Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
D.B. Criminal Appeal No. 928/2017
CNR: RJHC020931912017 | URN: CRLA / 1646U / 2017
Vikas @ Sunny Son of Naresh Kumar, R/o Katopur, Police Station
Kotkasim, District Alwar. At Present Confined At Jail Alwar.
----Appellant
Versus
State of Rajasthan Through P.P.
----Respondent
For Appellant(s)
:
Shri Govind Prasad Rawat with
Shri Bhawani Singh Rathore
For Respondent(s)
:
Shri Jitendra Singh Rathore, P.P. for
State
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MAHENDAR KUMAR GOYAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI CHIRANIA
Judgment
Date of Conclusion of Arguments
Judgment Reserved On
::
::
27/07/2026
27/07/2026
Whether the full judgment or
only the operative part is pronounced : : Full Judgment
Judgment Pronounced On
::
31/07/2026
Per Hon’ble Mahendar Kumar Goyal, J.
Under challenge in this criminal appeal is the judgement
dated 01.04.2017 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge
No.2, Alwar (for short-`the learned trial court’) in Sessions Case
No.45/2013,
whereby,
the
accused-appellant
(for
appellant’) has been convicted and sentenced as under:
short-`the
(2 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
1.
Section
IPC:
[CRLA-928/2017]
One
month’s
simple
imprisonment and fine of Rs.500/-; in default
whereof, ten days’ additional simple imprisonment.
2.
Section
IPC:
Three
years’
rigorous
imprisonment and fine of Rs.1000/-; in default
whereof,
one
month’s
additional
rigorous
imprisonment.
3. Section 302 IPC: Life imprisonment and fine
of Rs.10,000/-; in default whereof, six months’
additional rigorous imprisonment.
Sentences to run concurrently.
The facts, in a nutshell, germane for disposal of the present
appeal are that the complainant Mahendra Singh (PW1) submitted
a written report (Ex.P1) with the Police Station Aravali Vihar, Alwar
on 20.09.2013 and as per the police endorsement on it, at about 9
am stating therein that the dead body of his son Naresh with
marks of incised weapon on various body parts was lying in the
mortuary of Government Hospital. It was further averred that
another boy namely Anoop was also injured in the incident and
was sent to SMS Hospital, Jaipur for treatment. A strong suspicion
was cast upon a boy namely Sunny behind the incident. Based
thereupon, an FIR dated 20.09.2013 was registered for the
offences under Sections 341, 323, 324, 307 and 302 IPC. After
investigation,
the
appellant
was
charge-sheeted
under
the
aforesaid provisions whereunder, charges were also framed. After
trial, the appellant has been convicted and sentenced, as stated
hereinabove.
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
(3 of 13)
[CRLA-928/2017]
Assailing the impugned judgement, learned counsel for the
appellant contended that the findings of the learned trial court are
based on conjectures and surmises and there was no legally
admissible evidence available on record to warrant his conviction.
He submitted that the learned trial court erred in relying upon the
testimony of so-called eye witness Anoop Kumar (PW7) ignoring
and overlooking that his police statement (Ex.D2) was recorded as
late
as
on
26.09.2013,
whereas,
the
incident
was
dated
19.09.2013. Elaborating his submission, he argued that the
prosecution has miserably failed to offer any explanation for this
inordinate delay in recording his statement under Section 161
Cr.P.C. which is fatal to his credibility. He further canvassed that as
per his injury report (Ex.P11), the x-ray report (Ex.P20) and the
Sonography report (Ex.P19), the injury on his body was found to
be simple in nature and therefore, there was no reason for this
inordinate delay in recording the police statement.
Learned counsel asserted that while holding him guilty, the
learned trial court seriously erred in relying upon recovery of a
knife-the alleged weapon of offence at his instance. In this regard,
inviting the attention of this Court towards the seizure memo of
the knife (Ex.P13) as also statement of the Investigating Officer
Shri Ganpatram (PW20), he contended that therefrom, it was
established that the place of recovery was not under his exclusive
possession rather, was accessible to all and sundry. Learned
counsel argued that in the aforesaid factual backdrop, he could
not have been connected with the alleged offence with the aid of
(4 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
[CRLA-928/2017]
recovery of the knife. He, therefore, prayed that the appeal be
allowed, the judgement dated 01.04.2017 be quashed and set
aside and he may be acquitted of the charges framed against him.
Learned counsel relied upon a coordinate bench judgement of this
Court dated 16.01.2026 in the case of Mangal Pandit @ Mangal
Pandey
vs.
State
of
Rajasthan,
D.B.
Criminal
Appeal
No.131/2021 and five connected appeals in support of his
contentions.
Per
contra,
learned
Public
Prosecutor
opposing
the
submissions, contended that the learned trial court has held the
appellant guilty of the charges levelled against him based on
cogent evidence available on record and therefore, the appeal
deserves to be dismissed being devoid of merit.
Heard. Considered.
Vide judgement impugned, the appellant has been held
guilty of, inter alia, murder of Naresh. As per the postmortem
report of his body (Ex.P15), he has received 7 stab wounds on
thoracic and abdominal cavity, i.e., vital part of the body and as
per opinion of the Medical Board which conducted the autopsy,
cause of death was hemorrhage shock due to lungs injuries which,
in the ordinary course of nature, were sufficient to cause death.
The autopsy report was duly proved by Dr. Rajeev Kumar Gupta
(PW13), a Member of the Medical Board. Nothing has borne out
from his cross examination to indicate that the death of Naresh
did not occur on account of ante-mortem injuries received by him.
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
(5 of 13)
[CRLA-928/2017]
On that premise, it is found to be an established case of culpable
homicide.
The question before us is whether the prosecution has been
able to bring home the charge of murder of Naresh against the
appellant.
In support of its case, the prosecution has relied upon
testimony of S/Shri Rahul, Anoop Kumar, Praveen, Ms. Manisha
and Ms. Pooja as the eye witnesses of the incident. Amongst
them, their star witness is Anoop Kumar (PW7)-an injured eye
witness. As per his testimony, in the evening of fateful day, i.e.,
19.09.2013 at about 5.30 pm, after purchasing a lock from the
Hope Circus, he, along with the deceased Naresh and Rahul went
on a motorcycle to Mani-ka-bad where the deceased purchased a
book for himself. Thereafter, they went near old RTO where
Praveen was already standing and all four of them had “pani ke
patase” (golgappa). He stated that in the meanwhile, two girls
also came there to have golgappa and since, Rahul knew them, he
requested them to become friend with him and the deceased but,
they did not respond and went away. Whereafter, they all four left
for hostel and in the way, Naresh requested Praveen and Rahul to
fetch the book which he inadvertently had left at the golgappa
cart. He further deposed that thereafter, when they were
proceeding to the hostel, they found both the girls at electricity
house near RTO office along with the appellant who, alleging that
they had teased the girls, inflicted an injury with a knife on his left
thigh and stabbed 5-7 times in the abdomen and chest of Naresh.
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
(6 of 13)
[CRLA-928/2017]
He stated that in the meanwhile, Praveen and Rahul had also
reached the scene of crime whereupon, the appellant fled away. It
was alleged that Naresh had died at the spot and initially, he was
taken to Solanki Hospital, but, on account of his serious condition,
he was shifted to the SMS Hospital, Jaipur.
A perusal of his cross-examination reflects that his testimony
remained unshattered although, he admitted that some of the
averments made in the examination-in-chief were not part of his
police statement (Ex.D2) but, we do not find the same to be of
such material worth so as to discredit the substance of his
testimony reflecting complicity of the appellant in the crime.
In the case of Balu Sudam Khalde & Anr. vs. State of
Maharashtra-(2023) 13 SCC 365, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
has laid down the following legal principles to be kept in mind
while appreciating the testimony of an injured eye witness:
“26. When the evidence of an injured eyewitness is to be
appreciated, the undernoted legal principles enunciated by
the courts are required to be kept in mind.
26.1 The presence of an injured eyewitness at the time and
place of the occurrence cannot be doubted unless there are
material contradictions in his deposition.
26.2 Unless, it is otherwise established by the evidence, it
must be believed that an injured witness would not allow
the real culprits to escape and falsely implicate the
accused.
(7 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
26.3
The
evidence
of
[CRLA-928/2017]
injured
witness
has
greater
evidentiary value and unless compelling reasons exist, their
statements are not to be discarded lightly.
26.4 The evidence of injured witness cannot be doubted on
account of some embellishment in natural conduct or minor
contradictions.
26.5
If
there
be
any
exaggeration
or
immaterial
embellishments in the evidence of an injured witness, then
such contradiction, exaggeration or embellishment should
be discarded from the evidence of injured, but not the
whole evidence.
26.6 The broad substratum of the prosecution version must
be
taken
into
consideration
and
discrepancies
which
normally creep due to loss of memory with passage of time
should be discarded.”
If the testimony of the injured eye witness in the instant
case, i.e., PW7 is tested on the touchstone of the aforesaid legal
principles, we find the same to be natural, reliable and free from
material contradictions or embellishments so as to discredit the
same.
Further,
his
testimony
stood
corroborated
from
the
deposition of Praveen (PW8). Supporting the deposition made by
Anoop Kumar, he has further stated that when he reached to the
scene of the crime after fetching the book left by the deceased at
the golgappa cart, he saw the appellant inflicting knife blows on
the body of the deceased and upon seeing them, he fled away.
Although, during his cross-examination, he admitted that he did
not inform either the family members of the deceased or the
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
(8 of 13)
[CRLA-928/2017]
police and his police statement was recorded on 22.09.2013 but,
we are of the view that mere non-information to either the family
members of the deceased or the police of the incident would not
impeach
his
testimony
which
otherwise,
is
found
to
be
creditworthy as well as trustworthy in the attending facts and
circumstances. It is trite that every person reacts differently in
unexpected and sudden extreme distress situation and nobody can
be expected to do exactly in similar fashion a normal prudent
human being would have done in identical circumstances.
Another prosecution witness Rahul (PW4), although declared
hostile inasmuch as he declined to identify the appellant; but, in
his deposition, he has corroborated the statement of S/Shri Anoop
Kumar and Praveen to the extent that they had gone at the given
time on the fateful day to purchase a lock from the Hope Circus
Alwar, whereafter, the deceased purchased a book, wherefrom,
they came to golgappa cart where Praveen was already standing
and they all had the golgappa. He has also stated that in the
meanwhile, two girls also reached there to have golgappa and he
knew one of them namely; Pooja. He has further stated that he
had requested Pooja to talk to Naresh and Anoop. Further, he has
corroborated the prosecution evidence that he, along with
Praveen, went back to golgappa cart to fetch the book purchased
by Naresh, who had inadvertently left it there and when they
reached the scene of crime on motorbike, he saw Naresh fallen on
the ground with injury to Anoop. Similarly, though the girls,
namely, Manisha (PW5) and Pooja (PW6) were declared hostile
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
(9 of 13)
[CRLA-928/2017]
inasmuch as they had feigned ignorance as to how Naresh died
but, in the course of their deposition, they have supported the
prosecution case that at about 6.30 pm on 19.09.2013, they had
met the deceased and his friends at golgappa cart where they
tried to talk to them but, they refused. They have further admitted
that two boys namely; Naresh and Anoop came behind them.
It may be worthy to notice here that the allegations levelled
against the appellant of causing death of Naresh Kumar by
stabbing him with the knife 5-7 times on his chest and abdomen
as also infliction of a knife injury on the left thigh of injured Anoop
Kumar, stood corroborated from the postmortem report of the
body of deceased Naresh (Ex.P15) and the injury report of Anoop
Kumar (Ex.P11).
Therefore, in the conspectus of aforesaid testimony of the
injured eye witness namely; Anoop Kumar and other eye
witnesses, we are convinced that it was established that the four
boys including the deceased met PW5 and PW6 at golgappa cart in
the evening of the fateful day, i.e., 19.09.2013 and while, two
boys namely; Praveen and Rahul went back to the cart to fetch
the book purchased by the deceased Naresh, Naresh and Anoop
Kumar went towards the scene of crime. Further, from the
testimony of the injured eye witness Anoop Kumar (PW7), the eye
witness Praveen (PW8) and the medical evidence, it was also
established that while, the appellant inflicted a knife blow on the
left thigh of the injured, Anoop Kumar was stabbed 5-7 times on
his chest and abdomen resulting into his instant death.
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
(10 of 13)
[CRLA-928/2017]
In so far as submission of learned counsel for the appellant
as to delay in recording police statement of PW7 destroying the
probative value of his deposition is concerned, we do not find any
force in it. Although, the police statement of Anoop Kumar (PW7)
was recorded with delay, i.e., on 26.09.2013 but, we are not
persuaded to record a finding that it discredited his entire
testimony. From the ocular evidence, as discussed hereinabove as
also from the injury report (Ex.P11) and the deposition of Dr. Udai
Bhan Yadav (PW18) who has prepared it, it was established that
Anoop Kumar had received a stab wound on left thigh near his
private part entailing his admission in the hospital. His police
statement also reflects that it was recorded while he was under
treatment in the City Ward Bed No.11, SMS Hospital, Jaipur and
its scribe namely; Shri Banbihari Sharma (PW17), the then ASI at
Police Station Aravali Vihar, Alwar, has categorically stated that he
recorded this statement at SMS Hospital, Jaipur which was not
challenged during his cross-examination. We also notice from the
record that the Investigating Officer Shri Ganpat Ram (PW20) was
not confronted during his cross-examination as to delay in
recording the police statement of the PW7. In the case of State of
U.P. vs. Satish-(2005) 3 SCC 114, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
has held as under:
“18. As regards delayed examination of certain
witnesses, this Court in several decisions has held
that unless the Investigating Officer is categorically
asked as to why there was delay in examination for
the
witnesses
the
defence
cannot
gain
any
advantage therefrom. It cannot be laid down as a
(11 of 13)
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
[CRLA-928/2017]
rule of universal application that if there is any
delay in examination of a particular witness the
prosecution
version
becomes
suspect.
It
would
depend upon several factors. If the explanation offered
for the delayed examination is plausible and acceptable
and the court accepts the same as plausible, there is no
reason to interfere with the conclusion [See Ranbir and
Ors. vs. State of Punjab, AIR (1973) SC 1409, Bodhraj v.
State of Jammu and Kashmir, [2002] 8 SCC 45 and Banti
v. State of
M.P.,
[2004] 1
SCC
414.]”
(Emphasis
supplied).
Further, in somewhat identical circumstances, their Lordships
have, in the case of Ganesh Lal vs. State of Maharashtra(1992) 3 SCC 106, declined to discredit the testimony of Moti
Ram (PW6) who, otherwise, was found to be a natural witness and
reliable on the premise that there was delay of nearly two and a
half months in recording his statement as the investigation did not
proceed in the desired lines initially and only after PW16 took over
the investigation, he recorded the statement of the PW6. It was
further observed that his presence at the scene of crime was
natural, he had no axe to grind against the appellant or any of the
members of his family and was an independent witness though,
he was a Compounder working with Dr. Chitlange, brother-in-law
of PW5, an interested witness. Further, it was categorically held
that since, the PW6 was a natural witness, his evidence could not
have been doubted due to delay in his statement.
In the instant case as well, the presence of the witness
Anoop Kumar along with deceased at the time of incident is found
to be proved beyond an iota of doubt. It is not the defence case
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
(12 of 13)
[CRLA-928/2017]
that either he had any enmity with the appellant or that he had
any relationship with the deceased. His testimony is otherwise
found to be natural and trustworthy and therefore, in the
backdrop of the aforesaid precedential law, we have no hesitation
to hold that mere delay in recording his Section 161 Cr.P.C.
statement would not discredit it.
So far as recovery of weapon of offence-the knife at behest
of the appellant is concerned, although, the learned trial court has
recorded a finding that the prosecution was able to connect him
with its recovery; however, we have a different view. As
per
its
seizure memo (Ex.P13), it was recovered from the room rented to
the appellant in the residential house of Shri Chedi Lal. However,
Shri Ganpat Ram (PW20)- the
Investigating
Officer
has
categorically admitted in his cross-examination that the room
wherefrom the knife was recovered, was open and in the
remaining portion of the subject house, the landlord and his family
members were residing. He has also admitted that a possibility
could not be denied that the room was accessible to one and all.
Further, from the testimony of Shri Hamesh Prakash (PW10), one
of the motbir witnesses to the seizure memo, it is not reflected
that the subject room was opened by the appellant rather, it was
found to be open. From the aforesaid testimony, it is established
that the subject room was not under exclusive possession of the
appellant and the learned trial court erred in connecting the
appellant with the recovered knife. However, in view of the wholly
reliable ocular testimony establishing the guilt of the appellant, we
[2026:RJ-JP:29564-DB]
(13 of 13)
[CRLA-928/2017]
are of the considered view that even if the prosecution has not
been able to establish recovery of the weapon of offence, it would
not come to rescue of the appellant. Dealing with an identical
situation, it was held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the
case of State through Inspector of Police vs. Laly & Ors.-AIR
2022 SC 5034 as under:
“7. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Similarly, assuming
that the recovery of the weapon used is not established
or proved also cannot be a ground to acquit the accused
when there is a direct evidence of the eye witness.
Recovery of the weapon used in the commission of the
offence is not a sine qua non to convict the accused. If
there is a direct evidence in the form of eye witness, even
in the absence of recovery of weapon, the accused can be
convictedxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx”
Reliance placed by the learned counsel for the appellant on
the judgement of this Court in the case of Mangal Pandit (supra)
is of no help to him having been rendered in entirely different
factual context.
Upshot of the aforesaid discussion is that we find that the
learned trial court did not err in returning the finding of guilt of
the appellant under Sections 341, 324 and 302 IPC as the
prosecution was able to establish the ingredients thereof to the
hilt.
Resultantly, the appeal is dismissed being devoid of merit.
(RAVI CHIRANIA),J
50/RAVI SHARMA
(MAHENDAR KUMAR GOYAL),J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review