Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Jurisdiction)
DATED: 11th August, 2017
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. M. C. No. 20 of 2014
Petitioner :
Vinay Rai,
S/o Late Kulwant Rai,
Aged about 65 years,
R/o 12, Aurangzeb Lane,
New Delhi.
VERSUS
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
AND
Crl. M. C. No. 21 of 2014
Petitioner :
Vinay Rai,
S/o Late Kulwant Rai,
Aged about 65 years,
R/o 12, Aurangzeb Lane,
New Delhi.
VERSUS
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
Criminal Miscellaneous Petitions under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Shakeel Ahmed and Mr. Yogesh Kumar Sharma, Advocates
for the Petitioner.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Additional Public Prosecutor with Mr. S.K.
Chettri, Assistant Public Prosecutor and Mr. Thinlay Dorjee
Bhutia, Advocate for the Respondent.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
By filing these Petitions under Section 482 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter „Cr.P.C.), the Petitioner
seeks quashing of the Charge-Sheet, the cognizance Order dated
5.6.2013 and subsequent proceedings of the then learned Chief
Judicial Magistrate (South and West) at Namchi, in General Register
Case No. 119/2013, arising out of FIR No. 51/2012, dated 1.9.2012,
under Sections 420/467/471/201/120B of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 (hereinafter „IPC‟), against the Petitioner herein. (Presently
pending before the learned Judicial Magistrate (East) at Gangtok, Sikkim, as
General Registrar Case No. 21 of 2013, renumbered as 819 of 2013).
2.
Crl. M. C No. 20 of 2014 and Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014
are being disposed of by this common Order, as they both pertain to
the same FIR.
3.
It is indeed pertinent to advert briefly to the background
of the filing of the instant Petitions. The Petitioner along with two
others, were before this Court in Crl. M. C. No. 17/2013, Crl. M. C.
No. 18/2013, Crl. M.C. No. 22/2013, Crl. M.C. No.23/2013 and Crl.
M.C. No. 24 of 2013, praying for quashing of the First Information
Report (for short „FIR‟) and the entire Charge-Sheet filed against
them, under Sections 406/420/467/120B/34 of the IPC, as detailed
hereinabove. This Court, on due consideration of the matter was of
the view that, prima facie, there were sufficient materials to
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
continue the proceedings against the accused persons and dismissed
the Petitions vide a common Order dated 15.10.2014. Against the
Order of this Court, the Petitioner approached the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court in Special Leave to Appeal (Criminal) Nos. 8923-8924/2014,
Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim, seeking permission to bring additional
facts and file additional documents. The Supreme Court
on
1.12.2014, ordered as follows;
“……........………………………………………………………….
Mr. Kapil Sibal, learned senior counsel
for the petitioner seeks leave to withdraw the
special leave petition pointing out that certain
documents have not been produced before the
High Court and hence to rely upon those
documents.
He also prays for liberty to pursue
appropriate remedy by placing such facts
before the High Court in the matter.
This special leave petition is not
pressed and we have not expressed any
opinion on the merits of the case. All points
raised are kept open before the High Court
and the High Court will decide the same in
accordance with law. Liberty is granted to
apply before the High Court.
Special Leave Petition is dismissed as
withdrawn.
………………………………………………………………………….”
Hence, the instant Petitions filed with additional documents
being Annexures P-6, P-7, P-8 and P-9 and points urged in relation
to the documents and the aforestated prayer.
4.
The Petitioner‟s case is that the Eastern Institute for
Integrated Learning in Management University (for brevity „EIILM
University‟), was established vide Notification No. 28/LD/2006 dated
3.4.2006, by enacting the “Eastern Institute for Integrated Learning
in Management University, Sikkim Act, 2006 being Act No. 4 of 2006
(hereinafter „EIILM University Act, 2006‟). The sponsor of the said
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
University was EIILM, Kolkata, West Bengal, a Unit of Malvika
Foundation, New Delhi. A Suo Motu FIR, being FIR No. 51/2012
dated
1.9.2012, under
Sections
406/420/467/120‟B‟
IPC
was
registered by the Station House Officer, Jorethang Police Station,
South Sikkim, making various allegations against the Management
of the EIILM University, where the name of the Petitioner found
mention sans his specific role and position in the University. He was
granted anticipatory bail vide Order of this Court dated 15.1.2013.
That, he has ceased to be a Trustee of the Rai Foundation or of the
Malvika Foundation, having resigned therefrom on 9.11.2001 and
22.3.2004, respectively. The Investigating Officer (for short „I.O.‟)
despite being seized of the matter submitted Charge-Sheet against
him on 6.5.2013.
5.
The learned Trial Court vide its Order dated 5.6.2013,
took cognizance in a routine manner without application of judicial
mind and summoned the Petitioner and others named therein, to
face trial. The Police failed to collect any legally admissible evidence
against the Petitioner and the statement of witnesses under Sections
161 and 164 of the Cr.P.C. do not support the Prosecution case. The
Charge-Sheet fails to disclose what conspiracy the Petitioner had
entered into and a wrongful reference has been made to a few
emails responded to by the Petitioner in his advisory capacity, which
were without promise of any illegal act and are not admissible in
evidence. The Police have wrongfully linked the Rai Foundation
Trustees
therein
with
the
Petitioner
treating
him
as
the
owner/beneficiary of the Trust when the Trust is a Charitable Trust,
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
duly registered under Section 12 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The
EIILM University has been granted accreditation by the University
Grants Commission (for short „UGC‟), under Section 22 of the
University Grants Commission Act, hence, the question of the
Petitioner conspiring with the EIILM University does not arise.
6.
That,
allegations
in
the
Charge-Sheet
about
the
pendency of Central Bureau of Investigation matters against the
Petitioners are sub judice and cannot be referred to in the instant
matter. That, the Police have relied on Annexure C-6, statements of
the Axis Bank, to establish that large amounts of money were
transferred to the Petitioner but the statements extending from
18.3.2005 to 4.4.2013 reveal that only Rs.4,49,941/- (Rupees four
lakhs, forty-nine thousand, nine hundred and forty-one) only, was
paid to the Petitioner by the Rai Foundation as consultancy charges.
It is prayed that in the absence of any materials to make out a case
against the Petitioner under any of the afore cited provisions of the
IPC and there being no concept of vicarious liability in criminal
proceedings, this Court may quash the proceedings as prayed.
7.
In response, the State-Respondent averred that the
Petitioner had agitated the same facts before this Court in the
earlier Petitions which have been dismissed with an observation that
there are prima facie materials against him. That, the suo motu case
was registered after conducting a preliminary inquiry and obtaining
permission from the government for registration of the case. That,
the Petitioner appeared after four months of absconsion from the
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
Investigating Agency and was thereafter granted anticipatory bail.
The statements of the Officers of Human Resource Development
Department prove that the Petitioner was the Chairman and the
Founder of Malvika Trust, duly corroborated by documentary
evidence being the „Minutes‟ of the relevant Meeting annexed with
the Charge-Sheet.
8.
That, upon search warrant being issued by the learned
Chief Judicial Magistrate, South and West Sikkim, in connection with
the case, when the Investigating Team reached the location at the
Delhi Head Office, it was found abandoned, the documents and
computers having been removed and the officials incommunicado.
The statements of the students and other official witnesses prove
that the students were cheated by the Members/Management of the
EIILM
University.
Miscellaneous
Case
Although,
the
Petitioner
No.
of
2013,
had
denied
in
Criminal
receiving
any
remuneration, in contradiction thereof, he now admits receipt of
certain amounts by way of remuneration. It is also averred that the
Petitioner has responded to the email of one Henok Guangul, as the
Head of the University rather than a Consultant. As the Petitioner is
stated to be the overall In-Charge of the Rai Foundation and EIILM
University, the responsibility of any action taken by the University
falls on the Petitioner. That, the documents as per directions of this
Court were filed in the previous matter (Annexure P-17), after which
the Court being satisfied dismissed all the Petitions so filed under
Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. That, in the statements recorded under
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
Sections 161 and 164 of the Cr.P.C., the Petitioner has been named
as the overall Chairperson.
9.
A Rejoinder was filed to the said response of the State,
contending that facts and documents regarding the resignation of
the Petitioner from Malvika Foundation and Rai Foundation were
never pleaded or annexed with the previous Petitions and were
subsequent to the Order of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court. The
Petitioner claims ignorance of any search operation carried out by
the State-Respondent in its Delhi Office and that in the absence of
any case against the Petitioner, the Petition be allowed in terms of
the prayers made.
10.
In Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014, the Petitioner reiterated the
Orders of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court dated 1.12.2014 and averred
that the Investigating Agency had lodged FIR No. 92 of 2013 dated
6.5.2013, under Sections 467/468/471/181/120B of the IPC at the
Sadar Police Station, Gangtok. The Petitioner herein, was named in
the FIR with similar allegations as those in FIR No. 51/2012. FIR No.
92 of 2013, was challenged before this Court and quashed vide
Order of this Court dated 4.6.2013. The Investigating Agency
carried out further investigation under FIR No. 51/2012 and filed
supplementary Charge-Sheet.
11.
The Petitioner is, thus, aggrieved with the contents of
the supplementary Charge-Sheet which alleges that one Mandeep
Kaur had never attended regular classes nor visited the campus in
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
Sikkim but had completed the course via distance mode while the
University had reflected it as regular mode. Further, she was
awarded a degree by way of distance education without the
approval of the Distance Education Council (for short „DEC‟). In fact,
Mandeep Kaur had pursued M.A. in Education from the Directorate
of Distance Learning of EIILM University, as evident from the
admission-cum-examination form, duly signed by her, clearly
mentioning that she is pursuing the course from distance learning
mode. Her statements make no allegations against the Petitioner.
The Police have falsely alleged that Mandeep Kaur obtained a
government job on the basis of a degree of EIILM University, when
in fact she is working in a Private College. The allegation in respect
of forgery of document is also void, as the opinion of the Regional
Forensic Science Laboratory confirms that the degrees of the
University bear genuine signatures of its officials. It is also averred
that this Court vide its Order dated 15.10.2014, wrongly held that
the Petitioner is an Official of the said University, when in fact he
has no hand in the affairs thereof. Pausing here, it would be relevant
to point out that although the Petitioners had approached the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court against the said Order, no argument was
raised on this point as is evident from the Order dated 1.12.2014 of
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, already extracted hereinabove and
agitating it before this forum is inappropriate.
12.
The State-Respondents, thereafter, filed their response
denying and disputing the grounds put forth in the Petition and
averred that the instant matter was heard by this Court and vide its
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
Judgment dated 15.10.2014, was pleased to dismiss the Petitions of
Vinay Rai and others with the following observations;
“............................................................
“15. Thus, there appears to be sufficient
materials against the Petitioners to continue
the criminal prosecution against them.
.................................................................
19.
I am of the view that prima facie there
is sufficient material to continue with the
proceedings against the accused persons.
20.
The Petitions, therefore, are liable to be
dismissed and are hereby dismissed.
…………………………………………………………………………”
13.
That, the instant Petition being similar to the previous
Petitions disposed of by this Court, deserves dismissal.
14.
Learned Counsel for the Petitioner while advancing his
arguments before this Court, reiterated the submissions in the
pleadings and sought to clarify that the Petitioner has been made
vicariously liable in the FIR, as alleged Founder and Chairman of the
Sponsoring Body and President of the Rai Foundation, as would be
evident even from the Charge-Sheet. The Petitioner is nowhere
involved in the running of the EIILM University, wherein the Malvika
Foundation is the Sponsoring Body. Referring to Annexure P-2 dated
22.3.2004, it was urged that the Petitioner had tendered his
resignation from the post of Trustee of the Malvika Foundation and
Annexure P-3, the Minutes of the Meeting of the Board of Trustees
held on 22.3.2004, would testify to this fact. The EIILM University
was established in the year 2006, subsequent to his resignation,
thus, no question of his involvement arises. Further, the Petitioner‟s
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
name does not figure in the list of Trustees dated 31.3.2005 of the
Malvika Foundation.
15.
It was next urged that Annexure P-6 dated 9.11.2001,
would also clearly reveal that the Petitioner had resigned from the
Board of Trustees of the Rai Foundation, while Annexure P-7 the
Minutes of the Meeting of the Board of Trustees held on 9.11.2001,
establishes acceptance of his resignation. That, Annexure P-8 the
Income Tax Returns of the Rai Foundation, does not bear the
Petitioner‟s name as a Trustee. That, Annexure P-9 would indicate
that his email was vinay.rai@raifoundation.org.
16.
It was further canvassed that the occupation of the
Petitioner as per the FIR is Chairman ASSOCHAM, with no
association with Malvika Foundation or the EIILM University, apart
from which no allegations have been made individually against the
Petitioner in the FIR. Drawing the attention of this Court to
Annexure P-12, learned Counsel would argue that that Mrs. Deepa
Basnett, Director, Higher Education, Human Resource Development
Department, had attended the Board of Governors Meeting held on
30.7.2012, at Uttarakhand, where the Petitioner was referred to as
the Founder and Chairperson of EIILM University but at the relevant
time he was not associated with the EIILM University and had
merely gone to deliver a welcome address. Besides, Annexure P-17,
Prospectus of the Distance Education Programme, does not bear his
name. Clarifying the naming of the Petitioner in the Section 161
Cr.P.C. statement of Col. (Retd.) Alok Bhandari, as the „Advisor‟ and
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
„overall In-Charge‟ of the EIILM University, it was contended that no
such designations exist but being a Member of the ASSOCHAM, he
used to advise the University. As per learned Counsel, in the
statement of O.B. Vijayan, it is apparent that the Police have
inserted the word „owner‟ subsequently, following the Petitioner‟s
name, to his detriment, when in fact he is not the owner.
17.
That, although in Annexure P-III, the Petitioner has
been addressed as Founder Chairman of the Sponsoring Body, it
would not imply that the position would subsist for his life time, thus
the statement of Mrs. Deepa Basnett is highly prejudicial to him.
Annexure R-6 relied, on by the State-Respondent showing payment
of Rs.6,00,00,000/- (Rupees six crores) only, to Malvika Foundation,
does not bear the Petitioner‟s name and the only payment that has
been made to him is Rs.79,74,258.73 (Rupees seventy-nine lakhs,
seventy-four thousand, two-hundred fifty-eight and seventy-three
paisa) only, on 7.2.2012 as consultancy fees by the Rai Foundation
over a period of time. An amount of Rs.5,42,808.73 (Rupees five
lakhs, forty-two thousand, eight-hundred-eight and seventy-three
paisa) only, also pertains to monthly amounts deposited in his name
for his works as Advisor to Rai Foundation. To buttress his
submissions on vicarious liability in criminal proceedings, learned
counsel for the Petitioner has placed reliance on Sunil Bharti Mittal vs.
Central Bureau of Investigation1, Thermax Limited and others vs K.M.
Johny and others2, R. Kalyani vs Janak C. Mehta and Others 3
2015(1) SCALE 140
(2011) 13 SCC 412
and
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
Madhavrao Jiwajirao Scindia and Others vs. Sambhajirao Chandrojirao
Angre and Others4. Reliance was also placed on State of Haryana and
others vs Bhajan Lal and Others5, Satish Mehra vs. State of N.C.T. of Delhi
& Ano.6 and Anwar P.V. vs P.K. Basheer & Others7. To prove that he has
not caused any disappearance of evidence, he has relied on V. L.
Tresa vs. State of Kerala8, That, Section 161 Cr.P.C. has no value and
it can only be used for the purposes of corroboration, reliance was
placed on Ashok Tshering Bhutia vs. State of Sikkim9.
18.
The contra, arguments advanced by learned Additional
Public Prosecutor for the State Respondent was that although the
Petitioner claims to have resigned from the University, the Section
161 Cr.P.C. statement of O.B. Vijayan, Vice Chancellor, recorded on
7.5.2013, would reveal that the Petitioner is the owner/Advisor of
EIILM University, while the Statement of Alok Bhandari, Registrar,
places the Petitioner as the Advisor and In-Charge of the EIILM
University.
According
to
Vinod
Kumar
Dahiya,
Controller
of
Examination, the Petitioner is the overall In-Charge and Advisor of
EIILM University and the Section 164 Cr.P.C. statement of R.P.
Banerjee, Member of EIILM University, indicates that the Petitioner
was the Chairman of the University, besides, the Respondent asserts
(2009) 1 SCC 516
(1988) 1 SCC 692
1992 Supp (1) SCC 335
2013 CRI. L.J. 411
(2014) 10 SCC 473
(2001) 3 SCC 549
(2011) 4 SCC 402
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
that rupees six crores has been collected by the Petitioner through
various illegal methods. Learned Additional Public Prosecutor sought
to convince this Court that the Rai Foundation consists of the
Petitioner and his sister, his sons and other family members, as also
the Malvika Trust and the Integrated Institute of Excellence Society
and Rai Business School. The Petitioner is the owner of the Malvika
Trust, Sponsoring Body of the EIILM University, substantiated by the
Statement of witness Tempo Gyamtso, Special Secretary, Technical
Education, Human Resource Development Department, Sikkim, who
stated that the Petitioner introduced himself as Chairman and
Founder of the Sponsoring Body. It was put forth that the modus
operandi of the EIILM University was brought to light by one
Mohabbat Hussain, a resident of Jalpaiguri District, West Bengal,
who having enrolled in EIILM University, went to the University
Distance Education Programme at Badarpur, Delhi, but was told by
the Security Guard that no such office existed at the said place. The
emails between Henok Guangul and the Petitioner indicate that he
was still a part of the EIILM University in 2008. He was also using an
email ID of Rai Foundation which substantiates the fact that he
continued to be a part of the Rai Foundation despite his claim of
resignation. To buttress his submissions, reliance was placed on
Suresh alias Pappu Bhudharmal Kalani vs. State of Maharashtra 10, Om
Wati (Smt) and Another11, Mosiruddin Munshi vs. Mohd. Siraj and
Another12.
(2001) 3 SCC 703
(2001) 4 SCC 333
(2014) 14 SCC 29
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
19.
The rival contentions advanced were heard at length.
The Judgments relied on as also the Order of this Court dated
15.10.2014 and all documents on record, including the emails dated
8.10.2008, received from Henok Guangul, Addis Ababa, Ethopia and
the response dated 9.10.2008, from the Petitioner from his email
vinay.rai@raifoundation.org, were carefully perused. What requires
examination by this Court is whether in the said facts and
circumstances, the powers under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. are to
be exercised.
20.
Dealing first with the parameters of Section 482 of the
Cr.P.C, it may be stated that it is a well established principle that
the Court has inherent powers to act ex debito justitiae to do real
and substantial justice and to prevent abuse of the process of the
Court. But, the power being extraordinary ought to be reserved as
far as possible for extraordinary cases.
21.
In Mosiruddin Munshi vs. Mohd. Siraj and Another (supra),
it was held as follows;
“6. The legal position with regard to exercise of
jurisdiction by the High Court for quashing the first
information report is now well settled. It is not
necessary for us to delve deep there into as the
propositions of law have been stated by this Court in
R. Kalyani v. Janak C. Mehta [(2009) 1 SCC 516] in the
following terms;
“15. Propositions of law which emerge from
the said decisions are:
(1)
The High Court ordinarily would not exercise
its inherent jurisdiction to quash a criminal
proceeding and, in particular, a first
information report unless the allegations
contained therein, even if given face value and
taken to be correct if their entirety, disclosed
no cognizable offence.
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
(2)
For the said purpose the Court, save and
except in very exceptional circumstances,
would not look to any document relied upon
the defence.
(3)
Such a power should be exercised very
sparingly. If the allegations made in the FIR
disclose commission of an offence, the Court
shall not go beyond the same and pass an
order in favour of the accused to hold absence
of any mens rea or actus reus.
(4)
If the allegation discloses a civil dispute, the
same by itself may not be a ground to hold
that the criminal proceedings should not be
allowed to continue.”
7. Yet again in Mahesh Chaudhary v. State of
Rajasthan [(2009) 4 SCC 439] this Court stated the law
thus:
“The principle providing for exercise of the
power by a High Court under Section 482 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure to quash a criminal proceeding
is well known. The Court shall ordinarily exercise the
said jurisdiction, inter alia, in the event the
allegations contained in the FIR or the complaint
petition even if on face value are taken to be correct
in their entirety, does not disclose commission of an
offence.”
22.
This Court in its Order dated 15.10.2014, has already
referred to the categories of cases where inherent powers under
Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. can be invoked. That in State of Haryana
and others vs Bhajan Lal and Others (supra), it was held as follows;
“(1)
Where the allegations made in
the first information report or the complaint,
even if they are taken at their face value and
accepted in their entirety do not prima facie
constitute any offence or make out a case
against the accused.
(2)
Where the allegations in the first
information report and other materials, if any,
accompanying the FIR do not disclose a
cognizable offence, justifying an investigation
by police officers under Section 156(1) of the
Code except under an order of a Magistrate
within the purview of Section 155(2) of the
code.
(3)
Where
the
uncontroverted
allegations made in the FIR or complaint and
the evidence collected in support of the same
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
do not disclose the commission of any offence
and make out a case against the accused.
(4)
Where, the allegations in the
FIR do not constitute a cognizable offence but
constitute only a non-cognizable offence, no
investigation is permitted by a police officer
without an order of a Magistrate as
contemplated under Section 155(2) of the
Code.
(5)
Where the allegations made in
the FIR or complaint are so absurd and
inherently improbable on the basis of which no
prudent person can ever reach a just
conclusion that there is sufficient ground for
proceeding against the accused.
(6)
Where there is an express legal
bar engrafted in any of the provisions of the
Code or the concerned Act (under which a
criminal proceeding is instituted) to the
institution and continuance of the proceedings
and/or where there is a specific provision in
the Code or the concerned Act, providing
efficacious redress for the grievance of the
aggrieved party.
(7) Where a criminal proceeding is
manifestly attended with male fide and/or
where the proceeding is maliciously instituted
with an ulterior motive for wreaking
vengeance on the accused and with a view to
spite him due to private and personal grudge.”
23.
On the anvil of the principles enunciated hereinabove
while considering the investigation undertaken pursuant to the FIR
No. 51/2012, it is, inter alia, revealed that after the EIILM University
came into existence by the EIILMU Act, 2006. The UGC vide its
letter dated 22.7.2008, allowed the University to award degrees, as
specified by the UGC, under Section 22 of the UGC Act, 1956, with
the approval of the Statutory Council wherever required. The
University was allowed to conduct a total of 46 (forty-six)
programmes but had been conducting around 74 courses in the
Distance Education Mode without any authority from the concerned
bodies as enumerated in the Charge-Sheet. Section 10 of the
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
EIILMU Act permitted the University to conduct the programmes as
listed in the Charge-Sheet subject to approval from the concerned
national accreditation bodies, the University, however, obtained
approval only from the Distance Education Council which allowed it
to conduct three courses being B.A. (Hospitality & Tourism), M.B.A.
and B.C.A. for the academic session 2009-10. In May 2012, the DEC
vide a written communication addressed to the Vice Chancellor of
EIILM University, O.B. Vijayan, barred it from conducting any
courses in distance mode which it ignored and continued enrolling
students. The DEC in August 2008 decided not to grant permission
to any Institution to conduct B.Tech./B.E. Programmes in the light of
the directives of the Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India, this decision would continue till clearance by
the All India Council of Technical Education (for short „AICTE‟). In
violation thereof, the EIILM University continued to offer such
courses by Distance Education Mode and award degrees for wrongful
gains. It also transpired that the EIILM University has 17 national
coordinators, each having over 300 admission centres and more
than 4000 admission centres functioning all across the country, from
where students were being admitted, degrees and diplomas signed
and issued by the University authorities even for unauthorised
courses. The students who were enrolled thereof were paying large
amounts as fees in the belief that their degrees and diplomas were
genuine. That, an additional category Collaborative Industry Based
Education (CIBE) was being offered by the EIILM University in
collaboration with National Centre for Internship Studies (NICS),
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
thereby luring students into programmes without approval of any
accreditation bodies. The investigation further revealed that the
study material for the courses, the conduct of examination, checking
of question papers, issue of mark Sheets, degrees was all done by
the University but the University had failed to comply with any of
the directions/requirements of the AICTE, UGC and other national
accreditation bodies which are essential pre-requisites for providing
quality education to students. It was also found that the faculty
members for the teaching courses were short of the requirement.
Investigation also brought to light that Malvika Trust was set up by
late Kulwant Rai, father of Vinay Rai and the Trust is the Sponsoring
Body of EIILM University, Kolkata and consequently became the
Sponsoring Body of the EIILM University, Sikkim. Along with Malvika
Foundation, Rai Foundation and Integrated Institute of Excellence
Society was set up by late Kulwant Rai along with his son, Vinay Rai.
Funds collected from students of EIILM University have been
transferred to the account of the Rai Foundation and huge sums of
money were removed from the account of EIILM University into the
accounts of Integrated Institute of Excellence Society, Rai Tech and
Rai Business School. Money was also directly put into the account of
the Petitioner from Rai Foundation (Annexure C-7). There is a
common thread between all the Trusts i.e. Malvika Trust, Rai
Foundation and Rai Business School, which were all started by late
Kulwant Rai with his family members as Trustees, while the
Petitioner is the founding Member/Trustee of Rai Foundation and the
Founder and Chairman of Malvika Trust, apart from which the
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
Sections 161 and 164 Cr.P.C. statement of witnesses‟ fortify the
Prosecution case. Thus, it was found that on the basis of the
circumstantial facts and material evidence, prima facie case under
Sections 406/420/467/120B/34 of the IPC existed against the
Petitioner.
24.
In Thermax Limited and others vs K.M. Johny and others
(supra) relied on by the Petitioner, the Supreme Court held that in
view of the infirmities in the case and in the light of Section 482 of
the Code, the High Court ought to have quashed those proceedings
to safe guard the rights of the appellants. The order passed by the
Judicial Magistrate 1st Class, Pimpri on 20.8.2007 and the Judgment
of the High Court dated 11.1.2008 in the Criminal Writ Petition were
set aside. It would be necessary to point out that in the said matter
the Respondent No.1/Complainant had stated that he had carried
out several fabrication jobs for the Accused/Appellant and a sum of
Rs.91,95,054/- (Rupees ninety-one lakhs, ninety-five thousand and
fifty-four) only, was outstanding from the Appellant. In spite of
several requests of the Complainant, the Accused being influential,
no
cognizance
was
taken
of
the
complaints
lodged
by
the
Complainant. The learned Magistrate called for a report under
Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C. from the Crime Branch, Pune. In
appeal by the Appellant Company, the High Court remitted it back to
the Magistrate for reconsideration of the entire prayer made by the
Complainant and to pass fresh orders after giving adequate
opportunity of hearing to both sides and to decide afresh the
application seeking direction under Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C. by
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
giving cogent reasons for such conclusion. Pursuant thereto, an
application filed under Section 91 of the Cr.P.C. by the Appellant
Company was rejected, order which was upheld by the High Court.
The Hon‟ble Apex Court after analysing a catena of cases for the
purpose and the provisions of Sections 405, 406, 420 and 34 of the
IPC, came to the conclusion that the principles enunciated from the
decisions quoted, clearly show that for proceeding under Section
156(3) of the Cr.P.C., the Complaint must disclose relevant material
ingredients of Sections 405, 406, 420 read with Section 34 of the
IPC. That, if there is a flavour of civil nature, the same cannot be
agitated in the form of criminal proceeding and if there is a huge
delay, criminal proceedings cannot be resorted to in order to avoid
the period of limitation. The Court also arrived at a finding that the
Respondent No.1 had roped all the Appellants in a criminal case
without their specific role or participation in the alleged offence with
the sole purpose of settling his dispute with the Appellant Company
by initiating criminal prosecution. That, the Appellants 2 to 8 are the
Ex-Chairperson, Ex-Directors and Senior Managerial personnel of
Appellant No.1 Company, who do not have any personal role in the
allegations and claims of Respondent No.1, neither were there
specific allegations with regard to their role. Thus, the Respondent
No.1 was trying to circumvent the jurisdiction of the Civil Court
which estopped him from proceeding on account of the Law of
Limitation, hence the above orders. The facts of the case at hand
are clearly distinguishable, the matter does not comprise only of
civil wrongs, neither are the ingredients of criminal offences found
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
wanting, requiring exercise of powers under Section 482 of the
Cr.P.C.
25.
Now
addressing
the
argument
of
the
Petitioner
pertaining to cognizance and absence of application of judicial mind,
I deem it essential to refer to the Order of this Court in I.A. No. 1 of
2016 arising out of Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014, dated 19.8.2016,
wherein the Petitioner had prayed that the matter be remanded
back to the learned Magistrate with a direction to issue a speaking
and reasoned order while taking cognizance, if any, duly affording
the
Petitioner
an
opportunity
of
making
submissions
before
cognizance and that liberty be granted to the Petitioner to urge all
other pleas raised in Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014, before the learned
Magistrate at the time of hearing on cognizance. This Court rejecting
the Petition concluded as follows;
“10.
Thus, it does not involve any
formal action, but occurs as soon as the
Magistrate applies his mind to the suspected
commission of the offence. The Court at that
stage is not required to undertake an
elaborate enquiry neither is he required to
mention the documents which he took into
consideration for satisfying himself to take
cognizance. Although it has been argued by
Counsel for the Petitioner that the matter be
remanded back to the Magistrate for passing a
speaking order duly allowing the Petitioner to
present his case, in my considered opinion,
this is a concept alien to the Cr.P.C. and is not
tenable since Section 190 of the Cr.P.C.
nowhere envisages such license to the
Petitioner. The Section is confined to the duty
of a Magistrate and cannot be expanded to
allow the Petitioner to make any submissions
at this stage. The Petitioner shall be given
ample opportunity to make any submissions at
the stage of hearing on Charge.”
In this context, we may also notice the decisions of the
Hon‟ble Apex Court.
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
26.
In Bhushan Kumar and Another vs. State (NCT of Delhi) and
Another13, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held as follows;
“11. In Chief Enforcement Officer v.
Videocon International Ltd. [(2008)2 SCC 492]
(SCC p.499, para 19) the expression
“cognizance” was explained by this Court as “it
merely means „become aware of‟ and when
used with reference to a court or a Judge, it
connotes „to take notice of judicially‟.
It
indicates the point when a court or a
Magistrate takes judicial notice of an offence
with a view to initiating proceedings in respect
of such offence said to have been committed
by someone.” It is entirely a different thing
from initiation of proceedings; rather it is the
condition precedent to the initiation of
proceedings by the Magistrate or the Judge.
Cognizance is taken of cases and not of
persons. Under Section 190 of the Code, it is
the application of judicial mind to the
averments in the complaint that constitutes
cognizance. At this stage, the Magistrate has
to be satisfied whether there is sufficient
ground for proceeding and not whether there
is sufficient ground for conviction. Whether
the evidence is adequate for supporting the
conviction can be determined only at the trial
and not at the stage of enquiry. If there is
sufficient ground for proceeding then the
Magistrate is empowered for issuance of
process under Section 204 of the Code.”
27.
In Sushil Bharti Mittal vs. Central Bureau of Investigation
(supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed as follows;
“42. ................................................
Sine Qua Non for taking cognizance of
the offence is the application of mind by the
Magistrate and his satisfaction that the
allegations, if proved, would constitute an
offence. It is, therefore, imperative that on a
complaint or on a police report, the Magistrate
is bound to consider the question as to
whether the same discloses commission of an
offence and is required to form such an
opinion in this respect. When he does so and
decides to issue process, he shall be said to
have taken cognizance. At the stage of taking
cognizance, the only consideration before the
Court remains to consider judiciously whether
the material on which the prosecution
proposes to prosecute the accused brings out
a prima facie case or not.”
(2012) 5 SCC 424
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
It is evident that the Charge-Sheet was perused by the
Magistrate who then took cognizance of the matter. It cannot be
said that there was no application of judicial mind. This point has in
fact been elaborately discussed in the Order of this Court in I.A. No.
1 of 2016 arising out of Crl. M. C. No. 20 of 2014, mentioned supra.
28.
So far as the arguments on Statements under 161
Cr.P.C. is concerned, in the first instance, it may be pointed out that
Section 161 Cr.P.C. deals with examination of witnesses by the
Police, where any police officer making an investigation examines
any person who is supposed to be acquainted with the facts and
circumstances of a case. The provision authorises the police officer
to reduce in writing such statement made by a witness. At the same
time there is no obligation on the part of the accused person to
make any statement to the police. The fundamental principle of
procedural law is that a statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C. cannot
be considered as substantive evidence, this is to be used for
confronting the witness to impeach his credibility. Should the
witness make contradictory statements, then a suspicion can arise
against the witnesses‟ credibility. In Ashok Tshering Bhutia vs. State of
Sikkim (supra) relied on by the Petitioner, the Hon‟ble Apex Court
held
that
investigating
any
information
officer
under
or
statement
Section
made
before
Cr.P.C.,
corroboration by sufficient evidence. In the absence
the
requires
of any
corroboration thereof it would merely be a case where some
witnesses had stated a particular fact before the investigating officer
and the same remained inadmissible in law, in view of the provisions
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
of Section 162. In Baldev Singh vs. State of Punjab14, it was held that
the statement recorded under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. shall not be
used for any purpose except to contradict a witness in the manner
prescribed in the proviso to Section 162 (1). Addressing the
arguments concerning statements recorded under Section 164 of
the Cr.P.C., such statements or confessions can never be used as
substantive evidence but may be utilised for contradiction or
corroboration of the witness who made it. In the case at hand, in
light of the above discussions, as the statements under Sections 161
and 164 of the Cr.P.C. have not been tested as required under the
law as elaborated hereinabove, therefore this argument of the
Petitioner is not tenable being premature.
29.
Urging that there is no concept of vicarious liability in
criminal law, learned Counsel for the Petitioner relied on Sunil Bharti
Mittal vs. Central Bureau of Investigation (supra). The matter therein
arose as the Appellants were issued summons by the Special Judge,
although their names did not figure in the Charge-Sheet. The
learned Magistrate after examining the file pertaining to the matter
reached the following finding;
“................................................................
4.
I also find at the relevant time, Shri
Sunil Bharti Mittal was Chairman-cumManaging Director of Bharti Cellular Limited,
Sh. Asim Ghosh was Managing Director of
Hutchison Max Telecom (P) Limited and Sh.
Ravi Ruia was a Director in Sterling Cellular
Limited, who used to chair the meetings of its
Board. In that capacity, they were/are prima
facie, in control of affairs of the respective
companies. As such, they represent the
directing mind and will of each company and
(1990) 4 SCC 692
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
their state of mind is the state of mind of the
companies. ..... Consequently, I find enough
material on record to proceed against them
also. ....... It will also be pertinent to mention
here that the appellants were not implicated
as accused persons in the Charge-Sheet.”
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court set aside the Order on the ground
that the Magistrate had not recorded his satisfaction by mentioning
the role played by the Appellants which would bring them within the
criminal net. The facts in the said matter and the case at hand are
clearly distinguishable inasmuch as the Petitioner‟s name appears in
the Charge-Sheet and his role therein has already been reflected
hereinabove.
30.
Reliance was also placed on State (Government of NCT of
Delhi) vs. Nitin Gunwant Shah15
to establish that to prove conspiracy
it must be borne in mind that meeting of mind is essential and mere
knowledge or discussion would not be sufficient. On this count, it
may appropriately be pointed out that at this stage, it is not
necessary for the learned Trial Court to delve deeply into each
ingredient of the provisions under which the accused has been
booked.
31.
Having carefully examined the facts placed before this
Court pertaining to the matter at hand and also having meticulously
examined all documents on record, I am of the considered opinion
that there are sufficient prima facie materials to proceed against the
petitioner, as it is apparent that there is a predominance of
criminality in the acts of the Petitioner which cannot be categorised
2016 II AD (CRI.) (SC) 1
Crl. M.C. No. 20 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
&
Crl. M.C. No. 21 of 2014 : Vinay Rai vs. State of Sikkim
as essentially of a civil nature, although civil wrongs cannot be ruled
out. Thus, it does not call for the exercise of the powers under
Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. by this Court.
32.
The Criminal Miscellaneous Petitions are liable to be and
are accordingly dismissed.
33.
No order as to cost(s).
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
11.08.2017
Approved for reporting :Yes
Internet :Yes
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review