Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.M.MANOJ
WEDNESDAY, THE 5TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 14TH PHALGUNA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 4660 OF 2015
PETITIONER :
VIDYA E A
AGED 30 YEARS
ASSISTANT PROFESSOR (ECONOMICS), SREE NARAYANAGURU
COLLEGE, CHELANNUR, KOZHIKODE.
BY ADVS. SRI.K.SASIKUMAR
SRI.R.ROHITH
RESPONDENTS :
DIRECTOR OF COLLEGIATE EDUCATION, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
695 001.
DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF COLLEGIATE EDUCATION
KOZHIKODE - 673 001.
PRINCIPAL,
SREE NARAYANA GURU COLLEGE, CHELANNUR,KOZHIKODE - 673 021.
MANAGER,
SREE NARAYANA COLLEGE, THE SREE NARAYANA TRUSTS,KOLLAM 691 001.
STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENTHIGHER
EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM695 001.
BY ADVS. SRI.A.N.RAJAN BABU(R4)
SRI.P.GOPALAKRISHNAN MVA(R4)
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
OTHER PRESENT:
R1,2 AND 5 - SRI.BINOY DAVIS, GOVERNMENT PLEADER
THIS
WRIT
PETITION
(CIVIL)
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD
05.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
JUDGMENT
Dated this the 5th day of March, 2025
The petitioner was appointed as a Lecturer in Economics under
the 4th respondent’s College at Kollam on 24.02.2010, which falls
within the jurisdiction of Kerala University. Thereafter, her appointment
was approved as per Ext.P2. The petitioner is Serial No.10. Later, the
probation period was declared successful with effect from 05.03.2011.
2. Since the petitioner is a native of Thrissur District, she sought
a convenient posting to her home place-Irinjalakuda, on interuniversity transfer. While continuing there, a vacancy arose at Sree
Narayana Guru College, Chelannur, Kozhikode due to the relieving of
Dr.M.P. Dinesh with effect from 04.07.2013 to take up employment in
Government service. Under such circumstances, the 4th respondent
Manager has issued order dated 05.07.2013, whereby the petitioner
was transferred to SN College, Chelannur as Assistant Professor in
Economics against the vacancy that arose on relieving Dr.M.P.Dinesh.
On 15.07.2013, petitioner was relieved from the service of 4 th
respondent to join the college of 3rd respondent. Both these colleges
are under the same management.
The transfer was accepted and
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
formalities for payment of salary were finalised without delay and the
petitioner was receiving salary while working in that college under the
Calicut university.
3. After some time, the 3rd respondent received a letter from the
2nd respondent calling for a report on the basis of an unsigned
complaint received by them in the name of one ‘Save SNDP Forum’
alleging that a teacher from SN College under the Kerala University in
the Economics Department was transferred to SN College, Chelannur,
and as there was no sufficient workload for the sanctioned post in the
Department of Economics in that college, it was requested to enquire
into the matter. In response to that, the 3rd respondent preferred a
report to the 2nd respondent wherein it is taken that there is an
exemption of 4 hours in the weekly workload of NCC ANOs was not a
hollow statement but supported by a government decision.
It is
evident from Ext.P10 dated 13.10.2004 issued by the Principal
Secretary to Government to the Director of Collegiate Education and
the
Director
of
Technical
Education
No.4475/A2/04/H.Edn. dated 26.02.2004,
issued
to
reduce
the
that
by
letter
a clarification has been
weekly
workload
of
ANOs upto a maximum of 4 hours, wherever adequate staff is available
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
in accordance with the UGC Norms. But a restriction is imposed with
respect to the appointment of additional staff.
4. Later in the year 2015, the incumbent who holds the post of
ANO, Smt.Kumari Padmaja P.S., Associate Professor in Economics
Department retired from service with effect from 30.04.2014. Thereby,
only two faculties under the Economics Department are working with
effect from 01.05.2014.
At that point of time, the workload of the
Department of Economics under the 3rd respondent College was 40,
which permits appointments of two posts at the rate 16 hours per post.
On taking into consideration Ext.P10 dated 13.10.2004, it is contended
by the counsel for the petitioner that since the second incumbent is
holding the charge of ANO, she is entitled to a reduction of 4 hours out
of 16 hours. Moreover, being an Associate Professor, she is required to
handle only the workload of 14 hours. Taking into consideration all
these factors, altogether 26 hours of workload was available for the
existing two teachers at the time of joining of the petitioner against the
40 hours of assessed workload. The remaining is 14 hours workload.
5. The petitioner was appointed against the vacancy due to the
relieving of Dr.M.P. Dinesh whose appointment was approved and who
drew salary till 04.07.2013. On approving the inter-university transfer,
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
the petitioner was also permitted to draw salary till 12/2014. By the
time of Ext.P14 Order dated 22.12.2014, there were sufficient posts
available as per the existing workload as Smt.Kumari Padmaja P.S.,
retired from service with effect from 30.04.2014, and the vacancy was
available with effect from 01.05.2014. The 3rd respondent has also
certified that, at that point of time, already two faculties were working
under the Economics Department against the workload of 40 hours.
6. In the meanwhile, by Ext.P2 the 2nd respondent has forwarded
a report to the 1st respondent on the basis of an anonymous and
unsigned complaint. Wherein it is stated that the workload at the 3 rd
respondent College is 40 hours. As per law, two faculties can be
accommodated for 32-hour workload. What remains is 8 hours. On
03.12.2014 itself three faculties were working. From 2013 July 4, the
petitioner was transferred from Kollam SN College to SN College
Chelannur which comes within the jurisdiction of the University of
Calicult
as
Department.
an
inter-University
transfer
under
the
Economics
Moreover, it is also reported that as per the GO(MS)
No.640/2013/H.Edn. dated 10.10.2013,
earlier Government Order
dated 12.09.2013 was modified and the course allotted to 3rd
respondent College for BBA was converted as MA Economics. Thereby
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
the workload has been raised to 66 hours. This report is issued on
07.10.2014. Even thereafter, on 04.11.2014, the 4th respondent was
directed to cancel the transfer and repatriate the petitioner to the SN
College, Kollam. In the light of that, Ext.P14 sanction of the salary was
declined. This is the circumstance in which the petitioner has preferred
this writ petition.
7. Per contra, a counter affidavit has been filed by the 2 nd
respondent stating that the petitioner was originally appointed under
SN Trust Management, at SN College, Kollam as Asst. Professor
Economics, under the Kerala University. The SN Trust management
has a practice of transferring teachers from one college to another
under separate Universities without considering the workload and
nature of posts. While transferring her, only two sanctioned posts were
available under the 3rd respondent against 40 hours workload per
week. The petitioner was transferred on 15.07.2013 to 3rd respondent
College against the third post, which is not sanctioned. She joined the
College on 17.07.2013 against the vacancy of Dr.M.P. Dinesh, who had
been relieved from service to join government service. Apart from the
petitioner, two other teachers were working against the existing
workload. While a complaint was received from a forum named ‘save
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
SNDP Forum’ stating that the transfer was effected against a nonexisting post and against the workload available in the college and
hence the 1st respondent directed the 2nd respondent to conduct
enquiry into the affairs.
8. Accordingly, a report was obtained from the 3rd respondent
wherein it is stated that one teacher of the Economics Department is
NCC ANO and she has an exemption of 4 hours on the basis of
Government letter dated 13.10.2004 and such workload can be
reduced up to a maximum of 4 hours, wherever adequate staff are
available in accordance with the UGC Norms. Appointment of additional
staff on this account will not be permissible and misconstruing the said
letter, the 4th respondent continued to appoint the teachers. It is also
admitted that after the retirement of Smt.Kumari Padmaja from
Economics Department on 30.04.2014, only two teachers were
available, including the petitioner.
On a finding that there is no
sufficient workload, the 4th respondent was directed to withdraw the
petitioner from 3rd respondent college and to appoint her to 4 th
respondent college. The transfer of the petitioner was effected against
a vacancy that occurred on a subsequent event. In fact, the vacancy in
which the petitioner was originally appointed was an excess one.
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
Therefore, the contentions raised by the petitioner cannot be
considered.
9. In reply to the counter affidavit filed by the 2nd respondent, the
petitioner has filed a reply affidavit wherein she reiterated the
contention raised in the writ petition. It is also contended that there
were three teachers working in the Economics Department. When a
third teacher, Smt.Sindhu Krishnadas, was denied salary on the ground
of insufficient workload, she had approached this Court and obtained a
judgment whereby the High Court directed to release her salary on
declaring that once the university approved the appointment of a
teacher in a college, the Directorate of Collegiate Education is bound
to release salary. Thereby, the working of third teacher in SN College
Chelannur is settled. Moreover, by Ext.P18 the petitioner is trying to
substantiate that there was sufficient workload to accommodate the
petitioner.
10. An additional counter affidavit was filed by the 2nd respondent
wherein on the strength of Exts.R2(a) and R2(b), the actual workload
after accommodating two Assistant Professors is 8 hours only. The 4
hour exemption of an ANO cannot be calculated as per the Government
Letter dated 13.10.2004. Since the letter dated 18.08.2015 of the
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
Director of Collegiate Education to the Deputy Director of Collegiate
Education says not to fill up the posts consequent to the retirement of
Kumari Padmaja, the petitioner’s transfer to SN College Chelannur is
irregular. This was also replied to by the petitioner by preferring an
additional affidavit. Thereby denied the contentions in the additional
affidavit.
11. A counter affidavit has been filed by the 4th respondent, but
supporting the contentions of the petitioner.
12. I have heard Sri.K.Sasikumar, learned counsel for the
petitioner. Sri.A.N Rajan Babu for R3 and R4, Sri.Binoy Davis, learned
Government Pleader for R1, R2 and R5.
13. Having considered the submissions across the Bar, it appears
that the petitioner was originally appointed against the existing
vacancy under the 4th respondent. Her appointment was approved by
the University and her probation was declared. Later, on her request
for a transfer to a convenient place near to home station, she was
transferred to a vacancy that arose at 3rd respondent College due to
the relieving of Dr.M.P.Dinesh to join government service. Thereafter,
that appointment itself was approved by the University and salary was
disbursed till a complaint was received by the 2nd respondent.
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
14. On receipt of the complaint from a third person, with respect
to the workloads as well as excess of teachers under the Economic
Department, enquiry has been conducted by the 2nd respondent, and
a report was submitted to the 1st respondent. Accordingly, the 1st
respondent directed the 4th respondent to cancel the transfer of the
petitioner and to repatriate her. In the light of such direction, the salary
of the petitioner was denied from 12/2014.
But during the pendency
of the writ petition, on considering that a vacancy has arisen with effect
from 01.05.2014, due to the retirement of Kumari Padmaja, the
Associate Professor, a direction was issued to disburse the salary of the
petitioner with effect from the date of the petition and the petitioner is
now receiving the salary. What remains is a period between 12/2014
till the disbursal of salary to the petitioner after Ext.P14. Under such
circumstances, a perusal of Ext.P7 judgment has relevance.
In a
similar situation, this court has considered the issue and concluded that
once the University has approved the appointment of a teacher in a
college, the director of Collegiate Education is bound to release the
salary.
15. The remedy available in such cases is that the Director of
Collegiate Education can move the University to cancel such approval.
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
Unless and until the University cancels such approval, the 1 st or 2nd
respondent cannot deny salary.
Here, the University has already
approved, and later salary has been disbursed to the petitioner till
12/2014. With regard to the workload and excess posting of teachers,
the management cannot deny salary to the petitioner. That too on the
basis of Ext.P12 report, wherein it is specifically stated that at the time
of issuing Ext.P14, the workload of Economics Department has been
increased to 66 hours pursuant to the introduction of MA Economics.
Hence, Ext.P14 and P13 are set aside and the 2nd respondent is directed
to calculate the salary which is in arrears and disburse it to the
petitioner within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this judgment.
The Writ Petition is disposed of accordingly.
Sd/-
P.M.MANOJ
JUDGE
ttb
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 4660/2015
PETITIONER EXHIBITS :
EXT.P-1: A TRUE COPY OF THE APPOINTMENT ORDER
DATED 24.2.2010 ISSUED BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT
EXT.P-2: A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
6.12.2010 ISSUED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF KERALA.
EXT.P-3: A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
2.8.2011 PASSED BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT
EXT.P-4: A TRUE COPY OF THE RELIEVING ORDER
DATED 4.7.2013 ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT
EXT.P-5: A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
5.7.2013 ISSUED BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT
EXT.P-6: A TRUE COPY OF THE RELIEVING ORDER
DATED 15.7.2013 ISSUED BY THE PRINCIPAL,
S.N.COLLEGE, KOLLAM.
EXT.P-7: A TRUE COPY OF THE UNSIGNED COMPLAINT
IN THE NAME OF THE PRESIDENT SAVE SNDP FORUM
EXT.P-8: A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED
29.1.2014 FORWARDED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT TO
THE 3RD RESPONDENT
EXT.P-9: A TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT DATED
6.2.2014 FORWARDED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT TO THE
2ND RESPONDENT
EXT.P-10: A TRUE COPY OF THE GOVERNMENT LETTER
DATED 13.10.2014 ADDRESSED TO THE IST
RESPONDENT
EXT.P-11: A TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE DATED
16.1.2015 SHOWING THE FACT OF THAT RETIREMENT
AND THE FACT OF ONLY 2 FACULTIES WORKING IN THE
DEPARTMENT WITH EFFECT FROM 1.5.2014.
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
EXT.P-12: A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED
4.10.2014 FORWARDED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT TO
THE IST RESPONDENT
EXT.P-13: A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
4.11.2014 ISSUED BY THE IST RESPONDENT
EXT.P-14: A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
22.12.2014 ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT TO THE
3RD RESPONDENT
EXT.P-15: A TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION
DATED 6.1.2015 FORWARDED BY THE PETITIONER TO
THE 2ND RESPONDENT
EXT.P-16: A TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION
DATED 29.1.2015 FORWARDED BY THE PETITIONER TO
THE IST RESPONDENT
EXT.P-17: A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGEMENT DATED
28.8.2006 IN WPC NO.35412 OF 2005 PASSED BY
THIS HON'BLE COURT.
EXT.P-18: TRUE COPY OF THE EXTRACT OF THE UGC
REGULATIONS DATGED 30.06.2010.
EXT.P-19: A TRUE COPY OF THE GO DATED
12.03.2012 ISSUED FROM THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA
HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT.
EXT.P-20: A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
24.01.1999 ISSUED BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT.
EXT.P-21: A TRUE RELEVANT EXTRACT OF GO(P)
No.58/2010/H.Edn., DATED 27.03.2010.
RESPONDENT’S EXHIBITS:
EXT.R2(A): TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER
No.18138/A2/04/H.EDN. DATED 13.10.2004.
EXT.R2(B): TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER
D2/37852/2013/COLL.EDN. DATED 18.08.2015.
2025:KER:19806
WP(C)No. 4660 of 2015
EXT.R2(C): TRUE COPY OF THE POST ADALATH
//TRUE COPY//
Sd/P.S. TO JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review