Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Supplementary List I
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 327 of 2020
Date of Decision: 08.02.2023
Smti. Wa-I-Sa Sumer & Anr.
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, AAG with
Ms. Z. E. Nongkynrih, GA (For R 1-4)
Mr. S. Sen, Adv. (For R 5-9).
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This writ petition has been filed for recall of impugned notification
dated 11-12-2012 whereby under the Meghalaya School Education Service
Rules, 2012, the State-respondents have prescribed the proportion for filling
up of vacancies under Junior Grade-II service from amongst the categories of
Vice-Principal/Assistant Headmaster/Assistant DAEOs at 75 per cent and
from Assistant Lecturer at 25 per cent.
2.
The writ petitioners herein, are all direct recruits to the post of Assistant
Lecturer and their services are governed by the Meghalaya School Service
Rules, 2012. Under these Rules the service comprises of ‘Senior School
Service’ and ‘Junior School Service’. For the purposes of this case what is
relevant, is the Senior School Service, which comprises of Grade-I and
Grade-II. The petitioners belong to Senior Grade-I category along with the
Vice-Principal/Assistant Headmaster etc. and having served for a number of
years are eligible for promotion to the next higher post in Junior Grade-II
under the Meghalaya School Education Service Rules, 2012.
3.
The writ petitioners’ main grievance is with the classification of the
Senior Grade-I into two groups for the purposes of appointment/promotion,
and by the prescription of percentage or quota, of persons to be promoted
from amongst these two categories which they contend is violative of Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
4.
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that
the petitioners (Assistant Lecturers) fall under the same cadre as VicePrincipal/Assistant Headmaster/Headmistress etc. in the Grade-I service as
provided under Rule-4 of the Meghalaya School Service Rules, 2012 and, as
such, form a single class. He further submits that the source of entry into the
cadre is irrelevant and that seniority is always based on the date of entry into
a cadre, and by this estimate the petitioners are senior to the privaterespondents in service. The action of the State-respondents, he contends, in
issuing the impugned notification creating two categories of posts, by
classifying
the
Vice-Principal/Assistant
Headmaster/Headmistress
repeatedly and providing 75 percent reservation in promotion for them, and
the remaining 25 percent for Assistant Lecturers is unsustainable in law and
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
5.
The learned Counsel submits that this classification of reservation of
75 percent for Vice-Principal/ Assistant Headmaster/Headmistress, as
opposed to 25 percent for Assistant Lecturers, is totally unreasonable,
inasmuch as, the State-respondents have taken into account all the other
grades i.e. Grade-I and Grade-II, in computing the strength of service of the
Vice-Principal/Assistant
Headmaster/Headmistress
etc.,
instead
of
considering only the actual strength of Grade-I who are in service. He further
submits that the strength of Assistant Lecturers in Grade-I service as on 2012,
was
whereas,
the
strength
of
Vice-Principal/Assistant
Headmaster/Headmistress etc., in Grade-I service was 28. In this scenario,
he contends the provision for reservation by the impugned notification is
disproportionate, unreasonable and has resulted in the deprivation of the
petitioners from being considered for promotion inspite of having served long
years.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner in support of his arguments has
placed reliance on the following cases:i)
State of Bihar and Ors. Vs. Bihar State ‘Plus-2’ Lecturers
Associations and Ors. (2008) 7 SCC 231.
ii)
Confederation of Ex-Servicemen Associations & Ors. Vs. Union of
India (2006) 8 SCC 399.
iii)
State of Jammu & Kashmir Vs. Shri. Triloki Nath Khosa & Ors.
(1974) 1 SCC 19.
iv)
State of Mysore & Anr. Vs. P. Narasinga Rao AIR 1968 SC 349.
v)
K.S. Puttaswamy (Retired) & Anr. Vs. Union of India & Anr. (2019)
1 SCC 1.
vi) Modern Dental College and Research Centre & Ors. Vs. State of
Madhya Pradesh & Ors. (2016) 7 SCC 353.
7.
Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, learned AAG assisted by Ms. Z. E. Nongkynrih,
learned GA for the State-respondent Nos. 1-4 in reply, has submitted that
Rule-4 read with Schedule-II of the Meghalaya School Service Rules, 2012
provides for the composition and strength of the service, and Rule-4 (1) (b)
further provides that each of the categories of post shall form an independent
cadre. A bare reading of the above Rule along with the Schedule, he submits,
makes it crystal clear that though the post of Vice-Principal/Assistant
Headmaster/Headmistress etc. and that of Assistant Lecturers are placed in
the same grade, they form separate cadres and this classification is evident
from the entry level itself.
8.
The learned counsel then refers to Rule-6 of the said Rules of 2012 and
submits that sub Rule (1) thereof, provides for the method of appointment to
the post of Vice-Principal/Assistant Headmaster/Headmistress etc., and that
the appointment to the post of Assistant Lecturers is specifically given in SubRule (2). This he contends in the method of recruitment itself; a classification
has been introduced as there is a clear distinction in the posts, which is
apparent right from the entry level. To further substantiate this point, the
learned counsel submits that Rule 6 (1) affirms that appointment to the posts
of Vice-Principal/Assistant Headmaster/Headmistress etc. in Grade-I, shall
be made by promotion from amongst members holding the next lower posts
in the Grade, except for those posts indicated in the proviso to Rule 6 (2).
Rule 6 (2) he submits, which provides for the method of appointment to the
posts of Assistant Lecturers, affirms that 25 percent is to be filled up by
promotion from amongst Assistant Teachers, while 75 percent was to be by
direct recruitment based on the recommendation made by the Meghalaya
Public Service Commission. He also submits that the Assistant Lecturers and
Vice-Principal/Assistant Headmaster/Headmistress etc. fall in different
categories even when it comes to educational qualification and qualifying
service.
9.
In the preparation of gradation list as per Rule-19 of the Meghalaya
School Service Rules, 2012, learned counsel submits that the seniority list is
prepared separately, as the different posts in Grade-I under the senior school
service form separate cadres. The next higher post which is Junior Grade-II
which is governed by the Meghalaya School Education Service Rules, 2012,
at Rule-6 (5), he submits, provides for appointment to Junior Grade-II from
amongst the member of Grade-I of the Meghalaya School Service, and that
in this Rule itself, it has been further laid down that the proportion of
vacancies to be filled up in a year shall be prescribed by the Government.
These Rules he argues, authorise the State-respondent to determine the
proportion of vacancies to be filled up under the cadre of Junior Grade-II, and
the writ petitioners having not challenged the validity of these Rules cannot
be entitled to the reliefs prayed for in this writ petition.
10.
The learned counsel then submits that there is a distinction in the nature
of functions and duties with regard to the posts of Vice-Principal/Assistant
Headmaster/Headmistress etc. and Assistant Lecturers, which is reflected in
the report and recommendation of the 5th Meghalaya State Pay Commission,
wherein higher pay level has been recommended for the post of VicePrincipal. The learned counsel has also drawn the attention of this Court to
the executive instructions which were prevalent prior to the framing of the
Meghalaya School Service Rules, 2012 to highlight the distinction between
the post of Vice-Principal and Assistant Lecturer, and submits that although
presently the scale of pay has now been made equivalent, it does not mean
that the posts are merged into one cadre. With regard to the chart appended
at Annexure-7 to the writ petition, he submits that the same only reflects the
channel of promotion of each cadre and is a proposal for fixing the proportion
as provided in Rule 6(5), and that the fixation of proportion has been done
taking into consideration the avenues of promotions for the entire lower cadre
of services also.
11.
In concluding his submission, the learned AAG submits that the post
of Assistant Lecturers and Vice-Principal have not been classified as one
category of posts, at any point of time and even the inclusion of both the posts
in Grade-I service, cannot imply that they are in the same category. Such
classification he contends is not impermissible in law and has cited the
decision in the case of Manish Kumar Vs. Union of India reported in (2021)
5 SCC 1 to fortify this submission.
12.
Mr. S. Sen, learned counsel for respondent Nos. 5 – 9, apart from
endorsing the submissions made by the learned AAG, submits that the
allocation for promotion has been based on reasonable grounds as reflected
in the chart dated 19-11-2012 (Annexure-7). He submits that, though the
cadre strength of Vice-Principal and other posts belonging to common cadre
of Grade-I is only 28, in consideration of the large strength of the feeder
cadre, 75 percent was, therefore, allocated to this branch. It is further
submitted that it is an admitted position that when the petitioners entered in
service, they were not at par with the post of Vice-Principal, but it was only
after the Rules of 2012 that they have been granted equivalent pay and placed
in the same grade.
13.
It has lastly been submitted that the impugned notification has been
made in exercise of the powers conferred under Rules 6 (5) (i) of the
Meghalaya School Education Service Rules, 2012 which is not under
challenge, as such, on this ground alone the writ petition is not maintainable
and no interference is called for by this Court.
14.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties. Before coming to the
claims and counter-claims of the parties herein, it would be necessary to first
examine the rules under which the petitioners and respondents are governed
by. It is to be noted that that two sets of rules i.e. ‘The Meghalaya School
Service Rules, 2012’, (hereinafter referred to as “Rules I) and ‘The
Meghalaya School Education Service Rules, 2012’, (hereinafter referred to
as “Rules II) are in play, inasmuch as, on reaching Senior School Service
Grade-I under Rules I, the teachers on promotion will then be governed by
the provisions of Rules II, at the entry level of Junior Grade-II. Under Rules
I, it is important to note that under the heading ‘Composition and Strength of
Service’, as given in Rule-4, the service comprises of Senior School Service
and Junior School Service, with the Senior School Service comprising of
Grade-I and Grade-II, with Grade-II being the feeder post for promotion to
Grade-I.
Grade-I
consists
of
Vice-Principal,
Assistant
Headmaster/Headmistress, Assistant Lecturer (HSS) Assistant D.I. Schools
(redesignated as Additional SDSEO) and Assistant DAEO/Assistant
DASEO. Rule-6 (1) & (2) with regard to the ‘method of recruitment’,
provides as follows;
Method of recruitment:
(1) Appointment to any post in Grade I of the Senior School Service
shall be made by promotion from amongst the members of the
Service holding the next lower posts in the grade, except for those
posts indicated in proviso to para 6 (2) below; and those belonging to
Grade II as specified in the Schedule-I and Schedule-II and in the
select list approved under sub-rules (d) and (e) of Rule 8.
(2) Appointment to the post of Assistant Lecturer (HSS) in Senior School
Service, Grade I shall to the extent of 25 per cent of vacancies shall
be made by promotion from amongst the Assistant Teachers of
HSS/SS having the requisite qualification of Post Grade Degree (in
the required streams/subjects) with 5 (five) years of continuous and
satisfactory service, as such.
Provided 75 per cent of the posts of Assistant Lecturers (HSS)
shall be filled by direct recruitment based on the recommendations
of the Meghalaya Public Service Commission.
The Proviso quoted above it can be seen provides for 75 percent of the
post of Assistant Lecturer to be filled up by direct recruitment based on
recommendation of the Meghalaya Public Service Commission.
15.
The Schedule-II to Rule-1, made under Rule- 4 (1) with regard to the
cadre/post shows that for promotion of Vice-Principal, Assistant
Headmaster/Headmistress, Assistant Lecturer (HSS) Assistant D.I. Schools
(redesignated as Additional SDSEO) and Assistant DAEO/Assistant
DASEO, the same is to be made from the Assistant Teachers etc. having a
degree with B.Ed and 8 years of continuous and satisfactory service, and there
is no provision for direct recruitment. However, to the post of Assistant
Lecturer as provided by the proviso to Rule 6 (2), the same is to be made 25
per cent by promotion from amongst Assistant Teachers having P.G. Degree
with 3 years of continuous and satisfactory service and 75 percent by direct
recruitment from candidates having P.G Degree.
16.
The proportion as to the percentage reserved for the Vice-Principal,
Assistant Headmaster/Headmistress, etc., vis-à-vis Assistant Lecturers, is
therefore to be examined as to whether, the same will amount to a reasonable
classification, notwithstanding the fact that, both are in the same cadre. On a
perusal of the method of recruitment to the post of Vice-Principal, Assistant
Headmaster/Headmistress, as opposed to the post of Assistant Lecturers,
what strikes this Court first is that, there is a clear distinction, inasmuch as,
the same is strictly by promotion with the next lower grade of Assistant
Teachers etc., constituting the feeder grade. However, in the case of Assistant
Lecturers, only 25 percent of the vacancies is by promotion, whereas, 75
percent is by direct recruitment. Thus, at this level itself, which constitutes
the Senior School Service Grade – I, the mode of placement or recruitment
are not similar. Furthermore, the eligibility to be promoted or recruited,
differs between the Vice-Principal, Assistant Headmaster/Headmistress etc.,
and Assistant Lecturers, inasmuch as, the educational qualifications and
qualifying service for promotion are also not similar. It is therefore apparently
clear that, the proportion allotted to two different streams, though in the same
grade, was based on intelligible differentia.
17.
Another feature that supports the case of the respondents is that, while
determining the proportion, the feeder cadre was also taken into consideration
to arrive at the total cadre strength as the post of Vice-Principal, Assistant
Headmaster/Headmistress, etc., is strictly a promotional post, which is not
the case of the Assistant Lecturers, wherein, 75 percent of the total cadre
strength, were occupying Senior School Service Grade – I posts, by coming
in by way of direct recruitment. This classification taking into account, the
distinction between Vice-Principal, Assistant Headmaster/Headmistress, etc.,
and Assistant Lecturers, which is at the entry level itself as provided by Rule
6(1) and the proviso to Rule 6(2) therefore, cannot be said to be unreasonable
or arbitrary.
18.
An added factor which also cannot be ignored is that, the validity of
the Rules, particularly the authority of the government to determine the
proportion of vacancies to be filled up by promotion, has not been challenged
by the writ petitioners. Rule 6(5) of Rules II, empowers the government with
the discretion to determine the proportion of vacancies and it reads as follows;
“6. Method of Recruitment …………….
(5) Appointment to Junior Grade II of the Service shall be made
by the following methods:
(i) By promotion from amongst the members of Grade I of the
Meghalaya School Service. The proportion of vacancies to be filled up in
any year shall be as prescribed by the Government.”
The government therefore, in determining the proportion has acted in
accordance with the powers granted by Rule 6(5), and as such, the contention
that, the prescription of the proportion is illegal, cannot be sustained.
19.
Article 14 does not forbid reasonable classification of persons, by
legislature or rules thereof, for the purpose of achieving specific ends, but this
classification must not be artificial, arbitrary and must be based upon a
substantial distinction, which has a just and reasonable nexus with the object
sought to be achieved by the Act or Rules. In the instant case, in the
considered view of this Court, the classification arrived at, fulfills the
conditions necessary such as, ‘Intelligible differentia’ and that the differentia,
has a rational relation to the object sought to be achieved by the Rules. As is
well settled, ‘Intelligible differentia’ means the difference which can be
discerned and understood, that is, the factor that distinguishes one class from
another, as is well apparent in the instant case.
20.
In this backdrop, the judgment as cited by the learned AAG on behalf
of the respondents, that is the case of Manish Kumar vs. Union of India
reported in (2021) 5 SCC 1, supports the view of this Court, on the point of
the permissibility of a reasonable classification within the same class which
will not offend Article 14 of the Constitution. Para – 225 of the judgment,
while placing reliance on the judgment of State of Kerala vs. N.M. Thomas
and other related judgments had observed as follows;
“225. In State of Kerala v. N.M. Thomas, this Court was
dealing with the challenge to the judgment of the High Court
by which it had upheld the challenge by the respondent to a
rule which granted power to the appellant State to grant
further exemption to the members of Scheduled Castes and
Scheduled Tribes to pass the departmental test necessary for
being considered for promotion. The learned ASG drew
support from the following statement in the judgment by K.K.
Mathew, J.: (SCC p. 348, para 83)
“83. A classification is reasonable if it includes all
persons who are similarly situated with respect to the
purpose of the law. In other words, the classification
must be founded on some reasonable ground which
distinguishes persons who are grouped together and the
ground of distinction must have rational relation to the
object sought to be achieved by the rule or even the rules
in question. It is a mistake to assume a priori that there
can be no classification within a class, say, the lower
division clerks. If there are intelligible differentia which
separates a group within that class from the rest and that
differentia have nexus with the object of classification, I
see no objection to a further classification within the
class. It is no doubt a paradox that though in one sense
classification brings about inequality, it is promotive of
equality if its object is to bring those who share a
common characteristic under a class for differential
treatment for sufficient and justifiable reasons. In this
view, I have no doubt that the principle laid down in All
India Station Masters’ & Asstt. Station Masters’ Assn.
v. Central Railway; S.G. Jaisinghani v. Union of India
and State of J&K v. Triloki Nath Khosa has no
application here.”
21.
The judgment of State of J&K vs. Triloki Nath Khosa reported in
(1974) 1 SCC 19, which has also been discussed in Manish Kumar (supra)
at paras 30-32, had also held as follows;
“30. Since the constitutional code of equality and equal
opportunity is a charter for equals, equality of
opportunity in matters of promotion means an equal
promotional opportunity for persons who fall,
substantially, within the same class. A classification of
employees can therefore be made for first identifying
and then distinguishing members of one class from
those of another.
31. Classification, however, is fraught with the danger
that it may produce artificial inequalities and therefore,
the right to classify is hedged in with salient restraints;
or else, the guarantee of equality will be submerged in
class legislation masquerading as laws meant to govern
well-marked classes characterized by different and
distinct attainments. Classification, therefore, must be
truly founded on substantial differences which
distinguish persons grouped together from those left out
of the group and such differential attributes must bear a
just and rational relation to the object sought to be
achieved.
32. Judicial scrutiny can therefore extend only to the
consideration whether the classification rests on a
reasonable basis whether it bears nexus with the object
in view. It cannot extend to embarking upon a nice or
mathematical evaluation of the basis of classification,
for were such an inquiry permissible it would be open to
the courts to substitute their own judgment for that of
the legislature or the rulemaking authority on the need
to classify or the desirability of achieving a particular
object.”
22.
The judgments placed by the petitioners counsel on the point of
reasonableness and proportionality, will be of no assistance in the present
case, considering the facts and situation as discussed above.
23.
In the totality of the circumstances therefore, the classification and the
prescription for percentage of promotion having met the test of
reasonableness, and further the provision itself allowing for the same, not
having been challenged, this writ petition fails and is accordingly dismissed.
24.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
08.02.2023
“Biswarup-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review