Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
APHC010752282018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3397]
FRIDAY,THE SECOND DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VENUTHURUMALLI GOPALA
KRISHNA RAO
SECOND APPEAL NO: 1582/2018
Between:
...APPELLANT
Vaddi Satishbabu
AND
B Yasodamma Died and Others
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. P RAMA SHARANA SHARMA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. P RAJASEKHAR
The Court made the following:
...RESPONDENT(S)
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE V. GOPALA KRISHNA RAO
SECOND APPEAL No.1582 of 2018
JUDGMENT:
This second appeal is filed aggrieved against the Judgment and decree
dated 20-08-2018 in A.S.No.20 of 2013 on the file of the Judge, Family Courtcum-III Additional District Judge at Srikakulam, confirming the Judgment and
decree dated 04.02.2013 in O.S.No.56 of 2006 on the file of the Principal
Junior Civil Judge at Srikakulam.
2.
The appellant herein is the defendant and the respondent herein is the
plaintiff in O.S.No.56 of 2006 on the file of the Principal Junior Civil Judge at
Srikakulam. The sole-respondent died during the pendency of the first appeal
before the First Appellate Court and her son was brought on record as the
respondent No.2 in the first appeal proceedings.
3.
The plaintiff initiated action in O.S.No.56 of 2006 on the file of the
Principal Junior Civil Judge at Srikakulam, with a prayer for eviction of the
defendant from the plaint schedule property as a trespasser as lease period
was over on 21.08.2005 and also to pay Rs.2,600/- per month towards
damages from September, 2005 for unauthorized occupation and for costs of
the suit.
4.
The learned Principal Junior Civil Judge at Srikakulam, decreed the suit
with costs directing the defendant to vacate the plaint schedule property within
3 months from the date of decree and deliver vacant possession to the plaintiff
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
and also directed to pay damages for use and occupation at the rate of
Rs.2,600/- per month from September, 2005 till the property is deliver to the
plaintiff. Felt aggrieved of the same, the unsuccessful defendant in the above
said suit filed the aforesaid appeal before the first appellate Court. The
learned Judge, Family Court-cum-III Additional District Judge at Srikakulam,
dismissed the first appeal by confirming the judgment and decree passed by
the trial Court. Aggrieved thereby, the unsuccessful defendant/appellant
approached this Court by way of second appeal.
5.
For the sake of convenience, both parties in the second appeal will be
referred to as they are arrayed in the original suit.
6.
The case of the plaintiff, in brief, as set out in the plaint averments in
O.S.No.56 of 2006, is as follows:
The plaintiff is the owner of the plaint schedule property and the
defendant took the plaint schedule property under lease for his business
purpose to run a photo studio under the name and style of ‘Satish Photo
Studio’ for rent from the plaintiff. Thereafter, the defendant executed a rent
deed agreeing to pay the rent of Rs.2,000/- per month on 10.09.2003, for the
period of two years and the said lease period was over on 31.08.2005. The
plaintiff further pleaded that after expiry of the lease period, a fresh lease
would be executed, taken for further two years on the enhancement of the rent
by 30% per hundred per year in the present rent of Rs.2,000/-. However, the
defendant did not come forward to execute the fresh lease deed after expiry of
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
the lease period i.e. on 31.08.2005, nor the defendant handed over the
possession of the plaint schedule property to the plaintiff and the defendant
became trespasser, who is in unlawful possession of the property from
01.09.2005.
While so, the plaintiff gave a registered legal notice to the defendant on
27.10.2005, through her advocate to vacate the plaint schedule property. The
defendant received the same and gave a reply through his counsel on
09.11.2005 stating that he has been in possession of the property from
February, 1995 onwards, with a rent of Rs.500/-, which has been extended
from time to time up to the year 2005 and that the lease period was over by
31.08.2005. The plaintiff further pleaded that her son has no business to
collect the rent and even if the defendant paid the same, it is not binding on
the plaintiff and she did not receive any amounts from the defendant. As such,
the defendant became trespasser after the lease period, and a notice was
also given by the plaintiff to the defendant to vacate the plaint schedule
property and also to pay an amount of Rs.2,600/- per month towards damages
from September, 2005 to till the defendant vacates the plaint schedule
property. Hence, the plaintiff is constrained to file the present suit.
7.
The defendant filed written statement before the trial Court. The brief
averments in the written statement are as follows:
On 01.09.2003, the plaintiff and her son approached the defendant and
requested to register the lease deed for the purpose of income tax and also
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
requested the defendant to enhance the rent to Rs.2,000/- per month from
Rs.800/- as the municipal taxes were enhanced. As there is no other
alternative, the defendant agreed to pay the rent of Rs.2,000/- per month
because the defendant modernised the photo studio by investing huge
amounts. The defendant further pleaded that he believed the story of the
plaintiff and registered the rent deed on 10.09.2003, since then the defendant
obtained a rent receipts from the plaintiff’s son and sincerely paid the rents
without any default till the expiry of the lease deed i.e. on 31.08.2005.
The defendant further pleaded that on 31.08.2005, the deceased
plaintiff and her son approached the defendant and collected an amount of
Rs.2,000/- towards rent from him and issued a rent receipt to the defendant on
the said date, the deceased plaintiff and her son requested the defendant
orally to enhance 10% on Rs.2,000/- rent, but the defendant did not agree to
pay additional 10% of rent and he requested the plaintiff that he will pay a 5%
added
rent
on
Rs.2,000/-
in
the
presence
of
elders
namely,
1) S.Venkateswararao, 2) G.Giribaby and 3) R.Manmadharao and the
deceased plaintiff and her son agreed to enhance the rent of 5% on
Rs.2,000/- rent and accordingly the deceased plaintiff and her son
approached the defendant on 19.06.2005, and collected the rent from him and
issued the rent receipts for the same and even on 16.09.2005, the deceased
plaintiff and her son did not demand the defendant to vacate the premises and
both the plaintiff and her son maintained cordial relations with the defendant.
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
The defendant further pleaded that he made several efforts to pay the
rents and he continued as tenant in the plaint schedule property under the oral
agreement between the plaintiff and the defendant, as such, the question of
trespass does not arise and the defendant is not liable to be evicted from the
plaint schedule property. He further pleaded that the plaintiff with mala fide
intention has issued a legal notice through her counsel with false allegations
on 27.10.2005, to call upon the defendant to vacate the premises; the
defendant received the legal notice and issued a reply notice on 09.11.2005
with all facts. The defendant further pleaded that he is unemployed, having old
parents and a large number of persons depending on the earning of the
defendant and the he has no business other than the photo studio and he is
eking out his livelihood through the source of photo studio business, as such,
he prayed to dismiss the suit with costs.
8.
On the basis of above pleadings, the learned Principal Junior Civil
Judge at Srikakulam, framed the following issues for trial:
1) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to evict the defendant from plaint
schedule property?
2) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recover damages as prayed for? and
3) To what relief?
9.
During the course of trial before the trial Court, on behalf of the plaintiff,
P.W.1 was examined and Exs.A-1 to A-4 were marked. On behalf of the
defendant, D.Ws.1 to 3 were examined and Exs.B-1 to B-22 were marked.
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
10.
The learned Principal Junior Civil Judge at Srikakulam, after conclusion
of trial, on hearing the arguments of both sides and on consideration of oral
and documentary evidence on record, decreed the suit with costs. Felt
aggrieved thereby, the unsuccessful defendant filed the appeal suit in
A.S.No.20 of 2013, on the file of the Judge, Family Court-cum-III Additional
District Judge at Srikakulam, wherein the following points came up for
consideration:
1) Whether the Decree and Judgment dated 04.02.2013 passed by the
Principal Junior Civil Judge, Srikakulam in O.S.No.56 of 2006 is liable to
be set aside as prayed for?
2) Whether this Court needs interference?
11.
The learned Judge, Family Court-cum-III Additional District Judge at
Srikakulam, i.e., the first appellate Judge, after hearing the arguments,
answered the points, as above, against the defendant and dismissed the
appeal suit filed by the defendant. Felt aggrieved of the same, the defendant
in O.S.No.56 of 2006 filed the present second appeal before this Court.
12.
Heard Sri P.Rama Sharana Sharma, learned counsel for the appellant
and Sri P.Rajasekhar, learned counsel for the respondents.
13.
It has to be kept in mind that the right of appeal is neither a natural nor
an inherent right attached to the litigation. It is regulated in accordance with
law. A second appeal preferred under Section 100 of C.P.C., could be
admitted only when the appellant satisfies the Court that substantial question
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
of law between the parties arise in the case. A proper test for determining
whether a question of law raised in the case is substantial would be or
whether it directly and substantially affects the rights of the parties and if so,
whether it is either an open question in the sense that it is not finally settled by
the superior Courts or is not free from difficulty or cause for discussion of
alternative views. In a case of Boodireddy Chandraiah v. Arigela Laxmi1,
the Apex Court held that it is not within the domain of High Court to investigate
grounds on which the findings were arrived at by the last Court of fact namely,
the first appellate Court. In a case where from a given set of circumstances
two inferences of facts are possible, one drawn by the lower appellate Court
will not be interfered by the High Court in a second appeal. Adopting any other
approach is not permissible. Where, the facts required for a point of law have
not been pleaded, a litigant should not be allowed to raise that question as a
substantial question of law in second appeal. Mere appreciation of facts,
documentary evidence and contents of documents cannot be held to be
raising a substantial question of law.
14.
The defendant having chosen to invoke the jurisdiction of this Court
under Section 100 of Civil Procedure Code, it is for him to meet the above
principles and satisfy the Court whether there exists any substantial question
of law.
15.
This second appeal is filed against the concurrent findings arrived by
both the Courts below, therefore, the grounds urged in the second appeal are
(2007) 8 SCC 155
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
to be scrutinized to find out whether the appellant has shown any substantial
question of law. The contention of appellant is that the judgment and decree of
the trial Court as well as the first appellate Court are contrary to law and that
the second appeal may be allowed by setting aside the judgment and decree
passed by both the Courts below i.e. the trial Court and the first appellate
Court.
16.
The respondent No.1 is the plaintiff in the suit proceedings; the
respondent No.1 filed a suit for eviction of the appellant from the plaint
schedule property and also for damages as stated by the plaintiff in the plaint.
The relationship of tenant and land-lady in between the appellant and the
plaintiff is undisputed by the appellant. The undisputed facts are that the
plaintiff is the absolute owner of the plaint schedule property and there a lease
deed in between the tenant/appellant and the land-lady/plaintiff on
10.08.2003, under Ex.A-1 and the terms of the lease deed are that “after the
lease period expires in the month of August, 2005, a fresh lease deed has to
be obtained by the plaintiff and the tenant/appellant has to pay 30% of the
enhanced rent to the plaintiff in the event of continuation in the premises and
he has to obtain a fresh lease deed from the plaintiff.” Admittedly, there is no
fresh lease deed in between the appellant and the plaintiff beyond 10.08.2005
and Ex.A-1 expired in the month of August, 2005.
17.
The contention of the appellant is that the son of the plaintiff used to
collect the rent from him and issued the receipts to him and that the son of the
appellant did not demand the appellant to vacate the premises. Admittedly, to
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
prove the same, no prima facie evidence was adduced by the appellant.
Another contention put forth by the appellant is that he continued as the tenant
in the suit schedule property under an oral agreement, hence the question of
trespass does not arise and he is not liable to vacate the suit schedule
property. Admittedly, no evidence was produced by the appellant to show that
there was an oral agreement in between the plaintiff and the appellant to
continue as a tenant by the appellant in the plaint schedule premises.
Admittedly, the lease period under Ex.A-1 expired in the month of August,
2005, and later no fresh lease deed was obtained by the appellant from the
plaintiff. D.W.2, who is none other than the own witness of the defendant
admitted that on 31.08.2008, the plaintiff demanded the appellant to enhance
the rent and the appellant is his friend. D.W.3 is the person, who worked as a
photographer in the studio run by the appellant in the plaint schedule
premises. D.W.3 fairly admits that the lease deed expired in the month of
August, 2005, and on 31.08.2005, the plaintiff and her son came to the
schedule premises and made a demand to enhance the rent and he did not
advise the appellant to enter into a fresh lease deed for extension of the lease
deed.
18.
The contention of the appellant is that he continued as a tenant in the
suit schedule premises under an oral agreement as stated supra and to that
extent, no evidence was produced by the appellant. A registered legal notice
under Ex.A-2 was issued by the plaintiff to the defendant by demanding the
defendant to vacate the suit schedule property. Having received the notice,
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
the appellant issued a reply notice and did not vacate the premises and also
did not obtain a fresh lease deed beyond 31.08.2005, and continued
possession in the plaint schedule property.
19.
It is well settled that on expiry of period of lease, the erstwhile lessee
continuous in possession because of the law of the land viz., that original
land-lady cannot physically thrown out such an erstwhile tenant by force. She
must get her claim for possession adjudicated by a competent Court as per
the relevant provisions of law. It is also equally settled that the status of an
erstwhile tenant has to be treated as tenant at sufferance akin to a trespasser
having no independent right to continue in possession. Learned counsel for
the appellant has brought to the notice of this Court that the appellant is not
paying damages as ordered by the trial Court, which was confirmed by the
First Appellate Court. Learned counsel for the appellant contended that in
case, if the appellant has to pay any arrears of damages as ordered by both
the Courts below, he will pay the arrears of damages to the plaintiff.
20.
Law is well settled that in the second appeal under Section 100 of the
Code of Civil Procedure the High Court cannot substantiate its own opinion
unless the Court finds that the conclusions drawn by both the Courts are
erroneous being, (i) contrary to the mandatory provisions of the applicable law
or (ii) contrary to the law as pronounced by the Apex Court or based on
inadmissible or no evidence. Admittedly, in the case on hand, the defendant
failed to prove that the conclusions drawn by the First Appellate Court were
erroneous being contrary to the mandatory provisions of applicable law or the
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
conclusions drawn by the First Appellate Court is based on inadmissible in
evidence.
21.
Having regard to the reasons assigned, this Court is satisfied that the
concurrent findings of fact recorded by both the Courts below on all the
issues/points against the defendant and in favour of the plaintiff do not brook
interference and that both the Courts below are justified in decreeing the suit
in favour of the plaintiff. The findings of fact recorded by both the Courts below
were based on proper appreciation of evidence and the material on record
and there was neither illegality nor irregularity in those findings and therefore,
the findings do not require to be upset. Further, the existence of substantial
questions of law is a sine qua non for the exercise of jurisdiction by this Court
as per Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure. The questions raised, strictly
speaking, are not even pure questions of law, let alone substantial questions
of law.
22.
Viewed thus, this Court finds that none of the questions raised are
substantial questions and there is no subsistence in the questions raised and
that therefore, the second appeal is devoid of merits and is liable for dismissal
at the stage of admission. The law is well settled that a second appeal shall
not be admitted if no substantial questions of law arise for consideration and
when no substantial questions of law is involved. The view of this Court is
reinforced by the ratio laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Gurdev
Kaur v. Kaki2. In the case on hand, as stated supra, this Court finds after
AIR 2006 SC 1975
VGKR, J.
SA_1582_2018
careful examination of the pleadings, evidence and contentions that no
substantial question of law is involved, this second appeal is liable for
dismissal at the stage of admission, in view of narrow compass of Section 100
of Civil Procedure Code.
23.
In the result, the second appeal is dismissed at the stage of admission,
confirming the judgment and decree of both the Courts below, by directing the
appellant to deposit the
arrears
of
damages
to
be
paid
to
the
respondent/plaintiff, as ordered by the trial Court, if not paid, which was
confirmed by the First Appellate Court, within a period of two (02) months
before the Executing Court from the date of this order, failing which the
Executing Court shall proceed in the Execution Petition in accordance with
law. In the event of deposit of arrears of amount of damages by the appellant,
as ordered by the trial Court, which was confirmed by the First Appellate
Court, additional time for a period of three (03) months is granted to the
appellant to deliver the vacant possession of the schedule premises to the
respondent/plaintiff. Considering the facts and circumstances, there shall be
no order as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in the Appeal shall
stand closed.
__________________________
V. GOPALA KRISHNA RAO, J.
Date: 02.01.2026
SRT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review