Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
$
%
%
"
"
!#
"
&
' ( ' )
*+
'
*
,
!
"
Digitally signed
by
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
"
#$%
!
"
%&
' ($#
"
'
"
"
# ##
#
$ $
$ %
'
"
"
$
$%
$ $
"
&#
$#% "
""
& %%
-2-
%$(
!
"
%
# #
"
"
"
"
"
"
'
)
)
*
+,-
./0,-,12
3/4,4,12
,-
5,./64/5
9:58;/24 574/5
# ##
=> 4+/
55<
,-4.,64 725
/--,12- :58/
=./0,4>
@",.-4
33/<<74/
1:.4A!
33/<<74/
$ % 37--/5 ,2
787,2-4
4+/
1#
$ $
7,6+:.
?1.
4+/
",.-4
.<
B+/./=>
1:.4 5,-;,--/5 4+/ 733/7< ?,</5 => 4+/ ./0,-,12
3/4,4,12/. => 612?,.;,28 4+/ 9:58;/24 1? 6120,64,12 725
1.5/. 12 -/24/26/ 37--/5 ,2
$
$%
$ $ => 4+/
=./0,4> C4+/ .,7<
,0,<
:58/ 725
#&
"
$#% 574/5
720,
?1.
1:.4D!
"1. 4+/ -7E/ 1? 6120/2,/26/
4+/ 37.4,/- 7./
./?/../5 41 7- 3/. 4+/,. .72E,28- =/?1./ 4+/ .,7<
1:.4
-3-
%
#
$&
+/ ?764:7< ;74.,F 1? 4+/ 3.1-/6:4,12 ,- 4+74 12
$#% 74 7=1:4 $# $$ 7 ;
,2 4+/ /7.<> ;1.2,28 4+/
766:-/5 ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. =/,28 4+/ 5.,0/. 1? <1..> =/7.,28
./8,-4.74,12
&
%( $ 5.10/ 4+/ -7;/ ,2 7 +,8+
-3//5 725 .7-+ 725 2/8<,8/24 ;722/. 74 4+/ =.,58/ 1?
720,
7,6+:.
=/7.,28
175 725 4+/./=> 57-+/5 4+/ 4.7,</. 4.7641.
./8,-4.74,12
0,<<78/.- 1?
%G
72/-+7 ,51< ,2 7 -4./7;
4+.// 3/.-12- 27;/<>
7;/-+7
B+/./,2
-:-47,2/5
8.,/01:-
-:66:;=/5 41 4+/ ,29:.,/-
7<<7337
,29:.,/-
,-+B7.75>7 , /
./-3125/24
& %%
'
1<,6/
<74/.
4+/>
'
'
- -:6+
12/
55,4,127<<>
<158/5 4+/ 61;3<7,24 =/?1./ 4+/
B+,6+
B7-
./8,-4/./5
,2
$#% ?1. 4+/ 1??/26/- 3:2,-+7=</ :25/.
%$(
-7
:<,8/337 725
-:-47,2/5 ,29:.,/- 5:/ 41 4+/ 766,5/24
1 #&#
4+/
/<7+7<<, 0,<<78/ 4.70/<,28 ,2 4+/ -7,5 4.7641.
4.7,</. ?1. ,;;/.-,12 1? 1.5
./-:<4
#G
! 1?
.,;/
/64,12-
:=-/H:/24<> 4+/ ./-3125/24 I
1<,6/ 6125:64/5 4+/ ,20/-4,874,12 725 <7,5 6+7.8/ 787,2-4
766:-/5 =/?1./ 4+/
.,7<
1:.4 ?1. 4+/ 1??/26/- 3:2,-+7=</
-4-
:25/.
/64,12-
# # 1?
(
& %%
%$(
! 1?
/64,12- % 725
1 3.10/ 4+/ 6+7.8/- </0/<</5 787,2-4 4+/
766:-/5 =/?1./ 4+/
B,42/--/- 7F- # 41
.,7<
' # 41
#
1:.4 4+/ 3.1-/6:4,12 /F7;,2/5 &
' & 725 ;7.E/5 #
516:;/24- 7-
+/ 766:-/5 2/,4+/. /F7;,2/5 72> B,42/--
12 +,- =/+7<? 21. ;7.E/5 72> 516:;/24-
7--/--;/24
1?
1.7<
516:;/247.>
/0,5/26/ 4+/ .,7<
1:.4 6120,64/5 4+/ 766:-/5 ?1. 4+/
%%
%$(
! 1?
/64,12- % 725 # # 1?
64 725
-/24/26/5 +,; 7- :25/.)
#$ %
&
' " 6&
!
"
(###)*
+ ,-. / 0
,! '
45 -2 &
'
+'2 3 ! '%
1 " 7
#$ % &
' " 6&
'
+'2 3 ! '%
1 " 7
!
'<
!
"
(###)*
+ ,-. / 0
,! '
45 -2 &
8#49:;
" #
&
'
(#=###)*
&
+
-5-
,-. / 0
'
" 6&
+'2 3 ! '%
1 " 7
,! '
8= (>( ? : ,
"
5##)*
+ ,-. / 0
,! '
-2 &
'
!
! '%
:
4 >
G
+2 &2 3
B / C
!E
88.,/0/5
4+/
&
" 6&
12 @
"
C -.D 2
'F 'G H ' +
=>
$ %
+'2 3
1 " 7
2 , 1 " 7 '1A
/ '- 2 3
/0 I
-7,5
9:58;/24
4+/
766:-/5 3/4,4,12/. 3./?/../5 72 733/7< =/?1./ 4+/ ",.-4
33/<<74/
1:.4
1:.4 ,2
.<
1#
$ $
+/ ",.-4
33/<<74/
12 ./7--/--,28 4+/ /0,5/26/ 725 516:;/24- 12
./61.5 612?,.;/5 4+/ 9:58;/24 1? 6120,64,12 725 1.5/. 1?
-/24/26/ 37--/5 => 4+/
.,7<
1:.4 725 4+/./=> 5,-;,--/5
4+/ 733/7< ?,</5 => 4+/ 766:-/5 3/4,4,12/.
-7;/ ,-
=/?1./ 4+,-
+7<</28/ 41 4+/
1:.4
/7.5 </7.2/5 61:2-/< ?1. 4+/ ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/.
725 4+/ </7.2/5
./-3125/24
,8+
1:.4
10/.2;/24
</75/. ?1. 4+/
474/
37.4 ?.1; :.8,28 -/0/.7< 6124/24,12- </7.2/5
61:2-/<
?1.
4+/
3/4,4,12/.
3.,;7.,<>
6124/24/5
4+74
-6-
9:58;/24-
:25/.
4+,-
./0,-,12
3/4,4,12
3/.0/.-,4> 725 ,<</87<,4> -,26/ 4+/
33/<<74/
.,7<
-:??/.-
?.1;
1:.4 725 4+/ ",.-4
1:.4 8.1--<> /../5 B+,</ 6120,64,28 4+/ 766:-/5
725 -/24/26,28 +,; B,4+1:4 733./6,74,28 4+/ /0,5/26/ 12
./61.5 ,2 7 .,8+4 3/.-3/64,0/
/ ?:.4+/. 6124/25/5 4+74
12 3/.:-7< 1? 4+/ /0,5/26/ 1? ,29:./5 />/B,42/--/- , /
'
'
4+/./ 7./ ;:6+ 5,-6./3726,/- 725 4+/>
?7,</5 41 ,5/24,?> 4+/ 3/4,4,12/. 7- 7 5.,0/. 5:.,28 4+/
61:.-/ 1? 766,5/24 -,26/ 4+/ 766,5/24 B7- 67:-/5 /7.<>
;1.2,28
$# $$
7;
#
$&
$#%
/
7<-1
6124/25/5 4+74 74 21 31,24 1? 4,;/ 4+/ 766:-/5 5.10/ 4+/
<1..> ,2 H:/-4,12 725 ,2 ?764 4+/ 766:-/5 B7- 7 6</72/. 1?
4+/ -7,5 <1..>
/-3,4/ 4+/
20/-4,874,12
??,6/. ?7<-/<>
<7,5 6+7.8/ -+//4 787,2-4 4+/ ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. B,4+1:4
3.13/.<> 6125:64,28 4+/ ,20/-4,874,12
12/4+/</--
3.1-/6:4,12 +7- 214 /F7;,2/5 4+/ 20/-4,874,12
-:6+ 6,.6:;-4726/
4+/ =/2/?,4 1? 51:=4 +7- 41 =/
/F4/25/5 41 4+/ 766:-/5 ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/.
+/ 6124/25/5 4+74
??,6/.
4+/
4+/
.,7<
<4/.274,0/<>
1:.4 725 ",.-4
33/<<74/
-7-
1:.4 /../5 ,2 ,;31-,28 ;7F,;:; 3:2,-+;/24 1?
?1. 4+/ 1??/26/ 3:2,-+7=</ :25/.
/64,12 %$(
1?
>/7.725
12 4+/ ?764 725 6,.6:;-4726/- 1? 4+,- 67-/ 725 7<-1
612-,5/.,28 4+/ 78/ 1? 4+/ 766:-/5 4+74 +/ B7- $ >/7.- 74
4+/ 4,;/ 1? ,26,5/24 4+/ </2,/26/ 672 =/ -+1B2 41 4+/
766:-/5 ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. => ;15,?>,28 4+/ -/24/26/
',4+ 4+/-/ -:=;,--,12-
+/ 3.7>- 41 7<<1B 4+/ ./0,-,12
3/4,4,12
&
4+/
</7.2/5
.,7<
1:.4 725 ",.-4
33/<<74/
+7- 6124/25/5 4+74
1:.4 7?4/. ;/4,6:<1:-<>
/F7;,2,28 4+/ /24,./ /0,5/26/ 12 ./61.5 .,8+4<> 6120,64/5
4+/
766:-/5
./0,-,12
3/4,4,12/.
B,4+
./7-12/5
9:58;/24- B+,6+ 51 214 67<< ?1. 72> ,24/.?/./26/ 74 4+/
+725- 1? 4+,1?
'
1:.4
'
/ 7<-1 6124/25/5 4+74 4+/ /0,5/26/
B+1 B/./ 4+/ ,29:./5 />/B,42/-- 41 4+/
,26,5/24 6</7.<> 5/3,64- 4+74 12 4+/ 574/ 1? 766,5/24 4+/
766:-/5 ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. 5.10/ 4+/ <1..> ,2 7 .7-+ 725
2/8<,8/24 ;722/. 725 57-+/5 4+/ 4.7641. 4.7,</. ,2 B+,6+
-8-
4+/ 5/6/7-/5 725 4+/ ,29:./5 B/./ 4.70/<,28 ?1. 4+/
,;;/.-,12 1?
#$
72/-+7 51<
/ ?:.4+/. 6124/25/5 4+74 7- 4+/ <1..> B7- ?/<<
51B2 ,2 4+/ -4./7; 4+/ 766:-/5 ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12/. 7<-1
-:-47,2/5 ,29:.> ,2 4+/ 766,5/24
2 -:6+ 6,.6:;-4726/-
4+/ 5/?/26/ 1? 4+/ 766:-/5 4+74 +/ B7- 214 5.,0,28 4+/
<1..> 672214 =/ =/<,/0/5
0/2 14+/.B,-/
+/ +7- 214
-474/5 /,4+/. ,2 +,- %#% -474/;/24 21. /F7;,2/5 +,;-/<?
=> 3.10,5,28 +,- 5/?/26/ /0,5/26/
661.5,28<> +/ 3.7>-
41 5,-;,-- 4+/ ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12
##
+70/ 8,0/2 ;> 72F,1:- 612-,5/.74,12 =14+ 12
4+/ -:=;,--,12- ;75/ => 4+/ </7.2/5 61:2-/< ?1. 4+/
./-3/64,0/ 37.4,/- 725 4+/ 516:;/24- 707,<7=</ 12 ./61.5
#
7-/5 12 4+/ /0,5/26/ 12 ./61.5 ,2 4+/ ,2-4724
67-/ 4+/ 766,5/24 ,2 H:/-4,12 =/4B//2 4+/ <1..> =/7.,28
./8,-4.74,12
&
%( $ 725 4+/ 4.7641. 4.7,</.
%G
=/7.,28 ./8,-4.74,12
720,
7,6+:.
4+/
#G
74 4+/ =.,58/ 1?
,24/.0/2,28
2,8+4
1?
-9-
#
$&
$#% 725 #
$&
-/.,1:-<> ,2 5,-3:4/
$#% 74 7=1:4 $# $$ 7 ;
,- 214
":.4+/. ,4 ,- 7<-1 214 ,2 5,-3:4/ 4+74
5:/ 41 4+/ 766,5/24
4+.// 3/.-12- , /
12/
7<<7337
:<,8/337 725
7;/-+7 -:66:;=/5 41 4+/ ,29:.,/- 725
'
-:-47,2/5 ,29:.,/-
'
4+/,. 5/74+
41 3.10/
4+/ 3.1-/6:4,12 +7- ./<,/5 12 4+/ ,2H:/-4
3726+727;7 74
./31.4
55,4,127<<>
F- #
F- #$
G 725 7<-1 4+/ 7:413->
#
<<
4+/-/
516:;/24-
674/81.,67<<> /-47=<,-+ 4+74 7<< 4+/ 5/6/7-/5 7./ 5,/5 5:/
41 4+/ 766,5/24
- -:6+ 4+/ H:/-4,12 ?1. 612-,5/.74,12 ,2
4+/ ,2-4724 67-/ ,- B+/4+/. 4+/ -7,5 766,5/24 B7- 67:-/5
5:/ 41 4+/ .7-+ 725 2/8<,8/24 5.,0,28 1? 4+/ ./0,-,12
3/4,4,12/. 1? 4+/ <1..> =/7.,28
4+/./=> 57-+/5 41 4+/ 4.7641. 4.7,</.
&
%( $ 725
1 -:=-4724,74/ 4+/
-7,5 7-3/64 4+/ 3.1-/6:4,12 +7- 3.,;7.,<> ./<,/5 12 4+/
/0,5/26/ 1?
'
'
/>/B,42/--/- 41 4+/ ,26,5/24
'
B+1 7./ 4+/ ,29:./5
<< 4+/-/ B,42/--/- B/./
674/81.,67<<> -474/5 ,2 4+/,. /0,5/26/ 4+74 12 4+/ 574/ 1?
,26,5/24 4+/ 766:-/5 B7- 5.,0,28 4+/ <1..> ,2 7 +,8+ -3//5
- 10 -
725 .7-+ 725 2/8<,8/24 ;722/. 12 4+/ =.,58/ 1?
7,6+:.
720, .175 725 57-+/5 4+/ 4.7641. 4.7,</. ,2 B+,6+ 7<< 1?
4+/; B/./ 4.70/<<,28 ?1. ,;;/.-,12 1? 4+/
72/-+
51<
+1:8+ 4+/-/ B,42/--/- B/./ 6.1-- /F7;,2/5 74 </284+ =>
4+/,.
5/?/26/
61:2-/<
214+,28
B1.4+B+,</
+7-
=//2
/<,6,4/5 ?.1; 4+/,. ;1:4+ 41 5,-67.5 4+/,. 4/-4,;12>
#%
'
55,4,127<<> 4+/ 3.1-/6:4,12 +7- 7<-1 /F7;,2/5
61;3<7,2724 ,2 4+,- 67-/ => ./,4/.74,28 4+/ 61;3<7,24
70/.;/24-
'
+7- 674/81.,67<<> -474/5 4+74 12 4+/ 574/
1? ,26,5/24 +/ 7<128 B,4+ 5/6/7-/5 725
'- # 725
B/./ 4.70/<,28 ,2 4+/ 4.7641. 725 4+/ 4.7641. B7- -4133/5
12 4+/ /F4./;/ </?4 -,5/ 1? 4+/
7,6+:.
720, =.,58/
4+74 4,;/ 4+/ 3/4,4,12/. =/,28 4+/ 5.,0/. 1? 4+/ <1..> 67;/
,2 7 .7-+ 725 2/8<,8/24 ;722/. 725 57-+/5 4+/ 4.7641.
7 ./-:<4
-
4+.// 3/.-12- B/./ 5,/5 725 14+/.- B/./
-:-47,2/5 ,29:.,/-
661.5,28 41 +,; 4+/ <1..> 7<-1 ?/<< 12
4+/ -4./7; 725 4+/ 3/4,4,12/. 5.,0/. -:-47,2/5 ,29:.,/- 5:/
41 4+/ -7,5 766,5/24
+,- /0,5/26/ 1?
61..1=1.74/- 4+/ 4/-4,;12> 1? '-
'
6</7.<>
- 11 -
#(
1 51:=4 4+/ B,42/--/- ?1. 4+/ -314 ;7+7J7.
+70/ 4:.2/5 +1-4,</ 41 4+/ 3.1-/6:4,12 67-/
1B/0/.
-,26/ 4+/ ,29:./5 />/B,42/--/- -:331.4/5 4+/ 67-/ 1?
3.1-/6:4,12 B+1 B/./ 0/.> ;:6+ 3./-/24 12 4+/ -6/2/ 1?
4+/ 166:../26/ 4+/ /0,5/26/ 1? -314 ;7+7J7. B,<< 214 3<7>
;:6+ 0,47< .1</
#
+/ 5/?/26/ 1? 4+/ 766:-/5 4+74 +/ B7- 214
5.,0,28 4+/ <1..> ,2 H:/-4,12 725 +/ B7- 7 6</72/. 74 4+74
4,;/ 672214 =/ 766/34/5 ?1. 4+/ -,;3</ ./7-12 3.,;7.,<>
4+/ 766:-/5 +7- -:-47,2/5 ,29:.,/- 5:/ 41 4+/ 766,5/24 725
/F6/34 +,; 21=15> B7- ,2 4+/ <1..>
0/2 14+/.B,-/ +/
+7- ?7,</5 41 /F3<7,2 ,2 +,- %#% -474/;/24 ,? +/ +7- 214
5.10/ 4+/ <1..> 4+/2 B+1 /<-/ 5.10/ 4+/ -7;/ 74 4+/ 4,;/
1? 766,5/24
2 -:6+ 6,.6:;-4726/
4+/ 5/?/26/ 1? 4+/
766:-/5 ,- 214 7 3.1=7=</ 12/
4+/
#G
2 67./?:< 3/.:-7< 1? 4+/ 9:58;/24 37--/5 =>
.,7<
1:.4 725 4+/ ",.-4
33/<<74/
1:.4
=14+ 4+/
1:.4- +70/ .,8+4<> 5/7<4 B,4+ 4+/ /0,5/26/ 725 ;74/.,7<12 ./61.5
55,4,127<<>
+70/ 3/.:-/5 4+/ 3+1418.73+-
- 12 -
725 4+/ -314 ;7+7J7. 3.15:6/5 7- 3/.
5/3,64-
F
4+/ -7;/
4+/ <1..> ,2 H:/-4,12 B7- 57-+/5 787,2-4 4+/
4.7641. 10/. 4+/ =.,58/ 725 7- 7 ./-:<4 4+/ -7;/ ?/<< 12
4+/ -4./7; 725 4+/ ,2;74/- 4.70/</.- 1? 4+/ 4.7641. 4.7,</.
5,/5 725 14+/.- B/./ ,29:./5
#
1./10/. 4+/ 766:-/5 +75 21 -:6+ 07<,5 5.,0,28
<,6/26/ 74 4+/ 4,;/ 1? 766,5/24
212 /F7;,274,12 1? 4+/
2 -:6+ 6,.6:;-4726/ ;/./
20/-4,874,28
??,6/. ,2 4+/ 67-/
,4-/<? 51/- 214 47E/ 7B7> 4+/ 67-/ 1? 4+/ 3.1-/6:4,12 B+/2
7;3</ /0,5/26/ 1? 4+/ />/B,42/--/- 725 14+/. ;74/.,7<7./ 707,<7=</ 12 ./61.5
2 -:6+ 6,.6:;-4726/
7; 1? 4+/
612-,5/./5
,24/.?/./26/
4+/
,;3:82/5
4+/
7<4/.274,0/
0,/B
4+74
,2
9:58;/24- 51 214 67<< ?1.
#
1B/0/.
B,4+
./87.5
6124/24,12 1? </7.2/5 61:2-/< ?1. 4+/ 3/4,4,12/. ,2 ./-3/64
1? ;15,?,674,12 1? -/24/26/ ,- 6126/.2/5 75;,44/5<> 4+/
3/4,4,12/. B7- 78/5 7=1:4
$ >/7.- 74 4+/ 4,;/ 1? ,26,5/24
661.5,28 41 4+/ </7.2/5 61:2-/< ?1. 4+/ 3/4,4,12/.
- 13 -
3./-/24<> 4+/ 766:-/5 ,- ;7..,/5 725 +70,28 -6+11< 81,28
6+,<5./2
#&
2 -:6+ 6,.6:;-4726/
7; 1? 4+/ 612-,5/./5
0,/B 4+74 4+/ -/24/26/ 1? # >/7. ?1. 4+/ 1??/26/ 3:2,-+7=</
:25/.
/64,12 %$(
,2-4/75 1?
1?
B1:<5 ;//4 4+/ /25- 1? 9:-4,6/
>/7.- ,;31-/5 => 4+/
7??,.;/5 => 4+/ ",.-4
33/<<74/
.,7<
1:.4 B+,6+ B7-
1:.4 => ;7,247,2,28 ./-4 1?
4+/ -/24/26/- ,;31-/5 => 4+/
.,7<
1:.4
661.5,28<>
3.16//5 41 37-- 4+/ ?1<<1B,28)
,
+/ ./0,-,12 3/4,4,12 ,-
,,
+/ 9:58;/24 1? 6120,64,12 725 1.5/. 1?
-/24/26/ ,;31-/5 => 4+/
.,7<
1:.4
B+,6+
4+/
",.-4
B7-
33/<<74/
612?,.;/5
=>
1:.4
4+/
3:2,-+7=</ :25/.
?1.
/64,12-
1??/26/-
& %%
/64,12- % 725 # # 1?
1?
,-
+/./=> 612?,.;/5
,,,
+/ 6120,64,12 ,;31-/5 ?1. 4+/ 1??/26/
3:2,-+7=</ :25/.
/64,12 %$(
1?
,-
- 14 -
7<-1
612?,.;/5
1B/0/.
-/24/26/
,;31-/5 ?1. 4+/ -7,5 1??/26/ ,- ;15,?,/5
?1. 7 3/.,15 1? # >/7. ,2-4/75 1?
B,4+ 7 ?,2/ 1?
- #$ $$$
>/7.-
,2 5/?7:<4 1?
37>;/24 1? ?,2/ 766:-/5 -+7<< :25/. 81
-,;3</ ,;3.,-12;/24 ?1. 7 3/.,15 1? G
;124+,0
<< 4+/ -/24/26/- -+7<< .:2 6126:../24<>
/8,-4.> ,- 5,./64/5 41 -/25 =76E 4+/
.,7<
1:.4 ./61.5- 7<128 B,4+ 7 6/.4,?,/5 613>
1? 4+,- 1.5/. 41 4+/ 6126/.2/5
1:.4
?1.4+B,4+
-+
'
"
*
"
,-4
4)
1)#
<
1) %
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review