Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 19497/2026
CNR: RJHC020940122026 | URN: CW / 40700U / 2026
Vinita Pooniya D/o Rajendra Prasad Pooniya, Aged About 25
Years, Resident Of Ward No. 14, Purana Power House Ke Pichhe,
Khatoo, District Sikar, Rajasthan, Presently Elected Councillor
From Ward No. 11, Nagar Palika Khatushyamji, District Sikar,
Rajasthan.
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
State Of Rajasthan, Through Its Principal Secretary, Local
Self Government Department, Government Secretariat,
Jaipur, Rajasthan.
2.
State Election Commission, Rajasthan, Through Its Chief
Election Officer And Secretary, Government Secretariat
Campus, Jaipur, Rajasthan.
3.
District
Election
Officer
(Municipal),
Sikar,
District
Collector, Collectorate, Sikar, Rajasthan.
4.
Returning Officer, Election Of Chairman, Nagar Palika
Khatushyamji,
(Additional
District
Magistrate,
Sikar),
Collectorate, District Sikar, Rajasthan.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Major R.P. Singh, Sr. Adv. assisted by
Mr. Ashish Punia,
Mr. Abhiraj Singh Deval,
Ms. Anchal Rathore,
Mr. Rituraj Bhullar,
Ms. Anushka Khandelwal and
Mr. Sanwar Chaudhary
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Amit Kuri with
Mr. Ayush Sharma
JUSTICE ANOOP KUMAR DHAND
Order
24/09/2026
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
1.
(2 of 19)
[CW-19497/2026]
The instant petition has been preferred with the following
prayer:
“It is, therefore, most respectfully prayed that this
Hon'ble Court may graciously be pleased to:
(i) direct the respondents to forthwith open the duly
sealed ballot box containing the 19 votes cast on
21.09.2026, undertake the counting thereof in
accordance
with
the
rules
of
the
Rajasthan
Municipalities (Election) Rules, 1994 and declare the
result of the election for Chairman, Nagar Palika
Khatushyamji in accordance with law;
(ii) quash and set aside any decision/order by which
election
process
of
Chairman,
Nagar
Palika
Khatushyamji is stayed or deferred or interfered with in
any manner whatsoever and direct the respondents to
declare the results of Chairman, Nagar Palika
Khatushyamji basedon votes cast within the time frame
published by the State Election Commission on
21.09.2026 immediately;
(iii) quash and set aside the communication dated
22.09.2026 (Annexure-7), to the extent that contradicts
prayer
(i)
&
(ii)
wherein
proposes
to
conduct/recommence the election for Chairman, Nagar
Palika Khatushyamji on 25.09.2026;
(iv) restrain the respondents from permitting any fresh
or additional voting in respect of the election for
Chairman, Nagar Palika Khatushyamji after expiry of the
polling period of notified by the State Election
Commission vide Annexure-1;
(v) pass any other appropriate order or direction which
this Hon’ble Court may deem just and proper in the
facts and circumstances of the case.”
2.
By way of filing the instant petition, a prayer has been made
for issuing directions to the respondent-authorities to open the
duly sealed ballot box containing the 19 votes cast on 21.09.2026
and undertake the counting thereof in accordance with the
provisions contained under the Rajasthan Municipalities (Election)
Rules, 1994 (for short, ‘the Rules of 1994’) and declare the result
(3 of 19)
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
of
election
for
the
post
of
[CW-19497/2026]
Chairman,
Municipal
Board,
Khatushyamji, District Sikar, in accordance with law.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the elections
for the post of Chairman, Municipal Board, Khatushyamji, District
Sikar were scheduled to be conducted on 21.09.2026, as per the
programme declared by the State Election Commission. Counsel
submits that as per the programme declared by the State Election
Commission, the election for the post of Chairman, Municipal
Board, Khatushyamji, District Sikar were supposed to be held on
21.09.2026 and the time for the voting process was fixed between
10.00 AM to 02.00 PM, and after completion of the voting process,
the counting was required to be conducted on the same day, i.e.
on 21.09.2026. Counsel submits that in all, the 20 members
elected to the Municipal Board, Khatushyamji, District Sikar were
supposed to cast their votes, but only 19 members cast their
votes within the above stipulated timeline, and one member failed
to cast her vote. Counsel submits that the concerned Returning
Officer, on his own whim, initially extended the deadline for
casting the votes from 02.00 PM to 02:30 PM, thereafter from
02:30 PM to 05.00 PM, and from 05.00 PM to 08.00 PM, from
08.00 PM to 10:30 PM and finally, the deadline for casting the
votes was extended from 10:30 PM to 11:30 PM on the fateful
day, i.e. on 21.09.2026. Counsel submits that thereafter, the
concerned Returning Officer wrote a letter to the Secretary, State
Election Commission seeking guidance by giving reference of an
FIR registered by the husband of the member who failed to cast
her vote. Counsel
submits
that the aforesaid FIR bearing
No.181/2026
registered
with
was
the
Police
Station
Khatu
(4 of 19)
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
[CW-19497/2026]
Shyamji, District Sikar, by the complainant Harlal, wherein it was
alleged that his wife was elected from Ward No.10, Municpal Board
Khatushyamji, District Sikar, but she was abducted and was
unable to cast her vote. Counsel submits that the aforesaid FIR
was registered after two hours and thirteen minutes of completion
of
the
voting
deadline,
as
prescribed
under
the
original
programme declared by the State Election Commission. Giving
reference of the aforesaid FIR, guidance was sought by the
concerned Returning Officer from the State Election Commission.
Thereafter, the State Election Commission, vide impugned order
dated 22.09.2026, directed the Returning Officer to stay the
election process for the post of Chairman, Municipal Board,
Khatushyamji,
District
Sikar
and
complete
the
same
on
25.09.2026. Counsel submits that the aforesaid action on the part
of the State Election Commission and Returning Officer in
deferring the election process and re-counting the votes is
contrary to provisions contained under the Rules of 1994. Counsel
submits that a mechanism has been provided for conducting the
elections of members and Chairman of the Municipality under the
Rules of 1994, particularly Rules 24, 25, 36, 41, 52, 53, 78, 85,
86, 87 and 97 of the Rules of 1994.
4.
Counsel submits that in contravention of the aforesaid
statutory rules, the State Election Commission as well as the
concerned Returning Officer have deferred the election process.
The election process is required to be completed strictly in terms
of the programme fixed by the State Election Commission,
meaning thereby that the result of the election was required to be
declared on the basis of the votes cast on the day of election as
(5 of 19)
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
[CW-19497/2026]
per the original programme declared by the State Election
Commission, i.e. on 21.09.2026. Counsel submits that under
these
circumstances,
the
impugned
order
passed
by
the
respondent-authorities is not tenable in the eyes of law and the
same is liable to be quashed and set aside.
5.
Lastly, counsel for the petitioner argued that in case the
practice adopted by the respondent-authorities is permitted to
continue, the election process would become endless and will not
come to its final conclusion. Counsel further submits that the
process can be completed on the basis of the votes cast by the
persons present at the polling station and willing to cast their
votes within the timeline prescribed by the State Election
Commission. Any person who was not present at the polling
station within the aforesaid fixed timeline cannot be allowed to be
defer the election process and cast their vote at a later point of
time. Counsel submits that the act of the respondents-authorities,
by misinterpreting the applicable provisions of law, falls within the
ambit of legal malice.
6.
In support of his arguments, counsel for the petitioner has
placed reliance upon the judgments passed by the Hon'ble Apex
Court in the case of Kalabharati Advertising versus Hemant
Vimalnath Narichania and Ors, reported in 2010 (9) SCC 437
and Ravi Yashwant Bhoir versus District Collector, Raigad
and Ors, reported in 2012 (4) SCC 407.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondents opposed the arguments raised by the counsel for the
petitioner and submitted that in all, the 20 members elected to
the Municipal Board, Khatushyamji, District Sikar were supposed
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
(6 of 19)
[CW-19497/2026]
to cast their votes on the polling day. Since one of the members of
Ward No.10, Municipal Board Khatushyamji, District Sikar, Smt.
Lakshmi Devi was abducted, therefore, she could not participate in
the election process and cast her vote. Hence, awaiting her
presence, the timeline for casting the votes was extended from
02.00 PM to 02:30 PM in terms of the provisions contained under
the Rule 78(6)(xii) read with Rule 80 of the Rules of 1994.
Counsel submits that thereafter, the time was further extended
from 02:30 PM to 05.00 PM, from 05.00 PM to 08.00 PM, from
08.00 PM to 10:30 PM and finally, from 10:30 PM to 11:30 PM on
the date of election, i.e. on 21.09.2026. Counsel submits that the
entire aforesaid proceedings were recorded in the note sheet,
which bears the signatures of the petitioner. Hence, the petitioner
is estopped by her signatures, as she herself put her signatures,
accepting the aforesaid view taken by the concerned Returning
Officer. Counsel submits that this Court, in the case of Ram Avtar
Saini vs State of Rajasthan and Ors, while deciding SB Civil
Writ Petition No.19285/2026, vide order dated 21.09.2026 has
taken a view that the newly elected Councilors are entitled to
participate in the election process of Chairperson. No authority or
individual has the right to deprive the elected members to cast
their votes as per their own free will. Counsel submits that the
Right to Vote is a statutory right and is a basic tenet of
democracy. An individual cannot be deprived of his/her right to
vote on the basis of the whims and fancies of another individual,
or on account of any political interference or enmity. Counsel
further submits that this Court was of the view that since the Chief
Election Commissioner was seized of the matter, this Court
(7 of 19)
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
[CW-19497/2026]
restrained itself to interfere with the election process and left it
open with the State Election Commission to take a decision in
accordance
with
law.
Counsel
submits
that
following
the
proposition of law as propounded by this Court in the case of Ram
Avtar Saini (supra), the State Election Commission as well as the
Returning Officer deferred the election process for the post of
Chairman,
Municipal
Board
Khatushyamji,
District
Sikar
to
25.09.2026 due to the circumstances narrated above, i.e., since
one of the elected members was abducted and was unable to cast
her vote. Counsel submits that under these circumstances, by
exercising the powers contained under Rule 78(6)(xii), the
concerned Returning Officer extended the time period for casting
the votes, hence, there is no infirmity in the impugned order
passed by the respondent-authorities. Counsel submits that under
these circumstances, interference of this Court is not warranted
and the instant petition is liable to be rejected.
8.
Heard and considered the submissions made at the Bar and
perused the material available on the record.
9.
Perusal of the record indicates that the process for election of
Municipalities was initiated by the State Election Commission by
issuing a notification dated 19.08.2026, wherein the entire
election programme was declared. The public notice was issued on
27.08.2026 for filing of nominations for the election of members
to the Municipalities. The last date for submission of nomination
for election of members to the Municipalities was fixed as
31.08.2026. The dates for the aforesaid elections was declared in
two phases, i.e. 09.09.2026 and 11.09.2026; and the date for
counting the votes was fixed as 14.09.2026. On the basis of the
(8 of 19)
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
[CW-19497/2026]
aforesaid election programme, as declared by the State Election
Commission, further elections for the post of Chairperson of the
Municipal Boards was supposed to be conducted w.e.f. 15.09.2026
by way of issuing public notice. The last date for filing the
nomination was 16.09.2026 and the date for election in the entire
State of Rajasthan was fixed as 21.09.2026. The time for the
voting was fixed between 10.00 AM to 02.00 PM and the date for
counting the votes was also fixed for 21.09.2026, immediately
after polling.
10.
In the instant case also, the polling started at 10.00 AM on
the fateful day, i.e. on 21.09.2026. It has been apprised at Bar by
both sides that in all, the 20 members elected to the Municipal
Board Khatushyamji, District Sikar were supposed to cast their
votes on the date fixed for polling as per the aforesaid programme
declared by the State Election Commission, i.e. on 21.09.2026. It
has also been apprised at Bar that till 02.00 PM on 21.09.2026,
only 19 elected members had cast their votes and one of the
members was absent.
11.
The legislature has framed and enacted the Rules of 1994,
and the entire mechanism for conducting municipal elections and
declaring the results of the same has been provided therein.
12.
Rule 24 of the Rules of 1994 deals with the provisions of
polling. Similarly, Rule 25 deals with hours of polling. Rule 36
deals with the provision of voting. Rule 41 deals with the provision
of
closing
of
poll.
Rule
deals
with
the
procedure
of
postponement of poll in emergencies. Rule 53 deals with the
adjournment
of
poll.
Rule
deals
with
the
election
of
Chairperson. Rule 85 deals with the procedure after publication of
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
(9 of 19)
[CW-19497/2026]
list of contesting candidates. Rule 86 deals with the provisions of
voting result of election. Rule 97 deals with the power of the State
Election Commission for removal of difficulties, in case any
difficulty arises in implementation of the Rules of 1994.
13.
For ready reference, these rules are reproduced as under:
“24. Poll.- In case of a contested election, a poll shall
be taken on the date mentioned under rule 10.
25. Hours of poll.- The State Election Commission
shall fix the hour at which polling shall commence and
the hour at which it shall close.
36. Voting.- (1) Save as hereinafter provided, all
voters voting at an election shall do so in person at
the polling station provided for them under the rules.
(2) vote shall be given in person and no vote shall be
given through a proxy.
41. Closing of poll.- (1) The presiding officer shall
close polling station at the hour fixed in that behalf
under rule 25 and shall not thereafter admit any voter
into the polling station:
Provided that all voters present at the polling
station before it is closed shall be allowed to cast their
votes.
(2) If any question arises whether a voter was
present at the polling station before it was closed, it
shall be decided by the presiding officer and his
decision shall be final.
52. Postponement of poll in emergencies.- The
State Election Commission may, for sufficient cause
be recorded in writing, postpone the date or extend
the period fixed for polling in case of emergencies
such as disturbance of the public peace, natural
calamity etc. Where a poll is so postponed, the State
Election Commission shall endeavour to conduct the
poll as soon as practicable.
53. Adjournment of poll.- (1) If at any election it is
not possible to take the poll at any polling station or
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
(10 of 19)
[CW-19497/2026]
the proceedings at any polling station are interrupted
or obstructed by riot, violence, disturbance of the
public peace, natural calamity, the presiding officer
for such polling station may adjourn the poll and shall
forthwith inform the returning officer who shall in turn
report to the Commission accordingly.
(2) Whenever a poll is adjourned the returning officer
shall as-soon as may be with the previous approval of
the State Election Commission, notify the date and
hours during which and the polling stations at which
the poll shall recommence and shall not count the
votes cast at any such election until such adjourned
poll shall have been completed.
78. Election of Chairperson:- (1) The office of the
Chairperson of a Municipality shall be filled by a
person chosen by elected members of the
Municipality.
Explanation: "Elected member" means a member
elected from a ward of the Municipality.
(2) A person shall be eligible for being chosen as, or
holding the office of, a Chairperson, if he is qualified
and is not disqualified under the provisions of the Act
for being chosen as a member of the Municipality.
(3) An elected member shall also be eligible for being
chosen as, or holding office, of a Chairperson.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule
(2) and (3), a person shall not be eligible for being
chosen as, or for holding office of, a Chairperson, if he
is a member of the Parliament or the State legislative
Assembly or is a member or Chairperson of a
Panchayati Raj Institution.
(5) A person or an elected member, as the case may
be, shall not be qualified to be chosen to fill the post
of the Chairperson unless,(a) in the case of an office of the Chairperson
reserved for the Scheduled Castes or Scheduled
Tribes or the Backward Classes, such person is a
member of any of these Castes or Tribes or Classes,
as the case may be;
(b) in the case of an office of the Chairperson
reserved for a woman, such person belongs to the
female sex; and
(c) in the case of an office of the Chairperson
reserved for a woman belonging to the Scheduled
Castes or Scheduled Tribes or the Backward Classes,
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
(11 of 19)
[CW-19497/2026]
such person is a member of any of these castes or
tribes or classes, as the case may be, and belongs to
the female sex.
(6) The provisions of the rule 10 to 23, 56, 71 to 75,
86, 87 and 88 shall apply mutatis mutandis to the
election of a Chairperson, subject to following
modifications: (i) that the nomination paper for the office of a Mayor
shall not be valid unless accompanied with a receipt
of security deposit of Rs. 30000/- in case of general
candidate and Rs. 15000/- in case of woman
candidate and candidates belonging to Scheduled
Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes;
(ii) that the nomination paper for the office of
President shall not be valid unless accompanied with a
receipt of security deposit of Rs. 20000/- in case of
general candidate and Rs. 10000/- in case of woman
candidate and candidates belonging to Scheduled
Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes;
(iii) that the nomination paper for the office of
Chairman shall not be valid unless accompanied with
a receipt of security deposit of Rs. 10000/- in case of
general candidate and Rs. 5000/- in case of woman
candidate and candidates belonging to Scheduled
Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes;
(iv) that a candidate shall not be deemed to be duly
nominated for election of the office of a Chairperson
unless the nomination paper is subscribed by an
elected member as a proposer,
(v) the last date for filing of nominations shall be the
second day after the day on which the result of
elected members is declared, or if that day is public
holiday, the next succeeding day, which is not a public
holiday;
(vi) the date for scrutiny of the nomination papers
shall be the day next to the last date for the filing of
nominations, or if that day is public holiday, the next
succeeding day, which is not a public holiday;
(vii) the date for withdrawal of candidature shall be
the day next to the date of scrutiny of the nomination
papers, or if that day is public holiday, the next
succeeding day, which is not a public holiday;
(viii) the symbol shall be allotted to the contesting
candidates immediately after the expiry of time fixed
for withdrawal of candidature;
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
(12 of 19)
[CW-19497/2026]
(ix) the design and form of the ballot papers shall be
specified by the State Election Commission. The
particulars on the ballot paper shall be in Hindi in
Devnagri script;
(x) the poll shall be taken, if necessary, in the
meeting of elected members to be held in the office of
the Municipality on the third day after the date for the
withdrawal of the candidature or in exceptional
circumstances any other later day as may be fixed by
the State Election Commission. The votes shall be
counted and result shall be declared immediately
after the conclusion of the poll;
(xi) the Returning Officer shall affix notice of meeting
of elected members on the notice board of the
municipality immediately after the expiry of time fixed
for withdrawal of candidature stating therein,(a) 10.00 AM to 02.00 PM as the hours of poll;
(b) counting of votes shall be made immediately after
completion of poll; and
(c) every contesting candidate, whether he is elected
member or not, is entitled to attend the meeting to
watch the proceedings of poll and counting of votes.
However only elected member is entitled to cast his
vote in the meeting;
(xii) the Returning Officer may extend time for poll, if
necessary or may declare the poll as finally concluded
earlier in case all the elected member holding office
have voted;
(xiii) a person or elected person after chosen as
Chairperson of a Municipality shall hold his office after
taking oath before the Collector or his nominee in
form prescribed under rule 69;
(xiv) references to Form 1, Form 2, Form 3, Form 4,
Form 5, Form 6, Form 7, Form 8, Form 22A and Form
23 shall be construed as including references to Form
1A, Form 2A, Form 3A, Form 4A, Form 5A, Form 6A,
Form 7A, Form 8A, Form 22AA and Form 23A
respectively; and
(xv) reference to Schedule VI shall be construed as
including reference to Form 22A-1.
85. Procedure after publication of list of
contesting candidates.- (1) If there is only one
candidate, there shall be no poll and the candidate so
nominated shall be declared to have been duly
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
(13 of 19)
[CW-19497/2026]
elected as the 1 [ViceChairperson] in the form
prescribed in Schedule-V.
(2) If there are two or more of such candidates, an
election shall be held by secret ballot and votes of the
members present at the meeting shall be taken.
(3) If there is no validly nominated candidate, all
proceedings in relation to election shall be
commenced afresh.
86. Voting. - (1) The returning officer shall cause
such arrangement to be made as will ensure the
secrecy of the ballot.
(2) Returning officer will be assisted by Polling Officer
to be appointed by District Municipal Election Officer.
(3) The ballot paper shall be in the form prescribed in
Schedule- IV and shall be duly authenticated by the
seal and signature of the returning officer. The names
of the candidates shall be arranged on the ballot
paper in the same order in which they appear in the
list of contesting candidates. The polling officer shall
tick mark the entry in the list of members before
issuing ballot paper.
(4) Every member wishing to vote shall place a cross
mark on the ballot paper against the name of the
candidate whom he wants to vote by means of the
instrument supplied for the purpose by the returning
officer and by no other instrument.
(5) He shall then fold up the ballot paper so as to
conceal his vote and deposit the same in a ballot box
placed in the view of the returning officer.
(6) If the voter is illiterate or is unable to place a
mark on the ballot paper owing to blindness or other
physical infirmity the returning officer or another
member chosen by the voter shall record the vote on
the ballot paper in accordance with the wishes of the
voter and fold it up so as to conceal the vote and the
voter shall then himself or with the assistance of the
Returning Officer insert the ballot paper into the ballot
box.
(7) The ballot box shall be so constructed that the
ballot papers can be introduced therein but cannot be
withdrawn.
(8) Every person wishing to record his vote shall do in
person can be introduced therein but cannot be
withdrawn.
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
(14 of 19)
[CW-19497/2026]
97. Removal of difficulties.- If any difficulty arises
in the implementation of these rules, the State
Election Commission or any authority directed by it,
may by an order in writing give directions as may
appear necessary to it for the removal of any such
difficulty.”
14.
In terms of the mandate contained under Rules 24 and 25 of
the Rules of 1994, the timeline for polling was fixed on
21.09.2026, between 10.00 AM to 02.00 PM. Rule 52 of the Rules
of 1994 deals with the provision for postponement of poll in case
of emergencies. Rule 52 of the Rules of 1994 states that the State
Election Commission may, for sufficient cause to be recorded in
writing, postpone the date or extend the period fixed for polling in
case of emergencies such as disturbance of the public peace,
natural calamity, etc. It further states that where a poll is so
postponed, the State Election Commission shall endeavor to
conduct the poll as soon as practicable.
15.
Similarly, Rule 53 deals with adjournment of poll. It states
that if at any election it is not possible to take the poll at any
polling station or the proceedings at any polling station are
interrupted or obstructed by riot, violence and disturbance of the
public peace, natural calamity, the presiding officer for such
polling station may adjourn the poll and shall forthwith inform the
returning officer, who shall in turn report to the commission
accordingly.
16.
Sub Rule 2 of Rule 53 says whenever a poll is adjourned the
Returning Officer shall as soon as may be with the previous
approval of the State Election Commission, notify the date and
hours during which and the polling stations at which the poll shall
(15 of 19)
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
[CW-19497/2026]
recommence and shall not count the votes cast at any such
election until such adjourned poll shall have been completed.
17.
Rule 78(6)(xii) of the Rules of 1994 lays down that the
Returning Officer may extend time for poll, if necessary or may
declare the poll as finally concluded earlier in case all the elected
members holding office have voted.
18.
Now the questions that arise for consideration of this Court is
whether the Returning Officer and the State Election Commission
were right in postponing the polling and counting of the votes
from
21.09.2026
to
25.09.2026?
Whether
such
exercise
conducted by them is legally permissible in terms of the provisions
contained under the Rules of 1994?
19.
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of N.P. Ponnuswami vs.
Returning Officer, Namakkal Constituency and Ors., reported
in 1952 (1) SCC 94, has held that once the election process has
been initiated upon issuance of election programme by the
Election Commission, there can be no interference by the Court in
the election process.
20.
It has been held by the Apex Court that having regard to the
important functions which the legislature has to perform in
democratic countries, it has always been recognized to be a
matter of primary importance that elections should be concluded
as early as possible, according to the time schedule prescribed by
the Election Commission, and all controversial matters and all
disputes arising out of the elections should be postponed till after
the elections are over, so that the election proceedings may not be
unduly retracted or protracted.
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
21.
(16 of 19)
[CW-19497/2026]
In the instant case, this fact is not in dispute that the polling
started at 10.00 AM on the original dated fixed for polling, i.e. on
21.09.2026, and deadline for polling was fixed as 02.00 PM. This
fact is not in dispute that prior to expiry of the aforesaid deadline,
out of the 20 elected members, only 19 elected members cast
their votes and one of the members was absent.
22.
It is worthy to mention here that there was no FIR or
complaint lodged by anyone to the Returning Officer during the
aforesaid period stating that one of the members was abducted
and was unable to cast her vote.
23.
As per the mandate contained under the Rules of 1994, the
counting of votes was required to be conducted immediately after
casting of the votes and closing of the polls in terms of the Rules
36 and 41 of the Rules of 1994. The respondent-authorities were
not justified in adjourning the election process and deferring the
same to a later date, as there existed no such situation as
described under Rules 52 and 53 of the Rules of 1994.
24.
As per the mandate contained under Rules 52 and 53 of the
Rules of 1994, the polling process can be adjourned only in
extreme
circumstances
where
the
polling
is
obstructed
or
interrupted by riots, violence, disturbance of public peace or
natural calamity.
25.
The instant case does not fall under any of the above
circumstances as described under Rules 52 and 53 of the Rules of
1994. As per the mandate contained under Rule 78(6)(xi), the
election process was supposed to be completed on the date fixed
for polling, i.e. on 21.09.2026, within the time so fixed for the said
purpose, i.e. between 10:00 AM to 02:00 PM.
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
26.
(17 of 19)
[CW-19497/2026]
With no stretch of imagination, it can be believed that one of
the members who was not present at the time of polling was
abducted, as there was no such complaint during the aforesaid
hours. The FIR was registered after more than two hours of
closing of the polling hours. Hence, under these circumstances,
the respondent-authorities were duty bound to complete the
election process on the basis of the votes cast on the fateful day,
i.e. on 21.09.2026 between 10:00 AM to 02:00 PM, without
waiting for the person who was absent at the time of polling.
27.
In case the absent person, who is an elected member of
Ward No.10, Municipal Board Khatushyamji, District Sikar, feels
aggrieved and believes that she has been deprived of the
opportunity to participate in the election process as she was not
present at the time of polling for reasons beyond her control, she
is at liberty to assail the election process by way of filing an
election petition in terms of the provisions contained under the
Rajasthan Municipalities Act, 2009 and the Rules of 1994.
28.
Election process is a core tenet of a democratic setup and
the election schedule fixed by the Election Commission should not
be normally interfered with.
29.
This Court is of the considered view that the election
schedule fixed by the State Election Commission shall not be
postponed under any circumstances, except in case of adverse
situations like riots, natural calamity, law and order situation or
any other force majeure condition, which makes it impossible to
hold the election. Mere absence of a voter cannot be treated as an
adverse situation.
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
30.
(18 of 19)
[CW-19497/2026]
The right to vote is a statutory right. It is to be exercised at
the time, place and in the manner prescribed by the Election
Commission. If a voter chooses not to remain present or fails to
remain present at the time of polling, the election cannot be
stalled or re-poll cannot be ordered at his/her instance. If such a
plea is accepted, then there would be no end to elections and
every election would be liable to be postponed on the ground that
one or the other voter could not vote.
31.
The concept of re-poll is provided under the Rules of 1994
only when the polling is vitiated by booth capturing, large scale
rigging, failure of EVM, riots, violence, disturbance of public peace
or natural calamity which affects the free and fair polling. Isolated
absence of a single voter does not fall under any of these
categories. A voter cannot claim his right to vote after expiry of
time fixed for polling.
32.
Rules 63 and 68 of the Rules of 1994 provide a complete
mechanism for counting of votes and declaration of result. Rule 63
deals with counting of votes, and Rule 68 deals with the
declaration of results. The aforesaid Rules are mandatory in
nature. The Returning Officer has no option but to count the votes
and declare the results, immediately after completion of polling.
33.
In the instant case, the polling has already been completed
as per the original programme declared by the State Election
Commission, i.e. on 21.09.2026 between 10:00 AM to 02:00 PM.
Therefore, the Returning Officer is under a statutory obligation to
proceed with counting and declare the result as per Rules 63 and
68 of the Rules of 1994.
(19 of 19)
[2026:RJ-JP:38958]
34.
[CW-19497/2026]
In view of the above, this Court deems it just and proper to
dispose of the petition with the following directions:
i) The election schedule fixed by the State Election
Commission
shall
not
be
postponed
under
any
circumstances, except in case of adverse situations like
riots, violence, disturbance of public peace, natural
calamity etc.
ii) The absence of a single voter at the time of polling
cannot be a ground for re-polling. The impugned order
dated 22.09.2026 passed by the respondent-authorities
stands quashed and set aside.
iii) The Returning Officer is directed to conduct the
counting of votes and declare the results for the post of
Chairman, Municipal Board, Khatushyamji, on the basis of
the votes cast on 21.09.2026 between 10:00 AM to 02:00
PM, strictly in terms of Rule 63 and 68 of the Rules of
1994, preferably within 24 hours from receipt of certified
copy of this order.
iv) The result so declared shall be subject to remedy of
election petition, if available to the petitioner under the
law.
35.
The stay application and all pending applications, if any, also
stand disposed of.
(ANOOP KUMAR DHAND),J
KuD/305
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review