The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. This Court further notices that the 2nd respondent has placed reliance on Ext.P18 Government Order (G.O.(P) No.199/2014/Fin. dated 29.05.2014) while issuing Ext.P17 communication. In this connection, it is to be noticed that the provisions of Section 16(5) prior to the Amendment in 2019 provided for extending the term of office and conditions of the service of the State Chief Information Commissioner in the manner provided therein. The Government Order at Ext.P18 referred to above seeks to depart from the provisions of the statute as noticed above. The Apex Court in Dr. Rajinder Singh v. State of Punjab and Others [(2001) 5 SCC 482] has laid down that “no government order, notification or a circular can be a substitute of the statutory rules framed with the authority of law.” To the same effect is the judgment in State of Jharkhand and Others v. Jitendra Kumar Srivastava and Another [(2013) 12 SCC 210], wherein the Apex Court has laid down that pension is not a bounty and therefore, in the nature of “property” which cannot be taken away without due process of W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023 2025:KER:30868 law. Therefore, I am of the opinion that Ext.P18 Government Order also requires to be set aside and I do so.
15. On the whole, I am of the opinion that the petitioner is entitled to succeed. Resultantly, this writ petition would stand allowed by quashing Exts.P14 and P17 communications issued by the 2nd respondent as well as the Government Order, G.O.(P) No.199/2014/Fin. dated 29.05.2014. There will be a direction to the respondents to extend the retirement benefits to the petitioner in tune with the provisions of Section 16(5) of the Act as it existed prior to the amendment in 2019, read along with the provisions of Ext.P2 Act as discussed above. Sd/HARISANKAR V.MENON, JUDGE ln W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023 2025:KER:30868 PETITIONER’S EXHIBITS: EXHIBIT P1 A TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION G.O(MS) NO.60/2016/GAD 28-04-2016 EXHIBIT P2 ELECTION COMMISSION (CONDITIONS OF SERVICE OF BUSINESS) ACT, 1991 EXHIBIT P3 5/2/2013/CIC/ADMN DATED 09-04-2018 OF THE SECRETARY, COMMISSION, NEW DELHI EXHIBIT P4 A NO.193/1/201(I) DATED 19-03-2021 OF THE SENIOR PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,, ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA, NEW DELHI EXHIBIT P5 A 5/2/2013/CIC/ADMN DATED 31-03-2021 OF THE JOINT SECRETARY (ADMN), CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION, NEW DELHI EXHIBIT P6 SUPREME COURT JUDGES RULES, 1959 RETRIEVED FROM THE WEBSITE: WWW.COURTKUTCHEHRY.COM EXHIBIT P7 A TRUE COPY OF THE G.O.(MS) NO.377/2008/GAD DATED 09-12-2008 ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT EXHIBIT P8 PENSION PAYMENT ORDER NO. 111621713 DATED 0401-2016 ISSUED TO THE PETITIO…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE HARISANKAR V. MENON
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 29933 OF 2023
PETITIONER:
VINSON M. PAUL, AGED 68 YEARS,
STATE CHIEF INFORMATION COMMISSIONER OF THE
KERALA STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION (RETIRED),
S/O.THE LATE M.M.PAUL, RESIDING AT 12-A, KAMALA GARDENS,
PEROORKADA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695005.
BY ADVS.
H.VISHNUDAS
O.V.RADHAKRISHNAN (SR.)
GEORGE VARGHESE
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY ITS CHIEF SECRETARY,
SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695001.
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
GENERAL ADMINISTRATION (CO-ORDINATION) DEPARTMENT,
GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695001.
BY SRI.E.G.GORDEN, SENIOR GOVERNMENT PLEADER
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 07.04.2025,
THE COURT ON 10.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
“CR”
JUDGMENT
The petitioner, who retired as the State Chief Information
Commissioner, has filed the captioned writ petition seeking to
challenge
Exts.P14
and
P17
communications
of
the
2nd
respondent, by which he is denied the post-retirement benefits
claimed by him.
2. The petitioner, a member of Indian Police Service, retired
on 22.11.2015. He was appointed as the State Chief Information
Commissioner
as
evidenced
by
Ext.P1
notification
dated
28.04.2016. He demitted the office on 22.11.2020 on attaining
the age of 65 years. In connection with his retirement, the 2nd
respondent was requested to determine the post-retirement
benefits through Ext.P13 communication of the Secretary to the
State Information Commission, Kerala. By Ext.P14, the 2nd
respondent informed that the Government is not in a position to
consider “the Chief Information Commissioners at par with
retired
Supreme
Court
Judges
and
the
retired
Election
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
Commissioners”. It is further found that such benefits could not
be extended to one class of officers, that the Central Government
admitted the Election Commission of India and Central/State
Information Commission are different, etc. Therefore, the
retirement benefits sought for by Ext.P13 was not extended to
the petitioner.
By Ext.P17 communication dated 12.07.2021,
the same stand is repeated, further holding that the pension can
only be fixed as per the provisions of G.O.(P) No.199/2014/Fin.
dated 29.05.2014 produced along with the writ petition as
Ext.P18.
3. It is in the afore circumstances that the captioned writ
petition is filed by the petitioner.
4. I have heard Sri.O.V. Radhakrishnan, the learned senior
counsel for the petitioner and Sri.E.G.Gorden, the learned Senior
Government Pleader for the respondents.
5. Sri.Radhakrishnan, the learned senior counsel, would
contend that:
i.
The petitioner is appointed as the State Chief Information
Commissioner with reference to the provisions of Section
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
16 of the Right to Information Act, 2005 (for short, the
‘Act’). Sub-section (5) makes it clear that a State Chief
Information Commissioner is entitled for the salary and
allowances as well as the terms of office and conditions of
service as applicable to that of an Election Commission.
ii.
With reference to the above, he contends that under the
provisions of the Election Commission (Conditions of
Service of Election Commissioners and Transaction of
Business) Act, 1991 (Ext.P2 Act), under Section 3, the
salary of the Chief Election Commissioner is equal to the
salary of a Judge of the Supreme Court. Similarly, under
Section
6(2),
the
pension
of
the
Chief
Election
Commissioner is equal to the pension payable to a Judge
of the Supreme Court. In the light of the afore, it is his
contention that the petitioner was also entitled for similar
treatment.
iii.
He would rely on Ext.P7 Government Order dated
09.12.2008, to contend that the petitioner was entitled to
pension/retirement benefits as noticed above.
iv.
With reference to the provisions of the Right to Information
(Amendment) Act, 2019, (for short, the “Amendment Act”)
relied on in the impugned communication, he would
contend that insofar the petitioner was appointed earlier to
the afore amendment, he would be entitled to be
governed under the unamended provisions.
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
6. Per contra, Sri.Gorden, the learned Senior Government
Pleader, would contend that:
i.
The petitioner is not entitled to the afore benefits, in view
of Ext.P18 Government Order dated 29.05.2014.
ii.
The benefits available, if any, are only those admitted in
the counter affidavit.
7. I have considered the rival submissions as well as the
connected records.
8. The short issue arising for consideration in this writ
petition is the entitlement of the petitioner for the retirement
benefits as applicable to the Election Commission, as contended
by him. It is not in dispute that the petitioner is appointed as
the State Chief Information Commissioner under the provisions
of the Act. Chapter IV to the Act provides for the State
Information Commission. Section 16 thereunder provides for the
“term of office and conditions of service” of the State Chief
Information
Commissioner.
Sub-section
(5)
categorically
provides as under:
“(5) The salaries and allowances payable to and other terms and
conditions of service of-
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
(a) the State Chief Information Commissioner shall be
the
same as that of an Election Commissioner;
(b) the State Information Commissioner shall be the same as
that of the Chief Secretary to the State Government.”
Thus, the salary/allowances, as well as the terms and conditions
of service of the State Chief Information Commissioner, shall be
the same as that of the Election Commissioner.
Ext.P2 Act
provides for the determination of conditions of service of the
Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners.
Section 3 thereto provides that the salary payable to the Chief
Election Commissioner shall be equal to the salary of a Judge of
the Supreme Court. As regards pension, Section 6(2) provides
as under:
“(2) Where the Chief Election Commissioner or an Election
Commissioner demits office whether in any manner specified in
sub-section (3) or by resignation, he shall, on such demission be
entitled to (a) a pension which is equal to the pension payable to a Judge
of the Supreme Court in accordance with the provisions of
Part III of the Schedule to the Supreme Court Judges
(Conditions of Service) Act, 1958 (41 of 1958), as amended
from time to time; and
(b) such pension including commutation of pension, family
pension and gratuity as are admissible to a Judge of the
Supreme Court under the said Act and the rules made
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
thereunder, as amended from time to time.”
Thus, the Chief Election Commissioner/Election Commissioner is
entitled to the pension payable to a Judge of the Supreme Court.
Therefore, the petitioner is justified in contending that since he
retired as the State Chief Information Commissioner, by virtue of
the provisions of Section 16(5)(a) of the Act read along with the
provisions of Section 6(2) of Ext.P2 Act, he was entitled to the
pension payable to a Judge of the Supreme Court.
9.
This
Court
further
notices
that
even
the
State
Government when it issued Ext.P7 Government Order dated
09.12.2008 has found that “the State Chief Information
Commissioner would be entitled to avail pension and postretirement benefits as are admissible to a Judge of the Supreme
Court”.
10. True, Act came to be amended pursuant to the
Amendment Act, 2019 whereby Section 16(5) stood substituted
as under:
“(5) The salaries and allowances payable to and other terms and
conditions of service of the State Chief Information Commissioner
and the State Information Commissioners shall be such as may be
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
prescribed by the Central Government;
Provided that the salaries, allowances and other conditions of service
of the State Chief Information Commissioner and the State
Information Commissioners shall not be varied to their disadvantage
after their appointment;
Provided further that the State Chief Information Commissioner and
the
State
Information
Commissioners
appointed
before
the
commencement of the Right to Information (Amendment) Act, 2019
shall continue to be governed by the provisions of this Act and the
rules made thereunder as if the Right to Information (Amendment)
Act, 2019 had not come into force.”
A reading of the afore sub-section as amended would show that
the salary and allowances payable to the State Chief Information
Commissioner shall be as such as may be prescribed by the
Central Government.
However, the first proviso thereto has
provided that the conditions of service of the State Chief
Information Commissioner is not to be varied to his disadvantage
after the initial appointment. Similarly, the second proviso has
laid down that those State Chief Information Commissioners who
have
been
appointed
Amendment Act,
before
the
shall continue
unamended provisions.
commencement
of
the
to be governed by the
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
11. In this connection, it is to be noticed that the petitioner,
as seen from Ext.P1, came to be appointed as the State Chief
Information Commissioner on 28.04.2016. Therefore, he is
entitled to the protection extended by both the provisos to the
amended sub-section as noticed above.
12. When that be so, I am of the opinion that the petitioner
is entitled to the benefits as prayed for. The impugned
communication at Ext.P14 seeks to place reliance on the
Amendment Act without noticing the impact of the first and
second provisos to Section 16(5). To the above extent, Exts.P14
and P17 requires to be set aside.
13. This Court further notices the averments contained in
paragraph 6 of the counter affidavit filed by the 2nd respondent
herein, as per which, the petitioner being the retired State Chief
Information Commissioner, would also be entitled for the medical
facilities, residential telephone/mobile charges, orderly charges
and domestic help facilities.
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
14. This Court further notices that the 2nd respondent has
placed
reliance
on
Ext.P18
Government
Order
(G.O.(P)
No.199/2014/Fin. dated 29.05.2014) while issuing Ext.P17
communication. In this connection, it is to be noticed that the
provisions of Section 16(5) prior to the Amendment in 2019
provided for extending the term of office and conditions of the
service of the State Chief Information Commissioner in the
manner provided therein. The Government Order at Ext.P18
referred to above seeks to depart from the provisions of the
statute as noticed above. The Apex Court in Dr. Rajinder Singh
v. State of Punjab and Others [(2001) 5 SCC 482] has laid
down that “no government order, notification or a circular can be
a substitute of the statutory rules framed with the authority of
law.” To the same effect is the judgment in State of Jharkhand
and Others v. Jitendra Kumar Srivastava and Another
[(2013) 12 SCC 210], wherein the Apex Court has laid down
that pension is not a bounty and therefore, in the nature of
“property” which cannot be taken away without due process of
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
law. Therefore, I am of the opinion that Ext.P18 Government
Order also requires to be set aside and I do so.
15. On the whole, I am of the opinion that the petitioner is
entitled to succeed.
Resultantly, this writ petition would stand allowed by
quashing Exts.P14 and P17 communications issued by the 2nd
respondent
as
well
as
the
Government
Order,
G.O.(P)
No.199/2014/Fin. dated 29.05.2014. There will be a direction to
the respondents to extend the retirement benefits to the
petitioner in tune with the provisions of Section 16(5) of the Act
as it existed prior to the amendment in 2019, read along with
the provisions of Ext.P2 Act as discussed above.
Sd/HARISANKAR V.MENON, JUDGE
ln
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 29933/2023
PETITIONER’S EXHIBITS:
EXHIBIT P1
A TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION G.O(MS)
NO.60/2016/GAD
DATED
28-04-2016
OF
THE
SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT
EXHIBIT P2
A TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF THE
ELECTION COMMISSION (CONDITIONS OF SERVICE OF
ELECTION COMMISSIONERS AND TRANSACTION OF
BUSINESS) ACT, 1991
EXHIBIT P3
A TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE MEMORANDUM NO.
5/2/2013/CIC/ADMN DATED 09-04-2018 OF THE
JOINT
SECRETARY,
CENTRAL
INFORMATION
COMMISSION, NEW DELHI
EXHIBIT P4
A
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
OFFICE
MEMORANDUM
NO.193/1/201(I) DATED 19-03-2021 OF THE SENIOR
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,, ELECTION COMMISSION OF
INDIA, NEW DELHI
EXHIBIT P5
A
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
FILE
NO.
5/2/2013/CIC/ADMN DATED 31-03-2021 OF THE
JOINT SECRETARY (ADMN), CENTRAL INFORMATION
COMMISSION, NEW DELHI
EXHIBIT P6
A TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF THE
SUPREME COURT JUDGES RULES, 1959 RETRIEVED FROM
THE WEBSITE: WWW.COURTKUTCHEHRY.COM
EXHIBIT P7
A TRUE COPY OF THE G.O.(MS) NO.377/2008/GAD
DATED 09-12-2008 ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P8
A TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES OF THE
PENSION PAYMENT ORDER NO. 111621713 DATED 0401-2016 ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER
EXHIBIT P9
A TRUE COPY OF THE RIGHT TO INFORMATION
(AMENDMENT) ACT, 2019 OF THE SECRETARY,
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA.
EXHIBIT P10
A TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION DATED 24-102019 PUBLISHED IN THE GAZETTE OF INDIA,
EXTRAORDINARY DATED 24-10-2019 OF THE ADDL.
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL,
GRIEVANCES AND PENSIONS, NEW DELHI.
PUBLIC
EXHIBIT P11
A TRUE COPY OF THE RIGHT TO INFORMATION (TERM
OF OFFICE, SALARIES, ALLOWANCES AND OTHER TERMS
AND CONDITIONS OF SERVICE OF CHIEF INFORMATION
COMMISSIONER, INFORMATION COMMISSIONERS IN THE
CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION, STATE CHIEF
INFORMATION COMMISSIONER AND STATE INFORMATION
COMMISSIONERS
IN
THE
STATE
INFORMATION
COMMISSION)
RULES,
2019ADDL.
SECRETARY,
MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL, PUBLIC GRIEVANCES AND
PENSIONS, NEW DELHI.
EXHIBIT P12
A TRUE COPY OF THE SUPREME COURT JUDGES
(AMENDMENT)
RULES,
2021,
OF
THE
JOINT
SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF LAW AND JUSTICE, NEW
DELHI.
EXHIBIT P13
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.8486/G8ADMN/2020/SIC
DATED
14-09-2020
OF
THE
SECRETARY TO THE COMMISSION, STATE INFORMATION
COMMISSION, KERALA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
EXHIBIT P14
A
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
REPLY
LETTER
NO.53/CDN.5/2020/DAD DATED 12-04-2021 OF THE
2ND RESPONDENT.
EXHIBIT P15
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED 21-042021 OF THE PETITIONER TO THE 2ND RESPONDENT
EXHIBIT P16
A
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
FORWARDING
LETTER
NO.6297/G8-ADMIN/2018/SIC DATED 01-06-2021 OF
THE COMMISSION SECRETARY, STATE INFORMATION
COMMISSION, KERALA.
EXHIBIT P17
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.33/CDN.5/2021/GAD
DATED
12-07-2021
OF
THE
2ND
RESPONDENT
ADDRESSED TO THE SECRETARY, STATE INFORMATION
COMMISSIONER, GOVERNMENT OF KERALA.
EXHIBIT P18
A TRUE COPY OF THE G.O.(P) NO. 199/2014/FIN.
DATED 29-05-2014 OF THE JOINT SECRETARY
(FINANCE) TO GOVERNMENT.
EXHIBIT P19
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.360-PAR(GENL.)/G8P103/2017(PT.I)
DATED
06-05-2021
OF
THE
W.P(C) No.29933 of 2023
2025:KER:30868
ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF
WEST BENGAL.
EXHIBIT P20
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 07-01-2022 OF
THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF
PUNJAB.
EXHIBIT P21
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED 2-122022 OF THE PETITIONER TO THE CHIEF SECRETARY,
GOVERNMENT OF KERALA.
EXHIBIT P22
A TRUE COPY OF THE HIGH COURT AND SUPREME COURT
JUDGES (SALARIES AND CONDITIONS OF SERVICE)
AMENDMENT ACT,2018 (ACT NO.10 OF 2018) GAZETTE
NOTIFICATION DATED 27-01-2018.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review