Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.M.MANOJ
WEDNESDAY, THE 19TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 30TH MAGHA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 26470 OF 2012
PETITIONER :
VARKEY P.J.
AGED 58 YEARS
S/O.JOSEPH, PULLAT HOUSE, CHEMPANODU P.O., PERUVANNAMOOZHY
VIA., KOZHIKODE DISTRICT-673528 (RTD.HSA, CRESCENT HIGH
SCHOOL, ADAKKAKUNDU, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT)
BY ADV SRI.SUNIL V.MOHAMMED
RESPONDENTS :
THE STATE OF KERALA
REP. BY THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,
EDUCATIONAL DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695001.
THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF EDUCATION
DOWNHILL P.O., MALAPPURAM -676519.
THE DISTRICT EDUCATIONAL OFFICER,
WANDOOR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT-679428.
THE MANAGER,
CRESCENT HIGH SCHOOL, ADAKKAKUNDU, VIA.KALIKAVU,
MALAPPURAM DISTRICT-676525.
P. KHALID,
RTD.HEADMASTER, PULPADAN HOUSE, PULLANKODE,
VIA.KALIKAVU, CHOKAD P.O.,
MALAPPURAM DISTRICT-676525.
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
THE HEADMASTER,
CRESCENT HIGH SCHOOL, ADAKKAKUNDU, VIA KALIKAVU,
MALAPPURAM DISTRICT-676525.
BY ADV SRI.R.RAMADAS
OTHER PRESENT:
SRI.BINOY DAVIS, GOVERNMENT PLEADER
THIS
WRIT
PETITION
(CIVIL)
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD
19.02.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
P.M. MANOJ, J
-----------------WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
---------------------Dated this the 19th day of February, 2025
JUDGMENT
The writ petition is preferred challenging Exts.P3, P5, P7, P11,
P12 & P21. Ext.P3 is the memo. Ext.P5 is the order of the District
Educational Officer for extension of suspension period beyond 15 days.
Ext.P7 is the memo of charges. Ext.P11 is the rejection of request for
examining 50 teachers. Ext.P12 is the show cause notice and Ext.P21
is the order passed as per the direction in Ext.P19 decision of the
Division Bench of this Court.
2. Alleging certain irregularity in the conduct of the petitioner, he
was suspended from the service of the 4th respondent School as per
Ext.P3. Thereafter the suspension was extended by Ext.P5 order by
invoking sub-rules (7) & (8) of Rule 67 Chapter XIV A KER at the
request of the Manager, the 4th respondent. Thereafter, Ext.P7 memo
of charges was issued to the petitioner.
In the light of Ext.P7 the
petitioner put forth his reply as per Ext.P8.
The petitioner has
approached the Deputy Director of Education to reinstate him in service.
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
However, his request was concluded citing that his suspension was
highly essential for concluding the disciplinary proceedings, and by
fixing a time limit for concluding the disciplinary proceedings, his
request was rejected. Thereafter, the proceedings were continued. At
the request of the petitioner, the enquiry officer was also changed, and
the said enquiry officer continued the enquiry, and his request for
cross-examining 50 teachers was rejected on the ground that it was
his attempt to protract the finalisation of disciplinary proceedings.
Thereafter, Ext.P12 show cause notice was issued to the petitioner
whereby it was proposed to dismiss the petitioner from service. The
petitioner preferred his reply as per Ext.P13. Thereafter he approached
this Court by preferring OP No.16375 of 1999. However, this court has
not considered the merits of the contention whereas directed to dispose
the revision petition preferred by the petitioner.
3. Since the punishment proposed is dismissal from service, in
statutory compliance with Rule 74 of Chapter XIV A KER, the manager
approached the Deputy Director of Education. On considering the said
application, the DDE has declined permission to impose major
punishment like dismissal from service and directed to impose some
other lesser punishment by reinstating the petitioner in service. Being
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
aggrieved by that the Manager has preferred revision before the
Government. By considering the revision, the government revised the
punishment imposed by the Manager by barring two increments with
cumulative effect and directed him to reinstate the petitioner in service.
Being aggrieved by that, the manager has preferred OP No.14188 of
2000.
4. By setting aside Ext.P16 Government Order, the writ petition
was disposed of on the ground that the manager was not given an
opportunity to be heard. Being aggrieved by that the petitioner has
preferred WA No.1221 of 2000. The writ appeal was disposed of with
a direction to the government to reconsider the revision petition.
Accordingly, Ext.P17 was issued by reconsidering the revision petition.
Wherein it was found that the punishment proposed by the manager
was not commensurate with the gravity of offence and government
suggested the punishment of barring the increment with cumulative
effect for two years and treating the period of suspension as eligible
leave. Being aggrieved by that, the petitioner as well as the manager
challenged Ext.P17 by filing WP(C) No.10304 of 2001 and 10442 of
2001 respectively.
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
5. Both writ petitions were disposed of by a common judgment
whereby OP No.10304/2001 filed by the manager was disposed holding
that the alternate penalty directed to be imposed by the DDE and
government is correct as no major penalty is warranted in the facts of
the case. However, the manager was free to take fresh action as to
what penalty should be imposed on the delinquent employee and
directed to impose one of the minor penalties provided under Rules 65
Chapter XIV A KER. On the other hand, OP No. 10442/2001, preferred
by the petitioner herein, was also disposed with a direction to the
manager to reinstate the petitioner within a stipulated time, and his
period of suspension shall be regularized, in accordance with law. The
DDE was directed to consider his claim for salary from the date of
reporting to the school in accordance with law. It is further directed
that in case it was found that the petitioner was kept out of service
unnecessarily by the manager, the salary, if any, ordered to be paid to
him may be recovered from the Manager by the DDE.
6. Being aggrieved by that, the Manager has preferred two Writ
Appeal Nos. 1132/2002 & 1140/2002. The writ appeals were disposed
with certain directions, whereby the judgment dated 08.04.2002 of the
learned Single Judge was set aside to the extent that it is inconsistent
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
with the findings in Writ Appeals. Then Ext.P17 Government Order was
quashed. The decision of the DDE to deny permission to impose the
penalty of dismissal was upheld.
The Manager was directed to
reconsider the matter. However, the Manager was restricted from
imposing any of the penalties other than the penalties mentioned in
Rule 64 of Chapter XIV A KER. The Manager was directed to reinstate
the petitioner within two weeks from the date of receipt of the copy of
the judgment. It was further directed to regularise the period of
suspension of the teacher. However, it was clarified that these
directions will not preclude the teacher from resorting to statutory
remedies available to him against the final order to be passed by the
Manager in the disciplinary proceedings against him. The challenge
against the Division Bench judgment was unsuccessful before the Apex
Court. Thereafter by Ext.P21, the Manager, in compliance with the
directions in Writ Appeal passed fresh orders, whereby he awarded a
punishment of barring increments for two years and the period of
suspension was treated as eligible leave.
Aggrieved by this, the
petitioner preferred Ext.P2 revision before the Government under Rule
92 Chapter XIV A KER. By Ext.P1 order, the revision petition preferred
by the petitioner has been disposed of on considering the fact that the
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
petitioner retired from service on 31.03.2009. The period between the
date of suspension and the reinstatement in duty is decided to be
treated as duty for the purpose of pension.
7. The 3rd respondent-DEO as well as the 4th respondent-Manager
had preferred counter affidavits. It is contended in the counter affidavit
filed by the 3rd respondent that the petitioner had retired from service
on 31.03.2009. Ext.P3, a memo with respect to the commencement
of disciplinary proceedings is not liable to be challenged. Ext.P5 is an
order passed by the DEO, under Rule 67 Chapter XIV A KER, granting
permission to the manager to keep the petitioner under suspension
beyond 15 days. As the petitioner retired from service, the challenge
against Ext.P5 has no relevance, and Exts.P7 and P11 are the memo
of charges and report of the enquiry, not amenable to any challenge.
Since it has already culminated in punishment, and those punishments
and the punishment imposed by the manager have undergone judicial
scrutiny as per Ext.P18 and P19, finally, in compliance of the directions
of the Division Bench judgment, Ext.P21 order imposing punishment
was
issued.
The
petitioner
has
preferred
revision
before
the
Government and the Government has considered and passed an order
in the revision preferred under Rule 92. The period of suspension was
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
regularised by holding that the period between 07.02.1996 and
26.03.2003 was ordered to be counted for pension treating it as duty
and the period from that date till 28.12.2008 was declared to be the
period during which he was on duty or is to be counted as eligible leave
in terms of Rule 56(v) (9) of Part I KSR. Therefore, none of the prayers
raised in the writ petition cannot be pressed.
8. Similarly, the 4th respondent has also submitted that in view of
the various government orders and judgments of this Court, produced
by the petitioner, it is clear that charges levelled against the petitioner
were proved and the Manager is justified in imposing the penalty as
per Ext.P21. The respondents 4 to 6 acted strictly in compliance with
the provisions of the Kerala Education Act and Rules, and there was no
attempt on their part to deliberately keep the petitioner under
suspension for an indefinite period.
The action of the Manager was
upheld by the educational authority, the government as well as this
Court. However, it restricted the Manager from imposing minor
punishment under Rule 65 Chapter XIV A KER.
That is quite evident
in Ext.P19 judgment. Thereafter, the petitioner preferred revision
under Rule 92 against Ext.P21 and on considering the revision petition,
i.e., Ext.P2, the government passed Ext.P1 order. But, the petitioner
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
has not raised any challenge against Ext.P1, however, he challenged
the orders from the memo to the final order of imposing punishment
as per Ext.P21.
This cannot be permitted even after availing his
remedy under Rule 92, without challenging the same.
9. I have heard Sri.Sunil V. Mohammed, learned counsel for the
petitioner, Sri.Binoy Davis learned Government Pleader for the official
respondents
and
Sri.R.Ramadas,
learned
counsel
for
the
4th
respondent.
10. The learned counsel for the petitioner contended that though
the disciplinary proceedings is culminated in Ext.P21, in the light of the
directions given by the Division Bench in Ext.P19 judgment, he is
entitled to challenge the entire proceedings behind Ext.P21 which is
not yet concluded. Since the revision petition preferred by the
petitioner raises allegation against the disciplinary proceedings,
without considering the same, Ext.P1 was issued confirming the
punishment imposed by the Manager with slight modification with
respect to treating the period of suspension.
In support of his
contention, it is submitted that the entire challenge raised against
Exts.P18 and P19 is with respect to the proceedings under Rule 74 of
Chapter XIV A KER. This court has not considered the alleged
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
irregularities in the enquiry conducted by the educational authorities.
It is also contended that, the petitioner even now reserved with the
right to challenge Ext.P21 under Rule 80, has brought the attention of
this Court to the reported decision in Muhammed v. Secretary to
Government [2003 (2) KLT
SN 34] i.e. none other than Ext.P19
judgment wherein as stated above, power under Rule 74 was
considered by the Court and found that the educational authority
cannot suggest imposing an alternative penalty and government
cannot pass an order under which subordinate authority could not have
legally passed. Similarly, a reported decision in Seetharam Upper
Primary School v. State of Kerala [2012 (2) KLT 338] whereby
contended that while conducting enquiry, principles followed for
conducting the enquiry against a government servant should be
mandatorily followed.
11. The counsel for the petitioner also brought the attention of
this Court to the reported decision in Meenakshi P. v. State of Kerala
& Others
[2020 (5) KLT 166] to substantiate that the manager is
bound to pay the amount that has been disbursed to a teacher or nonteaching staff, if failed to reinstate the teacher or nonteaching staff in
service in spite of specific direction by the educational officer on the
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
basis of its preliminary investigation. However, unfortunately, I could
not relate this decision to the facts involved in this case. Primarily,
Ext.P21 was issued by the 4th respondent in compliance with the
direction contained in the judgment of the Division Bench as per
Ext.P19. Even thereafter the challenge raised by the petitioner against
the enquiry proceedings prior to the Division Bench judgment cannot
be countenanced. In that regard, it is submitted by the counsel for the
petitioner that in WA No.1242 of 2015 and WP(C) No. 30422 of 2013
between Ribin K.A. and State of Kerala and others, the petitioner
tried to establish that there is a finding in the judgment that, depending
on the outcome of the writ petition, the manager will have to issue
fresh proceedings, and on the issue of such proceedings it is for the
delinquent to seek appellate remedy that is available to him under Rule
80 of Chapter XIV A KER and in that proceedings it will be open to the
appellant to canvass the correctness or otherwise of the enquiry and
the findings of the enquiry officer which ultimately culminated in the
order of punishment. I cannot accept this position with respect to the
facts of this case.
12. Going by Ext.P19 judgment of the Division Bench, this court
has meticulously examined the procedure conducted during the
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
disciplinary proceedings specifically stressing the procedure adopted
under Rule 74 Chapter XIV A KER.
Moreover, the disciplinary
proceedings undergone by the petitioner has undergone judicial
scrutiny at the first instance by Ext.P14. Thereafter, by Exts.P18 and
P19, and finally by Ext.P19, the Manager was directed to impose
punishment prescribed under Rule 65 Chapter XIV A KER.
In
compliance with that, the Manager issued Ext.P21. Whereby, barring
of increment with cumulative effect for two years was imposed as
granted permission by the Division Bench, the petitioner has also
challenged the same under Rule 92. As per Ext.P2 that culminated in
Ext.P1 by the Government. However, without challenging Ext.P1, the
petitioner has challenged the memo, whereby the disciplinary
proceedings initiated, Ext.P5 the order of extension of period of
suspension, Ext.P7 the memo of charges, Ext.P11 the enquiry report
of the educational authority and Ext.P12 the notice proposing
punishment finally Ext.P21 order of punishment issued in compliance
of the directions in Ext.P21. Since the disciplinary proceedings
culminated on the direction issued in Ext.P19, the petitioner is left with
a remedy to challenge the same under Rule 80 or Rule 92 of Chapter
XIV A KER. The petitioner has exercised this option under Rule 92 and
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
obtained an order. Now he turned around to challenge Ext.P21 under
Article 226.
13. These contentions were opposed by the learned Government
Pleader as well as the counsel for the 4th respondent. The petitioner
cannot traverse beyond Ext.P19. He can challenge the proprietress of
Ext.P21 in appeal or in revision by invoking Rule 80 or Rule 92 of
Chapter XIV A KER. That part is already invoked by the petitioner by
preferring Ext.P2 and obtained an order as per Ext.P1. However, no
challenge is raised against Ext.P1, but he is challenging Ext.P21 and
the proceedings prior to Exts.P18 and P19. That can't be permitted at
all.
14. From the above circumstances, it is clear that the petitioner
has availed the remedy available to him under the provisions of KER as
well as under the provision of the Constitution of India.
Capital
punishment was initially proposed by the manager, which was
interfered with by the educational authority and directed to reduce the
punishment. That part was originally upheld by the learned Single
Judge. However, the learned Division Bench though upheld the findings
of the learned Single Judge with respect to the quantum of punishment
but interfered with the direction to reinstate and payment of salary and
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
recovery of salary from the Manager. The Division Bench also directed
that the manager can impose any other penalties mentioned in Rule 65
Chapter XIV A KER.
Under the aforementioned circumstances, I do not find any
reason to grant the reliefs sought in the writ petition. Accordingly, the
Writ Petition fails and is dismissed.
Sd/-
P.M.MANOJ
JUDGE
ttb
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 26470/2012
PETITIONER’S EXHIBITS :
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 17.01.2012 OF THE
1ST RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE REVISION PETITION DATED
16.03.2009 FILED BEFORE THE GOVERNMENT.
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO DATED 10.01.1996 OF THE
4TH RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE EXPLANATION DATED 23.02.1996
SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER TO THE 4TH
RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 19.02.21996 OF
THE 3RD RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO OF CHARGES DATED
30.05.1996.
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE PETITIONER’S REPLY DATED
10.12.1996.
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 29.07.1997 OF THE
2ND RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 08.07.1998 OF THE
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS,
THRIRUVANANTHAPURAM.
Exhibit P11
TRUE COPY OF THE ENQUIRY REPORT DATED
15.10.1998 OF THE DISTRICT EDUCATIONAL
OFFICER, TIRUR.
Exhibit P12
TRUE COPY OF THE SHOW CAUSE MEMO DATED
10.11.1998 OF THE 4TH RESPONDENT.
2025:KER:27110
WP(C) No. 26470 of 2012
Exhibit P13
TRUE COPY OF THE EXPLANATION DATED 14.12.1998
SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER.
Exhibit P14
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 22.07.1999 IN
OP No.16375/1999.
Exhibit P15
TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS DATED 10.12.1999
OF THE 2ND RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P16
TRUE COPY OF THE GO(Rt) No.1405/2000/G.EDn.
DATED 06.04.2000 ISSUED BY THE GOVERNMENT.
Exhibit P17
TRUE COPY OF THE GO(Rt) No.848/2001/G.EDn.
DATED 02.03.2001.
Exhibit P18
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 08.04.2002 IN
OP No.1044/2001.
Exhibit P19
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMON JUDGMENT DATED
26.03.2003 IN WA No.1132/2002 AND WA
No.1140/2002.
Exhibit P20
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 09.04.2004 IN SLP
No.7384/2003 AND 7385/2003.
Exhibit P21
TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS DATED 31.12.2009
OF THE 4TH RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P22
TRUE COPY OF THE ENQUIRY REPORT DATED 15.10.1998 OF
THE DISTRICT EDUCATIONAL OFFICER, TIRUR, WHICH HAS
BEEN FORWARDED TO THE PETITIONER AS PER COVERING
LETTER DATED 06.11.1998 OF THE 4TH RESPONDENT.
//TURE COPY//
Sd/P.S. TO JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review