Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on:16.09.2025
Judgment delivered on:20.02.2026
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.A. 36602/2019
.....Petitioner
STATE (NCT) DELHI
versus
.....Respondent
VIKRAM SINGH MEENA
+
CRL.M.C. 10017/2024 & CRL.M.A. 38388/2024
.....Petitioner
VIKRAM SINGH MEENA
versus
STATE GOVT.OF NCT OF DELHI AND ANR.
.....Respondents
Advocates who appeared in this case:
For the Petitioner
: Ms. Priyanka Dalal, APP for the State
Inspector Bhanu Pratap, PS- Vigilance in
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019
Mr. Abhas Mishra & Ms. Deepika Gawri
Tyagi, Advs.
Mr. Ramesh Gupta, Sr. Adv. with Ms.
Shailendra Singh, Mr. Ishaan Jain & Mr.
Surya Pratap Singh, Advs. in CRL.M.C.
10017/2024
For the Respondent
: Mr. Abhas Mishra & Ms. Deepika Gawri
Tyagi, Advs.
Mr. Ramesh Gupta, Sr. Adv. with Ms.
Shailendra Singh, Mr. Ishaan Jain & Mr.
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
Surya Pratap Singh, Advs. in CRL.M.C.
4808/2019.
Ms. Priyanka Dalal, APP for the State
Inspector Bhanu Pratap, PS- Vigilance in
CRL.M.C. 10017/2024.
CORAM
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
1.
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 is filed by the State against the order
dated 16.03.2019 passed by the learned Special Judge, Central, Tis
Hazari Courts, Delhi in CC No. 2/16 whereby the application filed by
the accused – Vikram Singh Meena under Section 311 of the Code of
Criminal
Procedure,
(‘CrPC’) seeking
summoning
of
sanctioning authority to prove the validity of sanction and further
seeking discharge on account of invalidity of sanction was partly
allowed to the extent of summoning the sanctioning authority for
examination on the question of validity of sanction.
2.
CRL.M.C. 10017/2024 is filed by the accused – Vikram Singh
Meena against the sanction order dated 05.07.2017 and seeking
quashing of supplementary chargesheet in FIR NO. 345/2013
registered at Police Station Shahdara.
3.
The relevant facts leading to the filing of the present petitions
are as follows:
3.1.
On 04.09.2013 a written complaint was given by one Joginder
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
Singh stated to be engaged in the work of construction of buildings. It
is alleged that in the month of February, 2013, the complainant started
a construction work at Plot No. 1/5798, Plot No. 21, Gali No. 13,
Balbir Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi and the building plan was sanctioned
from MCD. It is alleged that no sooner did the complainant start the
construction work than he was contacted by a Beat Constable who
allegedly approached the complainant and told him that the work
could not be commenced without the sanction plan and also asked the
complainant to meet the SHO being the accused – Vikram Singh
Meena. It is alleged that the complainant met the accused – Vikram
Singh Meena along with the sanction plan who then allegedly
demanded a bribe of ₹1 lakh and also threatened him that he could not
start the construction without giving the money. It is alleged that the
complainant paid the sum of ₹1 lakh and started the construction
work.
3.2.
It is alleged that after 5 months, accused – Vikram Singh Meena
again demanded a sum of ₹50,000/-. It is alleged that thereafter in the
month of August, 2013, accused HC Somdev visited the site and asked
the complainant to stop the construction work and also told him that
the building was unauthorized. It is alleged that thereafter the
complainant was asked to meet the SHO/accused – Vikram Singh
Meena. It is alleged that thereafter, the complainant went to the Police
Station, however, the accused – Vikram Singh Meena was not present.
Thereafter, the accused – Vikram Singh Meena allegedly contacted the
complainant on his phone number and called him to the Police Station.
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
Thereafter, the accused – Vikram Singh Meena allegedly informed the
complainant that the building was unauthorized, threatened to register
an FIR against the complainant, and allegedly asked him to pay a sum
of ₹50,000/- and meet accused HC Sumdev.
3.3.
It is alleged that thereafter, the complainant purchased a video
recording camera and when he was contacted by accused HC Sumdev,
he recorded the said conversation on his phone, however, on that
occasion the complainant did not mention about the demand of
₹50,000/- made by the accused – Vikram Singh Meena. It is alleged
that on the second instance when the complainant was contacted,
accused HC Sumdev asked the complainant to pay a sum of ₹50,000/as per the direction of the SHO/ accused – Vikram Singh Meena,
however, the said conversation was not recorded. It is alleged that
thereafter accused HC Sumdev asked the complainant to meet him. It
is alleged that thereafter the complainant alongwith his friend Leelu
met accused HC Sumdev at the stipulated time in a car and a video
recording of the incident was done where the complainant handed a
sum of ₹20,000/- to accused HC Sumdev on his demand. On this, it is
alleged that accused HC Sumdev insisted that the SHO would not
accept the amount, and the complainant paid an additional sum of
₹5000/3.4.
During the course of the investigation, the camera and mobile
phone given by the complainant were seized. The CFSL result of the
original recording alongwith voice/photo samples of accused Sumdev
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
and complainant were obtained and the samples tallied with the
original recordings. No bribe money was however recovered.
3.5.
Chargesheet was filed against accused HC Sumdev for the
offences under Sections 7/13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption
Act, 1988 (‘PC Act’) and Section 384 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
(‘IPC’) and sanction was obtained against him. No evidence could be
obtained against the accused – Vikram Singh Meena but for the
allegations made by the complainant and disclosure of accused HC
Sumdev. The chargesheet records that the complainant also admitted
in transcription that when he went to meet the SHO/ accused – Vikram
Singh Meena, he was offered soft drinks and nothing was asked from
him. No audio/video recording of the accused – Vikram Singh Meena
was brought forth by the complainant. Consequently, prosecution
sanction was not sought against accused – Vikram Singh Meena and
he was placed under column 12.
3.6.
The learned Special Judge vide order dated 19.02.2016 took
cognizance of the offences under Sections 7/13(1)(d) of the PC Act
and Section 384 of the IPC. It was noted that sanction under Section
19 of the PC Act qua accused Sumdev had been placed on record and
that the accused – Vikram Singh Meena had not been chargesheeted
and had been placed under column 12. Accused HC Sumdev was
thereafter summoned.
3.7.
Subsequently, during the course of further proceedings, the
learned Special Judge vide order dated 01.09.2016 directed the
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
prosecution to obtain requisite sanction against the accused – Vikram
Singh Meena while noting that sufficient material existed which prima
facie reflected that the accused – Vikram Singh Meena had committed
offences under Sections 7/13(1)(d) of the PC Act and Section 384 of
the IPC. During that time, the learned Special Judge was considering
arguments on charge and noted that specific allegations were made by
the complainant against the accused – Vikram Singh Meena. The
learned Special Judge noted that the complainant alleged that the
accused – Vikram Singh Meena had called him from his mobile phone
and had asked him to make a visit. It was noted that the call record of
the complainant showed that he had received a call from the accused –
Vikram Singh Meena’s number on 06.08.2013 which prima facie
supported the allegation of the complainant. It was noted that from the
video-audio recording of the incident, it transpired that accused HC
Sumdev had received ₹25,000/- for the accused – Vikram Singh
Meena and ₹5,000/- for himself from the complainant in the presence
of Leelu. The learned Special Judge also took into account the
statement of Leelu under Section 161 of the CrPC where he
corroborated the allegations of the complainant.
3.8.
Thereafter, the Joint Commissioner of Police (‘JCP’) vide
Sanction order dated 05.07.2017 accorded sanction under Section 19
of PC Act to prosecute the accused – Vikram Singh Meena. While
doing so, the JCP took into account that during the course of
arguments on charge against accused HC Sumdev, the learned Special
Judge directed the requisite authority to obtain sanction for conducting
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
trial against the accused – Vikram Singh Meena who was, on an
earlier occasion, not chargesheeted on account of lack of any
corroborative and physical evidence in lieu of allegations of the
complainant. While doing so, the evidence against the accused –
Vikram Singh Meena was noted to be first, the statement of Leelu
recorded under Section 161 of the CrPC who was accompanying the
complainant on the day of the incident and was sitting in the car when
the bribe money was paid to accused HC Sumdev, second, the
disclosure of the accused HC Sumdev who disclosed that the bribe
money was received on behalf of the accused – Vikram Singh Meena
and third, one CDR of complainant’s mobile which was made by the
accused – Vikram Singh Meena to the complainant.
3.9.
In the interregnum, Supplementary chargesheet was filed
against the accused – Vikram Singh Meena for the offences under
Sections 7/13(1)(d) of the PC Act and Section 384 of the IPC. The
learned Special Judge vide order dated 11.09.2017 taking note of the
supplementary chargesheet against the accused – Vikram Singh
Meena accordingly took cognizance and directed the supplementary
chargesheet to be clubbed with the main file and summoned the
accused – Vikram Singh Meena.
3.10. The accused – Vikram Singh Meena challenged the order dated
01.09.2016 passed by the learned Special Judge vide CRL. M.C.
3559/2016.
3.11. The said petition was dismissed as withdrawn with liberty to
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
raise the issue of invalidity of sanction for prosecution before the
learned Special Judge. Pursuant to the same, the accused – Vikram
Singh Meena filed an application under Section 311 read with Section
197 of the CrPC before the learned Special Judge praying summoning
of the sanctioning authority to prove the validity of sanction and
further praying invalidation of the impugned sanction and discharge of
the accused – Vikram Singh Meena. The said application was partly
allowed to the extent of summoning of the sanctioning authority for
examination pertaining to the question of validity of sanction vide
order dated 16.03.2019. The order dated 16.03.2019 has been
challenged by the State by the present petition being CRL.M.C.
4808/2019.
3.12. During the course of the proceedings in CRL.M.C. 4808/2019,
this Court vide order dated 20.09.2024 noted that ex facie it appeared
that the sanction order dated 05.07.2017 had been passed only because
directions were passed by the learned Special Judge directing the
prosecution to obtain requisite sanction. It was further noted that the
perusal of the sanction order ex facie showed non application of mind,
and in such circumstances, this Court is within its powers under
Section 482 of the CrPC to take cognizance of it. State was further
directed to file an affidavit in regard to the contentions raised on
behalf of the accused – Vikram Singh Meena.
4.
Subsequently, this Court vide order dated 19.11.2024, in
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019, while taking note of the arguments on behalf of
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
the accused – Vikram Singh Meena, had opined that the accused ought
not to be denied the liberty to challenge the sanction order. While
doing so, this Court took into account the arguments advanced on
behalf of the accused – Vikram Singh Meena that the State ought not
to be permitted to contend that summoning of sanctioning authority
should not have been done at this stage before framing of charge since
the same was only done pursuant to the liberty granted by this Court to
raise the issue of invalidity of sanction as per the ruling in State v.
Mukesh Kumar Singh & Anr. and K.G. Tyagi v. State : 2018 SCC
OnLine Del 8136 while disposing of the petition CRL.M.C.
3559/2016 and had further noted the submission of the accused –
Vikram Singh Meena that if the State had an objection to the
summoning of the sanctioning authority prior to framing of charges,
the accused be permitted to challenge the validity of order of sanction.
5.
Consequently, CRL.M.C. 10017/2024 was filed by the accused
– Vikram Singh Meena challenging the sanction order dated
05.07.2017 whereby sanction was accorded by the Sanctioning
authority under Section 19 of the PC Act to prosecute the accused –
Vikram Singh Meena.
6.
The learned counsel for accused – Vikram Singh Meena
submitted that the sanctioning authority had, on an earlier occasion,
passed an order, sanctioning the prosecution of the other accused
person. He submitted that admittedly, no evidence was found against
the accused – Vikram Singh Meena at that stage. He submitted that it
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
is not the case of the prosecution that any further investigation was
carried out pursuant to filing of the chargesheet and some other
additional evidence had come on record which led to passing of a
fresh sanction order by the sanctioning authority.
7.
He submitted that while the sanctioning authority notes that
there is sufficient evidence on record to prove guilt of accused –
Vikram Singh Meena, however, at the time of filing of chargesheet
against accused HC Sumdev no evidence was found against the
accused – Vikram Singh Meena and consequently no prosecution
sanction was sought and the accused – Vikram Singh Meena was
placed in column 12.
8.
He submitted that the order taking cognizance dated 19.02.2016
specifically noted the name of the accused – Vikram Singh Meena and
it was noted that he had been kept in Column No. 12 and the
cognizance had been taken against the other accused person. He
submitted that undisputedly the Court can proceed to take cognizance
against the persons who have not been named as an accused, if
pursuant to subsequent investigation, certain evidence has been
collected. He further submitted that the Court, at the initial stage of
taking cognizance, could have taken cognizance, however, no such
order was passed and the order dated 01.09.2016, in such
circumstances, cannot also be presumed under Section 319 of the
CrPC.
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
9.
The learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the State
submitted that the sanction order was passed considering the specific
allegations of the complainant against the accused – Vikram Singh
Meena, the statement of Leelu recorded under Section 161 of the
CrPC who had accompanied the complainant on the day when the
incident took place and was sitting in the car when the bribe money
was paid to accused HC Sumdev and the CDR of the complainant’s
mobile which reflected that the accused – Vikram Singh Meena had
made a phone call to the complainant.
10.
She submitted that the power under Section 311 of the CrPC
could not have been exercised by the learned Special Judge before
framing of charges. She submitted that the validity of sanction should
not be examined at pre-trial stage. She submitted that the learned
Special Judge failed to take into account that the satisfaction of
Sanctioning Authority in according sanction is a question of fact and
the same can only be tested during the course of the trial after the
charges have been framed.
ANALYSIS
11.
Firstly, insofar as the challenge presented by the State is
concerned, it is argued that the learned Special Judge has erred in
permitting the summoning of the sanctioning authority by exercising
power under Section 311 of the CrPC even before the consideration on
the point of charge.
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
12.
Thus, at the outset, it is imperative to first appreciate the law in
relation to Section 311 of the CrPC. The Hon’ble Apex Court in
Natasha Singh v. CBI : (2013) 5 SCC 741 while observing that the
power to summon or recall witnesses can be exercised at any stage of
trial observed as under:
“8. Section 311 CrPC empowers the court to summon a material
witness, or to examine a person present at “any stage” of “any
enquiry”, or “trial”, or “any other proceedings” under CrPC, or
to summon any person as a witness, or to recall and re-examine
any person who has already been examined if his evidence
appears to it, to be essential to the arrival of a just decision of the
case. Undoubtedly, CrPC has conferred a very wide discretionary
power upon the court in this respect, but such a discretion is to be
exercised judiciously and not arbitrarily. The power of the court in
this context is very wide, and in exercise of the same, it may
summon any person as a witness at any stage of the trial, or other
proceedings. The court is competent to exercise such power even
suo motu if no such application has been filed by either of the
parties. However, the court must satisfy itself, that it was in fact
essential to examine such a witness, or to recall him for further
examination in order to arrive at a just decision of the case.
15. The scope and object of the provision is to enable the court to
determine the truth and to render a just decision after discovering
all relevant facts and obtaining proper proof of such facts, to
arrive at a just decision of the case. Power must be exercised
judiciously and not capriciously or arbitrarily, as any improper or
capricious exercise of such power may lead to undesirable results.
An application under Section 311 CrPC must not be allowed only
to fill up a lacuna in the case of the prosecution, or of the defence,
or to the disadvantage of the accused, or to cause serious prejudice
to the defence of the accused, or to give an unfair advantage to the
opposite party. Further, the additional evidence must not be
received as a disguise for retrial, or to change the nature of the
case against either of the parties. Such a power must be exercised,
provided that the evidence that is likely to be tendered by a witness,
is germane to the issue involved. An opportunity of rebuttal
however, must be given to the other party. The power conferred
under Section 311 CrPC must therefore, be invoked by the court
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
only in order to meet the ends of justice, for strong and valid
reasons, and the same must be exercised with great caution and
circumspection. The very use of words such as “any court”, “at
any stage”, or “or any enquiry, trial or other proceedings”, “any
person” and “any such person” clearly spells out that the
provisions of this section have been expressed in the widest
possible terms, and do not limit the discretion of the court in any
way. There is thus no escape if the fresh evidence to be obtained
is essential to the just decision of the case. The determinative
factor should therefore be, whether the summoning/recalling of
the said witness is in fact, essential to the just decision of the
case.”
(emphasis supplied)
13.
Similarly, the Hon’ble Apex Court in Ratanlal v. Prahlad Jat
and Others : (2017) 9 SCC 340 observed as under:
“17. In order to enable the court to find out the truth and render
a just decision, the salutary provisions of Section 311 are enacted
whereunder any court by exercising its discretionary authority at
any stage of inquiry, trial or other proceeding can summon any
person as witness or examine any person in attendance though
not summoned as a witness or recall or re-examine any person
already examined who are expected to be able to throw light upon
the matter in dispute. The object of the provision as a whole is to
do justice not only from the point of view of the accused and the
prosecution but also from the point of view of an orderly society.
This power is to be exercised only for strong and valid reasons and
it should be exercised with caution and circumspection. Recall is
not a matter of course and the discretion given to the court has to
be exercised judicially to prevent failure of justice. Therefore, the
reasons for exercising this power should be spelt out in the order.”
(emphasis supplied)
14.
As is evident from the aforesaid judgments, the Court can
summon a person at any stage of the trial if the evidence of such a
person is essential for the just decision of the case. The provision
explicitly makes use of the phrase–“at any stage of any inquiry, trial
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
or other proceeding under this Code”. Exercise of power under
Section 311 of the CrPC is thus not prohibited at the pre-trial stage.
15.
Relying upon the case of CBI v. Manohar Baburao
Nandanwar : 2009 SCC OnLine Bom 1543, the State has argued that
the issue of validity of sanction is best left for trial. In that case, the
Hon’ble High Court of Bombay was faced with similar circumstances
where the sanctioning authority was examined prior to framing of
charges, and the accused was subsequently discharged as the sanction
was found to be illegal. The discharge was set aside by the High
Court, and it was observed that resorting to Section 311 of the CrPC
before framing of charge in such circumstances was improper. The
relevant portion of the judgment is as under:
“4. I have considered the rival submissions. Considering the fact
that the non applicant was prosecuted under the provisions of the
Prevention of Corruption Act, it was absolutely necessary for the
learned Judge, Special Court to adopt the procedure, which is
required to be adopted for conducting the Sessions Trial. In such
case, there is no question of Section 240 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure getting attracted to the present case from any angle. It
is also required to be mentioned that the provisions of Section
311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure regarding examining a
particular witness are to be used by using judicial discretion and
in a proper case. The view taken by learned Judge that it would
be appropriate to examine the sanctioning authority first before
framing of charge then question can be decided whether the
charge should be framed or not, is found not in consonance with
the well settled provisions of law as well as procedure to be
followed.
xxx
6. It is noted that the learned Judge, Special Court proceeded to
record a finding that the sanction was bad before framing of
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
charge. This procedure adopted by learned Judge is contrary to
the well established principle as regards conducting the trial. On
account of this, I am inclined to observe that order dated
04.08.2005 is illegal and is required to be set aside. Needless to
mention that the evidence given by the sanctioning authority on the
basis of which order dated 04.08.2005 came to be passed is
required to be quashed and set aside.
7. In the circumstances, now the learned Judge, Special Court will
conduct the matter and dispose of the same in accordance with the
provisions of law. At one stage, the learned Advocate for the non
applicant contended that the sanction granted to prosecute the non
applicant is patently illegal and if the said stand is being taken by
the non applicant, he may adhere to that stand and attend to the
matter in accordance with the provisions of law. At what stage the
said stand can be taken by the non applicant need not be mentioned
by this Court.”
(emphasis supplied)
16.
On the other hand, the accused – Vikram Singh Meena has
relied upon a number of judgments to contest that such an issue can be
raised at any stage, and power under Section 311 of the CrPC can be
resorted to for the same. The judgments relied upon by the accused
Vikram in this regard are discussed hereunder.
16.1. One of the foremost cases relied upon by the accused – Vikram
Singh Meena in this regard is that of Ashok Kumar Aggarwal v.
Central
Bureau
of
Investigation
(through
its
Director)
:
2007:DHC:5289 to endorse that the validity of the sanction can be
challenged at the initial stage by resorting to the power under Section
311 of the CrPC. In that case as well, the accused had challenged the
validity of the sanction even before the arguments on charge could be
advanced on the ground that the same was unsustainable in law as the
entire record of investigation was not placed before the sanctioning
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
authority. As the learned Trial Court had not recorded any finding that
the non-production of relevant material before the sanctioning
authority had not resulted in failure of justice and merely observed
that it could not be said that the sanction was invalid, another Bench of
this Court had remanded the matter back to the learned Trial Court for
recording an observation in terms of Section 19 of the PC Act, 1988. It
was also observed that the Trial Court could examine the sanctioning
authority as a witness before charge, in view of the provisions of
Section 311 of the CrPC. The said judgment was upheld by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in CBI v. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal : (2014) 14
SCC 295, where it was held that although the stage of examining
validity of sanction is during trial, however, the facts of the case
warranted a different course, especially since the order had been partly
complied with. In such facts, the Hon’ble Apex Court noted that it
found no reason to interfere with the order of the High Court.
16.2. Reliance is placed on the case of Chandan Kumar Basu v.
State of Bihar : (2014) 13 SCC 70, where the Hon’ble Apex Court
had opined that the question of sanction under Section 197 of the
CrPC could be raised at any time after cognizance had been taken. In
that case, the accused had challenged the cognizance before the Court
of Sessions on the ground that no sanction had been obtained.
16.3. The accused – Vikram Singh Meena has also relied on the case
of Nanjappa v. State of Karnataka : (2015) 14 SCC 186. In that case,
the Hon’ble Apex Court had set aside the conviction of the appellant
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
therein on the ground of absence of a valid sanction. It was observed
that the statute forbids cognizance against a public servant except with
the previous sanction of the competent authority, and question
regarding validity of sanction can be raised at any stage as the
competence of the Court trying the accused depends on the same.
16.4. Reliance is also placed on the case of State v. Mukesh Kumar
Singh & Anr. and K.G. Tyagi v. State (supra), where after referring to
a catena of judgments, another Bench of this Court had emphasized
that objections as to validity of sanction can be raised at any stage, and
the Court is duty bound to consider the same. In that case, the accused
had raised the question of validity of sanction, which was rejected.
The Sessions Court had also discharged two of the accused, which was
challenged by the State separately.
Pertinently, the accused – Vikram Singh Meena had moved the
subject application under Section 311 of the CrPC after withdrawing
his challenge to order dated 01.09.2016 with liberty to raise the issue
of invalidity of sanction for prosecution before the learned Special
Judge in terms of the decision of this Court in the case of State v.
Mukesh Kumar Singh & Anr. and K.G. Tyagi v. State (supra). The
relevant portion of the judgment is as under:
“96… (b) The grant of sanction is an administrative function and
the court would not sit in appeal over it by embarking upon an
exercise of examining the adequacy of material placed before the
sanctioning authority;
(c) The judicial scrutiny is more of the decision making process it,
however, being incumbent on the prosecution to prove that the
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
appropriate authority had granted the sanction having regard to
all the relevant facts and after perusing the materials placed before
it in entirety, such material comprising all the vital documents
including those which may “tilt the balance in favour of the
accused”. The material on which the sanctioning authority
proceeds to accord its approval for prosecution must be relevant to
the case against the public servant and also be admissible in law;
(d) It is also sine qua non for the validity of the sanction that the
competent authority on which the power to grant sanction is
conferred does not treat it as an idle formality and applies its own
independent mind undertaking the task in a manner that does not
reflect mechanical approach, not the least being under pressure,
compulsion or constraint from any external force or quarter;
(e) While mere error, omission or irregularity may not be of any
consequence, withholding of vital documents or material from the
sanctioning authority, particularly such material as may tilt the
balance in favour of the accused public servants causes serious
prejudice which may occasion failure of justice vitiating the
sanction for prosecution;
(f) While absence of sanction for prosecution is a question to be
agitated at the threshold, objection to the validity of sanction may
be raised by the accused public servant “at any time” or “at any
stage” in the course of or during trial, it being incumbent on the
Special Judge presiding over the trial to find, and determine, if
there is any invalidity attached to the sanction order and further
as to whether failure of justice has occurred on such account and
pass the necessary order thereupon-more appropriate stage for
reaching such conclusion being after evidence has been adduced
on the “issue in question” which means evidence having been
adduced on the issue of validity of sanction;
(g) If such objection is raised belatedly, the time lapse being of
considerable significance, the court is not obliged to consider the
effect of any such error, omission or irregularity. In order to
claim the protection of law against prosecution without valid
sanction, the public servants, however, is expected to raise the
issue at the earliest stage of the trial. The objection of such nature
pressed when the trial is near termination would render the issue
inconsequential. To put it simply, if the challenge to the validity of
sanction is made at the initial stage of trial, and within
reasonable period of time, the Special Judge is duty bound to
examine the issue, being “free” to pass an appropriate order
thereupon, the inhibition of Section 19(3)(a) of the POC Act and
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
Section 465 Cr. PC being inapplicable to the trial court, such
provision forbidding the appellate or revisional court from
entertaining such objection for the first time at later stages. It
must, however, be added here that the determination of the issue by
the Special Judge in the course of the trial is subject to judicial
scrutiny by this court in the supervisory jurisdiction; and
(h) Further, it is necessary that the objection to the validity of
sanction is considered and the issues raised are determined at the
earliest for the reason continuation of criminal prosecution on
invalid sanction is not desirable since such proceedings are void
ab initio. Rather, if the objection is raised at an early stage, the
court is duty bound to consider and decide upon it instead of
relegating it to the concluding stage of final determination of the
case, it being not just or fair to do so since that approach would
render the statutory protection illusory.”
(emphasis supplied)
17.
While the facts of the present case may not be identical to the
relied upon judgments, it is clear from the above that sanction under
Section 197 of the CrPC is a sacrosanct precursor which determines
the competence of a Court to try the case against the accused. Thus,
the issue in relation to any irregularity or validity of sanction ought to
be raised at the earliest. Lapse of time in agitation of such an issue
would render the same as inconsequential. The accused can thus not
be faulted for agitating the issue at the outset.
18.
Even though there is some merit in the contention of the State
that the stage of examining the validity of sanction is during the course
of trial rather than at the pre-trial stage [Ref. CBI v. Ashok Kumar
Aggarwal (supra)], however, there is no bar against consideration of
the issue at pre-trial stage, and the issue can be determined at the
outset if the facts warrant the same. It is important to note that hearing
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
of arguments on charge necessarily includes prima facie appreciation
of the material collected during the investigation. In prosecution of
Government Servants, the cogency of the sanction is also a necessary
fact that has to be considered by the learned Special Judge as the same
has bearing on the Court’s competence to try the accused. In CBI v.
Manohar Baburao Nandanwar (supra), the Hon’ble Bombay High
Court has not provided any reasons for its observation that recourse to
Section 311 of the CrPC for examining the Sanctioning Authority is
contrary to the principles of law. As discussed above, the issue qua
sanction can be raised at any stage, preferably at the earliest, and the
power under Section 311 of the CrPC can be exercised at any stage as
well. Moreover, this Court is of the opinion that the glaring facts of
the present case necessitate examination of the Sanctioning Authority
before the learned Special Judge can proceed further.
19.
In order to appreciate the same, it is important to appreciate the
peculiar facts which led to passing of the impugned order by the
learned Special Judge. Chargesheet in the present case was initially
filed only against the co-accused Sumdev and the prosecution had kept
the accused - Vikram Singh Meena in Column No.12 on account of
not finding any conclusive evidence against him. No sanction was
sought against the accused - Vikram Singh Meena due to the same
either. It is only subsequently that the learned Special Judge, while
hearing the arguments on charge in regard to the co-accused Sumdev
on 01.09.2016, observed that prima facie case is also made out against
the accused – Vikram Singh Meena. As the correctness of the order
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
dated 01.09.2016 is not assailed in the present proceedings, this Court
is refraining from commenting upon the same at this stage since the
challenge to the said order has already been disposed of by this Court
as withdrawn on an earlier occasion. However, it is imperative to note
that the Sanctioning Authority granted the sanction after taking note of
the observations of the learned Special Judge in order dated
01.09.2016.
20.
It is in the backdrop of the aforesaid facts that the accused -
Vikram Singh Meena has expressed a legitimate apprehension of the
sanction being plagued with non-application of mind. The case of the
accused – Vikram Singh Meena is essentially helmed on the argument
that the sanction granted against him is unsustainable in law as the
same was granted solely on direction of the learned Special Judge,
thereby robbing the administrative authority of the discretion of
applying its mind.
21.
The law in regard to grant of sanction is well-settled. The same
requires independent application of mind by the Sanctioning Authority
on the basis of material collected during the investigation. Independent
application of mind by the sanctioning authority and appreciation of
all relevant material is a sine qua non for a valid sanction. In the case
of CBI v. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal (supra), the Hon’ble Apex Court
had detailed the essentials of a valid sanction as under:
“16. In view of the above, the legal propositions can be
summarised as under:
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
16.1. The prosecution must send the entire relevant record to the
sanctioning authority including the FIR, disclosure statements,
statements of witnesses, recovery memos, draft charge-sheet and
all other relevant material. The record so sent should also contain
the material/document, if any, which may tilt the balance in favour
of the accused and on the basis of which, the competent authority
may refuse sanction.
16.2. The authority itself has to do complete and conscious
scrutiny of the whole record so produced by the prosecution
independently applying its mind and taking into consideration all
the relevant facts before grant of sanction while discharging its
duty to give or withhold the sanction.
16.3. The power to grant sanction is to be exercised strictly
keeping in mind the public interest and the protection available to
the accused against whom the sanction is sought.
16.4. The order of sanction should make it evident that the
authority had been aware of all relevant facts/materials and had
applied its mind to all the relevant material.
16.5. In every individual case, the prosecution has to establish and
satisfy the court by leading evidence that the entire relevant facts
had been placed before the sanctioning authority and the authority
had applied its mind on the same and that the sanction had been
granted in accordance with law.”
(emphasis supplied)
22.
By way of order dated 01.09.2016, after appreciating the
material on record, the learned Special Judge had explicitly directed
the prosecution to obtain the requisite sanction to prosecute the
accused – Vikram Singh Meena. A perusal of the sanction order as
well as the affidavit tendered on behalf of State reflect that the
relevant material was put to the Sanctioning Authority for obtaining
sanction, instead of sanction being sought solely on the thrust of the
observations made by the learned Special Judge. The present case is
not one where the sanction was rejected by the Sanctioning Authority,
and subsequently granted on the direction of the Court. Undisputably,
no sanction was ever sought by the prosecution against the accused -
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
Vikram Singh Meena at the first instance.
23.
Even so, although no positive direction for grant of sanction
was made to the Sanctioning Authority by the learned Special Judge,
the possibility of the Sanctioning Authority being unduly weighed by
the observations of the learned Special Judge cannot be negated. In the
distinctive facts of this case where the prosecution had not sought
sanction on an earlier occasion and the sanction has only been granted
subsequently after certain observations were made by the Court, it is
imperative to ascertain independent application of mind. The said
aspect can only be clarified by the Sanctioning Authority.
24.
Though this Court does not seek to propose recourse to Section
311 of the CrPC at the pre-trial stage in every case in a routine manner
where question of validity of sanction is raised, in the atypical facts of
the present case, the learned Special Judge cannot be faulted for
summoning the Sanctioning Authority before proceeding further with
the arguments on charge. It has been rightly observed by the learned
Special Judge that since consideration of the issue of sanction is not
per se barred at the pre-trial stage, there is no cause to deny the
accused a fair opportunity to demonstrate his case.
25.
Secondly, insofar as the petition filed by the accused – Vikram
Singh Meena being CRL.M.C. 10017/2024 is concerned, it is pertinent
to note that the accused – Vikram Singh Meena, on an earlier
occasion, had challenged the order dated 01.09.2016 whereby the
learned Special Judge had directed the prosecution to obtain requisite
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
sanction against the him.
26.
The State has contested the maintainability of the challenge as
the accused – Vikram Singh Meena had previously withdrawn his
petition, being, CRL.M.C. 3559/2016 whereby the order dated
01.09.2016 was challenged. Reliance is placed on the case of State v.
G. Easwaran : 2025 SCC OnLine SC 643, where the Hon’ble Apex
Court was dealing with challenge to quashing of proceedings by the
High Court on account of the sanction being illegal. In that case, the
Sessions Court had dismissed the application of accused for discharge,
which he assailed in revision before High Court, which was dismissed
with the observation that prima facie, the available material had been
considered. Pursuant to the same, the accused filed a petition under
Section 482 of the CrPC for quashing of the proceedings, which was
allowed by the High Court, after considering the statement of the
representative of the sanctioning authority. Finding the observations
on sanction to be premature, the Hon’ble Apex Court deplored the
interdiction of proceedings by the High Court.
27.
It is argued on behalf of the accused – Vikram Singh Meena
that considering the State’s challenge to summoning of sanctioning
authority prior to framing of charge, he must be allowed to challenge
the validity of the sanction order.
28.
From a perusal of the material on record, it appears that the
accused – Vikram Singh Meena, on the earlier occasion, had sought
permission to withdrawn the petition with liberty to raise the issue
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
before the learned Special Judge. Consequently, this Court, while
disposing of the petition being CRL. M.C. 3559/2016 had given
liberty to the accused – Vikram Singh Meena to raise the issue of
invalidity of sanction for prosecution before the learned Special Judge
in terms of the ruling of this Court in State v. Mukesh Kumar Singh
& Anr. and K.G. Tyagi v. State (supra).
29.
The liberty granted by this Court on that occasion cannot be
construed to mean that the issue ought to be agitated at the conclusion
of the trial at the final stage. The same, in the opinion of this Court, is
a necessary and relevant fact to be considered given the peculiar facts
of the case. It is not in doubt that the accused – Vikram Singh Meena
was satisfied with the disposal of the petition on that occasion and he
took his chance to file an application under Section 311 of the CrPC
before the learned Special Judge.
30.
At this juncture, it is apposite to note that as the previous
petition preferred by the accused had been withdrawn with liberty and
the issue of validity of sanction was not considered on merits on the
previous occasion, this Court is not precluded from considering the
challenge in exercise of its inherent power under Section 482 of the
CrPC.
31.
It is settled law that any order of sanction can only be set aside
if the same is passed without application of mind or without
considering the material relied upon by the prosecution or for
extraneous considerations. Be that as it may, insofar as the argument
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
in relation to application of mind is concerned, having found that the
learned Special Judge had rightly summoned the Sanctioning
Authority, this Court does not consider it apposite to stifle the
prosecution against the accused at this juncture. On the first blush,
while it may appear that the order granting sanction has been passed
without application of mind solely because the learned Special Judge
had opined that sufficient material existed which prima facie reflected
that the accused – Vikram Singh Meena had committed offences under
Sections 7/13(1)(d) of the PC Act and Section 384 of the IPC,
however, a perusal of the sanctioning order also indicates that the
authorities had considered the material before passing the sanction
order.
32.
Whether the sanction order was passed solely being weighed by
the order passed by the learned Special Judge or not can only be
ascertained after the sanctioning authority is examined. It cannot be
determined with certainty in the present proceedings as to whether the
sanction order is invalidated due to absence of application of mind.
33.
While the accused – Vikram Singh Meena has also agitated
arguments in relation to Section 319 of the CrPC not being applicable
and the Court having erred in proceeding against him after stage of
cognizance was over, pertinently, the challenge before this Court is
limited to the sanctioning order and the supplementary charge sheet.
Considering the same as well as the fact that the accused – Vikram
Singh Meena had previously withdrawn his challenge to order dated
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
01.09.2016 with liberty to raise argument in relation to validity of
sanction before the learned Special Judge, this Court does not consider
it apposite to delve into the said arguments at this juncture.
34.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court finds no reason to
interfere with the impugned order dated 16.03.2019 or to quash the
sanction order and supplementary chargesheet.
35.
Accordingly, CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 is dismissed and CRL.M.C.
10017/2024 is disposed of in the aforesaid terms. Pending applications
also stand disposed of.
36.
Needless to say, the accused – Vikram Singh Meena is at liberty
to agitate all arguments at the appropriate stage.
37.
A copy of this judgment be placed in both the matters.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
FEBRUARY, 20 2026
“SS”
Digitally Signed
By:SHIKHA SEHGAL
17:50:39
CRL.M.C. 4808/2019 & CRL.M.C. 10017/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review