Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:The Hon’ble Justice Madhuresh Prasad
And
The Hon’ble Justice Prasenjit Biswas
W.P.S.T. 248 of 2025
With
CAN 1 of 2026
Sri Vinod Kumar
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Jaydip Kar, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Amitava Chaudhuri,
Mr. N. Roy,
Mr. Pradipta Siddhanta
For the State
: Mr. D. N. Ray, Ld. G.P.,
Mr. Guddu Singh,
Mrs. Sarda Sha
For the P.S.C., W.B.
: Ms. Shraboni Sarkar,
Ms. Umme Habiba Khatun
Judgment on
: 8th July, 2026
Madhuresh Prasad, J.:
1. Heard the learned senior advocate for the writ petitioner and the learned
G.P assisted by Mr. Guddu Singh, learned advocate appearing on behalf of
the State.
2. The
writ
petitioner
was
the
applicant
before
the
West
Bengal
Administrative Tribunal (for short ‘Tribunal’) in O.A. 602 of 2021. The
Tribunal declined to entertain the Original Application filed by the writ
petitioner by an order dated 04.09.2025 which is the subject matter of the
present writ petition.
3. The brief factual background starts from issuance of an advertisement in
the year 2009-2010 for appointment of Sub-Inspectors. The petitioner
participated in the recruitment process and was temporarily appointed on
16.01.2010. Upon his appointment the petitioner was required to undergo
training which comprises of written as well as physical curriculum.
Candidates were required to pass the training both in the written as well
as physical by securing an aggregate of 60 per cent marks and 50
(qualifying) marks in each of the subjects. The petitioner could not obtain
the qualifying marks in the swimming test.
4. Despite the petitioner not qualifying in the swimming test, his name was
published in the result of the final examination dated 11.02.2011. It was
mentioned in the result that he was declared to have passed the training
course and to pass out, but a resolution be taken directing the petitioner
to appear in the examination of the outdoor subjects in which he could
not secure the qualifying marks. The petitioner thereafter was declared to
be placed at serial no. 3 in the merit list of cadets published by the DIG at
the Police Training College, Barrackpore on 16.06.2011. This position
(serial no.3) was consequently reflected in an order no.238/CRO dated
06.07.2011 issued by the Joint Commissioner of Police, Head quarters
Kolkata. The fact is obvious from the order dated 06.07.2011, wherein at
the bottom of the order it is mentioned “This refers to Memo No.2061/RO
dated 16.06.2011 of DIG P.T.C BKP.”
5. Thereafter, the petitioner appeared for the supplementary swimming test
which he later qualified. The petitioner was thus declared to be finally
passed in the training. He was thereafter placed at serial no. 171 in the
gazette notification dated 11.02.2013, wherein the inter se position of the
cadets Sub-Inspectors/Sub-Inspectress of the petitioner’s batch was
published.
6. It is submitted by the learned senior advocate appearing on behalf of the
applicant/writ petitioner that petitioner had already been declared at
serial no. 3 in the merit list published by the Deputy Inspector General of
Police on 16.06.2011 and Commissioner of Police on 06.07.2011. The
declaration of his position at serial no. 3 was despite the fact that he had
initially not qualified in the swimming test. Such position was consciously
awarded to the petitioner and down grading of the same to serial No. 171
in the gazette notification dated 11.02.2013 could not be done, but by way
of a penalty.
7. The learned senior advocate took us through the provisions of the Police
Training College Manual, 1936 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the 1936
Manual’). Referring to Rule 63 he would submit that seniority of the
cadets/candidates was required to be fixed with reference to the date of
their posting on probation. The petitioner was posted on probation based
on final result dated 11.02.2011 by the Deputy Inspector General of
Police, Training, West Bengal and order dated 06.07.2011 issued by the
Commissioner of Police Kolkata wherein he was placed at serial No. 3.
Such determination of petitioner’s seniority was in accordance with
Clause 63 of the 1936 Manual. We,
therefore, consider it apposite to
reproduce Clause 63 of the 1936 Manual relied upon by the learned
Senior Counsel, which reads:
“63. The relative seniority of the cadets appointed
probationary sub-inspectors will be ordinarily in accordance
with the marks obtained in the final examination. This rule,
however, does not affect any subsequent order of the
degradation or stoppage of promotion or promotion by
selection or merit.”
8. The learned senior advocate submitted that being aggrieved by such down
grading of the petitioner’s seniority, contrary to the provisions contained
in the 1936 Manual, the petitioner earlier approached the Tribunal by
filing O.A. No. 274 of 2020. The same was disposed of directing the
competent authority to consider the petitioner’s claim. The order of the
Tribunal passed in the earlier Original Application is dated 18.11.2020.
Pursuant thereto the petitioner’s claim was considered by the Joint
Commissioner of Police and was rejected by an order dated 14.01.2021.
The same was put to challenge by the petitioner promptly by filing an O.A.
No. 602 of 2021.
9. The learned senior advocate, therefore, submits that the order of the
Tribunal rejecting the petitioner’s claim on the premise that the petitioner
had moved the Tribunal five and half years after the petitioner’s down
grading of the seniority is unsustainable. The order of the Joint
Commissioner was passed in the year 2021 in compliance of an order
passed by the Tribunal in O.A. No. 274 of 2020. Promptitude was not
lacking on the part of the petitioner in assailing this order. Therefore, the
reason assigned by the Tribunal that petitioner challenged downgrading of
his seniority by a representation after 5 and half years is unsustainable.
10.
He
submits
that
the
petitioner’s
claim
substantially
is
for
rectification of the mistake which occurred in the gazette notification
dated 11.02.2013. He, therefore, prayed for restoration of a seniority
earlier granted by the authorities as per the determination made by the
Deputy Inspector General of Police on 16.06.2011. Such rectification was
required to be done by the authorities so as to restore the petitioner’s
seniority (at serial 3), which was in terms of Clause 63 of the 1936
Manual. He, therefore, submits that this Court should set aside the order
of the Tribunal and direct for restoration of the petitioner’s seniority as
obtained on 11.02.2011.
11.
The learned advocate appearing for the State on the other hand
submitted that the order of the Tribunal insofar as it has considered the
petitioner’s approach belated, requires no interference. The rectification of
the petitioner’s seniority was done long back on 11.02.2013. The Original
Application was filed in the year 2021. While filing the Original
Application, the writ petitioner did not implead the persons whose
seniority was determined above him in the gazette notification dated
11.02.2013. It is submitted that the petitioner’s approach to the Tribunal
is, therefore, a belated approach. The Tribunal, therefore, rightly held the
same.
12.
It is further submitted by the learned advocate for the State that as
per Rule 57(c) of the 1936 Manual, the petitioner was required to pass the
swimming test before a final result could be issued declaring him passed.
Only thereafter the petitioner could be confirmed in service. The fact that
he was allowed to join on probation, therefore, does not vest any right in
the petitioner to claim a seniority, with effect from a date when he did not
even possess the requisite qualification for being declared finally passed.
The authorities have considered the petitioner’s claim with reference to
the rule and also taking into consideration the petitioner’s belated
challenge to the gazette notification. The same, therefore, did not require
any interference.
13.
In support of his submission that the petitioner’s approach to the
Tribunal was a belated approach, he placed reliance on the decision of a
Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of
Malcom Lawrence Cecil D’Souza –Vs.- Union of India and Others
reported in (1976) 1 SCC 599.
14.
A further submission is advanced that there is an inherent
jurisdiction or option in every administrative authority to rectify its own
mistakes, unless there is some specific provision of law which prohibits
such a course. No such prohibitory provision has been pointed out. In fact
a harmonious reading of Rule 57(c) and 63 leaves no ambiguity that the
petitioner could not be considered as having passed the requisite training
for confirmation in service. Till such time the petitioner did not possess
the requisite qualification of training passed, he continued to be a
probationer and, therefore, no right could be claimed in respect of the said
period.
15.
We have considered the rival submissions and the judgments cited
at the bar.
16.
The substantial claim of the petitioner is restoration of his seniority
as declared in the communication dated 16.06.2011 issued by the Deputy
Inspector
General
and
order
dated
06.07.2011
issued
by
the
Commissioner of Police, Kolkata. The petitioner claims that the gazette
notification of 11.02.2013 insofar as it is at variance with the earlier letter
dated 16.06.2011 and order dated 06.07.2011 is unsustainable.
17.
We find a basic fallacy in such claim of the writ petitioner for the
simple reason that the fixation of the petitioner’s seniority was in a merit
list of candidates published by the Deputy Inspector General of the Police
Training Centre. It is not in dispute that as on the date (16.06.2011) when
the said list was published, the petitioner did not possess the requisite
qualification of having 50% marks in each subject and 60% in aggregate
for being declared finally passed or contemplated in Rule 57(c) of the 1963
Manual. We also find that the initial result of the final examination
published by the DIG training contained a clear stipulation in the
following terms:
“They may be declared to have passed the training course
and to pass out. Resolution may be taken directing the Cadet
SI’s to appear in the examination of the Outdoor subjects in
which they could not secure the qualifying marks.”
18.
Therefore, there is no ambiguity regarding a fact that petitioner did
not possess the requisite marks for being declared finally passed in the
training curriculum. He was passed out with a stipulation for taking a
resolution directing the petitioner to appear in the examination in the
subject (swimming) in which he did not secure the qualifying marks.
19.
The merit list published by the DIG training on 16.06.2011 wherein
the petitioner has been shown at serial no.3 is based on the final result
dated 11.02.2011 wherein the petitioner was declared passed with a
condition that a resolution be taken requiring him to appear in the
examination of another subject in which he did not secure qualifying
marks.
The
consequent
order
dated
06.07.2011
issued
by
the
Commissioner is based on the merit list contained in the DIG letter dated
16.06.2011. The same is obvious from the footnote of the Commissioner’s
order. Both these lists (dated 16.06.2011 and 16.07.2011) failed to take
into consideration the fact that the petitioner had not been declared
finally passed in the ‘Result of Final Examination’ dated 11.02.2011.
Therefore, the two merit lists also failed to take into consideration the fact
that as per the initial result of the final examination dated 11.02.2011,
petitioner was required to appear in the examination for the subject
(swimming) in which he did not secure qualifying marks. This is obvious
from the note at the bottom of the final result dated 11.02.2011 extracted
above. This fact is apparent from a merit list of candidates published
thereafter on 03.11.2011 by the DIG training wherein the petitioner’s
name figures in a separate “List of Failed Cadet SIs (UB)KP of Batch
No.57/09-10.”
20.
Thereafter the petitioner qualified in the subject wherein he had
failed (swimming), when he was declared passed in the second
supplementary final examination by an order no.628 dated 29.05.2012.
Only after the petitioner qualified in the swimming test, he became eligible
for being declared passed as per Rule 57(c) of the 1936 Manual. After
being declared finally passed he became eligible for being placed in the
seniority list of sub-inspectors/sub-inspectress of the batch. Thus, he was
rightly placed in the merit list accordingly at serial 171 in the Kolkata
Police gazette publication dated 11.02.2013.
21.
From the several letters and orders considered above it is obvious
that the inadvertent error of placing the petitioner at serial 3, when he
had not even finally passed the training curriculum was rectified by the
merit list dated 03.11.2011 wherein the petitioner was shown in a list of
failed candidates. Thereafter, the petitioner participated in the second
supplementary final examination for clearing the subject (swimming) in
which earlier he had not qualified. Such conduct of the petitioner
demonstrates that he was well aware of the fact that he had not finally
passed the training curriculum and was required to pass the same for
being considered finally passed in terms of Rule 57(c) of the 1936 Manual.
If at all the petitioner was of an opinion otherwise, he would have
challenged the merit list contained in order no.1237 dated 03.11.2011
wherein his name was figuring in the list of failed cadets, which he did not
do.
22.
In view of our consideration above we find that there was no scope
for the petitioner to contend otherwise. The petitioner was not finally
passed and could not be permitted to take any advantage of his position
in the merit list contained in letter dated 16.06.2011 issued by the DIG or
the order dated 06.07.2011 issued by the Commissioner of Police.
23.
The order no.1237 was issued thereafter on 03.11.2011 showing
the petitioner as a failed candidate and the same was not objected to or
challenged by the petitioner. Thus, there was no occasion or basis for the
petitioner to place reliance on the earlier two letters dated 16.06.2011 and
06.07.2011 issued by the DIG and the Commissioner of Police. The order
dated 03.11.2011 rectified the erroneous position of the petitioner in the
merit list vide letter dated 16.06.2011 issued by the DIG and the order
dated 06.07.2011 issued by the Commissioner of Police. Therefore, there
is no basis for the petitioner to claim any benefit of the inadvertent
seniority indicated in the earlier two orders which stood rectified without
any objection from the petitioner by order no.1237 dated 03.11.2011. The
rectification, noticed above was also in accord with Rule 57(c) of the 1936
Manual.
24.
Insofar as the claim with reference to Rule 63 is concerned, a plain
reading of the same reveals that the relative seniority of the cadets who
are appointed on probation will be “….in accordance with the marks
obtained in the final examination….”. The determination of seniority,
therefore, is not dependent upon the posting of the cadet on probation,
but in accordance with the marks obtained in the final examination.
25.
It is not in dispute that the seniority published on 11.02.2013 is
based on the petitioner’s marks obtained in the final examination. The
claim of the petitioner, therefore, in our considered view is unsustainable
since the petitioner’s merit list position dated 16.06.2011 ceases to exist
on issuance of the order number 1237, on 03.11.2011. Therefore, a
submission
that
the
gazette
notification
dated
11.02.2013
was
unsustainable, is devoid of any substance.
26.
The submissions of the petitioner are founded on a position in the
earlier merit list which was an inadvertent error, which was duly rectified
without any demur from the petitioner. The petitioner cannot claim for
perpetuation of an obvious mistake, which was in violation of clause 57(c)
of 1936 Manual, and was required to be rectified. The same has rightly
been done by the authorities in the order dated 03.11.2011 bearing
no.1237; and the Kolkata Police Gazette publication dated 11.02.2013.
The petitioner therefore, is estopped from claiming any benefit based on
the merit list contained in the DIGs letter and the order of the
Commissioner, dated 16.06.2011 and 06.07.2011 respectively. Even
otherwise it is trite law that one cannot claim any right on the basis of a
mistake.
27.
Another issue raised by the learned G.P is the issue of delay. We
also find substance in such submission. We find that not only is there a
delay but there are latches also, since the petitioner never assailed the
merit list dated 03.11.2011. The petitioner approached the Tribunal for
the first time in 2020, about seven years after determination of the
petitioner’s seniority vis-à-vis the other candidates by the Gazette
publication dated 11.02.2013. The issue raised also concerns third party
rights being the seniority of about 170 candidates placed above him in the
Gazette notification dated 11.02.2013.
28.
Considering the above facts, we find substance in the submission of
the learned State Counsel that the petitioner’s approach to the Tribunal
was a belated approach. We, therefore, find force in reliance placed by the
learned State advocate on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
case of Malcom Lawrence Cecil D’Souza (supra).
29.
Insofar as the submission of the learned senior advocate that the
order of the Tribunal dated 18.11.2020 gave a fresh cause of action. We
find such submission to be unsustainable. It has been held by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in the case of Union of India & Ors. –Vs.- M. K.
Sarkar reported in 2010 (2) SCC 59 that for the purposes of delay and
latches the initial cause of action has to be considered and merely for the
fact that any Court or Tribunal has issued a direction for consideration of
the claim will not give rise to a fresh cause of action.
30.
Relevant extract of the judgment in the case of M. K. Sarkar
(supra) reads:
“15.When a belated representation in regard to a “stale” or
“dead” issue/dispute is considered and decided, in
compliance with a direction by the court/tribunal to do so, the
date of such decision cannot be considered as furnishing a
fresh cause of action for reviving the “dead” issue or timebarred dispute. The issue of limitation or delay and laches
should be considered with reference to the original cause of
action and not with reference to the date on which an order is
passed in compliance with a court’s direction. Neither a
court’s direction to consider a representation issued without
examining the merits, nor a decision given in compliance with
such direction, will extend the limitation, or erase the delay
and laches.”
31.
In view of our above consideration above, we find no reason to
interfere with the decision of the Tribunal dated 04.09.2025 passed in
O.A. No. 602 of 2021 impugned in the present writ petition, in exercise of
extraordinary and discretionary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
32.
The writ petition is dismissed.
33.
Pending application, if any, is also dismissed.
34.
Urgent certified copy of this order, if applied for, be given to the
parties upon compliance of all necessary formalities.
(Madhuresh Prasad, J.)
I agree.
(Prasenjit Biswas, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review