Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supp. List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 358 of 2023
Date of Order :21.11.2023
Shri. Vicky S.Sangma & 2 Ors.
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Chief Justice (Acting)
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. K.Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S.Chanda, Adv.
Mr. S.K.Hassan, Adv.
Mr. B.Snaiting, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. A.Kumar, AG with
Mr. E.R.Chyne, GA.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The facts briefly put are that the petitioners, who possess the
qualification of B.Ed and MTET, had applied for the post of Assistant
Teacher L.P.School pursuant to an advertisement dated 14-06-2023, issued
by the respondent No. 6, for filling up of 71 vacancies in Ampati SubDivision of South West Garo Hills. In the said advertisement, at para 3
thereof, the qualifications prescribed was as follows:
“Para 3 – Qualifications
1. Essential Qualification for Lower Primary School
Teachers: Class 12th Passed with 50% for General
Candidates & 45% for ST/SC Candidates with D.El.Ed.
or Graduate with B.Ed. As Per NCTE Notification dated
23/08/2010 - Sl. 1.
2. MTET Passed Certificate: Compulsory.
3. D.El.Ed. Passed Certificate: Compulsory.
4. Language proficiency will be required as per the medium
of the instruction of the school.
5. Age limit:
a. In pursuance to the Personnel & A.R.(A) Department
Office Memorandum vide No. PER. 38/2021/30 dated
Shillong, 3rd February 2022, the candidate upper age
limit will be 32 years on the first day of the year in
which the advertisement is made i.e. as on 1st January
2023 and 5 years additional relaxation in case of
candidates belonging to ST/SC will be applicable.
b. Age relaxation for Persons with Disabilities (PwDs)
will be as per Personnel & A.R.(B) Department Office
Memorandum vide No. PER (AR) 150/88/560 dated
Shillong, 18th January 2023.
c. In the case of candidates already in government
service, he/she should have first entered service within
the age limit mentioned in Clause 4(a) above and
he/she shall have to obtain a No Objection Certificate
(NOC) from the concerned office/department for
applying.
d. In pursuance of Memo. No. PER (AR). 60/2023/Pt./5
– A dated Shillong, the 24th May 2023, a one-time age
relaxation is provided for those who have passed
MTET in 2021 but are now overage for consideration
of this advertisement.
6. Basic Computer literacy will be an added preference.”
2.
From the above, it can be noted that Graduates of B.Ed. as per
NCTE Notification dated 23-08-2010 have been mentioned. It appears that
the said Notification was amended, to provide for the said condition of
eligibility by a Notification dated 28-06-2018, which later became a
subject matter in issue, as regards the eligibility and suitability of
candidates having a B.Ed. Degree, to teach in Primary Schools, before the
Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh High Courts. This was then also adjudicated
by the Supreme Court on an appeal being carried against the judgment of
the Rajasthan High Court, by a judgment dated 11-08-2023, the Supreme
Court then in Civil Appeal No. 5068 of 2023 (Devesh Sharma vs. Union
of India) along with other connected matters, quashed and set aside the
Notification dated 28-06-2018. With the setting aside of the Notification,
candidates who held a B.Ed. Degree therefore, in effect, were no longer
eligible to apply for the post of Primary School Teachers.
3.
The petitioners’ main grievance, is with the rejection of their
candidature as given in the impugned list dated 06-11-2023, for not
possessing D.El.Ed. Diploma which was one of the qualifications
prescribed by the advertisement. It has been contended by the petitioners
that at the time when the advertisement was issued, there was no bar as to
aspirants who possessed a B.Ed. Degree and MTET qualification and their
rejection therefore, which they allege is on the basis of the quashing of the
Notification dated 28-06-2018 by the Supreme Court, being a subsequent
event, the same cannot be taken into account for rejecting their
applications.
4.
Mr. K.Paul, learned Sr. counsel for the petitioners, has strenuously
argued that the setting aside of the Notification by the Supreme Court, will
not affect the candidature or eligibility of the petitioners as the same is a
prospective declaration of law, and that if recourse by the respondents is to
be taken to the same to disqualify the petitioners, the advertisement would
have to be withdrawn, as the Notification has been found to be bad in law.
In this context, the learned Sr. counsel has referred to the order of the High
Court of Chhattisgarh dated 21-08-2023, passed in WPS No. 5788 of 2023,
wherein he submits, in a similar situation, the entire recruitment process
was kept in abeyance with regard to candidates having B.Ed. qualification
which however, was interfered with by the Supreme Court in SLP No.
35325/2023, (Harishankar & Anr. vs. State of Chhattisgarh & Ors.)
wherein by order dated 29-08-2023, the order dated 21-08-2023 of the
Chhattisgarh High Court, was stayed and the recruitment process was
allowed to continue, however, with the appointments made subject to the
result of the final outcome of WPS. No. 5788 of 2023. He therefore,
submits that the situation in the present case being similar and identical,
the candidature of the petitioners, should be taken into consideration in the
selection process which has commenced since the issuance of the
advertisement by the respondents.
5.
Mr. A.Kumar, learned AG for the respondents, in his reply, has
submitted that possession of a B.Ed. Degree is no longer a qualification in
the eye of law. The advertisement, he contends, has clearly at Sl. No. 3 of
paragraph 3, stipulated that D.El.Ed. Pass Certificate is compulsory and
this has to be read in isolation, as regards qualifying criteria
notwithstanding the criteria mentioned in Sl. No. 1, which provided for
Graduates with B.Ed. qualification to be eligible. Reliance has been placed
on the Rajasthan judgment, to advance his argument that the B.Ed
qualification was found not suitable or designed for teaching at the primary
level, by referring to paragraph 25, 26 and 27 of the said judgment, and
that the quashing and setting aside of Notification dated 28-06-2018,
which allowed candidates with B.Ed. to apply, has extinguished any right
vested or otherwise, of the petitioners to claim eligibility.
6.
Another limb of argument advanced by the learned AG, is that the
advertisement was issued after the NCTE Notification had been declared
unconstitutional by the Rajasthan High Court vide its judgment dated 255
11-2021, passed in Civil Writ Petition No. 2109 of 2021, and that the
advertisement being issued on 14-06-2023, even on a date of the issuance
of the advertisement, there existed no right in favour of the petitioners to
be appointed as teachers at the primary school level. The learned AG has
placed reliance on the case of CBI vs. R.R.Kishore, 2023 SCC Online SC
1146, and submits that where a notification is declared unconstitutional,
the same would be void-ab-initio and non-est in law. Reliance has also
been placed on the case of State of Manipur vs. Surjakumar Okram, 2022
SCC Online SC 130, wherein the Supreme Court at para 22 and 23 of the
judgment, has held that where a statute is adjudged to be unconstitutional,
it is as if it had never been, and rights cannot be built up under it. He
further submits that the selection process is ongoing and it has not ceased,
and as such, selection is to be based upon the rules and regulations which
are in force, as on the date of consideration, and not on the basis of the
rules which were in force on the date of the advertisement of the vacancies.
In support of this argument, the learned AG has cited the following cases
(i) State of Uttar Pradesh vs. Rachna Hills & Ors. 2023 SCC Online SC
506, (ii) Deepak Agarwal vs. State of UP (2011) 6 SCC 72, (iii) State of
Himachal Pradesh vs. Raj Kumar 2022 SCC Online SC 680.
7.
The learned AG lastly submits, that incorrect reliance has been
placed upon the case arising out of Chhattisgarh High Court, inasmuch as,
in that case, the writ petition was instituted challenging the inclusion of
B.Ed. qualified candidates by the Government which was stayed by that
High Court. The Supreme Court, he submits, by the stay order dated 2908-2023, did not declare any law vesting any right in favour of the B.Ed.
candidates, but only directed that the entitlement of the candidates for
recruitment would be subject to the determination of the writ petition by
the High Court. He therefore, contends that the Notification wherefrom
B.Ed. qualified candidates were allowed to offer their candidature being no
longer in existence, and in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in
holding that a B.Ed. Degree holder was not suitable for teaching in primary
schools, and with the selection yet to be completed, the petitioners do not
possess any vested or legal right to be considered for selection. The
argument advanced earlier that D.El.Ed. was compulsory and is a must was
reiterated by the learned AG.
8.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and looking into the
materials and the facts at hand, the issue before this Court is twofold. First,
whether the rejection is justified considering the finding in the judgment of
the Supreme Court that B.Ed. qualification was not suitable for primary
level education, and secondly, whether the requirement of D.El.Ed. which
was made compulsory at Sl. 3 of the advertisement dated 14-06-2023 is to
be read independently of Sl. No. 1 wherein B.Ed. qualification has been
mentioned.
9.
On the first issue, the judgment of the Supreme Court will no doubt
have a decisive bearing on the present case. This observation is made in
view of the findings recorded at paragraphs 31, 32, 33 which are
reproduced herein below:
“31. The sequence of events show that what
started as an exercise for consideration of B.Ed.
qualified candidates as teachers for Primary classes in
Central schools, was expanded to include all primary
schools throughout the country. The apparent
reasoning given is that B.Ed. qualified candidates are
better suited for appointment as teachers in Primary
schools, as they have 'higher qualifications', and as
such they should be appointed as teachers in all
Primary schools. Another reason for doing this is the
dearth of qualified TET candidates. The figures given
in the meeting suggests that only 6% to 16% of the
candidates who appear in the TET examination
qualify the test. The suggestion appears to be that with
the inclusion of B.Ed. candidates the number of TET
qualified candidates would increase. But this logic
does not hold good when B.Ed. as a qualification has
not passed the basic pedagogical threshold for
teaching primary classes.
We have already examined this aspect in great
detail. B.Ed. is not a qualification for teaching at
Primary level of classes, much less a better or higher
qualification, in context of Primary classes. This
finding is self-evident in the very admission of NCTE
which mandates that all B.Ed. qualified teachers who
are appointed to teach Primary level classes must
mandatorily undergo a pedagogical course for
elementary classes
appointment.
within
two
years
of
their
32. In Society for Unaided Private Schools of
Rajasthan v. Union of India & Anr. (supra) this Court
while upholding the validity of the RTE Act, held that
primary education, which is now a part of
fundamental right under Part III of the Constitution,
has to be a meaningful education, and not just a
formality. When Diploma in elementary education
(D.El.Ed.), was placed as an essential qualification
for teachers in Primary school, it was with a purpose,
and the purpose was to declare only such teachers as
qualified who are trained to impart education to
children at 'primary level'. The pedagogy for a child
who has just entered the school, is an important
consideration. A child has come to face a "teacher",
so to speak, for the first time in a class room. It is the
beginning of a journey for the child student and
therefore world over great care is taken in laying
down proper foundations in these formative years.
Well qualified and trained teacher in elementary
school is an extremely vital aspect. A teacher must be
trained to teach students at "primary level", and this
is precisely what the training of Diploma in
elementary education (D.El.Ed.) does; it trains a
person to teach children at primary level. B.Ed. is not
a 'higher qualification', or a better qualification, as is
being canvassed in its favour, while comparing it with
'Diploma in elementary education'. B.Ed. is a
different qualification; a different training. Even
assuming it is a higher qualification, it would still not
be a suitable qualification for primary level of classes.
Unlike Diploma in elementary education (D.El.Ed.),
B.Ed. does not equip a teacher to teach at primary
level. This fact is implicitly recognised in the
Notification as well (notification dated 28.06.2018),
which still requires a person, who is appointed as a
teacher with B.Ed. qualification to 'mandatorily
undergo a six-month Bridge Course in Elementary
Education'. This defeats the very logic of including
B.Ed. as a qualification, as the very notification which
pushes for the inclusion of B.Ed., also recognises its
inherent pedagogical weakness in its relation to
primary classes. It is to cover this defect, that all such
candidates, must undergo a mandatory six months
Bridge Course in elementary education! The irony
here is that all this is being done when the State of
Rajasthan already has more than the required
number of Diploma qualified candidates available.
This is besides the fact that there is presently no such
"bridge course” available; at least there was none till
the disposal of the petition by the Rajasthan High
Court.
33. Under these circumstances, we are unable
to comprehend as to what was the pressing need to
include B.Ed. candidates, who are admittedly not fully
trained to take up Primary Classes! Consequently, the
decision of the NCTE to include B.Ed. as a
qualification for teachers in a primary school seems
arbitrary, unreasonable and in fact has no nexus with
the object sought to be achieved by the Act i.e. Right
to Education Act, which is to give to children not only
free and compulsory but also 'quality' education.
10.
Further, in para 36 of the same judgment, the Supreme Court was
also of the opinion that the Notification dated 28-06-2018, was violative of
the principles as laid down in the RTE Act, and that the same was against
the purpose and mandate of law which was to provide a meaningful and
quality primary education to children. The Supreme Court had then gone
on to record the finding that the State of Rajasthan was clearly in error in
not calling for applications from B.Ed. qualified candidates for the reasons
that till that time when such advertisement was issued by the Rajasthan
Government, B.Ed. candidates were included as eligible candidates as per
the statutory notification of the NCTE, which is binding on the Rajasthan
Government till it was declared illegal or unconstitutional by the Court.
11.
In the above context therefore, applying the facts of the instant case
to the judgment discussed hereinabove, the advertisement in question was
published on 14-06-2023, and the Notification dated 28-06-2018 had been
quashed by the Rajasthan High Court by order dated 25-01-2021, which
was then upheld by the Supreme Court by order dated 11-08-2023. Though
at the relevant point of time, prior to the issuance of the advertisement, the
Notification dated 28-06-2018, had been quashed by the Rajasthan High
Court, the final binding verdict i.e., the order of the Supreme Court which
has settled the issue finally as to the legality of the Notification dated 2806-2018 cannot be ignored. This observation is made in view of the fact
that notwithstanding any other factors that may be in favour of B.Ed.
qualified candidates to apply for selection for appointment to the post of
primary school teachers, the fact that B.Ed. qualification has been found to
be unsuitable for primary level education, will make any other discussion
on other points of law as purely academic.
12.
Similarly, in the case arising from an order of the Chhattisgarh High
Court in WPS. No. 5788 of 2023, the Supreme Court in SLP No.
35325/2023, (Harishankar & Anr. vs. State of Chhattisgarh & Ors.)
(supra) had only allowed the recruitment process to continue, but made the
same subject to the outcome or result of the consideration to be made by
the High Court in WPS. No. 5788 of 2023. The relevant paragraphs
wherein this direction is contained is reproduced hereinbelow:
“In the meantime, taking into consideration
that the recruitment process which was in progress, is
now interrupted by the ad-interim order dated
21.08.2023 and the aspect ultimately to be considered
by the High Court is with regard to the manner in
which the judgment in C.A. No. 5068 of 2023 passed
by this Court is to be construed, at this stage
interrupting the recruitment process would not be
justified.
Therefore to the said extent, we hereby stay the
order dated 21.08.2023 passed by the High Court and
clarify that the recruitment process, which was in
progress prior to the date of the said interim order
passed by the High Court, shall continue and the
appointments, if any, made thereunder will however
remain subject to result of the consideration to be
made by the High Court in W.P.S No. 5788 of 2023.
The selected candidates shall be informed of the same
by the Appointing Authority concerned.”
13.
Though it has been argued by the Sr. counsel for the petitioners that
the quashing of the Notification dated 28-06-2018, will amount to a
prospective declaration of law and that the advertisement being issued
prior to its quashing should be saved and the B.Ed. qualified candidates be
permitted to take part in the selection process, the peculiar facts of the
instant case warrant that this proposition be viewed from a different angle.
No doubt, as held in the case of N.T. Devin Katti & Ors. vs. Karnataka
Public Service Commission (1990) 3 SCC 157, when a selection process is
initiated by issuing an advertisement, the selection normally should be
regulated by the rule or order then prevailing, and any subsequent
amendment or order will not affect the pending selection process, in the
present case, the implication of the judgment of the Supreme Court
whereby the Notification was set aside and quashed, is necessary and vital
to be given due consideration, and will surely operate as a contrary
indication to the principles laid down by the judgment in N.T. Devin Katti
(supra).
14.
Another aspect which though lesser in importance in this discourse,
is the requirement as stipulated in Sl. No. 3 of the advertisement with
regard to qualification wherein it has been prescribed that D.El.Ed. is
compulsory. This requirement it is noted, has categorically been provided
in the advertisement itself, and a perusal of the impugned rejection of the
petitioners, reflects that the same was on account of the candidates not
having the said qualification without any other reason being ascribed. The
inference that can be drawn therefore, is that notwithstanding the essential
qualifications as given in Sl. No. 1, the respondent authority while
considering the applications had treated the said requirement as given in
the advertisement at Sl. No. 3 as compulsory.
15.
Without further dwelling on the other judgments and propositions of
law that has been advanced by the parties, in the considered view of this
Court, the judgement of the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No. 5068 of
2023 (Devesh Sharma vs. Union of India), is the existing law in force as
far as the suitability of B.Ed. qualified candidates is for teaching at the
primary level. Further, the selection process which was initiated by the
advertisement dated 14-06-2023, is ongoing and is yet to be concluded,
which in the facts of the present case, that is, with the setting aside of the
Notification dated 28-06-2018, should not serve as a legal bar for the
application of the existing law in the consideration of eligible candidates.
16.
Taking into account the situation as it pertains today, with the
eligibility and suitability of the B.Ed. qualified candidates having been
conclusively determined by the Supreme Court, this Court is of the view
that notwithstanding any other circumstances, such as, if any rights have
accrued or can be derived from the advertisement dated 14-06-2023, any
further discussion on this point will be but a futile academic exercise.
17.
Accordingly, for the reasons hereinbefore mentioned, due to the
peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, the reliefs as claimed, if
granted being opposed to approved educational standards and also against
public policy, the writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
18.
No order as to costs.
Chief Justice (Acting)
Meghalaya
21.11.2023
“Samantha PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review