Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MACMA No. 778 of 2023
VS,J.
APHC010608042023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
MONDAY, THE SIXTEENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 778/2023
Between:
1. VICE CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR, APSRTC, REGIONAL
MANAGER. APSRTC BUS COMPLEX KAKINADA, EAST GODAVARI
DISTRICT
...APPELLANT
AND
1. SALAGRAMA KRISHNA KUMARI, W/O LATE VENKATARAMANA
SUBRAHMANYAMSATYANARAYANA MURTHY, AGED ABOUT 43
YEARS, R/O D.NO. 23-6-6 PINDIPROLUVARI STREET, KAKINADA,
EAST GODAVARI DISTRICT
2. GANDHAM RAMAKRISHNA, S/O SUBBARAO AGED ABOUT 52
YEARS. DRIVER APSRTC BUS
BEARING NO. AP-05Z-0031,
APSRTC BUS COMPLEX KAKINADA, EAST GODAVARI DISTRICT
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. K SRINIVASA PRASAD SC For APSRTC
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. T V JAGGI REDDY
The Court made the following:
MACMA No. 778 of 2023
VS,J.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 778/2023
JUDGMENT:
1.
This Motor Accident Claims Miscellaneous Appeal (for short
MACMA) has been preferred by the Appellant/2nd Respondent –Andhra
Pradesh State Road Transport Corporation (for short APSRTC), represented
by its Vice Chairman and Managing Director, Regional Manager, APSRTC
Bus Complex, Kakinada, East Godavari District, challenging the Order/Award
and Decree passed by the Chairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (for
short MACT) –cum- VII Additional District Judge, East Godavari at
Peddapuram in M.V.O.P.No.53 of 2015 dated 29.08.2023 awarding an
amount of Rs.19,59,000/- as compensation as against the claim of
Rs.30,00,000/-.
For the sake of convenience and to avoid confusion, the parties herein
after are referred to as they were arrayed before the Tribunal i.e., Appellant
herein as 2nd respondent, Respondent No.1 herein as Petitioner/claimant,
Respondent No.2 herein as Respondent No.1.
2.
The Petitioner being injured filed claim petition in M.V.O.P.No.53
of 2015 under section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act claiming compensation of
Rs.30,00,000/- together with interest and costs for the injuries sustained by
her in a motor vehicle accident.
MACMA No. 778 of 2023
VS,J.
3.
Brief averments of the claim petition in MVOP No.53 of 2015 are
that: the petitioner is permanent resident of Kakinada. On 22.03.2014 while
the petitioners along with deceased Late. Salagrama Venkata Ramana
Subrahmanya Satyanarayana Murthy and Late. Salagrama Sri Chakra
Vishnavi proceeding from Rajahmundry to Kakinada, after attending their
relatives marriage function, on their TATA motor car Indigo CS bearing No.AP
05 BL 6996 with caution and when they reached near Venkannapeta village at
Rangampeta Mandal on the ADB road, suddenly 1st respondent proceeding
from Kakinada towards Rajahmundry drove the APSRTC bus on the ADB
road in a rash and negligent manner at high speed and dashed the vehicle
bearing No.AP 05 BL 6996, due to which, the petitioners travelling in the
vehicle sustained severe damage and due to the hit went out the ADB road
and the said accident was occurred only due to rash and negligent driving of
the 1st respondent. In the said accident deceased Late. Salagrama Venkata
Ramana Subrahmanya Satyanarayana Murthy who is husband of 1st petitioner
and father of 2nd petitioner died on the spot and Late. Salagrama Sri Chakra
Vishnavi and petitioners received grievous injuries. Nearby persons took them
to the Government General Hospital, Rajahmundry, through 108 Ambulance
and when petitioners and Late. Sri Chakra Vishnavi reached Government
General Hospital, Rajahmundry, due to severity in injuries, Doctors advised to
go to Government General Hospital, Kakinada or any super specialty hospital
for better treatment and that the petitioner and Late. Salagrama Sri Chakra
Vishnavi admitted at Apex Hospital, Rajahmundry.
While undergoing
MACMA No. 778 of 2023
VS,J.
treatment on 23.03.2014 at about 04.20 p.m., Late, Salagrama Sri Chakra
Vishnavi expired at Apex Hospital, Rajahmundry, due to head injury causing
viral organ damage which leads to cardio respiratory arrest.
i.
The
petitioner
after
undergoing
treatment
at
Apex
hospital,
Rajahmundry as inpatient from 22.03.2014 to 02.04.2014 due to her severity
discharged from the Apex hospital, Rajahmundry on 02.04.2014 and for
further follow up treatment, petitioner was advised to go to Miot hospitals,.
Chennai, for fixation of fracture right acetabulum i.e., Central dislocation of
right hip further management and that the petitioner went to Miot hospitals
Chennai and was admitted as inpatient on 03.04.2014 and was undergone
treatment after making provisional diagnosis by the Head of the Department
Dr.P.V.A.Mohandas
and
other
doctors
by
name
Dr.Ramaprasad,
Dr.Brahmaraju, T.J., Dr.Rajavadivel, Dr.Muthukumar, Dr. Dinesh Kumar,
Dr.Dilip
Abdul
Khadar,
Dr.Sathya,
Dr.Visakan
Jagadeesan,
Dr.Arun,
Dr.Sridhar, Dr.Prashant Madan Mohan and Dr.Purohithi P, and undergone
open reduction and internal fixation fracture both columns post-wall on
07.04.2014 by Orthopaedic surgeon and also made final diagnosis with
respect to - 1) T fracture of right actebulam with severe comminution of
posterior wall with Central dislocation of femoral head with impression fracture
of head of right femur. (2) sciatic nerve injury right with foot drop. (3) 10 days
following Orif with plate, screws, K-wire fixation of left distal radius, (4) 10 days
following Orif with plate and screws of right lower 1/3rdradius, (5) 10 days
MACMA No. 778 of 2023
VS,J.
following fixation of fracture facial bones, (6) old case of cerebrovascular
accident and left fronto parietal infarct during pregnancy and (7) urinary tract
infection and discharged the petitioner on 25.04.2014 stating that the
petitioner has to follow the instructions specified by the doctors and due to
permanent disability sustained to the petitioner, the petitioner was advised not
to walk, not to turn to right side do ankle and show mobilization and
statiequardriceps exercise, active knee pending exercise, pelvic bridging
exercise and only to sit out in the chair etc., and the petitioner after
discharging from the hospital became bed-ridden and used to consume the
medicines as specified by the doctors.
ii.
To remove implants and to undergo fracture for left radius admitted
again at Apex hospital, Rajahmundry on 12.07.2014 and surgery was done to
the petitioner for implants removal and fracture left distal radius and the
petitioner was discharged from the hospital on 14.07.2014. The petitioner after
discharging from hospital used to visit the hospital for review and still
consuming medicine and became permanently disabled person and was
unable to do her activities on her own and became dependent upon others.
iii.
The petitioners submit that the Station House Officer, Rangampeta
Police Station registered a case in crime No.40 of 2014 for the offence
punishable under Sections 304A and 338 I.P.C., against the 1st respondent.
4.
The accident was occurred only due to the rash and negligent
driving of the 1st respondent. 1st respondent being driver of the bus of 2nd
MACMA No. 778 of 2023
VS,J.
respondent, 2nd respondent being the owner of the APSRTC bus bearing
No.AP 05 Z 0031, both are jointly and severally liable to pay the
compensation.
5.
The 1st respondent remained exparte.
6.
2nd respondent filed counter, denied the averments in the petition
and contended that on the date of accident i.e., on 22.03.2014 the bus was
proceeding towards Rajahmundry from Kakinada as non-stop service. When
the bus reached near Venkannapeta village, a car came from opposite
direction to the bus from Rajahmundry side without observing the bus, the
driver of the car by seeing the bus suddenly confused and turned the car
opposite to the bus and due to that the accident happened. There was
negligence on the part of the deceased - driver of the car. The driver of the
bus was driving the bus very slowly and cautiously. The accident was
occurred only due to careless act of the driver of the car. There was no
negligence on the part of the driver of the bus. The petitioners are not entitled
to claim any interest, much at the rate as claimed in the petition. The
petitioners are not entitled for the various amounts claimed under various
heads of column No.23 of the petition. There are no merits in the petition and
hence prayed to dismiss the petition.
7.
Basing on the above pleadings, the following issues have been
framed by the tribunal for trial:
MACMA No. 778 of 2023
VS,J.
1) Whether the deceased Salagrama Krishna Kumari, W/o. Late
Salagrama Venkata Ramana Subrahmanya Satyanarayana Murthy
sustained injuries in a motor accident occurred on dt. 22.03.2014 due
to rash and negligent driving of APSRTC Bus bearing registration
No.AP 05 Z 0031 driving by its driver/1st respondent?
2)
Whether the petitioner is entitled to claim compensation? If so, to
what amount and from which of the respondents?
3) To what relief?
8.
During the course of trial, petitioner herself got examined as
P.W.1, eyewitness to the accident got examined as P.W.2, the Doctors who
treated the petitioner got examined as P.W.3 to P.W.5 and got marked Ex.A.1
to Ex.A.81 and Ex.X.1 documents.
No oral or documentary evidence is adduced on behalf of 2nd
respondent.
9.
Upon hearing both side counsel, upon perusing the oraland
documentary evidence placed on record by both parties, the tribunal partly
allowed
the
claim
petition,
with
proportionate
costs,
by
awarding
Rs.19,59,000/- as compensation together with interest at 7.5% per annum
from the date of petition, till the date of realization, directing Respondents
No.1 and 2 to deposit the compensation amount within 30 days from the date
of order.
MACMA No. 778 of 2023
VS,J.
10.
Being aggrieved by the said order/award, the APSRTC filed the
present appeal on the ground that the Tribunal erred in granting compensation
of Rs.19,59,000/- to the claimant, and that the Tribunal committed serious
irregularities in holding that the rash and negligent driving on the part of the
bus driver which caused the accident, in fact the accident had occurred due to
negligent driving of car driver, along with other grounds.
11.
Having heard the submissions made by the learned counsel
representing both parties and on perusal of the material available on record,
the point that arises for consideration is as follows:
Whether the order of the Tribunal needs any interference?
12.
On perusal of the award passed by the Tribunal, it can be seen
that the claimant got examined her brother-in-law as P.W.1 and P.W.2
eyewitness to the accident and got marked Exs.A.1 to A.81. P.W.2 deposed
that respondent No.1 driver of the RTC Bus bearing No.AP 05 Z 0031 drove
the same in a rash and negligent manner at high speed and dashed against
the vehicle of the claimant, and as a result of which, the claimant and her son
received grievous injuries and the claimant’s husband died on the spot and
also their daughter received grievous injuries, who was shifted to GGH,
Rajahmundry, where she died while undergoing treatment.
13.
Relying upon the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 2 coupled with Ex.A.2-
F.I.R, and in the absence of any contra evidence adduced by the respondents,
MACMA No. 778 of 2023
VS,J.
the Tribunal answered issue No.1 in favour of the claimant holding that the
accident took place on account of the rash and negligent driving of the RTC
bus by respondent No.1.
14.
In the claim petition, claimant stated that she has received
grievous injuries in the accident. The claimant examined the doctor
R.Bhaskara Rama Choudary, who had treated her as P.W.3 and he deposed
that the claimant underwent trichostomy, fixation of multiple fractures of facial
bones, fixation of mental tibial bone, insertion and minor surgeries. He also
deposed that the claimant underwent bone reduction and plate fixation on
fracture and that Exs.A.45 to 73 were issued by their hospital and that Ex.A.44
was final bill for the first admission during the period 22.03.2014 to 02.04.2014
and Ex.A3 was the final bill for the subsequent admission for the period
12.07.2014 to 14.07.2014 relating to removal of implants. Case Sheet of the
petitioners was also marked as Ex.X1.
15.
The claimant also got examined Dr.Nallu Krishna Mohan Rao as
P.W.4 and he deposed about the paralytic stroke and loss of speech by the
claimant and that he issued the certificate for the same.
16.
The claimant examined Dr.J. Ram Prasad as PW5 who had
deposed about asitabular reconstructive surgery undergone by the claimant in
MIOT hospital for the period 03.04.2013 to 25.04.2014.
MACMA No. 778 of 2023
VS,J.
17.
The claimant also filed Ex.A81 to show that her disability is 67%.
From the above evidence of PW1 to 5 along with Ex.A1 to A81 the claimant
was able to prove that she suffered from permanent disability and underwent
various surgeries for paralysis stroke, loss of speech and multiple fractures,
implantation of plates and rods and subsequently removal of implants. Hence
the evidence of P.Ws. 1 to 5 clearly shows that the petitioner sustained
injuries in the accident and got treatment under Ex.X1 as spoken by P.Ws. 3
to 5 she became disabled as shown in Ex.A81 and incurred expenses as
shows under Exs.A3 to A.80. Thus, she is entitled for 67% disability sustained
by her.
18.
Considering the socio-economic conditions prevailing at the time
of the accident and the age of the claimant, the Tribunal fixed the monthly
income of the claimant as Rs.3,000/-. Accordingly, annual income of the
claimant would come to (Rs.3,000 X 12) Rs.36,000/-.
After applying the
appropriate multiplier i.e. 16 for the age group of 31 to 35 years, as per the
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in “Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport
Corporation 1 ”, the loss of earnings would come to (Rs.36,000 X 16)
Rs.5,76,000/-. Therefore, the claimant is entitled for an amount of
Rs.3,85,920/- (Rs.5,76,000 X 67%) towards loss of future income for the
disability sustained by her.
2009 ACJ 1298
MACMA No. 778 of 2023
VS,J.
19.
In addition to the above, relying on the evidence of P.Ws.3 to 5
Doctors and Exs.A.3 to A.80 medical bills, the Tribunal also awarded a sum of
Rs.13,57,134/- towards medical bills, Rs.25,000/- towards future medical
expenses, Rs.1,00,000/- towards pain and suffering, Rs.30,000/- towards
extra nourishment, Rs.30,000/- towards transportation, Rs.1,000/- towards
damages to clothes, Rs.5,000/- towards attender charges, Rs.25,000/towards loss of amenities. In total, the Tribunal below awarded Rs.19,59,054/to the claimants.
20.
Considering the material available on record, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the amount of Rs.19,59,054/- awarded by the Tribunal
to the claimant for the grievous injuries and permanent disability sustained by
her was on reasonable basis and is sustainable under law, which needs no
interference.
21.
Accordingly, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is
dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
The miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall also stand closed.
_______________________
SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
KS
Dated 16.03.2026.
MACMA No. 778 of 2023
VS,J.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENTS CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 778/2023
DATED 16.03.2026
KS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review