Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Criminal Revisional Jurisdiction)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. Rev. P. No. 02 of 2025
1.
Bidhan Trikhatri,
Aged about 29 years,
Son of Bimal Trikhatri,
Resident of Upper Syari,
Gangtok, Sikkim,
Pin No. 737102.
2.
Bikash Trikhatri,
Aged about 25 years,
Son of Bimal Trikhatri,
Resident of Upper Syari,
Gangtok, Sikkim,
Pin No. 737102.
(Presently both of them are in Rongyek Central
Jail, Rongyek, Sikkim).
….. Revisionists
Versus
State of Sikkim.
…..Respondent
Application under Section 438 and 442 of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.
(Revision against the Impugned Judgment dated 12.12.2024
passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Gangtok, Sikkim in
Criminal Appeal No. 17 of 2024 titled Bidhan Trikhatri & Ors. vs.
State of Sikkim, dismissing the appeal of the petitioners herein).
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
Mr. Kazi Sangay
Revisionists.
Thupden,
Advocate
for
the
Mr. Yadev Sharma, Additional Public Prosecutor for
the Respondent.
---------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing
:
13.03.2026
Date of Judgment
:
23.03.2026
Date on which uploaded :
23.03.2026
JUDGMENT
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
The present revision petition seeks to challenge the
impugned judgment dated 12.12.2024 passed by the
learned Sessions Judge, Gangtok in Criminal Appeal No. 17
of 2024 (Bidhan Trikhatri & Ors. vs. State of Sikkim)
dismissing the appeal of the revisionists.
2.
Section 438 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) which is in pari materia to section
397 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C.)
contemplates the power of revision solely for the purpose of
satisfying itself or himself as to the “correctness, legality or
propriety of any finding, sentence or order, recorded or
passed, and as to the regularity of any proceedings of such
inferior court ..... .” Therefore, the ambit and scope of the
power of revision is not only clear from the provision itself
but well explained in numerous judgments rendered by the
constitutional courts. One such judgment as cited by Mr.
Kazi Sangay Thupden, learned counsel for the revisionists
is taken into consideration.
3.
In Kishan Rao vs Shankargouda1 the Supreme Court
considered two of its previous judgments which examined
1 (2018) 8 SCC 165
the scope of section 397/401 Cr.P.C. and the ground for
exercising the revisional jurisdiction by the High Court. In
State of Kerala vs. Puttumana Illathjathavedan Namboodiri2
the Supreme Court held that the jurisdiction is one of
supervisory jurisdiction exercised for correcting miscarriage
of justice. However, the revisional powers cannot be
equated with the power of an appellate court nor can it be
treated even as a second appellate jurisdiction. Ordinarily,
therefore, it would not be appropriate for the High Courts
to re-appreciate the evidence and come to its own
conclusion on the same when the evidence had already
been appreciated by the Magistrate as well as the Sessions
Judge in appeal, unless “any glaring feature” is brought to
the notice of the High Court which would otherwise
“tantamount to gross miscarriage of justice.”
4.
In Sanjaysinh Ramrao Chavan vs. Dattatray Gulabrao
Phalke3 the Supreme Court held that unless the order
passed by the Magistrate is perverse or the view taken by
the court is wholly unreasonable or there is nonconsideration of any relevant material or there is palpable
misreading of records, the revisional court is not justified in
setting aside the order, merely because another view is
2 (1999) 2 SCC 452
3 (2015) 3 SCC 123
possible. Unless the finding of the court is shown to be
perverse or untenable in law or is grossly erroneous or
glaringly unreasonable or where the decision is based on
no material or where the material facts are wholly ignored
or where the judicial discretion is exercised arbitrarily or
capriciously, courts may not interfere with decision in
exercise of their revisional jurisdiction.
5.
Keeping in mind the well settled principles of law for
the exercise of revisional jurisdiction let us now proceed to
examine the present revision petition.
6.
The learned Chief Judicial Magistrate convicted the
revisionists for the offence under section 380/454 of the
Indian
Penal
Code,
(IPC)
by
judgment
dated
23.08.2022. The learned Sessions Judge dismissed the
appeal of the revisionists by a judgment dated 12.12.2024.
The judgment of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate
finding the revisionists guilty of the offences under section
380 and 454 of the IPC was upheld. However, the learned
Sessions Judge was of the view that the revisionists were
also liable to be convicted under section 34 of the IPC.
7.
Two concurrent findings of guilt under section 380
and 454 of the IPC is now once again sought to be
challenged
before
this Court
invoking the
revisional
jurisdiction.
8.
The revisionists complain that during investigation
several items were seized on 28.11.2021 from a flat at
Bagdogra that are claimed to be the stolen items. These
seizures according to the revisionists were effected in the
presence of two witnesses who were residents of Nam Nang
and not of the surrounding locality of Bagdogra where the
items were seized. The revisionists question as to why no
independent witnesses of the locality i.e. Bagdogra were
used.
9.
The property seizure memos (exhibit-11 and 12) were
both effected under section 102 of the Cr.P.C. which does
not mandate the requirement of any witnesses. The
property seizure memo (exhibit-11) relates to seizure made
on 24.11.2021 at the place of occurrence i.e. Nam Nang,
Gangtok. The property seizure memo (exhibit-12) relates to
seizure made at Bagdogra on 26.11.2021 from the room of
revisionist no.1 and another acquitted by the Sessions
Judge. The submission of the learned counsel for the
revisionists on the requirement of independent persons of
the locality perhaps stems from section 100 Cr.P.C. which
was not invoked by the Investigating Officer-(I.O.). In any
case, the learned counsel for the revisionists has not been
able to point out any prejudice caused.
10. In State of Haryana vs. Rajmal & Anr.4 the Supreme
Court was examining the scope of revision under section
401 and 397 of the Cr.P.C.. It was contended therein that
the seizures were made without any independent witnesses
from the locality at the time of conducting the raid. The
High
Court
agreed
and
interfered
in
its
revisional
jurisdiction. The Supreme Court referred to its three Judge
Bench judgment in Radha Kishan vs. State of U.P.5 in which
it was held that an illegal search does not vitiate the
seizure of the article. The only requirement of law in such
cases is that the court has to examine carefully the
evidence regarding the seizure but beyond this no further
consequences ensues. The Supreme Court then went on to
find that this principle is being consistently followed by it
and by different High Courts since then. It was held if that
principle is followed no error could be discerned from the
courts below proceeding on the materials collected, as a
result of the seizure of materials.
11.
In State of Punjab vs. Baldev Singh6 the Constitutional
bench of the Supreme Court was examining a case under
4 (2011) 14 SCC 326
5 (AIR) 1963 SC 822
6 (1999) 6 SCC 172
the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985.
The Supreme Court referred to its judgment in State of
Punjab vs. Balbir Singh7 where it was opined that failure to
comply with the provisions of the Cr.P.C. in respect of
search and seizure and particularly those of section 100,
102, 103 and 165 per se does not vitiate the prosecution
case.
12.
This ground therefore, does not permit the revision
court to interfere with concurrent findings of the trial court
as well as the appellate court.
13.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
revisionists
also
submitted that there is no evidence to establish that the
ten digit specimen fingerprints were in fact of the
revisionists as there is no record that they were taken by
the I.O. As such, the conviction, which is based solely on
the investigation of the chance fingerprints obtained from
the place of occurrence, cannot be sustained. Although this
issue was not raised either before the court of the learned
Chief Judicial Magistrate or before the learned Sessions
Judge, this Court shall examine the records for the sole
purpose of satisfying itself that the revisionists were not
prejudiced during the trial.
7 (1994)3 SCC 299
14.
The record reveals that the chance fingerprints
obtained from the place of occurrence by Police InspectorTensung Bhutia (P.W.2) were exhibited as exhibits „X‟, „Y‟
and „Z‟ by him. He deposed that he had lifted the chance
fingerprints
from
the
place
of
occurrence. The
I.O.
confirmed this fact. The ten digit specimen fingerprints of
the revisionists have been exhibited as exhibits „A‟ and „B‟
and are available in the records of the case. The I.O.
exhibited the requisition he made to the Superintendent of
Police for comparison of the chance fingerprints developed
from the Godrej Almirah from the place of occurrence with
the
ten digit specimen fingerprints of the suspects
incluidng the revisionists marked at exhibits „A‟, „B‟ and „C‟.
The fingerprint expert-Police Inspector-Tensung Bhutia
(P.W.2) in his expert opinion (exhibit-8) confirmed having
received both the developed and lifted chance fingerprints
from the place of occurrence as exhibits „X‟, „Y‟ and „Z‟ as
well as the ten digits specimen fingerprints of the three
suspects including the revisionists as exhibits „A‟, B‟ and
„C‟. He thereafter forwarded his opinion (exhibit-8) to the
Station
House
Officer
vide
communication
dated
23.12.2021 (exhibit-9).
15.
The I.O. and the fingerprint expert-Police Inspector-
Tensung Bhutia (P.W.2) have given detailed narratives of
the process of developing of the chance fingerprints and
sequence of events that followed thereafter. The only cross
examination with regard to this is the suggestion that the
I.O. had not obtained any permission from the Court while
lifting the fingerprints of the three accused while they were
in police custody. There is not even a suggestion during the
cross-examination that the fingerprint exhibits „A‟, „B‟ and
„C‟ were not of the revisionists or that they were not taken
from the revisionists.
16.
The fingerprint expert opinion (exhibit-8) concluded
that the developed and lifted chance fingerprints matched
with the specimen fingerprints of all the three suspects
including the revisionists.
17.
The defence was unable to demolish the evidence of
Tensung Bhutia (P.W.2) during cross-examination. In fact,
there is not even a suggestion that the fingerprint expert
opinion falsely mentioned about having received and
examined the developed and lifted chance fingerprints and
the ten digit specimen fingerprints of the three suspects
including the two revisionists. Therefore, this Court finds
no reason to doubt the I.O. and the fingerprint expert‟s
opinion.
18.
None of the issues raised by the learned counsel for
the
revisionists
permits
this
Court
to
interfere
the
concurrent findings of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate
and the learned Sessions Judge convicting and upholding
the conviction of the revisionists for the crimes they had
committed.
19. As a final plea the learned counsel for the revisionists
prayed that the Court should view the sentence leniently
considering that the father of the revisionists was aged and
that they were not financially stable. The learned counsel
could not show any material to establish his submission
from the records of the case. The learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate has sentenced the revisionists for a term of five
years along with a fine of Rs.20,000/- each for the offence
under section 454 of the IPC. In default of payment of fine
they were to undergo a simple imprisonment for further six
months. For the offence under section 380 of the IPC the
revisionists
were
sentenced
to
undergo
simple
imprisonment for a term of three years along with a fine of
Rs.10,000/- each. In default of fine, the convicts were to
undergo simple imprisonment for three months.
20. The conviction and sentence of the revisionists under
section 454 IPC is for lurking house trespass or house
breaking in order to commit offence punishable with
imprisonment with the intention of commiting theft. The
theft has been adequately proved. The theft is of large sum
of money, gold jewelleries and other valuable articles. The
sentence imposed could have been for imprisonment
extending
to
ten
years.
The
learned
Chief
Judicial
Magistrate has sentenced the revisionists for a period of
five years only.
21. For the offence under section 380 IPC i.e. theft in a
dwelling house the punishment prescribed is imprisonment
for a term which may extend to seven years. The learned
Chief Judicial Magistrate has sentenced the revisionists for
only three years.
22. The purpose of punishment is also proportionate
response to wrongdoing. Retribution and deterence are
equally vital consideration. As the revisionists have already
served the substantial part of their sentences this Court is
not inclined to interfere with the proportionate sentences
awarded.
23. Accordingly, the criminal revision petition is rejected
and dismissed.
24. Let a copy of this judgment be transmitted forthwith
to the Court of the learned Sessions Judge, Gangtok and to
the Court of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, East
Sikkim at Gangtok forthwith.
The records of the Court
below be remitted accordingly.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
Approved for reporting
Internet
to/
: Yes
: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review