously. However, the findings returned
by the Writ Court in SWP No. 1268/2017 rendered vide Judgment dated
February 15, 2018 have attained the finality, therefore, same acts as res
judicata insofar as the second Writ Petition is concerned. The Appellant has
omitted to throw challenge to the appointment of Respondent No.10 in the
earlier round of litigation, though at that point of time, the appointment
Order in favour of the Respondent No.10 was in existence as same was
issued much before the filing of the said Writ Petition. Therefore, the
question of appointment of Respondent No.10 deemed to have been a
matter directly and substantially in issue in the earlier Writ Petition, but the
Appellant has deliberately omitted to question the same, thus, the Petition is
barred by constructive res judicata also.
18.
On cumulative assessment of the facts and circumstances in
which the Appellant is found to have repetitively indulged in re-litigation,
we have no hesitation to observe that this is a classic instance of repetitive
and abuse of process of law that has been pursued through multiple rounds,
despite being hopelessly barred by well-established principles of finality,
election of remedies and jurisdictional propriety.
LPA No. 161/2021 in
SWP No. 296/2018
19.
For the foregoing reasons, we do not find any error of law or
fact having been committed by the Writ Court while dismissing the Writ
Petition. Accordingly, the instant appeal is dismissed, along with connected
CM(s). Interim direction(s), if any subsisting as on date, shall stand vacated.
(SHAHZAD AZEEM)
JUDGE
(SINDHU SHARMA)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
March 10th, 2026
“TAHIR”
i.
Tahir Manzoor Bhat
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
Whether the Judgment is approved for reporting?
Yes/ No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review