Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No: OWP No. 282/2019
CM No. 2664/2023
CM No. 1398/2019 [1/2019]
Reserved on : 10.09.2026
Pronounced on : 18.09.2026
Uploaded on:18 .09.2026
Vakil Singh, aged 65 years S/O Shri
Kamal Singh R/O Village Ladhyala,
Tehsil and District Udhampur.
…Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. R.P.Sharma, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Shazia Khanam, Advocate
Vs.
1. State of J&K through Commissioner
Secretary, Revenue Department,
Jammu.
2. Financial Commissioner (Revenue),
Jammu.
3. Deputy Commissioner, Udhampur.
4. Uttam Singh S/O Sh. Chett Ram
5. Shakti Singh, S/O Sh. Badri Nath,
6. Romel Singh, S/O Sh. Sunit Singh,
7. Chain Singh S/O Sh. Sunit Singh
8. Hans Raj S/O Sh. Hari Chand
All residents of Village Ladhyala,
Tehsil and District Udhampur.
Through:
…. Respondent(s)
Ms. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
Mr. I.H.Bhat, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioner, through the medium of the present petition, has
challenged order dated 06.02.2019 passed by the learned Financial
Commissioner (R), Jammu, whereby the Revision Petition filed by the
OWP No.282/2019
petitioner against judgment and order dated 06.12.2017 passed by the
Divisional Commissioner, Jammu, has been dismissed.
2. As per the case of the petitioner, respondents 4 to 8 (hereinafter
referred to as “private respondents”) filed a suit under Section 32 of
the Land Revenue Act against the petitioner before the Court of
Deputy Commissioner (Collector), Jammu. In the said suit, the private
respondents sought a direction for correction of the Record of Rights
appearing in the Settlement (Misal Haqiat) prepared in the year 20102011 in respect of village Ladhyala, Patti Chakla, Tehsil and District
Udhampur, with respect to the land comprising in Khasra No. 300
situated in Village Saley. Vide order dated 30.06.2017, the said suit
was decided by the Collector, Udhampur in favour of the private
respondents, and it was ordered that the land measuring 10 Kanal 11
Marlas under new Khasra No. 300, corresponding to old Khasra No.
2639, be recorded in the Record of Rights for the year 2010-2011,
Tarf Saley, and land measuring 14 Kanals 11 Marlas under new
Khasra No. 300 be entered against old Khasra No. 2655, Tarf Ladala.
Besides this, the action of the Tehsildar, Udhampur, omitting the
recorded entry of the petitioner in Rabi 2012 from new Khasra No.
300, corresponding to old Khasra No. 2639, has been confirmed.
3. The aforesaid order of the Collector, Udhampur, was challenged in
appeal by the petitioner before the Divisional Commissioner, Jammu,
who, vide order dated 06.12.2017, dismissed the said appeal and
upheld the order of the Collector.
4. The aforesaid order passed by the Divisional Commissioner, Jammu,
came to be challenged by the petitioner by way of a Revision Petition
OWP No.282/2019
before the Financial Commissioner (R), Jammu, who, vide the
impugned order, proceeded to dismiss the Revision Petition.
5. It is case of the petitioner that his father, Kamal Singh, and his
ancestors were big landlords. It has been submitted that after the
advent of the J&K Big Landed Estates Abolition Act, the owners were
given an opportunity to make an application for selection of their
lands, as per their choice, up to 182 Kanals of land which they wanted
to retain. In the case of the father of the petitioner, the Special
Tehsildar, without obtaining his choice, made selection of the land.
The order of the Tehsildar, made on 20th Phagun 2008, was
challenged by way of a Revision Petition before the Financial
Commissioner, Jammu, and vide order dated 01.02.1962, the order of
the Special Tehsildar was set aside and the Tehsildar was directed to
obtain claims from the landlords and attest fresh mutations in terms of
Section 4 of the J&K Big Landed Estates Abolition Act.
6. It has been submitted that the Additional Tehsildar, Udhampur, passed
a fresh order on 24.05.1978, and the fresh claim of the father of the
petitioner was accepted, as a consequence whereof, the land under
Survey No. 2639 min, measuring 25 Kanals 19 Marlas, in Village
Malahar, was selected by the father of the petitioner. It has been
submitted that the father of the petitioner continued to be in
possession of the land comprised in Survey Nos. 2655 and 2639 in his
capacity as one of the owners of the land falling in Village Ladhyala,
of which Shamilat was identified, recorded and measured to the extent
of 193 Kanals 05 Marlas in Survey No. 2639, as also for Khasra No.
OWP No.282/2019
2639. It has been submitted that the petitioner had a vested right of a
paritable share in the Shamilat land.
7. After preparation of the new Misal Haqiat of Village Ladhyala for the
year 2010-2011, Shamilat land of 2639 min was recorded in
possession of the petitioner as a sharer to the extent of 24 Kanals 15
Marlas after recording separate Survey No. 300 new out of old Survey
No. 2639 min. Other parcels of land out of 2639 min were recorded as
new S. Nos. 299 (17 Kanals 4 Marlas), 391 (82 Kanals 12 Marlas),
399 (8 Marlas) and 407 (6 Marlas) to the extent of 368 Kanals and 15
Marlas.
8. It has been submitted that in the suit filed by the private respondents
under Section 32 of the Land Revenue Act before the Collector, the
impugned order dated 30.06.2017 came to be passed without
affording an opportunity of being heard to the petitioner and without
affording him an opportunity to file a written statement/documents in
support of his claim, nor was he afforded an opportunity to produce
evidence. Thus, according to the petitioner, the Collector, Udhampur,
has made a fundamental error while passing the order against the
petitioner, omitting his name from the revenue record. It has been
contended that the Collector has exercised its jurisdiction contrary to
law and in an arbitrary and mala fide manner. It has been submitted
that the Collector has relied upon the report of the Tehsildar,
Udhampur, against which the petitioner had filed objections, and
without considering the said objections, the report of the Tehsildar has
been relied upon by the Collector while passing order dated
30.06.2017, as a consequence whereof the name of the petitioner
OWP No.282/2019
recorded in the cultivation column was omitted in contravention of the
Record of Rights for the year 2010-2011.
9. It has been submitted that even the appellate authority and revisional
authority have not dealt with the contention of the petitioner that the
Collector did not adhere to the procedure prescribed under the Land
Revenue Act while passing order dated 30.06.2017.
10.The private respondents, in their reply to the writ petition, have
submitted that the finding of the Collector is based on the record and
physical possession on the spot. It has been contended that the
contentions raised by the petitioner have been dealt with by the
Divisional Commissioner, Jammu, as well as by the Financial
Commissioner (R), Jammu, and that there is nothing illegal about the
orders passed by the authorities below.
11.The official respondents have filed their reply to the writ petition, in
which they have defended the orders passed by the authorities below.
It has been submitted that the petitioner was given a proper
opportunity of being heard in defending his case, which is evident
from the record of the Collector.
12.I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. I
have also perused the record of the Collector relating to Suit filed by
the private respondents under Section 32 of the Land Revenue Act.
13.It appears from the record that the private respondents filed a suit
under Section 32 of the Land Revenue Act before the Collector,
Udhampur, seeking correction of the revenue record of rights after the
settlement proceedings in respect of Khasra No. 300 (new) (old
Khasra No. 2639) situated at Village Saley. In the said suit, it was
OWP No.282/2019
pleaded by the private respondents that they are owners in possession
of the land under Khasra No. 2655, measuring 24 Kanals 15 Marlas,
situated at Village Ladyala, and the said land is Shamilat Deh. It was
also pleaded that, as per the old record, the land under Khasra No.
2639 (old) and Khasra No. 300 (new), situated in Village Salay, is
falling on the other side of the nallah, which is about one kilometer
away from Village Ladyala, where the land under Khasra No. 2655 is
located. It was alleged that the whole record had been manipulated
intentionally at the instance of the petitioner herein, thereby shifting
the situation of the land under Khasra No. 2639 (old) and Khasra No.
300 (new) from Village Salay to Village Ladhyala in Khasra No. 2655
in the revenue papers. Thus, the private respondents sought a decree
for correction of the revenue record regarding Khasra No. 2639 (old)
and Khasra No. 300 (new), along with Titma Shajara, to the extent
that land under Khasra No. 300 is not situated in Village Ladhyala
under Khasra No. 2655, but the same is situated in Village Salay,
which is on the other side of the nallah.
14.It appears that the petitioner put in an appearance before the Court of
the Collector, Udhampur, through his counsel and, during the
pendency of the suit, the Tehsildar, Udhampur, submitted his report
before the Collector, who, on the basis of the said report, proceeded to
pass order dated 30.06.2017, decreeing the suit of the private
respondents and directing correction of the revenue record, including
omission of the entry of the petitioner from new Khasra No. 300,
which corresponds to old Khasra No. 2639. The record would show
that even though the petitioner had appeared before the Collector, he
OWP No.282/2019
has not filed any written statement before the Collector. A perusal of
the minutes of the proceedings would reveal that he had not been
called upon to file a written statement by the Collector. The record
further reveals that the petitioner had made an application before the
Collector on 19.06.2017, praying therein that the proper procedure
under the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure be adopted while
dealing with the case. It was stated in the application that neither any
issue had been framed in the suit nor the statements of the parties have
been recorded and that the petitioner had not been given an
opportunity to lead evidence. Although, in the said application, the
petitioner had stated that he had filed written statement and objections
yet, the same are not available on the record, nor is there any interim
order on the file that would go on to show that the petitioner had in
fact filed any objections to the suit filed by the private respondents.
The minutes of the proceedings further reveal that none of the parties,
which include the petitioner, was given any opportunity of producing
documents or leading evidence.
15.Learned counsels for the respondents have vehemently argued that the
provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure are not strictly applicable to
the proceedings in a suit filed before a Collector under Section 32 of
the Land Revenue Act and only the principles of natural justice and
the procedure prescribed under the Land Revenue Act and the rules
framed thereunder are to be followed, which, in the instant case, have
been followed by the Collector.
16.There is no quarrel with the proposition of law that all the provisions
of the Code of Civil Procedure are not applicable to proceedings
OWP No.282/2019
before the Revenue Officers deciding matters under the Land Revenue
Act. However, the provisions of the Land Revenue Act and the Rules
framed thereunder constitute a complete code in themselves, and
Revenue Officers, while dealing with cases before them, are to follow
the procedure prescribed under the Land Revenue Act and the rules
framed thereunder. A Collector, while exercising his jurisdiction
under Section 32 of the Land Revenue Act, is acting as a quasijudicial authority and is vested with power to decide valuable rights of
the parties. Therefore, it is incumbent upon the Collector to adhere to
the principles of natural justice, which would include allowing the
parties to file documents in support of their respective claims, produce
witnesses in support of their respective cases and also to file pleadings
projecting their respective claims.
17.Section 15-A of the Land Revenue Act gives power to a Revenue
Officer to summon persons and to record their statements. Rule 21 of
the Land Revenue Rules provides for the procedure of the Revenue
Officers. As per this provision, the statements and pleadings made by
the parties have to be recorded in a concise narrative of the facts, and
the written application or statement filed by the parties in the revenue
proceedings has to be drawn up and verified in the manner provided
by the Code of Civil Procedure for written statements in suits. Rule 26
of the Rules provides that in proceedings before a Revenue Officer, he
shall make with his own hand a brief memorandum of the statements
of the parties and the witnesses at the time when each statement is
made, whereas Rule 27 provides that when an order is made by the
Revenue Officer on the merits of an inquiry, he shall record a brief
OWP No.282/2019
statement of the reasons on which it is founded. From statutory
framework it is clear that the rules of natural justice, including
providing a proper opportunity to the parties to produce documents
and evidence in respect of their respective claims, have to be read into
the proceedings in a suit under Section 32 of the Land Revenue Act,
as the determination of a suit under the said provision affects valuable
rights to property of the parties.
18.This Court, in the case of Ahali Manhassan v. Financial
Commissioner and others, OWP No. 201/2007, decided on
20.11.2008, has, after analyzing the provisions contained in Sections
26 and 32 of the Land Revenue Act, held that a suit under Section 32
has to be decided after hearing the parties concerned and affording
them the requisite opportunity to substantiate their respective claims
regarding the entries on the basis of such material as they may opt to
rely upon in support of their respective claims.
19.Turning to the facts of the present case, a perusal of the record of the
Collector would show that the petitioner was never called upon to file
his written statement and objections to the suit. He was not called
upon to produce documents in support of his claim, nor was he called
upon to lead evidence in support of his claim. In spite of the petitioner
having made an application before the Collector, bringing to his
notice that an opportunity to lead evidence may be afforded to him, no
such opportunity was granted by the Collector to the petitioner.
Instead of doing so, the Collector proceeded to rely upon the report of
the Tehsildar, Udhampur, against which the petitioner had filed his
objections, alleging that the said report is mala fide and result of
OWP No.282/2019
corruption. The objections of the petitioner against the report of the
Tehsildar were not dealt with by the Collector while passing the order
dated 30.06.2017. Thus, the Collector, Udhampur, has violated both
the provisions contained in the Land Revenue Act and the Rules
framed thereunder, as also the principles of natural justice, and
proceeded to decide the suit of the private respondents merely on the
basis of the allegations made in the plaint and the report of the
Tehsildar. Despite bringing this lacuna in the proceedings before the
Collector to the notice of the appellate and revisional authorities, the
petitioner’s grievance was not adverted to by the said authorities, who
proceeded to dismiss his Appeal and the Revision Petition without
dealing with this aspect of the matter.
20.For the foregoing reasons the writ petition is allowed. The impugned
order dated 30.06.2017 passed by the Deputy Commissioner
(Collector), Udhampur, order dated 06.12.2017 passed by the
Divisional Commissioner, Jammu and order dated 06.02.2019 passed
by the Financial Commissioner (R), Jammu are set aside. The matter
is remanded to the Collector, Udhampur for its fresh decision after
affording the petitioner an opportunity of filing the reply to the suit
filed by the private respondents and after providing an opportunity to
the parties to produce evidence and documents in support of their
respective claims. The suit shall be disposed of by the Collector as
expeditiously as possible preferable within a period of six months
from the date a copy of this order is made available to the said
authority.
OWP No.282/2019
21.The record of the Collector be returned to Ms. Kohli, learned Sr.AAG
appearing on behalf of official respondents.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
Jammu
18.09.2026
Madan Verma-Secy
Whether order is speaking?
Whether order is reportable?
MADAN LAL VERMA
2026.09.18 16:37
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
OWP No.282/2019
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review