The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. The regular second appeal is allowed. The judgment and decree dated 21.10.2009 passed in RA No.273/2002 by the Court of Fast Track Court, KGF, is hereby set-aside and the judgment and decree dated 29.10.2002 passed by the Court of - 12 NC: 2026:KHC:1192 RSA No. 1692 of 2009 HC-KAR I Addl. Civil Judge (Jr. Dn), KGF, decreeing the suit of the appellants is hereby confirmed. SD/(S VISHWAJITH SHETTY) KK/DN
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:1192
RSA No. 1692 of 2009
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 7TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S VISHWAJITH SHETTY
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 1692 OF 2009 (INJ)
BETWEEN:
1.
VASANTHAIAH
S/O LATE MUNISWAMY GOWDA
AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS.
2.
M.V. KUMAR
S/O VASANTHAIAH
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS.
3.
M.V. MANJUNATH
S/O VASANTHAIAH
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS.
4.
M.V. RAGHU
S/O VSANTHAIAH
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS.
NANDINI M S
Location: HIGH COURT
OF KARNATAKA
ALL ARE RESPONDENTS BY THEIR
GPA HOLDER N. PRASAD
AGED 48 YEARS
S/O NARAYANAGOWDA
R/A MAVAHALLI VILLAGE
ROBERTSONPEHOBLI
BANGARPET TALUK
KOLAR DISTRICT - 563 101.
…APPELLANTS
(BY SMT. CHARISHMA, ADV., FOR
SRI L. VENKATARAMA REDDY, ADV.)
AND:
1.
HANUMANTHA BHOVI
SINCE DEAD BY LRS.
a)
CHANGAMMA
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS.
-2NC: 2026:KHC:1192
RSA No. 1692 of 2009
HC-KAR
b)
SRINIVAS
AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS.
c)
RAMESH
AGED AOBUT 30 YEARS.
d)
SHIVAPPA
AGED AOBUT 27 YEARS.
e)
SURESH
AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS.
No.(a) IS THE WIFE AND (b)
TO (e) ARE THE CHILDREN OF
LATE HANUMANTHA BHOVI AND
ALL ARE RESIDING AT SAMPANGIRAMAPURA
MARAGAL CHIKKANKANDAHALLI POST
BANGARPET TALUK
KOLAR DISTRICT - 563 101.
2.
SUBHANNA BHAVI
S/O YELLANNA BHAVI
R/AT SE\AMPANGIRAMAPURA
MARGAL, CHIKKANAHALLI POST TALUK
BANGARPET, DIST: KOLAR - 563 101.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI T. SRINIVASAN, ADV. FOR R-1(A-E);
V/O DTD:21.08.2017 APPEAL AGAINST R-2 IS ABATED)
THIS
RSA
JUDGEMENT
&
IS
FILED
DECREE
U/S.
DATED
OF
CPC
AGAINST
THE
21.10.2009
PASSED
IN
R.A.NO.273/2002 ON THE FILE OF THE PRESITING OFFICER FAST
TRACK COURT, KGF, ALLOWING THE APPEAL AND SETTING ASIDE
THE
JUDGEMENT
AND
DECREE
DATED29.10.2002
PASSED
IN
OS.NO.262/1999 ON THE FILE OF THE 1ST ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE
(JR.DN.),K.G.F.
THIS
APPEAL,
COMING
ON
FOR
HEARING,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
THIS
DAY,
-3NC: 2026:KHC:1192
RSA No. 1692 of 2009
HC-KAR
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S VISHWAJITH SHETTY
ORAL JUDGMENT
1.
This Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 of CPC is
filed with a prayer to set aside the judgment and decree dated
31.10.2009 passed in R.A.No.270/2002 by the Fast Track
Court, KGF, Kolar District.
2.
Heard the learned Counsel for the parties.
3.
Suit in O.S.No.262/1999 was filed by the appellants
herein before the jurisdictional Civil Court seeking the relief of
permanent injunction in respect of the suit schedule property.
4.
It is the case of the plaintiffs that the suit schedule
property
was
granted
in
favour
of
one
Gullappa,
and
subsequently he had sold the said property in favour of Smt.
Kanakamma - wife of plaintiff no.1 and mother of plaintiff nos.2
to
under
a
registered
sale
deed
dated
21.02.1977.
Subsequently, the revenue records in respect of the suit
schedule property were also transferred in the name of Smt.
Kanakamma and after survey of the said land, a new survey
number was given as Sy. No.180. Survey sketch was also
-4NC: 2026:KHC:1192
RSA No. 1692 of 2009
HC-KAR
prepared fixing the actual boundaries of the suit schedule
property. After the death of Smt. Kanakamma, plaintiffs had
succeeded to the suit schedule property. Defendants who have
no right or interest whatsoever over the suit schedule property,
were illegally interfering with the possession of the plaintiffs in
respect of the suit schedule property, and it is under these
circumstances, they had filed the suit. The defendants had filed
their written statement and opposed the suit claim. Before the
Trial Court, plaintiffs had examined three witnesses as PW1 to
PW3 and got marked ten documents as Ex.P1 to P10. On behalf
of defendants, two witnesses were examined as DW1 and DW2
and eight documents were got marked as Ex.D1 to D8. The
Trial Court after hearing the arguments addressed on both
sides had decreed the suit by judgment and decree dated
29.10.2022. The First Appellate Court in RA No.273/2002 by
judgment and decree dated 21.10.2009 has set-aside the said
judgment and decree passed in OS No.262/1999 by the Trial
Court. Aggrieved by the same, the plaintiffs have preferred this
regular second appeal.
-5NC: 2026:KHC:1192
RSA No. 1692 of 2009
HC-KAR
5.
This Court vide order dated 05.10.2010, while admitting
this regular second appeal has framed the following substantial
question of law for consideration in this appeal:"Whether the lower Appellate Court was justified in
holding that the land in question was granted land
with a non-alienation clause and therefore could not
have
been
alienated
within
the
non-alienation
period and that such transfer was mull and void in
terms of Section 4 of the Karnataka Scheduled
Caste and Scheduled Tribe (Prohibition of Transfer
of Certain Lands) Act, 1978?"
6.
Learned counsel for the appellants having reiterated the
grounds urged in the appeal memorandum submits that the
Appellate Court had no jurisdiction to invoke the provisions of
the Karnataka SC/ST (PTCL) Act.
She submits that it is
nobodys case that suit schedule property was purchased by
Smt. Kanakamma from the original grantee PW2 Goolappa in
violation of the provisions of the Karnataka SC/ST (PTCL) Act
and therefore, the Appellate Court was not justified in passing
the impugned judgment and decree.
7.
Per
contra,
learned
counsel
for
the
respondents/defendants has argued in support of the impugned
-6NC: 2026:KHC:1192
RSA No. 1692 of 2009
HC-KAR
judgment and decree. He submits that plaintiffs have failed to
prove their title and possession over the suit schedule property
before the Trial Court was therefore, the Trial Court was not
justified in decreeing the suit. The grant order does not
mention the boundaries of the granted land and in the plaint,
the boundaries have been given to the suit schedule property
based on the survey sketch which is prepared subsequently.
The grant of two acres of land made in favour of the father of
the defendant No.1 is also included in the suit schedule
property. The Trial Court has failed to appreciate this aspect of
the matter and has erred in decreeing the suit. Accordingly, he
prays to dismiss the second appeal.
8.
Respondents/defendants have filed written statement in
OS No.262/1999 denying the grant made in favour of Gullappa
and the sale of the granted land by the grantee in favour of
Smt. Kanakamma. It is further contented that father of
defendant No.1 was granted land in Sy.No.92 of Mavahalli
Village to the extent of land measuring 2 acres. Defendants are
in possession and enjoyment of the said land. It is alleged that
plaintiffs have claimed aforesaid extent of 2 acres of land in the
-7NC: 2026:KHC:1192
RSA No. 1692 of 2009
HC-KAR
suit and an attempt is made to dispossess the defendants from
the suit schedule property. The Trial Court based on the rival
pleadings had framed four issues, which read as follows:"1.
Whether the plaintiff proves that they are in
lawful Possession of the suit schedule property
as on the date of the suit?
2.
Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for the relief
sought for?
3. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for the relief
sought for?
4.
9.
To what order or decree?"
In support of plaintiffs' case, three witnesses were
examined as PW1 to PW3 and ten documents were got marked
as Ex.P1 to P10. PW1/Prasad is the power of attorney of
plaintiffs. PW2 is the vendor of suit schedule property and this
witness has stated that suit schedule property was allotted to
him and he was in possession of the property and he has also
admitted
the
Sale
Deed
executed
in
favour
of
Smt.
Kannakamma in respect of the suit schedule property. Ex.P3 is
the grant certificate dated 06.06.1978 under which the suit
schedule property was granted to Gullappa and Ex.P2 is the
-8NC: 2026:KHC:1192
RSA No. 1692 of 2009
HC-KAR
registered Sale Deed executed by PW2 in favour of Smt.
Kanakamma, wife of plaintiff No.1 and mother of the other
plaintiffs. Ex.P4 is the mutation extract and Ex.P10 is the
survey sketch of the suit schedule property under which the
boundary of the properties which were purchased by the
plaintiffs under registered Sale Deed Ex.P2 from PW2. From the
oral evidence of PW1 to PW3 and the documentary evidence
that was produced on behalf of the plaintiffs, it is very clear
that plaintiffs had proved the title and possession of the suit
schedule property.
10.
On
behalf
of
the
defendants,
two
witnesses
were
examined as DW1 and DW2 and eight documents were got
marked as Ex.D1 to D8. Though it was contented on behalf of
defendants that 2 acres of land in Sy.No.92 of Mavahalli Village
was allotted to the father of defendant No.1, no such document
was produced before the Trial Court to prove such grant. DW1
has pleaded ignorance about the boundary of the suit schedule
property and also has pleaded his ignorance about the grant of
4 acres of land in Sy.No.92 of Mavahalli Village in favour of
Goolappa. Even DW2 has pleaded ignorance of the grant made
-9NC: 2026:KHC:1192
RSA No. 1692 of 2009
HC-KAR
in favour of Goolappa. It is under these circumstances, the Trial
Court had decreed the suit.
11.
The First Appellate Court having upheld that the plaintiffs
were in possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule property
has set-aside the judgment and decree passed by the Trial
Court solely on the ground that sale of the suit schedule
property made by PW2, who is the original grantee in the
present case was hit by Section 4 of the Karnataka Scheduled
Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain
Lands) Act, 1978 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Karnataka
SC/ST (PTCL) Act) and therefore, the said sale is void and
cannot be sustained. It is under these circumstances, the First
Appellate Court having set-aside the judgment and decree
passed in OS No.262/1999 has directed the plaintiffs to deliver
the possession of the suit schedule property to the State
Government within two months from the date of the order.
12.
Section 4 of the Karnataka SC/ST (PTCL) Act, provides for
prohibition of transfer of granted lands and Section 5 provides
for resumption and restitution of granted lands. The Assistant
Commissioner, is the competent officer under Section 5 of the
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:1192
RSA No. 1692 of 2009
HC-KAR
Karnataka SC/ST (PTCL) Act, who is empowered to take action
suo motu or on an application filed by any interested person if
he is satisfied that the transfer of any granted land is null and
void under sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the said Act, in the
said event, he is empowered to take possession of such land
after evicting all persons thereof in the manner known to law
and restore possession of the said land to the original grantee
or his legal heir and if the same is not practicable to restore the
land, such land shall be deemed to have vested in the
Government free from all encumbrances.
13.
In the case on hand, it is nobodys case that the sale of
the granted land by the original grantee in favour of Smt.
Kanakamma was hit by Section 4 of the Karnataka SC/ST
(PTCL) Act and thereby the same is null and void. A perusal of
the provisions of the Act would go to show that it is only the
jurisdictional Assistant Commissioner, who is authorized to take
action as provided under Section 5 of the said Act, in the event,
if it is found that the transfer of granted land is hit by Section 4
of the Act. The Civil Court has no jurisdiction to pass any orders
as provided under Section 5 of the Act, even in the event, if it
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:1192
RSA No. 1692 of 2009
HC-KAR
is presumed that defendants have raised such a contention in
their written statement.
14.
In the case on hand, as stated earlier, no such contention
was raised by defendants and no issue was framed by the Trial
Court. However, the Appellate Court after having arrived at a
conclusion that the suit schedule property was sold by the
grantee (PW2) in favour of Smt. Kanakamma in violation of the
provisions of the Karnataka SC/ST (PTCL) Act has proceeded to
order resumption of the land and has directed the plaintiffs to
hand over the possession of the suit schedule property to the
State Government. This approach of the Appellate Court is
illegal and perverse. Under the circumstances, the substantial
question of law framed by this Court is answered in the
affirmative. The judgment and decree passed by the First
Appellate
Court
in
RA
No.273/2002
is
therefore,
not
sustainable. Accordingly, the following order:-
15.
The regular second appeal is allowed. The judgment and
decree dated 21.10.2009 passed in RA No.273/2002 by the
Court of Fast Track Court, KGF, is hereby set-aside and the
judgment and decree dated 29.10.2002 passed by the Court of
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:1192
RSA No. 1692 of 2009
HC-KAR
I Addl. Civil Judge (Jr. Dn), KGF, decreeing the suit of the
appellants is hereby confirmed.
SD/(S VISHWAJITH SHETTY)
JUDGE
KK/DN
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review