Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010546362025
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MOHAMMED AADIL
KHAN
Date: 2026.09.18
17:52:58 +0530
Reserved for orders on :30-06-2026
Order passed on : 18-09-2026
WP227 No. 2 of 2026
1 - Vishnu Vishwas @ Munna Vishwas, S/o Late B.K. Vishwas, Aged About 54
Years, Resident of Near Paalbai, Near New Gudakhu Factory, Hemu Nagar Torva,
Bilaspur, At presently residing at Tenant of Arun Manoharrao Gulhane, 282 Kelkar
Badi, Wardha (Maharashtra) Pin Code 442001.
... Petitioner
versus
1 - Smt. Bhagmati, W/o Abhayankar Kewat, Aged About 50 Years, Occupation
House Wife Resident of Hemu Nagar, Torva, Bilaspur District- Bilaspur
Chhattisgarh,
2 - Narayan Vishwas S/o B.K. Vishwas, Aged About 35 Years (Presently Aged About
65 Years) Resident of Near Paalbai, Near New Gudakhu Factory, Hemu Nagar
Torva, Bilaspur District- Bilaspur Chhattisgarh,
3 - Smt. Jamuna Vishwas (Dead) W/o B.K. Vishwas Resident of Near Paalbai, Near
New Gudakhu Factory, Hemu Nagar Torva, Bilaspur
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
: Mr. Vishnu Vishwas @ Munna Vishwas, Petitioner in
person.
For Respondent No.1 : Mr. J.K. Gupta, Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J.
C A V Order
1.
The present writ petition has been filed by the petitioner/judgment debtor
assailing the order dated 06.12.2025 passed by the learned 4th Additional
Judge to the Court of the learned First Civil Judge, Senior Division, Bilaspur,
in Misc. Case No. CJ/12/2012, whereby the application preferred by the
petitioner under Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short,
“the CPC”), has been dismissed. The petitioner prayed for the following relief
in the writ petition:“10.1
That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to the
judgment debtor humbly submits that the impugned order
passed by the learned 4th Civil Judge Class 2 Bilaspur has
passed the judgment dated 27.04.2004 and in the judgment
and decree passed by the learned trial judge which was land
out of kahsra no. 789/4 30x59= 1770 sq.ft. and over the
western side house of judgment debtor and the learned
executing court had not carried to considered the application
filed by the judgment debtor under Section 151 of CPC not
carried to see the infirmities between the difference of
original judgment and decree passed by in civil suit No. 92A/2001 on 27.04.2004 passed by learned 4th Civil Judge
Class 2 Bilaspur and further order was passed 3 rd Civil Judge
Class 2 Bilaspur in civil suit No. 92A/2001 on 17.01.2008 and
that between the said judgments the demolition of wall has
been mentioned in the subsequent order dated 17.01.2008
but 4th Civil Judge Class 2 Bilaspur dated 27.04.2004 and
since the execution application has already been filed by the
decree holder and since the execution proceeding and since
the executing court she also not judgment debtor and had
dismissed the application filed by the judgment debtor and
that the house of judgment debtor has been built khasra no.
789/4 and over the western side of the wall of the suit house
if it is demolished and broken, then in that circumstances
judgment debtor and therefore an application is being filed
for grant of ex party stay in favour of the judgment debtor
because all the ways of the executing court have been
closed for executing court and the only remedy which is
available to the judgment debtor which can be obtained by
this court for grant of ex party stay in favour of judgment
debtor by directing the executing court not be demolished the
western side of the wall in order to seek the western side of
the wall suit house and therefore on the basis of the instant
petition which has been filed by the judgment debtor be
allowed and the order passed by the learned 4th Civil Judge
Class 2 Bilaspur in Misc. Civil Judicial Case CJ 12/2012
dated 6.12.2025 be order to be set aside and also the order
passed by the same court for dismissing an application for
maintaining the status quo be order to be set aside.
10.2
Any other relief, which this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and
proper, may also be passed in favour of the petitioner.”
2.
The petitioner, appearing in person, would submit that the learned Executing
Court has committed an error in dismissing the application under Section 151
of the CPC without properly examining the terms and scope of the judgment
and decree dated 27.04.2004 passed in Civil Suit No. 92-A/2001. The
decree-holder had initiated execution proceedings in Misc. Civil Case No.
CJ/12/2012 for execution of the said decree, whereby relief of declaration,
permanent injunction and possession in respect of the suit property carved
out of Khasra No. 789/4, admeasuring 1770 sq. ft., was granted in favour of
the decree-holder. It is submitted that the original judgment and decree did
not contain any specific direction for demolition of the wall standing over the
western portion of the petitioner's house or for delivery of possession of 88.5
sq. ft. of land. The petitioner, therefore, submits that the Executing Court
could not enlarge or travel beyond the decree by directing demolition of the
wall or delivery of an additional portion of land which, according to him, was
never specifically decreed by the trial Court.
3.
The petitioner would further submit that, in his application under Section 151
of the CPC, he had brought to the notice of the Executing Court that
subsequent mutation proceedings had been carried out in respect of Khasra
No. 789/8, admeasuring 0.0160 hectare (1800 sq. ft.), and that there was a
dispute regarding the actual measurement and identity of the property. It was
specifically pleaded that, against the purchased area of 1800 sq. ft., only
about 1750 sq. ft. was available on the spot and that there was thus a
discrepancy of approximately 50 sq. ft. The petitioner had, therefore, sought
a report from the Tahsildar, Bilaspur, so that the actual position,
measurement and identity of the property could be ascertained and the
execution proceedings could be confined strictly to the property covered by
the decree. According to the petitioner, the said prayer was neither frivolous
nor intended to delay the execution, but was made only to remove the
ambiguity concerning the suit property; however, the learned Executing Court
rejected the application without undertaking such verification. He would also
submit that the subsequent order passed by the learned Executing Court
whereby 88.5 sq. ft. of land was directed to be delivered to the decree-holder
amounts, in substance, to an enlargement or modification of the original
decree and could not have been made in execution proceedings, particularly
when the original judgment and decree dated 27.04.2004 did not contain any
direction for demolition of the wall or delivery of the said 88.5 sq. ft. portion. It
is his further contention that the Executing Court is bound to execute the
decree as it stands and cannot go behind, alter or add to the decree under
the guise of execution.
4.
He would also submit that though there is no specific measurement in the
impugned decree, to avoid any controversy, he already vacated the 90 Sqr.
Ft. of the subject land on 22.03.2024 and now the decree has become
satisfied, and no further proceedings are required in the execution case. He
would refer to his affidavit dated 28.03.2024, submitted before the learned
Executing Court, and a copy of the same has also been filed in the petition
on 04.06.2026 along with an application for taking documents on record.
5.
He would submit that the application under Section 151 CPC was filed to
bring this jurisdictional issue to the notice of the Executing Court, but the
same has been dismissed without properly considering the contents of the
decree and the documents placed on record. He would, therefore, contend
that the impugned order dated 06.12.2025 is erroneous, arbitrary and
contrary to the settled principles governing execution of a decree and
deserves to be set aside, and the execution proceedings may be directed to
be closed.
6.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No.1/decree-holder
would submit that the present writ petition is misconceived and has been
preferred only with a view to delay and obstruct the execution of the decree
dated 27.04.2004 passed in Civil Suit No. 92-A/2001, which has attained
finality. It is submitted that the petitioner, being the judgment-debtor, cannot
seek to reopen or indirectly challenge the decree under the guise of an
application under Section 151 of the CPC. The alleged subsequent mutation
in respect of Khasra No. 789/8, the alleged discrepancy in the area
purchased by the petitioner, and the claim of shortage of 50 sq. ft. are wholly
irrelevant to the execution of the decree in favour of the respondent.
Revenue entries or subsequent mutation proceedings cannot override a
decree of a competent Civil Court. The prayer for obtaining a fresh report
from the Tahsildar is, therefore, nothing but an attempt to create an artificial
dispute regarding the identity and measurement of the decretal property and
to prolong the execution proceedings. If the petitioner was aggrieved by the
judgment and decree dated 27.04.2004, he ought to have challenged the
same before the competent appellate forum and cannot seek its
reconsideration in execution proceedings. He would further submit that the
Executing Court has neither travelled beyond the decree nor modified the
same; rather, it has only taken steps necessary for giving effect to the relief
granted by the trial Court. The decree has to be construed as a whole, and
the mere absence of a separate recital regarding demolition of the wall
cannot defeat the substantive relief of possession granted in respect of the
decretal property. If any structure of the judgment-debtor obstructs delivery of
possession of the property covered by the decree, its removal is merely a
mode of execution and does not amount to enlargement of the decree. The
inherent jurisdiction under Section 151 CPC cannot be invoked by the
judgment-debtor to stall execution or to obtain a fresh adjudication of matters
which already stand concluded. The learned Executing Court, upon
consideration of the objections raised by the petitioner, has rightly dismissed
the application, and no jurisdictional error, perversity or manifest illegality has
been demonstrated so as to warrant interference under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India. The writ petition, therefore, deserves to be dismissed.
7.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the documents
annexed with the petition and the record of the executing court, which has
been called by this Court vide order dated 18.06.2026.
8.
Before entering into consideration, it would be relevant here to observe
various order sheets of the learned executing court in the execution
proceeding, by which the applications of the respective parties have been
decided. From the record of the learned executing Court, it transpires that the
application for execution of the decree dated 27.04.2004 was filed on
18.04.2006. Vide order dated 29.12.2006, the order for delivery of
possession of 88.5 Sqr. Ft. out of total 1770 Sqr. Ft. of land of Kh. No. 789/4
was passed, and a possession warrant was issued. For one or other reason,
the decree could not be executed, and then the execution of the decree
through special process server was passed on 15.11.2007. On 11.12.2007,
an application under Section 47 of the CPC was filed by the judgment debtor,
which was allowed on 17.01.2008, in which the commissioner’s report was
considered and held that the decree holder is entitled for vacant possession
of 88.5 Sqr. Ft. (3 x 59/2) of land and directed the judgment debtor to remove
the construction from there on his own and hand over the possession to the
decree holder. Thereafter, on 23.01.2008, another application under Order 21
Rule 29 of CPC was filed by the judgment debtor, which was allowed on
19.09.2008, and further proceedings of the execution case were stayed till
the decision of another Civil Suit No. 02-A/2008. Thereafter, till 14.02.2019,
the execution proceedings were held up.
9.
On 14.02.2019, in compliance of the order dated 24.10.2018, the parties
have submitted the status of the Civil Suit No. 02-A/2008 (New No. was 207A/2014) by which the Civil Suit was disposed of on 05.08.2017. Thereafter,
the learned executing Court again proceeded in the case. On 26.03.2019, an
application under Section 151 of CPC was filed by the judgment debtor,
which was disposed of on 23.10.2019 on the condition that if the judgment
debtor fails to produce any stay order, the possession warrant should be
issued. After the Covid-19 pandemic, the proceedings again started by the
learned trial Court. On 23.06.2023, the execution of the possession warrant
was ordered to be in the presence of police force as the judgment debtor
made hindrance in execution of the decree. On 14.06.2024, the judgment
debtor has filed his affidavit stating therein that he has already vacated the
90 ft. of the disputed part of the land by removing the sunshade, and thereby
the decree is satisfied. The learned executing Court has not accepted the
explanation submitted by the judgment debtor through his affidavit and
ordered the issuance of a possession warrant as per the decree. Thereafter,
on 18.07.2024, the judgment debtor has filed another application under Order
21 Rule 99 of the CPC, which was decided on 05.08.2024, and the
application was dismissed. In its detailed order, the learned executing Court
considered all the aspects of the case as well as the contents of the affidavit
of the judgment debtor regarding handing over the vacant possession of the
suit land. Still, the decree could not be executed for one or another reason,
and the dates were adjourned.
10.
The facts emerging from the record are that in Civil Suit No. 92-A/2001, the
learned trial Court, by judgment and decree dated 27.04.2004, granted in
favour of respondent No.1 the relief of declaration, permanent injunction and
possession in respect of the suit property described in the plaint and decree.
The
said
decree
has
attained
finality
and,
consequently,
the
petitioner/judgment-debtor cannot, in the present execution proceedings or
by invoking the inherent jurisdiction under Section 151 CPC, seek to reopen
the findings recorded in the original suit. The limited question before this
Court is, therefore, whether the learned Executing Court, while dealing with
the petitioner's application, was justified in declining to examine his objection
that the decree did not specifically direct demolition of the wall or delivery of
possession of a separately identified portion measuring 88.5 sq. ft. It is a
settled principle of execution law that an Executing Court cannot go behind
the decree, nor can it add to, alter or modify the substantive relief granted by
the Court which passed the decree. At the same time, the decree is required
to be construed as a whole and the Executing Court possesses jurisdiction to
issue consequential directions which are necessary for giving effect to the
decree, provided such directions do not enlarge the relief granted therein.
11.
In the present case, the petitioner has specifically pleaded that although the
decree granted possession of the suit property, there is no express direction
in the judgment and decree dated 27.04.2004 for demolition of the western
wall of his house or for delivery of a separately demarcated area of 88.5 sq.
ft. The petitioner has also relied upon the subsequent revenue proceedings
relating to Khasra No. 789/8, admeasuring 0.0160 hectare, and has asserted
that against the area of 1800 sq. ft. allegedly purchased by him, only about
1750 sq. ft. is available on the spot, thereby giving rise to a dispute regarding
the actual measurement and identification of the property. On this basis, he
sought a report from the Tahsildar, Bilaspur. In the considered opinion of this
Court, the subsequent mutation or revenue entry cannot, by itself, confer any
right contrary to the decree or modify the property adjudicated upon by the
Civil Court. Nevertheless, where the judgment-debtor specifically raises a
dispute regarding the physical identity, measurement and location of the
property sought to be delivered in execution, the Executing Court is required
to determine whether such dispute can be resolved on the basis of the
decree and the existing record. Such an exercise would not amount to going
behind the decree, so long as it is confined to identification and
implementation of the property actually covered by the decree.
12.
The further factual aspect which assumes significance is the petitioner's
submission that he had already vacated and delivered possession of
approximately 90 sq. ft. of the disputed land on 22.03.2024 and that,
therefore, no further execution remains to be undertaken. In support thereof,
reliance has been placed upon the affidavit dated 28.03.2024 stated to have
been filed before the learned Executing Court. The said assertion has to be
considered in the context of the decree-holder's stand and the execution
record. Mere filing of an affidavit by the judgment-debtor cannot, by itself,
establish satisfaction of the decree unless the factum and extent of delivery
of possession are accepted by the decree-holder or otherwise established
before the Executing Court. Conversely, the decree-holder cannot claim
delivery of an area in excess of what is covered by the decree merely on the
ground that such delivery or demolition is considered necessary by her. The
satisfaction or partial satisfaction of a decree is essentially a matter falling
within the jurisdiction of the Executing Court, which is competent to examine
the relevant documents, the earlier proceedings and the actual position at the
site.
13.
The reliance placed by the petitioner upon Section 151 CPC also requires to
be considered in its proper perspective. The inherent power under Section
151 CPC is intended to secure the ends of justice and prevent abuse of the
process of the Court; it cannot be exercised in a manner inconsistent with an
express provision of the CPC or for granting substantive relief which was not
granted by the original decree. Equally, the provision cannot be invoked by a
judgment-debtor merely to protract execution of a decree which has attained
finality. Therefore, the petitioner's application could not have been allowed for
the purpose of re-adjudicating his title, questioning the validity of the decree
or altering the rights finally determined therein. However, his limited request
for verification of the identity and measurement of the decretal property,
coupled with the specific plea that possession of approximately 90 sq. ft. had
already been delivered, was required to be examined with reference to the
execution record, particularly when the ultimate object of execution is to
secure satisfaction of the decree and not to confer upon either party a relief
beyond the decree.
14.
Thus, this Court finds that the learned Executing Court was justified in
declining to reopen or modify the decree dated 27.04.2004; however, the
impugned order does not satisfactorily deal with the petitioner's specific
factual objections concerning the alleged delivery of 90 sq. ft., the
identification and measurement of the decretal property and the necessity, if
any, of further execution. The distinction between a consequential step
necessary for execution of the decree and an act which amounts to
enlargement of the decree is material. If demolition of the wall is merely
consequential to delivery of the very property covered by the decree, the
same may be permissible as a mode of execution; but if such demolition
results in delivery of a portion which was not the subject matter of the decree,
the Executing Court would lack jurisdiction to grant such enlarged relief. This
aspect is required to be determined on the basis of the decree, the pleadings,
the execution proceedings and the actual identification of the property, and
not merely on the assertion of either party.
15.
In view of the aforesaid factual and legal position, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the matter deserves limited interference under Article
227 of the Constitution of India. Accordingly, the impugned order dated
06.12.2025 passed in Misc. Case No. CJ/12/2012 is set aside, and the
matter is remitted to the learned Executing Court for fresh consideration of
the application under Section 151 CPC, confined strictly to the question of
execution and satisfaction of the decree dated 27.04.2004.
16.
The learned Executing Court shall examine the decree as it stands, the
petitioner's affidavit dated 28.03.2024 and other documents relied upon by
him, the objection of the decree-holder, and shall determine whether any
portion of the decretal property remains to be delivered. If the identity or
measurement of the decretal property cannot be determined from the existing
record, the Executing Court may, if considered necessary, obtain a report
from the competent revenue authority for the limited purpose of identification
and measurement. Such exercise shall not be construed as permitting either
party to reopen, vary or enlarge the decree.
17.
Needless to say, if the decree is found to have already been satisfied, the
execution proceedings shall be dealt with accordingly; otherwise, the
Executing Court shall proceed only to the extent necessary for enforcement
of the decree. The writ petition is accordingly disposed of.
18.
No orders as to costs.
19.
Registry is directed to send back the record of the Executing Court forthwith
along with a copy of this order for information and necessary compliance.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Aadil
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review