Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:168
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 2nd NOVEMBER, 2016
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------S.B. : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Petitioners
:
1.
Vineet Singh,
S/o Shri Mahender Pratap Singh,
R/o Plot No.114,
Runkata,
NH 2, Agra,
U.P.
2.
A Institute of Hotel Management
through its Promoter Director Vineet Singh,
having its Office at 22/88,
NH 2, Near Canara Bank,
Sikandara,
Agra,
Uttar Pradesh.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
State of Sikkim
represented by and through
the Principal Secretary,
Human Resource and Development Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok.
2.
University Grants Commission
Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg,
New Delhi – 110 002.
3.
Eastern Institute of Integrated Learning
and Management
Jorethang,
South Sikkim.
Writ Petition under Articles 226/227
of the Constitution of India
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Ajay Rathi and Mr. Rahul Rathi, Advocates for the
Petitioners.
Mr. S. K. Chettri, Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Government
Advocates for the State-Respondent No.1.
Mr. Bhusan Nepal, legal Retainer for Respondent No.1.
Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal, Senior Advocate with Mr. Thinlay
Dorjee Bhutia, Advocate for the Respondent No.2.
Mr. Shakeel Ahmed, Ms. Chitra Sharma, Mr. Yogesh Kumar
Sharma and Mr. S. P. Bhutia, Advocates for the Respondent
No.3.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
By filing this Petition under Articles 226/227 of
the Constitution of India, the Petitioners, inter alia, pray for
issuance of a Writ in the nature of Certiorari, to quash the
impugned Order dated 30-04-2015 and to declare that
Degrees awarded to the students who have passed the
examinations
conducted
by
the
Eastern
Institute
for
Integrated Learning in Management University (for brevity
“EIILMU”) are valid and legal and for a Writ in the nature of
Mandamus directing the Respondents to allow the Petitioner
to grant Mark Sheets and Migration Certificates to the
students.
2.
It is the Petitioners’ case that the Petitioner No.1
is the Promoter Director of Petitioner No.2 “A Institute of
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Hotel Management” (for brevity “AIHM”) having its Campus
at Agra, Greater Noida in the State of Uttar Pradesh and in
Guwahati, Assam.
That, the said AIHM commenced in the
year 2006 and provides Graduate and Post Graduate Courses
in Hospitality and Management which are approved by the
Joint Committee of University Grants Commission (UGC)-All
India
Council
for
Technical
Education
(AICTE)-Distance
Education Council (DEC) under the Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Government of India.
That, the
Institute of the Respondent No.3, i.e., EIILMU, came into
existence by the Eastern Institute for Integrated Learning in
Management University, Sikkim Act, 2006 (for short “the Act
of 2006”), with the objective of providing quality job oriented
education after school.
Powers were conferred upon the
EIILMU to run Distance Education Courses provided the said
Courses were not inferior in standard to the Courses run by
the DEC, but no condition was imposed upon it to seek prior
approval or pre-recognition from the DEC. The Committee of
the UGC inspected the premises of the EIILMU on 15/16-032008
and
submitted
a
Report
that
the
EIILMU
has
jurisdiction all over India, but omitted to mention that the
EIILMU has not been accorded permission to open offShore/Study Centres or admission centres outside the State.
It merely mentioned that the status at the time of the Report
was to the effect that no such Centres were established
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
outside the State. That, vide letter dated 22-07-2008 of the
UGC, the EIILMU was informed that it was empowered to
award Degrees as specified by the UGC under Section 22 of
the UGC Act, 1956, but it did not state that the UGC has the
power to authorise any University to award or confer
Diplomas or such action is regulated by the UGC. That, the
letter mentioned that approval of the Statutory Council is to
be taken by the University, wherever required. It is averred
that the Distant Education Council is not a Statutory Council
being a Department of the IGNOU.
approaching,
the
EIILMU
for
On the Petitioner’s
opening
Admission
and
Counseling Centre and being allowed to do so admissions
were taken by the Institute, students enrolled, classes taken,
examinations conducted and results declared, as per the
schedule of the University. The Petitioner was of the belief
that the authorisation was as per the required law and Rules
of the UGC as the Board of Governors of the University
included a Member each of the UGC and the State of Sikkim.
The Mark Sheets of the students who qualified in the
University examinations were sent by the University to the
Institute and made over to the students.
On 01-09-2012,
however, the Station House Officer of Jorethang P.S., lodged
a suo motu FIR against the EIILMU Officials alleging
distribution
of
fake
Mark
Sheets
to
students
without
admission, classes and examinations. It was alleged that the
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
University in violation of the UGC Regulations had illegally
opened Study Centre/off-Campus Study Centres outside the
State of Sikkim.
That, the UGC vide a Public Notice in the
newspaper “The Times of India” dated 12-07-2013 informed
the
general
public
about
advertisements
published
in
national dailies offering opportunities to award University
Degrees through various franchise programmes conducted
by certain Private Institutions and for the first time informed
that the UGC had not granted permission to any Private
University to establish off-Campus/Study Centres. The Joint
Secretary of the UGC vide letter dated 04-09-2013 directed
the Vice Chancellor of the EIILMU to discontinue the Courses
run by it without the approval of the UGC and DEC, under
Distance Mode.
The State Government then deemed it
necessary to take over and run the Management of the
EIILMU through its Officers.
Vide Notifications No.55/DIR
(HE)/HRDD and 56/DIR(HE)/ HRDD both dated 30-04-2015
the general public were informed that the State Government
had declared the dissolution of the University invoking the
powers under Section 47 of the Act of 2006 and students
were restrained from applying for fresh admissions in the
Academic Session 2015-16.
That, vide Notice Ref. No.
56/DIR(HE)/HRDD dated 30-04-2015 it was informed that
regular students of the Campus at Budang, Soreng, could
send duplicate copy of their documents including Mark
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
Sheets
of
the
previous
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
year,
Provisional
Certificates,
Enrolment Number, Admit Card, Registration Number and
any other concerned document to the Department on 07-052015. The documents would be verified after which issuance
of Original Mark Sheets would be communicated. That, the
above Notification viz. Ref. No. 56/DIR(HE)/HRDD dated 3004-2015 is bad in law as it has differentiated between
students who have studied in Sikkim and students who have
studied outside the State even though enrolled as regular
students by the EIILMU. That, students who have appeared
in the examination conducted by the EIILMU cannot be
denied
their
basic
legitimate
right
due
to
any
error
committed by any or all of the Officials of the EIILMU.
Accordingly, the prayers reflected hereinabove.
3.
In its Counter-Affidavit, the Respondent No.1
averred that the Respondent No.3-EIILMU has been under
controversy since 2012 when the Sikkim Police registered a
suo motu FIR against the Sponsoring Body of the EIILMU for
sale of fake Degrees and Certificates.
Subsequently, the
Enforcement Directorate issued a Provisional Attachment
Order on the property and Bank Accounts of Respondent
No.3 under Section 5 of the Prevention of Money Laundering
Act, 2002, and the UGC had issued directions to the EIILMU
to immediately close down its Distance Education Courses
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
and its Centres which had been opened without any approval
of the Statutory Bodies. The activities of EIILMU came to a
standstill after the suspension of the examination by its
Management on 24-12-2014 the reason being the absence of
the Management Authorities including the Vice Chancellor,
Registrar, Deputy Controller of Examination, Faculties, etc.,
raising apprehension amongst students and law and order
situation in the EIILMU. The Respondent No.1 to contain the
situation issued instructions to the Respondent No.3 through
the Acting Vice Chancellor (“AVC” for brevity) to conduct the
examinations immediately. Despite numerous instructions,
Notices
and
reminders
by
the
Respondent
Respondent No.3 failed to comply.
Respondent
No.3
were
not
Respondent
No.1
took
all
normalcy to the EIILMU.
No.1
the
The employees of the
paid
salaries,
necessary
steps
while
to
the
restore
Ultimately to stem the chaos the
Respondent No.1 took over the EIILMU and conducted the
examinations in the larger interest of the students.
The
Respondent No.3, however, failed to appear before the
Authority to set out their grievances or to resolve their
problems.
The
Respondent
No.3
consequently
took
necessary steps for the regular students, however, with
regard to the Distance Education, the EIILMU was dealing
with it itself and the legality of imparting Distance Education
has been decided by the Division Bench of this High Court in
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Sikkim Manipal University vs. Indira Gandhi National Open
University and Others1. However, it is denied that the EIILMU
was allowed to run Distance Courses without the prior
approval of the competent Authority. It is averred that the
UGC has forwarded a letter dated 04-09-2013 addressed to
the State Government regarding the Courses being run by
EIILMU without the approval of UGC and DEC. That, in view
of the above grounds the Petition requires no consideration.
4.
The Respondent No.2, the UGC, in its Counter-
Affidavit averred that it was constituted under the provisions
of the University Grants Commission Act, 1956 (Act No.3 of
1956) which made provisions for coordination determination
and maintenance of standards of teaching, examination and
research in Universities.
The Commission has been vested
with the power to recommend to any University (i.e., any
University under a Centralised Provincial Act or State Act
recognised by the Commission as per relevant regulations,)
the measures necessary for improvement of University
education and to advise the University upon action to be
taken for the purpose of implementation of the said
recommendations.
It’s functions as provided under the
University Grants Commission Act has been elucidated in the
averments.
That, in order to prevent the mushrooming
growth of Private Universities as also the commercialisation
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
1.
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Judgment dated 26-06-2015 passed in WP(C) No.04 of 2013
of education, the UGC framed the UGC Regulations in 2003
duly notified in the Gazette Notification on 27-12-2003, of
which Regulation 3 deals with Establishment and Recognition
of Private Universities and all Private Universities are
regulated by the Regulations supra with the objective of
ensuing not only proper territorial jurisdiction of each Private
University but also to ensure that concerned University attain
standards in terms of physical and academic infrastructure.
Thus, under Regulation 3.3, a Private University established
under a State Act shall ordinarily operate within the State
concerned and after the development of the main Campus,
in
exceptional
circumstances,
after
five
years
of
its
existence, the University may be permitted to open offCampus Centres/off-Shore Campuses and Study Centres,
subject to the fulfilment of conditions as prescribed under
the Regulations.
This is with the objective of ensuring not
only the proper territorial
jurisdiction of each Private
University, but also to ensure that the concerned University
attains
minimum
standards
in
terms
of
physical
and
academic infrastructure before proceeding to expand further
within its permissible territorial limits. So far as the Distance
Education Programme (DEP) is concerned, earlier it was
controlled by the DEC. The Government of India vide its
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Notification dated 01-03-1995 duly notified in the Gazette
Notification dated 08-04-1995, made it mandatory to obtain
approval from DEC (IGNOU), New Delhi, for award of all
Qualifications/Degrees
by
Universities
through
Distance
Education Mode (DEM). On 10-05-2007, a Memorandum of
Understanding (MoU) was signed between the UGC, AICTE
and DEC for an initial period of three years to be reviewed
from time to time constituting a Joint Committee to ensure
quality of technical and general education offered through
Distance and Mixed Mode and to prevent duplication of
efforts in streamlining of activities. The UGC and the AICTE
agreed to utilise the expertise and involvement of DEC in
such functions for review of the Programmes and Courses,
Curricula,
norms,
etc.
In
November,
2007,
the
UGC
requested the Director, DEC, IGNOU to ensure that approval
letters are issued as per the provisions laid down in Clause 9
of the MoU for Professional Courses. Meetings held between
the Secretary, Department of Higher Education (Distance
Learning
Division),
Ministry
of
Human
Resource
Development, convened on 19-02-2008 and subsequent
meeting of UGC-AICTE-DEC held on 11-05-2009 so also
details of the meeting held between the UGC-AICTE-DEC
have also been put forth in the Affidavit.
That, in the
meeting between the UGC-AICTE-DEC it was, inter alia,
decided that the jurisdiction prescribed in the Act of the
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
University or MOA or Deemed University would be strictly
adhered to subject to the decision of Prof. Yashpal and
Another vs. State of Chhattishgarh and Others2, wherein the
State Universities have been directed not to operate outside
the jurisdiction of the respective States. Thus, the UGC did
not delegate its power to the Joint Committee supra and
actions suggested by the Committee, was required to be
placed before the Chairman, UGC and thereafter, the
Commission for information.
2012,
the
Ministry
of
Vide a letter dated 29-12-
Human
Resource
Development,
Government of India, inter alia, directed the UGC and the
AICTE to act as Regulators for Higher Education (excluding
Technical Education) and Technical Education through Open
and Distance Learning (ODL) Mode.
However, if the
Universities were offering any Programme in the ODL Mode,
they would require recognition from UGC-AICTE and NCTE
and such other Regulators of the Conventional Mode of
education in those areas of study. The UGC and AICTE were
also
directed
to
develop
appropriate
Regulations
for
maintaining standards in ODL Programme/Courses to create
necessary physical infrastructure, qualified manpower and to
discharge such responsibilities to prepare an Action Plan. On
24-01-2013, Statute 28 of IGNOU which established the DEC
in 1991, was repealed and Notification issued on 01-05-
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
2013, dissolving the DEC.
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
It was further averred that so far
as a State Private University established by an Act of State
2. (2005) 5 SCC 420
Legislature is concerned, it is empowered to award Degrees
as specified by the UGC under Section 22 of the UGC Act,
1956, at its main Campus in Regular Mode with the approval
of
Statutory
Bodies/Councils,
whenever
it
is
required.
However, such a University is not competent to extend its
jurisdiction and operations beyond the State in which it has
been established.
That, the UGC vide its letter dated 16-04-
all
informed
State
Governments
that
Private
Universities established by the State Governments have
opened
off-Campuses/Study
Centres
and
also
created
franchise in the name of DEP, outside the States and
requested the States to take suitable steps for amending the
existing Acts to bring it in conformity with the observations
of the Apex Court in Prof. Yashpal2 (supra) and to stop all
State/State Private Universities from operating beyond the
territorial jurisdiction of their respective States.
This letter
was also sent to the Vice Chancellors of all Private
Universities.
A Public Notice dated 27-06-2013 was issued
on the same lines advising students not to take admissions
in
unapproved
Study
Centres,
off-Campus
Centres,
franchisee Institutions, Colleges/Institution claiming to be
affiliated with Private Universities or Deemed Universities.
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
That, as Distance Education is a part of Higher Education,
the Institutes require prior approval of the UGC to start the
DEP which in the instant case was not obtained.
That, the
Gazette Notification dated 01-03-1995 made it clear that
prior approval of DEC would be required for any Degree in
Distance Mode to be valid and legal. The UGC had accorded
recognition
to
EIILMU
for
only
three
Distance
Mode
Programmes vide its letter dated 09-09-2009 (Annexure R11), i.e., in B.A. (Hospitality & Tourism), BCA and MBA. On
receipt of complaints by the DEC and the UGC from various
individuals against the Respondent No.3 regarding numerous
Programmes being run through Distance Mode, opening of
unauthorised
Study
Centres,
Franchising
of
Higher
Education, issuing Degrees to students, selling degrees in
India, etc., a fact Finding Committee was constituted by the
UGC vide letter dated 26-06-2014 and the Vice Chancellor
EIILMU informed accordingly.
The Fact Finding Committee
after making necessary enquiries, recommended dissolution
of the EIILMU and Public Notice was issued on 05-08-2015
cautioning the students not to take admission in the EIILMU
and/or any of its Centres/Campuses/DEPs.
Thereafter, the
Notice dated 30-04-2015 [Annexure P-9 (colly)] was issued
by the State Government regarding dissolution of the
EIILMU.
It is admitted that the UGC also had recommended
to the EIILMU on 04-09-2013 immediate closure of all the
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Admission-cum-Counselling Centres as it was in complete
violation of the UGC Regulations.
That, the Petitioner’s
Institution was never recognised by the Respondent No.2 for
Regular or Distance Mode Programmes or as a Centre of the
Respondent No.3, while letter dated 09-09-2009 (Annexure
R-11) permitting EIILMU to start Distance Mode Education
clearly prohibited opening Centres outside the State of
Sikkim.
Thus, with the passing of the Notice dated 30-04-
2015 of Respondent No.1 the powers conferred on the
University to award Degrees automatically stands withdrawn
and the Petition be dismissed as whatever grounds have
been taken were settled by this Court in Sikkim Manipal
University1, hence the Writ Petition is not maintainable.
5.
The Respondent No.3 in its response denied that
the students who appeared in the examinations conducted
by the EIILMU are denied their basic legitimate rights due to
any error committed by any or all the Officials of the EIILMU
when it was being run by the Respondent No.3.
That this
Court may issue appropriate Writ or direction or pass such
orders as deemed fit.
6.
Advancing
his
arguments
for
the
Petitioner,
Learned Counsel drew the attention of this Court to
Notification
No.28/LD/2006
dated
03-04-2006
and
contended that Section 8(a) of the said Notification gives the
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
EIILMU powers to establish, maintain and recognise such
Regional Centres and Study Centres as may be determined
by the EIILMU from time to time in the manner laid down by
the Statutes.
That, Section 8(c) empowers the EIILMU to
confer Degrees, Diplomas, Charters, Certificates and other
Academic Distinctions and Professional Designations in the
manner and under conditions laid down in the Statutes.
That, the Member, EIILMU consisted of representatives of
the UGC and of the HRDD, Government of Sikkim, therefore,
it is evident that both the Authorities were aware of the
EIILMU
having
allowed
the
Petitioner
to
commence
admissions in the Engineering Courses off-Campus.
That,
the Notice bearing Ref. No.56/DIR(HE)/HRDD dated 30-042015
differentiates
between
regular
students
and
off-
Campus students as provisions were made after closure of
the EIILMU for the regular students to send duplicate copies
of documents including Mark Sheets, Provisional Certificate,
Enrolment Number, Admit Card, Registration Number and
any other document to Department of HRDD by 07-05-2015.
That, the Notice also provides that after due verification of
the duplicate documents further
information would
communicated
Original
for
issuance
of
Mark
be
Sheets,
Migration Certificate and Degrees, as the case may be. No
reference has been made to the off-Campus students which
the Petitioner had recruited in terms of the permission
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
granted to it by the Respondent No.3.
In this regard,
attention is drawn to Annexure P3, a letter issued by the
Authorised Signatory of EIILMU addressed to the Petitioner
No.1
dated
16-10-2010
whereby
the
Petitioner
was
appointed as the Non Exclusive Admission & Counselling
Centre (EACC) of the Respondent No.3.
he
was
also
authorised
to
Vide the said letter,
facilitate
Registration
and
Admission to private candidates into EIILMU, Sikkim.
He
was further authorised to admit students in Engineering
Diploma Programmes offered by EIILMU. Therefore, on the
strength of this letter, the Petitioner has taken steps and
recruited the students who have now been left without any
Degree inasmuch as only Provisional Degrees have been
provided to them and with the issuance of Notice of closure
of the EIILMU as also the Notice differentiating the Regular
and off-Campus students, the future of the off-Campus
students
recruited
by
the
Petitioner
are
in
jeopardy.
Therefore, the Petitioners seek quashing of the Notification
dated 30-04-2015.
Learned Counsel while referring to the
Report of the Inspection Committee on its visit to the EIILMU
on
15/16-03-2008
submitted
that
Serial
No.5
of
the
Inspection Report (Annexure P1) noted that the “Territorial
Jurisdiction” of the EIILMU was “all over India and Courts in
the Indian Territory of Delhi”. That, the Report at Sl. No.21
in response to the query “whether any off-Campus or
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Study/off-Shore Centre or Admission” as ‘No’.
Since the
Inspection was conducted in 2008, it was clear that at that
time there was no off-Campus or off-Shore Centre of the
EIILMU. Permission to the Petitioner was given only in 2010
and was not reflected therein.
The Inspection Report
nowhere revealed that off-Campus and off-Shore Centres
were not permitted by the UGC.
That, the Respondent
University is estopped from retracting its earlier statement
granting authorisation to the Petitioner.
That, unlike the
UGC or the AICTE the DEC is not a Statutory Body and does
not enjoy powers to compel its Regulations, consequently
the prayers made in the Petition be granted.
7.
Per contra, the question raised by Learned Senior
Advocate for the Respondent No.2 while advancing his
arguments was firstly on the point of locus standi of the
Petitioner.
According to him, the Petition itself indicates
“That the petitioner is promoter Director of A Institute of Hotel
Management popularly known and herein after referred to as
AIHM having it’s Campus at AGRA and Greater Noida in the State
of Uttar Pradesh and one campus in Guwahati, Assam”.
That,
the Petition also reflects that the Institute provides Graduate
and Post-Graduate Course in Hospitality and Management.
Therefore, the question is when it is an Institute for
Hospitality, how could the Institute be offering a Course in
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
Engineering. In the next leg of his argument, it is submitted
that the aggrieved students have not approached the Court
neither have they authorised the Petitioner to appear and
place their case before the Court on their behalf. Therefore,
the question of quashing the Notice does not arise. That, in
fact, the IGNOU vide letter dated 09-09-2009 (Annexure R11) addressed to the Vice Chancellor, EIILMU, based on the
recommendations of the Joint Committee of UGC-AICTE-DEC
had been accorded recognition for the Academic Year 200910 for offering a number of Programmes through Distance
Education Mode.
One of such Programmes was B.A.
(Hospitality & Tourism) as found in Sl. No.1 of Table 1 of the
letter. Table 2, specifies Programmes not recommended by
the IGNOU while include Diploma in Mechanical Engineering.
Therefore, the question of the EIILMU granting permission to
the Petitioner to recruit students in Mechanical Engineering,
Electrical Engineering or any other Engineering Course did
not arise as the EIILMU itself had not been permitted to run
Engineering Courses.
In fact, if one were to carefully
scrutinise the contents of the letter dated 16-10-2010 by the
EIILMU to the Petitioner No.1, it only authorises him “to
admit” students into Engineering, Diploma Programmes
offered by the EIILMU. On this count, it is reiterated that in
the first instance, the EIILMU itself did not have permission
to run Engineering Courses and secondly, the letter merely
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
authorises the Petitioner “to admit” students into the
Engineering Diploma offered by the EIILMU, but does not
authorise him to admit off-Campus students or to offer
Courses to them in such Campus. Therefore, the Petitioner
is responsible for all acts committed by him and can hold no
one responsible. It is also contended that as per the letter
dated 09-09-2009 (Annexure R-11), with regard to territorial
jurisdiction for offering Programmes through Distance Mode,
the latest UGC Notifications will prevail over all previous
Notifications
and
Circulars.
That,
as
per
the
UGC
Notification, State Universities (both Private as well as
Government funded) can offer Programmes only within the
State and Deemed Universities from the headquarters and in
no case outside the State.
However, Deemed Universities
could seek permission to open off-Campus Centres in other
States and offer DEPs through the approved off-Campus
Centres only with the approval of the UGC and DEC.
The
Section specifies that the territorial jurisdiction of EIILMU
shall be Sikkim State and the DEC prohibits franchising all
Study Centres, thus EIILMU would not franchise any Study
Centres. Attention of this Court was invited to letter dated
04-09-2014 (Annexure R-14) addressed to the Station
House Officer by the Deputy Director of the UGC clarifying
therein that the territorial jurisdiction of the EIILMU was
confined
to
the
State
of
Sikkim
which
was
duly
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
communicated vide DEC letter.
territorial
jurisdiction
policy,
That, in light of the UGC
examinations
were
to
be
conducted at its headquarters or its own centres within the
State of Sikkim only. Apart from the above, the letter lays
down that the recognition accorded by the erstwhile DEC was
only for one year, i.e., 2009-10.
Thus, any Programme
offered by the University are not recognised by the DEB,
UGC after the said Academic Year 2009-10. That, in view of
the documents on record, the prayers put forth by the
Petitioner require no consideration.
8.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent No.3 in his
arguments submitted that the averments in its response
were being relied upon and that the DEC was a part of the
IGNOU and permission had been granted to the EIILMU to
open off-Shore Centres.
9.
I have considered the rival contentions put forth
by Learned Counsel at length and meticulously examined all
the documents on record.
10.
What arises for consideration before this Court is,
whether the Petitioner can seek quashing of Notice bearing
Ref. No.56/DIR(HE)/HRDD dated 30-04-2015, inter alia, on
the
ground
that
off-Campus
students
were
being
differentiated as against the regular students after closure of
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
the EIILMU, in view of the letter dated 16-10-2010 of the
Respondent No.3, authorising him to admit students in the
Engineering Diploma Programmes.
11.
In this regard, we may first refer to Notice
bearing Ref. No.55/DIR(HE)/HRDD dated 30-04-2015. Vide
this Notice, the HRDD, Government of Sikkim, Respondent
No.1 reads as follows;
“………………………………..
It is to inform to all concerned that State
Government has approved dissolution of EIILM
University under Section 47 of the EIILM University
Act 2006. Hence, no students should apply for fresh
admission in EIILM University for the forth coming
academic session of 2015-16.
…………………………………………..”
This Notice is not under challenge in this Writ Petition.
It is the second Notice of the same date, i.e., 30-04-2015,
bearing Ref. No.56/DIR(HE)/HRDD which is being referred to
by the Petitioners. For better understanding of the matter, it
would be expedient to reproduce the relevant portion of the
Notice hereunder;
“…………………………………..……………
It is to inform to all students who were
registered as regular student (sic) in EIILM
University, Budang Campus, Soreng, West Sikkim
that the Department is in compilation of the mark
sheets, migration Certificate and Degrees of
previous year as well as current year. Hence, it is
directed that the regular students who have studied
within Sikkim can send the duplicate copies of
documents including previous year mark sheets,
provisional certificates, Enrolment Number, Admit
Card, Registration Number and any other concern
(sic) document to the Department by 07th May,
2015.
………………………………………………………
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
After due verification of the documents further
information would be communicated for issue of
original mark sheets, migration certificate and
degrees, as the case may be.
…………………………………………………….”
12.
It is the specific contention of the Petitioner that
the Department has made provision of issuing Original Mark
Sheets, Migration Certificate and Degrees only for students
who have registered as regular students in EIILMU, Budang
Campus, Soreng, West Sikkim, while at the same time,
although
he
had
been
accorded
permission
by
the
Respondent No.2 to admit students in Engineering Diploma
Programmes, no similar provisions exists for these students.
Now, in this connection, in the first instance, it would be
essential to refer to letter dated 09-09-2009 (Annexure R11).
The letter is addressed to the Vice Chancellor of the
Respondent No.3 by the Director, DEC, IGNOU, New Delhi,
informing the Vice Chancellor as follows;
“………………………………………………….
With reference to your application seeking
recognition of Distance Education Council for offering
programmes through distance education mode, I
have been directed to inform you that based on the
recommendations of the Joint Committee of UGCAICTE-DEC, your University/Institution has been
accorded recognition for a period of one year
academic year w.e.f. academic year 2009-10 for
offering following programmes through distance
education mode:
………………………………………….”
Thereafter, a Table has been prepared in which the
First Table pertains to “1. Programmes recommended for one
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
year” which included B.A. (Hospitality & Tourism) which has
a duration of three years, BCA with a duration of three years
and MBA for three years.
The next table reads as “2.
Programmes not recommended”, which are eight in number,
and include B.A. (Fashion Technology), BCA-MCA Integrated,
MCA,
M.Sc
(Biotechnology),
Communication),
Diploma
in
MA
(Journalism
Mechanical
&
Mass
Engineering,
Diploma in Electrical Engineering, Diploma in Electronics and
Communication.
Apart from the above Tables, it is also
specified that the territorial jurisdiction of the Institution
shall be in Sikkim State. Paragraph 6 of the letter specifies
that ―
“6.
Regarding territorial jurisdiction for offering
programmes through distance mode the latest
UGC notifications will prevail all over previous
notifications and circulars.
As per the UGC
notification, State Universities (both private as
well as Govt funded) can offer programmes
only within the State and Deemed Universities
from the Headquarters and in no case outside
the state. However, Deemed Universities may
seek the permission to open off campus
centres in other states and offer distance
education programmes through the approved
off campuses only after approval of UGC and
DEC. Central Universities will also adhere to
the UGC norms. The territorial jurisdiction for
the institutions (both private as well as Govt
funded) shall be the Headquarters, and in no
case outside the State. Thus, the territorial
jurisdiction of your Institution shall be Sikkim
State.”
Hence, this letter speaks for itself and no further
elucidation is necessary.
Despite such a clear cut letter
which succinctly lays down the parameters within which
State Universities (both Private as well as Government
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
funded) were to work under, the Respondent No.3 has
chosen to issue letter dated 16-10-2010 (Annexure P3) to
the Petitioner.
Assuming that the Petitioner cannot be
faulted for having recruited students to the Engineering
Diploma being unaware of the provisions mentioned in letter
dated 09-09-2009 (Annexure R-11), his fault lies in the fact
that although he was merely authorised to admit students in
the Engineering Diploma Programmes offered by the EIILMU
he has proceeded to conduct classes, give examinations and
results. In fact, he has been appointed as a “Non Exclusive
Admission & Counseling Center”.
Nowhere does the letter
permit him to give Classes,
run the Course for the
Engineering Diploma or empower him to issue degrees to the
students. Besides the above facts, it is also evident that the
communication between the Petitioner No.1 and the EIILMU
(Annexure P3) vide which the Petitioner was authorised to
“admit students in Engineering Diploma Programmes offered by
EIILM University” was not brought to the notice of the UGC,
DEC or for that matter to the HRDD, Government of Sikkim,
who were in the dark about such communication shared
between the Petitioner and the Respondent No.3.
All
correspondence on record for sure do not indicate any
permission by the UGC to open off-Campus Centres or Study
Centres to the EIILMU and even when permission was
granted for Distance Education Mode for three Courses, it
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
was only for the Academic Year 2009-10.
Therefore, the
EIILMU blatantly and in clear violation of the directions of the
IGNOU which was based on the recommendations of the
Joint Committee of UGC-AICTE-DEC, issued letter dated 1610-2010, Annexure P3, to the Petitioner No.1.
It is thus
apparent that neither the HRDD nor the UGC were aware of
the arrangement and communication between the EIILMU
and the Petitioner, and, therefore, now the Petitioner cannot
be heard to say that the HRDD is making a differentiation in
the off-Campus students and the regular students, when
they are devoid of knowledge of any such arrangements
between the Petitioner and the Respondent No.3. It may be
reiterated for emphasis that the Petitioner was not even
authorised to offer the Course and run Classes or issue
Diplomas/Degrees to the students.
As pointed out by the
Learned Senior Counsel for the Respondent No.2 the
allegedly aggrieved students have not approached the Court
added to which the Petitioner was only a Promoter Director
of “A Hotel Management Institute”, how he was equipped or
had the wherewithal to offer Courses in the Engineering
Programmes, is beyond the comprehension of this Court.
One also needs to mull over the averment of the Petitioner
that the UGC vide a Public Notice in the newspaper “The
Times of India” dated 12-07-2013 (Annexure P-6) informed
the general public about advertisement published in national
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
dailies offering opportunities to award University Degrees
through various franchise Programmes conducted by certain
Private Institutions and for the first time informed that the
UGC have not granted permission to any Private University
to establish off-Campus/Study Centres. The above Notice is
evidently in the knowledge of the Petitioner who as per
Annexure P-3 dated 16-10-2010 was authorised by the
Respondent No.3 to admit students in the Engineering
Diploma
Programmes
October, 2010, itself.
offered
by
Respondent
No.3
in
Why he exercised restraint from
taking necessary steps against the Respondent No.3 in view
of the facts and circumstances and also bringing the facts to
the notice of Respondents No.1 and 2 has not been
explained. If the notice was issued in 2013 and was within
his knowledge it is questionable as to why he took up
cudgels for the allegedly aggrieved students only on 10-092015 by filing the instant Writ Petition.
In addition to the
above, it was also averred “That vide letter dated 4.9.2013, the
Joint Secretary of the University Grants Commission Shri A. K.
Dogra directed the Vice Chancellor of the EIILM University to at
once discontinue the courses run by the EIILM University under
distance mode through study centre without the approval of the
UGC and DEC. ……….……” “………….. and directed the Universities
that (i) courses under distance mode can be conducted only after prior
approval of UGC; (ii) immediately close down all the ‘Admission-
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
cum-Counselling
Centres’
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
which
are
admitting
students
for
courses run under distance mode. ……………” (Annexure P-8).
The Petitioner undoubtedly was seized of this letter, but did
not deem it essential to bring his position to the Notice of the
Respondents No.1 and 2 and neither did he question the
Respondent No.3.
I also find that since the Petitioner has
taken upon himself to file this Petition and none of the
allegedly aggrieved students have deigned it fit to do so, the
act of the Petitioner smacks of forestalling thereby preempting steps that may be taken against him by off-Campus
students recruited by him.
His conduct in rushing to the
Court reinforces this assumption as he admittedly has not
approached the HRDD, Government of Sikkim, with his
grievances on closure of the University. He has not deemed
it essential to inform the Respondents No.1 and 2 of the
pitfalls he has had to endure, but has approached the Court
without exhausting the other remedies available to him.
The question of invoking the doctrine of promissory estoppel
by the Petitioner against any of the Respondents in the facts
and circumstance does not arise.
13.
In the result, the Writ Petition is dismissed.
14.
No order as to costs.
2016:SHC:168
WP(C) No.56 of 2015
Vineet Singh and Another
vs.
State of Sikkim and Others
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
02-11-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds
Internet : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review