Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
o
-..
'4.:.
IN TI.IE I{IGH Cq'RT FOR T}IE STATE OF TELANGANA
i.4
\
FRIDAY,TFIE NINTFI DAY OF JANUARY
n /O THOUSANDATID T\ ,ENTY SIX :
PRESENT
THE I-IO]\IOUil\ALE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHMAN
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of lndia, aggrieved by the
Order Dated 06.01.2025 passed in Revision Petition No.908 of fr24 on the file
of the National Consumer Disputes Redressat Commission at New Oethi Eled
against the Order dated 07.11-2023 rnade in F.A.No.625 of 2020 passed by the
State Gonsumer Redressal Commission at Telangana against the Order dated
19.03.2020 made in C.C.No.271 ol 2018 on the file of the Distrlct Consumer
Redressal Gommission at Warangal.
Between:
1.
2.
AND
1. Bussari RajeshwarRao, SIo Komuraiah, Age. 4O years, Occ. Agriculture, R/o
Shivaji Nagar, H/o. Rekampally Duggondi Mandal, Warargal Rural District.
2. MadhuriAgerrcies. Pesticides and Seeds, Opp. SunilTalkies, Station Road,
Warangal, Rep by its Proprietor.
3. Aruna Seeds and Pesticides, H.No - 8-5-5012, Near Poctrammagudi, Station
Road. Warangal, .Rep by its Proprietor.
4. Bharath Seeds, H.t{o. 7-1-147, Opp. t{ew Busstop, Warargal, Rep by its
Proprietor.
...RE'ISPONDENTS'RESPON DENT/RESPOM)ENT'COiII PLAIN ANT
lA tlO: 2 OF 2A25
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit fibd in support of the petitlon, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the lmpugned Judgment and final Order dated 06.01 .2025, passed by
G
the Naticrnal Consumer Disputes Redressal Cornrnission, New Delhi, in Revision
. ;ri,.:i::
.:',
' }
Gounsel for the Petitioners : SRI:'I( ANiRtlgl{',negOY
Counsel fior the Respondent Nd.l : SRI Pr;RAVl,SHAlll(€R
The Gourt made the following: OREER
:
o
IN THE HTGH COTTRT T'ORTHE STAIE, OF TEI,AI{GANA
ATETDERABAD
TITE HONOT'RABLE SRI JT'STICE I( LAI(SMi{AN
Betwen:
VNR Seeds Pvt ttd and another
...Petitioners
AI{D
Bussari Rajeshwar Rao and threeotbers
...Respondents
ORDER:
This civil Revision Petition is dismissed in terrrs of the
conrmon order dated lg.l2.2g?5 passed in C.R.p.No
.llls of 2025'
and batch. There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall
stand closed.
SD/- A. SREENIVASA REDOY
REGISTRAR
\
,TTRUE COPYII
To,
SECTION OFfICER
l. The National ConsurnerRedressal
New Delhi
2- The State Consumer Redressal Commission
3. The District Consumer Redressal Commission at Warangal.
4. One CC to Sri K.Anirudh Reddy; Advocate {oPUc}
5. One CC to Sri P.Ravi Shankar, Advocate (oPUc)
6. Two CO Copies_-Ks/PSL
-W
(annex a copy of rhe Order dated 19.12.2025 inC.R.P.No.l 175 of Z02S and batch
to
this order)
€ 3
HIGH'COURT
DATEr':09r01 12026
CRP,No.36{8 of 2025
iATE
..:
o
O
1 $ tEB 2$?[
-!:
Dismissing the C.R.P.
Without costs.
l,\,t
.:rj
-.'"s r'
Itttps://csis.slrc.gov.in/trcordersl2025 lcrylcq _ll7 5 2025.p<
crp_1175 2025.docx - crp_l 175 2025.pdf
KI. J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batcb
HIGH COI'RT FOR TIIE STATE OF TELATTGAI\A
AT ITYDERABAI)
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE I( LAKSHMAIY
CIVIL REVISION PETITION Nos. 1175. 1196. 1197. 1198. 1201. 1202.
1203. L205. 1206. 1210. l2l!.1222.1249.1260.1264 .1266. 1279. 1290.
t281. 12g2. l2g3 .1294.1293. 1314. l32o .1321.1324 .1325 .1326, 1327.
t340. 1346. 1372. 1373.1377.1392.1393.1407 .1409. 1409. 1494. 1485.
1486. 1487. 1488. l4gg.1490. l4gl.1492.1493.1494. 1495. 1496. 1497.
17 24. 17 25. t7 26. 17 27 . 17 43. 17 44. 17 45. 17 46
. 2017. 17 47. 17 49. 17 49.
I750. 1753. 1821. 1822. 1924. 1923. 1925. 1926. 1827. 1828. 1929. 1830.
1831. 1945. 1946. 1947. 1949. 1949. 1959. 1E59. 1960. 1E61. 1962. 1963.
1864. 1865. 1g67. lg6g. 1g6g. 1g70. 1g71. 1g72. 1g73. 1g74. 1g76. 1g77.
1878. 1880. 1892. 1893. 1994. 1995. 1996. 1997. lEgg. 1999. 1921. 1923.
1926. 1929. 1940. 1957. !959. lg5g.1972. lgg3. 1999.2000.2001,2002.
I
2t
2t4,1. 2149.,2150. 215t. 2154. 2155. 21tr6. 2157. 2163. 2164. 2165. 2t77.
2 184. 2324. 232s. 2696. 2326. 2344. 2346. 2345. 2347. 23 48. 237 4. 2380.
5 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.shc.gov.in/trcordesl2025 I crpl crp_ll7 5 2025.pd|
ctp_1175 2025.docx - crp-l 175 2025.pdf
r'_
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
2698. 2699. 27 00. 27 01. 27 02. 27 03. 27 0 4. 27 14. 27 15. 27 16. 27 l7 . 27 18.
3086. :1097. 3100. 3088. 3109. 3179. 3114. 3161. 3166. 3167. 3168. 3169.
3l
3184. :1185. 3186. 3187 . 3207 . 3208. 3209. 3225. 3227. 3239. 3240. 3249.
3502. 3;503. 3504 OF 2025
Betwer:n
VNR Seeds Private Limited
.Petitioners
and other
and
Linganrpalli Ravinder
and others
6 of99
Respondents
215/2026,4:50 PM
crp_ll75 2025.docx - crp_1175 2o25.gf
hqs://csis.S,hc.gov.in/hcordersl2025l crpl crp_ll7 5 2025.pt
KI",
CRP l.b.l t75 of2025 & Barch
The Court passed the following
COMMON ORDER:
Heard Mr. Ankit Swaroop, Mr. Drupad Sangwan,
Mr. N. Pavan Krishna Reddy, Mr. Rishi Bhargava, Mr. Rrrchil Raj,
Ms. Harika Tejavath, Ms. Duvnrru Ruthitca Reddy, M. M. Naga
vekata Neeraj and Mr. K. Anirudh Reddy, rearned counsel for
respective petitioners and Mr. Kunamalta Karunakar, Mr. p.Ravi
Shankar and Mr. P. Aravind Reddy, teamed counsel for respective
respondents.
2- All these revisions arise out of common order dated
06.01 .2025 passed by learned National consumer Disputes Redressal
commission, New Delhi (for short, 'leamed NcDRc') in Revision
Petition No.l376 of 2024 and batch, whereby learned NCDRC had
upheld the orders passed by learned Distict Forum by setting aside
the orders passed by learned State Commissiea wherein State
commission allowed some appeals filed by the peitioners, in part,
reduced the quantum of compensation granted by leanred District
7 of99
2/5/2026,4:50 PM
httss://csis. tshc. gov.in/hcorderv2o25/crdcrp-l
crp ll75-2o25.docx - crp-l175 -202 5.pdf
E
I 75-2025'Pdl
.
KI. J
CRP I.Io.l175 of2025 & Bd.h
Foruln and allowed some appeals in toto, set aside some of the orders
passed by the District Forum in respect of some farmers
-
3. Since there are multiple revisions, it would be difficult to
discuss facts of all the cases. Further, the facts of all the cases are
similar, except the names of parties and the quantum of compensation
gratrted. There is no dispute with regard to the facts. Therefore, to
avoid confusion and to have more clarity, it would be better to refer to
the fa<';ts of the case in CRP No. 1203 of 2025.
4. The revision petitioner is a company registered under the
Companies Act, 1956. It engaged in the business of seed production
and sal es having its registered office at Raipur,
:i. Respondent No.l is a farmcr and resident of Agrahampahad
village, Atmakur Mandal, Warangal District, Telangana State and is
claimirg to have been cultivating chilli crops for the last few years.
8 of99
215D0-6,4:50 PN
W_1175 ]025.docx - crp_l I 75_2025.pdf
--
hsps://csis.tstrc.gov.inlhcorde rsl2025l crp/ crp_ll7 5 2O25.p,
r"
KI. J
CRP No.ll75 of2025 & Barch
6. It is also apt to note that even other farmers/complainants
residents of the said village and other nearby villages of warangat
district, claiming to have been cultivating chilli crop for the last few
years
7. Respondent No.2 is a dealer, who sold the soeds to the
farmer. Respondent No.l - farmer purchased ten (10) packets of MrlR
145 chilli seeds on 07.03.2017 from respondent No.2 dealer vide Lst
No.l870 after paying an amount of Rs.3,300/- manufactured by
Respondent No.l. Thereafter, respondent No.r sowed the seeds in an
area measuring Ac.l.00 guntas in the month of April, said to have
incurred an amount of Rs.40,000/- for cultivating the land.
8. According to respondent No.l - Farmer, there was crop loss
due to supply of defective, mis-branded, genetically poor chilli seeds
9. Upon a letter written by various farmers onM.07.2017 with
regard to alleged bad condition of crop, the Distict collector,
warangal, informed the same to the Agriculture officer, Joint
Director of Agriculture and District Horticulture and Sericulture
9 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
https://csis.tshc. gov.iry'hcordes/2O25 I crpl crp
crp_ll7 5 2}25.docx - crp-l 175- 2025.pdf
-ll7 ]025.pd|
(',
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
Officr:rs. Later, the District Agricutture Officer, vide letter dated
07.07.2017 directed the Mandal AgriculUrre Offrcer to conduct
joint
inspection with the Horticulture offrcer and report compliance at the
earlier;t.
10. The Mandal Agriculture officer, vide letter dated
lO.O7.2Ol7, informed the Asst. Director of Agriculture, Telangana
DNA Frnger Printing Crops monitoring Lab that he is sending green
chillies leaves of 50 plants (randomly selected) for analysis. The Joint
District-Level committee conducted a visual inspection on I [ -07 -2017
and subsequenfly submitted its report, stating that the crop had been
severely affected by 'Thrips incidence', during the initial crop
growing stage, attributed to the prevalence of high temperatures.
Further it was stated that the crop was affected by viral diseases such
as PBIW @eanut Bud Necrosis Virus) and CMV (Cucumber Mosaic
Virus) which led to poor growth.
.[1. Thereafter, on 0[.08.2017, the Genetic Purity test report
was submitted to the District Agriculture officer, Warangal, and the
Cornmissioner of Agriculture, Telangana have concluded that, sample
l0 of99
21512026,4:50 PV
ctp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_ll7 5 ]025.dt
https://csis.tstrc.gov.in/bcoderV2025 I crf, ctp_ll7 5 _2025.p<
KI" J
CRP No.l 175 of z)25 & Barch
taken from the field and the sample given by the Manufacturerpetitioner differed and termed thern 'Misbranded'
12. The respondent No. t approached the tearned District
consumer Forum, warangal, by filing a consumer complaint bearing
No.199/2018 under section 12 ofrhe consumer Protection Act, 1986
(herein aftet'' Act, 1986") to direct the Petitioners herein to pay
compensation for the alleged crop loss and other expens€s incurred
with regard to the crop failure. Likewise, other similarly situated
farmers also filed complaints with similar contentions. The Learned
District Consumer Forum has allowed the complaints in part holding
that the petitioners herein - opposite parties are jointly and severally
liable and directed them to deposit a sum of Rs.1,35,000/- (One Lakh
Thirty Five Thousand only) towards crop loss for Ac.l.00 guntas of
land with interest @7.5o/o p.a. and ro pay Rs.10,000/- (Ten Thousand
Rupees only) towards mental agony, legal expenditure including costs
with one month from the date of receipt of a copy of that order.
13. Aggrieved by the orders passed by the learned District
Forum, the Petitioners herein have preferred appeals in State
I I of99
21512026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcorde rs/2025 I crpl ap
cry_1175 2025.docx - crp-I175. 2025.pdf
-ll7
5 2025 -fi1
a-.
L2
.
KL,J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
Comrnission under Section 15 of the Act, 1986 vide Appeal
No.7()3/2020 and batch. Vide orders all dated 07.11 .2023, the learned
State Corrmission has allowed some appeals in part and some appeals
in toto, reduced the quantum of Compensation awarded by the District
Constrmer Forum in some appeals, directing to pay a sum of
Rs.67,500/- to the Respondent No.l/Complaint along with Rs. 10,000/towarrls costs of the titigation within eight weeks.
14. Against the orders passed by the State Commission,
Hyderabad, the Petiti
and farrners - complainants have filed
Revision Petitions under Section 2l(b) of the Act of 1986 before the
leamerl NCDRC. The learned NCDRC has disposed of the Revision
Petitions vide commonorder dated 06.01 .2025. The learned NCDRC
has upheld the orders passed by the learned District Forum, and has
set asirle the orders passed by the State Commission.
t5. The Petitioners have filed these Civil Revision Petitions
against the said common order dated 06.01 .2025 passed by the learned
NCDRC, New Delhi.
12 of99
21512026,4:50 Ptv
ctp _ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_1175 ]025.pdf
htps://csis.tshc.gov.infircorde ls12025 I crplc,rp _ll7 5 ]025.p<
KI.,
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
16. rf,fe have heard leaned counsel for the petitioners and
respondents {onsumers extensively.
17. At the initial stage of hearing, learned counsel for the
respondents did raise an objection as to the maintainability of the
present civil Revision Petitions filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India. However, upon further hearing and after
adverting to the seffled legal position, both leamed counsel ultimately
agreed that the petitions are maintainable. The issue of maintainability
is, in any event, no longer res integra. In M/s. Indus Hospitals v.
Rajeev Lochan Singht (C.R.P. No. 2gg4 of 2024, decided on
02.05.2025), High Court of Andhra Pradesh, in paragraph 45, has
categorically held that a Revision Petition filed under Article 227 of
Constitution of India, against an order passed by the NCDRC under
Section 58(lxb) of the Consumer Protecrion Act, 2019, as such an
order is not appealable and the learned NCDRC answen the
description of a "Tribunal". The said conclusion was reached by
tQ02s) 3ALD 801
l3 of99
215/2026,4:50 PM
https://csis.shc. gov.in/hcorde rsl 2025 I crpI ctp
ctp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp-l I 75- 2025.pdf
-ll7
-2O25
-pdl
t-"
L4
KI. J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batcb
placing reliance on the authoritative pronouncement of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in lbrat Faizan Y. Omaxe Buildhorne Pvt. Ltd.,2
whictr recognizes the supervisory jurisdiction of the High Court over
tribunals. [n view of the aforesaid binding precedent and the
consensus ultimately recorded between the parties, the objection as to
maintlinability stands answered, and the pnesent Civil Revision
Petitions are maintainable.
18. Definition of cConsumert' under the Consumer
Proter:tion Act.
i) The present batch of matters requiros an authoritative
exami::lation of the meaning and ambit of the expression "consumer
"
as employed in Section 2(1Xd) of the Act of 1986 and its successor
provis:on, Section 2(7) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019
(hereirrafter, "the 2019 Act"). Both enactrnents are products of
Parliarnent's resolve to protect individual purchasers and recipients of
service.s from exploitation by economically dominant market actors.
The slatute is, therefore, remedial and beneficent in nature; its
provisions must receive a liberal and purposive construction
'(zozl) lr scc 594
l4 of99
2/5/2026,4:50 PM
ctp_ll7 5 J025.docx - crp_ll7 5 ?l25.df
hrps://csis.tshc. gov.in/hcorde rsl2025I crp/crp_ll7 5 _ZO25.pc
KL,
'
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Barct
consistent with the objective of consumer welfare rather than be
confined by narrow or technical interpretation.
ii) Section 2(1Xd) of the 1986 Act defined a consunrer as any
person who buys goods or hires or avails services for consideration,
but does not include a person who obtains such goods or services for
resale or for any conrmercial purpose, save where such goods or
services are used exclusively for earning a livelihood by means of
self-emplo1m.ent. This formulation reflects a deliberate legislative
balance between consumer protection and commercial freedom. The
2019 Act, through Section 2(7), substantially re-enacts the same
language, signiffing legislative continuity and endorsemenr of the
interpretation placed upon the earlier Act by the Courts.
iii) The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Lucknow Development
Authority v. M.I( Gupta3, characterized the Act as a "social-welfare
legislation" desigued to provide inexpensive and expeditious redressal
to consumers. The Court observed that provisions of such welfare
15 of99
lreel; r scc243
2/5t2026,4:50 PM
hups://csis.shc.gov.io/hcordersl2025 I crpl crp
cry-1175 2025.docx - crp-I175 2025.pdf
-ll7
5 2025 -pdl
tt'\
- KI.J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
statutes must be construed in a manner that advances their object and
suppresses the mischief they intend to remedy. The ratio was
subsequently reiterated in Kusum Sharma Y. Batra Hospitala, which
held that the Act's reach extends to every sector public or private
when: goods or services are offered for consideration.
iv) The definition of consumer thus admits of two essential
elements:
a) the existence of a transaction of purchase or hiring for
consicteration, and
b) the exclusion of transactions for resale or commercial
purpose.
v) The latter exclusion, however, is tempered by the statutory
exception for livelihood-based self-employment. The clause was
designed to prevent large-scale conrmercial enterprises from invoking
the Act while ensuring that individuals engaged in small or
subsistence-based activity are not deprived of its protection. Judicial
interpretation has consistently emphasised that this exclusion must be
' lzottr;3 scc 480
16 of99
215/2026.4:50 PV
crp_ll7s 2025.docx - crp_I175 2025.pdf
lrtps://csis.Slrc.gov.inlhcorde sl 2025I crpkrp_ll7 5 2O25.g.
L7
' Kr'J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
narrowly constnrd, lest the remedial purpose of the legislation be
defeated.
vi) The Supreme Court in Laxmi Engineering Works v. pSG
Industrial Institutes, intoduced what has come to be known as the
dominant-purpose test. It held that the determination whether a
transaction is commercial must depend on the dominant purpose for
which the goods or services are obtained. where the dominant
purpose is to eam livelihood by setf-employment, the purchaser
remains a consumer, where it is to engage in large-scale commercial
exploitation for profit, the exclusion applies. This doctrinar
development has guided subsequent judicial reasoning for nearly three
decades.
vii) Following Laxmi Engineering (supra), the consumer fora
and High courts have uniformly held that the definition of consurner
must be interpreted with functional realism, focusing on the nature of
use rather than the scale of activity. The expression "commercial
s
l7 of99
lress;3 scc 583
215/2026,4:50 PM
hups://csis.shc.gov.in/hcorde rs/ 2025 I crpl crp
ctp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp-l I 75-2025.pdf
-ll7 -2025.pd|'
(
KI. J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batcb
purpose" cannot be read in a rigid economic sense divorced from the
statutt:'s welfare objective. The true test is whether the transaction
bears the characteristics of consumption that is, use for personal
benefit or livelihood rather than of commerce.
viii) In Emaar MGF Land Ltd. v. Aftab Singh6, the Supreme
Court further clarified that the Consumer Protection Act provides an
additional and special remedy, and must be constued harmoniously
with its underlying policy of consumer welfare. The jurisdiction of the
consurner fora is thus to be interpreted expansively to effectuate, not
to limit, the right of the consumer to seek redressal.
ix) Read conjointly, these authorities establish that the term
consunrer under both the 1986 and 2019 Acts is not confined to a
contractual purchaser in the ordinary mercantile sense but extends to
any person who buys goods or avails services for consideration in
order t,r satisff personal, domestic, or livelihood-related needs. The
exclusi,)ns for resale and commercial purpose are exceptions to this
l8 of99
1zo re1 r 2 scc 751
2/512026,4:50 Plv
crp _lL7 5 2025.docx - crp_l I 75_2025.pdf
htqs://csis.Shc.gov.in/hcordes/2o25l
crp/crp_ll7 5 2025.pd
KI" I
CRP l.Io.l 175 of2025 & Batch
broad rule and must be strictly proven by the pafty asserting them.
The legislative continuity between the two Acts, coupled with
sustained judicial interpretation; reinforces a single principle that the
expression consumer must be consfiued purposively and liberally to
promote access to justice for individuals who, as end-users, depend on
the fairness, competence, and integnty of suppliers and serviceproviders.
x) Accordingly, this Court holds that for the purpose of
adjudication under the Consumer Protection Act, a consumer is any
person who purchases goods or avails senrices for consideration for
personal or livelihood use and not for resale or profit-oriented
enterprise. The determination in each case must rest upon the
dominant purpose of the tansaction, viewed in its social and
economic context. Such interpretation alone gives full effect to the
beneficent purpose of the enacfuent and aligns with the consistent
exposition of the law by the Supreme Court of India.
19 of99
2/5t2026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.tshc.gov itlhcordersl2025 I crpl crp_l I 1 5
crp_l175_2025.docx - crp-l 175. 2025.pdf
-2O2
5.pd:
a,'
-
xr4 J
CRP No.l U5 of2025 & Bdch
19.
a
'rs
,
i) The issue whether a cultivator purchasing seeds for sowing
can bc regarded as a "consumef' within the meaning of the Consumer
Prote(:tion Acts has engaged the attention of judicial fora for over
three decades. It arises here in a cluster of complaints wherein the
respondents small and marginal farmers allege defective hybrid seeds
and n:sultant crop failure. Resolution of this issue tums upon the
proper construction of Section 2( I )(d) of the 1986 Act and its
successor provision, Section 2(7) ofthe 2019 Act.
:.i) Both provisions adopt the same legislative scheme, a
consumer is any person who buys goods or avails services for
considr:ration, but does not include one who does so for resale or for
any co:nmercial purpose, save where such goods or services are used
exclusively for earning a livelihood by means of self-employment.
This e:,:press saving clause reflects the Legislahre's intent to shield
those engaged in livelihood-based activity even where such activity
20 of99
21512026,4:50 PN
crp_1175 Jn25.docx - crp_l 175 2025.pdf
hfips://csis.Shc"gov.in/trcorde
rs/2025 I crpl crp_ll7 5 2025
N
KL,
'
CRP tb.l 175 of2025 & Batch
incidentally yields income. The exclusion for "coimmercial purpose"
iii) Applyrng that principle, th€ National Commis5iell in
Maharashtra Hybrid Seeds Co. Ltd. v. Alavalapati Chandra
ReddyT, held that cultivators who purchased h)forid seeds for their
own fields were consumen under tbe Act, and that the seed
company's plea of "commercial use" was misconceived. The Court
observed that the scale of cultivation is immaterial so long as the
dominant purpose is livelihood, and rejected the argument that sale of
the produce in the market converted the activity into commerce. The
ruling marked the frrst authoritative recognition of agriculturists as
consumers within the stanrtory framework.
iv) This reasoning was taken forward in Nandan Biomatrix
Ltd. v. Ambika DeviE, where the National Commission held that
failure of germination in Jatropha Curcas seeds constituted deficiency
in service and that the complainant farmers, harring purctrased the
scc 738
'1reer;6
I2ozo
13 scc l3o
2l of99
2/5/2026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.shc.gov.ini1rcorderV2025/crp/crp_1175
crp_l 175_2025.docx - crp_l175-_2025.pdf
2025.pdt
C
KL, J
CRP No.l175 of2025 & Batcb
seeds for their own cultivation and not for resale, were consumers.
The Commission emphasized that agricultural operations carried on
for livelihood are excluded from the expression 'tommercial
purpose", even ifthey yield marketable surplus.
v) The law now stands conclusively settled by the Supreme
Court in National Seeds Corporation Ltd. v. M. Madhusudhan
Reddyq. The Supreme Court, after examining the scheme of the Seeds
Act, 1966 and the Act of 1986, held that a farmer who purchases
seeds tor his own use and not for resale is a consumer, and that supply
of delbctive seeds resulting in crop loss amounts to deficiency in
senrico. It.was categorically obsewed that the fact that a cultivator
sells his produce in the market does not make the tansaction
commercial, since such sale is a natural incident of livelihood and not
an act of trade. The Court directed the seed corporation to compensate
the farmers and reaffirmed that the statute must receive a liberal and
purposive interpretation to fulfill its welfare objective.
e
22 of 99
lzotzlz scc 506
21512O26,4:5O PM
cry_ll7 5 _2025.docx - crp_l I 75 2025.pdf
htps://csis.tshc.govjn/trcorde
_ll7 S 2025.pc
rs/ 2025 I crpl crp
:
KI",J
CRPNo.ll?5 of2025 & Batch
vi) Following Madhusudhan Reddy (supra), a oonsistent line
of authority has developed. In Fortune Hybrid Seeds Ltd. v.
Bommala Pedda Swamyro, the learned NCDRC? relying on
departmental and laboratory reports that established low germination
and genetic impurity, held that the farmers were consumers and that
the manufacturer's plea of adverse weather was untenable in the
absence of scientific proof.
vii) These precedents collectively establish that the Act must be
applied in its social-economic context. furiculture in India is
primarily a means of livetihood, not commerce, the cultivator is a
consumer who relies on representations and scientific expertise of
seed companies. To exclude such persons woulddefeat the beneficent
purpose of the statute and perpetuate structural inequality between
corporate suppliers and rural purchasers.
viii) This purposive construction also accords wittl the
constitutional vision embodied in Articles 38 and 39(b) of the
r0
23 of99
2015 SCC Online learned NCDRC 325
A5/2026,4:50 PM
https://csis.shc.gov.in/trcorders/2O25 I cr! cry
crp_ll't5 2025.docx - crp-1175- 2025'pdf
-ll7
5 2025 -pd',
-KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
Constitutioa of India, which require the State to secure social and
economic justice and ensure equitable distribution of resources. By
recogllzing fanners as consumers, the judiciary has harmonized
con$lmer law with agrarian policy, ensuring that statutory protection
exter.ds to those most vulnerable to market asynmetries.
ix) Accordingly, this Court holds that agriculturists who
purchase soods or other agricultural inputs for cultivation undertaken
for their own livelihood squarely fall within the definition of
consumer under Section2(7) of the 2019 Act. The mere fact that such
cultirration yields income or involves sale of produce in the market
does not alter its character. What is decisive is the dominant purpose
that the goods are purchased for use in livelihood and not for
commercial resale.
x) To hold otherwise would be to deny the very class of persons
whorn the legislation was designed to protect. The cultivator is not a
trader in soeds but an end-user of them, he consumes, rather than
markets, the product. In the absence o[ any contrary legislative intent,
24 of99
215/2026,4:50 PM
crp_ll7 5 3O25.docx - crp_ll7 5 2025.pdf
https://csis.tstrc.gov.iry'trcordes/2025 I crpl crp_l 17 5 2025 @
KI. J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
the judicial consensus ttrat farmers are consumers under the Act must
be regarded as settled law.
Extent
, i) At this stage, it becomes necessary to delineate the tnre
import, content and extent of the expression "deficiency in service" as
envisaged under the Consumer Protection Act. The distinction
between defect in goods and deficiency in service lies at the heart of
the present controversy, for the outcome in these matters tums upon
whether the acts and omissions alleged against the petitioners
constitute statutory defi ciency
ii) Sections 2(lX0 and 2(lXg) of the 1986 Act, define defect
and deficiency respectively as a scheme that has been substantially
carried forward into Sections 2(10) and 2(l l) of the 2019 Act.
'Defecf' means any fault, imperfection or shortcoming in the quality,
quantity, potency, purity or standard required by law or contract to be
maintained in relation to goods; while "deficiency'' refers to any fault,
imperfection, shortcoming or inadequacy in the quality, nature or
25 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.shc. gov.iry'hcorderd 2025 I crpl crp_l 17 5
crp_1175 2025.docx - crp_l 175 2025.pdf
-2025.pd|
KL,T
CRP No.l I75 of2025 & Batch
manner of performance required to be maintained by law or
undertaken in relation to any service.
iii) Section 2(11) of the 2019 Act now expressly includes
within its ambit "any act of negligence or omission or commission
and deliberate withholding of relevant information by such person to
the consumer." This legislative amplification acknowledges the
asymrneoy of inforrration between provider and consumer and
broadens the statutory reach to include acts of concealment and
r,nisinfbrmation a significant development reflecting the transition
from a fault-based to a duty-based model of liability.
iv) The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Lucknow Development
Authority (supra), interpreting these very provisions, held that both
public authorities and private service-providers fall within the ambit
of the Act, and that delay, negligence or defective work amount to
deficiency in service. The Court observed that while defect in goods
may be: remedied by replacement or repair, deficiency in service must
26 ot99
2/5/2026,4:50 PM
crp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_l I 75_2025.pdf
htps://csis.tshc. gov.in/hcorde rsl&25 I crpl crp_ll7 5 J025
d
KL,
'
CRP No.l175 of Z)25 & Batch
ofte,n be compensated through damages, for it affects the quality and
manner of performance itsetf.
v) The expression "service" itself, defined in Section 2(t)(o) of
the 1986 Act (now Section 2(42) of the 2019 Act), is of the widest
amplitude. It encompasses seruice of any description made available
to potential users and specifically includes facilities relating to
banking, finance, insurance, transport, energy, housing, construction,
and dissemination of information.
Gupra) described the definition as three-fold a main clause, an
inclusive clause, and an exclusionary clause and observed that ttre
words uant''and'lotential" are of wide import, thereby extending the
Act's cov€rage from one to all categories of service.
vii) In Indigo Airlines v. Kalpana Rani Debbarmart, the
Apex Court clarified that any deviation, whether by an act or
omission, from the prornised or expected standard of performance
" eozo)9scc4z4
27 of99
U512026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.tshc.gov.iry'hcorders/2025 I crpl crp_ll7 5 2025.pd|
ctp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_l 175_ 2025.pdf
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Barch
constitutes deficiency. tikewise?
,SGS India Ltd. v. Dolphin
International Ltdr2.r, held that once the complainant discharges the
initiat onus, the burden shifts to the service-provider to establish that
its conduct rnet the requisite standard.
viii) The jurisprudence recognizes three dimensions of
deficiency:
viii-a) Quatitative, where service is sub-standard;
viii-b) Procedural, where there is delay or neglect;
viii-c) Informational, where material facts are suppressed.
Each is actionable, since the Act intends not merely to compensate but
to uphold a standard of reasonableness and diligence expeoted in
servic:e re lationships.
ix) The Supreme Court in Spring Meadows Hospital v. Harjol
Ahlu'rvalial3, extended the concept of deficiency to professional
neglilJence, emphasizing that lack of due care or timely attention, even
without mala fides, attacts statutory liability. Intent is immaterial,
'= 2oz) SCC online SC 879
'31r908;4 scc 39
28 of99
2/512026,4:50 PM
ctp_1175 mzS.docx - crp_1175 2OZ5.gf
hrps://csis.tshc.gov.in/lrcorderV2 025I crp/ crp_ll7 S _2O2S.pd
KI. .,
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
what'matters is performancebelow the benchmark of a reasonable and
prudent professional;
,x) Th€ 2019 Act, while modernizing consumer jurisprudence
thrcugh provisions on product liability and unfair contracts,
consciously retained the same definition of deficiency, thereby
affirming judicial precedent. This continuity reflects legislative
approval of the liberal interpretation that views the Act as a
mechanism to enforce standards of care, competence and fair dealing
across all service sectors.
xi) Thus, deficiency in service is not confined to breach of
contract but extends to any failure statutory, contractual or moral to
render service with reasonable skill, care and diligence. tt may arise in
both private and public transactions and encompasses negligent
performance, arbitrary delay, or concealment of information. The
consumer fora are, therefore, empowered to grant both compensatory
and preventive reliet, ensuring accountability and deterrence.
29 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.tshc. gov.in/lrcorde tsl 2025 I cryl ctp
crp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp-l 175-2025.pdf
:0
-&
-ll7 ]025
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
xii) Viewed in this light, the scope,of "deficiency'' under the
Cons,rmer Protection Act is both remedial and'disciplinary. It serves
not c'nly to compensate individual loss but also to enforce public
standards of reliability and transpareircy. This Court thus reiterates
that the provisions of the Act must be interpreted expansively so as to
advance its beneficent object and to secure effective protection of
consrlmer rights.
21. Applicabilitv of 5'Deficiencv in Selvice? to Goods and
ServLces. inctuOine
S
.
i) The legislative scheme of the Consumer Protection Act draws
a conceptuat distinction between defect in goods and deficiency in
servirle, but recognizes that the two ar.e often interlinked in composite
trans;rctions. Section 2(10) of the 2019 Actdefines defect as any fault,
imperfection, shortcoming or inadequacy in the quality, quantity,
potency, purity or standard of goods required to be maintained by or
under any law or contract; Section 2(ll) defines deficiency with
refer,:nce to the quality, nature or manner of performance of service.
Together, these provisions establish that where a transaction involves
30 of99
2/512026,4:50 PM
htQs://csis.tshc. gov.in/hcorde rsl2025 I cfl crp_ll7 5 ]025.pd
cry_1175 2025docx - crp_l 175 2025.pCf
KI.,
CRP IIo.l 175 of2025 & Batch
both supply of goods and related obligations of testing, storage,
certification, or after-sale assistance, the failure of any element
attracts statutory liability. '
I
'
ii) The sale of seeds, fertilizers, or pesticides is a paradigm of
such a composite transaction. The physical sale of seeds constitutes
'.,
the goods component, but the processes of laboratory testing, genetic
certification, labeling, pack4ging, ild after-sale support from the
service compone,nt inseparably connected to it. As observed by the
National Commission in several decisions, including Alavalapati
Chandra Reddy (supra) and Nandan Biomatrix Ltd (supra), a seed
company's statutory and contactual obligations do not cease upon
delivery, they extend to ensuring that the seeds conform to prescribed
germination and genetic-purity standards and that all representations
made to cultivatoni arc accurate and verifiable.
iii) In M. Madhusudhan Reddy (supra), the Supreme Court
held that the supply of defective seeds resulting in crop failure
constitutes deficiency in service under the Act. The Court reasoned
3l of99
21512026,4:50 PM
ctp_ll7 5 2o25.docx - crp_l I 75_-2025.pdf
htps://csis.shc.gov.iry'hcordesl2025l
crpl crp_ll7 5 2O25.pd
KL;J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Buch
that the responsibility of the seed-producer is twofofd, first, to deliver
seeds meeting the quality standards mandated by the Seeds Act and
Rules; and second, to ensure that such standards were verified and
certified through competent laboratories. Failure on either count is a
breach of statutory duty. The Court further emphasized that, once a
complaint supported by credible laboratory or departuental reports
shows sub-standard quality, the evidentiary burden shifts to the
manuf'acturer to establish conformity, bare assertions of pest attack or
weatht:r fluctuation are inadequate.
iv) The same principle was applied in Fortune Hybrid Seeds
Ltd. (supra), where the National Commission found that laboratory
analysis revealed genetic impurity and poor germination. The
manuftrcturer's defense that the loss was caused by climatic
conditions was rejected for want of scientific corroboration. The
Commrssion held that the manufacturer's omission to disclose parent-
line dar.a and testing records amounted to.deficiency in service within
Section 2(lXg) of the 1986 Act (now 2(ll) of the 2019 Act),
32 of99
2/5t2O26,4:50 PM
crp_ll7 5 ]025.docx - crp_ll7 5 2025.pdt
IttQs://csis.Shc.gov.in/hcorde s/2025 tcrp/ crp
_ll7 S ]O2Sd
WT
CRP No.l 175 of2b25 & Batch
observing that "suppression of material inforuration concerning
quatity control is itself a form of negligence.,,
v) Similarly, in Nandan Biomatrix Ltd (supra), the National
commission held that where seeds fail to germinate as represented,
the defect is not confined to the product but extends to the service of
ensuring quality, testing, and truthful representation. The complainant
is thus entitled to redress under the head of deficiency in service even
if the seeds, as tangible goods, are no longer available for testing. The
rationale is that the farmer pwchased not merely a physical product
but also the assurance of is certified characteristics an assurarrce
forming part of the service element ofthe tansaction.
vi)These principles are in harmony with the broader doctrine
laid down in Lucknow Development Authority (supra), and
Ghaziabad Development Authority (supra), that the consumer
Protection Act must be interpreted to advance its remedial object and
to make service-providers publicly accountable for negligence and
arbitrariness. The provision is both comp€nsafory and deterrent, it
33 of99
2/512026,4:50 PM
cry
-ll7
htps://csis.tshc.gov.in/trcorde s12025 I crpl crp
5 2025.docx - crp-l 175-2025'pdf
-ll7
5 2025'pd
rKI.I
CRP No.l l?5 of2025 & Batch
in-troduces a pubtic-law dimension into private comm€rcial relations
,,
by hclding those who profit from such relations to standaras of
faimess and diligence.
vii) It follows that the concept of deficiency in serviqe applies
equally to goods where ancillary or dependent services form an
integ:ral part of the transaction. The manufacturer's obligation to
ensure quality, to test, to labet correctly, and to provide truthful
information is a continuing service obligation. The breach Of any of
these duties constitutes deficiency, notwithstanding that the tangible
prodlrct itself is defective. [n such cases, defect and deficiency
overlap, and the consumer fora are competent to graqt comprehelsive
reliel:.
viii) Therefore, in transactions involving agricultural inputs,
parti,:ularly seeds, fertilizers and pesticides, the statutory duty of care
impc,sed upon the producer or distributor is both legal and moral. Any
failure to comply with the standards prescribed under the Seeds Act
and Rules, or to disclose relevant testing information, amgunts to
34 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
crp_1175 2025.docx - crp_l I 75_2o25.pdf
htQs://csis.tshc.gov.inAcorde rs/2025 I crp/crp_ll7 S ZO2S.N
KI. T
CRPNo.l175 of2025 & Barch
deficiency in service under Section 2(ll) of the ZOlg Act The
legislative intent is to secure accountability commensurate:with the
vulnerability of the consumer the fanner who, relying on the technical
expertise and representations of the manufacAuror, stan& at an
inherent disadvantage.
22. Burden of Proof and Evidentiarv,Standards:
i) Having delineated the legal
ework of deficiency in
seryice, it becomes apposite to consider the rules goveming proof and
evidentiary burden in consumer disputes, particularly those involving
agriculturat inputs. The statutory design of the Consumer Protection
Act is remedial and informal; its procedure departs from the rigidity
of the Evidence Act while retaining its essential principles of fairness
and probability. Accordingly, the standard of proof is that of a
p reponde rance o
f probabi lities, not proof beyond reasonable doubt.
ii) The initial onus rests upon ttre complainant to assert and
substantiate the alleged deficiency. However, consuilrcr jurisprudence
has evolved the doctrine of dynamic burden-shifting, recognizing that
35 of99
- 2151m26,4:50 PM
https://csis.tshc.gov.in/trcordercl2025 I crpl crp
crp-!l7 5 2025.docx - crp-l 175- 2025'pdf
-117
5 2025.6
I
KL,T.
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Buch
thre c;onsumer especially a farmer is often ill-equipped to, access
technical data or production records exclusively in the possession of
the rnanufacturer or dealer. Once a complainant places credible
matelial showing prima facie defect or deficiency, the burden shiffs to
the opposite party to rebut the presumption through contemporaneous
and l'erifiable evidence.
iii) In Haryana Seeds Development Corporation Ltd. v.
Sadbula, the Hon'ble Supreme Court emphasized that when a
comprlainant alleges defective agricultural inputs such as seeds, the
con$rmer forum rnust carefully evaluate the findings of exPert
comroittees constituted for that purpose. The Court held that such
expelt committee reports carry signifrcant evidentiary weight and that
mere allegations without technical scrutiny will not suffice. While
app\,ing the definition of "consumer" under the Act, the Court
observed that the purchase of seeds for livelihood may bring within its
ambit, but the consumer forum must go beyond cursory conclusions
ra
36 of99
AIFI2oo5 sc 2023
2/5n026,4:50 PM
crp _ll? 5 ]025.docx - crp_l I 75_2025pdf
hcps://csis.tsk.gov.irvhcorde rst}025/ crp/ crp
_ll7 5 _ZO2S.pd
KI{ J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Barch
and consider the expert evidence relating to soil, water; climate, and
seed purity before imposing
underscored the jurisdictional boundary of consumer,lrorums to
adjudicate fact-intensive and technicalty complex disputes only when
. '
,'
.
the requisite expert findings and procedural safeguards have been
iv) Accordingly, the decision in Sadhu (supra) lap down that
liability for defective seeds cannot be presumed m91ely because the
crop failed, the chain of causation must be supported by scientific and
expert evidence, and the consumer forum must record reasons for
accepting or rejecting such specialist evidence.
v) In M. Madhusudhan Reddy (supra), the Hon,ble Supreme
court hetd that the primary onus to establish the quality, purity and
viability of seeds lies with the manufacturer and not the fannerconsumer. The Court observed that a farmer who acquires seeds for
cultivation of livelihood cannot be expectedto retain ru-fLr, comduct
,
elaborate testing or carry forward scientific records, therefure, the
37 of99
2/5/2026,4:50 PM
cry
-ll7
htps://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcordetsl2025l crpl crp
5 2025.docx - crp-l 175- 2025.pdf
-ll7
5 2025 pd
;
t':
(i
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
statutory,$cheme places the burden on the manufacturer to preserve
batcb samples,'facititate testing and fumish evidence of quality. The
Court furtber affir-med that where the manufacturer fails to produc.e
retained salnples or competently rebuts testing of distributed seeds,
the Jrresumption of defect crystallizes and a consumer forum will
rightly place reliance on such official test reports and expert
inspe,ctions as being of high evidentiary value. Consequently, the
docfiine of burden-shifting in seed-supply disputes mandates that a
deficiency in service or unfair trade practice may be inferred from the
manufactuler's non-compliance with its evidentiary obligation
withrrut necessitating the farmer-complainant to discharge an onerous
technical burden.
vi) The National Commission, in a series of decisions including
Fortune Hybrid Seeds l.td. (supra), and Mahyco Seeds Ltd. v. B.
Yedrrkondaluls, has consistentty applied the principle, where credible
departmental or expert reports disclose defect, and the manufacturer
fails to funrish contemporaneous quality-control documentation, the
's 2oi,.l SCC online learnedNCDRC 32
38 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
hups://csis.shc.gov.in/hcorderd2025 I crpl crp_ll7 5 J025.fi
ctp_ll7 5 ]O25.docx - crp_l 175_2025.pdf
l)
KI4 J
CRP No.l l7l of 201!5 & Batch
Commission has drawn an adverse inference of negligence and
confirmed deficiency. It has been repeatedly held that "a manufacturer
who withholds scientific evidence within his special knowledge
cannot escape liabitity by invoking speculative causes."
vii) This burden structure is also justified by considerations of
equrty and policy. The consumer fora were constifuted to ensure
accessible justice without the procedural rigor of civil courb.
Imposing upon a small farmer the onerous task of proving scientific
defect beyond prima facie probability would defeat the Act's purpose.
Accordingly, once the complainant produces the purchase invoice,
departmental inspection report, or any accredited laboratory certificate
showing sub-standard quality, the evidentiary equilibrigm shifts
decisively against the supplier.
viii) At the same time, the principle of causation remains vital.
The complainant must demonstrate a reasonable nexus between the
deficiency alleged and the loss suffered. [ntervening causes such as
flood, drought or pest attack, if proved by credible scientific evidence,
39 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
crp _ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_l I 75_2025.pdf
htps://csis.tshc.gov.inlhcordersl 2025 I crpl crp_ll7 5 2025 pd
l-
KL,JCRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
may sever the causal ctrain. Conversely, where the official report
attributes faiture to defective seeds, the manufacturer's liability
becornes complete. This two-stage analysis proof of defect and proof
of carlsation preserves both faimess and accountability.
ix) Accordingly, this Court affirms that in consumer disputes
relating to agricultural inputs, the burden of proof is fluid and shifts
with control of evidence; that scientific and departmental reports
consl.itute retiable primary evidence; and that manufacturers who fail
to produce contemporaneous quality-control data must bear the
consequences of adverse inference. Such an approach alone realizes
the remedial and preventive purposes of the Consumer Protection Act
23. Summary of the prior orders passed bv Consumer fora
23.1. District Fqrum Order:
i) On considering the evidence of the complainant (PW- I ), the
DN.p. Expert (PW-2), the District Agriculture Oflicers (PWs-3 and 4),
Exhibits A-l to A-12,X-series documents including departmental and
DNl. reports, and the oral and documentary evidence adduced by the
40 of99
2/5/2026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcodeny'2025 I crpl cry_1175 ]O25.pd
crp_ll7 5 _:nz5.docx - crp_ll7 5 _2O25.pdf
4L
KI{ I
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
opposite parties @Ws 1-4; Exs. B-1 to B-17), the District Forum held
th4t,the.complainant is a 'bonsumef', that the Seeds Act does not bar
recourse to the Consumer Protection Act; the expert and deparfuental
reports, having remained unrebutted by any independent scientific
evidence from the seed company, conclusively established that the
'I
;..
I
seeds supplied were "mis-branded" and that there was deficiency in
service and unfair trade practice on the part of all opposite parties.
ii) On quantification, the District Forum relying on the market
value verification certificates (Exs. A-l l, A-12 I X-87 to X-90), took
the average market price of chilli as {4,500 per quintal, considered the
company's own yield repr€sentation (30 quintals per acre) and the fact
that some yield was obtained, determined the loss at 30 quintals per
acre. It accordingty awarded t1,35,000/- towards crop {oss per
Ac.1.00 guntas, <35,000/- per acre towards cultivation expenses
including cost of seed, and {10,000/- towards mental 4gony and
litigation expenses, together with intere st at 7 .5%o p.a. from the date of
complaint till realization, held that the dealer (OP No.l) and the
4l of99
2l5l2o%,4:50?M
crp_l 175_2025.docx - crp_l l7:t 2025.pdf
ht$s://csis.tshc.gov. in/hcordcrV2025/crp/c tp _l I 7 5 _202 5 -pd
KL, J
CRP No.l t75 of2025 & Batch
manufacturer/distributors (OP Nos.2 to 4) jointly and severally liable.
Thus, the District Forum partly allowed the complaints by orders all
datect 19.03.2020.
23.2. State Commission ordet:
i) Challenging the said orden, 419 appeals were filed under
Section 15 of the Act, 1986, by the manufacturer, to set aside District
forurrLs orders dated 30.01.2020.
ii) The State Commission, upon re-appreciation of the pleadings
and evidence, found that the substratum of the complaints suffered
from :;erious infirmities relating to the authenticity of the purchase
bill, the date of purchase, sowiug and
proof of land
owner;hip or lawful cultivatioo, and correlation between the quantity
of see<ls purchased and the land allegedly cultivated. The Commission
noted r:hat some of the complainants failed to produce original bilts,
pattad?.r passbooks, lease documents, proof of irrigation or farnily
membe rs certificates, and that contradictions existed between the
pleaderl dates and the exped inspection period. Viewing these
42 of 99
21512026,4:5O PM
htps://csis.tstrc.gov.in/trcbrdesl2025l crplcrp_ll7 5 2025.pd
crp_ll7 5 _m25.docx - crp_l I 75_2025.pdf
J-
KI. J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
discrepancies as sffing at tbe root of the claim, the State
:
,,
Commission'held that the -District Forum had erred in granting relief
without addressfng these foundational deficiencies.
iii) Proceeding on- the aforesaid reasoning, the State
Commission concluded that the burden cast upon the complainant in a
claim alleging defect in goods and deficiency in service had not been
duly discharged.It was observed that when the very foundation of the
complaint namely, proof of tawful purchase, cultivation, and temporal
alignment with the alleged crop failure remains in doubt, the opposite
parties cannot be fastened with liability on presumptions or
conjectures. The Commission emphasized that appellate interference
was warranted where the District Forum had adopted a uniform and
mechanical approach in atlowing multiple complaints, without
undertaking a case-specific examination of essential documents and
factuat assertions.
iv) The State Cornmissi
ingly held that the impugned
orders of the District Forum in some appeals suffered from material
irregularity and could not be sustained in law. Consequently, State
43 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
ctp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_l I 7l;_202 5.pdf
htps://csis.shc.gov.in/hcorders/202i{
crp/crp_ll7 5 2025.pd
r--,' .
:':
M
KL,J
_
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
Commission allowed some appeals in part,lsome appeals in toto and
dismi.ssed some appeals. State Commission also dismissed 07 appeals
preferred by Manufacturer for default. The appellants in some appeals
were pernitted to withdraw the statutorylamount deposited to the
credit of the complainants along with accrued interest.
23.3. National Commission order:
i) Challenging the said orders passed by State Commission,
both the revision petitioners herein and farmers filed revisions and
cross-revisions before the learned NCDRC under Section 2l(b) of the
Act, 1986. The revision petitions were filed predominantly by VNR
Seeds Pvt. Ltd., the manufacturer of \/IrIR-145 hybrid chilli seeds,
along with its dealers, while cross-revision petitions were filed by the
complainant - farmers, aggrieved by the partial relief granted by the
State Clommission.
ii) the challenge before the learned NCDRC was directed
against the State Commission orders whereby, while affirming the
frnding that the seeds were defective, the State Commission had
44 of99
2/5/2026,4:50 PM
crp_ll7s 2025.docx - crp_l175 2025.pdf
https://csis.ehc.gov.intrcordesl2025
I crpl crp
-ll7
5 2025 #
KI' J
CRP l,b.l175 of 2025 & Batch
substantially reduced compensation awarded by the Distict Forum
deleted the interest component, disallowed cultivation expenses
including seed cost and confinrcd liability solely to the Manufacturer
absolving the dealers gfanting only a nominal amount towards
litigation costs in some appeals.
iii) On consideration entire record, the learned NCDRC
affirmed the concurrent factual findings of the District Forum and the
State Commission on the issue of defect in seeds. The Commission
placed significant reliance on the District Level Committee report and
the Genetic Purity Test conducted by the Telangana DNA
Fingerprinting & Transgenic Crop Monitoring Laboratory, which
categorically declared the seeds as "misbranded". The learned
NCDRC noted that these reports were prepared by independent
Government experts, were scientific in nature, and had not been
rebuffed by the seed company through any independent laboratory
analysis or expert testimony. Consequently, the contention of
petitioners i.e. VNIR Seeds P\rt. Ltd. that the crop failure was
45 of99
215/2026,4:50 PM
crp_1175 2025.docx - crp_ll7l; 2025.pdf
hrps://csis.shc.gov.inlhcorderc/2025
_ll7 5 2025.pd
/ crpl crp
'-t_
KI.I
CRP NoJ 175 of2025 & Barch
attributable to climatic factors, agronomic practices, or pest infestation
unrelated to seed quality was rejected.
iv) On the question of quantum of compensation, the learned
NCDRC found serious infirmity in the approach adopted by the State
Comrnission. It held that the State Commission's method of
comprltilg crop loss by mechanically assuming a uniform standard
yield ,rf 30 quintals per acre and arbitrarily applying a 75yo loss factor
was not founded on scientific evidence or contemporaneous market
data. The learned NCDRC emphasized that farmers cannot be
expected to maintain detaited yield records or preserve bills for
agricu:ltural inputs, and that insistence on such documentation would
defeat the object of consumer protection in agricultural disputes. The
Commission observed that the District Forum had correctly relied on
market price verification certificates and expert assessment of crop
damagt: while awarding compensation and had adopted a pragmatic
and rea I is ti c approach cons is tent with settled consumer jurisprudence.
46 of99
2/5/2026,4:50 PM
lr{ps://csis.shc.gov.in/trcorde sl2025 lcrpl crp_ll7 5 2025.N
ctp_1175 _2025.docx - crp_l I 75_2o25.pdf
KL,
'
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batcb
v) The tearned NCDRC fu4her held that the deletion of interest
and cultivation expenses by the State Commission was unjustified, as
compensation for crop loss would be illusory if it failed to account for
actual expenditure incurred by farmers and the time value of money
lost due to defective goods. On,the issue of liability, the learned
NCDRC restored the finding of the District Forums holding the
manufacturer, and dealer jointly and severally liable, observing that
':
the supply chain could not be artificially severed to the detriment of
the consumer once defect and deficiency were established.
vi) With the said reasons and findings, the learned NCDRC
partly allowed the revisions filed by the farmets, dismissed the
revisions filed by Manufacturer i.e. MrIR Seeds Pvt. Ltd., and set
aside the reduction effected by the State Commission. The leamed
NCDRC restored the relief granted by the District Forum in respect of
compensation towards crop loss, cultivation expeff;es, mental agony,
and interest. All revision petitioap and cross-revision petitions were
accordingly disposed of by a oommon order.
47 o€99
2t5/2026,4:50 PM
hups://csis.Shc.gov.in/trcordersl2025l crpl crp_ll7 5 2025.pd
crp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_ll7 5 _2025.pdf
(
KT. J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
vii) Challenging the said order, petitioners filed the present
revlslons.
24.llontentions of the Petitioners:-
i) The complainants failed to discharge the initial burden of
proving that the seeds supplied were defective, as mandated in seed-
related disputes, and that no legally admissibte or scientifically
reliable evidence was produced, contrary to the principles laid down
in Mahyco Seeds Ltd. v. G. Shrinivash& Orsr6. and M.B.
Yedukondalu (supra). The learned NCDRC erroneously relied on the
DNA report dated 01.08.2017, which described the seeds as
"misbranded", overlooking that "misbranding" under Section 2$$ of
the Seeds Bill, 2004 relates to false labelling and does nrot ipso facto
establish genetic impurity or defect, particularly when the report
merely' notes mismatch of molecular profiles. The sampling and
inspect.ion by the Mandal Agricultural Officer were vitiated by non-
compliance with Rule 25 of the Seeds Rules, 1968, as the identity of
the farmer, survey number, and source of leaf samples were not
'6MANIr/cF /o3ro/2o12
48 of99
2/512026,4:50 PM
ctp_1175inz5.docx - crp_l 175_2025.pdf
trtps://csis*shc. gov.in/lrcordersl2025 I crpl crp_ll7 5 J025.pd
t',
KI. J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
,-,,-,:
'g[gw4'pldb:
rendering
disclosed, and samples were taken fr'"r
linkage to any specific seed lot impossible. ,
' . '.
'
'
ii) Inspection reports rocorded only ptrenbg-5rpicaI, observations,
relied on non-representative and infected
,failed to use
appropriate SSR markers, and were condugted :prematurely and
without notice, depriving the petitioners of an opportunity to assist or
provide correct seed samples. The genetic purity testing must involve
seed-to-seed or leaf-to-leaf comparison, whereas an impermissible
leaf-to-seed comparison wix adopted. Although approximately 15
different lots of 'fNR-145 chilli seeds were marketed, DNA testing
was confined only to Lot No. 1870, pertaining to merely 97 out of 466
CRPs, rendering the conclusions unrepresentative. The DNA report is
also assailed for not examining statutory parameters such as
germination, moisture, pure seed and genetic purity percentages,
while the petitioner's in-house laboratory report dated 04.05.20t7
records satisfactory results, which, it is contended, were iguored by
the consumer fora, contrary to the principle in Zimidara Agro Center
49 of99
215/2026,4:50 PM
ctp_1175 2025.docx - crp_l17:i 2025.pdf
https://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcondes/20251
crfl crp_ll7 5 2025 pd,
'i-
KL,
I
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
,:
v. Srukhdev, Singhr'. The official who conducted the DNAtest,lacked
,:,,
the qualifications prescribed under Rule 20 of the Seeds Rules, 1968.
Vt$f-t+S chilti seeds and the 'sonali' variety of Rasi Seeds as
scientifically impennissible, as inspection reports themselves record
Thrips infestation and viral diseases such as PBNV and CMV
affer:ting both varieties, indicating pest-borne causes rather than seed
defect. VllR-145 was never represented as Thrips-resistant that no
causal nexus was established between susceptibility and defect, and
that the complainant failed to prove adherence to recommended
agronomic practices or produce vouchers for fertilizers and pesticides.
lv) the crop failure could have resulted from external factors
sucl as climate, pest infestation and irrigation issues, constituting
intervening causes, and that Rule 23-A of the Seeds Rules, 1968 was
not c:omplied with.
I72OI7
50 of99
SCC ONIiNE LEARNED NCDRC 39
21512026,4:50 PM
htQs://csis.shc.gov.inrhcordcrV2025l crp/crp_l l7 5 2025.p<
ctp_1l75 2025.docx - crp_1175 2025.pdf
- - i(I{r
CRP M.l175 of 2025 & Batch
v) The complainant does not qualiry as a 'tonsumet'' under
Section 2(d) of the Act, 1986, being engaged in large-scale cultivation.
;,
The improbability of the crop timeline is also stress4 as seeds
purchased on l l .05.2017 could not have matured by July 2017. The
State Commission had rightly interfered with the Disfrict Forum,s
orders based on thurnb-rule assessment.
vi) The finding of the learned NCDRC with regard to
deficiency by misreading evidence, disregarding binding preoedent, is
perversed warranting interference under Article 227 of the
constitution of tndia. Reliance also placed on state of Haryana v.
Jai Singhrt.
vii) Referring to the Expert Committee R.eport @x. X-21),
agricultural literature of Professor Jayashankar ftlangana State
Agricultural University, and the decisions in M. Madhusudhan
Reddy (supra) and Maharashtra Hybrid Seeds Company Ltd. v.
Garapati Srinivas Raore, petitioners contended that Thrips
tscirril
Appeal No. 6990/2014
No.
2602 of 2008 & Ors., decided onlZ.0Z-2014
'eR.P.
51 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
hqs://csis.shc.gov.ir/trcodcrd202s/crdcr1.
crp_l175_2025.docx - ctp-ll7:i 2025.df
-l
5 2025.Pdt
,^.1
KL, J
CRP No.ll75of202s & Britr
infestation and viral diseases constitute a novus achts interveniens,
inspection reports based on visual assessment without notice are
inadmissible, and absence of controlled scientific comparison or
examination ofother seed suppliers vitiates the findings.
viii) Placed reliance on the cancellation of its seed licence dated
21.08.2017, which was set aside by this Court in W.P. No. 40269 of
2017 ot the ground ofnon-compliance with Rule 23-A ofthe Seeds
Rules, 1968, thereby demonstrating that the regulatory action itself
wari procedurally unsustainable. Ex. B-4 and Ex. 8-16 establish
compliance with prescribed quality standards and also disclose that
variation in yield is dependent upon agro-climatic conditions. The
consistent performance and success of the same seed variety in other
regions negate any allegation of inherent or systemic defect. In
suppott of these submissions, reliance is placed on Sadhu (supra)' M.
Madhusudhrn Reddy (supra) and Mahyco Seeds Company v.
Basappa Channappa Mooki20, to contend that liability cannot be
2oci,rit ,a.ppeal No .2428 of 2008
52 of 99
2t5n026, 4:50 PM
https://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcorderV2025 lcrp/ crp_ll7 5 _!fi25.pd:.
crp_1175 2025.docx - crp_1175 2025.pdf
KL, J
CRP No.l 175of2025 & Batch
fastened in'the'absence,of clear, cogent and scientific evidence
establishing,defect in the seeds supplied.
25. Case laws cited bv the Petitioners:
i) In Sadhu (supra), the Supreme Court held that compensation
cannot be awarded in the absence of proof that crop failure was
auributable to defective seeds. The Court referred the expert
committee's report, which attributed poor crop performance to
extraneous fa:,lgr-s suc.h as soil satinity and irrigation conditions, over
a local officer's certificate. Finding no infirmity in the expert report,
the Court concluded that the consumer fora erred in awarding
compensation and allowed the appeal.
ii) In Mahyco Seeds Company Limited v. Basappa
Channappa Mooki (supra), the Supreme Court, relyrng upon
Haryana Seeds Development Corpn. Ltd. (supra), held that mere
variation
Tt
p yreld cannot be attributed to defective seeds in the
absence of coge,lrt evideirce. The Court found that several external
factors influence crop perfonnance and that the Agricultural Officer's
53 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
crp_l175_2025.docx - crp_l 17 5_2025.pdf
htps://csis.tshc. gov. innuordersl 2025 I c.d crp_l I 7 5 _2O25.pd
s4
KI.
'
CnP No.l175 of2025 & B.tch
report did not record any defect or inferiority in the seeds. In the
absence of material establishing seed defect, the complaint was held
to be unsustainable and the appeal was allowed.
iii) In State of Haryana v. Jai Singh (supra), the Supreme
Court considered the vesting of unutilized 'tachat" land reserved
during consolidation and upheld the view that such land continues to
vest with the original proprietors if not earrrarked for a specific
comnron purpose. Applying the doctrine of strtre declsls, the Court
emphasized that a legal position
followed in over a
hundred judgments must be respected to preserve certainty and
stability in law.
iv) ln Banta Ram u fai Bharat Beej Company Super Marku
(supra). the National Commission held that the complainant failed to
prove any defect in the seeds supplied, as no statutory laboratory
testing was conducted in accordance with Section 13(l)(c) of the
Consurner Protection Act, 1986. The
ruled that field
inspection reports alone are insufficient to establish seed defect in the
54 of 99
21512026,4:50 PM
cry_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_l I 75_2025.pdf
htps://csis.strc.gov.iry'trcorde rs/N25/ crplcrp _ll? 5
-2025.pd
KL,'
CRP No.l175 offi2s & Barch
absence of proper sampl€'t€s1ing,'and consequently dismissed the
complaint.
,r
l' :.
v) In Mahyco Seeds:Ltd;,v. G. Shrinivash & Ors. (supra), the
learned NCDRC held 'rthat
of defective seeds must be
proved through proper laboratory testing as mandated under Section
Commission found that the
l3(lXc)
.
complainants relied only on'preliminary and departmental reports
without producing tegally'admissible laboratory evidence. In the
absence of such proof, and compliance with statutory procedure, the
complaint was dismissed.
'
'
vi) In Mahyco Vegetable Seeds Ltd. v. G. Sreenivasa Reddy
(supra), the learned NCDRC held that the complainants failed to
establish that the brinjal seeds supplied were genetically defective.
Relying on the Commissioner's rq)ort, ttre Commission found that
crop variation or mixed SIowth did not conclusively prove genetic
defect in the seeds. It was reiterated that the burden of proof lies on
55 of99
215t2026,4:50 PM
cry_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_l I 7 5_2025.pdf
hups://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcordersl 2025I cryl crp_l l7 5 _2025.N
KI. r
CRP No.l175 of 2025 & Batctr
the complainants, and in the absence of credible evidence, the orders
of the lower forums were set aside and the complainJs dismissed.
vii) [n Mahyco Vegetable Seeds Ltd. v. Ishwarbhai
:
Baburao Thakare (supra), the learned NCDRC held that crop failure
coulc[ not be attributed to defective seeds in the absence of conclusive
laboratory evidence. Though the District seeds committee noted
steril.ty and disease, it did not link these findings to seed defect, and
no test report of the complainants' samples was produced. Retying on
the petitioner's laboratory reports showing satisfactory germination
and genetic purity and considering environmental factors, the
comnrission set aside the compensation and dismissed the complaint.
'riii) In Indo-American Hybrid Seeds v. Vijayakumar
Shanlcarao (supra), the learned NCDRC hetd that poor crop yield by
itself rloes not establish defect in seeds or deficiency in service. The
comrrrission found that the Agriculture officer's report did not
conclusively attribute the low yietd to defective seeds and noted that
externill flactors such as soil conditions, climate, and pesticide use
56 of99
215/2026.4:50 PM
crp_1175 NZ5.docx - crp_1175 2025.pdf
hQs://csis.strc.gov.idhcorders/2
025I cryl crp_ll7 5 _N25.pd
KI4 J
CRP tb.l 175 of2025 & Batcb
coutd affect crop perfonnanc€. In the absence of scientific testing or
credible evidence proving seed defect, the compensatory orders were
set aside and the complaint dismissed.
ix) In Hindustan Insecticides Ltd: v. Kopolu Sambasiva Rao
(supra), the learned NCDRC held that the complainants failed to
establish that the insecticide supplied was defective or caused crop
damage. The Commission noted non-compliance with the mandatory
testing procedure under Section l3(l)(c) of the Consumer Protection
Act and relied on laboratory reports certirying conformity with ISt
standards. [n the absence of conclusive proof of defect or deficiency
in service, the revision petitions were allowed.
x) tn B. Yedukondalu (supra), the learned NCDRC held that
the complainants failed to prove that the chilli seeds supplied were
defective. The inspection reports noted deviations and pest infestation
but did not attribute crop failure to seed defect, and no .laboratory
testing was conducted as required under Section l3(1Xc) of the Act,
1986. Holding that the burden of proof was not discharged and that
57 of9
2/512026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.shc.gov.in/hcordesl2025l crpl crp_ll7 5 2025.N1
crp_1175 2025.docx - crp_ll7li 2025.pdf
r':\
l-
KL,J
CRP No.l l?5 of2025 & Batch
the ,:onsumer fora misread the agricultural reports, the Commissio!
set aside the compensation and dismissed the complaints.
xi) In Syngenta India Ltd. v. P. Chowdaiah2r, the learned
NCDRC held that Thrips infestation and viral infection constifirted
ptausible alternate causes for crop failure and could not, by
theurselves, establish defect in the seeds supplied. The Commission
observed that delayed inspections and visual assessments without
sample testing were insuffrcient to prove deficiency in senrice.
Hokting that the complainants failed to discharge the burden of
proving seed defect, the learned NCDRC set aside ths ssmpensation
awarded by the State Commission and restored the District Forum's
order.
xii) In Garapati Srinivas Rao (supra), the learned NCDRC
held that the complainant failed to establish defect in the seeds
throrrgh scientific or laboratory evidence as mandated by the Seeds
Act. The inspection reports were based on delayed visual assessments
conducted without notice to the seed company and noted pest and
2t
58 of99
lzrlt:107 NCDRC cK ooo3
21512026,4:50 PV
ctp_Ll7s 2025.docx - crp-l 175 2025pdf
-j'
/
https://csis.tshcgovin/trcordesl2025 I crpl crp_ll7 5 ]A25.pc
.l
- -KI.r
CRP No.l I75 of2025 & Barch
viral infestation as altemate causes of:crop frilure. Holding that crop
loss could result from multiple factors.and that the complainant failed
,
to prove sub-standard or defective seeds, the Cop1ission set aside the
State Commission's order and allowed the revisionpetition.
xiii) In Zimidara Agro Center,(supfa), the leamed NCDRC
held that allegations of defective se€ds cannot be sustained solely on
the basis of inspection reports prepared by non-accredited
laboratories. The Commission found that the statutory requirement of
testing through a notified or accredited governmentlaboratory was not
comptied with. Due to this procedural
**t*
and lack of reliabte
scientiFrc evidence, the complaints against the seller were dismissed.
xiv) tn Mahyco Seeds Ltd. v- G. Venkata Subba Reddy22
(supra), the learned NCDRC held that the burden to prove genetic
impurity in seeds lies squarely on the complainant. The Commission
noted that the inspection was conducted only after harvest, at a stage
when seed defects could not be scientifically assessed. In the absence
" lzon ) cPJ 99 NC
59 of99
215/2026,4:50 PM
crp_1175 2025.docx - crp_l175, 2025.pdf
htps://csi s.shc.gov.in/hcordersl2025 lcrpl crp_ll7 5 ]025.pd|
T--'
KL,J
-- "
CRP No.l l?5 of2025 & Batch
of conclusive scientific evidence establishing genetic defect, the ct4rm,
was :rejected and liability was not fastened on the seed nranufacturer.
l
'26. (lgnteh4ons of Respondents:-
i) The present Civil Revision Petitions are gross abuse of
process, as the petitioners, having. suffered concurrent sdverse
findings before the District Forum, Warangal, the Telangana State
Commission, Hyderabad, and the leamed NCDRC, have invoked
Article 227 of the Constitution of [ndia, only to delay execution of
laufiil decrees in favour of small and marginal farmers.
ii) Al[ three fora, upon exhaustive appreciation of oral and
docunentary evidence including expert and governmental reports,
have consistentty held the petitioners guilty of deficiency in service
and unfhir tade practice in supplying defective VNIR-145 hybrid chilli
seeds,
iii) l" respondents comptainants are agriculturists who
purcbased \rNR-145 chilli seeds from the authorized dealer and
cultivated in Warangal District, where the crop soon exhibited stunted
60 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
crp_ll7 5 ]025.docx - ap _ll7 5 _2025.fit
lrtQs://csislshc.govfur/hcoderV20 25 lup/ ap _l 17 5 _N25.pd
KI.,
CRP l,!o.l175 of 425 & Bard
growth, poor flowering, viral infection and total
ln
loss of livelihood.
iv) They deny the allegation that the
are
"commercial cultivators". Reliance placed on M.
Reddy (supra), which recognizes farmers purchasing
self-
cultivation as "consumers" under Section 2(1Xd) of the Act. ; l
'.,
I 'l'
' v) Crop failure was directly attributable to genetic iApurity and
'''':
,,.,,
mis-branding, supported by the DNA Fingerprintiug and Tmnsgenic
. ,. .,
Crops Monitoring Laboratory Report dated 0l-08-2017 @x.'X-6), the
:
Expert Committee Report dated 28-07-2017 (E4. X-14), the
assessment of Dr. B. Ram Prasad, Entomologist, RARS Warangal (Ex.
B-8), and the petitioners' own documents (Exs. B-9, B-14 and B-15)
admitting long-term marketing of VNR-145 as a high-fuiting, heatset hybrid yielding up to 160 quintals per acre. The Distict Forum,
after analyzing Exs. A-l to A-12, B-1 to 8-16, X-l to X-90 and
testimony of PW-2 to PW-4, rightly fastened joint and several liability
on the petitioners and dealer. Though compensation was reduced by
5l of99
215/2026,4:50 PM
https://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcordesl2o25 I crpl crp_ll7 5 2025.61
ctp _1175 2025.docx - crp_l l7!; 2025.pdf
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
the titate Commission, the teamed NCDRC, by its reasoned order
datecl 06-01-2025, restored the District Forum's order. The leamed
NCDRC's decision rests on concurrent findings of fact and law,
raising no jurisdictional issue for interference under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
vi) Statutory laboratory and field reports establish noncompliance with the Seeds Act, 1966, Seeds Rules, 1968 and Seeds
(Control) Order, 1983, including obligations under Sections 5-9 of the
Act and Rules l3(3), l7 and 38, and that sale of mis-branded seed
constitutes a per se defect and deficiency under Sections z(fl and2(g)
of the, 1986 Act. The theory of climatic causation is denied with
reference to temperature data (2013-2017) annexed to Ex. X-14 and
the categorical findings in Ex. X-6. Although licence cancellation was
set aside on technical grounds, this Court in W.P. No. 14356 of 2017
expressly preserved farrters' right to claim compensation.
'irii) The petitioners have approached this Court without fu[
disclosure of material facts, having selectively withheld the complete
62 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
https://csis.tshc.gov.iryhcorde
crp_lL7 5 _20,25.docx - crp-l 1 75-2025.pCf
rs12025/ crp/crp
-l
17 5
-2025
-pdr
- KI4,
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
set'of extribits and omitted to disclose that no application for,re-testing
:
under Section l3(lXc) of the Act was ever made dopite their
Statutory obligation to preserve samples. Thus, there is suppressio:r of
material evidence.
viii) The petitioners failed to pres€rve or seek re-testing of
samples as required under Rule l3(3) of the Seeds Rules and Section
13(lXc) of the Act, attracting the principle in Alavalapati chandra
,
Reddy (supra), and that objections based on Rule 25 of the Rules; are
barred by pleadings in view of Ex. X-2, relying on Neelam Gupta v.
Rajendra Kumar Gupta23.
ix) Placing reliance on Ghaziabad Development Authority
(supra), complainants contend that prolonged litigation against
farmers, defeats the humanitarian object of consumer law. Having
waited over eight years for relief, any further delay would amount to
denial of substantive justice
232015
63 of99
SCC Online SC 1972
A512026,4:50 Ptv
crp_l 175_2025.docx - crp_l l;'5_2025.pdf
hrtps://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcordersy'2025/crp/c
rp_l I 7 5 _2O25.p<
KL,I
CRP No.l175 of2025 & Brrclr
x) Placed reliance on the judgments in Alavalapati Chandra
Reddy; Nandan Biometrir Ltd, M. Madhusudhan Reddy, Fortune
Hybrid Seeds Ltd., (supra), Seeds works International Pvt, Ltd v.
Nempally
Development Authority,
Neelam Gupta (supra); Shrihari Limraj Karanjkar vs Ajeet Seeds
Limted2s; H.N. Shankara Shastry vs Asst Director of Agriculture
Karnataka26; Vl\lR seeds Pvt Ltd vs The State of Telangana2T;
seeds Pvt Ltd vs The State of Telangana28; Waryam Singh vs
Amarnath2el Shalini Shyam Shetty vs Rajendra Shankar Patil3o;
Managing dircctor, Kerela Tourism Development Corporation
Ltd rs Deepti Singh3r; Eshalla Reubber vs Dass Estate Ltd32;
2nDecid,rd
by LEARNED NCDRC Delhi 06.05.2015 in R.P No. 2742 otl}t4
batch
:tzozr
1r; cen glcl ao
SICC online SC 648
2'WP
oo. 40269 of 2Ol7 dex:rdd, on 12.12.2O17
no. 14356 of20l7 decitted on 11.10.2017
'8WP
T1954
sCC online SC 13
Itzoroy s scc 329
:62004
rr20l9 0
Supreme (SC) 408
'=2001 SCC online SC 1097
64 of 99
21512026, 4:50 PM
htps://csis.shc. gov.inltrcorderV2 025lcryl ap_ll7 5 _2025.pd
ctp_ll7 5 ]O25.docx - crp_l I 75_2025.pdf
KI.,
CRP No.l175 of 425 & Batch
vs Prakesh Chad Goel 33., Rasi Seeds hrt.Ltd vs
Bhagwan34
:
:,,
27. Case ICws cited by the Respondents:
:r
i) The respondents have placed strong reliance upon a series of
binding and p- ersuasive precedents
ii) In Alaialapati Chandra Reddy (supra), the Supreme Court
held that a farmrcr purchasing seeds for cultivation and not for resale is
a 'tonsumet''
under the Consumer Protection Act, 19E6. It was
,]
clarified that sale of the agricultural produce does not amount to a
..,
commercial purpose and that the scale of cultivation or volume of sale
is immaterial. The decisive test is whether the dominant intention is
livelihood and sustenance, a principle squarely applicable to farmers
alleging cqop loss due to defective seeds.
iii) In Nandan Biomatrix Ltd. (supra), the National
Commission:held that supply of defective or misbranded seeds
tt2o2z4 scc r8l
3a
65 of99
Revision Petition No. 4598 of 20 l0
21512026,4:50 PM
ctp_1175 2025.docx - crp_ll7!: 2025.pdf
hups://csi s.tshc. gov.in/hcorde rsl 2025 I crpl crp_ll'l 5 _2025.pdl
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batctr
constitutes "deficiency in service" under Section 2(l)(g) of the
Consumer Protection Act, 1986. The Commission observed that once
germination failure or poor yield is established through official
inspe:tion or scientific analysis, the burden shifts to the manufacturer
to disprove defect, and,tiabilify cannot be avoided by attributing loss
to climatic or pest-related factors. This principle squarely applies
where farmers produce DNA and field inspection reports indicating
genetic variation in the seeds supplied.
iv) tn M. Madhusudhan Reddy (supra), the Supreme Court
authoritatively held that supply of defective or substandard seeds
resulti;rg in crop loss constitutes "deficiency in service" under the
Consuner Protection Act. The Court recognised farmers purchasing
seeds lbr self-cultivation as "consumers" and held seed rnanulacturers
statuto,ily responsible for maintaining prescribed standards of
germination and genetic purity. Liability was held to arise once
official testing reveals deviation from such standards, forming a
foundat ional precedent in agriculttrral consumer jurisprudence.
66 of99
21512026,4:50 PV
ctp_ll7 5 2025.docx - up _1175]025,pdf
htrps://csis.tslrc.gov.inlhconde rc12025/ crpl crp_ll7 5 ]O25.pc
-kut
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
,
v) In Fortune Hybrid Seeds Ltd. (supra), learned NCDRC
,l
held that once d€fectivei hybrid :seeds or deviation in varietal
characteristics is established through oflicial inspection or laboratory
anallNsis, tiability under the Act follows, and pleas of adverse weather
or pest attack cannot exonerate the manufacturer. The Commission
further observed that gwernment testing procedures are presumed
valid unless disproved by credible expert evidence and that
misleading labelling and non-compliance with mandatory standards
constihrte both deficiency in service and unfair trade practice,
warranting compensation for crop loss and mental agony.
vi) In Nampelly Sudhakar (supra), the Supreme Court
dismissed petitions filed by a seed manufacturer arising from identical
findings of deficiency by the consumer fora and directed payment of
compensation to farmers. Though the Court left the question of law
open, the dismissal signified affirmation of concurrent factual findings
against the manufacturer and lends persuasive weight to the
conclusion that such deficiencies warrant consumer redress.
67 of99
215/2026,4:50 PM
crp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_l 175 _2025.pdf
hrps://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcondercl2025 / crpl crp_l I 75-2025.pdt
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Barch
vii) In Ghaziabad Development 'Authority (supra), the
Supn:me Court held that "deficienry in'service?'under the Consumer
,.,
Prote,;tion Act encompasses failure to perform, statutory or contractual
obligations within a reasonable time, rnrcluding administative delay
l
and arbitrary conduct causing harassmerrt. Emphasising the welfare
natur€, of the legislation, the Court affirmed thre power of consumer
fora to award compensation not only for monetary loss but also for
mental agony and inconvenience, guiding a broad and remedial
interpretation of consumer rights.
viii) In Neelam Gupta (supra), the Supreme Court emphasised
that jurlicial interference must be exercised with circumspection where
concurrent findings subsist. The Court held that interim protections
such as maintenance of status quo are warranted to preserve the
subject-matter pending final adjudication and to prevent prejudice
arising from multiplicity of proceedings. The decision reinforces the
princip.le that authorities must act within jurisdiction and respect
subsisting orders of competent fora.
68 of99
21512026,4:50 Plv
ctp_1175_2025.docx - crp_l I 75 2025.pdf
https://csis.shc.gov.in/hcorderV20Zl
I crpl crp_117 5 ]O25.p<
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
ix) In Alavalapati Chandra Reddy (supra), the Supreme Court
held that while agiculture is a livelihood activity, a complainant must
establish a clear nerals between defective segds and crop loss. The
Court observed that climatic conditions, soil quality, and agronomic
practices arerrelevant factors, and that crop failure alone does not
automaticalty establish deficiency in service. The judgment strikes a
balance between safeguarding farmen and protecting manufacturers
from speculative claims absent scientific proof.
x) In Shrihari Limrai Karanikar (supra), the National
Commission held that th€ initial burden lies on the complainant to
establish prima facie deficiency. It was observed that field inspections
conducted without notice to the manufacfurer and without laboratory
testing under Section l3(lXc) of the Act are insufficient to fasten
liability. The Commission recognised that agricultural loss may arise
from external factors, and unless these are excluded by cogent
evidence, defioiency cannot be presumed against the seed supplier.
69 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
ctp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_l l7!' 2025.pdf
hups://csis.shc.gov.in/hcorderV2O25l crpl crp_l I 75 2025.pd1
KI. J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
xi) In H. N. Shastry (supra), the Karnataka High Court held
that administrative or preliminary reports prepared without sfricJ
adherence to the sampling and testing procedures prescribed under the
Seeds Rules, 1968 cannot form the basis for penal or regulatory
actic,n. The Court emphasised that where statutory provisions mandate
testing through notified laboratories, any non-compliance vitiates thre
entire action. This principle underscores that findings of misbranding
or dr;ficiency cannot be sustained without compliance with mandatory
proc,tdural safeguards
xii) In VNR Seeds (supra), in W.P. No. 40269 of 2017, the
High Court set aside the cancellation of a seed dealer's licence on the
ground that the facts and issues were identical to those decided earlier
in \['.P. No. 14356 of 2017 and batch. The Court held that once a
coorrlinate Bench has declared the procedure adopted by the licensing
authority to be contrary to the Seeds Rules and the Seeds (Control)
Order, 1983, adrninistrative consistency rnandates that similar cases
be dr:cided on the same reasoning. The writ petition was accordingly
70 of99
215/2026,4:50 PM
ctp_1175 Jm25.docx - crp_1175 2025.pdf
l@s://csis.shc.gov.in/hcorde
rsl 2025 I crplcrp_l 17 5 _2O25.pd
7t
RLJ
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
allowed and the licence restored,'underscoring the principle of
.
,'
,:...,
t'
"
uniformity in adminisfrative adjudication: '
,
xiii) In \ [R Seeds (supra), W.P.,No. 14356 of 2017 and
batch, the High Court held that cancellation of licences of seed
distributors without compliance with'Rule 23-A of the Seeds Rules,
and without recording specific ,findings of statutory violation, is
unsustainable in law. The Cou{ emphasised that authorities must
clearly distinguish between the roles'of manufacturers and distributors
and cannot impose col[ective liabitity absent proof of mens rea or
procedural compliance. The writ petitions were allowed, licences
restored, and the authorities caufoned to sfiictly adhere to the
prescribed inspection and testing procedures in future actions.
Analvsis and Findings of the Court:-
28. It is apt to note ttrat both trearned counsel for the petitioners
and learned counsel appearing for pspondents on instructions,
submitted that 427 Farmers filed complaints under Section 12 of the
Act, [986 against the petitioners before the District Consumer Forum,
7l of99
21512026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcordersl2025 I cryl crp_ll7 5 2025.pd.
crp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_l 175 2025.fif
,KI4'
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
'Warangal, out of which, the District Consumer Forum allowed 419
:ssmtrlaints in part and dismissed 08 complaints for default.
29. Petitioners herein preferred 419 appeals before the State
Comrnission and State Commission allowed 138 appeals in toto and
274 appeals in part. 07 appeals were dismissed for default. It is also
brought to the notice of this Court that the restoration applications
filed in the said 07 appeals to restore the appeals to its original
positirn are pending in State Commission.
30. It is further submitted that 466 revisions were filed before
learne,l NCDRC by the Manufacturer, dealer and Farmers challenging
the said orders passed by the State Commission. learned NCDRC has
dispos,:d
of the said 466 revisions vide common order dated
06.01.:.t025.
-l
l. Challenging the said common order, petitioners herein and
nlanufacturers filed the present 466 revisions. Out of them, CRP
No.2940 of 2025 was dismissed by this Court on 25.09.2025 as
withdra.wn.
72 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
crp_ll7 5 2{25.docx - crp_1175 }O21Sf
hqa://csis.tshc.gov.inrtcordersl2025/
crp/ crp_ll7
5 2025.p<
KIt J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
32. There is no dispute that respondqrts - Farmers purchased
that there was crop failure.
33. It is the specific contention of the I't respondents - farmers
that the petitioners have supplied defective, mis-branded,,genetically
poor chilli seeds. Thus, there is defect in manufacturing of the said
seeds and there is deficiency in senrice. Accordiqg to them, petitioners
made them to believe that the seeds are geneticalty pure, high
performing and superior quality hybrid. The said seeds are genetically
stable. But the petitioners have supplied defective, mis-branded,
genetically poor chilli seeds contrary to the assurance given by them.
34. Whereas, according to the petitioners, they have supplied
genetically pure seeds and farmers did not irrigate properly, they did
not use pesticides as recommended by them, there was Thrips
infestation which is nothing to do with the genetic makeup of the
seed, temperature was very high and there are adverse weather
conditions in the subject area.
73 of99
215t2026,4:50 PM
https://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcordersl}0Z1 / crf, crp_ll7 5 2025.fi1
cry _1L75 2025.docx - crp_l 175 2025.pdf
-l
KL, J
CRP No.t 175 of 2025 & Batch
35. It is apt to note that the respondents - farmers examined 04
witlesses i.e. P.Ws.l to P.W.4 and filed EXs.A.l to A.12 (the number
of exhibits marked by the complainants differ from case to case).
36. Whereas, petitioners herein examined 02 witnesses i-e.
R.Wl, and R.W.2, filed Exs.B.l to B.16. Learned District Consumer
Forum marked Exs.X.1 to X.19 through P.Ws.3 and 4.
37. P.W.l is Farmer Complainant, P.W.2 is Assistant
Director, Agriculture, Hyderabad, P.Ws.3 and 4 are District
Agrictrlture Officers.
.38. It is also not in dispute that there was complaint against the
petitiorrers, manufacturers by the huge number of farmers belong to
several villages of Atmakur Mandal of Warangal District, alleging
that petitioners supplied defective chilli seeds due to which there was
crop flilure and they sustained huge loss. They have written a
letter/complaint to the District Collector, Warangal, with a request to
do justice who in turn, informed the same to the Agricutture Offtcer,
74 of99
4512026,4:50 PM
htQs://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcordersl2025 luplcrp-ll7 5 2O25.pdt
qp_l 175_2025.docx - c*p-l 175 2025.pdf
KL.,i
CRPNo.l175of2025 &Bat h
Joint Director of Agriculture, Warangal, District Horticulttre and
Sericulture Officen.
39. The District Agriculture Officer, Warnagal, vid€ his letter
dated 07.07.2017 directed the Mandal Agriculture Officer to conduct
joint inspection with Horticulture Officer and report complianco at the
earliest. In compliance with the same, vide letter dated lO.O7.2Ol7,
Mandal Agriculture OfIicer, informed the Assistant Director of
Agricultgre, Telangana, DNA Fingerprinting crops, monitoring Lab
that he is sending green chillies leaves of 50 plants (randomly
selected) for analysis. The Joint District Level Committee conducted a
visual inspection on I I .07.2017 andsubsequently submiated its report
stating that the crop had been severely affected by Thrips incidents,
during initial crop growing stage, attributed to the prevalence of high
temperatures. The crop was affected by virat diseases such as Peanut
Bud Necrosis Virus (PBNV) and Cucumber Mosaic Virus (CMV)
which led to poor growth.
75 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
ctp_1175 2025.docx - crp_ll7ii 2o25.pdf
hups ://csis.shc. gov. in/hcord ers/ 2O25 I crpl ctp_ll7 5 ]025.pd
KL,I
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
, 40. On 01.08.2017,
--
..(^l
r'
the genetic purity test report was submitted
to thr: District Agncutture Offrcer, Warangal, and the Commissioner
of A,griculture, fs[angana, who in turn drawn conclusion that the
genetic purity test rwealed that field sample differs from the standard
profile , then rendered the sample as 'mis-branded'.
4l.It is also apt to note that petitioners herein, manufacturers of
subjec;t chilli seeds and dealers filed counters before the District
Consumer Forum.
42.\t is also apt to note that Farmers - Complainants examined
themselves as P.W.1 and they specif,rcally deposed that petitioners and
their dealers came to their villages, gave wide publicity in respect of
VNR 145 chilli seds, assured them and the other farmers of the
villages with regard to the quality of the said seed. They have also
assuredl that there would be 100 to 150 qunitals per acre of yield of
green r:hillies. They have also brought photographs, posters and
pamphlets of their company seed grown elsewhere. They have assured
that the said chilli seeds are having resistance to jassids (leaf hoppers)
76 of 99
21512026,4:50 PM
ctp_ll7 5 !&t25.docx - ap
lrt$s://csis.shc.gov.in/hcorderV2 025lupl crp
-ll7 ]O2l.pdf
-ll7
5 2025.pd
KI. J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Bat fi
: inherently, heavy heat and cool withstand against rain aRO othe,r
tl
made the farmers including':the
diseases. Thus, the petitioners
;'
, .
,.
.
"
,. ' ,
'
complainants herein to believe the aforesaid aspects and on the said ,'
belief, they have purchased VNR 145 chilli seeds.
43. They have also specifically deposed with regard to details
of purchase, cultivation, apply of fertilizer, pesticides, as advised by
the petitioners and also about loss of crop including germination and
sustenance of loss. [n proof of the same, they have filed cash bills,
pattadar passbooks, show cause notice, representation submiffed to the
District Collector etc.
44. Petitioners cross-examined the complainants at length but
nothing useful was elicited from them during cross-examination.
45. It is also apt to note that the complainants examined
Assistant Director, Agriculture, Hyderabad, who is also DNA
Fingerprint expert as P.W.2, District Agriculture Officers as P.Ws.3
and 4. The District Consumer Forum, marked corresponderrce
between them and also reports submitted by them.
77 of99
A5D026,4:50 PM
https://csis.strc.gov:in/hcorde rs12025 I cryl crp_ll7 5 2025.pd
crp _1175 2025.docx - crp_l 175 2025.pdf
I
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
:
46. P.Ws.2 to 4 were cross-examined by the petitioners and
r:'
'' i
',t
'
nothing usetul was eligitg!,fiom them.
,:
47. It is also ,apt to note that P.W.2 Assistant Director of
,:,.
Agriculture, wtro ,is. also
Fingerprint Expert, specifically
deposed about collection of samples including collection of 50 leave
samples from Akkampet village, standard hybrid and parental line
samples from thq petitioners. She has extracted DNA from each leave
using ISSR markers:809, 823 and 886, the molecular profiles were
compered with the standard hybrid type sample provided by the
petitioners, the laboratory report i.e. Ex.X.6, dated 01.08.2017 and
declarr:d the field sample his-branded' as its molecular profile did
not match the standard parental [ine. She also gave a clarification with
regard to examination of lot No.l870 only as it represented the
comm()n parental line supplied to alt dealers and therefore, the test
results would uniformty apply to all farmers.
78 of99
2t5/2026,4:50 PM
crp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_1175_2025pdf
htrpsr//csis.tshc.gov.in/lrcordeN&2Slcryl
crp_ll7 5 2025.pd
-1'
Kr.T CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Barch
48.,,She further
that she .l€q}€sted the
c-ol-npany to furnibh gel prints or marker details and petitioners did not
_-:.....
fumish the same.
49. Howev-er, during cross-examination she has admitted that
the'gel'prints will be supplied and that she has not received the gel
prints. Ttre District Agriculture Officer, will give license to
manufaclq{p-g companies to sell the seeds in market world, for the
purpose of manufacturing the seeds, the commissioner of Agricutture
will accord permission to the seeds companies. After determining the
S9n9!c purity and SSR markers and gel prints, the license will be
given for the pu.ryose of manufacturing seeds. The centre license is
meant for both for manufacturing and for sales. The gel prints wilt be
given to only commissioner of Agriculture.
50. Thus, nothing useful was elicited from her during crossexamination.
51. As discussed supra, petitioners hetein examined Sri
P.Srinivasa Swamy, Zotal Manager as R.W.l and Mr. Paraq Agarwal,
79 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
crp
-ll7
hups://csis.shc.gov.in/hcordersl2025l crpl ctp
5 2}25.docx - crp-l I 75- 2025.pdf
-1
75 2025.pd1
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
Breerler as R.W.2, who dgposed ,that ,the seeds supplied by the
petitioners are genetically pUIq, high qualit-y hybrids and there is no
genel:ic defect in the said chilli seeds pllrdhased by the farmen
-
complainants. There is no deficiency of service on their part.
52. lt is also apt to note that in some complaints, petitioners
exanLined the dealer as R.W.3.
53. On consideration of the said evidence both oral and
documentary, vide order dated 30.01.2020, learned District Consumer
Forum, allowed the said complaints in part, holding that the seeds
supptied by the petitioners are 'mis-branded', geneticatly poor and
there is def,rciency in service. Leamed District Forum also considered
Field Inspection Report, Disfiict Level Report, and DNA Fingerprint
Labc,ratory Report. Leamed District Forum also considered the bills
frled by the complainants, pattadar passbooks etc, for the purpose of
comllutation of loss. Ultimately, learned District Forum held that both
the nranufacture and dealer are joinfly and severely liable and directed
them to pay an amount of Rs.1,35,000/- towards crop loss per acre
80 of99
2/512026,4:50 PM
hQs://csis.tshc.gov.ir/hcorde rs/2025 /crpkrp
crp-1175 2025.docx - crp-1175 2025.pdf
-l
17 5
-2025
-pd:
KI.,
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
,,:
atogg with'/;So/p tntprest per annum from the date of filing of the
,,
.,
'
j..
,.
.
..,"':.,:',,
,
.:l
.
.i:. .:.1 .':
'
"
.'
complaint iri,;.-tii;a6:2018 till date of realization of the same. Learned
,.,,,',,
.. t
. :i.-:: .'
Distict Forum,,ilS'O. dii-ected the petitioners and dealer to pay an
,:': ' ":l
per acre to the complainants towards
amount ,ofl. RS,35,000/._..:.'''
'
:'
'
1....
,.
expenditure inctrrreA by them inctuding costs of seeds, Rs-10,000/' :",towards metnA1.a9,.o1y: legal expenses including costs within one
.
month from the date of receipt of copy of the said order-
,.:
54. As discgssed supra, learned District Forum, answered all
the three points in'favour of the complainants. District Forum gave
,,
:
specific r€asory+g on alt the aforesaid three issues including
.
computation. "
,,:,
'
55. Petitioners herein preferred appeals before the state
Commission challenging the said orders passed by the District Forum'
The State Commission allowed some appeals filed by the petitioners
:
on ttre ground tnat trc complainants did not f,rle evidence such as bills
in proof of the pgrchaSe of the seeds, ownership of the cultivated land,
details of family members, use of pesticides and proof of crop loss'
8l of99
21512026,4:50 PIv
ctp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_l l7!: 2025.pdf
hups://csis.shc.gov.io/hcordes/20251cry1 cry_ll7 5 2025 qc
KI".t
a^\
CRP No.l lT5 of2025 & Barch
However, the state commission allowed soB.g 4ppears in part and
redur:ed interest on the ground that complainants have not filed proper
docurnents and without considering the said aspects, District Forum
allowed complaints in part and directed the'petitioners to pay the
56. It is also apt to note that in some appeals which were
allow,:d, State commission considered the fact that farmers failed to
file bills for purchase of the seeds, land documents, date of purchase
and sowing and transplantation of the seedlings. District Forum
passecl impugned orders in an uniform manner mechanically without
exami;ring the aforesaid relevant documents with the said findings,
learnerl State commission allowed some appeals filed by the
petitio:rers in toto.
:i7
- whereas, leamed NCDRC considered appointment of
committee, drawing of samples by the committee, sending the same
for examination in the labs and submissionofreport. learned NCDRC
also cc,nsidered the depositions of p.ws.l to 4 more particularly,
82 of99
2/512026,4:50 PM
crp_ll7 5 ]A25.docx - crp_l 17 5 ]025.pdf
htQs://csis.tslrc gov.inlhcorde rs/X25 I crptcrp
_ll7 5 J02S.V.
KI.J- CRP No. I 175 of2025 & Adch
iof
P.W.2 Assistant Direbtor
t.
.
DNA Fingerprint Expert,
.. .
Seed
using
r\rNR
chillies
learned
weather
and other documents exhibited.through P.ws.3 and 4 before the
DistrictForum.
,,,,,,
:
58. It is apt to notc that in the said Joint [nspection report, it
,,.
was reported as follows:j
t.
Crop is at the stage of flowering to fiuiting stage having upward
:
curling with low floweriug and fruiting,
ll.
Plants not shows uniformity, some plants at the stage of pre-
flowering, some plants at the stage of flowering to fruiting stage
and some plants severely affacked by viral disease.
83 of99
2/512026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.shc. gov.in/hcorde rsl 2025 I ctpl crp
crp_1175 2025.docx - crp-l 175-2025-pdf
-ll7
5 2025'pdl
//:
!
KI;
'
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
Offrcer, Warangal Urban and Rurat District, ,AssiStana . Director,
Agriculture, Horticulture Officer, visited fields and submiAed report.
60. It is also not in dispute that on the recommendations of the
,, ,l
:
Committee, a genetic purity test was also condtrcted after collecting
,
..,
j.:.1
r
treave,s from the frelds and VNIR 145 hybrid stpdard qpe sample
subrnitted by the seed company. A genetic purity test wa-s conducted
in Tr:langana DNA Fingerprinting and Transgenic Cfqp monitoring
lab, Hyderabad. The said genetic purity test revealed that as per the
field sample, molecular profile is different froq the standard
molecular profile, the sample is declared as 'mis-branded'. The said
report was also marked as Exhibit. Petitioners herein failed to falsiff
the sraid report <turing cross-examination or by producing any other
contra evidence.
84 of99
2t5/2026,4:50 PM
crp_L175 2025.docx - crp_l 17 5 2025.pdf
hcps://csis.tshc.gov.inlhcordes/2O25 / upl crp_ll7 5
-p25.pd
KI.,
CRP lb.l 175 of2025 & Bdch
,
,, ,,,,,]
61. Learned NCDRC considbred'the said aspects and disposed
,. :,, . ;......:....
of the revisions filedrby the petitioners vide impugued comnon order.
,,
, ..''
,, ', ,.
".
.
62.Tlte sum and substance of contgntions of the petitioners are
as follows:-
Burden lies on the complainants
- farmers to prove that the
seeds are defective.
ll.
Genetic purity cannot be established through visual site
inspection.
ul.
The complainants -farmers have to show nexus between defect
lv.
The alleged visual inspection by the Committee was not
independent and it was behind the back of the petitioners.
ln-house lab report of the petitionen will prevail over the site
inspection report.
vl.
Procedural lapses on the part of the complainants.
vrt.
Proceedings, issued by the Deparfinent cancelling the
manufacturing license was set aside by the High Court.
85 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcorderV2025 lcrplcrp _ll7 5 2025 pdt
ctp_ll7s 2025.docx - crp_l175. 2025.pdf
I
KL,J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
vltl.
There was Thrips infestation which cannot be auributed to'thc
genetic purity of the seeds and farmers did not take necessary'
,-
63. In the light of the said submission, it is apt to note tha! thre
dispule concerning alleged defective seeds, the complainants must
ultimately estabtish i) the seeds supplied have suffered from
defects/substandard quality in a manner materialty affecting the
perfbrmance. ii) and such defect bore a proximity nexus with the loss
of crop on the consequential damages claimed
64. There is no dispute that there was crop failure and such crop
failure by itself does not automaticatly lead to an inference of
defective seed. Nonetheless, where the material on record demonstrate
genetic: deviation ' mis-branded' coupled with consistent field level
failure traceable to the supplied variety, the above nexus requirement
stands :;atisfied.
(;5. A conjoint reading of the Seeds Act, 1966 and the Seeds
Rules, 1968 makes it clear that the authority to test and certiff the
86 of99
215/2026,4:50 PM
hqs://csis.blrc.gov.in/hcorders/2025/crp/crp-l 1 75-2025.pdt
ctp_ll7 5 _m25.docx - crp_l I 75 2025.pdf
.
:
.'',:...,..1..
:'''. , ; .lr' ,..,t,,:,
quality, purity and gen€tic charact
titb,,,,'of
,
cRPNo.,*irrrr*uo*
i. - '
seeds :is 'vested
.
....
. : I ,.."r,..
exclusively in the Central Seed Laboratoly.oi:'-qtate Seedr Laboratory
'
:'
'
'"" t
'-ti
notified under Section 4 of, the. A9!;,,and,",suCh testing can be
.ltt
'.
''.','
'
undertaken only by duly quatified: Seedi.Analysts appointed in
accordance with the Act and Rules, Sections 14.tb i6 of the Act, read
with Rules 20 to 33 of the Seeds Rules,.prescribe a mandatory
procedure for sampling, sealing, dispatch and scientific analpis, and
confer statutory f,rnality on reports issued, by such notified
laboratories. The Act does not recognize D-I{A or genetic testing
conducted by non-notified laboratories or by offcers not qualified as
,...
Seed Analysts. Consequently, any DNA or.gen€1ic purity test relied
upon for regulatory or adjudicatory purposes m-ust strictly conform to
the statutory framework, failing which such reports lack legal sanctity
and cannot form the basis for a finding of misbranding, genetic
impurity or deficiencY in sewice.
66. lt is also significant to note that Prffs. 2 to 4 are independent
and official witnesses, being officers of the'State discharging statutory
87 of99
21512026,4:50 PIt
ctp_1175 2025.docx - crp_I17:i 2025.pdf
https://csis.shc.gov.in/trcorde rc120251 ctpl erp_lL7 5 2025.pt
KI.I
r-\
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Barch
ne{her afleged nor established any bias or animus on their part in
,
,, f4vprrr of the comrplainants, and no suggestion to that effect was even
put trr,these ldtnesses during c ros s -exami nation.
,
67. section 13 of the Acr, 1986 deals with procedure on
admission of complaint. Section l3(l) (c) of the Act, 19g6 says that
:.'
therEristrict Forum shall on admission of complaint if it relates to any
goo4s where the complaint alleges in defect in the goods which
caourlt be determined without proper analysis or test of the goods,
Distn,ct Forum shall obtain sample of the goods from the complainant,
obtain report etc. [n the present case, District Forum placed relianoe
on thr: Field Inspection Report and DNA Fingerprinting report etc. on
consirleration of the same, District Forum, gave a specific finding that
the seeds supplied by the petitioners are of mis-branded, defective and
thcre is deficiency of service.
88 of99
4512026,4:50 PM
htqa://cs,is.tstrc.gov.in/hcorderV2o25 / crpl crp_ll7 5 2025.fi
ep_1175 2025.docx - crp_1175 2025.pdf
KI" J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Bal6
.
.., . --..:.
l:
68. It is also apt to note that by fillilg the aforesaiddocuments
,
..: , , ,,.
t
::':'
' .:t'''"'',''
"
thpir
and by examining P.Ws.l to 4, the complainants diso@ed,
t.thet
initial burden. Therefore, petitioners cannot contel
,, ,,., ' r,
,'thb
,:,, ,
complainants failed to discharge their burden. Thus;'6-nce 'the
.
: :.
,: ..,
.,,.:-.
,
..
I
complainants have discharged their initial burden, the burden shifts on
the petitioners to prove that they have supplied the goods property
without any defect and there is no deficiency in service'by rebutting
prima facie evidence as held by the Supreme , Court in
M.Madhusudhan Reddy (supra). They have to lead reliable contra
evidence. [n the present case, petitioners utterly failed to do,so.
69. As discussed supra, petitioners entered appearagce before
the District Forum and filed their counters. They have cross-examined
the complainants' witnesses and also filed documents. They have not
pleaded the aforesaid aspects in the counters. They have raised severat
grounds for the first time before the State Commission, learned
NCDRC and this Court which they have not raised Uefore tne District.,
Forum.
89 of99
'
.'
21512026,4:50 PM
.
htps://csis.shc. gov.in/hcordersl 2O25 / crplup_ll7 5 ]025 &
ctp_ll7s 2025.docx - crp_l175- 2025.pdf
,/' -t
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batclt
70. It is rite law that the petitioners herein have to plead and
prove by producing reliable evidence to show that they have supplied
genet.cally pure seeds and that there was no deficiency in service.
They have to disprove the allegations, contentions of the complainants
- farrners that the petitioners supplied defective seed and there is
deficir:ncy in service. In the present case, petitioners herein failed to
plead and prove the same.
71. With regard to the contentions of the petitioners that this
Court in a batch of writ petitions set aside the proceedings issued by
the dgriculture Deparbnent cancelling the manuflacturing license
issued in favour of the petitioners. However, perusa[ of the said orders
would releal that this Court set aside the cancellation proceedings
pointing out procedural irregularities. The said orders will not have
any be'aring on the present proceedings. The said order will not
preclude the complainant's remedies under the Act, 1986.
12.Itis also relevant to note that complainants filed bills, proof
of land owned by them etc. Even then, petitioners failed to dispute the
90 of99
21512026,4:fl) PM
Irttps://csis.slrc.gov.ir/trcordersl2025 I af, crp_Ll7 5 ]025.pd
crp_l 175_2025.docx - crp_ll7 5 _?f,25 Adf
KI. J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Bald
' ,r same and did not eticit anything from P.W.l (complainan8). They
' have not examined the dealer to disprove the said bills and in fact, the
:
, saidhills are certified by the dealer.
73.It is also apt to note that as per Rule 38 of the Seeds Rules,
1968, a person carrying on a business of seeds shall maintain record
i.e. stock record of seeds, record of sale of seeds. Rule 2(g) deals with
definition of complete record and it says the information which relates
to the origin, variety, kind, germination and purity of seed of any
l
notified kind or variety offered for sale, sold or otherwise supplied.
Rule 13 of the Rules, deals with requirements to be complied with by
a person carrying on the business of seeds. In the present case, the
petitioners failed to produce the same to disprove the bills submitted
by the complainants and also to disprove the claim of the
complainants.
74. It is also apt to note that petitioners did not file any
objections to the aforesaid reports
9l of99
21512026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcord ers/2025 I crpl crp_ll7 5 2025 pd
crp_1175 2025.docx - crp_1175. 2025.pdf
(..
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
75. Petitioners have to maintain certain statutory forms in terms
of Seods Rules. Theyhave not produced the said forms.
76. Petitioners did not take any steps before the District Forum
to send the samples to lab for conducting genetic purity test in terms
of Sec:tion 13 of the Act, 1986. Therefore, they cannot contend that all
the necessary markers were not considered in the DNA Fingerprinting
report
77.It is also apt to note that State Commission allowed some
appeals frled by the petitioners on the ground that the complainants
failed to file bitls, proper documents regarding purchase of seeds, crop
loss etr:. Complainants
- farmers, cannot be expected to preserve the
bills under which they purchased the subject chilli seeds. Farmers
being common people, cannot be expected to assume or presume there
would lre a crop loss.
?'8. This Court has carefully scrutinized the entire record,
including the depositions of witnesses, reports of the District-Level
Committee, Laboratory findings of
92 of99
the Telangana DNA
2/512026,4:50 PM
ctp
-ll7 ]Oz5.docx
- crp-l I 75-2025 pdf
https://csis.shc gov.in/hcorde rsl2025 t cryl crp
-ll7 -2025.fi|
KI. J
CRP l.Io.l175 of 2025 & Batch
,
Fingerpiinti,g , &: Transgenic Crops Monitoring Laboratory '
. '',,:,,,,'
,
Hy{t bad, official communications between the Department of
t.
,
,
Aqiculture and the Manufacturer, and ancillary documentary material
such as invoices, weather reports, and market-rate certificates. The
,
concurrent findings of the District Forum, State Commission, and
National Commission rest upon this comprehensive body of evidence.
' |g.It is welt settled that the 'Complainants-farmers' fall within
the definition of 'tonsumef' under Section 2(1Xd) of the Act, 1986,
and the objection raised by the petitioners on the $ound of
"commerCial cultivation" is untenable. The Supreme Court in
M. Madhusudhan Reddy (supra) authoritatively held that farmers
who purchase seeds for cultivating their own land, remain consumers,
even if the agricultural produce is sold, such activity is essentially for
livelihood and sustenance and not a commercial enterprise. This
principle was reiterated in Alavalapati Chandra Reddy (supra),
wherein thr Court applied the 'dominant purpose test' and clarified
that the scale of cultivation or volume of sale is immaterial so long as
93 of99
21512026,4:50 PV
cry _ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_l I 75 _2025.pdf
htps://csis.shc.gov.in/trcorde rs/2025 / crp/ crp_ll7 5 2025.p<
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Barcb
the primary object is eamiqg livelihood. In the light of these binding
.
il.
prec,rdents, the respondenls were,rightty treated as consumers by the
fora below, and the proceedings rmder the Act, 1986 are clearly
..
mairrtainable, warranting no interference on this ground.
80. [t is also well settl;o uw that the suppry of defecrive or sub-
stan<lard seeds resulting in crop loss constitutes "deficiency in
service" within the meaning of section 2(rXg) of the Act, 19g6. The
Supreme court in M. Madhusudhan Reddy (supra) held that seed
manrrfacturers owe a statutw and contracfual duty to maintain
presr:ribed standards of quality, germination and genetic purity, and
any ceviation therefrom, once established through official inspection
or scientific material, attracts liabitity under consumer law. The
NCI)RC in Nandan Biomatrix Ltd.(supra) and Fortune Hybrid
seeds Ltd.(supra) furttrer clarified that where prima facie defect or
misbranding is demonstrated, the manufacturer cannot evade
responsibility by attributing crop faiture to climatic or pest-related
factc,rs. In the present case, the concurrent findings of the consumer
94 of99
2/5/2026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.strc. gov.iry'hcorde rsl2025 lcrpkrp
ctp_1175 2025.docx - crp_l 175_2$25.pdf
-ll7
5 2025.pd
KI.,
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Barcli
I
,'.,,,,,,
.::
..
..
fora, based on eipert reports and official inspections, clearly establish
'deficiency in'.servicel'ron the part of the petitioners, and the said
conclusion is;,rn'.4bsolUte consonance with the settled jurisprudence
govermrlg:.feed qelaGd consumer disputes.
81. :The:Act, '1986 is a beneficial and remedial legislation
enacted With the odect of providing speedy, inexpensive and effective
redressal to consumers, and prolonged litigation runs directly contrary
to its legislati4' ihtent, The Supreme Court in Ghaziabad
Developnient Authority (supra) underscored that consumer fora must
discourage tactics, which'delay relief and cause conti nued harassment
to consumers,,partidularly those who are economically vulnerable. In
the context of agricultural disputes, where farmers depend on a single
crop cycle for their livelihood, repeated and successive challenges to
conqurent findings only serve to defeat the very purpose of the Act.
In the present case, the dispute relates to the agricultural season of
20t7, and the respndents have been compelled to litigate for several
years across multiple fora. Such protraction of proceedings, in the
95 of99
215/2{26,4:50 PM
crp_ll7 5 2025.docx - crp_l I 75_ 2025.pdf
hups://csis.shc. gov.in/hcorde sl2025 I crpl crp_ll7 5 _2025.pd,
t'
KL, J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Batch
absence of any demonstrated jurisdictional error, is antithetical to the
objecr:of the Act, 1986 and cannotbe countenanced.
82. The scope of interference under Anicle 227 of the
Constitution of India, is supervisory and not appellate, and it does not
permi; re-appreciation of evidence or substifution of factual
concltrsions reached by competent fora, It is a settled principle that
where concurrent findings of fact have been recorded by the tribunals
below after due consideration of the material on record, such findings
do no,: warrant interference unless they are shown to be perverse,
based on no evidence, or vitiated by jurisdictionat error. The Supreme
Court in Jai Singh (supra) and this Court in Neelam Gupta (supra)
have t:mphasized that supervisory jurisdiction is to be exercised
sparinllly and with circumspection. In the present case, the District
Forum and learned NCDRC gave coffiistent findings of deficiency in
service founded on scientific and documentary evidence, and no
pervers.ity or patent illegality has been demonstrated. .Interference
under r\rticle 227 ofthe Constitution of India, in such circumstances
96 of99
2/512026,4:50 PM
htps://csis.strc.govio/hcorde
ctp_1175 2025.docx - crp-l175 2025.pdf
rsl 2025 I crpl crp
-Ll7
-2025.&l
KT. J
CRP No.l 175 of2025 & Balch
would amount to converting the supervisory jurisdiction into an
appellate forum, which is impermissible in taw.
83. It is relevant to note that on consideration of the aforesaid
aspects, learned Disfiict Fo4rm allorred the complaints filed by the
farmers and . awarded compensation. Learned State Commission
allowed some appeals filed by the petitioners, set aside the orders
passed by the Distict !o1um on the ground that the complainants
failed to fite bitts etc. The said findings of the State Commission are
erroneous and conffary to the principle laid down in the aforesaid
judgments. However, learned NCDRC considered the said aspects and
disposed of the revisions filed by the petitioners herein and
complainants vide courmon ordor dated 06.01 .2025. It is a reasoned
order and well founded. Petitioners herein failed to make out any case
to interfere with the said order.
84. As discussed supra, there are concurrent frndings by the
learned District,Forum and learned NCDRC with regard to supply of
mis-branded defective seeds and there is deficiency in service
97 of99
2/5/2026,4:50 PM
crp_1175 2025.docx - crp_l I 7i;_2025.pdf
htps://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcordersl2025 lcrpl crp_ll7 5 2025.p<
stat(, commission ered in setting aside some of the'orders passed by-
,,,,.........,,.......
the District Forum and reducing the compensation,awarded by the
:" '
' tl '
District Forum in complaints. The said findings are contBry to the
:...-
:
object of the Act, 1986, procedure laid down under'Seeds Act and
Ruk;s, and also principles laid down in the aforesaid judgments.
85. It is also apt to note that learned counsel'for,the petitioners
on instructions, submitted that the tiability of the petitio.aers to comply
..,...,
with orders passed by the District Forum would be'aroundr Rs.ll
crores and learned NCDRC would be Rs.9 crores, in,compliance
'..,
with the interim orders passed by this court, the petitioners have
lainants in alt the. complaints are
.,,
-,..
.
,
consumers and the complaints filed by them before the DiStict Forum
undt:r Section 12 of the Acr, 1986 are maintailble.,There is
defir:iency of service on the part of the petitioners herein.
98 of99
215/2026.4:50 PM
lrtss://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcorde rs/ 2025 I crp/ crp
crp_1175]?.O25.docx - crp-l 175 2025pdf
-ll7
5 2025.pd[
,/':99
KI.
'
CRP No.t 175 of2025 & Batctr
Conclusion:87. In the light of the aforesaid discussion, as discussed supra,
the impugned common order dated 06.0L.2025 passed by the learned
NCDRC is a reasoned order and well founded. It does not require
interflerence by this Court by invokiqg its powers under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India. Thus the present revisions fai[, they are
liable to be dismissed and accordingly dismissed.
JUSTICE IC LAKSHMAN
19th Decemberr2025
Note: L.R.copy to be marked.
b/o.wr.
99 of99
21512026,4:50 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review