Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.13
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.131/2021
Date of Order: 13.04.2022
Smti. Valencia Syiemlieh
Coram:
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & anr
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv with
Mr. D.K. Warjri, Adv
Mr. R.S. Malngiang, Adv
For the Respondents
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. S. Sen, Sr.GA
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The petitioner is a Grade-III employee and is working as a
Receptionist in the Meghalaya Legislative Assembly Secretariat. The
grievance in the petition is that a change in the applicable Rules
pertaining to promotion from what was provided under the original
Rules of 2011 has resulted in serious prejudice to the petitioner and
robbed the petitioner of the monetary benefits that the petitioner would
have gained upon the promotion that she could have obtained in terms of
the Rules of 2011.
2.
It is the petitioner’s case that at the time that she joined the
service, there were no Rules in place providing for promotion or
indicating which of the posts would be filled up by direct recruitment
and which others only by promotion or by a combination of promotion
and direct recruitment. The petitioner says that upon the Meghalaya
Legislative Assembly Secretariat (Recruitment and Conditions of
Service) Rules, 2011 coming into effect, the cadre of Lower Division
Assistant (LDA) in the Assembly Secretariat was to be filled up to the
extent of 20 per cent by promotion and the remaining 80 per cent by
direct recruitment. As to the provision for promotion, the said Rules of
2011 provided as follows:
“From amongst the Receptionist/Intercom Operators/Typist
and other eligible employees of the Meghalaya Legislative
Assembly Secretariat with 3 years experiences (sic) in any of
those grades and possessing Higher Secondary School Leaving
Certificate qualification.”
3.
The Rules of 2011 came to be completely replaced by the
Meghalaya
Legislative
Assembly
Secretariat
(Recruitment
and
Conditions of Service) Rules, 2015 published on or about May 4, 2016.
4.
Under the 2015 Rules, 20 per cent of the persons inducted as
LDA would be by way of promotion from various streams and the
remaining 80 per cent would also be by way of promotion but only from
among the Typists as per the seniority list.
5.
The first grievance of the petitioner is that when Typists were
included as a part of the members from various streams at the Grade-III
level who would be entitled to be considered for promotion to be
appointed as LDA, the 2015 Rules did away with LDA being an entrylevel post to the extent of 80 per cent and 80 per cent of LDA posts were
kept reserved from promotees from among Typists. The petitioner
claims that this change in the Rules was arbitrary as the petitioner as a
Receptionist was earlier required to be treated at par with the Typists and
Stenographers to be eligible for consideration for promotion to LDA, but
Typists were more favoured under the changed Rules of 2015.
6.
The bogey raised by the petitioner pertaining to the 2015 Rules
need not be addressed at all. It is the admitted position that the Rules of
2020 have now been introduced and, under such Rules, only existing
employees would get entry at LDA level by promotion and, if the
promotees do not fill up the vacancies, the remaining vacancies would
be filled up by departmental competition from among the Grade-III staff,
subject to the candidates possessing a degree with computer knowledge
and at least three years’ experience at the Grade-III level. Such Rules of
2020 have been challenged in the present proceedings as being arbitrary,
whimsical and prejudicial to the interest of the petitioner since the
petitioner was earlier assured of the promotion and monetary benefits,
subject to meeting certain criteria.
7.
As to the challenge to the 2015 Rules, there does not appear to
be any merit therein, particularly since 20 per cent of the posts at the
LDA level, even under the 2015 Rules, had been kept for promotees
from among the Typists, Receptionists, Computer Operators and other
eligible personnel in Grade-III. It is true that 80 per cent of the posts
were reserved under the 2015 Rules for promotion from among the
Typists, but what is of paramount importance is that the petitioner’s right
was not prejudiced since the petitioner and others of her ilk were still
entitled to be considered for promotion for filling up the 20 per cent of
the vacancies at the LDA level. More importantly, it is the prerogative of
the employer to decide what kind of employees such employer would
want at a particular level. However, if there are existing Rules that
provide for the career progression to persons at a lower level by way of
promotion, the avenues for promotion cannot be taken away by the
employer.
8.
By the 2015 Rules, the petitioner’s position remained
unaffected, though Typists stood much better as a class as they were to
make up 80 per cent of the LDA posts upon promotion. To the extent
that the petitioner’s challenge to the 2015 Rules may be seen as
preferring a class of employees over another, the same would not be
justiciable and it would fall within the prerogative domain of the
employer. However, if the petitioner’s position had been prejudiced to
her detriment, in the sense that her promotional avenues were curtailed,
that may have excited the Court. Since 20 per cent of the LDA posts
were kept for promotees from among the various categories to which the
petitioner belonged, the fact that another class of employees had been
given a better chance to be promoted cannot be a good ground for
challenging the change in the Rules.
9.
The 2020 Rules are, however, completely different. The
petitioner and other persons in Grade-III no longer stand a chance to be
promoted to the post of LDA except in an extraordinary situation when a
vacancy is not filled up by the primary method indicated in the 2020
Rules and a departmental competition is resorted to. Also, it must not be
missed that the 2020 Rules have a further educational qualification that
was not there in the previous sets of Rules. Thus, under the 2020 Rules,
even if the petitioner otherwise has a chance to be promoted to LDA in
any examination, if she does not possess the requisite educational
qualification, the petitioner would not be considered for promotion.
10.
Prima facie, these are good grounds for challenging the 2020
Rules. However, the employer has indicated in the affidavit filed in the
present proceedings that in lieu of the lack of promotional avenues for
employees like the petitioner, an assured career progression scheme has
been introduced and the petitioner will be entitled to the benefits
thereunder.
11.
While an employee under a State or in a body answering to the
description of “authority” in Article 12 of the Constitution can claim a
right to be considered for promotion if the relevant post envisages
promotion, such right is directly linked to the additional monetary or like
benefits that the concerned employee may be entitled to upon promotion.
If, instead of promoting the employee, the monetary and other benefits
due to such employee upon promotion are made available by a scheme
introduced for such purpose, the concerned employee should have no
further grievance.
12.
The principle must be understood. Just as a public employee
has merely a right to be considered for promotion and no veritable right
to be promoted, similarly, such right can be traced to the additional
benefits that the promoted post would bring to the employee. Just as it is
possible for a person who has been promoted to not be required to
discharge the duties of the promoted post on the choice of the employer,
as long as the benefits and perquisites pertaining to the promotional post
are made available to the employee, the employee can have no grievance
in such regard.
13.
Thus, upon the career progression scheme being put in place
by the employer in this case, the possibility of an employee in the
position of the petitioner herein to be promoted after a certain number of
years has to be taken into consideration for the purpose of indicating the
quantum of benefits, whether monetised or not, that the concerned
employee would be getting in lieu of the probable promotion upon the
promotional avenues being abolished. In other words, if an employee
was likely to be promoted to a superior post at the end of a fixed tenure
and the post is abolished or the promotional avenues are taken away
prior thereto, the career progression scheme introduced for such
employee must be such as would confer the same monetary benefits and
perquisites that such employee may have obtained upon the employee
being promoted after the given number of years. To an extent, the 2020
Rules may not be justified, but upon the career progression scheme as
indicated in the employer’s affidavit being introduced to ensure that the
same monetary benefits and perquisites are also available to an
employee in the position of the petitioner, in lieu of the chance to be
promoted, the grievance of the petitioner appears to have been
addressed.
14.
Accordingly, WP (C) No.131 of 2021 is disposed of by
observing that it will be open to the petitioner to approach this Court
again in the event that under the career progression scheme which now
covers the petitioner, the petitioner earns less than what the petitioner
would have earned or such scheme gives the petitioner less than the
perquisites that the petitioner would have obtained if the petitioner had
been considered for promotion or promoted in terms of the Rules as they
stood prior to the Rules of 2020 taking effect. In the event the career
progression scheme referred to by the State is less beneficial in terms of
money and perquisites than what the petitioner would have got upon
promotion under the earlier Rules, it will be open to the petitioner to
challenge the scheme.
15.
Since the prejudice likely to be suffered by the petitioner upon
the petitioner’s promotional avenues being taken away has been
addressed in monetary terms upon the career progression scheme being
introduced, as long as such scheme results in the petitioner getting the
same benefits after a given number of years that the petitioner may have
got if the petitioner had been promoted, the Rules of 2020 do not call for
any interference.
16.
There will, however, be no order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
13.04.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review