Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH: AMARAVATI
MACMA No.262 OF 2023
% Dated 07.05.2026
# 1. Veerapaneni Venkata Subhashini
2. Veerapaneni Venkata Harshith
Naties of Chvuru Village,
Gudluru Mandal, Prakasam District
….. Petitioners
Versus
1. Arikatla venkata Rathnam
s/o Chinna Penchalaiah, Hindu
owner of Tractor bearing No.
AP 26 TX 4087
Residing at JR Peta Village,
Atmakur Mandal
2. National Insurance Company Limited
Gandhinagar, Nellore
…. Respondents
JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED ON: 07.05.2026
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
Whether Reporters of Local newspapers
may be allowed to see the Judgments?
Whether the copies of judgment may be marked
to Law Reporters/Journals
Whether Their Ladyship/Lordship wish to see the
fair copy of the Judgment?
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
+ HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
MACMA No.262 OF 2023
% Dated 07.05.2026
# 1. Veerapaneni Venkata Subhashini
2. Veerapaneni Venkata Harshith
Naties of Chvuru Village,
Gudluru Mandal, Prakasam District
….. Petitioners
Versus
1. Arikatla venkata Rathnam
s/o Chinna Penchalaiah, Hindu
owner of Tractor bearing No.
AP 26 TX 4087
Residing at JR Peta Village,
Atmakur Mandal
2. National Insurance Company Limited
Gandhinagar, Nellore
…. Respondents
Counsel for the petitioner
: Nuthalapati Krishna Murthy
Counsel for Respondent No.2: Mrs. S. Pranathi
<GIST:
> HEAD NOTE:
? Cases referred
1. (2009) 6 SCC 121
2. (2004) 5 SCC 385
3. 2022 Law Suit (SC) 1576
4. 2008 ACJ 1197
5. 2006 ACJ 923
6. (2020) 2 SCC 550
7. 2009 ACJ 1197
-
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
HON’ BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
MACMA No.262 of 2023
JUDGMENT:
1.
The appellants/claimants preferred this appeal under
Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 against the award,
dated 11.08.2015 passed in M.V.O.P.No.750 of 2012 on the file
of the Court of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cumI Additional District Judge, Nellore (for short ‘the Tribunal’).
2.
The appellants/claimants filed the said O.P seeking
compensation
of
Rs.5,00,000/-
for
the
death
of
one
Veerapaneni Venkata Ravindra in a motor accident that occurred
on 02.08.2012 involving a Tractor bearing registration No.
AP 26 TX 4087. As against the claim of Rs.5,00,000/- the
Tribunal granted a compensation of Rs.50,000/-. Assailing the
same the appellants/claimants filed the present appeal.
3.
The brief facts that lead to the filing of the case are that, on
the night of 01.08.2012, as per the instructions of the 1st
respondent during the course of employment, as driver of the
tractor, one Veerapaneni Venkata Ravindra was driving the
tractor bearing No.AP 26 TX TR 4087 from Siripuram Village to
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
Kalavalla village of V.V. Palem Mandal, Prasam District.
One
Chirumamilla Ramesh was following ahead of the deceased on
motor cycle. When the deceased reached near Peddacheruvu
Chapta at Mogalluru Village, Gudluru Mandal, at about 1:00 A.M
on 02.08.2012, the deceased drove the Tractor in a rash and
negligent manner at high speed, due to which he had lost control
over the steering, as a result of which, the tractor turned turtle,
due to which the Ravindra fell down on the road and sustained
severe bleeding injuries and died on the spot. Immediately, on
hearing big noise, Chirumammilla Ramesh, who was proceeding
ahead of the tractor, stopped his motorcycle and returned to the
scene of offence and found Ravindra dead. Based on the
complaint given by Chirumamilla Ramesh, a case in Crime
No.114 of 2012 was registered on the file of Gudlur Police
Station. The police came to the scene of accident and after
inquest, the dead body of the deceased was sent to the
Government Hospital for Post Mortem Examination. By the
impugned order, the Tribunal allowed the said M.V.O.P awarding
compensation of Rs.50,000/- against a claim of Rs.5,00,000/-.
Aggrieved by the same, the appellants/claimants preferred this
appeal.
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
4.
Before the Tribunal, P.W.1 and P.W.2 were examined and
got marked Exs.A-1 to A-5 which happened to be the copy of
First Information Report, Inquest Report, Post Mortem Certificate,
Final Report, Family Member Certificate. On behalf of the
respondents, R.W.1 was examined and got marked Ex.B-1 viz,
copy of the insurance policy.
5.
While the 1st respondent - owner of the tractor remained ex
parte, the 2nd respondent – Insurance Company contested the
matter denying all the averments made in the claim petition.
Before the Tribunal, it is contended that the tractor bearing No.AP
26 TX TR 4087 owned by the 1st respondent was not validly
insured with the 2nd respondent insurance company. It is also
contended that the deceased was not possessing valid and
effective driving license to drive the crime/accident vehicle. There
was no employee – employer relationship between the deceased
and the 1st respondent. The accident occurred due to rash and
negligent act of the deceased himself while driving the tractor on
the date of incident, therefore,
the insurance company is not
liable to pay any compensation to the claimants.
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
6.
Based on the pleadings, the Tribunal framed necessary
issues as to the culpability in causing the accident and the
entitlement of the just compensation by the claimants. The
Tribunal considering the evidence of PW-1 who is none other
than the wife of the deceased and also the evidence of
PW.2 - eye witness to the accident and who was with the
deceased on the fateful day and also the Ex.A-1 copy of the
F.I.R, Ex.A-2 Copy of the Inquest Report, Ex.A-3 copy of Post
Mortem Certificate, Ex.A-4 Final Report, Ex.A-5 Copy of the
Family Member Certificate, observed that the accident occurred
due to own negligence of the deceased driver of the tractor. The
Tribunal also did not find any evidence that the deceased was
employed
under
the
1st
respondent
and
held
that
the
appellants/claimants are entitled to compensation of Rs.50,000/under the head of loss of dependency and directed the 2nd
respondent Insurance Company to satisfy the award to the
claimants and then recover it from the 1st respondent owner of the
tractor and accordingly granted compensation of Rs.50,000/-.
7.
During hearing, Sri Nuthalapati Krishna Murthy, learned
counsel for the appellants, argued that since the appellants lost
their head/breadwinner of the family and their future dependency
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
has been affected, Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
should be applied. He submitted that this provision, which deals
with compensation in hit-and-run motor accident cases, along
with the Second Schedule of the Act, ought to have been used to
determine compensation payable to the legal heirs of the
deceased. He further contended that Section 163-A does not
restrict entitlement
only to third parties, and that legal
representatives or dependants of the deceased are also eligible
to claim compensation. Therefore, the Tribunal erred in not
assessing compensation in accordance with the statutory
provisions. In support of his contentions, learned counsel for the
appellants placed reliance on the judgments of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in Sarla Verma vs. Delhi Transport Corporation1; Deepal
Girishbhai Soni vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd2; Ram
Murti vs. Punjab State Electricity Board3 and judgment of
Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd
vs. Salma4; judgment of High Court of Punjab and Haryana in
New India Assurance Co. Ltd vs. Shyamo Chauhan5. On the
(2009) 6 SCC 121
(2004) 5 SCC 385
2022 Law Suit (SC) 1576
2008 ACJ 1197
2006 ACJ 923
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
strength of the principles laid down in the above judgments,
learned counsel sought to award just compensation to the
appellants in the circumstances of the case.
8.
On the other hand, Smt. S. Pranathi, appearing for the
2nd respondent – Insurance Company contends that, argued that
the Tribunal correctly awarded compensation of Rs.50,000 under
Section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 on the principle of
no-fault liability. She submitted that the deceased himself was
driving the vehicle, lost control due to his own negligence, fell into
a ditch, and died in the accident. She further contended that the
deceased was not an employee of the first respondent and there
was
no
employer–employee
relationship
between
them.
Therefore, it should be treated as a case where the deceased
was driving his own vehicle and caused the accident himself, and
hence a claim under Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 is not maintainable. The learned counsel also argued that
the deceased was negligent while driving the vehicle and did not
possess a valid driving licence to drive the tractor involved and
which was in the accident. She stated that the Tribunal rightly
observed that no documentary evidence was produced to prove
that the first respondent had paid salary to the deceased. In view
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
of these facts, the appellant is not entitled to claim compensation
of Rs.5,00,000 under Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act. In
support of her contentions, learned counsel placed reliance on
the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Ramkhiladi vs.
United India Insurance Company6.
9.
It is observed that, as per the evidence of P.W.1, the wife of
the deceased, she has categorically deposed that the deceased
was employed under the first respondent as a driver and was
earning Rs.10,000/- per month. The finding of the Tribunal that no
documentary evidence was produced to prove the payment of
salary appears to be contrary to the practical realities prevailing in
the agrarian sector and contrary to the oral evidence led in before
the Court. A tractor is primarily used for agricultural operations
and serves as an important mechanized tool in agricultural
activities. In such sectors, payment of wages to a tractor driver is
often made through informal means such as cash, kind, or other
customary arrangements, and therefore documentary proof of
payment of salary may not always be available. It is the duty of
the Tribunal in the absence of any documentary evidence, the
(2020) 2 SCC 550
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
other evidence i.e. oral evidence which was led by the parties
should be looked into and it cannot be brushed aside unless it is
rebutted by proper evidence. In the instant case there was a clear
and categorical evidence of P.W.1 before the Court and the same
was not rebutted by the respondent. Therefore, the Court below
cannot ignore the evidence before the Court only on the ground
that there is no documentary evidence. It is settled law that the
oral evidence is also valuable evidence unless rebutted.
10.
From the evidence on record, it can reasonably be inferred
that the deceased, being an earning member of the family, was
maintaining the livelihood of his family through his earnings as a
tractor driver. It is further observed that, except making a
contention that the deceased did not possess a valid driving
licence, the second respondent has not produced any oral or
documentary evidence before the Tribunal to substantiate the
said claim. In the absence of any such evidence, it is to be
presumed that the deceased possessed a valid driving licence.
The said principle was held by the Hon’ble Apex Court as well as
this Cour.
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
11.
It is contended by the learned counsel for Respondent No.2
that since the accident occurred due to the self-negligence of the
deceased, the claimants are entitled only to the compensation
under the principle of no-fault liability under Section 140 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 lacks merits and contrary to the clear
evidence before the Court and not under Section 163-A of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. However, the said contention is not
valid, acceptable, or sustainable. Section 163-A of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 provides for payment of compensation on a
structured formula basis without the requirement of proving
negligence. The provision is a beneficial legislation intended to
provide speedy relief to the victims of motor accidents or their
dependents. Therefore, the question of negligence of the
deceased is not a relevant factor while considering a claim under
Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. In view of the
above legal position, the contention of Respondent No.2 that the
claim petition under Section 163-A is not maintainable on the
ground of self-negligence of the deceased cannot be accepted.
Accordingly, the claim made by the appellants under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is maintainable.
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
12.
In Deepal Girishbhai Soni vs. United India Insurance
Co. Ltd (referred supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as
follows:
“We may notice that Section 167 of the Act provides
that where death of, or bodily injury to, any person gives
rise to claim of compensation under the Act and also
under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, he
cannot claim compensation under both the Acts. The
Motor Vehicles Act contains different expressions as,
for example,
"under the
provision
of the
Act",
"provisions of this Act", "under any other provisions of
this Act" or "any other law or otherwise". In Section 163A, the expression "notwithstanding anything contained
in this Act or in any other law for the time being in force"
has been used, which goes to show that the Parliament
intended to insert a non- obstante clause of wide nature
which would mean that the provisions of Section 163-A
would apply despite the contrary provisions existing in
the said Act or any other law for the time being in
force. Section 163-A of the Act covers cases where
even negligence is on the part of the victim. It is by way
of an exception to Section 166 and the concept of social
justice has been duly taken care of.”
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
13.
In New India Assurance Co. Ltd vs. Shyamo Chauhan
(referred supra), learned single Judge of High Court of Punjab
and Haryana held as follows:
“3. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant
Insurance Company submitted before us that the provisions
of Section 163-A of the Act would not apply to the present
case since Boby @ Bhartender himself was the driver of
the said vehicle and as such his legal heirs could not claim
compensation amount for the death of the deceased, in the
petition u/s 163-A of the Act. Reliance has been placed on
Appaji and Anr. v. M. Krishna and Anr., 2004 Accident
Claims Tribunal 1289 (Karnataka).
4. However, we find no force in this submission of the
learned counsel for the appellant Insurance Company. A
perusal of Section 163-A of the Act would show that
notwithstanding anything contained in the said Act or any
other law for the time being in force or instrument having
the force in law, the owner of the motor vehicle or the
authorised insurer shall be liable to pay in the case of death
or permanent disability due to accident arising out of the
use of motor vehicle, compensation, as indicated in the
Second Schedule, to the legal heirs or the victim as the
case may be. Thus, from a perusal of the provisions of
Section 163-A of the Act, it would be clear that the owner
and the Insurance Company would be liable to pay the
compensation amount to the legal heirs of the deceased in
the case of death where the accident had taken place
"arising out of the use of motor vehicle". Even if the
deceased was the driver of the motor vehicle in question,
still the owner and the Insurance Company of the said
Motor Vehicle would be liable to pay compensation to the
legal heirs of the deceased under the "no fault liability" u/s
163-A of the Act. In this view of the matter, the learned
Tribunal was perfectly justified in holding the owner and the
Insurance Company liable to pay the compensation amount
to the claimants.”
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
14.
In Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd vs. Salma7, learned single
Judge of High Court Karnataka held as follows:
8. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
relied upon the decision of this Court in the case of Appaji
(Since Deceased) and Another Vs. M. Krishna And
Another
reported
in (2004
ACJ
1289 [LQ/KarHC/2003/1084] ) wherein it is held that
Section 163A provides awarding compensation on
structure formula and if death is cause due to the
negligence of the victim himself, the petition is not
maintainable. In subsequent judgment of Hon‟ble
Supreme Court case in case of Deepal Girishbhai Soni
and Others Vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Reported
in (2004 ACJ 934), the 3 judge bench of the supreme
court has held in para 66 of the Judgment as follows:
“We may notice that Section 167 of the Act provides that
where death of, or bodily injury to, any person gives rise
to claim of compensation under the Act and also under
the Workmen‟s Compensation Act, 1923, he cannot claim
compensation under both the Acts. The Motor Vehicles
Act contains different expressions as, for example, „under
the provision of the Act‟, or „any other law or otherwise‟. In
section 163-A, the expression “notwithstanding anything
contained in this Act or in any other law for the time being
in force” has been used, which goes to show that
Parliament intended to insert a non obstante clause of
wide nature which would mean that the provisions of
section 163-A would apply despite the contrary provisions
existing in the said Act or any other law for the time being
in force. Section 163-A of the Act covers cases where
even negligence is on the part of the victim. It is by way of
an exception to section 166 and the concept of social
justice
has
been
duly
taken
care
of”.
In view of the above said principle laid down by the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court, it is clear that a petition under
2009 ACJ 1197
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act is maintainable
even in case where negligence is on the part of the victim.
9. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant
submitted that the said observation is not ratio descidendi
or the principle laid down by the Supreme Court in the
said case as in the said case, the Supreme Court was
considering the question as to whether ceiling limit of
Rs.40,000/- for the purpose of calculating compensation
to be awarded under structured formula.
15.
It is observed that the learned counsel for the petitioners
has contended that, by virtue of the amendment to Chapter X of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 through Act 32 of 2019, Section 140
of the Act has been omitted. Simultaneously, Chapter XI has
been substituted and Section 164 has been introduced, which
provides for payment of compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- in case of
death and Rs.2,50,000/- in case of grievous hurt arising out of a
motor vehicle accident. In view of the said statutory amendment,
and considering the fact that the deceased died as a result of the
motor
vehicle
accident,
the
claimants
are
entitled
to
compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- as provided under Section 164 of
the Motor Vehicles Act. The said principle was upheld by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ram Murthy & others vs. Punjab
State Electricity Board (referred supra), wherein it is held as
follows:
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
“6. Thee is no cogent basis for this court to entertain the
challenge against the findings of fact which have been
recorded concurrently by the Tribunal and by the High
Court while dismissing the claim under Section 166 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
7. The provisions of Section 140 which formed a part of
Chapter 10 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 were
omitted by
Act 32 of 2019. Simultaneously,
Chapter 11 was substituted of which Section 164
provides for payment of compensation in the case of
death in the amount of Rs.5 lakhs and in the case of
grievous hurt of Rs.2.5 lakhs.
8. We are inclined to give the appellants the benefit of
the beneficial provisions which have been enacted by
Parliament. Hence, in modification of the order of the
High Court, we direct that the appellants shall be
entitled to an amount of Rs.5 lakhs as compensation.
However, if the amount of Rs.50,000/- which has been
awarded by the High Court has already been paid over,
the balance (or the entirety of Rs.5 lakhs if no amount
has been paid) shall be paid over to the appellants......)
16.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in Sarla Verma vs. Delhi
Transport Corporation (referred supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held as follows:
“The Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 was amended by Act
54 of 1994, inter alia inserting Section 163A and the
Second
Schedule
with
effect
from
14.11.1994. Section 163A of the MV Act contains a
special provision as to payment of compensation on
structured formula basis, as indicated in the Second
Schedule to the Act. The Second Schedule contains
a Table prescribing the compensation to be awarded
with reference to the age and income of the
deceased. It specifies the amount of compensation to
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
be awarded with reference to the annual income
range of Rs.3,000/- to Rs.40,000/-. It does not specify
the quantum of compensation in case the annual
income of the deceased is more than Rs.40,000/-.
But it provides the multiplier to be applied with
reference to the age of the deceased. The table starts
with a multiplier of 15, goes upto 18, and then steadily
comes down to 5. It also provides the standard
deduction as one-third on account of personal living
expenses of the deceased. Therefore, where the
application is under section 163A of the Act, it is
possible to calculate the compensation on the
structured formula basis, even where compensation
is not specified with reference to the annual income of
the deceased, or is more than Rs.40,000/-, by
applying the formula : (2/3 x AI x M), that is two-thirds
of the annual income multiplied by the multiplier
applicable to the age of the deceased would be the
compensation. Several principles of tortious liability
are excluded when the claim is under section 163A of
MV Act. “
17.
It is observed that the learned counsel for Respondent
No.2 contended that the Tribunal rightly passed the award
under the principle of no-fault liability under Section 140 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and awarded a sum of Rs.50,000/-,
placing reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Ramkhiladi vs. United India Insurance Company.
However, on perusal of the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court and other High Courts in the judgments
referred to above, this Court is of the opinion that the award
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
passed by the Tribunal is not in consonance with the principles
laid down therein. It is evident that the accident resulted in the
death of the deceased and, therefore, the claim petition under
Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is maintainable,
having regard to the object of the Act, which is a beneficial and
welfare legislation. Even assuming that the deceased was
negligent and contributed to the accident, in view of the
amendment brought by Act 32 of 2019, the claimants would be
entitled to compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- in the case of death
as contemplated under Section 164 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988. Though the accident had occurred prior to the said
amendment, at the time of final adjudication by this Court, the
claimants are entitled to be granted the maximum benefit so as
to ensure award of just and reasonable compensation.
18.
It is a settled principle that the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
is a beneficial and welfare legislation and, therefore, the
benefits conferred under the Act are required to be interpreted
in a manner that advances the object of the legislation and
ensures just compensation to the victims or their dependents.
In the present case, the matter has come up for consideration
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
after the amendment introduced by Act 32 of 2019. By virtue of
the said amendment, Section 164 under Chapter XI provides
for payment of compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- in the event of
death arising out of a motor vehicle accident. Having regard to
the said statutory provision and considering that the accident in
the present case resulted in the death of the deceased, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the claimants are
entitled to compensation of Rs.5,00,000/-. Out of the said
amount, a sum of Rs.3,50,000/- shall be allotted to the first
claimant, being the wife of the deceased, and the remaining
sum of Rs.1,50,000/- shall be allotted to the second claimant,
being the son of the deceased. The said amount shall carry
interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of petition till
the date of realization.
19.
In the result, MACMA is allowed. No costs.
20.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications if any, shall
stand closed. No costs.
________________________________
VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA, J
Date:07.05.2026
SP
NV, J
macma no.262 of 2023
pHON’ BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
MACMA No.262 of 2023
07.05.2026
W
SP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review