Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3,189 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE
AT HYDERABAD
OF TELANGANA
THE TWELFTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
THURSDAY,
. TWO iHOUSNTO AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
KOSHY
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM
AND
SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
JUSTICE
SRI
THE HONOURABLE
INCOME TAX TRIB UNAL APPEAL N os:
INCOME TA X TRIBU NAL APP EAL N
152 O F 2008 an d3 37 ot 2O11
O: 152 OF 2008
260 A of the lncome
lncome Tax Tribunal Appeal under Section passed in ITA- No
Tax Act, 1961 againstitt" o':t[i o"ted 31'102007 on the file of the
years 2003-04
1138/H/2006, for the
"t"tt*"nt
Bench '8" Hyderabad.
lnoome Tax Appellat" fi['""f ' Hydeiabad
Betwee n:
Vodrthala Education Society, 7 -1 -621
I
A,S.R.Nagar' HYderabad
.APPELLANT
AND
The Director of lncome Tax [Exemptions]'
Appeal against the Sole Respondent
dared 28 10.2014
Counsel for the APPellant
Hyderabad
is Disd for Default vide Court Order
...RESPONDENT
: Sri. K Vasantkumar
Kpunna (senior Standing counsel for
counser for the Respondent : sri. viihay
lncome Tax DePartment)
INCOME TA X TRIBU NAL AP PEAL N
O: 337 oF 2011
260 A of the lncome
lncome Tax Tribunal Appeal Under Section
3009'2010 passed in ITA No'
Tzrx Act. 1961 against the Order dated
43OlHl2OO8, for the assessment years 2004-05 on the file of the lncome
Tax Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench 'B', Hyderabad.
Between:
Vodithala Education Society, 7 1-6211A. SR Nagar, Hyderabad
...APPELLANT
AND
The Director of lncome Tax lExemptions], Hyderabad
...RESPONDENT
Appeal against the Sole Respondent is Disd for Default vide Court Order
dated 28 10 2014
Counsel for the Appellant
: Sri. K Vasantkumar
Counsel for the Respondent Sri. Vijhay K Punna (Senior Standing counsel for
lncome Tax Department)
The Court delivered the following
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAI)
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
ITTA Nos. 152 of2OO8 and 337 of2OLl
Dt. \L .02.2026
Between:
Vodithala Education Society
Appellant
and
The Director of Income Tax(trxemptions), Hyderabad
... Respondent
COMMONJUDGMENT: (Per lhe Hon'ble Sri Justlce Suddqla Chalapathi Rao)
1. The instant appeals have been frled by the appellant/ assessee
challenging the orders passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal
(hereinafter referred to as 'ITAT] in ITA No.1138/H/06 (2OO3-04) and
ITA.No.43olH/2ooB(2OO4-O51, dt.31.10.2007 and dt.30.09.2010,
respectively, in respect of the assessment years 2OO3-O4 and 2OO4-05.
2.
Since both appeals arise out of the proceedings relating to the same
assessee and involve common issues, though pertaining to two different
assessment years, they were analogously hea-rd and disposed of b-v this
common judgment.
3'
The brief facts of the case are that the appe,ant/assessee is
Society engaged in running educational institutions ald
the state of the then composite state of Andhra pradesh
a
hostels within
and Maharastra.
Further, for the assessment years 2oo3-0 4 and 2oo4-05,
the assessee
had filed returns on 03.12.2oo3 and 02. 1r 2oo4, respectivery,
claiming
exemption under sectio, r 1 of Income Ta-x Act, 196 i (for
short .the ActJ.
Before the assessments $,ere taken up for scrutiny,
a survey was
conducted on 20.07.2005 at the engineering co[eges run
by the assessee
at Ramtek, Nagpur of Maharastra, unclcr which, certain incrementing
materia-l was alleged to have been seized b-r, the authorities
course of surve-y operal ions, statement of one of the
assessee, namery Mr. R.Srini'as Rao, *'as recorded. In
and in the
employees of the
the statement, the
said person alleged to h.r,e statcd as to certain irregurarities
in collection
of amounts in excess .f the fees prescribed by the Government
from
students, who w.ere admitted under the management quota. pursua,t
thereto, incriminating materia-i *,as seized and basing
on the same and
along with the statement or Mr R.Srinivas Rao, the
Assessing officer
came to the conclusion that the assessee, rvho r.,r,as
running educational
institutions, hacr collected capitation fees from students,
admitted under the management quota.
who were
Thus, the impugned
assessment orders, dt.31.03.2006 and dt.26. 12.2006,
respectively were
passed for the assessment years 2003_O 4 and,
2OO4_05, respectivety, by
rejecting the claim of the assessee for exemption under
Section 1 I as
well as under Section 1O(23C) of the Act.
4'
Aggrieved by the said assessment orders, the appe[a,t/assessee
preferred appeals before the commissioner of Income
Tax (Appeals) (for
short 'GIT(A)), inter a/la contending that due procedure had not
followed, that no opportunity was given to cross-examine
been
Mr. R. Srinivas
Rao, and that the amounts reflected in the seized material
calnot be
taken as excess collection or capitation fee. It was contended
that the
amounts collected represented the total fees payabre by the
students
admitted under the management quota for the entire four years
course,
collected at one time.
5'
The GIT(A), upon considering the materia,I on record and the
submissions made, dismissed the appea-ls hording that ttre assessee
violated the provisions of Section 13(1)(c) of the Act and the
societ5r were utilized for the benefit of persons in
had
funds of the
the management. It
was further held that the assessee was not entitred to exemption
under
Section 1 1 , as the educational trust has not derived income from
properties of the trust and that even the benefit under section
the
1o(23c)
could not be extended, as the institution was not being run solely for
a\
educational purposes. Thus, the CIT(A) dismissed the appeals holding
that beneht of exemption under Section l1 ald Section 1O(23C) cannot
be given to the assessee.
.
The assessee carr jed the matters in further appeals before the
learned ITAT in
ITA.No ll3S|H/2OO6(AY 2003-04) axd
ITA.No.430/Hyd/08(AY 2004-os).
7.
The learned ITAT initially heard the appeal ITA.No.ll38/H/2006
relating to the assessment vear 2OO3-O4, and after appreciation of the
facts and material on record ln proper perspective, passed a detailed
order on 3l.lO.2OO7 affirming the findings of the Assessing Authority
and the CIT(A), and assailing the said order, the assessee filed
ITTA.No.l52 of 2O0B before this Court
8.
Subsequently, the learned ITAT dismissed I1'A.No.43O/H/08, by
order, dt.30.09.2010, in line with the orders passed
1n
ITA.No. ll38 / H / 2006, dt.3 1. IO.2OO7, for rhe assessmenr year 2OO4-O5,
u,hich is assailed before this Court in ITTA.No.337 of 20 1 I
9.
Both the appeals
were
substantial questions of law
admitted to consider the following
"l' whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case made
in
contravention of the mandatory provisions of section
ttre
ffni
was
justified in upholding
ordei oi a"..""*ri 142(3) of the Act?
^2. Whether on the factsthe
and i" tt. .i."rm"1ances of the case. the
ITAT was correct in law in no.t appreciati"Slf,.
fact that 6;.J";
has called for any expianation i.o- tt J Appellant
Assessing Officer nor the Commissioner with neither the
reference to
impounded
material?
3. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of
the case u/s
f O(23C)(vi) of the Act which was neither
cLaimea in the ITAT was
justified
in considering the issue of e*.-ptio, return of income
nor
order?
on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the
ITAT was correct in law in holding that there was
no requirement
for cross-examining the Deponlnt UV
tf.,.
Appellant, whose
.
. source
statement
was the only
ol the implgned assessment?
5. Whether on the facts and in the circumJt..r"." of the
case, the
ITAT was correct in law in coming to conclusion
that the appjf.ri
had collected excess fee and u,as"uti.lis.a by tne persons
interested
t] the society, solely based on the s,,Join
statement of Mr.
R.Srinivasa Rao ald without vcrification of books
6. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances ofofaccounts?
the
ITAT was correct in law in holding that the Appellant case, the
is not a
charitable institution u/s 2(15) of ihe Act o,, rn"..
surmises and
presumptions?
c_onsidered by thc CIT(A) in his appellate
_ Whether
4.
10' In addition to the above, ITTA.No. rs2 of 2oog was admitted
consider tl.e following substantial questions :
"7
.
^
8.
9.
Whether on the facts and in the circumstances
of the case,
-oi
the ITAT was correct in law in holding tfr" prori"il.r"
Section 1O(23.C) (iv) of thc Act are applicable despite the
faci
that the Appellant was granrcd .*.*jtio., u/s I l^of the Aci?
Whether on the facts and in the ciriumstalces of the
case,
the ITAT was correct in larv in holding that the p.ovisions
oi
section 1 1 cannot override the provision of f OtZSCttr")
oi tf,;
Act?
Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the
case,
the ITAT was correct in law in hotding that the nppeffani is
not holding any property undcr trust so as to entitle itself
for
exemption u/s 11 of thc Act?"
to
I 1.
Heard Sri A.V.Raghu Ram, learned counsel representing
Sri K.Vasalt Kumar, learned counsel for appellart and Sri Vryay K
Punna, learned Senior Stalding Counsel for lncome Tax Department for
respondent/ Revenue.
12. Learned counsel for the appellant/ assessee contended that the
entire assessment orders are vitiated in law as it was totally based on the
statement of Mr. R. Srinivas Rao, who is not at a]l connected q,ith the
affairs of the assessee, rvithout affording the assessee an opportunity to
cross-examine him, despite specihc request made before the assessing
officer and also before the lower appellate authorities, and denial of such
opportunitv amounted to violation of principles of natural justice. It was
further contended that the seized material s,as misconstrued by the
Assessing Authority as if the amounts reflected therein amounted to
collection of capitation fee or excess fee from the students, but contended
that it is the aggregate fees payable by students for the entire four-year
course collected at a time. The learned counsel contended that no
independent verification of the books of accounts was undertaken and
the Assessing Authority' proceeded on surmises and presumptions and
passed the impugned assessment orders, w,hich are untenable.
13' It was also urged that the assessee, being an educational
institution established for charitabre purposes, was entitled to exemption
under Section 1 1 of the Act and that the authorities erred in denying
such benefit. It was further submitted that the assessee had the option
to claim exemption either under Section 1l or under Section ro(23c)(vi)
of the Act and that rejection of exemption under both provisions was
contrary to law.
14. Per contra, learned Senior Standing Counsel for
the
respondent/Revenue, Mr.vijay K punna, contended that the lindings
recorded by the Assessing Authority, the crr(A) and the learned ITAT
were ,.ot merely based on the statement of Mr. R. Srinivas Rao but were
based on the substa,tial incriminating materia-l seized during the survey
operations, which clearly established collection of amounts over and
above the fees prescribed by the Government from students admitted
under the management quota. It was further contended that such
amounts were neither accounted for in the regular books nor deposited
in the bank accounts of the assessee, the same were utilized by persons
interested in the management of the societJr, thereby attracting the
mischief of Section l3(1)(cl of the Act.
B
15. Learned Scnior Standing Counsel further contended that the
assessee has not derived any income from propert5r held under Trust and
that its entire income is derived from running educational institutions,
thus the exemplion under Section 11 is impermissible. It was further
contended that the assessee had initialllr sought exemption under
Section I 0(23C)(vi) , u,hich was rejected, and thereafter attempted to
invoke Section 1I as an afterthought. According to the learned counsel,
the concurrer-r[ findings are recorded by thc CIT(A) and the learned ITAT,
s'ho are the fact-finding authorities, as such there is no substantial
question of lau' falling for consideration by this Court.
16. We have given earnest consideration to the submissions rnade by
the learned counsel appearing on either side and perused the material on
record.
77. Thc mzrin grievance of the appellant/ assessee is that the findings
recorded bv the authonties are vitiated as they are founded primarily on
the statement o[ Mr. R. Srinivas Rao, who has no nexus with the affairs
ol the :rsscssec, and the assessing authority u,ithout affording the
assessec a fair and effective opportunity to cross-examine the said
R.
Srinivas Rao. ar-rd that the amounts reflected in the seized m aterial
were erroneoLlslv treated as excess or unaccounted collections
I
18' In this backdrop, the only issue that arose for consideration
this court was whether the appenalt/assessee
before
had offered a satisfactory
ald credible explanation with respect to the incriminating
unearthed during the survey proceedings and
material
whether the alleged
collection of additionar amounts under the management
quota had been
duly accounted for in accordance with law.
19' A perusal of the record shows that the appertant/assessee
initially applied to the competent authority for exemption
under Section
lo(23c)(vi) of the Act, which was rejected. Subsequently,
Assessing Authority, the assessee claimed that
choose between Sections 1O(23C)(vi) and 1 1 of
it had the option to
ground that there was
no income from propert5r held by the Trust and that
the assessee was derived from running educational
20.
the entire income of
institutions, and held
applicable.
The Assessing Authority categorically found that the
violated the provisions of Section r 3(1)(c) of
before the
the Act. However, the
Assessing Authority denied the said craim on the
that the provisions of Section 1O(23C) alone were
assessee had
the Act, by utilizing the
lunds of the society for the benefit of persons interested
manegement and there is no income of the assessee
as such exemption under Section l l of the Act
had
in the
from its properties
is impermissible.
2l . Before the CIT(A), the issue was whether the assessee was entitled
to claim exemption under Section 1 1 or under Section 1O(23C)(vi) of the
Act. The CIT(A), n,ho is the fact {inding appellate authority, noted that the
assessee's main activity u,as running educationa-l institutions and it did
not derive anlr in('ome frtrm property held under trust, thereby making
exemption under the provisions of Section 11 impermissible, and
consequentlv, the provisions of Section 1O(23C) alone would apply
22. The CIT(A) zrnd the learned ITAT further observed that substantial
incriminating matcri:rl serzed during the survey operations raised serious
doubt as to ra'hether tht: institution was being run with a charitable
object or u ith a profit motive. Further, it was observed that the amounts
collected lrom the students in excess of the fees prescribed by the
Government u,ould amount to collection of capitation fee. Further, a
ieeble atternpt is madc to prove that the said amount is the aggregate of
the total I'ee for four vears course collected at once from the students
admittcd r-rndcr management quota, but however, neither the books of
accounts nor tht' bank account contained the said amount, thus,
evidentl-r, cxcess fec collccted, which is not accounted for as per the
procedure. is capitation fee. Further, it can safely be inferred that the
running ol thc cducational institutions by the assessee is nothing but
1i
with profrt motive a,d the assessee has thereby
deviated from its stated
charitable objectives a,d the assessing authority
exemption under both Sections 1O(23C) arrd 1l
rightly denied
of the Act.
23' It is therefore a crear case of colection of amounts over and above
the prescribed fees amounting to capitation fee.
Thus, both the findings
of the learned ITAT and the .IT(A) that the assessee-society
solely for educationar purposes but existed only for
did not exist
the prorrt/benefit of
the management, appears to be va_lid and germane.
24. In the above circumstances, the submissions made
by the
appellant/assessee that the amounts reflected in the
incriminating
materia-l represented the total fees payable by candidates
for four years
collected at once, was not supported by any evidence.
Further, had the
said claim was true, the assessee wourd have maintained
separate books
of account for each candidate and deposited such arnounts
accounts. No such e,,.idence was produced. There was
also nothing on
record to show that the amounts allegedly collected in
prescribed fees had been properly credited to the
in its bank
excess of the
bank accounts oi the
assessee- However, a perusal of the statement of Mr. R.
Srinivas Rao,
revealed that notwithsta,ding his designation as a project
officer, the
manner in which he spoke about the a-ftairs of the management
clearly
t2
established that he rvas closely associated with the society and in that
view of the matter, the question of gralting opportunity for crossexamination of Mr.R.Srinivasa Rao, does not amount to aly violation of
principles of natural justice or doctrine of fair play.
25. In the abscnce of anv cogent or satisfactory explanation placed by
the appelian t/ asscssee to disbelieve the version of the Income-tax
authorities, and irr light ol the concurrent findings recorded by the CIT(A)
and the learned ITAT, u,e lind no grounCs to discredit the conclusions
drawn by the au[horities. Further, in our considered view, the CIT(A)
and the learned I'lA1', bcing the fact-finding authorities, have appreciated
the facts and evirlcnce on rccord in proper prospective. Though a feeble
attempt u as marle b,r the appellar-rt / assessee to assail the said findings,
no material u as placed on record to \r,arrant interference with the said
concurrent lindings
26. In vieu' of the above findings, we are of the considered view that,
the instant appeals are der,oid of merit and liable to be dismissed. The
substantial qucstions of law are thus, answered against the
appellan t I assessee arnd in fa.,,our of the respondent/Revenue.
27.
'
Accordingly, both the appeals are dismissed alfirming the orders
passed by the learned ITAT as well as the CIT(A) and the Assessing
I
i
I
Authority. There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
SO/. N.SRIHARI
DEPUW REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
I
J
To,
1. The lncome Tax Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench 'B', Hyderabad
I
i
I
2. One CC to Sri. K Vasantkumar Advocate [OPUC]
3, One CC to Sri. Viihay K Punna (Senior Standing counsel for lncome Tax
Department) [OPUC]
4. Two CD Copies
i
I
I
DUPSL
fk
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1210212026
COMMON JUDGMENT
lT'l-A.Nos.152 of !008 & 337 of 201 1
lHE S fa c'
(o
oo
t(
*
DISMISSING THE APPEALS
C
.ofl-
5r-
I H r\ I0 26
R
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review