Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:5967
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR
Judgment reserved on: 26.11.2025
Judgment delivered on: 03.02.2026
Uploaded on : 03.02.2026
CRMP No. 2858 of 2025
Digitally
signed by
JYOTI JHA
Date:
2026.02.03
16:26:48
+0530
1. Virendra Singh Tomar S/o Omprakash Aged About 44 Years R/o Sai
Village- Bhatagaon, Shyama Prasad Mukherjee Ward No. 61 Raipur,
District- Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2. Rohit Singh Tomar S/o Omprakash Tomar Aged About 31 Years R/o Sai
Villa Bhatagaon, Shyama Prasad Mukherjee Ward No. 61 Raipur, DistrictRaipur, Chhattisgarh.
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1. State Of Chhattisgarh Through- - Ig Raipur Range, OfÏce Of The Ig Raipur
Range, Raipur, District- Raipur Chhattisgarh.
2. The Superintendent Of Police Raipur, District- Raipur ( C.G. ).
3. Police Station Purani Basti Through- Sho P.S. Purani Basti, Raipur, DistrictRaipur, Chhattisgarh.
----Respondent/s
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For Petitioners
: Mr. Satish Chandra Verma Sr.
Advocate along with Mr. Sajal Gupta,
Advocate for petitioners
For Respondent/State
: Mr. Saurabh Pande, Dy. A.G.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Hon'ble Shri Justice Arvind Kumar Verma,
CAV Judgment
1. The applicant has preferred this petition under Section 528
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) challenging the
impugned order dated 14.07.2025 whereby the Learned Judicial
Magistrate First Class issued a proclamation under Section 84 of the
BNSS without recording reasons to believe, and the impugned order
dated 13.08.2025 whereby the Learned Judicial Magistrate First
Class initiated proceedings under Section 85 of the BNSS for
attachment of the property of the petitioner in Crime No. 230/2025
dated 05.06.2025, registered at Police Station Purani Basti against
the petitioners for offences under Sections 308(2), 111(1) IPC and
Section 4 of the Chhattisgarh Protection of Debtors Act and
Impugned Non-bailable warrant dated 04.07.2025(Annexure P/4)
against the petitioner without specifying the reason to believe and
directed them to appear before the Court.
2. Brief facts of the case are that on 05.06.2025, Police Station Purani
Basti received a communication conducted in Crime No. 332/2025
registered at P.S. Telibandha under Sections 296, 115(2), 351(2),
3(5) IPC against Petitioner Rohit Singh Tomar Acting on this
communication, a search warrant was obtained, and a search was
carried out on 03.06.2025, where certain documents were allegedly
seized. On the same day, FIR No. 230/2025 was registered against
the petitioners. Statements of three witnesses-Shri Jaideep
Banerjee, Shri Manish Sahu, and Shri Nasir Bakhsh were recorded,
alleging that the petitioners used signed cheques and stamp papers
as security for loans, and thereafter allegedly coerced persons to
repay with exorbitant interest or transfer undervalued land. Based
solely on these allegations, the Investigating OfÏcer sought issuance
of coercive process. On 04.07.2025, the Learned Magistrate issued
a non-bailable warrant against the petitioners and directed them to
appear before the Court. Thereafter the Learned Magistrate passed
the impugned proclamation order dated 14.07.2025 under Section
84 BNSS and the petitioners were directed to appear on 18.08.2025,
the Learned Magistrate hurriedly passed the impugned order dated
13.08.2025 initiating proceedings for attachment under Section 85
BNSS-five days before the appearance date exhibiting clear
arbitrariness and misuse of judicial power.
3. Learned Sr. counsel for the petitioners submitted that the impugned
orders dated 14.07.2025 and 13.08.2025 passed by the Learned
Judicial Magistrate First Class are contrary to the provisions of
Sections 84 and 85 of the BNSS, inasmuch as no "reasons to
believe" were recorded regarding the petitioners having absconded
or concealing themselves, which is a mandatory precondition for
issuing
proclamation
proceedings.
or
initiating
attachment
proceedings. The Learned Judicial Magistrate First Class acted
mechanically and without due application of judicial mind, by passing
the impugned orders solely on the plea of the Investigating OfÏcer,
without examining the case diary, documents, or evidence to arrive
at a subjective satisfaction as required under law.
4. Learned Sr. counsel for the petitioners further submitted that the
proclamation order dated 14.07.2025 in perfunctory and nonspeaking, consisting merely of recitals of facts, without fulfilling the
mandatory requirements of Section 84 BNSS, which requires
publication of a proclamation allowing not less than 30 days' time for
appearance, supported by recorded satisfaction. The order dated
13.08.2025 initiating attachment proceedings under Section 85
BNSS is also arbitrary, mala fide, and violative of the statutory
mandate, inasmuch as the preconditions of Section 84 BNSS were
not satisfied and no valid proclamation was issued before
proceeding to attachment. The impugned orders infringe the
fundamental rights of the petitioners guaranteed under Article 21 of
the Constitution of India, being arbitrary, illegal, and passed in
violation of the principles of natural justice. In support of his
contention, learned counsel for the petitioners placed his reliance
upon a decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State through
C.B.I. v. Dawood Ibrahim Kakkar, (2000) 10 SCC 438 whereby it
has categorically been held that issuance of warrants and
subsequent proceedings must be based on proper judicial
discretion, recording of satisfaction, and not on the mere asking of
the Investigating Agency. The impugned orders suffer from complete
non-compliance with this settled law.
5. Sr. Counsel further submitted that the impugned orders suffer from
complete non-application of mind, an held to be impermissible in
Pankaj Singh v. State of U.P., 2022 SCC Online All 1542, wherein
it was categorically observed: A bland assertion that the accused is
"evading arrest" is not sufÏcient; The Magistrate must explicitly
record (i) dates when notice was issued, (ii) whether the accused
was aware of proceedings, (iii) materials establishing absconding. In
the present case, the impugned proclamation order is a stereotyped,
nine-line extract containing no reasons, no dates, no satisfaction,
and no discussion of record.
6. Moreover, Section 84 BNSS (analogous to Section 82 Cr.P.C. )
mandates that the Magistrate must record reasons to believe that: a
warrant has been issued, the person has absconded or concealed
himself, the warrant cannot be executed, as held in Pankaj Singh
(supra), that "It is a mandatory duty of the court to record how and
when the person absconded or concealed himself... Unless such
subjective satisfaction is recorded, Section 82 CrPC (now Section
84 BNSS) cannot be invoked." In the present case: No such
reasons have been recorded, No date is mentioned when service
was attempted, No material is referred from case diary, No
satisfaction is recorded that warrant could not be executed. This
renders the entire proclamation order void ab initio. Moreover,
Section 85 BNSS (analogous to Section 83 Cr.P.C.) can be
invoked only after a legal and valid proclamation under Section 84.
Since the proclamation itself is invalid, the attachment order
automatically collapses. Section 82/84 orders must be strictly
construed as they affect liberty and property; Orders under the
attachment provision cannot survive if the foundational proclamation
is illegal. Thus the impugned attachment order dated 13.08.2025 is
illegal. Further the Learned Magistrate passed the attachment order
on 13.08.2025 when the petitioners were required to appear on
18.08.2025, itself establishes: arbitrariness, lack of judicial fairness,
pre-determined mind, undue influence of police. This precise
conduct of passing coercive orders in haste has been strongly
deprecated in Pankaj Singh (supra). The impugned orders deprive
liberty and property, without due process, without satisfaction,
without reasons, contrary to statutory safeguards. This is violative of
the settled law that "procedure established by law must be just, fair,
and reasonable.
7. Sr. Counsel placed a reliance upon a decision of Hon’ble Allahabhad
High Court in the matter of Pankaj Singh V. State of U.P. 2022
SCC Online All 1542 held as under:8. Having considered submissions advanced
by learned counsel for parties and upon
perusal of material on record, it appears that
initially an application was filed by the
investigating
bailable
ofÏcer
warrant
for
issuance
against
the
of
non
petitioner
whereafter non bailable warrants were issued
and subsequently the order impugned has
been passed under section 82 Cr. P.C. It is
not denied that the petitioner was initially not
named in the first information report.
9. From a perusal of the impugned order, it
appears that the court concerned has passed
orders under section 82 Cr.P. after examining
the case diary and upon the plea raised by the
investigating ofÏcer regarding non cooperation
of petitioner in the investigations being carried
out. However it is also evident that a number of
accused have been named in the first
information report but only a general allegation
has been recorded in the order impugned with
regard to non cooperation in the investigation
proceedings. The court concerned has not
bothered to indicate on which dates the
petitioner was made aware with regard to
issuance of any letter by the investigating
ofÏcer
for
seeking
cooperation
in
the
investigation or even the date on which the non
bailable
warrant
was
served
upon
the
petitioner. There is only a bland assertion
recorded in the impugned order that the
petitioner is evading arrest.
10.
Section
Cr.
P.C.
pertains
to
proclamation for person absconding and for
provisions of attachment. It clearly states that
the court has to record a reason to believe if
any person against whom a warrant has been
issued by it has absconded or is concealing
himself so that such warrant can not be
executed then such court may publish a written
proclamation requiring him to appear at
specified place and at a specified time not less
than 30 days from the date of publishing such
proclamation.
11. Upon perusal of provision of Section 82
Cr. P.C., it is evident that prior to issuance of
any order under the said provision, the court
has to record a reason that the person against
whom
warrant
has
been
issued
has
specifically absconded or has concealed
himself so that such a warrant can not be
executed. As such from reading of the
aforesaid provision, it is a mandatory duty cast
upon the court concerned to record as to how
and
when
the
person
concerned
has
absconded or has concealed himself so that
the warrant can not be executed. For such
purpose, it is the duty of the court concerned
to indicate that the person was aware of the
proceedings against him particularly also the
investigation being conducted against him.
Unless and until such a subjective satisfaction
is recorded by the court concerned, provisions
of Section 82 Cr. P.C. can not be invoked by
the court concerned.
12. In the case of Dawood Ibrahim (supra),
Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
has
referred
to
provisions of section 73 which may be read in
the context of Section 82 Cr. P.C. in the
following manner:"24. Now that we have found that Section 73
of the Code is of general application and that
in course of the investigation a Court can issue
a warrant in exercise of power thereunder to
apprehend, inter alia, a person who is accused
of a non-bailable offence and is evading arrest,
we need answer the related question as to
whether such issuance of warrant can be for
his production before the police in aid of
investigation. It cannot be gainsaid that a
Magistrate plays, not infrequently, a role during
investigation, in that, on the prayer of the
Investigating
Agency
he
holds
a
test
identification parade, records the confession of
an accused or the statement of a witness, or
takes or witnesses the taking of specimen
handwritings etc. However, in performing such
or similar functions the Magistrate does not
exercise judicial discretion like while dealing
with an accused of a non-bailable offence who
is produced before him pursuant to a warrant
of arrest issued under Section 73. On such
production, the Court may either release him
on bail under Section 439 or authorise his
detention in custody (either police or judicial)
under Section 167 of the Code. Whether the
Magistrate,
on
being
moved
by
the
Investigating Agency, will entertain its prayer
for police custody will be at his sole discretion
which has to be judicially exercised in
accordance with Section 167(3) of the Code.
Since warrant is and can be issued for
appearance before the Court only and not
before the police and since authorization for
detention in police custody is neither to be
given as a matter of course nor on the mere
asking of the police, but only after exercise of
judicial discretion based on materials placed
before him, Mr. Desai was not absolutely right
in his submission that warrant of arrest under
Section 73 of the Code could be issued by the
courts solely for the production of the accused
before the police in aid of investigation."
13. The aforesaid judgment clearly indicates
that for exercise of powers by the magistrate
concerned, orders are not to be passed as a
matter of course on a mere asking of police
but only after exercise of judicial discretion
based
on
material
placed
before
him
particularly since provisions of Section 82 Cr.
P.C. are stringent in nature and may entail loss
of liberty and property.
14. In the present case, merely a bland
advertment to the case diary would not be
enough, the court has a bounden duty to
indicate the factors for which it has reason to
believe
that
the
person
concerned
has
absconded or is not cooperating for the
purposes of service of warrant. Such a
procedure is compulsorily required to be
undertaken by the court concerned in view of
the provisions of Section 82 Cr. P.C.
15. Learned counsel for petitioner has also
referred to judgment of this Court in the case
of Kunwar Mahendra Pratap Singh (supra) with
the submission that prior to issuance of any
order under Section 82 Cr. P.C., it is
compulsory
that
the
magistrate
should
consider the application of the investigating
ofÏcer which should be supported by afÏdavit
stating the reasons why non bailable warrant
and proclamation under Section 82 Cr. P.C. is
required since the issue relates to personal
liberty of a person guaranteed under Article 21
of the Constitution of India.
16. Upon perusal of the aforesaid judgment,
juxtaposed with the provisions of Section 82
Cr. P.C., it is the considered opinion of this
Court that submission of an afÏdavit by the
investigating ofÏcer at the time of making of
application for issuance of process under
Section 82 Cr. P.C. can not be a mandatory
provision. There is no such provision under
Section 82 Cr. P.C. requiring the investigating
ofÏcer to submit an afÏdavit along with the
application. Such a provision may be required
when orders are being passed simultaneously
under Sections 82 and 83 Cr. P.C., but can not
be considered to be mandatory at the time of
consideration of an application filed only under
section 82 Cr. P.C. It is trite that casus
omissus can not be supplied by the court
particularly when there is no confusion with
regard to the provisions of statute. As such and
also upon reading of the judgment of this
Court in the case of Kunwar Mahendra Pratap
Singh (supra), it is evident that the requirement
of afÏdavit to be filed by the investigating ofÏcer
while seeking an application for issuance of
proceedings under Section 82 Cr. P.C. is
merely directory and not mandatory and may
be insisted upon the court concerned in
specific cases for reasons to be recorded.
17. Considering the aforesaid factors, it is
evident that the impugned orders not being in
consonance with the provisions of Section 82
Cr.P.C.
are
therefore
unsustainable.
Consequently the impugned orders dated 31st
August, 2021 and 15th September, 2021
passed passed by Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Pratapgarh with regard to case crime No. 407
of 2020 under Sections 147, 148, 149, 307
and 302 IPC in Police Station Kotwali Nagar,
District Pratapgarh quashed and resultantly the
petition is a allowed. Liberty however is
granted to the court concerned for passing
fresh orders in case it is necessary to do so
but only in accordance with provisions of
Section 82 Cr. P.C. as indicated herein
above."
8. Lastly, Learned Sr. Counsel submitted that the Learned Judicial
Magistrate First Class has acted in a wholly arbitrary, illegal, and
mala fide manner by passing the impugned orders, directing
attachment of the petitioners' property, despite the fact that the
petitioners were already directed to appear on 18.08.2025, therefore
he prays to quash and set aside the impugned order dated
14.07.2025 passed by the Learned Judicial Magistrate First Class,
Raipur, whereby a proclamation under Section 84 BNSS has been
issued against the petitioners, being illegal, arbitrary, and contrary to
law; and also prays to auash and set aside the impugned order
dated 13.08.2025 passed by the Learned Judicial Magistrate First
Class, Raipur, whereby proceedings under Section 85 BNSS for
attachment of property have been initiated against the petitioners,
being illegal, arbitrary, and without jurisdiction and also prays for
quashment of Impugned Non-bailable warrant dated 04.07.2025
against the petitioner without specifying the reason to believe and
directed them to appear before the Court which is bad in law.
9. Per contra, learned State counsel submitted that against the
petitioners Crime No. 230/2025 registered at Police Station Purani
Basti, Raipur, District Raipur (CG) for the offence punishable under
sections 308(2), 111 of BNS and section 4 of Chhattisgarh
Protection of Debtors Act, 1937 against the petitioner and other coaccused persons. During investigation of the Crime it has been
surfaced that against the present petitioners various crimes have
been registered within the Police Station Saraswati Nagar, Gudiyari,
Tikrapara, Devendra Nagar, Kotwali, Purani Basti, Kabir Nagar
District Raipur. The details of which are as under:The petitioner No. 1Virendra Singh Tomar has 12 criminal antecedents
S.
N
o.
Crime / FIR
No. & Year
Police
Station
Sections Invoked
Status / Remarks
130/2006
Sections 307, 324,
147, 148, 149, 34
Saraswati
IPC and Sections
Nagar, Raipur
25, 27 of the
Arms Act
111/2010
Gudiyari,
Raipur
Charge-sheet filed; Criminal
Sections 294, 323, Case No. 102/2010
506-B, 34 IPC
registered before the
competent Court.
189/2013
Tikrapara,
Raipur
Charge-sheet filed; Criminal
Section 302 IPC
Case No. 543/2013
and Sections 25,
registered before the
27 of the Arms Act
competent Court.
181/2016
Purani Basti,
Raipur
Sections 294, 323,
—
506, 34 IPC
288/2017
Purani Basti,
Raipur
Sections 294, 506,
—
34 IPC
134/2019
Devendra
Sections 384, 34
Nagar, Raipur IPC
—
178/2019
Purani Basti,
Raipur
Sections 420, 34
IPC
—
215/2019
Kotwali,
Raipur
Sections 327, 384,
—
506-B, 34 IPC
216/2019
Kotwali,
Raipur
Sections 384, 327,
294, 323, 506-B,
—
34 IPC
Kabir Nagar,
Raipur
Sections 384, 34
IPC
10 124/2019
Charge-sheet filed; Criminal
Case No. 3653/2006
registered before the
competent Court.
—
S.
N
o.
Crime / FIR
No. & Year
11 229/2025
12 230/2025
Police
Station
Sections Invoked
Purani Basti,
Raipur
Section 25 of the
Arms Act
Purani Basti,
Raipur
Sections 308(2),
111(1) of BNS and
Section 4 of the
Chhattisgarh
—
Protection of
Depositors’ Interest
Act, 2005
Status / Remarks
—
The petitioner -Rohit Singh Tomar has 16 criminal antecedents, the
particulars of which are mentioned as under.
S. Crime No.
Police Station Sections Invoked Current Status / Remarks
No.
/ Year
189/2015
Kotwali, Raipur
Charge-sheet filed vide
Sections 376, 294, Challan No. 194/15 dated
506, 377 IPC
23.08.2015; Criminal Case
No. 14318/2015 registered.
302/2016
Kotwali, Raipur
Charge-sheet filed vide
Sections 323, 506, Challan No. 266/16 dated
34 IPC
17.12.2016; Criminal Case
No. 23613/2016 registered.
288/2017
Purani Basti,
Raipur
Sections 294, 506,
—
34 IPC
56/2018
Rajendra Nagar, Sections 294, 323, Charge-sheet filed (details
Raipur
506, 34 IPC
mentioned above in chart).
121/2018
Purani Basti,
Raipur
Sections 386, 507
IPC
Kotwali, Raipur
Charge-sheet filed vide
Sections 327, 384, Challan No. 178/19 dated
506-B, 34 IPC
14.06.2019; Criminal Case
No. 5967/2019 registered.
216/2019
Kotwali, Raipur
Charge-sheet filed vide
Sections 384, 327,
Challan No. 181/19 dated
323, 294, 506-B,
19.06.2019; Criminal Case
34 IPC
No. 6115/2019 registered.
124/2019
Kabir Nagar,
Raipur
Sections 384, 34
IPC
134/2019
Devendra
Nagar, Raipur
Sections 384, 34
IPC
215/2019
Charge-sheet filed vide
Challan No. 75/18 dated
27.05.2018; Criminal Case
No. 3044/2018 registered.
Charge-sheet filed vide
Challan No. 194/15 dated
23.08.2015; (also referred
above).
Charge-sheet filed vide
Challan No. 155/19 dated
30.11.2019; Criminal Case
No. 12808/2019 registered.
(Earlier Case No.
S. Crime No.
Police Station Sections Invoked Current Status / Remarks
No.
/ Year
14318/2015 also registered.)
154/2023
Purani Basti,
Raipur
Sections 294, 323,
—
506 IPC
93/2024
Telibandha,
Raipur
Charge-sheet filed vide
Sections 427, 307, Challan No. 144/24 dated
34 IPC
31.03.2024; Criminal Case
No. 6832/2024 registered.
332/2025
Telibandha,
Raipur
Sections 296,
115(2), 351(2)
BNS
—
Purani Basti,
Raipur
Sections 308(2),
111(1) BNS and
Section 4 of the
Chhattisgarh
Protection of
Debtors Act, 1937
—
—
230/2025
231/2025
Purani Basti,
Raipur
Sections 308(2),
111(1) BNS and
Section 4 of the
Chhattisgarh
Protection of
Debtors Act, 1937
253/2025
Purani Basti,
Raipur
Sections 294, 506,
—
34 IPC
Purani Basti,
Raipur
Sections 384, 506,
34 IPC and Section
4 of the
—
Chhattisgarh
Protection of
Debtors Act, 1937
264/2025
10. The learned State counsel submitted further that after registration of
the present crime the statement of the witnesses were recorded
under section 180 of the BNSS and at their instance articles have
been seized from the house of the applicant from Divyansh Tomar,
Jaideep Banjerjee, Neha Tomar @ Subhra Singh Tomar, Jitendra
Dewangan, Banti Sahare, Rajiv Pandey, Bhawna Singh Tomar,
Rajeshwar Rao, Nishant Joshi and further a statement Panchanama
was also recorded. On being recovery of the articles the whereabouts
of the present petitioners are being searched but despite best efforts
and search and seizure the applicants could not be traced and at
present the investigation is going on and after due investigation the
police will file appropriate charge sheet before the Court having
competent jurisdiction. During investigation information in respect to
possession of Arms license has been sought from the District
Magistrate, Raipur District Raipur (CG) vide letter dated 04/06/2025
by the SHO, Police Station Purani Basti District Raipur (CG). Upon
which it has been informed by the OfÏce of District Magistrate, Raipur
through the Additional District Magistrate that the arms liceses issued
in favour of the present petitioner and brother of the petitioner Rohit
Tomar has been cancelled in the year 2013 on account of the
involvement of the petitioners in criminal activities.
11. The State Counsel further submitted that the present petitioners are
absconding and despite best efforts their whereabouts are not traced
and therefore the Sr. Superintendent of Police, District Raipur vide its
order dated 26/06/2025 made a declaration for giving reward of
Rs.5000/- if any information in respect to the present petitioners are
provided by the individual. Thereafter the Court of Learned Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Raipur vide its order dated 04/07/2025 issued
arrest warrant against the present petitioners and to submit the report
whether served or unserved before the Court below upto to
14/07/2025. The police after issuance of the arrest warrant against
the present petitioners tried their level best in searching the
whereabouts of the petitioners but could not be traced and the arrest
warrant as has been issued by the Learned Court below could not be
executed and accordingly vide letter dated 14/07/2025 the warrant as
has been issued by the Hon'ble Court has been deposited before the
Court below, as unserved and further a request has been made by
the Station House OfÏcer, Police Station Purani Basti, Raipur to issue
a proclamation order as per the provisions of section 84 of the BNSS,
2023 against the petitioners. The Court of Learned Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Raipur, as per the provisions of section 84 of
the BNSS, 2023 satisfying himself passed the proclamation order
dated 14/07/2025 wherein it has been directed to produce the
present petitioners before the Court below on or before 18/08/2025.
12. The State counsel further submitted that after issuance of the
proclamation order against the present petitioners police deployed
their informers and further reward has also been issued in respect to
providing information pertaining to the petitioners and police are
trying their level best but the accused persons could not be traced
and therefore the Deputy Inspector General of Police and Senior
Superintendent of Police after identified the immovable properties of
the petitioners had moved an application before the Court of Learned
Judicial Magistrate First Class, Raipur on 13/08/2025 for initiating
proceedings under section 85 of the BNSS for attachment of the
property of the petitioners in Crime No. 230/2025. The Learned Court
of 3rd Civil Jude, Senior Grade, Raipur District Raipur vide its memo
dated 13/08/2025 directed the District Magistrate District Raipur to
initiate the Kurki/RRC proceedings in respect to the immovable
property of the absconded accused persons/petitioners in respect to
Crime No. 230/2025 registered at Police Station Purani Basti, Raipur.
13. It is respectfully submitted by the State Counsel that during
pendency of the present case the present petitioner No.1/Virendra
Singh Tomar has been arrested on 09/11/2025 from Gwalior (MP)
and was produced before the Court of Learned Judicial Magistrate
First Class, Raipur and after obtaining police remand and judicial
remand the petitioner is languishing in jail. It is thus clear that the
respondents have initiated the proceedings against the petitioners
strictly in accordance with law and the BNSS Act, 2023 and thus the
instant petition deserves to be dismissed.
14. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available on record.
15. The record reveals that after registration of Crime No. 230/2025, repeated
efforts were made by the investigating agency to secure the presence of
the petitioners, including execution of search, seizure, recording of
statements of witnesses and issuance of non-bailable warrants. Despite
such efforts, the petitioners could not be traced and the warrants remained
unexecuted. The material placed by the State clearly indicates that the
petitioners were deliberately evading arrest. The report of the Station
House OfÏcer regarding non-execution of the warrants, the declaration of
reward for information about the petitioners, and the continued failure to
secure their presence constitute sufÏcient material for the learned Judicial
Magistrate First Class to arrive at a prima facie satisfaction that the
petitioners had absconded or were concealing themselves. In such
circumstances, the issuance of proclamation under Section 84 of the
BNSS cannot be said to be mechanical or without jurisdiction.
16. As regards the contention that the learned Magistrate did not record
“reasons to believe” in detail, this Court is of the opinion that the learned
Judicial Magistrate First Class acted within the four corners of Sections 84
and 85 of the BNSS. The proclamation order was preceded by issuance of
non-bailable warrant and a report regarding its non-execution. The
attachment proceedings were initiated only to ensure the presence of the
accused. Mere absence of elaborate reasoning in the impugned orders
does not render them illegal when the satisfaction of the Court is clearly
evident from the record as a whole. The submission that the attachment
order was passed five days prior to the date fixed for appearance, by itself,
does not vitiate the proceedings, particularly in view of the overwhelming
material showing persistent abscondence of the petitioners and the
necessity to prevent frustration of the process of law.
17. The submission of the petitioners that the impugned orders were passed
mechanically and in violation of Article 21 of the Constitution cannot be
accepted. The material on record discloses persistent evasion by the
petitioners, coupled with their extensive criminal antecedents, which
justified the adoption of coercive measures. The reliance placed by learned
senior counsel for the petitioners in the matters of Pankaj Singh v. State
of U.P. (supra) and State through CBI v. Dawood Ibrahim Kaskar
(supra) does not advance the case of the petitioners, as the facts of the
present case clearly demonstrate due application of judicial mind and
existence of material forming the basis of the impugned orders.
18. Moreover, during the pendency of the present petition, petitioner No.1 –
Virendra Singh Tomar has been arrested on 09.11.2025 and produced
before the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Raipur, whereafter he
was remanded to police/judicial custody. In view of the said subsequent
development, the primary grievance of the petitioners regarding
proclamation, non-bailable warrant and attachment proceedings no longer
survives, and the relief sought has lost its efÏcacy.
19. Once the petitioner No.1 Virendra Singh Tomar has been apprehended
and is in custody, the challenge to the proclamation and attachment
proceedings, which were essentially coercive measures to secure his
presence, has become academic in nature. No effective or live relief can
now be granted in the present petition.
20. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the petition is devoid of merit and, in any case, has
become infructuous due to the subsequent arrest of petitioner No.1.
21. Accordingly, the petition stands dismissed on merits as well as on the
ground of infructuousness. No order as to costs.
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
Judge
Jyoti
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review