Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3488 J
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE SIXTH DAY OF AUGUST
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
HONOURABLE
SRI
JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
THE
WRIT APPEAL NO: 794 OF 2026
Writ Appeal under clause '15 of the Letters Patent preferred against the order
dated 1211112025 in W.P.No.27469 of 2025 on the file of the High Court.
Between:
Vision Distribution Private Limited, Regd. Office at H-47, Bali Nagar, near
Ramesh Nagar Metro Station, New Delhi 1100'15 Represented by its
Authorised Representative, Mr Jasthi Sai Mohan Chowdhary
...APPELLANT / PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, School Education
Department, Government of Telangana, Saifabad, Khairtabad, Hyderabad 500004
2. The Commissioner and State Project Director, School Education Department,
Government of Telangana, B-block 2, Telephone Bhavan Road, Saifabad,
Khairtabad, Hyderabad - 500004
3. The [Vlanaging Director, Telangana State Technology Services Ltd., HACA
Bhavan, 2nd Floor, Opp. To Public Gardens, 5-10-103/40/206, Nampally,
Hyderabad 500004
...RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO: 2OF 2026
Petition under Section 15'1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to release the
due amount as admitted and recorded in the impugned Order dated 1211112025
passed by the learned single Judge in w.p No 27 469 of 2025 within a period of one
week, pending disposai of the writ appeal.
Counsel for the Appellant: SRt DAMA SESHADRT NAIDU, Sr. COUNSEL, REp.
SRI D.SIVA SANKAR ACHARYA
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 & 2: SRI T.VENKAT RAJU,
GP FOR EDUCATION
The Court delivered the following: JUDGMENT
IN THE HIGH
THE HON,BLE
COURT FO]
^
r r rl#tdli." oF TELANGANA
THE CHIEF JUS,
rHE HoN,BLE
sR,
t^' APARESH K,MAR
rJiT
STICE C.M.MOHIUDDIN
w RIT APPE AL No
DA T ED :06 .0
Between
Vision Distribution privare
I'hc State ot. I
[T,jr.,,,:
.79 4o f2 026
8.2 026
Limited
Appel lant
ANI)
elaneana
principil
srNc,
S"c.era.1.
,iffi#:l, t:T;::t.,,
JU DG M I]N T:
I
. . . Respondenb
leard Mr. Darna
representing
Mr. D. Siva Sankar
appellant/wri1 peritioner
pieader
2.
Scshaclri Naidu,
fbr r duca,ion
an(l
^.,r-
r ,'.
respondents
, l #-
a
periocr ol.rive
earned wri, c.un
has
: ;",. #;
rr,rJ;'.ril:*;*:..,*
ryoerabad' by
to consider *" ."^,,^^."-^''.
of the appellant
pending pa-vrnenrs
counsel for the
Govem,,en,
::::::*^# "ff*_ :" _i fi
D recror, Sarnagra
senior counser
a.tu.yu,
r.,,
"qrJd' tearned
;::;:,;::::
l/ide <trder under
Iei
directing the
for release of rhe
therein in accordance
", ,r,rl:jt:,'"st.
with law.
rnonths ,ru,r"tto
the datc ol-recerpt
ol.cop) o[.the
within a
order. The
H(J3l;t'll''
_''J
prcserrl appeal
(@18')i, oithe
ha' hectt prcttrred
principal
L'earned Se nior
3,
thc
bl
bcing aggrievcd
the due
aurotint tiom
Counsel tbr
29 08 101-l
'l
Apex Cotrrt
has approirched
the direction
oi tilc learncd
to make the duc
in
the amottnt became
dio n1t
the
furnished br
concernod
'I
:::" T".r,,- ,5: '-
urit Court' the responclents
-.'::::":
are under obligatton
pa) rne n1s
'::::::...;, il:,.::t
sttpt
\\ithin thc time
lbr the respondent
scttletl u'ithin
that WP No
\\ aS l1e\ t]r a
::
27469
the *rittcn instructions
behall
lor the Stats on
ot' interest
but the claitn
he rr riue tt illstILlcttolls
State strbmits
ol
ol olr the bast s
the learricti 'ounscl
(io\ ernlllenl
the
rvhictr the
lt is submitted
prescnt appeal
ttf course disposed
be llaid arrd
over
Therefore' interest
br r.108 2026
l.etrnled cotrnsel
of l0l5 s'as
of
due tiom
Rs l i 55'48'805/-'
accrue up to
Cortt t
4.
the clairn ol
Courts'
and other l{igh
this Courr in
pa)rrents
to make the
realizrtion'
thc melnorandum
paragraph 8 oi
.uu,r .,,on*usr:
rearncd wrir
dccisions of
intetest
the
o[ 695 da1's
'a 189'o s'ould
principal atnor'rnt
non-grant of
date till its
to the appellant'
hcrc is a dela--v
ur://J/'
that
appellant submits
clear\) indicated
appellant uas
According
',vrit appeal
ll .t \,,.
of thc Icspondent
dm ined '
thc pending
indicated that
timetiatre
a specilic
l'o
pa)'rnerlts could
r \\ hich the State
relcase the reqtrired budget
has becn recl ucsted ro
auontion trf lhis Court has beeu drarvn to
'lhe
the tertrls anci conditiotls ol'the
J
HCJ & GMIVT,J
tYA No.794 of2025
contract specifically the 'Pa).rnent Schedule' at clause 1l which
reads as
under
"l l. PAYMENT SCHfDULE
Pa),ments shall be made to the primary brdder if in case of consortium ot sole bidder
as per the following schedule:
Payment Schedule
S.No
Milestone D€scription
On
Delivery and successful
installation of equipmenr at sire and
% Pa),rn€nt
90% ofcontEct value
after verification of such items by
authorized agency,/School Education
Tela
On Acceptance Test
Rernaining l0% of the
will be paid afte.
submission
of
performance certifi cate
issued by the dept./AT
conducted by TSTS.
Two Sets of reports to
be subrnfied. One set to
Bitls division and one
set to AT division
Incase srte nor ready
75% of the Conrmct
value lor
that
site/location
Note:
TSTS Shall Process the palment aganst the submission bills for minimum
100 schools.
11.1 Payment Authority
The TSTS will make the paymenr as per payment terms and conditlons.
l.
2.
The Departmenr shall verif, the bidder,s statement and certify rhe amount
to be
paid to the bidder after certi! the software and hardware equipments.
The
Value o[work completed shall be decided by the Department.
The Department may erclude cny item cinified ln a pre!,tous
certificate or
reduce the proportion of cny item preriously cenified in any certificate
in the
Iight of later informanon
3. The payments as admissible shall be made after deducting the tunher security
deposit, tax deduction at source (TDS), sales tax, roya"lty and other
4.
5.
applicable at prevailing rate at the time of payments_
Payments to the bidder shall be made firough cheques/online.,,
taxes
A mere perusal of the payrnent schedule shows that the payment is in
staggered manner, 90%o of the contract value is to be paid on delivery and
successful installation of equipment at site and after verification of such
,l
HCJ & G.II,II,')
tt 1\,1..19J of2426
itetris h1 r'r1h()'i;re r1 llqcttcv School Education Department, Telangana,
rcnrrining lit lu i: lo be paid altel submission of performance ceftificate
issuecl b1 the dcparlment ' AT conclucted by TSTS. In case the site is not
reac11. 759'n oF the contract value for the said site,'location is to be paid The
pa)rnent autholit\ is under an obligation to verify the bidder's statement
anci certit_r'rhe arllount to be paid to the bidder after certifying the softu'are
ancl hardrr arc .qurplncnts The r.alue of r'' ork shall be decided by the
clepartment.
-fhc clepartrrent rnay erclude any item certified in a previous
certillcate Or. ietluce the propofiion of any item previotLsly certified in any
cefiificate in the lrght of the later intbrmation. Paunents shall be admissible
after decluciirrg [hc flulher securiil. deposit. Tar Deduction at source. sales
tax. 1'o)'alt) antl ,-rtlter tares applicable at the prer aiiing rates The aforesaid
palrnent schetlule clearll shou's that the entire amount on successful
instaliation of the etluiprrent at site is not palable in one go' The pleadings
on recorcl ilo not elarifl.on rh. part of the appellant th3
(lates oldelivery and
successful instlllatiort ol the eqtripment at site and the claims made
thereupon and also the specific period for r'r'hich the sum dtte remained
unpaid. On th!' I)a( ol the responclents. the instructions only refer to the
baiance clairu ,rl lls.i.1.71.12.807,- payable to the appellant. The claim of
intcrest is 1i6t l'211'11 as per the contractual terms but the date on rvhich any
sura becarre dLre and has not been paid in torms of the payment schedule
arc quesrio..; or'1act i"hich cannot
lre determinecr in writ
lLrrisdiction ancr at
)
HCI & GMII,J
WA No.791of2026
this appellate stage. The claim of interest over the sums unpaid beyond the
permissible date are issues which could be raised in a proceeding where
questions of fact can be determined on the basis of pleadings and evidence
adduced by the parties. The agreement provides for arbitration clause 5.15.
Leamed counsel for the appellant has relied upon the decision of the Apex
Court in the case of Surya Constructions v. State of Uttar Pradesh and
othersr. The operative part of the same is extracted hereunder:
"lt is clear, therefore, fiom the aforesaid order dated 22-03.2014 that there is
no dispute as to the amount that has to be paid to the appellant. Despite this, when the
appellant knocked at the doors of the High Court in a writ petition being writ Crvil
No. 2521612014, the impugned judgrnent dated 02.05.2014 dismissed the \riit pehtion
stating that disputed questions of fact arise and that the amount due arises out of a
contmct. We are afraid the High Court was wholly incorect inasmuch as there was
no disputed question of fact. On the contrary, the amount payable to the appellanr is
wholly undisputed. Equally, it is well senled that where the State behaves arbitrarily,
even in the realm ofcontract, the High Court could interfere under Article 226 of the
Constitution oflndia IABL Intemational Ltd and Another v. Export Credit Guarantee
Corporation oflndia Ltd. and Others ((2004) 3 SCC 553)1.
This being the case and the work having been completed long back in 2009.
we direct the Uttar Pradesh Jal Nigam to make the necessary payment within a period
of fbur weeks fiom today- Given the long period of delay, inte.est at the rate of 6 per
cent per annum may also be awarded."
In the instant case, as observed hereinabove, there is no pleading or
determination on facts as to the dates from which the sum became due and
remain unpaid over which the claim of interest could be granted. As such,
we are of the view that though the leamed writ Court has directed pa),rnent
of amounts admitted as per the written instructions furnished by the
Director of School Education & State Project Director, Samagra Shiksha,
Telangana, Hyderabad, since there are no avennents or findings on the issue
of interest accruable from the dates on which the sums due to the appellant
' lzorey ro scc ze+
HCJ & G.v;tt,J
u:1 .\o.79t oJ2D6
becrrnre niiral:.ie .
:i ,r i:,n[i fioI be proper lor this Court in erercise of
appellatl.1:risrl,lior ,o rencler any iinding for.granting interest
for. Horvever. it cloes not preclude the appellant from raising
interest in an appropnate proceeding such as arbitration
as prayed
the claim of
as per clause 5.15
of the agreement entered betrveen the parties.
Theiefore. u.e do not find any reason to interfere in the order
appeal. Accorcirngly. the instant writ Appeal is dismissed.
un,ler
There shall be no
order as to costs
Vliscellaneous applications. if any pencling. shall stand closed
//TRUE COPY'
SD/. N.SRIHARI
DEPUTY RE GISTRAR
SECTION OFFICER
To,
One CC to SRI D.SIVA SANKAR ACHARYA, Advocate
[OPUC]
Two ccs to GP FoR EDUCATTON, High court for the state of rerangana
at
Hyderabad [OUT]
3 Two CD Copies
BSR
TKS
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0610812026
JUDGMENT
,a'
WA.No.794 ot 2026
.ri \,
.r/ r'l
l'\)
1 .J
il,-'
t-.
t U l;
202 6
\. u,_
\\
DISMISSING THE WRIT APPEAL,
WITHOUT COSTS
b
\
\
\9\
f.
*
('
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review