Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:12557
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ARBR No. 55 of 2025
Vinay Jain, S/o Ramesh Chandra Jain, Aged About 42 Years, R/o B-302, Lal
Ganga Regalia, Amrapali Society, Pachpedi Naka, Raipur, Chhattisgarh
492001
... Applicant
versus
1. M/s G M Sanman Associates Through Authorized Signatory, Registered
Office- Maula Bux Building, 7 Gandhi Chowk Road, Lalta Chowk, District
Satna, Madhya Pradesh, 485001, Mob. No. 8225971571, 9425172951.,
Other Address GMS City Center, Virat Nagar, Panna Road, Satna,
Madhya Pradesh 485001.,
2. Vinay Kumar Goel S/o Shri Vinod Kumar Goel Aged About 37 Years R/o
Mansarovar, Haryana Dal Mill Compound, Kamta Tola, Raghuraj Nagar,
Distt. Satna, Madhya Pradesh.
3. Shrey Goel S/o Shri Subodh Goel Aged About 34 Years Mansarovar,
Haryana Dal Mill Compound, Kamta Tola, Raghuraj Nagar, District Satna,
Madhya Pradesh, 485001, Madhya Pradesh
4. Aruna Devi Goel W/o Shri Vinod Kumar Goel Aged About 60 Years
Mansarovar, Haryana Dal Mill Compound, Kamta Tola, Raghuraj Nagar,
District Satna, Madhya Pradesh, 485001, Madhya Pradesh,
PREETI
KUMARI
Digitally
signed by
PREETI
KUMARI
Date:
2026.03.19
11:06:14
+0530
5. Uma Goel W/o Shri Subodh Goel Aged About 57 Years Mansarovar,
Haryana Dal Mill Compound, Kamta Tola, Raghuraj Nagar, District Satna,
Madhya Pradesh, 485001,
6. Savita Goel W/o Shri Bajrang Lal Goel Aged About 52 Years
Mansarovar, Haryana Dal Mill Compound, Kamta Tola, Raghuraj Nagar,
District Satna, Madhya Pradesh, 485001,
7. Jitendra Jain S/o Shri Santosh Singh Jain Aged About 70 Years 18A,
Shrinagar, Indore, Madhya Pradesh- 452001,
8. Sandeep Jain S/o Shri Jitendra Jain Aged About 52 Years 18A,
Shrinagar, Indore, Madhya Pradesh- 452001,
9. Sachit Jain S/o Shri Jitendra Jain Aged About 50 Years 18A, Shrinagar,
Indore, Madhya Pradesh- 452001, Other Add.- 5th Floor, 17 Empire
House S.V. Road, Vile Parle (W), Irla, Mumbai, Maharashtra 400057,
10.Vikas Bohra S/o Shri Jethamal Bohra Aged About 40 Years M/s Sumit
Bazaar, Jai Stambh Chowk, Rajnandgaown, C.G.- 491441, Chhattisgarh
11.Vinod Bohra S/o Shri Jethamal Bohra Aged About 46 Years M/s Sumit
Bazaar, Jai Stambh Chowk, Rajnandgaown, C.G.- 491441, Chhattisgarh
12.Rahul Bohra S/o Shri Jethamal Bohra Aged About 36 Years M/s Sumit
Bazaar, Jai Stambh Chowk, Rajnandgaown, C.G.- 491441, Chhattisgarh
... Respondents
For Applicant
: Mr. Vivek Chopda, Advocate.
For Respondents
: Mr. Siddharth Shukla, Advocate.
Hon’ble Mr. Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Order on Board
16.03.2026
1. This is an application under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 for appointment of an Arbitrator.
2. The facts, in brief, as projected by the applicant are that a Partnership firm in
the name and style of M/s GM Sanman Associate was established as
between the applicant and the respondents herein, inter se on 18.02.2014,
by way of a registered deed of partnership for carrying out the Business of
Entertainment business, to build and run Shopping Malls, Hypermarkets,
Multiple food zones, Restaurants, and Hotels, etc., and also to purchase and
sale
land,
development
of
residential
and
commercial
properties,
construction of flats and blocks of flats and all kinds of real estate
development businesses. Said deed of partnership was registered by the
partners with the Registrar of Firms and Societies Rewa on 15.05.2014 and
a certificate towards such acceptance of registration was granted to the
partnership for respondent No.1 on 15.05.2014 and the registration number
granted to the said firm was 05/26/01/00021/14 year 2014-2015. The share
of the partners has been decided under the partnership deed, under
Clause 4, which clearly stipulates that the applicant was 10% shareholder of
the partnership firm in the profit and loss of the business of the partnership
firm. From a bare perusal of the clause 5 partnership deed, it is also
specifically mentioned and agreed that the capital introduced by the partners,
which is standing in their names in the Books of Accounts, shall carry
interest at the rate of 12% per annum or at any other rate, as maybe mutually
agreed upon subject to the provision of Section 40(b)(iv) of the Income Tax
Act, 1961 and the interest shall be credited in the partner's account on the
date of closing of accounts. Apart from the above, the parties to the
partnership were also liable to receive or draw salary or remuneration in the
proportion provided under clause 6 of the partnership deed, wherein the
share of the applicant has been duly and clearly stated to be 10%. The
duration of the partnership was at will and is also subject to one month's
notice in writing from any partner to the others of his intention to retire. Apart
from the above, there were other various clauses under the partnership deed
dated 18.02.2014 based upon which the parties hereto have invested huge
amount of money, by way of capital, in the partnership firm and has started
business of the nature as specified under clause 2 of the partnership deed. In
the initial years from 2014 to 2017, the partnership firm could only acquire
properties over which such business could be carried out and in acquisition
of such properties, the applicant herein has played an active and
considerable role in the transactions for such purchase. The applicant herein
has purchased the following properties for and on behalf of Respondent No.1
partnership firm M/s GM Sanman Associates, situated at Mouja, Amodha
Kala Ward No.1, Tehsil- Raghurajnagar, Circle- Sohawal, District -Satna,
Block-Sohawal, Madhya Pradesh.
S.No. Description of property with Total
address
Area
The amount in
which
it
Date
of
was purchase
purchased
1.
627/1/[k] 628/2 [k, 628/3/[k 0.113
Rs.38,00,000/-
12.03.2014
Rs.75,00,000/-
12.03.2014
Virat Nagar, Panna Road, Hectare
Satna (M.P.)
2.
627/1/x, 628/3/ Virat Nagar, 0.224
Panna Road, Satna (M.P.)
Hectare
3. Mr. Vivek Chopda, learned counsel for the applicant submits that for the
smooth functioning of the business, the partners herein have also opened a
bank account with the Allahabad bank Allahabad bank, SME Branch, Satna
(M.P.) and has been granted the current account number as 50199021408,
IFSC Code – ALLA0211958. Till the year of 2017, the respondents herein
have been providing the applicant with the audited accounts of the
partnership firm and has been kept completely informed, regarding the
transactions, carried on by the partnership firm. However, thereafter
suddenly, from the year 2017 onwards, have not provided the applicant with
the account statement of the partnership firm. It is submitted that post 2017
only, the business of the partnership firm has started yielding profits and as
the applicant is the resident of Raipur and therefore, after establishment of
the assets of the partnership firm, the applicant could not look after each and
every transaction of the partnership firm, due to his preoccupations with
family and other matters. Yet, the applicant has been asking from the
Respondent, (the remaining partners), the books of accounts and the
audited balance sheets and his share of profits and remuneration etc in the
partnership firm since the year 2017, however, the respondents have failed
to reply to the applicant regarding such books of accounts. In the meanwhile,
the applicant being suspicious of the acts of respondents has on 03.07.2019
through one of his associate has filed an application under RTI seeking the
information regarding. For the smooth functioning of the business, the
partners herein have also opened a bank account with the Allahabad bank
Allahabad bank, SME Branch, Satna (M.P.) and has been granted the
current account number as 50199021408, FSC Code ALLA0211958. Till the
year of 2017, the respondents herein have been providing the applicant with
the audited accounts of the partnership firm and has been kept completely
informed, regarding the transactions, carried on by the partnership firm.
However, thereafter suddenly, from the year 2017 onwards, have not
provided the applicant with the account statement of the partnership firm. It is
submitted that post 2017 only, the business of the partnership firm has
started yielding profits and as the applicant is the resident of Raipur and
therefore, after establishment of the assets of the partnership firm, the
applicant could not look after each and every transaction of the partnership
firm, due to his preoccupations with family and other matters. It is submitted
that, yet the applicant has been asking from the Respondent, (the remaining
partners), the books of accounts and the audited balance sheets and his
share of profits and remuneration etc in the partnership firm since the year
2017, however, the respondents have failed to reply to the applicant
regarding such books of accounts. In the meanwhile, the applicant being
suspicious of the acts of respondents has on 03.07.2019 through one of his
associate has filed an application under RTI seeking the information
regarding for the smooth functioning of the business, the partners herein
have also opened a bank account with the Allahabad bank Allahabad bank,
SME Branch, Satna (M.P.) and has been granted the current account
number as 50199021408, IFSC Code ALLA0211958. Till the year of 2017,
the respondents herein have been providing the applicant with the audited
accounts of the partnership firm and has been kept completely informed,
regarding the transactions, carried on by the partnership firm. However,
thereafter suddenly, from the year 2017 onwards, have not provided the
applicant with the account statement of the partnership firm. It is submitted
that post 2017 only, the business of the partnership firm has started yielding
profits and as the applicant is the resident of Raipur and therefore, after
establishment of the assets of the partnership firm, the applicant could not
look after each and every transaction of the partnership firm, due to his
preoccupations with family and other matters. Yet the applicant has been
asking from the respondent, (the remaining partners), the books of accounts
and the audited balance sheets and his share of profits and remuneration etc
in the partnership firm since the year 2017, however, the respondents have
failed to reply to the applicant regarding such books of accounts. In the
meanwhile, the applicant being suspicious of the acts of respondents has on
03.07.2019 through one of his associate has filed an application under RTI
seeking the information regarding the partnership firm and the partners
therein. In reply to the said RTI of the applicant, on 03.07.2019 wherein the
applicant has been provided with the same partnership deed dated
18.02.2014 wherein the name of the applicant finds place at Serial No.9.
Thereafter, when no response was received from the respondents, the
applicant herein has through his advocate, sent a notice dated 27.11.2019 to
the respondents, demanding the accounts for the financial year 2016-17 to
2018-19, as also, the bank account for the said period along with the details
of the capital of the applicant in the partnership firm and the profits earned by
the business. Thereafter, on 05.12.2019 a reply was given by the respondent
through their advocate, and the averments made in the legal notice sent by
the applicant was denied in toto and surprisingly, an allegation, and to the
utter surprise of the applicant, it has been informed by the counsel of the
respondents that the applicant has retired from the partnership firm with
effect from 20.03.2015 and as such, all the rights and liabilities of the
applicant stood extinguished from the said date in respect of all the affairs of
the partnership firm. From the bare perusal of the afore-stated notice sent by
the applicant and the reply received by the counsel of the respondent, it is
evident that, the respondents are clearly denying the applicant his lawful
rights to obtaining the accounts of the partnership firm to receive the profit
and loss of the partnership firm to the extent of his share illegally.
4. Mr. Chopda further submits that on receipt of such an information from the
counsel of respondent, the counsel for the respondent No. 1,2,3 and 4 only
however, the rest of the partners of the partnership firm chose not to respond
to the same. On receipt of such a shocking information, regarding the
applicant's resignation, which apparently the applicant has never made, the
applicant has sought for information from the Registrar of partnership firm
under the Right to Information Act by filing an application dated 03.06.2020
in as much as prior to that, the COVID 19 has struck the entire country and
the world. Based upon the application made by the applicant through his
associate, the information was provided by the Registrar of firms, on
10.07.2020, wherein the applicant could have been provided another deed
partnership dated 01.12.2017. A bare perusal of the said partnership deed
would reveal to this Court that, while removing the name of the applicant from
the list of partners, it has been mentioned in the said partnership deed that
the applicant and one Mr. Vikas Bohra have expressed their desire to retire
from the partnership firm with effect from 01.12.2017 which has been
accepted by the continuing partners, and accordingly, the retiring partners
have retired from the firm with effect from 01.12.2017, and remaining eight
partners have decided to continue the business of the partnership firm under
the name and style of M/s GM Sanman associates with introduction of two
new partners 1. Shri Vinod Kumar Bohra and 2. Rahul Bohra, who are none
other than real brothers of Mr. Vikas Bohra. Here it would be just and proper
to submit that in the earlier notice issued to the applicant, it has been
informed by the counsel for the respondents that the applicant stood retired
with effect from 20.03.2015. However, to the contrary from the other deed
which has been made on 01.12.2017, it is evident that the applicant is said
to have retired with effect from 01.12.2017 which in itself clearly establishes
the fraud committed by the respondent. It is submitted that, till date, the
applicant has never given any information to any of the partners of the
partnership firm with respect to his intention to retire from the partnership
firm. It is submitted that an illegal and arbitrary action has been initiated and
taken by the respondents herein for illegally retiring the applicant from the
partnership firm while using the capital of the applicant, which has been
submitted by him at the time of entering of the partnership firm on the
partnership deed dated 18.02.2014. It is submitted that, the fraudulent act of
the respondents herein is also deducible from the email which has been sent
by the respondent till the year 2017, not only for opening of the account of
the partnership firm, but also the sharing of the accounts of the partnership
firm till the year 2017, one such email being the 29.11.2017 where in the CA
of the applicant sought for the information, viz the documents relating to the
financial year 2015-16, 2016-17 for filing of income tax return that is the copy
of IT act, computation of total income balance sheet of partners' capital
account and the partnership deed. It is submitted that in reply to the said
email, the CA of the partnership firm has duly sent the said document,
confirming the accounts of the applicant and his capital statement till the year
2017. Thereafter, the applicant herein has made fervent request to the
respondents for giving him the total details of the audited account from the
respondents, time and again. Thereafter, the applicant has also made a
complaint to the registrar of firms, vide complaint dated 15.07.2020 and, to
the police authorities on 24.02.2020. Thereafter, the applicant has also made
request to one of the partners that is the Respondent No.2 i.e., Vinay Kumar
Goel for giving him the complete audit report of the partnership from the year
2016-17 to 2017-18 and the status report of the ongoing project that is GMS
City Centre Mall Satna. Thereafter, the applicant herein has time and again
made request to the respondents for providing the details of the accounts of
the partnership firm and regarding the properties of the partnership firm,
however, no response was received from the respondents to the applicant,
and therefore, the applicant has yet again made a complaint to the police
authorities on 17.08.2020. Thereafter, yet again on 01.03.2024, the
applicant herein has made a police complaint, however, the same has also
fetched no results. From a bare perusal of the afore-stated facts relating to
the partnership firm, it is more than evident that firstly, the applicant has not
retired from the partnership firm and secondly, that the applicant has not
been provided with the accounts of the partnership firm since the year
2017-18, till date. Thirdly, the applicant still is a partner in the partnership
firm in as much as there is no final settlement of the accounts, even if for the
sake of argument only though not admitting the applicant is treated as an
outgoing partner since the year 2017 as no payments whatsoever has been
made by the respondents to the applicant in such final settlement of the
accounts. At this stage, the applicant provides the audited accounts of the
partnership from the year 2014-15 to year 2016-17. From the bare perusal of
the audited accounts, as has been disclosed by the partnership firm to the
applicant in the year 2016 the capital account of the applicant clearly shows
that an amount of Rs. 14,40,404/-has been duly invested by the applicant,
which has not been returned by the respondents to the applicant till date,
neither any of the covenants as prescribed under the partnership deed of the
year 2014 has been followed by the respondents. A bare perusal of the
income tax return, as has been filed of the partnership firm in the year
2016-2017, it is evident that till the year 2016-17, there was no business
which was carried out and only investments which were made and as such,
zero income tax return has been filed. From the above factual narration, it is
evidently clear that the applicant has still not retired from the partnership firm,
and as such, is entitled for the entire account of the partnership firm in as
much as the cause of action for the applicant is a continuing one as the
capital of the applicant has been kept by the respondents and is being
utilized by them for the business of the partnership firm, for the day to day
business of the partnership firm and therefore, in terms of the partnership Act
1932, the applicant is entitled to all the reliefs as a partner.
5. Mr. Chopda further submits that the applicant herein has deprived of his
share which as on date would be around 6.5 crores in as much as the value
of the property purchased by the applicant for the partnership firm has
increased multi fold and out of the said land the partnership firm has
constructed a shopping mall which is named and styled as G.M.S City
Centre in which various shops have been given on rent by the partnership
firm to various brands and individuals and companies etc. from which rental
income to the tune of approximately of Rs. 60,00,000/- per month is being
derived at by the partnership firm and as such the applicant's share over the
said amount being 10% would come to Rs. 6,00,000/- per month and
therefore, for the period from 2018 till 2025, is the profit generated out of the
business of the partnership firm as if the said value was taken from the year
2020 onwards then an amount of Rs. 3,60,00,000/- comes as the profit
share of the applicant in the partnership firm and apart from the profit share
the applicant is also entitled to receive his capital share which in terms of the
lands purchased and the malls constructed over the same has now come to
Rs. 50-60 Cr. (Government value) and as such the applicant's share being
10% of the same comes to Rs.6,00,00,000/- and therefore, at present in
absence of the audited accounts of the partnership firm the applicant values
his claim for an amount of Rs. 8,60,00,000 exclusive of interest and further
the applicant claims an amount of Rs.1,00,00,000/- towards damages of
depriving the applicant from the works of the partnership firm since the year
2020 onwards and therefore at present the total amount claimed by the
applicant is of Rs. 9,60,00,000/- exclusive of interest. 30. It is submitted that
owing to the Respondents' continued refusal to render accounts, disclose
financial records, or comply with the obligations under the Partnership Deed
dated 18.02.2014, the applicant was constrained to invoke the arbitration
clause contained in Clause 18 of the said partnership deed. In furtherance
thereof, the Applicant issued a notice dated 14.07.2025, invoking arbitration
under Section 21 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. However, the
Respondents have categorically denied the applicant's right to invoke
arbitration or to unilaterally appoint an arbitrator. The respondents have also
failed to provide audited balance sheets or financial documents of the
partnership firm for any financial year, thereby frustrating the Applicant's
ability to enforce his legal rights.
6. The continued and willful breach of the terms and conditions of the
Partnership Deed by the respondents has given rise to a clear and subsisting
dispute between the parties, falling squarely within the ambit of the
Arbitration Agreement contained in Clause 18 of the Partnership Deed dated
18.02.2014. Hence, for the kind consideration of this Hon'ble Court, the
relevant arbitration clause is stated hereinbelow:
"Clause 18- That, if any dispute shall arise between the parties in
respect of interpretation, enforcement or operation of any of the
terms and condition of this deed in respect of anything, cause or a
matter connected with this deed, but not herein otherwise provided
for the same shall be referred for adjudication to the arbitration of
one person mutually appointed whose decision shall be final and
binding on all the parties."
7. Despite the applicant's issuance of notice dated 14.07.2025, calling upon the
respondents to take necessary steps for the nomination and appointment of
an Arbitrator in terms of Clause 18 of the Partnership Deed dated
18.02.2014, the respondents, through their reply dated 24.07.2025, have
categorically refused to comply with the said request. Consequently, the
applicant has been left with no efficacious remedy but to invoke the
jurisdiction of this Court under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996, for appointment of an Arbitrator to adjudicate the
disputes arising between the parties. In view of the subsisting disputes and
the respondents' failure to act upon the Applicant's earnest requests made
vide legal notices dated 01.05.2024 and 14.07.2025, the applicant hereby
nominates Hon'ble Justice (Retd.) Shri G. Minhajuddin as the Sole Arbitrator
to adjudicate upon the said disputes. Accordingly, the applicant respectfully
files the instant application seeking appropriate reliefs. The applicant has
come to know that the respondents are not only indulged into buying and
selling off the properties in the name and style of the partnership firm that is,
respondent No.1 without there being any concession or agreement made by
the applicant and as such all the acts which are being done by the
partnership and the respondents herein thus an application under section 9
has been preferred by the applicant on 10.09.2025 before the Commercial
Court at Naya Raipur registered as Arbitration MJC No. 41 of 2025 which is
pending consideration before the said Court and notices have been issued to
the respondents. The cause of action for filling of the instant application is a
continuous one and for the first time the same arose when the first notice
demanding the accounts of the partnership firm has been raised by the
applicant on 27.11.2019 thereafter, on 10.07.2020 when the information
were provided to the applicant by the registrar of firms and thereafter, on
15.07.2020 when the applicant made complaint to the registrar and the
police authorities on 24.02.2020 yet again the cause of action arose in favour
of the applicant on 17.08.2020 when no steps were taken by the police
authorities. The applicant has yet again made the complaint further on
01.03.2024 and yet again the thirdly, police complaint has been made by the
applicant and thereafter, the cause of action further arose when the applicant
herein has given a notice by himself to the respondent on 14.07.2025 and on
the subsequent denial of the same by the respondent on 24.07.2025. 36. It is
submitted that the applicant is a resident of Raipur, Chhattisgarh and the
Partnership Deed dated 18.02.2014 does not specify any exclusive
jurisdiction or seat of arbitration in its arbitration clause. In the absence of
any such stipulation, and considering that the cause of action has arisen in
part at Raipur and the applicant resides and carries on business within the
jurisdiction of this Court, it is respectfully submitted that this Court has the
exclusive jurisdiction to entertain and adjudicate the present application
under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
8. Mr. Siddharth Shukla, learned counsel appearing for the respondents,
opposes this arbitration request application, however, he submits that the
respondents will have no objection if any Arbitrator is appointed by this
Hon’ble Court for resolving the dispute that has arisen between the parties.
9. I have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties, perused the
pleadings and documents appended thereto.
10. A query was put to learned counsel appearing for the parties as to whether
they are agreeable for a common name who can be appointed as Arbitrator,
learned counsel for the parties submitted that they would have no objection if
any retired Judge of this High Court is appointed as the Sole Arbitrator. They
further submit that Hon’ble Mr. Justice Deepak KumarTiwari, who is a retired
Judge of this High Court may be appointed as the Sole Arbitrator.
11. In view of the above consensus between the learned counsel for the parties,
Hon’ble Mr. Deepak Kumar Tiwari a retired Judge of this High Court is
appointed to act as the Sole Arbitrator to resolve the dispute involved in this
arbitration request between the parties.
12. The Registry is directed to communicate this order to Hon’ble Mr. Justice
Deepak Kumar Tiwari in the proper address.
13. The remuneration of the Arbitrator shall be settled with the mutual consent of
the parties.
14. The arbitration request petition, accordingly, stands allowed.
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
Preeti
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review