Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on 13th July 2026
Pronounced on: 17th July 2026
Uploaded on: 18th July 2026
+
CRL.M.C. 4493/2014 & CRL.M.A 15409/2014
VENESSA BEUMONT
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. S.D. Singh, Sr. Adv. with Mr.
Siddharth Singh, Mr. Meenu Singh,
Mr. Kamla Prasad, Mr. Manan Saini
and Mr. Navneet Pathania, Advs.
Versus
STATE & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Naresh Kumar Chahar, APP for
State.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
MADHU JAIN, J.
1.
The present petition has been filed under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘CrPC’) seeking
quashing of Complaint Case No. 1/01/2014 pending before the Court of the
learned Metropolitan Magistrate-01, South District, Saket Courts, New Delhi.
The petitioner also seeks setting aside of the summoning order dated
01.08.2014 whereby the learned Metropolitan Magistrate summoned the
petitioner and co-accused for the offences punishable under Sections 419, 420,
468, 471 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘IPC’).
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
FACTUAL MATRIX:
2.
Briefly stated, Respondent No.2 instituted a complaint before the
learned Metropolitan Magistrate alleging that it is a company engaged in the
business of software development and bug fixing. It was alleged that the
petitioner and the co-accused, who had placed orders with the complainantcompany in the year 2011 for software development and bug fixing.
According to the complainant, the work assigned was completed and the
agreed consideration was also paid.
3.
The complaint alleged that the complainant-company had no
association, tie-up, joint venture or any other understanding with the petitioner
and the co-accused. It was averred that on 08.06.2012, the complainant came
to know that the petitioner and the co-accused were allegedly forging and
fabricating the complainant’s letterheads and other documents while falsely
representing themselves to be executives and authorised representatives of the
complainant-company.
4.
It is further alleged that appointment letters were being issued in the
name of the complainant-company, work visas and other statutory
compliances were being facilitated by using the complainant's documents, and
authority letters had been issued by the petitioner in the name of the
complainant-company. The complainant also alleged that premises had been
taken on rent at Oberoi Garden, Kandivali, Mumbai in the name of the
complainant-company, where its signboard had been displayed and persons
had been employed by representing the said premises to be an office of the
complainant-company.
5.
According to the complainant, despite repeatedly calling upon the
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
petitioner through email communications dated 08.06.2012 to cease such
activities and despite lodging a complaint with the Police Station Fatehpur
Beri on 19.01.2013, no action was taken by the police authorities.
6.
Consequently, Respondent No.2 instituted the complaint before the
learned Metropolitan Magistrate. During the pre-summoning stage the
authorised representative of the complainant-company-CW1 gave statement
and reiterated the allegations contained in the complaint. In support of the
complaint, reliance was placed on various documents, including the Board
Resolution authorising the institution of the complaint, email correspondence,
the alleged authority letter, appointment letters, work visa documents and the
complaint submitted to the police authorities.
7.
Upon consideration of the complaint, the learned Metropolitan
Magistrate by the Impugned Order dated 01.08.2014, observed that a prima
facie case was made out and summoned the petitioner and the co-accused to
face trial for offences punishable under Sections 419, 420, 468 and 471 read
with Section 34 Indian Penal Code, 1862 (hereinafter referred to as ‘IPC’).
The learned Metropolitan Magistrate held as under:
“At the stage of per summoning evidence, the
Complainant examined A.R. of the company who
reiterated the facts of the Complainant. After going
through the record contents of the Complainant and as
per deposition of the Complainant and the documents
placed on record, it is but evident that the accused
person have caused unlawful loss to the Complainant
while causing unlawful gain to themselves.
They have also misrepresented themselves to be on
part of the Complainant company which they infact are
not. They have forged the letter heads of the
Complainant and signed several letters on behalf of the
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
Complainant to various people. Hence, I summoning
the accused, Venessa Beumont and Kathrina Rulka. for
cheating and in personating U/s. 419/420/ 468/ 471/
34 IPC.
Summons to be issued to the accused persons for filling
the P.F., speed post for 23.9.2014.”
8.
Aggrieved by the issuance of the summoning order and the continuation
of the complaint proceedings, the present petition has been filed.
SUBMISSION ON BEHLAF OF THE PETITIONER:
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the complaint proceeds
on the premise that there was no association or business relationship between
the complainant-company and the entities with which the petitioner was
associated. Learned counsel submits that the material placed on record by the
petitioner shows that there existed a commercial relationship and an
understanding between the entities concerned.
10.
Learned counsel further submits that none of the documents relied upon
by the complainant establish that the petitioner forged any document,
impersonated any representative of the complainant-company or used its
letterheads without authority. It is contended that the documents relied upon
during the pre-summoning stage do not support the allegations made in the
complaint and, therefore, no prima facie case was made out for issuance of
summons.
11.
It is further submitted that the complaint does not disclose any material
to show that the petitioner derived any wrongful gain or caused any wrongful
loss to the complainant. It is contended that the observations to this effect in
the impugned order are not supported by the allegations contained in the
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
complaint or the material placed before the learned Metropolitan Magistrate .
12.
Learned counsel submits that the allegations regarding issuance of
appointment letters, misuse of letterheads and unauthorised recruitment of
employees are not supported by any contemporaneous document. It is
contended that the correspondence exchanged between the parties, including
the email communications relied upon by the petitioner, does not support the
complainant’s allegations and on the contrary reflects the commercial
relationship between the entities concerned.
13.
It is further submitted that the complaint is a consequence of disputes
which had arisen between the petitioner and Sh. Mahesh Chand Nagar.
Learned counsel submits that the petitioner had earlier initiated criminal
proceedings before the Economic Offences Wing alleging commission of
offences by the said Sh. Mahesh Chand Nagar and that the present complaint
has been instituted thereafter as a retaliatory measure. It is submitted that the
criminal proceedings have been initiated with the object of exerting pressure
upon the petitioner.
14.
The learned counsel further place reliance on the judgement of Supreme
Court in Pepsi Foods Ltd. Anr. Vs. Special Judicial Magistrate and Ors.,
(1998) 5 SCC 749, and Suresh Kumar Goyal and Ors. Vs. State of U.P. and
Anr, (2019) 14 SCC 318.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS:
15.
Per contra, learned APP on behalf of the state, supports the impugned
summoning order and submits that the present petition is devoid of merit and
is liable to be dismissed. It is submitted that the complaint and the documents
placed before the learned Metropolitan Magistrate disclose a prima facie case
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
for the offences alleged and therefore, no interference is called for in exercise
of the inherent jurisdiction of this Court.
16.
The reply filed on behalf of respondent no. 2 has been perused, in the
said reply, Respondent No. 2 has stated that the petitioner has sought to divert
the controversy by placing reliance upon disputes involving Sh. Mahesh
Chand Nagar and the proceedings initiated against him. According to
respondent No.2, those disputes are independent of the present complaint and
have no bearing on the allegations which form the subject matter of the present
case. It is submitted that the issue before this Court is confined to the alleged
unauthorised use of the complainant-company’s name by the petitioner and
the co-accused.
17.
Respondent No. 2 has further stated in its reply that the allegations in
the complaint are supported by the documents produced during the presummoning stage, which on face value demonstrate the unauthorised use of
respondent No.2’s name and credentials. Learned counsel submits that the
petitioner and the co-accused represented themselves as being associated with
respondent No.2, issued documents in its name and undertook activities on its
behalf without any authority. It is contended that these allegations disclose the
ingredients of the offences for which cognizance has been taken by the learned
Metropolitan Magistrate .
18.
It is also stated in the reply that the petitioner's reliance upon disputes
involving Mr. Mahesh Chand Nagar cannot constitute a defence to the
allegations in the present complaint. According to respondent No.2, even
assuming that disputes existed between the petitioner and the said individual,
the same would not justify the alleged acts attributed to the petitioner nor
affect the maintainability of the complaint.
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
19.
Respondent No. 2 has further stated that the learned Metropolitan
Magistrate has passed the impugned order after considering the complaint, the
statement of the authorised representative of respondent No.2 and the
documents placed on record. Learned counsel submits that, at the stage of
issuance of process, the Court is only required to examine whether the material
before it discloses a prima facie case and not whether the prosecution is likely
to ultimately succeed. According to respondent No.2, the learned
Metropolitan Magistrate has correctly applied the settled principles governing
the exercise of jurisdiction at the stage of summoning.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
20.
This Court has heard learned counsel for the petitioner and has perused
the material on record.
21.
The principal challenge in the present petition is to the summoning
order dated 01.08.2014 whereby the learned Metropolitan Magistrate has
summoned the petitioner for offences punishable under Sections 419, 420, 468
and 471 read with Section 34 IPC. According to the petitioner, the complaint
does not disclose the ingredients of the offences alleged. On the other hand,
respondent No.2 submits that the complaint and the pre-summoning evidence
disclose a prima facie case and that the defence sought to be raised by the
petitioner cannot be examined in proceedings under Section 482 CrPC.
22.
The scope of interference under Section 482 CrPC in relation to an
order issuing summons is well settled. The inherent jurisdiction of the High
Court is required to be exercised only in exceptional cases where continuation
of the proceedings would amount to an abuse of the process of law or where
the complaint fails to disclose the commission of any offence. This principle
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
was reiterated by the Supreme Court in the judgement of Pepsi Foods Ltd
(supra). The relevant paragraph is reproduced as under:
“28. Summoning of an accused in a criminal case is
a serious matter. Criminal law cannot be set into
motion as a matter of course. It is not that the
complainant has to bring only two witnesses to
support his allegations in the complaint to have the
criminal law set into motion. The order of the
Magistrate summoning the accused must reflect
that he has applied his mind to the facts of the case
and the law applicable thereto. He has to examine
the nature of allegations made in the complaint
and the evidence both oral and documentary in
support thereof and would that be sufficient for the
complainant to succeed in bringing charge home
to the accused. It is not that the Magistrate is a silent
spectator at the time of recording of preliminary
evidence before summoning of the accused. The
Magistrate has to carefully scrutinise the evidence
brought on record and may even himself put
questions to the complainant and his witnesses to
elicit answers to find out the truthfulness of the
allegations or otherwise and then examine if any
offence is prima facie committed by all or any of the
accused.
(Emphasis Supplied)”
23.
In Suresh Kumar Goyal (supra), the Supreme Court held that while
exercising jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC, the High Court may consider
defence material only if it is of sterling and unimpeachable quality and is
sufficient to completely displace the allegations contained in the complaint.
Where adjudication of the defence requires appreciation of disputed facts and
evidence, the same must necessarily be left for trial. The relevant paragraphs
are reproduced as under:
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
“12. While dealing with the jurisdiction under Section
482 CrPC to quash the proceedings at the stage of
issuance of process, or at the stage of committal, or at
the stage of framing of charges, that is to say before
the commencement of actual trial, in the light of
material placed on record by the accused, this Court
in Rajiv Thapar v. Madan Lal Kapoor³ laid down as
under : (SCC pp. 347-48, paras 28-30)
"28. The High Court, in exercise of its jurisdiction
under Section 482 CrPC, must make a just and
rightful choice. This is not a stage of evaluating the
truthfulness or otherwise of the allegations levelled
by the prosecution/complainant against the accused.
Likewise, it is not a stage for determining how
weighty the defences raised on behalf of the accused
are. Even if the accused is successful in showing some
suspicion or doubt, in the allegations levelled by the
prosecution/complainant, it would be impermissible to
discharge the accused before trial. This is so because
it would result in giving finality to the accusations
levelled by the prosecution/complainant, without
allowing the prosecution or the complainant to adduce
evidence to substantiate the same. The converse is,
however, not true, because even if trial is proceeded
with, the accused is not subjected to any irreparable
consequences. The accused would still be in a position
to succeed by establishing his defences by producing
evidence in accordance with law. There is an endless
list of judgments rendered by this Court declaring the
legal position that in a case where the
prosecution/complainant has levelled allegations
bringing out all ingredients of the charge(s) levelled,
and have placed material before the Court, prima facie
evidencing the truthfulness of the allegations levelled,
trial must be held
XXX
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
30. Based on the factors canvassed in the foregoing
paragraphs, we would delineate the following steps to
determine the veracity of a prayer for quashment
raised by an accused by invoking the power vested in
the High Court under Section 482 CrPC:
30.1. Step one : whether the material relied upon by
the accused is sound, reasonable and indubitable i.e.
the material is of sterling and impeccable quality?
30.2. Step two : whether the material relied upon by
the accused would rule out the assertions contained in
the charges levelled against the accused i.e. the
material is sufficient to reject and overrule the factual
assertions contained in the complaint i.e. the material
is such as would persuade a reasonable person to
dismiss and condemn the factual basis of the
accusations as false?
30.3. Step three : whether the material relied upon by
the accused has not been refuted by the
prosecution/complainant; and/or the material is such
that it cannot be justifiably refuted by the
prosecution/complainant?
30.4. Step four : whether proceeding with the trial
would result in an abuse of process of the court, and
would not serve the ends of justice?
30.5. If the answer to all the steps is in the affirmative,
the judicial conscience of the High Court should
persuade it to quash such criminal proceedings in
exercise of power vested in it under Section 482 CrPC.
Such exercise of power, besides doing justice to the
accused, would save precious court time, which would
otherwise be wasted in holding such a trial (as well as
proceedings arising therefrom) specially when it is
clear that the same would not conclude in the
conviction of the accused.”
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
24.
A perusal of the complaint shows that respondent No.2 has made
specific allegations that the petitioner and the co-accused had no authority to
represent themselves as officers or representatives of the complainantcompany. It is alleged that despite there being no association or understanding
between the parties, the petitioner used the complainant’s letterheads and
documents, issued appointment letters in the complainant’s name, facilitated
recruitment and visa formalities by using the complainant’s credentials and
established an office in Mumbai in the complainant’s name. The relevant
portion of the complaint made by the respondents is reproduced herein below:
“5. It is pertinent to mention that the applicant has no
association, tie-up, joint venture or any kind of
understanding with M/S Supply Chain Solutions or its
executives such as accused no.1 & 2.
6. In most shocking manner the applicant came to know
on 08.06.2012 that the accused no.1 & 2 are forging
and fabricating the letterheads and other documents of
the applicant company to falsely represent themselves
to be the executives of the applicant company despite
there being no such association.
7. It has also come to the knowledge of the applicant
that the accused no.1 & 2 are issuing appointment
letters to new recruits in the name of applicant
company and sending them to various countries. For
arranging the work visas and other mandatory
compliances also the accused persons are forging,
fabricating and misusing the applicant's documents to
impersonate themselves to be representing ,managing
or controlling the applicant company; which is not the
case.
8. The accused no. 1 & 2 has in fact issued authority
letters engaging Rajesh N. Devadiga and have further
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
taken a premises at 4021,4022, 4039(part),Oberoi
Garden, Kandevali, Mumbai on rent in the name of
applicant company and have also employed many
people fraudulently on behalf of the applicant
company. The accused persons have infact also put a
sign board of the applicant company in their fake office
at Mumbai.
9. It is pertinent to mention that the accused no,1 & 2
are forging, fabricating and impersonation the
documents purported to have been issued by or
belonging to the applicant company for employing
them and sending them abroad and arranging their
visa formalities.”
25.
The complaint further alleges that the aforesaid acts exposed the
complainant-company to financial, legal and reputational consequences,
including possible tax liabilities and claims by persons allegedly recruited in
its name. Whether these allegations are ultimately established is a matter of
evidence. However, at the stage of issuance of process, the Court is only
required to examine whether the allegations, if taken at their face value
discloses the commission of the offences alleged.
26.
During the pre-summoning stage, the authorised representative of the
complainant in her statement reiterated the allegations contained in the
complaint. the Board Resolution, email correspondence dated 08/06/2012,
authority letters, appointment letters, visa-related documents and the
complaint lodged with the police authorities.
27.
During the pre-summoning stage, CW1 the authorised representative of
the complainant-company in her statement reiterated the allegations contained
in the complaint. CW-1 deposed that the complainant had no association, tie-
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
up or authority in favour of the petitioner or the co-accused to act on its behalf.
It was further alleged that the petitioner and the co-accused had forged the
complainant’s letterheads and documents and issued appointment letters in the
complainant’s name. CW1 also relied upon various documents including the
Board Resolution (Ex. CW1/1), work visa documents (Ex. CW1/2), email
correspondence dated 08/06/2012 (Ex. CW1/3), the alleged authority letter
(Ex. CW1/4), the corresponding email (Ex. CW1/5) and the appointment letter
(Ex. CW1/6). The learned Metropolitan Magistrate, therefore, had before her
not only the allegations contained in the complaint but also the oral testimony
of CW-1 supported by documentary material while considering the question
of issuance of process. The relevant portion of the statement made by CW1 is
reproduced hereinbelow:
COMPLAINT STATEMENT
CW1- ANJU …The applicant has no association, tie-up, joint venture
TANWAR
or any kind of understanding with M/S. Supply Chain
Solutions or its executives such as accused No.1 & 2.
XXX
…The applicant/complainant came to know on
08.06.2012 that the accused No.1 & 2 are forging and
fabricating the letterheads and other documents of the
applicant company to falsely represent themselves to be
the executive of the applicant company despite their being
no such association.
28.
The learned Metropolitan Magistrate after considering the complaint,
the pre-summoning evidence and the documents placed on record, proceeded
to issue summons. The learned Metropolitan Magistrate in order dated
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
01.08.2014 held as under:
“In this respect the Complainant had filed the
complaint before the P.S. but no action was taken by
the police.
At the stage of per summoning evidence, the
Complainant examined A.R. of the company who
reiterated the facts of the Complainant. After going
through the record contents of the Complainant and as
per deposition of the Complainant and the documents
placed on record, it is but evident that the accused
person have caused unlawful loss to the Complainant
while causing unlawful gain to themselves.
They have also misrepresented themselves to be on
part of the Complainant company which they infact are
not. They have forged the letter heads of the
Complainant and signed several letters on behalf of the
Complainant to various people. Hence, I summoning
the accused, Venessa Beumont and Kathrina Rulka for
cheating and in personating U/s. 419/420/ 468/ 471/
34 IPC.
Summons to be issued to the accused persons for filling
the P.F., speed post for 23.9.2014.”
29.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed considerable reliance
upon various documents to contend that there existed a commercial
relationship between the parties and that the petitioner was duly authorised to
undertake the acts alleged in the complaint. However, whether such
relationship existed or whether it conferred any authority upon the petitioner
to use the complainant’s name or documents, and whether the documents
relied upon by the petitioner establish such authority are all disputed questions
of fact. Determination of these issues would necessarily require appreciation
of oral and documentary evidence, which cannot appropriately be undertaken
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
while exercising jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC.
30.
The contention that the complaint is a counterblast to disputes involving
Sh. Mahesh Chand Nagar also cannot be accepted at this stage. Even assuming
that disputes existed between the parties, the same would not by itself justify
quashing the complaint where the allegations taken at their face value disclose
the commission of cognizable offences.
31.
This Court is also unable to accept the submission that the learned
Metropolitan Magistrate issued summons mechanically or without application
of mind. The impugned order specifically records that the learned
Metropolitan Magistrate considered the complaint, the deposition of the
authorised representative and the documents placed on record before arriving
at a prima facie satisfaction.
32.
At the stage of issuance of process, the Court is not required to record
elaborate findings on each ingredient of the offences alleged. What is required
is the formation of a prima facie opinion on the basis of the material placed
before it. The impugned order cannot be said to suffer from any such infirmity
as would warrant interference in exercise of inherent jurisdiction.
33.
The present case also does not satisfy the test laid down in Suresh
Kumar Goyal (supra). The defence material relied upon by the petitioner
neither conclusively rules out the allegations made in the complaint nor is it
of such unimpeachable nature that continuation of the proceedings would
amount to an abuse of the process of the Court. The issues sought to be raised
by the petitioner are matters of evidence and are required to be adjudicated by
the learned Trial Court.
34.
The submissions made by the petitioner rests upon the defence sought
to be taken on the basis of the documents relied upon by the petitioner.
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
Acceptance of these submissions would require this Court to adjudicate upon
disputed questions of fact and assess the evidentiary value of the documents
produced by the parties. Such an exercise falls within the domain of the
learned Trial Court and cannot be undertaken by this court while exercising
jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC. At this stage, the Court is only concerned
with examining whether the complaint and the material placed before the
learned Metropolitan Magistrate discloses a prima facie case. The defence
available to the petitioner is a matter to be considered during the course of
trial.
CONCLUSION:
35.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is satisfied that the
complaint, the pre-summoning evidence and the documents placed before the
learned Metropolitan Magistrate disclosed sufficient material to form a prima
facie opinion for issuance of process. The contentions urged by the petitioner
raise disputed questions of fact which cannot be adjudicated in proceedings
under Section 482 CrPC. No perversity is made out in the impugned
summoning order dated 01.08.2014.
36.
Accordingly,
the
present
petition,
along
with
the
pending
application(s), if any, is dismissed. The interim order(s), if any, stand vacated.
MADHU JAIN
(JUDGE)
JULY 17, 2026/b/P
Signed By:RENUKA CRL.M.C. 4493/2014
NEGI
18:46:16
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review