Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:27067
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 6042 of 2024
Reserved on 28.4.2026
Delivered on 02.07.2026
Vinod Singh Thakur S/o Shri Rajendra Singh Thakur Aged About 35
Years By Occupation - Bus Operator, R/o Radha Krishna Ward No. 20,
Kawardha, District Kabirdham Chhattisgarh.
--- Petitioner(s)
SHYNA
AJAY
Digitally signed
by SHYNA AJAY
Date: 2026.07.03
15:01:40 +0530
versus
1 - The State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, Transport
Department,
Government
Of
Chhattisgarh,
Mantralaya,
Raipur
Chhattisgarh.
2 - Regional Transport Authority Of Chhattisgarh Atal Nagar, Nava
Raipur Chhattisgarh.
3 - New Jeevan Bus Service Through its Proprietor Akash Deep Singh,
R/o New Bus Stand Pandri, Raipur Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPC No. 6154 of 2024
Vinod Singh Thakur S/o Shri Rajendra Singh Thakur, Aged About 35
Years, By Occupation Bus Operator, R/o Radha Krishna Ward No. 20,
Kawardha, District Kabirdham Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - The State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, Transport
Department,
Government
Of
Chhattisgarh,
Mantralaya,
Raipur
Chhattisgarh.
2 - Regional Transport Authority Of Chhattisgarh Atal Nagar, Nava
Raipur Chhattisgarh.
3 - New Jeevan Bus Service Through its Proprietor Akash Deep Singh,
R/o New Bus Stand Pandri, Raipur Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPC No. 6036 of 2024
Vinod Singh Thakur S/o Shri Rajendra Singh Thakur, Aged About 35
Years, By Occupation-Bus Operator, R/o - Radha Krishna Ward No. 20,
Kawardha, District - Kabirdham, Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - The State Of Chhattisgarh, Through Secretary, Transport
Department, Government of Chhattisgarh, Mantralaya, Raipur (CG)
2 - Regional Transport Authority of Chhattisgarh, Atal Nagar, Nava
Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3 - Rajesh Dewangan S/o Shri Ramadhin Dewangan By OccupationBus Operator, R/o-Ward No. 13, Near Jain Temple, Simga, District Baloda Bazar - Bhatapara, Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
WPC No. 6049 of 2024
Vinod Singh Thakur S/o Shri Rajendra Singh Thakur, Aged About 35
Years By Occupation - Bus Operator, R/o Radha Krishna Ward No. 20,
Kawardha, District - Kabirdham, Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - The State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, Transport
Department,
Government
Of
Chhattisgarh,
Mantralaya,
Raipur,
Chhattisgarh.
2 - Regional Transport Authority Of Chhattisgarh, Atal Nagar, Nava
Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
3 - Rajesh Dewangan S/o Shri Ramadhin Dewangan By OccupationBus Operator, R/o Ward No. 13, Near Jain Temple, Simga, District Baloda Bazar, Chhattisgarh.
--- Respondent(s)
(Cause Title downloaded from CIS Periphery)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Subodh Pandey, Advocate
For Respondent 1 : Mr, Soumitra Kesharwani, Panel Lawyer
&2
For Respondent
No.3
: Mr. Birjesh Kumar Dubey, Advocate through
VC
SB: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
C A V Order
1. All these captioned petitions have been filed by the petitioner – a
bus owner, who has applied for grant of stage carriage permit(s)
by filing an application under Section 70 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 (in short “the Act”).
2. The petitioner applied for stage carriage permits with
different
timetables for the route from Raipur to Kawardha via Simga and
Bemetara. Though the number of buses varied, but the stage
carriage permit was sought for a single unified route i.e. Raipur to
Kawardha. As a result, four permits were granted to the petitioner
vide order(s) dated 18.4.2023 passed by the RTA, Raipur. This
order(s) was challenged by the respective private respondents
(respondent No.3 in each of the petitions) by way of four separate
revisions.
The said revisions were allowed by the impugned
order(s) dated 25.10.2024 on the sole, common ground that a
stage carriage permit cannot be granted for three termini.
Aggrieved by the said impugned order(s), the petitioner has
preferred four separate Writ Petitions i.e WPC No.6042/2024,
WPC No.6036/2024, WPC No.6049/2024 an WPC No.6154/2024.
Since a common seminal question of law arises for determination
in all of the Writ Petitions, they were clubbed together, heard
analogously and are being disposed of by this common order.
3. For the sake of convenience, WPC No.6042/2024 is being treated
as the lead case and the facts of the said petition are being
referred to for the purpose of adjudication. The decision rendered
herein, shall, however, govern the connected Writ Petitions as
well. In WPC No.6042/2024, the petitioner has prayed for the
following reliefs:
i. The Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to issue a
writ of certiorari quashing/setting aside the impugned
order dated 25/10/2024 (Annex.-P/6) passed by
learned Tribunal.
ii. Any other reliefs which this Hon'ble Court deem fit in
the circumstances of the case, may also be granted to
the Petitioner together with the cost of this writ petition.
4. The petitioner seeks permit to operate three daily return trips
(rounds) from Raipur to Kawardha via Simga and Bemetara. The
petitioner contends that he owns three buses for operation on the
aforesaid route bearing registration Nos.CG 09 JF 8201 and CG
09 JF 8199. Further, he keeps a vehicle (bus) in reserve for
operations on the aforesaid route. The petitioner has sought a
permit for an “Express Bus Service” and has submitted the
proposed timings along with his application. It is the case of the
petitioner that on the first day of the week (Monday), he will
commence plying the bus from Raipur to Kawardha. On Tuesday,
the departure would be from Kawardha to Raipur. Likewise, on
Wednesday, the bus will depart from Raipur and on Thursday, it
will depart from Kawardha to Raipur. Again, on Friday, the bus will
depart from Raipur to Kawardha and on Saturday, it will depart
from Kawardha to Raipur. Since the buses operate only between
Raipur and Kawardha and vice versa, there is no question of any
third terminus route. After considering the application filed by the
petitioner, objections were invited from other bus operators to
ensure
their
interests
would
not
be
adversely
affected.
Accordingly, after considering the objections filed by the objectors,
including respondent No.3 herein, the Regional Transport
Authority (in short “the RTA”), Raipur granted permit to the
petitioner to ply his buses in accordance with the schedule
specified in the order dated 18.4.2023.
5. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order, respondent No.3 preferred
Revision before the
a
Chhattisgarh State Transport Appellate
Tribunal (STAT). The respondent contended that granting the
permit to the petitioner for the Kawardha-Raipur route would
illegally create a third terminus. Since the bus would remain
stationed at Kawardha on Tuesday and Thursday nights, it
operates as a third terminus, which is
impermissible under a
stage carriage permit. Hence, the respondent contended that the
concerned RTA committed illegality in granting the said permit.
Ultimately, the STAT allowed the Revision Petition vide its order
dated 25.10.2024, holding that the timetable provided in the
permit did not operate simply from one terminal to another.
Instead, due to the night halting of the bus for 2-3 days i.e.
Tuesdays and Thursdays, it effectively created a third terminus.
As such, the STAT ruled that the stage carriage permit could not
be granted, as it violates the provisions of the Act and Motor
Vehicle Rules. Being aggrieved by the said order dated
25.10.2024, the petitioner has filed the present petition(s).
6. Mr. Subhodh Pandey, learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that the finding
recorded by the STAT holding that the bus
remaining stationed at Kawardha for the entire night on Tuesdays
and Thursdays creates a ‘third terminus’ is contrary to law. He
submits that a ‘third terminus’ refers to the unauthorized creation
of an additional stoppage for which no permit has been granted.
In the present case, the subject vehicle operates as an express
bus, originating from Raipur and terminating at Kawardha, without
stopping at any intermediate stations/stops. He further submits
that the finding recorded by the STAT regarding creation of a third
terminus is totally incorrect and unsustainable. He submits that
though the bus will remain stationed at Kawardha every two days
i.e. on Tuesdays and Thursdays, but this cannot be termed as
creation of a third terminus, as the vehicle does not proceed to
any other destination from Kawardha and is plied only on the
same route from which it arrived. He lastly submits that the finding
recorded by the STAT is not in accordance with law and is liable
to be set-aside.
7. Conversely, Mr. Brijesh Kumar Dubey, learned counsel for
respondent No.3, would submit that the bus remaining stationed
overnight at Kawardha amounts to creation of a third terminus, as
the vehicle does not perform a return journey to Raipur on the
same day. Hence, a permit of this nature sanctions unauthorized
operation of an additional (third) terminus, which is impermissible.
He further submits that the RTA did not consider this aspect,
whereas, the STAT correctly appreciated it. He lastly submits that
the impugned order has been rightly passed, which does not
warrant any interference and the Petitions are liable to be
dismissed.
8. Mr. Soumitra Kesharwani, learned Panel Lawyer for the
State/Respondents 1 & 2 submits that being the statutory
authority, the concerned authority has rightly passed the
impugned order, which does not call for any interference.
9. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and also perused the
documents annexed with the petition with utmost circumspection.
10. The core moot question upon which the adjudication of these writ
petitions depends is whether the STAT was legally justified in
allowing the Revision(s) and in setting aside the regular stage
carriage permit granted by the RTA, Raipur, on the sole ground
that an overnight halt at a permitted destination creates an
impermissible ‘third terminus’ in violation of the Act and the Motor
Vehicle Rules framed thereunder? Thus, the entire controversy
restricts itself to the legal effect of an overnight halt at a terminus.
11. Admittedly, the petitioner applied for permits on the subject route
and was accordingly granted four permits with specific timings.
Under these permits, the petitioner’s buses are to operate three
times daily from Raipur to Kawardha and vice versa. Further, it is
undisputed that the concerned RTA invited objections from other
bus operators plying on the said route, which resulted in
objections from as many as six objectors. All such objections
relate to clash of timings sought by the petitioner and those of the
existing operators. The concerned RTA, after duly considering
these objections, granted the permits in favour of the petitioner.
However, these grants were subsequently set-aside after certain
objectors (respondent No.3 herein in each of the petitions)
preferred separate revisions before the STAT.
12. In this backdrop, in order to appreciate the arguments advanced
by the respective counsel on this pivotal issue, it would be apt to
consider Section 2(38) of the Act, which defines a ‘route’ and
forms the basis for determining what falls within the ambit of
‘terminus’. The said Section reads as under :
2(38) “route” means a line of travel which specifies the
highway which may be traversed by a motor vehicle
between one terminus and another;
13. Further, Section 70 of the Act reads as under :
70. Application for stage carriage permit.—(1) An
application for a permit in respect of a stage carriage (in
this Chapter referred to as a stage carriage permit) or as
a reserve stage carriage shall, as far as may be, contain
the following particulars, namely:—
(a) the route or routes or the area or areas to which the
application relates;
(b) the type and seating capacity of each such vehicle;
(c) the minimum and maximum number of daily trips
proposed to be provided and the time-table of the normal
trips.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this section, section
72, section 80 and section 102, “trip” means a single
journey from one point to another, and every return
journey shall be deemed to be a separate trip;
(d) the number of vehicles intended to be kept in reserve
to maintain the service and to provide for special
occasions;
(e) the arrangements intended to be made for the
housing, maintenance and repair of the vehicles, for the
comfort and convenience of passengers and for the
storage and safe custody of luggage;
(f) such other matters as may be prescribed.
(2) An application referred to in sub-section (1) shall be
accompanied by such documents as may be prescribed.
14. Similarly, Section 72 of the Act is also relevant, which reads as
under :
72. Grant of stage carriage permits.— (1) Subject to
the provisions of section 71, a Regional Transport
Authority may, on an application made to it under
section 70, grant a stage carriage permit in accordance
with the application or with such modifications as it
deems fit or refuse to grant such a permit:
Provided that no such permit shall be granted in respect
of any route or area not specified in the application.
(2) The Regional Transport Authority, if it decides to
grant a stage carriage permit, may grant the permit for a
stage carriage of a specified description and may,
subject to any rules that may be made under this Act,
attach to the permit any one or more of the following
conditions, namely:—
(i) that the vehicles shall be used only in a specified
area, or on a specified route or routes;
(ii) that the operation of the stage carriage shall be
commenced with effect from a specified date;
(iii) the minimum and maximum number of daily trips to
be provided in relation to any route or area generally or
on specified days and occasions;
(iv) that copies of the time-table of the stage carriage
approved by the Regional Transport Authority shall be
exhibited on the vehicles and at specified stands and
halts on the route or within the area;
(v) that the stage carriage shall be operated within such
margins of deviation from the approved time-table as
the Regional Transport Authority may from time to time
specify;
(vi) that within municipal limits and such other areas and
places as may be prescribed, passengers or goods
shall not be taken up or set down except at specified
points;
(vii) the maximum number of passengers and the
maximum weight of luggage that may be carried on the
stage carriage, either generally or on specified
occasions or at specified times and seasons;
(viii) the weight and nature of passengers’ luggage that
shall be carried free of charge, the total weight of
luggage that may be carried in relation to each
passenger, and the arrangements that shall be made for
the carriage of luggage without causing inconvenience
to passengers;
(ix) the rate of charge that may be levied for
passengers’ luggage in excess of the free allowance;
(x) that vehicles of a specified type fitted with body
conforming to approved specifications shall be used:
Provided that the attachment of this condition to a
permit shall not prevent the continued use, for a period
of two years from the date of publication of the
approved specifications, of any vehicle operating on that
date;
(xi) that specified standards of comfort and cleanliness
shall be maintained in the vehicles;
(xii)the conditions subject to which goods may be
carried in the stage carriage in addition to or to the
exclusion of passengers;
(xiii)that fares shall be charged in accordance with the
approved fare table;
(xiv)that a copy of, or extract from, the fare table
approved by the Regional Transport Authority and
particulars of any special fares or rates of fares so
approved for particular occasions shall be exhibited on
the stage carriage and at specified stands and halts;
(xv)that tickets bearing specified particulars shall be
issued to passengers and shall show the fares actually
charged and that records of tickets issued shall be kept
in a specified manner;
(xvi)that mails shall be carried on the vehicle subject to
such conditions (including conditions as to the time in
which mails are to be carried and the charges which
may be levied) as may be specified;
(xvii)the vehicles to be kept as reserve by the holder of
the permit to maintain the operation and to provide for
special occasions;
(xviii)the conditions subject to which the vehicle may be
used as a contract carriage;
(xix)that specified arrangements shall be made for the
housing, maintenance and repair of vehicle;
(xx)that any specified bus station or shelter maintained
by Government or a local authority shall be used and
that any specified rent or fee shall be paid for such use
;(xxi)that the conditions of the permit shall not be
departed from, save with the approval of the Regional
Transport Authority;
(xxii)that the Regional Transport Authority may, after
giving notice of not less than one month,
(a)vary the conditions of the permit;
(b)attach to the permit further conditions:
Provided that the conditions specified in pursuance of
clause (i) shall not be varied so as to alter the distance
covered by the original route by more than 24
kilometres, and any variation within such limits shall be
made only after the Regional Transport Authority is
satisfied that such variation will serve the convenience
of the public and that it is not expedient to grant a
separate permit in respect of the original route as so
varied or any part thereof;
(xxiii)that the holder of a permit shall furnish to the
Regional Transport Authority such periodical returns,
statistics and other information as the State
Government may from time to time prescribe;
(xxiv)any other conditions which may be prescribed
[Provided that the Regional Transport Authority may
waive any such condition for a stage carriage permit
operating in a rural area, as it deems fit.
15. Evidently, the petitioner has been granted a permit for buses
bearing registration Nos. Nos. CG09 JF 8201 and CG 09 JF
8199, having a total capacity of 35 seats (excluding two additional
seats). The permit was granted to ply the bus as an express
service from Raipur to Kawardha and vice versa via Simga,
Bemetara, for three single trips daily, under Sections 72 and 84 of
the Act read with Rules 77(1), (2) and (4), Rules 70A and 70B(4)
and Rule 30A of the Motor Vehicle Rules. While granting the
permit, a specific time slot was also assigned.
16. From a perusal of the record, it appears that the petitioner had
applied for the same route for two different timings to operate an
express service, which the RTA subsequently allowed while
assigning specific operational timings to each permit. Further, the
permit was granted for the period from 1/5/2023 to 30/4/2028.
Before granting the permit, adequate opportunity of hearing was
afforded to all concerned, including respondent No.3.
Being
aggrieved by the order dated 18.4.2023, granting stage carriage
permit for three single trips of the express bus service, respective
respondent No.3 preferred revision(s) before the STAT on
different grounds. Although the Tribunal afforded an opportunity of
hearing to the parties, it ultimately allowed the revision on the sole
ground that the route in question consisted of three termini,
holding that the permit could not be countenanced on this basis
alone. Accordingly, on this count, the stage carriage permit
granted to the petitioner for the express service from Raipur to
Kawardha was set aside.
17. A perusal of Section 2(38) of the Act, which has been reproduced
in para 12, makes it abundantly clear that ‘route’ means a line of
travel which specifies a highway to be traversed by a motor
vehicle from one terminus to another. A route, therefore, has only
two termini and this must be stated not only in the application for
grant of permit but also in the permit granted in favour of the
party.
18. While the Act defines ‘route’
as a line of travel between one
terminus and another, it does not define the term ‘highway’. ' The
Oxford Dictionary defines ‘highway’ as a ‘public road’ or a ‘main
route by land, sea or air’. Accordingly in this context, ‘highway’
would mean a public route upon which a motor vehicle is plied.
Therefore, on a plain reading of the definition, a ‘route’ is the line
of travel between two specific termini, and the public road
connecting those two termini constitutes the ‘highway’.
19. Here, in compliance with this provision, the petitioner was granted
a permit delineating only two termini. The Tribunal’s impugned
finding allowing the revision on the ground that the route involved
three termini is erroneous and contrary to the settled provisions of
law. There is absolutely nothing on record either in the application
of the petitioner or in the permit subsequently issued, to show
upon or even suggest the existence of three termini. In view
thereof, the finding of the STAT, predicated upon factual
misapprehension of ‘three termini’, is perverse and unsustainable
and liable to be set-aside.
20. In the matter of Prem Naraian Ramlal Sharma Vs. State
Transport Appellate Tribunal and others reported in 1999(1)
MPLJ 185, the Madhya Pradesh High Court also considered this
aspect, and observed the following in para 5 :
"5. The S.T.A.T. passed the order reversing the order
passed by the R.T.A. on a single ground, as mentioned
in para 8 of its judgment. It has been observed that in
the present case the permission was not granted in
accordance with the provisions of Section 2(38) of the
M.V. Act. Hence the permit in which there were three
termini , could not be granted. This is the sole ground
on which the revision petition was allowed. In this
connection, we have to go through the provisions of
Section 2(38), which defines 'route'. It runs as follows:
“ “route” means a line of travel which specifies the
highway which may be traversed by a motor vehicle
between one terminus and another.”
A route has two termini, it must be stated not only in
the application but also in the permit. If we peruse the
application (Annexure P/1), we find that the petitioner
has complied with this provision. In this way, the
observation of the S.T.A.T., on the basis of which the
revision was allowed, appears to be against the
provision of law and wholly erroneous. The order
passed on this basis must, therefore, be quashed."
21. In the matter of State of West Bengal Vs. S.K. Nural Amin
reported in (2010) 11 SCC 182, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
further considered the aspect of two termini and observed the
following in para 7 & 8 :
7. The Division Bench proceeded on the basis
that when one of the termini is altered by the
Authority, then the permit is not granted in
respect of the route applied, and it would
amount to granting a permit in respect of a route
not specified in the application. On a careful
consideration, we are of the view that the
interpretation by the High Court is without basis.
8. What is prohibited by the proviso to subsection (1) of Section 72 is granting of a permit
in respect of any route or area not specified in
the application. The said proviso does not
prohibit curtailment in regard to portion of the
route applied for, for any valid reason. In fact
sub-section
(1)
specifically
authorises
the
Authority to grant the stage carriage permit with
such modifications as it deems fit. Curtailment of
a route would be a modification as contemplated
under sub-section (1). We may clarify this by an
illustration where the application is made for
grant of a permit in regard to a route A to D
through points B and C. If the grant is made for
the route A to C through B, excluding the last
portion C to D, it will be a modification which is
contemplated and provided for under subsection (1) of Section 72 of the Act. On the other
hand, if the grant is made in regard to route E to
F or in regard to route A to E, the grant will be in
regard to a route not specified in the application
and consequently the permit will be violative of
the proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 72 of
the Act.
22. In the matter of Dharmendra Singh Yadav Vs. The State of
Madhya Pradesh and others (Writ Appeal No.2228 of 2024
decided on 22.4.2025, a Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh
High Court considered the aspect of a route compromising two
termini, while affirming the order passed by the Writ Court, and
held as under :
6. It was the submission of learned counsel for the
petitioner that as per provision of Section 68 (3) (ca)
and Section 72 of the M.V.Act without making the
application for route, authority can not grant permit.
In the present case, authority granted permit from
the diverted route (via Dabra bypass), which is away
from the original applied/formulated route for around
9 kms. Therefore, such permit on without formulated
route is not sustainable in the eyes of law
17. Perusal of the discussion made by the writ court
as
referred
above
is
very
exhaustive
and
conclusively decides the anxiety of both the parties.
Once route has been formulated and respondent
No.3
applied
for
said
routes
then
with
the
modification as per different provisions of M.V.Act
specially Section 72 and while taking note of the
judgment of the Apex Court in the case of State of
West Bangal and others Vs. S.K.Nurul Amin reported
in AIR 2010 SC 2271, no violation of Section 72 of
M.V.Act was found and rightly so because it can at
best be modification but not deviation from the route.
Authority has included all those stations, which were
lying between Ashoknagar to Gwalior and return
back. Stations which fall within the route from
Ashoknagar to Gwalior were included.
23.
Reverting to the facts of the case at hand, in light of the
aforesaid principles laid down in the aforesaid judgments, it is
quite vivid that the STAT allowed the revision solely on the ground
that the subject route comprised three termini. This finding
is
factually unsustainable, as the record clearly establishes that the
route from Raipur to Kawardha consists of only two termini.
24. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the opinion
that setting aside of the permit(s) on the ground of ‘three termini’
by the STAT is not in accordance with law. The finding of the
Tribunal in the
impugned order(s) to the effect that the route
consists of ‘three termini’ is contrary to the facts as well as the
provisions of the Act.
25. Resultantly, all the Writ Petitions are Allowed. The impugned
orders dated 25.10.2024 are hereby quashed. Consequently, the
stage carriage permits granted by the RTA, Raipur are held to be
valid and restored, with all consequential benefits flowing
therefrom.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Shyna Ajay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review