Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC01084106
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3578]
TUESDAY, THE FIFTH DAY OF MAY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2932 OF 2018
Between:
Vamana Chitti Babu
...APELLANT
AND
The State of A.P. rep. by its Public Prosecutor and ...RESPODENT(S)
Others
Counsel for the Appellant:
Sri G VIJAYA SARADHI
Counsel for the Respondents(S):
ADDL. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
The Court made the following:
JUDGMENT : (per Hon’ble Sri Justice K. Suresh Reddy)
Sole accused in Sessions Case No.12 of 2018 on the file of the
Court of III Additional District and Sessions Judge, Srikakulam, is the
appellant in the present Criminal Appeal. He was tried by the learned
Additional Sessions Judge under two charges. First charge was under
Section 302 IPC and the second charge was under Section 498-A IPC.
2.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl.Appeal No.2932 of 2016
Gravamen of the charge is that prior to 16th July, 2016 the
accused used to harass his wife Vamana Kalavathi (hereinafter
referred to as “deceased”) and subjected her to cruelty by suspecting
her fidelity and on 16.07.2016 at about 10.30 A.M., the accused
poured kerosene on the deceased and set fire to her, at his house
situated at Buridi Kancharam Village, and while undergoing treatment,
the deceased succumbed to injuries on the same day at about 17.15
hours, thereby committed offences punishable under Sections 302 and
498-A IPC.
3.
After completion of trial, learned III Additional District and
Sessions Judge, Srikakulam, convicted the appellant for the offence
punishable under Section 302 IPC and sentenced him to suffer
imprisonment for LIFE and also to pay fine of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees
Ten Thousand only), in default, to suffer simple imprisonment for a
period of six months. The learned III Additional District and Sessions
Judge also convicted the appellant for the offence punishable under
Section 498-A IPC and sentenced him to suffer rigorous imprisonment
for a period of three years and also to pay fine of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees
Five Thousand only), in default, to suffer simple imprisonment for a
period of six months. Both the substantive sentences were directed to
run concurrently.
4.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl.Appeal No.2932 of 2016
Case of the prosecution, as per the allegations made in the
charge-sheet, briefly, is as follows.
a) The accused as well as the material prosecution witnesses
are residents of Buridi Kancharam Village, Ponduru Mandal,
Srikakulam District.
The deceased was also resident of the same
village and she is none other than wife of the accused.
Marriage
between accused and deceased was performed about two years prior
to the date of incident and they were blessed with a daughter. PW.1 is
the father; PW.2 is the mother; PW.3 is the sister and PW.4, PW.11,
PW.12 and PW.13 are relatives of the deceased, respectively. After
birth of the female child, the accused started harassing the deceased
both physically and mentally, suspecting her fidelity. He used to beat
the deceased with his hands and legs. She informed the harassment
of the deceased to her parents, PW.1 and PW.2.
(b) Whileso, at about 10.30 A.M. on 16.07.2016, as usual, the
accused picked up a quarrel with the deceased, then the deceased
poured kerosene on herself with an intention to commit suicide. When
she was trying to light a matchstick, the accused snatched the
matchbox from her and set fire to her. On hearing her cries,
neighbours – PW.6, PW.7 and PW.9 came there. Having received the
information, PW.1 and PW.2 also came to the house of the accused.
Immediately, the injured was shifted to Hospital. On the same day at
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl.Appeal No.2932 of 2016
about 9.00 P.M., PW.1 went to the Police Station and gave a report.
PW.19 A.S.I., Ponduru Police Station received Ex.P10 Report from
PW.1 and registered a case in Crime No.56 of 2016 under Sections
498-A and 306 IPC. He issued copies of F.I.R. to all the concerned.
Ex.P23 is the FIR.
(c) In the meanwhile, at about 1.00 P.M. on 16.07.2016, PW.16
Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Special Mobile Court, Srikakulam,
having received the intimation from Hospital, went and recorded the
statement – Ex.P18 from the injured. The same is treated as a dying
declaration.
(d) On 17.07.2016, PW.19 A.S.I. sent a requisition to the
Tahsildar, Ponduru, to depute two V.R.Os. for conducting inquest over
the dead body. Accordingly, PW.15 held inquest over the dead body
in the presence of PW.14 and others at RIMS Hospital, Srikakulam.
Inquest report is marked as Ex.P16. He also prepared a rough sketch
Ex.P24 at the scene of offence.
He also prepared an observation
report Ex.P15 at the scene of offence. He also took the photographs
of the scene of offence marked as Exs.P25 and P26. He seized MO.1
plastic can at the scene of offence. On the same day, he recorded
statements of PW.1 to PW.10.
While undergoing treatment, the
deceased succumbed to injuries on the same day at about 17.15
hours.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl.Appeal No.2932 of 2016
(e) After completion of inquest, PW.15 sent the dead body for
post-mortem examination. PW.17 Assistant Professor, RIMS Hospital,
Srikakulam, conducted autopsy over the dead body. He opined the
cause of death was due to shock as a result of 90% burns. He issued
Ex.P19 post mortem report.
(f) Whileso, at about 3.00 P.M. on 16.08.2016, S.I. of Police,
Ponduru Police Station, received copy of dying declaration from the
Court of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Special Mobile Court,
Srikakulam. On the basis of the said dying declaration, he altered
Section of Law from Sections 498-A and 306 IPC to Sections 302 and
498-A IPC. Ex.P27 is the altered memo.
He issued copies of the
altered F.I.R. to all the concerned.
(g) Further investigation was taken over by PW.21 Inspector of
Police, J.R. Puram. Immediately, PW.21 proceeded with investigation.
He verified the statements of PW.1 to PW.10 recorded by PW.19. He
also recorded statements of PW.11 to PW.13. On 07.08.2016, he sent
the material objects to F.S.L., Hyderabad.
(h) On 08.08.2016, PW.21 arrested the accused at his residence
and was remanded to judicial custody.
After receiving all the
documents and after completion of investigation, PW.21 filed chargesheet.
5.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl.Appeal No.2932 of 2016
In support of its case, the prosecution examined PW.1 to PW.21,
marked Exs.P1 to P39 and exhibited MO.1.
6.
When the accused was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C., he
denied the incriminating evidence appearing against him.
7.
Accepting the dying declaration-Ex.P18, the learned Additional
District and Sessions Judge convicted the accused as aforesaid, vide
impugned judgment, dated 14.09.2018. Aggrieved by the said
judgment, the present Criminal Appeal has been preferred.
8.
Heard Sri G.Vijaya Saradhi, learned counsel for the appellant/
accused, and Sri Marri Venkata Ramana, learned Additional Public
Prosecutor, representing the respondent/State.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellant/accused strenuously contends
that no reliance can be placed on dying declaration-Ex.P18 recorded
by PW.16, judicial officer. He further contends that all the material
prosecution witnesses, including parents of deceased, did not support
the prosecution and they were declared as hostile. Except the socalled dying declaration-Ex.P18, there is no other evidence available
on record. He further contends that even in Ex.P18 dying declaration,
the deceased has stated that there was a quarrel between the
accused and the deceased on the fateful day at about 10.00 A.M. It is
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl.Appeal No.2932 of 2016
further stated in the dying declaration that as she intended to commit
suicide, she herself poured kerosene on her body. It is further stated
in the dying declaration that, at that juncture, the accused set fire to
the deceased.
Coming to the ocular version of parents of the
deceased, they have stated before the Investigating Officer, that the
deceased committed suicide, unable to bear the harassment at the
hands of the accused. Investigating Officer – PW.21 also in his crossexamination admitted as follows: “It is true that all the witnesses stated
that the accused came there later and he accompanied his wife along
with parents of his wife in 108 Ambulance to the hospital”. As such,
the earliest version of all the prosecution witnesses before the
Investigating Officer was that the deceased poured kerosene on
herself and set fire to herself. Even in the inquest report – Ex.P16, at
Col.No.15, the mediators opined that the deceased poured kerosene
on herself and tried to commit suicide. As such, he requests this Court
to allow the appeal by setting aside the conviction and sentences
recorded by the learned trial Judge.
10.
On the other hand, learned Additional Public Prosecutor
opposed the appeal, contending that dying declaration-Ex.P18, which
was recorded by PW.16, Judicial Officer, can be relied on, and there is
nothing to discard Ex.P18. As such, he requests this Court to dismiss
the appeal by confirming the impugned judgment.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl.Appeal No.2932 of 2016
11.
We have perused the entire material on record. Admittedly, all
the material witnesses did not support the prosecution version and
they were declared as hostile. The only evidence available on record
is the so-called dying declaration-Ex.P18, recoded by PW.16.
In
Ex.P18, the deceased has stated that she intended to commit suicide
and, with that intention, she poured kerosene on herself. Later, the
accused set fire to her. Except these three lines, she did not state
anything.
Of course, she stated that it was preceded by a small
quarrel between both of them.
But, parents and sister of the
deceased, who were examined as PW.1 to PW.3, did not support the
case of the prosecution. In their earliest version before the
Investigating Officer, they have stated that the deceased committed
suicide, unable to bear the harassment at the hands of the accused.
As such, initially, the case of prosecution was a case of suicide. But,
in the dying declaration, the deceased has given a divergent version
stating that with an intention to commit suicide, she poured kerosene
on herself, then the accused set her ablaze.
As such, dying
declaration – Ex.P18 does not inspire confidence of this Court.
Further, there is no corroboration from any independent witness, at
least from the parents of the deceased, to the so-called dying
declaration-Ex.P18.
KSR, J. & CGR, J.
Crl.Appeal No.2932 of 2016
12.
Having analysed the uncorroborated dying declaration-Ex.P18
carefully, we have no hesitation to come to the conclusion that it does
not inspire confidence of this Court.
As such, the conviction and
sentence recorded by the learned III Additional District and Sessions
Judge, Srikakulam, needs to be interfered with.
13.
In the result, the Criminal Appeal is allowed. The conviction and
sentence recorded by the learned III Additional District and Sessions
Judge, Srikakulam, in Sessions Case No.12 of 2018, dated
14.09.2018, are hereby set aside and the accused is acquitted for the
offences punishable under Sections 302 and 498-A IPC.
The fine
amount, if any, paid by the accused shall be refunded to him. As the
appellant is enlarged on bail by order, dated 29.04.2024, vide I.A.No.1
of 2023, his bail bonds shall stand cancelled.
As a sequel thereto, the miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending
in this Criminal Appeal shall stand closed.
___________________
K. SURESH REDDY, J.
_______________________
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J.
Date: 05th May, 2026.
cs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review