Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
Appellate Side
17.07.2026
S/L No. 05
Ct. No. 4
(Naba)
W.P.S.T. 4 of 2026
Smt. Kalyani Sarkar
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Biswarup Biswas,
Mr. Pradip Kumar Ghosh,
Ms. Nupur Choudhuri
...for the Petitioner
Ms. Chandreyi Alam, Ld. A.G.P.,
Ms. Runu Mukherjee
...for the State
1.
Heard
the
learned
advocates
representing
the
parties.
2.
The present writ petitioner was the applicant before
the West Bengal Administrative Tribunal (hereinafter
referred to as "the Tribunal") and had approached
the Tribunal by filing Original Application No. 276 of
2025,
assailing
the
action
of
the
respondent
authorities in denying her claim for compassionate
appointment.
Upon
consideration
of
the
rival
submissions and the materials placed on record, the
Tribunal, by its order dated 18th August, 2025,
dismissed the Original Application and declined to
grant
the
relief
sought
for
by
the
petitioner.
Aggrieved by the said order and being dissatisfied
with the findings recorded therein, the petitioner has
invoked
the
writ
jurisdiction
of
this
Court,
questioning the legality, propriety and correctness of
the order passed by the Tribunal.
3.
The foundational facts giving rise to the present lis
are not in dispute. The petitioner's husband was
serving
as
Halisahar,
an
Inspector
District-Nadia
of
Rationing
under
the
Office,
Food
and
Supplies Department, Government of West Bengal.
While in service, he unfortunately met with a fatal
road accident and died in harness on 21st January,
2016. His untimely demise left the petitioner and the
surviving members of the family in a state of acute
financial distress. It is the petitioner's case that
immediately after the death of her husband, she
approached
the
competent
authority
seeking
compassionate appointment with a view to mitigating
the sudden financial crisis faced by the bereaved
family.
4.
It appears from the records that the petitioner
submitted her claim for compassionate appointment
on 13th May, 2016, i.e., within about four months of
the demise of her husband. However, despite the
claim remaining under consideration for several
years, no final decision was taken by the authorities.
Ultimately,
the
Deputy
Director
of
Rationing,
Barrackpore, Food and Supplies Department, by
Memo No. 919/DDR/BKP/2023 dated 14th August,
2023,
rejected
aggrieved
by
the
petitioner's
claim.
such
rejection,
the
Being
petitioner
challenged the said order before the Tribunal.
5.
Learned
advocate
appearing
on
behalf
of
the
petitioner submits that the Tribunal, while dismissing
the Original Application, proceeded principally on the
premise that the petitioner had failed to submit her
application in the prescribed proforma within the
stipulated period and, therefore, was not entitled to
be
considered
for
compassionate
appointment.
According to the learned advocate, the Tribunal
failed to appreciate the true factual and legal position
governing the petitioner's claim.
6.
According to the
learned advocate, once
it
is
accepted that the petitioner's pending claim was
required to be considered under Notification No. 26Emp. dated 1st March, 2016, the controversy narrows
down to a singular issue, namely, whether the
respondent authority was justified in rejecting the
petitioner's claim solely on the ground that her
application had not been submitted in the prescribed
proforma. It is argued that such a technical objection
could not have been made the sole basis for denying
the
substantive
benefit
of
compassionate
appointment, particularly when the petitioner had
admittedly
approached
the
authorities
within
a
reasonable time after the death of her husband and
her
request
had
remained
pending
before
the
administration for several years.
7.
The learned advocate further submits that the issue
relating to rejection of a claim for compassionate
appointment
merely
on
the
ground
of
non-
submission of the prescribed proforma is no longer
open to debate, as the same has already been
authoritatively considered and decided by Coordinate
Benche of this Court. In this regard, reliance has
been placed upon the decisions rendered in Mrinal
Kanti Das versus The Joint Secretary, Public
Works Department (WB) & Others (W.P.S.T.
No. 36 of 2025) and Akash Ranjan Ray versus
The State of West Bengal & Others (W.P.S.T.
No. 147 of 2024). It is submitted that in the
aforesaid decisions, this Court held that where an
applicant had approached the competent authority
within the relevant period and the claim remained
pending, the authorities could not reject such claim
merely on the hyper-technical ground that the
application was not submitted in the prescribed
proforma,
particularly
when
the
otherwise
disclosed
the
intention
to
and
authorities
compassionate
appointment
applicant
the
had
seek
themselves had kept the matter pending without
requiring the defect, if any, to be rectified.
8.
Placing strong reliance upon the aforesaid decisions,
learned advocate for the petitioner submits that the
present case is squarely covered by the principles
laid down therein. It is, therefore, contended that the
order of the Tribunal as well as the order of rejection
passed by the Deputy Director of Rationing cannot be
sustained in law and deserves to be set aside.
9.
Accordingly, it is prayed that the writ petition be
allowed by following the ratio laid down in the
aforesaid
Coordinate
Bench
decisions
and
by
directing the respondent authorities to consider the
petitioner's claim for compassionate appointment in
accordance with Notification No. 26-Emp. dated 1st
March, 2016 and the settled principles of law
governing the field.
10. The
learned
appearing
on
Additional
Government
behalf
the
of
Pleader,
respondent-State
authorities, opposed the writ petition and supported
the order passed by the Tribunal as well as the
decision of the Deputy Director of Rationing rejecting
the
petitioner's
claim
for
compassionate
appointment.
11. It is contended by the learned A.G.P. that the
petitioner is not entitled to derive any benefit under
Clause 10(aa) of Notification No. 26-Emp. dated 1st
March, 2016, which specifically deals with cases of
"Belated Request" for compassionate appointment.
According to the learned A.G.P., the said provision
contemplates
that
a
request
appointment
must
be
made
for compassionate
in
the
prescribed
proforma and within the time frame stipulated
therein. It is submitted that mere submission of a
representation
or
an
application
expressing
an
intention to seek compassionate appointment would
not satisfy the mandatory requirements of the
scheme unless such application is made in the
prescribed format.
12. Developing the aforesaid submission, the learned
A.G.P. argues that although the petitioner had
approached the authorities after the death of her
husband, she failed to submit the application in the
prescribed proforma within the period of five years
contemplated under Notification No. 26-Emp. dated
1st March, 2016. According to the respondents,
compliance with the prescribed procedure is an
essential requirement for invoking the benefit of the
compassionate
appointment
scheme,
and
any
deviation there from disentitles an applicant from
claiming consideration under Clause 10(aa).
13. It is further submitted that the scheme governing
compassionate appointment is statutory in nature
and must be implemented strictly in accordance with
the conditions contained therein. The authorities,
therefore, were justified in insisting upon submission
of the application in the prescribed proforma within
the stipulated period. Since the petitioner failed to
fulfil this essential procedural requirement, her claim
was rightly rejected by the competent authority.
14. The
learned
A.G.P.
further
contends
that
the
Tribunal, upon examining the relevant records and
the provisions of Notification No. 26-Emp., rightly
concluded that the petitioner had not complied with
the mandatory requirements of the scheme. The
Tribunal, therefore, correctly declined to interfere
with the order passed by the Deputy Director of
Rationing and dismissed the Original Application.
According
to
the
learned
A.G.P.,
the
findings
recorded by the Tribunal are based on a proper
appreciation of the applicable notification and the
materials on record, and do not suffer from any legal
infirmity
or
jurisdictional
error
warranting
interference by this Court in exercise of its writ
jurisdiction.
15. We have given our anxious consideration to the rival
submissions advanced by the learned advocates
appearing for the respective parties.
16.
We have also carefully perused the pleadings, the
materials brought on record, the impugned order
passed by the Tribunal, the order of rejection issued
by the Deputy Director of Rationing, Barrackpore, as
well as the decisions relied upon by the learned
advocate for the petitioner.
17. At the outset, it deserves to be noticed that certain
foundational facts are undisputed. It is not in
controversy that the petitioner's husband died in
harness on 21st January, 2016 while serving under
the Food and Supplies Department. It is equally
undisputed that the petitioner, being the widow of
the deceased employee, approached the competent
authority
seeking
compassionate
appointment
immediately after the demise of her husband and
submitted her application on 13th May, 2016. Thus,
the intention of the petitioner to seek compassionate
appointment was made known to the authorities
within the prescribe time after the death of the
deceased employee. The petitioner's claim remained
pending with the authorities for a considerable period
before it ultimately came to be rejected by the
Deputy Director of Rationing, Barrackpore by Memo
No. 919/DDR/BKP/2023 dated 14th August, 2023.
18. The principal ground on which the petitioner's claim
has been rejected is that the application was not
submitted
in
the
prescribed
proforma.
In
our
considered opinion, such an issue is no longer resintegra. The question as to whether submission of an
application in the prescribed proforma is mandatory
so as to defeat an otherwise genuine claim for
compassionate
appointment
has
already
been
authoritatively considered by Coordinate Benches of
this Court in Mrinal Kanti Das and Akash Ranjan
Ray.
The
legal
principles
emerging
from
the
aforesaid decisions squarely govern the controversy
involved in the present case.
19. It would be apposite to reproduce paragraphs 22, 23
and 24 of the judgment rendered in Akash Ranjay
Ray (supra), wherein the Coordinate Bench observed
as follows:
“ 22. The Co-ordinate Bench held that once
an application is made within the requisite
time, completion of the requisite formalities
including
submission
of
proforma
was
required to be followed up by the authorities
under Clause 10(bb) of 26-Emp. by meeting
and assisting the family of the deceased
Government
employee
so
as
to
ensure
fulfillment of necessary formalities. The same
having not done, rejection on the ground of
non-submission
of
an
application
on
proforma was held to be unsustainable.
23. The Court considered the object and
scope
of
application,
submission
of
wherein
all
a
proforma
the
relevant
parameters were required to be filled up by
the applicant for facilitating a comprehensive
consideration
of
the
claim,
subsequently
submitted
by
which
the
was
present
petitioner. It is nobody’s case that the
authorities could not consider the petitioner’s
claim for want of any details. In fact perusal
of the report of the Three Men Screening
cum
Enquiry
petitioner’s
Committee
claim
was
reveals
that
considered
with
reference to the relevant parameters.
24.
Having
considered
the
object
and
purpose, the Co-ordinate Bench held that the
proforma application has significance at the
time of consideration of the claim and does
not have any relevance to the time frame for
making an application. Judgment of the Coordinate Bench is binding on this Court and
the petitioner’s claim is required to be
considered
in
view
compliance
with
of
the
the
law
Judgment
and
the
in
Co-
ordinate Bench in the case of Mrinal Kanti
Das (supra).”
20. The aforesaid observations unequivocally lay down
that once an applicant expresses his or her intention
to seek compassionate appointment by submitting an
application
within
the
prescribed
period,
the
obligation does not end with the applicant alone.
Clause 10(bb) of Notification No. 26-Emp. casts a
corresponding duty upon the competent authority to
extend necessary assistance to the bereaved family
in completing the procedural formalities, including
submission of the prescribed proforma. The object of
requiring
a
proforma
application
is
merely
to
facilitate a comprehensive assessment of the claim
by obtaining the necessary particulars from the
applicant. Such procedural requirement cannot be
elevated to a rigid or inflexible condition so as to
defeat the beneficial object underlying the scheme
for compassionate appointment.
21. In the present case, it is not the case of the
respondents that the petitioner's claim could not be
examined for want of necessary particulars or that
the authorities were handicapped in processing the
application owing to absence of the prescribed
proforma. On the contrary, the materials on record
demonstrate that the petitioner's claim remained
under active consideration for several years before
ultimately being rejected. The rejection is founded
solely upon a technical objection regarding the
prescribed proforma, without there being any finding
that the petitioner was otherwise ineligible or that
her claim suffered from any substantive deficiency.
22. The very purpose of a scheme for compassionate
appointment is to provide immediate succour to the
family of a Government employee who dies in
harness, leaving the dependants in financial distress.
Such a beneficial scheme ought to receive a liberal
and purposive construction rather than a narrow and
hyper-technical
interpretation.
Procedural
prescriptions are intended to facilitate the process of
consideration and not to frustrate the substantive
right of consideration itself. Once the petitioner had
approached the authorities within the relevant period
and the authorities permitted the matter to remain
pending without taking steps contemplated under
Clause 10(bb) of Notification No. 26-Emp., they
cannot subsequently reject the claim by attributing
the failure to submit the prescribed proforma solely
to the petitioner.
23. In view of the law laid down by the Coordinate
Benches in Mrinal Kanti Das (supra) and Akash
Ranjay Ray (supra), we are unable to sustain the
order of rejection dated 14th August, 2023 passed by
the
Deputy
Director
of
Rationing,
Barrackpore.
Consequently, the order dated 18th August, 2025
passed by the Tribunal in O.A. No. 276 of 2025,
affirming the said rejection, is equally unsustainable
in law, as the Tribunal failed to appreciate the settled
legal position governing the issue.
24. Accordingly, the communication dated 14th August,
2023 bearing Memo No. 919/DDR/BKP/2023 issued
by the Deputy Director of Rationing, Barrackpore,
Food and Supplies Department, is hereby quashed
and set aside.
25. The respondent authorities are directed to reconsider
the petitioner's claim for compassionate appointment
strictly in accordance with the principles laid down by
this Court and in the light of the observations made
hereinabove. While undertaking such exercise, the
authorities shall not reject or refuse consideration of
the
petitioner's
claim
on
the
ground
of
non-
submission or delayed submission of the prescribed
proforma application. The claim of the petitioner shall
be considered on its own merits, subject to her
satisfying the other eligibility criteria and fulfilling the
requisite conditions and formalities contemplated
under the applicable policy.
26. The respondent authorities shall complete the entire
exercise of reconsideration and take a reasoned
decision thereon. If the petitioner is found otherwise
eligible, all consequential benefits flowing from such
consideration shall also be extended to her. The
aforesaid
exercise
shall
be
concluded
as
expeditiously as possible, preferably within a period
of eight (08) weeks from the date of communication
or production of a copy of this order.
27. For the reasons recorded hereinabove, the order
dated 18th August, 2025 passed by the West Bengal
Administrative Tribunal in O.A. No. 276 of 2025
cannot be sustained and is, accordingly, set aside.
28. The writ petition, therefore, succeeds and is allowed
in the above terms. There shall, however, be no
order as to costs.
(Madhuresh Prasad, J.)
(Prasenjit Biswas, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review