Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 17th February, 2026
Pronounced on: 11th March, 2026
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025 & CRL.M.A. 5416/2026
VARUN MALHOTRA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Anant Misra, Mr. Lokendra
Dixit & Ms. Devika Gaur,
Advs.
versus
THE STATE OF NCT OF DELHI AND ORS. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Sanjay Lao, Standing
Counsel (Criminal) for State
with Ms. Priyam Agarwal, Adv.
along with SI Krishan Pal
Singh, PS Mukherji Nagar,
Delhi.
Mr. Ankur Yadav, Mr. Vaibhav
Maheshwari & Ms. Vrinda
Goyal, Advs. for R-2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAVIN CHAWLA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA
JUDGMENT
RAVINDER DUDEJA, J.
1.
The present writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India has been filed by the petitioner/husband seeking issuance of a
writ of Habeas Corpus directing Respondent No.2/mother to produce
the minor son before this Court and further seeks a direction for his
return to Canada.
Factual Background
2.
The present petition has been filed by the petitioner, alleging
therein that the petitioner/father and respondent no. 2/mother got
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
married on 21st January, 2013 in Delhi according to Hindu rites and
ceremonies. The petitioner relocated to Chicago, USA in December
2014 for the purpose of employment. Respondent No. 2 joined the
petitioner in October 2017 in Chicago, USA. They stayed together in
USA till 2020. On 21st November, 2019, they were blessed with a
child namely Master ‘V’. In September 2020, the family relocated to
Canada in pursuit of better opportunities as permanent residents.
3.
It is alleged that in January 2023, the petitioner along with
respondent No. 2 and the minor son travelled to Mexico to celebrate
their 10th wedding anniversary. However, on 26th January, 2023, upon
receiving an information about the sudden demise of her elder sisterin-law, respondent No. 2 travelled from Mexico to India, leaving the
minor child Master ‘V’ in the care and custody of the petitioner. It is
further alleged that although, respondent No. 2 had initially indicated
a short stay in India, she later extended it to three months to support
her brother’s family. During this period, petitioner single-handedly
managed all the parenting duties. Later, he also travelled to India with
the child. In April, 2023, the couple along with their minor son and the
petitioner’s mother, flew back to Canada.
4.
It is alleged that matrimonial discord arose between the parties.
On 25th September, 2023, respondent No. 2 informed the petitioner
regarding her resignation from her job in Canada and decided to live
separately for a certain period. On 17th October 2023, respondent No.
2 travelled to India with the minor child with the consent of the
petitioner for a three week vacation to visit her family. On 06th
November, 2023, respondent No. 2 cancelled the return flight tickets
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
scheduled for 07th November, 2023 and did not return back.
5.
During her stay in India, respondent No. 2 filed a complaint
before the CAW Cell, alleging physical and mental harassment by the
petitioner. She filed a Guardianship Petition bearing GP No. 1/2024
under section 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 which is
stated to be pending before the learned Family Court, Rohini District
Court, Delhi. On 31st December, 2023, an FIR No. 1044/2023 was
registered at her instance under Sections 498A/406/34 of the Indian
Penal Code, 1860 [“IPC”] at PS Mukherjee Nagar, Delhi against the
petitioner and his mother. In January, 2024, she also filed a domestic
violence complaint against the petitioner and his mother before the
learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, North District, Rohini District
Court, Delhi.
6.
On 2nd March, 2024, petitioner filed an application under Order
VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 [“CPC”] for
rejection of the Guardianship Petition filed by the respondent No.2,
which is pending consideration before the learned Family Court,
Delhi.
7.
In March 2024, petitioner filed an urgent parenting application
before the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Canada, seeking the
immediate return of his minor son. Vide order dated 7th March, 2024,
the Ontario Superior Court, Canada, granted the petitioner interim sole
parenting rights in respect of minor child ‘V’ and directed the
immediate return of the child to Canada, holding that his retention in
India by respondent No. 2 is without the consent of the petitioner and
that his habitual residence is in Canada.
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
8.
Despite the return order passed by the Ontario Superior Court,
Canada, respondent No.2/mother along with the minor child has
continued to reside in India since October 2023. Feeling aggrieved,
petitioner filed the present petition before this Court on 23rd August,
2025.
Submissions on behalf of Petitioner/Husband
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that he is the
biological father and natural guardian of the minor child, who was
born in the United States of America and has been raised in Canada,
thereby establishing his habitual residence outside India. Learned
counsel further submitted that the child was brought to India by
respondent no. 2/mother on the pretext of a temporary visit of
approximately three weeks, for which the petitioner had granted
consent and necessary travel documents, but respondent no. 2
deliberately failed to return to Canada, thereby, demonstrating her
mala fide.
10.
It was argued that such conduct amounts to wrongful retention
and abduction of the child under international law. The petitioner
asserted that the Ontario Superior Court, Canada, by interim order
dated 7th March 2024, granted sole parenting rights to the petitioner
and directed return of the minor child, thereby affirming the
petitioner’s custodial rights. Learned counsel submitted that the
refusal of respondent no. 2 to comply with the foreign court’s order
demonstrates mala fide intent and disregard for lawful authority.
11.
It was further argued that the child’s education, social
environment, and emotional stability have been adversely affected due
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
to his sudden displacement from Canada and prolonged stay in India.
It was contended that the petitioner has been systematically denied
communication and access to his son, causing him severe emotional
trauma. It was also submitted that the respondent no.2/mother has no
care and concern for their child and is frequently partying, while
leaving the child behind with the house help.
12.
It was submitted that respondent no. 2 has instituted multiple
frivolous criminal and civil proceedings in India solely to create
obstacles to the child’s return and to harass the petitioner and his
family and to institute parallel proceedings, despite not being an
ordinary resident there. Learned counsel prayed that the welfare of the
child lies in restoring him to his habitual environment in Canada
where he had stable schooling, healthcare, and family support. It was
contended that principle of comity of courts require Indian courts to
enforce the orders passed by the Ontario Superior Court, Canada.
Hence, it was prayed that the present petition be allowed and the
minor child be returned to Canada. In support of his submissions, the
learned counsel for the petitioner placed reliance on the judgment of
this Court in Sunaina Rao Kommineni Vs. Abhiram Balusu,
2025:DHC:4483-DB.
Submissions on behalf of Respondent No.2/Wife
13.
Per contra, learned counsel for Respondent No.2 opposed the
petition and submitted that the present petition is not maintainable as
the child is in the lawful custody of his biological mother, which
cannot be termed illegal detention for the purpose of habeas corpus. It
was contended that habeas corpus is an extraordinary remedy meant
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
for unlawful confinement and not for adjudicating disputed custody
rights between parents.
14.
It was further submitted that upon arriving in India, Respondent
No.2 initiated appropriate legal proceedings seeking guardianship and
custody from the competent court, thereby invoking the jurisdiction of
Indian courts in accordance with law. Learned counsel emphasized
that the learned Family Court has already entertained the matter,
thereby recognizing its jurisdiction and the petitioner cannot bypass
that forum by invoking writ jurisdiction.
15.
It was further contended that there are serious allegations of
domestic violence, cruelty and harassment against the petitioner,
resulting in initiation of criminal proceedings in India by respondent
No. 2.
16.
It was contended that the minor son is now settled at Delhi with
the respondent no.2/mother and is attending school in Delhi since
October 2023. It was also argued that uprooting him from his present
surroundings and compelling his return to Canada would cause him
severe emotional and psychological distress.
17.
Learned counsel further argued that the foreign court’s order
relied upon by the petitioner is only interim and cannot override the
jurisdiction of Indian courts where the child is physically present and
an ordinary resident. Learned counsel contended that the return order
passed by the Ontario Superior Court, Canada cannot be enforced
mechanically and the courts in Delhi must independently consider the
welfare of the minor child. It was prayed that the writ petition be
dismissed. In support, the learned Senior Counsel for Respondent No.
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
2 has placed reliance on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Nithya
Anand Raghavan Vs. State (NCT of Delhi) & Anr., (2017) 8 SCC
454 and Tejaswini Gaud Vs. Shekhar Jagdish Prasad Tewari, (2019)
7 SCC 42.
Analysis and Findings
18.
We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and carefully
perused the material on record.
19.
The petitioner seeks issuance of a writ of Habeas Corpus for
production of his minor son and also seeks directions regarding his
custody and return to Canada. The dispute, in fact, is more of a
custody battle between estranged parents.
20.
It is not in dispute that the minor son is presently residing with
Respondent No.2, that is, his biological mother at Delhi. Custody with
a natural guardian, particularly the mother, cannot ordinarily be
termed illegal so as to justify the issuance of a writ of Habeas Corpus.
The extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution is
discretionary and is not intended to supplant statutory remedies.
Habeas Corpus is a prerogative writ which is an extraordinary remedy
and the writ is maintainable only where detention of the minor child is
illegal or without authority of law.
21.
The Supreme Court in Veena Kapoor Dr. (Mrs.) Vs. Varinder
Kumar Kapoor, (1981) 3 SCC 92 emphasized that in matters of
custody of minor child, the welfare of the child is the paramount
consideration and it will override the legal right of either party/parent.
In this case, the issue of custody of child was between the natural
guardians, who were not living together. The mother of the child, filed
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
the Habeas Corpus petition seeking custody of the child from her
husband alleging that her husband was having illegal custody of the
one and a half year old child. The Supreme Court directed the District
Judge concerned to take down evidence, adduced by the parties, and
send a report to the Supreme Court on the question whether
considering the interest of the minor child, its mother should be given
its custody.
22.
In Sarita Sharma Vs. Sushil Sharma, (2000) 3 SCC 14, the
tussle over the custody of two minor children was between their
separated mother and father. The Family Court of the USA while
passing the decree of divorce gave custody rights to the father. When
the mother flew to India with the children, the father approached the
High Court by filing a Habeas Corpus petition. The High Court
directed the mother to handover the custody to the father. The
Supreme Court in appeal, while dismissing the writ petition observed
that when a minor child is in the custody of the mother, such custody
cannot be considered unlawful merely because the father seeks
custody, and that the High Court should instead of allowing the
Habeas Corpus petition should have directed the parties to initiate
appropriate proceedings where a thorough enquiry regarding the
interest of children could be made. The relevant para of the judgment
reads as under:“6. …… Considering all the aspects relating to the welfare of the
children, we are of the opinion that in spite of the order passed by
the Court in U.S.A. it was not proper for the High Court to have
allowed the habeas corpus writ petition and directed the appellant
to hand over custody of the children to the respondent and permit
him to take them away to U.S.A. What would be in the interest of
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
the children requires a full and thorough inquiry and, therefore,
the High Court should have directed the respondent to initiate
appropriate proceedings in which such an inquiry can be held.
Still there is some possibility of the mother returning to U.S.A. in
the interest of the children. Therefore, we do not desire to say
anything more regarding entitlement of the custody of the children.
The chances of the appellant returning to U.S.A. with the children
would depend upon the joint efforts of the appellant and the
respondent to get the arrest warrant cancelled by explaining to the
Court in U.S.A. the circumstances under which she had left U.S.A.
with the children without taking permission of the Court. There is a
possibility that both of them may thereafter be able to approach the
Court which passed the decree to suitably modify the order with
respect to the custody of the children and visitation rights.”
23.
Similarly, in the landmark judgment of Tejaswini Gaud (supra),
the Supreme Court reiterated that a writ of Habeas Corpus in child
custody matters is maintainable only where the custody is unlawful or
without authority of law. Even in such cases, the Court must be guided
by the paramount consideration of the welfare of the child rather than
the legal rights of the parties. The Apex Court further held that in
child custody matters, the ordinary remedy lies only under the Hindu
Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 or the Guardians and Wards
Act, 1890. If the Court believes that the matter requires a thorough
examination of facts, it may choose not to use its extraordinary
jurisdiction and instead instruct the parties to seek relief before a civil
court. Only in rare and exceptional circumstances will the Court
decide custody rights through its extraordinary jurisdiction on a
Habeas Corpus petition. The relevant paras of the judgment reads as
under:“19. Habeas corpus proceedings is not to justify or examine the
legality of the custody. Habeas corpus proceedings is a medium
through which the custody of the child is addressed to the
discretion of the court. Habeas corpus is a prerogative writ which
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
is an extraordinary remedy and the writ is issued where in the
circumstances of the particular case, ordinary remedy provided by
the law is either not available or is ineffective; otherwise a writ will
not be issued. In child custody matters, the power of the High Court
in granting the writ is qualified only in cases where the detention of
a minor by a person who is not entitled to his legal custody. In view
of the pronouncement on the issue in question by the Supreme
Court and the High Courts, in our view, in child custody matters,
the writ of habeas corpus is maintainable where it is proved that
the detention of a minor child by a parent or others was illegal and
without any authority of law.
20. In child custody matters, the ordinary remedy lies only under
the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act or the Guardians and
Wards Act as the case may be. In cases arising out of the
proceedings under the Guardians and Wards Act, the jurisdiction
of the court is determined by whether the minor ordinarily resides
within the area on which the court exercises such jurisdiction.
There are significant differences between the enquiry under the
Guardians and Wards Act and the exercise of powers by a writ
court which is of summary in nature. What is important is the
welfare of the child. In the writ court, rights are determined only on
the basis of affidavits. Where the court is of the view that a detailed
enquiry is required, the court may decline to exercise the
extraordinary jurisdiction and direct the parties to approach the
civil court. It is only in exceptional cases, the rights of the parties
to the custody of the minor will be determined in exercise of
extraordinary jurisdiction on a petition for habeas corpus.”
24.
The Supreme Court in Nithya Anand (supra), has categorically
held that the High Court, when hearing a habeas corpus petition
involving a minor child, may either order the child’s return or refuse
to alter custody based on the specific facts and circumstances of the
case, with the child’s welfare being the paramount consideration.
Orders of foreign courts are subordinate to the child’s welfare and
cannot be enforced through habeas corpus as if the High Court were
executing a foreign decree. However, the petitioner remains free to
pursue other legal remedies available under the law to enforce the
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
foreign court’s order or to seek custody before an appropriate Indian
court. The relevant portion of the judgment reads as under:“46. The High Court while dealing with the petition for issuance of
a writ of habeas corpus concerning a minor child, in a given case,
may direct return of the child or decline to change the custody of
the child keeping in mind all the attending facts and circumstances
including the settled legal position referred to above. Once again,
we may hasten to add that the decision of the Court, in each case,
must depend on the totality of the facts and circumstances of the
case brought before it whilst considering the welfare of the child
which is of paramount consideration. The order of the foreign
Court must yield to the welfare of the child. Further, the remedy of
writ of habeas corpus cannot be used for mere enforcement of the
directions given by the foreign court against a person within its
jurisdiction and convert that jurisdiction into that of an executing
court. Indubitably, the writ petitioner can take recourse to such
other remedy as may be permissible in law for enforcement of the
order passed by the foreign Court or to resort to any other
proceedings as may be permissible in law before the Indian Court
for the custody of the child, if so advised.”
25.
The Supreme Court further held that foreign custody orders are
only one of the factors to be considered and that the Indian court must
independently examine whether returning the child would be in his or
her best interest. The welfare of the child is of paramount importance.
The relevant portion of the judgment reads as under:“66. The invocation of first strike principle as a decisive factor, in
our opinion, would undermine and whittle down the wholesome
principle of the duty of the Court having jurisdiction to consider
the best interests and welfare of the child, which is of paramount
importance. If the Court is convinced in that regard, the fact that
there is already an order passed by a foreign Court in existence
may not be so significant as it must yield to the welfare of the child.
That is only one of the factors to be taken into consideration. The
interests and welfare of the child are of paramount consideration.
The principle of comity of courts as observed in Dhanwanti Joshi’s
case (supra), in relation to non-convention countries is that the
Court in the country to which the child is removed will consider the
question on merits bearing the welfare of the child as of paramount
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
importance and consider the order of the foreign Court as only a
factor to be taken into consideration. While considering that
aspect, the Court may reckon the fact that the child was abducted
from his or her country of habitual residence but the Court’s
overriding consideration must be the child’s welfare.
67. XXX
68. XXX
69. We once again reiterate that the exposition in the case of
Dhanwanti Joshi (supra) is a good law and has been quoted with
approval by a three-judge bench of this Court in V. Ravi Chandran
(supra). We approve the view taken in Dhanwanti Joshi (supra),
inter alia in paragraph 33 that so far as non-convention countries
are concerned, the law is that the Court in the country to which the
child is removed while considering the question must bear in mind
the welfare of the child as of paramount importance and consider
the order of the foreign Court as only a factor to be taken into
consideration. The summary jurisdiction to return the child be
exercised in cases where the child had been removed from its
native land and removed to another country where, may be, his
native language is not spoken, or the child gets divorced from the
social customs and contacts to which he has been accustomed, or if
its education in his native land is interrupted and the child is being
subjected to a foreign system of education, for these are all acts
which could psychologically disturb the child. Again the summary
jurisdiction be exercised only if the court to which the child has
been removed is moved promptly and quickly. The overriding
consideration must be the interests and welfare of the child.”
26.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the present case, the
custody of the child with mother/Respondent No.2 cannot per se be
regarded as illegal. The petitioner’s grievance pertains to entitlement
to custody, which is a matter requiring detailed adjudication rather
than summary determination in writ proceedings.
27.
It is an admitted position that Respondent No.2 has instituted a
petition under the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, being GP No.
1/2024, seeking custody and guardianship of the minor child before
the learned Family Court at Delhi. The said Guardianship Petition is
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
presently pending adjudication before the competent court.
28.
The existence and pendency of the said proceedings is crucial.
The Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 provides a comprehensive
statutory framework for determination of custody disputes on the basis
of evidence and welfare considerations. The learned Family Court,
exercising parens patriae jurisdiction, in our opinion, is the
appropriate forum to evaluate the competing claims of the parents.
29.
The petitioner herein had challenged the maintainability of the
said Guardianship Petition by filing an application under Order VII
Rule 11 CPC seeking rejection of the petition on the ground that the
Indian courts lacked territorial jurisdiction. The said application is
stated to be pending.
30.
Since the learned Family Court has yet to adjudicate the
petitioner’s challenge to maintainability, it would be inappropriate for
this Court to entertain the present writ petition which, in effect, seeks
to circumvent the pending proceedings before the learned Family
Court.
31.
In Sunaina Rao (supra), the wife had filed the Guardianship
Petition after the husband had already approached the Arizona Court
and that Court had passed a detailed order on joint custody of the
child. Further, the Guardianship Petition filed by the wife in India had
been returned by the learned Family Court, finding lack of territorial
jurisdiction. The said judgment therefore, has no application to the
facts of the present case.
32.
The petitioner has placed reliance on orders passed by the
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
foreign court, that is, the Ontario Superior Court, Canada directing
return of the minor child. While such orders are entitled to due regard,
they cannot be enforced automatically through Habeas Corpus
proceedings, especially when the welfare of the child is required to be
independently assessed by the court within whose jurisdiction he
presently resides.
33.
Coming back to the present case, the material on record reveals
that the minor child is presently residing with his mother/Respondent
No.2 in Delhi, is attending school, and is living in a family
environment since last more than two years. Uprooting him abruptly
and directing his removal from the jurisdiction without a detailed
inquiry into his welfare would not be appropriate.
34.
It is well settled law by a catena of judgments that while
deciding matters of custody of a child, primary and paramount
consideration is welfare of the child. The issues raised by the
petitioner involve disputed questions of fact, including the
circumstances under which the child came to India, his present wellbeing, and the competing allegations of the parties regarding custody.
Such issues cannot be satisfactorily resolved in summary writ
proceedings and may require due appreciation of evidence.
35.
In our opinion, the present writ petition seeks to convert this
Court into an executing forum for a foreign order, which is
impermissible in custody matters. We feel it pertinent to point out that
the petitioner has an efficacious alternate remedy before the learned
Family Court where the Guardianship Petition is pending.
Entertaining the present petition, at this stage, would result in parallel
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
proceedings and may prejudice the adjudication before the learned
Family Court.
36.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the
considered opinion that no case is made out for issuance of a writ of
Habeas Corpus or for interference in the custody of the minor child at
this stage.
37.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
38.
It is clarified that the learned Family Court shall proceed with
the
Guardianship
Petition,
including
on
its
maintainability
expeditiously and decide the matter on its own merits, uninfluenced
by any observations contained herein.
RAVINDER DUDEJA, J.
NAVIN CHAWLA, J.
11th March, 2026/AK/RM
W.P.(CRL) 2808/2025
Signed By:VAISHALI
PRUTHI
16:15
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review