Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010207052024
2026:GAU-AS:1377
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
WP(C) NO. 5227 OF 2024
Vinod Kumar Meena
S/o- Babu Lal Meena
Address for communication- 1st Battalion,
Railway Protection Special Force, Lumding,
Karbi Anglong, Assam, PIN- 782447.
…….Petitioner
-Versus1.
The Union of India, represented by the
Secretary to the Government of India,
Ministry of Railways, Rail Bhavan, Raisina
Road, New Delhi, Pin- 782447.
2.
The Railway Board, represented by its
Chairman, Rail Bhavan, Raisina Road, New
Delhi, Pin- 110001.
3.
The Director/SEC (ABE) Railway Board, Rail
Bhavan, Raisina Road, New Delhi, Pin110001.
4.
The Director General of Railway Protection
Force, Rail Bhavan, Raisina Road, New
Delhi, Pin0 110001.
5.
The Principal Chief Security Commissioner,
Northeast Frontier Railway, Maligaon,
Guwahati- 781001, Assam.
6.
The Commanding Officer, 1st Battalion
Railway Protection Special Force, Lumding,
Karbi Anglong, Assam, Pin- 782447.
7.
The Commanding Officer, B, 11th Battalion,
Railway Protection Special Force, Gaziabad,
Uttar Pradesh, Pin- 201001.
……. Respondents
–BEFORE–
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. I. Rafique, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Ms. B. Sharma, Central Government Counsel.
Date on which judgment
is reserved
: N/A.
Date of pronouncement
of judgment
: 02.02.2026.
Whether the pronouncement
is of the operative part
of the judgment ?
: N/A.
Whether the full judgment
has been pronounced
: Yes.
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. I. Rafique, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner. Also heard Ms. B. Sharma, learned CGC
appearing for the respondent.
2.
The petitioner who is serving as constable under the
administrative control of Northeast Frontier Railway, Maligaon,
calls into question the transfer order dated 19.09.2024
whereby he has been transferred from 1st Battalion Railway
Protection Special Force, Lumding, Karbi Anglong, Assam, to
11th Battalion of Railway Protection Special Force, Ghaziabad,
Uttar Pradesh.
3.
The challenge is primarily on the ground that the
impugned transfer, though styled as an administrative
transfer, is in substance a punitive transfer, issued without
affording the petitioner any opportunity of hearing and in
violation of principles of natural justice.
4.
Mr. I. Rafique, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner, submits that the impugned transfer order attributes
to the petitioner involvement in groupism, disobedience of
senior officers, and creation of indiscipline. The impugned
transfer order advises counselling and warns of serious
disciplinary action. These recitals make the impugned order
stigmatic. He further submits that the impugned transfer order
not being preceded by any show cause notice or enquiry, the
same is totally illegal, arbitrary, and discriminatory.
5.
Per contra, Ms. B. Sharma, learned CGC appearing for
the respondent, submits that the impugned transfer was
necessitated by administrative interest to restore discipline in
the unit, as several personnel, including the petitioner, were
allegedly
forming
groups
and
disturbing
institutional
functioning.
6.
I have given my due consideration to the arguments
advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the contending
parties and also perused the materials available on record.
7.
The short question for consideration is whether the
impugned transfer order is a bona fide administrative transfer
or a punitive transfer founded on allegations of misconduct.
8.
Although transfer is an incident of service, where
misconduct forms the foundation, the transfer assumes a
punitive character. In other words, when an order of transfer
carries stigma or is based on specific allegations or
imputations, it ceases to be a simple transfer and assumes the
character of panel action. The courts while exercising
extraordinary writ jurisdiction in the context of allegations of
transfer being punitive, are empowered to lift the veil and
examine the real nature of the transfer order. Reference in this
regard is made to the decision of the Apex Court in the case of
Somesh Tiwari -Vs- Union of India & Ors., reported in
(2009) 2 SCC 592, wherein the Apex Court has held that a
transfer founded on allegations of misconduct is punitive and
unsustainable without opportunity of hearing. The relevant
Paragraph of the aforesaid judgment reads as under: –
“16. Indisputably an order of transfer is an
administrative order. There cannot be any doubt
whatsoever that transfer, which is ordinarily an
incident of service should not be interfered with, save
in cases where inter alia mala fide on the part of the
authority is proved. Mala fide is of two kinds-one
malice in fact and the second malice in law. The order
in question would attract the principle of malice in law
as it was not based on any factor germane for passing
an order of transfer and based on an irrelevant ground
i.e. on the allegations made against the appellant in
the anonymous complaint. It is one thing to say that
the employer is entitled to pass an order of transfer in
administrative exigencies but it is another thing to say
that the order of transfer is passed by way of or in lieu
of punishment. When an order of transfer is passed in
lieu of punishment, the same is liable to be set aside
being wholly illegal.”
9.
Likewise, in N.K. Singh vs. Union of India and
Ors., reported in (1994) 6 SCC 98, the Apex Court has held
that transfer for a collateral purpose, such as avoiding
disciplinary proceedings, is open to judicial review. Keeping in
mind the aforesaid principles let me now turn to the impugned
transfer order dated 19.09.2024, which reads as under: –
“GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
MINISTRY OF RAILWAYS
(RAILWAY BOARD)
********
No. 2024/Sec (ABE)/TR-5/2
Delhi, dated: -19.09.2024
Commanding Officer,
IBN/RPSF/LMG.
Sub: Inter Battalion transfer of CT/Vinod Kumar Meena of
IBN/RPSF.
Ref: -IBN' letters Nos. 1 बीपन/गोप/मिमित/एस.ओ/2024/712 &
713 मिन ां क 07.09.2024 & 09.09.2024
********
Apropos
above,
CT/Vinod
Kumar
Meena,
UIN/01SF1522251 of IBN/RPSF is hereby transferred and
posted to 11BN/RPSF/GHZ on administrative ground.
Further, it is advised that he should be counselled not
to spread groupism and disaffection among force personnel.
If he continues with his activities, he would be taken up
strictly under extant D&AR rules. He should treat this
transfer as an opportunity to start afresh, break free from his
past legacy and improve his conduct.
Necessary action may be taken accordingly.
Signed by
Vijay Kumar
Director/Sec(ABE)
Railway Board.”
10.
Reading the impugned transfer order, it is apparent
that the order records allegations of groupism, indiscipline,
and
disaffection
among
force
personnel
and
advises
counselling and also warns of disciplinary action. These are not
neutral
administrative
grounds.
They
attribute
blame,
misconduct behavior on the part of the petitioner and cast
aspersions on his conduct.
11.
It further appears from the affidavit in opposition
filed by the respondents on 18.12.2024 that the impugned
transfer order had to be issued due to the highly indiscipline
behavior of the petitioner while he was posted in the 1st
Battalion. Relevant paragraphs of the affidavit-in-opposition
read as under: –
“7. That with regard to the statements made in
paragraphs 3 and 4 of the writ petition, the deponent
states that the Commanding Officer of the 4th
Battalion had sent a confidential report on August 6,
2023, to the Railway Board, highlighting misconduct of
the petitioner. The report highlighted that he was
involved in activities that undermined discipline and
fostered disaffection within the force. The petitioner
was indulged in to create casteism & groupism in the
Company. The petitioner allegedly made false
accusations against other staff members and exerted
undue pressure on the Company Commander to take
action based on these false allegations. This behavior
caused
significant
administrative
difficulties,
disrupting the smooth functioning of office operations,
mess management, and duty allocations within the
company.
Apart from that the petitioner misbehaved with
subordinate officers, created groupism, and made
baseless allegations against disciplined personnel,
disrupting the administration. Despite warnings, his
behavior did not improve. As a result, on August 22,
2023,
the
petitioner
was
transferred
from
4BN/RPSF/New Jalpaiguri to 1st Battalion in
Lumding, Assam. Moreover, the Sr. DSC/RPF of
Lunding, looking after the charge of 1st Battalion, has
sent confidential reports on September 7 and 9, 2024,
after visiting G Company, which was stationed at
Jiribam and Silchar. During a security conference, a
lack of discipline within the unit/Company was noted,
particularly with the petitioner. He was found involved
in factional activities and unnecessary discussions
that undermined the company's cohesion.
The petitioner had a history of misconduct,
including an assault incident during his previous
posting in the 4th Battalion, which led to his transfer.
More troubling, at the security conference, he made an
inflammatory statement, referencing a recent incident
where a fellow constable died by shooting himself,
which was seen as instigating and harmful to the
force's discipline.
Based on these concerns, the Sr. DSC
recommended petitioner's transfer to improve discipline
within the unit. Consequently, on September 19, 2024,
the petitioner was transferred from the 1st
Battalion/RPSF/Lumding to 11th Battalion in Garhara,
Bihar in the interest of administration and to ensure
the best standards of discipline and to prevent any
serious incident in the Force.
8. That with regard to the statements made in
paragraph 5 of the writ petition, the deponent states
that
the
petitioner
was
transferred
from
4BN/RPSF/NJP to 1BN/RPSF/LMG due to his
indiscipline activity vide letter dated 22/08/23
administration grounds. In this connection, he was
taken up for departmental action U/R-153 of RPF
Rules, 1987 for improving his behavior by competent
authority of 4BN/RPSF/NJP. He was punished for
such serious indiscipline activity as per RPF Rules,
1987 vide order dated 23/03/23. After posting in 'G'
Coy/1BN, there was no change in nature of the above
said petitioner. Despite repeated warning by Company
Commander "G" Coy/BN, he did not change his
behavior. Subsequently, the Sr. DSC/RPF/Lumding,
who was looking after the charge of CO/1BN,
submitted confidential reports dated 07/09/24 and
09/09/24. In his reports, he detailed his visit to 'G'
Coy/1BN, which was deployed at Jiribam and Silchar
outposts. During his visit, a security conference was
conducted, and it was observed that there was a
noticeable lack of discipline within the company.
Particularly concerning was the conduct of the
petitioner, he was found to be involved in factional
activities and unnecessary conversations that were
detrimental to the cohesion of the company. The
petitioner had a previous incident of assault while
serving in 4BN/RPSF/NJP, which had resulted his
transfer
to
1BN/RPSF/LMG
from
4BN
on
administrative grounds.
9. That with regard to the statements made in
paragraphs 6,7,8,9 and 10 of the writ petition, the
deponent while re-iterates and re-affirms the
statements made in the preceding paragraphs of the
instant affidavit states that the Sr. DSC/RPF/Lumding,
who was looking after the charge of CO/1BN, has sent
confidential reports dated 07/09/24 and 09/09/24. In
his reports, he detailed his visit to G Coy/1BN, which
was deployed at Jiribam and Silchar outposts. During
his visit, a security conference was conducted, and it
was observed that there was a noticeable lack of
discipline within the company. Particularly concerning
the conduct of the petitioner, he was found to be
involved in factional activities and unnecessary
conversations that were detrimental to the cohesion of
the company. The petitioner had a previous incident of
assault while serving in 4BN/RPSF/NJP, which had
resulted in his transfer to 1BN/RPSF/LMG on
administrative grounds.
More alarmingly, during the security conference,
the petitioner made an open statement referencing
extreme actions, similar to the tragic incident involving
CT Sanuj Panwar, who had died by shooting himself
on 02/09/24. This statement was seen as highly
instigating and damaging to the force's discipline.
In light of above observations, the Sr.
DSC/RPF/LMG recommended petitioner's transfer for
administrative reasons, believing that a change in the
environment could help prevent further issues within
the company. The recommendation was intended to
restore order and discipline within the unit as strict
discipline and good conduct is vital for smooth
functioning in Armed Force.
Consequently, the petitioner of 1BN/G Coy was
transferred from 1st Battalion/RPSF/Lumding, Assam
to 11BN/RPSF/Garhara (Bihar) on administrative
ground vide letter dated 19/09/24 The petitioner was
also advised to not to spread groupism and
disaffection among force personnel. If he continues
with his activities, he would be taken up strictly under
extant D&AR Rules. He should treat this transfer as an
opportunity to start afresh, break free from his past
legacy and improve his conduct. This will also remove
local entanglements and provide another opportunity to
the petitioner to start afresh. The order did not intend
to penalize him but to save his livelihood and career.
Had he been allowed to continue in his present post, in
all likelihood, he would have involved himself and
some of his colleagues in some major misconduct
which would have resulted not only in them losing
their livelihood, but would also have led to tarnishing
the image of the force. Hence, the order made was
reformative in nature, not punitive.”
12.
It is evident from the afore-extracted paragraphs that
the confidential report received from the Commanding Officer
of the 4th Battalion, where the petitioner was posted prior to
his transfer to the 1st Battalion, highlights the involvement of
the petitioner in activities that undermine discipline and foster
disaffection within the force. In fact, from the letter dated
20.07.2023 enclosed as Annexure-A to the said affidavit-inopposition, it is further evident that the petitioner was warned
to be more careful in the future and not to indulge in
spreading disaffection among the force personnel, casting
aspersions on the administrative decisions, and instigating
force personnel to indulge in indiscipline and insubordination.
It is further evident that the petitioner was alleged to be
indulging in creating casteism and groupism in the company
and also alleged to have made false accusations against other
staff members, causing significant administrative difficulties
and disruption of smooth functioning of office operations,
mess management, and duty allocations within the company.
It is further alleged that the petitioner misbehaved with
subordinate officers. It is further evident that despite
warnings, since the petitioner did not improve, he was
subsequently transferred from the 4th Battalion to the 1st
Battalion, Lumding, Assam. It is further evident that even
while the petitioner was stationed at the 1st Battalion, he was
found
involved
in
factional
activities
and
unnecessary
discussions that undermined the company’s cohesion. It is
further alleged that during a security conference, the
petitioner made an inflammatory statement referencing a
recent incident where a fellow constable died by shooting
himself, thereby instigating harm to the force’s discipline. It is
further evident that, based on these concerns, the senior
DSC/RPF of Lumding recommended the petitioner’s impugned
transfer to improve discipline within the force. Accordingly, the
impugned transfer was issued.
13.
A plain reading of the impugned transfer order does
not indicate any finding of guilt being recorded or any penalty
being imposed. However, an order becomes punitive not
merely when a statutory penalty is imposed, but when it is
founded on imputations and it carries stigmatic recitals
affecting reputation and service standing. The references in
the impugned order to groupism, disobedience, indiscipline,
counselling, and warning of disciplinary action unmistakably
attribute blame and misconduct. Such languages travel beyond
administrative necessity.
14.
Therefore, the impugned transfer order is stigmatic
and founded on alleged misconduct. I am thus of the
unhesitant view that the same is punitive in nature. Having
found the transfer order to be punitive and stigmatic, the
petitioner had a right to notice of allegations. It is an admitted
position that no show-cause notice or enquiry is held. The
action
thus
violates
principles
of
natural
justice.
The
respondents ought to have initiated disciplinary proceedings;
instead, a penal consequence has been imposed under the
camouflage of transfer. Transfer cannot be used as a
substitute for disciplinary proceedings.
15.
Therefore, the impugned transfer order is illegal and
unsustainable in law.
Accordingly,
the
impugned
transfer
order dated 19.09.2024 is hereby set aside and quashed.
16.
Though this Court has held the impugned transfer
order to be illegal, it is not in dispute that the petitioner has
already joined the transferred post and has been working
there for almost more than 1 year and 3 months. It is further
brought to the notice of this court by the learned counsel
appearing for the respondents that another incumbent has
since been posted in the petitioner’s former place of posting. It
is well settled that the jurisdiction of this court under Article
226 of the Constitution of India is discretionary and equitable.
Even after holding an administrative action to be illegal, the
court is not bound to grant consequential relief in a manner
that balances legality with practical realities, administrative
exigencies,
and
intervening
equities.
Relief
in
service
jurisprudence is therefore not automatic but depends upon the
facts of each case. When subsequent events have altered the
situation or third-party rights have been intervened, the court
may tailor the relief to avoid administrative dislocation while
still correcting the illegality. In short, the courts exercising writ
jurisdiction are empowered to mold relief in the interest of
justice. [Refer: - U.P. State Brassware Corpn. Ltd., and
Anr. vs. Uday Narain Pandey, reported in (2006) 1 SCC
479, State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors., vs. Yogendra
Shrivastava, reported in 2010 12 SCCC 538, and B.C.
Chaturvedi vs. Union of India and Ors., reported in (1995)
6 SCC 749].
17.
In the facts of the subsequent events as indicated
above, restoration of the petitioner to the previous battalion
would disturb administrative arrangements and affect thirdparty rights. Hence, relief in the instant case consequent to
setting aside of the transfer order requires molding in view of
subsequent events.
18.
Accordingly, it is clarified that setting aside of the
impugned transfer order shall not automatically entitle the
petitioner to restoration to his previous place of posting. The
petitioner having already joined the transferred post and
having worked there for a considerable period, and another
incumbent having since been posted at the former place of
posting, restoration at this stage would disturb administrative
arrangements and third-party rights. Hence, the declaration of
illegality is confined to removing the stigmatic and punitive
character of the order and protecting the petitioner’s service
record. Posting and future placement of the petitioner shall
remain within the administrative domain of the competent
authority to be exercised in accordance with law.
19.
It is further clarified that the observations in the
impugned transfer order relating to groupism, indiscipline, and
misconduct shall not be treated as adverse remarks and shall
not affect the petitioner’s service record. However, the
petitioner shall be at liberty to submit a representation for the
posting of his choice, which shall be considered by the
competent authority, in accordance with law.
20.
prevent
It is furthermore clarified that this order shall not
the
respondents
from
initiating
disciplinary
proceedings against the petitioner, in accordance with law.
21.
With the above observations, the instant writ petition
stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
signed
Pranab Digitally
by Pranab
Das
Chand Chandra
Date:
2026.02.04
ra Das 00:57:51 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review