The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. ₹34,28,300/- In the result, both appeals preferred by Insurer and claimants are disposed of in the following terms: i) The claimants are granted revised compensation of ₹34,28,300/as just and fair, with interest @ 7.5% per annum thereon from the date of claim petition till realization; ii) Out of the revised compensation amount, 1st claimant - wife of the deceased is entitled for ₹18,28,300/- and claimants 2 to 5 are entitled for ₹4,00,000/- each. iii) The Insurer is directed to deposit the amount as aforesaid with interest and costs, adjusting the amount already deposited/paid, if any, before the Tribunal within one month. HCJ & CGR, J MACMA Nos.1897 of 2016 & 2930 of 2017 iv) On such deposit being made, the claimants are entitled to withdraw their respective shares as per the apportionment made above. There shall be no order as to costs. As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending in this case, if any, shall stand closed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
APHC010105122016
Bench Sr.No:-65
[3584]
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL
NOs: 1897 of 2016 & 2930 of 2017
ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Limited, ...Appellant
Vs.
Vangara Vasudha and Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
CORAM :THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 7th September 2026
Present:
Advocate for Appellant:
S PRANATHI, rep.by G.Jahnavi
Advocate for Respondent:
NIMMAGADDA REVATHI
COMMON JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
Both these appeals preferred under Section 173 of Motor
Vehicles Act since arise out of the very same award dated
22.03.2016 in M.V.O.P. No.290 of 2014 passed by learned
I Additional District Judge, Ongole, are heard together and
disposed by present common judgment.
2.
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.1897 of 2016 &
2930 of 2017
For convenience sake, the parties will hereinafter be referred
to as they were arrayed before the Tribunal.
3.
(a)
Insurer preferred M.A.C.M.A. No.1897 of 2016,
whereas claimants preferred M.A.C.M.A. No.2930 of 2017. The
deceased was engaged in aqua business. On 25.09.2015, while
he was returning to aqua tanks on his motorcycle, was hit from
behind by Tata Magic Auto (AP 27TV 1348) driven by its driver.
The deceased fell down and, due to injuries, succumbed. Police
registered Crime No.72 of 2013 against the driver of Tata Magic
Auto and later laid charge sheet for offence under Section 304-A of
IPC.
(b)
Wife and two minor children along with parents of deceased
preferred claim seeking compensation. 1st respondent, driver-cumowner of Tata Magic Auto, filed written statement denying that he
was negligent in driving the auto, that the deceased himself fell
down and sustained injuries, at any rate, as the auto was insured
with 2nd respondent and had subsisting policy, the claim against
him was not maintainable. The 2nd respondent – Insurer filed
written statement denying that the driver of auto caused the
accident due to rash and negligent driving, further that he did not
possess valid and effective driving licence and also that
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.1897 of 2016 &
2930 of 2017
non-impleadment of owner and insurer of motorcycle was fatal,
thus, the claim against it was not maintainable.
(c)
Based on the above pleadings, the Tribunal framed following
issues:
1. Whether the deceased Vangara Narayana died in a road
accident which took place on 25-09-2013 at 12-20 hours due
to rash and negligent driving of TATA ACE Magic Auto
bearing No. A.P. 27 TV 1348 by its driver?
2. Whether the driver of the TATA ACE Magic Auto bearing No.
AP 27TV 1348 is having valid and effective driving license at
the time of accident?
3. Whether the petition is bad for non-joinder of necessary
parties as prayed for?
4. Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation? If so,
to what amount and against whom?
5. To what relief the petitioners are entitled?
(d)
On behalf of claimants, PWs 1 to 3 were examined and
Exs.A1 to A31 were marked, whereas insurer examined RWs
1 to 4 and marked Exs.B1 to B6 and Exs.X1 to X3.
(e)
On overall appreciation of evidence on record, Tribunal
answered first issue in favour of claimants, holding that the
accident occurred on account of rash and negligent driving of the
auto by 1st respondent. The second issue was also answered in
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.1897 of 2016 &
2930 of 2017
negative, holding that the insurer failed to establish and prove that
the driver of auto did not possess valid and effective driving licence.
So also, the third issue was answered in negative. The Tribunal
assessed the income of deceased as ₹20,000/- per month,
considering his age as 44, applied multiplier of 14 and after
deducting 1/4th of the income towards personal and living
expenses, determined the loss of earnings. Tribunal also awarded
₹50,000/- towards loss of estate and ₹10,000/- towards funeral
expenses, thus, in total awarded ₹25,80,000/- along with interest
at the rate of 9% per annum.
(f)
Assailing the same, both insurer as well as claimants are in
appeal.
4.
Heard
Ms.G.Jahnavi,
learned
counsel,
representing
Mrs.S.Pranathi, learned counsel for Insurer and Mrs.Nimmagadda
Revathi, learned counsel for claimants.
5.
Learned counsel for insurer fairly submitted that liability of
insurer is not under challenge, rather, it is only the quantum of
compensation they are aggrieved with. It is contended that the
Tribunal assessed the income of deceased at the rate of ₹20,000/per month, which is without any basis and evidence on record,
rather, the Tribunal ought to have assessed the income at the rate
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.1897 of 2016 &
2930 of 2017
of ₹15,000/- per month, considering the minimum wages payable
to unskilled worker at relevant point of time. She further contended
that the Tribunal has awarded interest at the rate of 9%, which is
far excessive.
6.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the claimants
contended that though sufficient evidence has been produced
under Exs.A18 to A22 and A31 demonstrating that the deceased
actively engaged in aqua culture and earning about ₹10,00,000/per annum, the Tribunal merely assessed the income at the rate of
₹20,000/-, which is clearly unjustified and erroneous. She further
contended that the Tribunal has failed to award future prospects
and the amounts awarded under conventional heads were not in
consonance with the principles laid down by Hon’ble Apex Court in
National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi and
others1,
accordingly,
urged
to
determine
just
and
fair
compensation by allowing the appeal.
7.
We have considered the submissions of learned counsel and
perused the record.
8.
As there is no challenge to the aspect of liability, the only
question that arises for our consideration is whether the
1 (2017) 16 SCC 680
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.1897 of 2016 &
2930 of 2017
compensation determined by Tribunal is just, fair and reasonable
and if not, what would be appropriate compensation to be paid?
9.
It is the case of claimants that the deceased was engaged in
aquaculture and earning about ₹10,00,000/- per annum as on the
date of accident. To support the same, claimants examined PW3
and marked Exs.A17 to A26 and A31. Further, claimants also
marked Exs.A6 to A16, which are cash bills issued by M/s.Kalyani
Aqua Agencies. The Exhibits under A17 to A26 are essentially
licenses granted by Assistant Director, Fisheries Department, for
undertaking aquaculture activity in an extent of about 1.62 hectares
of land and the certificates issued by Coastal Aquaculture Authority
granting approval for the same. Exhibit A31 is the certificate issued
by Assistant Director, Fisheries, giving an estimate of income that
one would earn on account of cultivation of L-Vannamei Shrimp
per hectare.
10.
Learned counsel while taking this Court through aforesaid
evidence tried to persuade us that the evidence on record indicate
that the deceased had relevant licenses and permissions for
undertaking aquaculture activity and the certificate issued under
Ex.A31 would indicate the cultivation of L.Vannamei Shrimp would
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.1897 of 2016 &
2930 of 2017
earn at least ₹14,00,000/- per hectare, therefore, the income
assessed by Tribunal is meagre.
11.
We have gone through the Exhibits referred to above, as well
as evidence of PW3 and RW4 - partner of M/s.Kalyani Aqua
Agencies. RW4 denied that they issued Exs.A6 to A16. Insofar as
the licenses and permissions placed on record are concerned, the
same though indicate deceased was in the activity of aquaculture,
however, the same would not suggest the income he was earning.
The estimated income as certified under Ex.A31 cannot be relied
in coming to conclusion that the deceased was cultivating the same
variety of Shrimp with the same count as mentioned therein for
fetching similar profits. None of aforementioned evidence even
remotely mention the earnings of income of deceased.
12.
The Tribunal, on overall appreciation of evidence, assessed
the income of the deceased at the rate of ₹20,000/- per month.
Though learned counsel for insurer tried to contend that the income
ought to have been taken treating the deceased as skilled worker,
on the face of the evidence on record, we are of the view that the
approach of Tribunal is perfectly justified, thus, we sustain the
income of deceased at the rate of ₹20,000/- per month. There is
no quarrel about the age of deceased, multiplier and deduction
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.1897 of 2016 &
2930 of 2017
applied by the Tribunal. The claimants are entitled for future
prospects and the components under conventional heads also
required to be awarded in tune with the principles laid down in
Pranay Sethi’s case1. The interest awarded at the rate of 9% per
annum is on higher side, thus, we revised it to 7.5%.
13.
Accordingly, the compensation is revised in following terms.
Compensation
Heads
Amount Awarded
Monthly Income
₹20,000/-
Yearly Income
₹2,40,000/-
Future Prospects
(Age being 44 years)
Deduction (1/4)
Multiplier (14)
Loss of Income of
the deceased
Loss of Estate
Loss of Funeral
Expenses
Loss of Consortium
25% of ₹2,40,000/- =
₹60,000/₹3,00,000/- - ₹75,000/- =
₹2,25,000/₹2,25,000/- x 14 =
₹31,50,000/-
In accordance with
National Insurance Co.
Ltd v. Pranay Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC 680
Paras 37, 39, 41, 42 and
59.4
₹31,50,000/₹18,150/(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
₹18,150/(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
National Insurance Co.
Ltd v. Pranay Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC 680
Paras 37, 39, 41, 42 and
59.4
₹48,400/- x 5 = ₹2,42,000/(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
United Insurance
Co.Ltd. v. Satinder
Kaur
(2021) 11 SCC 780
Para 37.12
Rajwati alias Rajjo and
Ors v. United India
Insurance Company
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.1897 of 2016 &
2930 of 2017
Ltd. And Ors.
2022 SCC OnLine SC
Para 34
Sadhana Tomar & Ors.
Ashok Khushwaha &
Ors.
2025 SCC OnLine SC
Para 17
Total
14.
₹34,28,300/-
In the result, both appeals preferred by Insurer and claimants
are disposed of in the following terms:
i) The claimants are granted revised compensation of ₹34,28,300/as just and fair, with interest @ 7.5% per annum thereon from the
date of claim petition till realization;
ii) Out of the revised compensation amount, 1st claimant - wife of
the deceased is entitled for ₹18,28,300/- and claimants 2 to 5 are
entitled for ₹4,00,000/- each.
iii) The Insurer is directed to deposit the amount as aforesaid with
interest and costs, adjusting the amount already deposited/paid, if
any, before the Tribunal within one month.
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA Nos.1897 of 2016 &
2930 of 2017
iv) On such deposit being made, the claimants are entitled to
withdraw their respective shares as per the apportionment made
above. There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending in this case, if
any, shall stand closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
SS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review