Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:7966
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 13917 of 2025
1 - Vinod Kumar Markam S/o. Indraman Singh Markam, Aged About 38 Years R/o.
Motesara, Block Sajha, Ps. Debarbija, Dist. Bemetara (C.G.) Working At Office Of
Block Education Officer, Berla, Dist. Bemetara (C.G.) (Data Entry/ Computer
Operator)
2 - Brijmohan Lal Sinha, S/o Shanturam Sinha, Aged About 38 Years R/o. Village
Bahira, Post Karesara, Ps Bemetara, Dist. Bemetara (C.G.) Working At Office Of
Block Education Officer, Nawagarh, Dist. Bemetara (C.G.)......(Data Entry/
Computer Operator)
3 - Ashwan Kumar, S/o. Bhagchand Kurre, Aged About 37 Years R/o. Bhothidih,
Post Mohrenga, Ps Bemetara Dist. Bemetara (C.G.) Working At Office Of Block
Education Officer, Bemetara Dist. Bemetara (C.G.).......(Data Entry/ Computer
Operator)
4 - Girwar Lal Sinha, S/o. Saroj Kumar Sinha, Aged About 34 Years R/o. Godmarra,
Post Gadadih, Ps Parpodi, Block Sajha, Dist. Bemetara (C.G.) Working At Office Of
Block Education Officer, Sajha/ District Education Officer, Bemetara, Dist. Bemetara
(C.G.) (Data Entry/ Computer Operator)
5 - Purushottam Lal Banjare, S/o. Roshan Lal Banjare, Aged About 37 Years R/o.
Ward No. 31, Danteshwari Chowk, Village Devbaloda, Tehsil Bhilai- 3, Dist. Durg
(C.G.) Working At Office Of Block Education Officer, Sajha, Dist. Bemetara (C.G.)
(Data Entry/ Computer Operator)
6 - Pawan Kumar Kurre, S/o. Late Sitaram Kurre, Aged About 38 Years R/o. Nagar
Panchayat Berla, Dist. Bemetara (C.G.) Working At Office Of Block Education
Officer, Berla, Dist. Bemetara (C.G.) (Data Entry/ Computer Operator)
... Petitioner
Versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of School Education,
Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Naya Raipur, Dist. Raipur (C.G.)
2 - The Directorate Of Public Instructions, Section-3, 1st Floor, Indrawati Bhawan,
Naya Raipur, Dist. Raipur (C.G.)
3 - The District Education Officer, Bemetara, Dist. Bemetara (C.G.)
4 - The District Education Officer, Durg, District Durg (C.G.)
5 - The Block Education Officer, Sajha, Dist. Bemetara (C.G.)
6 - The Block Education Officer, Berla, District Bemetara (C.G.)
7 - The Block Education Officer, Nawagarh, District Durg (C.G.)
... Respondents
For Petitioner
:
For Respondents-State :
Mr. N. Naha Roy, Advocate
Mr. Ajay Kumrani, Panel Lawyer
SB: Hon'ble Shri Parth Prateem Sahu, Judge
ORDER ON BOARD
13/02/2026
1. The petitioners have filed this writ petition seeking following reliefs:“10.1 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to issue an appropriate writ in the nature of
mandamus and direct the respondents to consider
the case of the petitioners for regularization in terms
of the series of judicial verdicts are referred above
right from Umadevi’s case (supra) read with
Narendra Kumar Tiwari’s case (supra) upto recent
verdicts as a onetime measure within a timeframe as
deemed fit by this Hon’ble Court.
10.2 Grant any other relief, which is deemed fit in
the circumstances of the case. ”
2. Learned counsel for the petitioners submit that the petitioners are
employed under the respondent departments on the post of Data Entry
Operators/Computer Operator since 2011-12. They are continuously
working on the said post since then, without any break in service. He also
contended that the work of the petitioners is under the Mid-day Meal
Scheme as provided by the State Government. Petitioners since the date
of initial appointment are working on the fixed honorarium of Rs. 9,000/and in view of the circular of the State Government as also, the decision
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Secretary, State of Karnataka
and Others v. Umadevi and Others reported in (2006) 4 SCC 1,
petitioners are entitled for regularization of their services on the ground
that the petitioner are continuously in service since last more than 10
years and are still working as Data Entry Operators/Computer Operators.
3. On the other hand, learned counsel for the Respondents/State would
submit that the petitioner has not submitted any representation before the
authorities raising all their grievances as pleaded in this writ petition and
have directly filed this instant writ petition before this Court.
4. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the documents
placed on record.
5. The grievance of the petitioner as projected in this writ petition is that they
are continuously in employment since last about more than 14 years with
the Respondents/State on honorarium basis. Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Umadevi (Supra) considering that the daily-wage
employee/temporary employee will not be discriminated to the extent of
wages/salary as paid to the regular employees has considered the
regularization of employees who have been employed by the employer,
their service is not illegal but irregular and is continuous employment
since about more than 10 years and observed thus:“ 53. One aspect needs to be clarified. There may be
cases where irregular appointments (not illegal
appointments) as explained in S.V. NARAYANAPPA
(supra), R.N. NANJUNDAPPA (supra), and B.N.
NAGARAJAN (supra), and referred to in paragraph
15 above, of duly qualified persons in duly
sanctioned vacant posts might have been made and
the employees have continued to work for ten years
or more but without the intervention of orders of
courts or of tribunals. The question of regularization
of the services of such employees may have to be
considered on merits in the light of the principles
settled by this Court in the cases above referred to
and in the light of this judgment. In that context, the
Union of India, the State Governments and their
instrumentalities should take steps to regularize as a
one time measure, the services of such irregularly
appointed, who have worked for ten years or more in
duly sanctioned posts but not under cover of orders
of courts or of tribunals and should further ensure
that regular recruitments are undertaken to fill those
vacant sanctioned posts that require to be filled up, in
cases where temporary employees or daily wagers
are being now employed. The process must be set in
motion within six months from this date. We also
clarify that regularization, if any already made, but
not subjudice, need not be reopened based on this
judgment, but there should be no further by-passing
of the constitutional requirement and regularizing or
making permanent, those not duly appointed as per
the constitutional scheme.”
6. After the decision in the case of Umadevi (Supra), State Government has
issued circular addressing to all the stakeholders of different departments
of the State of Chhattisgarh on 05.03.2008 with the subject that
regularization of Class III and Class IV employees working as daily-wage
employee or temporary employee. In the aforementioned notification, it is
mentioned that the procedure for regularization of services of Class III
and Class IV employees working as daily-wage or temporary employees.
Paragraph 2 of the said circular is extracted below for ready reference:-
“ 2. उपरोक्त माननीय उच्चतम न्यायालय के निर्णय के परिप्रेक्ष्य में
राज्य शासन द्वारा सहानुभूतिपूर्वक विचार कर दैनिक वेतन भोगी/तदर्थ
रूप से नियुक्त कर्मचारियों की नियमितिकरण की प्रक्रिया निम्नानुसार
निर्धारित की जाती है :(i) व्यक्ति, रिक्त/स्वीकृ त नियमित पद के विरुद्ध पदस्थ किया गया हो
और विभागीय भरती नियमों में निर्धारित शैक्षणिक एवं अन्य योग्यताएं
रखता हो तो ही नियमित करने योग्य है।
(ii) दैनिक वेतन पर, तदर्थ रूप से अथवा कलेक्टर दर पर (दैनिक
वेतन पर) जब नियुक्ति हुई तब सेअब तक उस पद की आवश्यकता
रही है और आगे भी उस पद की आवश्यकता हो तो संबंधित पद के
विरुद्ध ऐसे व्यक्ति को पदस्थ मानते हुए विचार किया जा सके गा।
(iii) संबंधित व्यक्ति ने दैनिक वेतन भोगी (चाहे कलेक्टर दर पर) के
रूप में अथवा तदर्थ रूप में दिनांक 31-12-1997 तक लगातार उसी
पद पर या समकक्ष पद पर कार्य किया हो के संबंध में लगातार कार्य
करना (सेवा देना) तब ही माना जायेगा यदि प्रत्येक वर्ष में कु ल सेवा
ब्रेक एक माह से अधिक की न हो। लगातार सेवा के लिये हड़ताल की
अवधि सेवा में ब्रेक नहीं मानी जायेगी ।
(iv) दिनांक 31-12-1997 तक दैनिक वेतन पर अथवा तदर्थ नियुक्त
एवं कार्यरत तृतीय एवं चतुर्थ श्रेणी कर्मचारियों का नियमितिकरण
किया जाय ।
(v) व्यक्ति यदि कार्यभारित पदों के विरुद्ध कार्यरत है तो कार्यभारित
पद पर ही नियमित किया जाए नियमित पद के विरुद्ध कार्यरत हो तो
नियमित पद पर ही नियमित किया जाए।
(vi) छत्तीसगढ़ लोक सेवा (अनुसूचित जातियों, अनुसूचित
जनजातियों, और अन्य पिछड़े वर्गों के लिये आरक्षण) अधिनियम,
1994 का पालन किया जावे अर्थात् दैनिक वेतन भोगी/तदर्थ रूप में
कार्यरत व्यक्ति जिस वर्ग से संबंधित है रोस्टर के अनुसार उसी बिन्दु के
समक्ष उसका नियमितिकरण किया जाये एवं रोस्टर में अनुसूचित
जाति, अनुसूचित जनजाति, अन्य पिछड़े वर्ग के बिन्दु यदि उम्मीदवार
के अभाव में रिक्त रहते हैं तो भविष्य में होने वाली रिक्तियों की पूर्ति
आरक्षित बिन्दुओं के लिये प्राथमिकता के आधार पर बैकलाग की पूर्ति
की तरह की जायेगी।
(vii) नियमितिकरण स्वीकृ त एवं रिक्त पद पर ही किया जाएगा । इस
हेतु जिन विभागों में आवश्यक हो वहां सांख्येतर पद निर्मित किये
जायें। यदि पद ही कलेक्टर दर पर स्वीकृ त हो तो स्वीकृ त पदों (दैनिक
वेतन पर) को नियमित वेतनमान में परिवर्तित (सृजित) करना होगा।
(viii) परिपत्र जारी होने के बाद शासकीय विभागों द्वारा नियमितिकरण
के आदेश जिस दिन जारी किये जायेंगे उसी दिनांक से ही नियमित
कर्मचारी माने जावेंगे। पूर्व के किसी दिनांक से नहीं। पदक्रम सूची में
इनके नाम आपसी वरिष्ठता अनुसार एनब्लाक सबसे नीचे रखे जायेंगे।
(ix) उपरोक्तानुसार नियमित रूप से नियुक्ति दी गई व्यक्तियों की
आपसी वरिष्ठता दैनिक वेतन भोग कर्मचारी/कलेक्टर दर पर, अथवा
तदर्थ रूप से कार्यभार ग्रहण के दिनांक के आधार प निर्धारित की
जावेगी । वरिष्ठताक्रम निर्धारित करते समय यदि एक से अधिक व्यक्ति
एक दिनांक में नियुक्त किये गये हों तो उनमें से जो आयु में अधिक
होगा उसे वरिष्ठ माना जाएगा.”
7. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Narendra Kumar Tiwari & Ors.
Vs. State of Jharkhand & Ors. reported in (2018) 8 SCC 238
considering the decision in case Umadevi (Supra) has observed thus:-
“ 8. If a strict and literal interpretation, forgetting the
spirit of the decision of the Constitution Bench in
Umadevi (3)2, is to be taken into consideration then
no irregularly appointed employee of the State of
Jharkhand could ever be regularised since that State
came into existence only on 15-11-2000 and the cutoff date was fixed as 10-4-2006. In other words, in
this manner the pernicious practice of indefinitely
continuing irregularly appointed employees would be
perpetuated contrary to the intent of the Constitution
Bench.
9. The High Court as well as the State of Jharkhand
ought to have considered the entire issue in a
contextual perspective and not only from the point of
view of the interest of the State, financial or
otherwise — the interest of the employees is also
required to be kept in mind. What has eventually
been achieved by the State of Jharkhand is to short
circuit the process of regular appointments and
instead make appointments on an irregular basis.
This is hardly good governance.
10. Under the circumstances, we are of the view that
the Regularisation Rules must be given a pragmatic
interpretation and the appellants, if they have
completed 10 years of service on the date of
promulgation of the Regularisation Rules, ought to be
given the benefit of the service rendered by them. If
they have completed 10 years of service they should
be regularised unless there is some valid objection to
their regularisation like misconduct, etc.”
8. Hon’ble Supreme Court recently in the case of Jaggo Vs. Union of India
& Ors. reported in (2024) SCC OnLine SC 3826 while considering the
claim of part-time/ad hoc employees appointed as Safaiwale, Khalasi who
earlier engaged in CWC Establishment at Faridabad had observed thus:“22. The pervasive misuse of temporary employment
contracts, as exemplified in this case, reflects a broader
systemic issue that adversely affects workers' rights and
job security. In the private sector, the rise of the gig
economy has led to an increase in precarious
employment arrangements, often characterized by lack of
benefits, job security, and fair treatment. Such practices
have been criticized for exploiting workers and
undermining labour standards. Government institutions,
entrusted with upholding the principles of fairness and
justice, bear an even greater responsibility to avoid such
exploitative employment practices. When public sector
entities engage in misuse of temporary contracts, it not
only mirrors the detrimental trends observed in the gig
economy but also sets a concerning precedent that can
erode public trust in governmental operations.
23. The International Labour Organization (ILO), of which
India is a founding member, has consistently advocated
for employment stability and the fair treatment of workers.
The ILO's Multinational Enterprises Declaration6
encourages companies to provide stable employment and
to observe obligations concerning employment stability
and social security. It emphasizes that enterprises should
assume a leading role in promoting employment security,
particularly in contexts where job discontinuation could
exacerbate long-term unemployment.
24. The landmark judgment of the United State in the case
of Vizcaino v. Microsoft Corporation7 serves as a pertinent
example from the private sector, illustrating the
consequences of misclassifying employees to circumvent
providing benefits. In this case, Microsoft classified certain
workers as independent contractors, thereby denying
them employee benefits. The U.S. Court of Appeals for
the Ninth Circuit determined that these workers were, in
fact, common-law employees and were entitled to the
same benefits as regular employees. The Court noted that
large Corporations have increasingly adopted the practice
of hiring temporary employees or independent contractors
as a means of avoiding payment of employee benefits,
thereby increasing their profits. This judgment
underscores the principle that the nature of the work
performed, rather than the label assigned to the worker,
should determine employment status and the
corresponding rights and benefits. It highlights the
judiciary's role in rectifying such misclassifications and
ensuring that workers receive fair treatment.
25. It is a disconcerting reality that temporary employees,
particularly in government institutions, often face
multifaceted forms of exploitation. While the foundational
purpose of temporary contracts may have been to
address short-term or seasonal needs, they have
increasingly become a mechanism to evade long-term
obligations owed to employees. These practices manifest
in several ways:
• Misuse of “Temporary” Labels: Employees engaged
for work that is essential, recurring, and integral to the
functioning of an institution are often labeled as
“temporary” or “contractual,” even when their roles mirror
those of regular employees. Such misclassification
deprives workers of the dignity, security, and benefits that
regular employees are entitled to, despite performing
identical tasks.
• Arbitrary Termination: Temporary employees are
frequently dismissed without cause or notice, as seen in
the present case. This practice undermines the principles
of natural justice and subjects workers to a state of
constant insecurity, regardless of the quality or duration of
their service.
• Lack of Career Progression: Temporary employees
often find themselves excluded from opportunities for skill
development, promotions, or incremental pay raises. They
remain stagnant in their roles, creating a systemic
disparity between them and their regular counterparts,
despite their contributions being equally significant.
\• Using Outsourcing as a Shield: Institutions
increasingly resort to outsourcing roles performed by
temporary employees, effectively replacing one set of
exploited workers with another. This practice not only
perpetuates exploitation but also demonstrates a
deliberate effort to bypass the obligation to offer regular
employment.
• Denial of Basic Rights and Benefits: Temporary
employees are often denied fundamental benefits such as
pension, provident fund, health insurance, and paid leave,
even when their tenure spans decades. This lack of social
security subjects them and their families to undue
hardship, especially in cases of illness, retirement, or
unforeseen circumstances.
26. While the judgment in Uma Devi (supra) sought to
curtail the practice of backdoor entries and ensure
appointments adhered to constitutional principles, it is
regrettable that its principles are often misinterpreted or
misapplied to deny legitimate claims of long-serving
employees. This judgment aimed to distinguish between
“illegal” and “irregular” appointments. It categorically held
that employees in irregular appointments, who were
engaged in duly sanctioned posts and had served
continuously for more than ten years, should be
considered for regularization as a one-time measure.
However, the laudable intent of the judgment is being
subverted when institutions rely on its dicta to
indiscriminately reject the claims of employees, even in
cases where their appointments are not illegal, but merely
lack adherence to procedural formalities. Government
departments often cite the judgment in Uma Devi (supra)
to argue that no vested right to regularization exists for
temporary employees, overlooking the judgment's explicit
acknowledgment of cases where regularization is
appropriate. This selective application distorts the
judgment's spirit and purpose, effectively weaponizing it
against employees who have rendered indispensable
services over decades.
27. In light of these considerations, in our opinion, it is
imperative for government departments to lead by
example in providing fair and stable employment.
Engaging workers on a temporary basis for extended
periods, especially when their roles are integral to the
organization's functioning, not only contravenes
international labour standards but also exposes the
organization to legal challenges and undermines
employee morale. By ensuring fair employment practices,
government institutions can reduce the burden of
unnecessary litigation, promote job security, and uphold
the principles of justice and fairness that they are meant
to embody. This approach aligns with international
standards and sets a positive precedent for the private
sector to follow, thereby contributing to the overall
betterment of labour practices in the country.
28. In view of the above discussion and findings, the
appeals are allowed. The impugned orders passed by the
High Court and the Tribunal are set aside and the original
application is allowed to the following extent:
i. The termination orders dated 27.10.2018 are quashed;
ii. The appellants shall be taken back on duty forthwith
and their services regularised forthwith. However, the
appellants shall not be entitled to any pecuniary
benefits/back wages for the period they have not worked
for but would be entitled to continuity of services for the
said period and the same would be counted for their postretiral benefits.”
9. In case of Vinod Kumar v. Union of India, reported in (2024) 9
SCC 327, Hon'ble Apex Court had held that mere procedural
formalities cannot stand in the way of regularizing service of an
employee whose appointment was termed "temporary" but who has
rendered services akin to that of a regular employee, over a
substantial period of time, in the capacity of a regular employee. It
has been observed in the relevant paragraphs (i.e. para 6 & 7) that:“6. The application of the judgment in Uma Devi
(supra) by the High Court does not fit squarely
with the facts at hand, given the specific
circumstances under which the appellants were
employed and have continued their service. The
reliance on procedural formalities at the outset
cannot be used to perpetually deny substantive
rights that have accrued over a considerable
period through continuous service. Their
promotion was based on a specific notification
for vacancies and a subsequent circular, followed
by a selection process involving written tests and
interviews, which distinguishes their case from
the appointments through back door entry as
discussed in the case of Uma Devi (supra).
7. The judgment in the case Uma Devi (supra)
also distinguished between "irregular" and
"illegal"
appointments underscoring the
importance
of
considering
certain
appointments even if were not made strictly
in accordance with the prescribed Rules and
Procedure, cannot be said to have been made
illegally if they had followed the procedures
of regular appointments such as conduct of
written examinations or interviews as in the
present case....”
10.Recently, in SLP (C) No.30762/2024, parties being Bhola Nath vs
State of Jharkhand & ors, decided on 31.1.2026, Hon’ble
Supreme Court after referring its earlier decisions on the very issue,
has concluded thus:“13.6. This Court has, on several occasions,
deprecated the practice adopted by States of
engaging employees under the nominal labels
of “part-time”, “contractual” or “temporary” in
perpetuity and thereby exploiting them by not
regularizing their positions. In Jaggo v. Union of
India10, this Court underscored that government
departments must lead by example in ensuring
fair and stable employment, and evolved the
test of examining whether the duties performed
by such temporary employees are integral to the
day-to-day functioning of the organization.
13.7. In Shripal v. Nagar Nigam11, and Vinod
Kumar v. Union of India12, this Court cautioned
against a mechanical and blind reliance on
Umadevi (supra) to deny regularization to
temporary employees in the absence of
statutory rules. It was held that Umadevi (supra)
cannot be employed as a shield to legitimise
exploitative engagements continued for years
without undertaking regular recruitment. The
Court further clarified that Umadevi itself draws
a distinction between appointments that are
“illegal” and those that are merely “irregular”, the
latter being amenable to regularization upon
fulfillment of the prescribed conditions.
13.8. In Dharam Singh v. State of U.P.13, this
Court strongly deprecated the culture of “adhocism” adopted by States in their capacity as
employers. The Court criticised the practice of
outsourcing or informalizing recruitment as a
means
to
evade
regular
employment
obligations, observing that such measures
perpetuate precarious working conditions while
circumventing fair and lawful engagement
practices.
13.9. The State must remain conscious that
part-time employees, such as the appellants,
constitute an integral part of the edifice upon
which the machinery of the State continues to
function. They are not merely ancillary to the
system, but form essential components thereof.
The equality mandate of our Constitution,
therefore, requires that their service be
reciprocated in a manner free from arbitrariness,
ensuring that decisions of the State affecting the
careers and livelihood of such part-time and
contractual employees are guided by fairness
and reason.
13.10. In the aforesaid backdrop, we are unable
to persuade ourselves to accept the respondentState’s contention that the mere contractual
nomenclature of the appellants’ engagement
denudes them of constitutional protection. The
State, having availed of the appellants’ services
on sanctioned posts for over a decade pursuant
to a due process of selection and having
consistently acknowledged their satisfactory
performance, cannot, in the absence of cogent
reasons or a speaking decision, abruptly
discontinue such engagement by taking refuge
behind formal contractual clauses. Such action
is manifestly arbitrary, inconsistent with the
obligation of the State to act as a model
employer, and fails to withstand scrutiny under
Article 14 of the Constitution.
FINAL CONCLUSION:
14. In light of our discussion, in the foregoing
paragraphs, we summarize our conclusions as
follows:
I. The respondent-State was not justified in
continuing the appellants on sanctioned vacant
posts for over a decade under the nomenclature
of contractual engagement and thereafter
denying them consideration for regularization.
II. Abrupt discontinuance of such long-standing
engagement solely on the basis of contractual
nomenclature, without either recording cogent
reasons or passing a speaking order, is
manifestly arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of
the Constitution.
III. Contractual stipulations purporting to bar
claims for regularization cannot override
constitutional guarantees. Acceptance of
contractual terms does not amount to waiver of
fundamental rights, and contractual stipulations
cannot immunize arbitrary State action from
constitutional scrutiny.
IV. The State, as a model employer, cannot rely
on contractual labels or mechanical application
of Umadevi (supra) to justify prolonged adhocism or to discard long-serving employees in
a manner inconsistent with fairness, dignity and
constitutional governance.
V. In view of the foregoing discussion, we direct
the respondent-State to forthwith regularize the
services of all the appellants against the
sanctioned posts to which they were initially
appointed. The appellants shall be entitled to all
consequential service benefits accruing from the
date of this judgment .
11. Following the decision in the case of Jaggo (Supra), Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Shripal & Anr. Vs. Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad
reported in (2025) SCC OnLine SC 221 while considering the claim of
regularization of the appellants therein had observed thus:“12. The evidence, including documentary material and
undisputed facts, reveals that the Appellant Workmen
performed duties integral to the Respondent Employer's
municipal functions specifically the upkeep of parks,
horticultural tasks, and city beautification efforts. Such
work is evidently perennial rather than sporadic or projectbased. Reliance on a general “ban on fresh recruitment”
cannot be used to deny labor protections to long-serving
workmen. On the contrary, the acknowledged shortage of
Gardeners in the Ghaziabad Nagar Nigam reinforces the
notion that these positions are essential and ongoing, not
intermittent.
13. By requiring the same tasks (planting, pruning,
general upkeep) from the Appellant Workmen as
from regular Gardeners but still compensating them
inadequately and inconsistently the Respondent
Employer has effectively engaged in an unfair labour
practice. The principle of “equal pay for equal work,”
repeatedly emphasized by this Court, cannot be
casually disregarded when workers have served for
extended periods in roles resembling those of
permanent employees. Long-standing assignments
under the Employer's direct supervision belie any
notion that these were mere short-term casual
engagements.
15. It is manifest that the Appellant Workmen
continuously rendered their services over several
years, sometimes spanning more than a decade.
Even if certain muster rolls were not produced in full,
the Employer's failure to furnish such records—
despite directions to do so—allows an adverse
inference
under
well-established
labour
jurisprudence. Indian labour law strongly disfavors
perpetual daily-wage or contractual engagements in
circumstances where the work is permanent in
nature. Morally and legally, workers who fulfil ongoing
municipal requirements year after year cannot be
dismissed summarily as dispensable, particularly in
the absence of a genuine contractor agreement. At
this juncture, it would be appropriate to recall the
broader critique of indefinite “temporary” employment
practices as done by a recent judgment of this court
in Jaggo v. Union of India3 in the following
paragraphs:
“22. The pervasive misuse of temporary employment
contracts, as exemplified in this case, reflects a
broader systemic issue that adversely affects
workers' rights and job security. In the private sector,
the rise of the gig economy has led to an increase in
precarious
employment
arrangements,
often
characterized by lack of benefits, job security, and fair
treatment. Such practices have been criticized for
exploiting workers and undermining labour standards.
Government institutions, entrusted with upholding the
principles of fairness and justice, bear an even
greater responsibility to avoid such exploitative
employment practices. When public sector entities
engage in misuse of temporary contracts, it not only
mirrors the detrimental trends observed in the gig
economy but also sets a concerning precedent that
can erode public trust in governmental operations.
………
25. It is a disconcerting reality that temporary
employees, particularly in government institutions,
often face multifaceted forms of exploitation. While
the foundational purpose of temporary contracts may
have been to address short-term or seasonal needs,
they have increasingly become a mechanism to
evade long-term obligations owed to employees.
These practices manifest in several ways:
• Misuse of “Temporary” Labels : Employees engaged
for work that is essential, recurring, and integral to
the functioning of an institution are often labelled as
“temporary” or “contractual,” even when their roles
mirror those of regular employees. Such
misclassification deprives workers of the dignity,
security, and benefits that regular employees are
entitled to, despite performing identical tasks.
• Arbitrary Termination : Temporary employees are
frequently dismissed without cause or notice, as seen
in the present case. This practice undermines the
principles of natural justice and subjects workers to a
state of constant insecurity, regardless of the quality
or duration of their service.
• Lack of Career Progression : Temporary employees
often find themselves excluded from opportunities for
skill development, promotions, or incremental pay
raises. They remain stagnant in their roles, creating a
systemic disparity between them and their regular
counterparts, despite their contributions being equally
significant.
• Using Outsourcing as a Shield : Institutions
increasingly resort to outsourcing roles performed by
temporary employees, effectively replacing one set of
exploited workers with another. This practice not only
perpetuates exploitation but also demonstrates a
deliberate effort to bypass the obligation to offer
regular employment.
• Denial of Basic Rights and Benefits : Temporary
employees are often denied fundamental benefits
such as pension, provident fund, health insurance,
and paid leave, even when their tenure spans
decades. This lack of social security subjects them
and their families to undue hardship, especially in
cases of illness, retirement, or unforeseen
circumstances.”
16. The High Court did acknowledge the Employer's
inability to justify these abrupt terminations.
Consequently, it ordered re-engagement on daily
wages with some measure of parity in minimum pay.
Regrettably, this only perpetuated precariousness :
the Appellant Workmen were left in a marginally
improved yet still uncertain status. While the High
Court recognized the importance of their work and
hinted at eventual regularization, it failed to afford
them continuity of service or meaningful back wages
commensurate with the degree of statutory violation
evident on record.
17. In light of these considerations, the Employer's
discontinuation of the Appellant Workmen stands in
violation of the most basic labour law principles.
Once it is established that their services were
terminated without adhering to Sections 6E and 6N of
the U.P. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, and that they
were engaged in essential, perennial duties, these
workers cannot be relegated to perpetual uncertainty.
While concerns of municipal budget and compliance
with recruitment rules merit consideration, such
concerns do not absolve the Employer of statutory
obligations or negate equitable entitlements. Indeed,
bureaucratic limitations cannot trump the legitimate
rights of workmen who have served continuously in
de facto regular roles for an extended period.
18. The impugned order of the High Court, to the
extent they confine the Appellant Workmen to future
daily-wage engagement without continuity or
meaningful back wages, is hereby set aside with the
following directions:
I. The discontinuation of the Appellant Workmen's
services, effected without compliance with Section 6E
and Section 6N of the U.P. Industrial Disputes Act,
1947,
is
declared
illegal. All
orders
or
communications terminating their services are
quashed. In consequence, the Appellant Workmen
shall be treated as continuing in service from the date
of their termination, for all purposes, including
seniority and continuity in service.
II. The Respondent Employer shall reinstate the
Appellant Workmen in their respective posts (or posts
akin to the duties they previously performed) within
four weeks from the date of this judgment. Their
entire period of absence (from the date of termination
until actual reinstatement) shall be counted for
continuity of service and all consequential benefits,
such as seniority and eligibility for promotions, if any.
III. Considering the length of service, the Appellant
Workmen shall be entitled to 50% of the back wages
from the date of their discontinuation until their actual
reinstatement. The Respondent Employer shall clear
the aforesaid dues within three months from the date
of their reinstatement.
IV. The Respondent Employer is directed to initiate a
fair and transparent process for regularizing the
Appellant Workmen within six months from the date
of reinstatement, duly considering the fact that they
have performed perennial municipal duties akin to
permanent posts. In assessing regularization, the
Employer shall not impose educational or procedural
criteria retroactively if such requirements were never
applied to the Appellant Workmen or to similarly
situated regular employees in the past. To the extent
that sanctioned vacancies for such duties exist or are
required, the Respondent Employer shall expedite all
necessary administrative processes to ensure these
longtime employees are not indefinitely retained on
daily wages contrary to statutory and equitable
norms.”
12.In the above facts of the case and the decisions of Hon’ble Supreme
Court and further considering that the petitioners have not submitted any
representation before the Respondents No.1 & 2 raising all the grounds
as raised in this writ petition, in the opinion of this Court, I find it
appropriate to dispose of this writ petition permitting the petitioners to
submit representation before the Respondents No. 1 & 2 raising all the
grounds as raised in this writ petition and in the event, petitioners submit
representation, the Respondents No. 1 & 2 shall consider and take
decision on the representation to be submitted by the petitioners in
accordance with law, keeping in mind the decisions of Hon’ble Supreme
Court as discussed above, preferably within a period of 04 months from
the date of receipt of the representation.
13. With the aforesaid observation and direction, this writ petition stands
disposed of.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
Digitally
SHUBHAM signed by
DEY
SHUBHAM
DEY
Dey
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review