The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
8. As seen from the judgment passed by the first appellate Court in Appeal Suit No. 54 of 2012, the learned judge has assigned the only reason that the trail Court had not given proper findings on the issues. Except the said observation, the first appellate Court, itself can re-appreciate the evidence, and come to a conclusion on the evidence available on record instead of remanding the matter. There are no reasons except the observation made by the first appellate Court. Therefore, the learned first appellate Court ought to have considered the matter and recorded its own findings. Only if the first appellate Court comes to an opinion that the matter needs to be remanded, it shall record reasons for such remand without expressing any opinion on the merits.
9. Considering the above, the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed. The judgment and decree passed in Appeal Suit No. 54 of 2012 is set aside, and the matter is remanded to the first appellate Court to re-consider and reappreciate the entire evidence on record and dispose of the appeal in accordance with law. If the first appellate Court is of the opinion that the matter requires remand to the trial Court, it shall record reasons for such remand; without expressing any opinion on merits of the matter, otherwise, it shall proceed to dispose of the appeal itself in accordance with law. There shall be no order as to costs. As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010565852025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3573]
FRIDAY, THE 17th DAY OF JULY 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 743/2025
Between:
1. VELPULA RAJA NARASIMHA NARENDRA, S/O. OBAIAH, AGED
ABOUT 36 YEARS, HINDU, REVENUE INSPECTOR OF MANDAL
REVENUE OFFICE, PRODDATUR, KADAPA DISTRICT
...APPELLANT
AND
1. VELPULA HARI BABU, S/O. LATE CHINNA AGED ABOUT 33
YEARS,LAKSHUMANNA, HINDU, CULTIVATION, R/O. POTTIPADU
VILLAGE, RAJUPALEM MANDAL, KADAPA DISTRICT
2. VELPULA OBAIAH OBULESUDIED, HIS LEGAL HEIRS ARE ADDED
AS RESPONDENTS NO.3 TO 7
3. VELPULA BHAGYA LAKSHMI, , W/O. LATE OBAIAH @ OBULESU
AGED ABOUT 72 YEARSHINDU, HOUSE WIFE, R/O. NEAR
ARAVINDAASHRAMAM, PRODDATUR, YSR KADAPA DISTRICT.
4. VELPULA SRILATHA, , D/O. LATE OBAIAH @ OBULESU, AGED
ABOUT 50 YEARS,HINDU, TEACHER, R/O. D.NO.7/755, NEAR
SAIBABA TEMPLE, BHASKAR NIVAS APARTMENTS, YMR
COLONY, PRODDATUR, KADAPA DISTRICT.
5. VELPULA SAMPATH KUMAR, S/O. LATE OBAIAH @ OBULESU,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,HINDU, WORKING AS PROFESSOR CUMHOD, DEPARTMENT OF BIOCHEMISTRY, ESIC MEDICAL
COLLEGE, SR NAGAR, HYDERABAD, TELANGANA STATE.
6. VELPULA VIJAYALAKSHMI, D/O. LATE OBAIAH @ OBULESU,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,HINDU, SECRETARY IN SACHIVALAYAM,
R/O. D.NO.329, HANUMAN NAGAR, KOTHI SAMADHI STREET,
THIMMAIAH COLONY, PRODDATUR.
7. VELPULA VASAVI, D/O. LATE OBAIAH @ OBULESU, AGED ABOUT
39 YEARS, HINDU,SECRETARY IN SACHIVALAYAM, R/O.
D.NO.7/755, NEAR SAIBABA TEMPLE, BHASKAR NIVAS
APARTMENTS, YMR COLONY, PRODDATUR, KADAPA DISTRICT.
(RESPONDENT NOS. 3 TO 7 ARE NOT NECESSARY PARTIES)
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal Under Section_____against ordersbegs to present this
Memorandum of Civil Miscellaneous Appeal aggrieved by the Decree and
Judgement, dt.08.05.2025 in A.S.No.54/2012 on the file of the Court of the II
Additional District Judge, Kadapa at Proddutur reversing the Decree and
Judgement, dt.21.09.2012 in O.S.No.400/2011 on the file of the Court of the
Senior Civil Judge, Proddutur
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to suspend the operation of Decree and Judgement, dt.08.05.2025 in
A.S.No.54/2012 on the file of the Court of the II Additional District Judge,
Kadapa at Proddutur and pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. SODUM ANVESHA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. V NITESH
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 743/2025
ORDER
1.
The appeal is filed against the judgment and decree dated
08.05.2025 passed in Appeal Suit No. 54 of 2012 on the file of II Additional
District Judge, Proddatur, Kadapa District, which was filed against the
judgment dated 21.09.2012 in O.S.No.400 of 2011 on the file Senior Civil
Judge’s Court, Proddatur, Kadapa District.
2.
The first appellate Court, II Additional District Judge, Proddatur, Kadapa
District, remanded the matter by setting aside the judgment and decree
passed by the trial Court, Senior Civil Judge's Court, Proddatur, Kadapa
District, and directed it to re-admit the suit in its original number in the register
of civil suits and proceed to determine the suit by giving an opportunity to both
parties to advance their arguments with respect to the issues framed by the
trial Court.
3.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the learned Judge of the
first appellate Court, without recording any reasons, simply passed an order
herein is as follows:“11. After going through the entire record, it is found that
the trial Court has not given a proper finding for the reliefs
claimed by the plaintiff/appellant on the issues framed by the trial
court.
Hence, it is fit case to remand the matter for proper
appreciation of evidence to arrive to a right conclusion whether
the plaintiff is entitled for the reliefs prayed by him.”
4.
He further submitted that the first appellate Court itself can go into the
facts, appreciate the evidence on record and come to a conclusion, instead of
remanding the matter. If at all any remand is warranted reasons for such
remand of the matter has to be recorded without recording any finding on the
merits of the case.
5.
However, the learned counsel for the appellant placed reliance on the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Shivakumar and others Vs.
Sharanabasappa and others1 wherein it was held as under:
“A conjoint reading of Rules23, 23-A and 24 of Order 41 brings forth
the scope as also contours of the powers of remand that when the available
evidence is sufficient to dispose of the matter, the proper course for an
appellate court is to follow the mandate of Rule 24 of Order 41 CPC and to
determine the suit finally. It is only in such cases where the decree in
challenge is reversed in appeal and a retrial is considered necessary that
the appellate court shall adopt the course of remanding the case.
It
remains trite that order of remand merely elongates the life of the litigation
without serving the cause of justice.
An order of remand only on the
ground that the points touching the appreciation of evidence were not dealt
with by the trial court may not be considered proper in a given case
because the first appellate court itself is possessed of jurisdiction to enter
into facts and appreciate the evidence. There could, of course, be several
eventualities which may justify an order of remand or where remand would
be rather necessary depending on the facts and the given set of
circumstances of a case.”
(2021) SCC 277 in Civil Appeal No. 6076 of 2009
6.
Placing reliance on the above judgment, the learned counsel submitted
that the first appellate Court, without assigning any reasons for such remand,
simply recorded that after going through the entire record, the trial court had
not given proper findings, therefore, remanded the matter for proper
appreciation of evidence. He submitted that, being the first appellate Court, it
has jurisdiction to appreciate the entire evidence on record and come to a
conclusion. Therefore, remanding the matter without recording any reason for
remand unsustainable.
7.
The learned counsel for the respondents submitted that, as the matter
was remanded, the first appellate Court had not gone into the merits of the
case. He placed reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
J. Balaji Singh Vs. Diwakar Cole and others 2, wherein it was held as
under
“ So far as Order 41 Rule 23 is concerned, it enables the
appellate court to remand the case to the trial court when it finds that
the trial court has disposed of the suit upon a preliminary point. The
appellate court in such cases is empowered to direct the trial court to
decide all the issues on evidence on record.”
17.
So far as the impugned order is concerned, the High Court, in
our view, committed jurisdictional error when it also again examined
the case on merits and set aside the judgment of the first appellate
court and restored the judgment of the trial Court. The High Court, in
our opinion, should not have done this for the simple reason that it
was only examining the legality of the remand order in an appeal filed
under Order 43 Rule 1 (u) of the code. Indeed, once the High Court
(2017) 14 SCC 207 in Civil Appeal No.5540 of 2017
came to a conclusion that the remand order was bad in law, then it
could only remand the case to the first appellate court with a direction
to decide the first appeal on merits.
18. The High Court failed to see that when the first appellate court
itself did not decide the appeal on merits and considered it proper to
remand the case to the trial court, a fortiori, the High Court had no
jurisdiction to decide the appeal on merits, Moreover, Order 43 Rule
1(u) confers limited power on the High Court to examine only the
legality and correctness of the remand order of the first appellate
court but not beyond that. In other words, the High Court should
have seen that Order 43 Rule 1(u) gives a limited power to examine
the issue relating to legality of remand order, as is clear from Order
43 Rule 1(u) which reads thus:
1.
(u) an order under Rule 23 or Rule 23-A of Order XLI
remanding a case, where an appeal would lie from the decree of the
appellate court;”
8.
As seen from the judgment passed by the first appellate Court in
Appeal Suit No. 54 of 2012, the learned judge has assigned the only reason
that the trail Court had not given proper findings on the issues. Except the
said observation, the first appellate Court, itself can re-appreciate the
evidence, and come to a conclusion on the evidence available on record
instead of remanding the matter.
There are no reasons except the
observation made by the first appellate Court. Therefore, the learned first
appellate Court ought to have considered the matter and recorded its own
findings. Only if the first appellate Court comes to an opinion that the matter
needs to be remanded, it shall record reasons for such remand without
expressing any opinion on the merits.
9. Considering the above, the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed. The
judgment and decree passed in Appeal Suit No. 54 of 2012 is set aside, and
the matter is remanded to the first appellate Court to re-consider and reappreciate the entire evidence on record and dispose of the appeal in
accordance with law. If the first appellate Court is of the opinion that the
matter requires remand to the trial Court, it shall record reasons for such
remand; without expressing any opinion on merits of the matter, otherwise, it
shall proceed to dispose of the appeal itself in accordance with law. There
shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed.
____________________
BALAJI MEDAMALLI, J
Date: 17.07.2026
RMD
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BALAJI MEDAMALLI
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 743/2025
Date: 17.07.2026
RMD
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review