Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
* THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
&
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
+ CONTEMPT APPEAL No. 4 of 2025
% 16.07.2026
Between:
V. Seenaiah
.....APPELLANT
AND
Nellore Sudhakar and others
....RESPONDENTS
! Counsel for the Appellant
Counsel for the Respondents
< Gist :
> Head Note:
? Cases Referred:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
AIR 2012 SC 3891
(2003) 11 SCC
1970 (3) SCC 98
1962 SCC OnLine SC 368
(2024) 11 SCC 679
(2024) 12 SCC 85
: Sri E. Sambasiva Pratap, Addl.AG
Assisted by Sri K. Keerthi Teja
: Sri Madhavarao Nalluri
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
Date of reserved for orders : 23.06.2026
Date of pronouncement
:16.07.2026
Date of uploading
: 16.07.2026
APHC010619082025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3562]
CONTEMPT APPEAL NO: 4 of 2025
V Seenaiah
Vs.
Nellore Sudhakar and Others
...Appellant
...Respondents
**********
Advocate for Appellant:
SUDHIR MATTEGUNTA
Advocate for Respondent:
MADHAVA RAO NALLURI
CORAM : SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
DATE
: 16th July, 2026
JUDGMENT: (per Hon‟ble Sri Justice Ravi Nath Tilhari)
Heard Sri E. Sambasiva Pratap, learned Additional Advocate
General, assisted by Sri K. Keerthi Teja, appearing on behalf of appellant
and Sri Madhavarao Nalluri, learned counsel appearing for respondents.
2. This Contempt Appeal has been filed under Section 19 of the
Contempt of Courts Act,1971 by the appellant (respondent in Contempt
Case No.827 of 2018) arising out of the Judgment and Order dated
16.10.2025, passed by the learned single Judge holding the appellant
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
guilty of committing contempt of the Order dated 08.03.2018 in
W.P.No.7251 of 2018 and imposing the punishment of civil imprisonment
for a period of two months, also directing to restitute the loss suffered by
the writ petitioners by effecting reconstruction to bring the property to
status ante and in the event of failure in effecting the restitution within a
period of three months, imposing a further civil imprisonment for a period
of four months, with further direction to pay costs of Rs.10,000/- to each
of the writ petitioners, within a period of two weeks from the date in the
Order.
3. The respondents herein are the writ petitioners and also the
petitioners in the contempt case. There were four writ petitioners in the
writ petition and out of those, writ petitioners No.2 and 4 have filed the
contempt case, who are` respondents in this appeal.
4. W.P.No.7251 of 2018 was filed challenging the notice dated
26.02.2018 issued by Brahmadevam Gram Panchayat, represented by its
Secretary, Brahmadevam village, Muthukuru Mandal, SPSR Nellore
District. By the said notice, the petitioners were directed to remove the
encroachments on the public road. The notice also referred to the Order
dated 05.12.2017 passed in W.P.No.40019 of 2017. The Writ Petition
No.40019 of 2017 was filed by one M. Chenchaiah raising the grievance
that in spite of several representations made by him for removal of
encroachments in Panchayat land/rasta admeasuring Ac.0.66 cents in the
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
village, no action was taken by the Panchayat Authorities. The said writ
petition was disposed of, directing the respondents therein to consider the
representation of M. Chenchaiah, within a specified period.
5. The learned Judge in W.P.No.7251 of 2018 has recorded that
the Order of 05.12.2017 in W.P.No.40019 of 2017 showed that the
learned standing counsel for the Gram Panchayat submitted that the
survey was conducted and as soon as they receive the report action
would be initiated. Thereafter, notice dated 26.02.2018 was given to the
writ petitioners to remove the alleged encroachment which was under
challenge in W.P.No.7251 of 2018. The said writ petition was disposed of
at the admission stage setting aside the impugned order/notice dated
26.02.2018, on the ground that in the W.P.No.40019 of 2017 there was
direction to consider the representation and no positive direction to
remove the encroachment was given. But in directing the encroachment
to be removed, no opportunity of hearing was given to the writ petitioners
and they were not put to any notice.
6. W.P.No.7251 of 2018 was thus disposed of vide paragraphs-4 &
5 of the judgment dated 08.03.2018 in the following terms:
“4. Thus, this infirmity goes to the root, impugned order is not sustainable
and is accordingly set aside.
Writ petition is disposed of at the stage of
admission. The order (termed as notice) dated 26-2-2018 shall be treated as
show cause notice. The learned Standing Counsel also undertakes to instruct his
client to furnish a copy of the survey report to the petitioners within three (3)
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
days from today. The petitioners shall file their explanation within two (2)
weeks from the date of furnishing survey report.
5. On considering the explanation, appropriate orders shall be passed by the
Gram Panchayat. Until decision is taken and communicated to the petitioners,
the 5th respondent-Gram Panchayat shall maintain status quo obtaining as on
today.”
7. The contempt petitioners filed the contempt case No.827 of 2018
raising the grievance that from the aforesaid Order, it is evident that the
Order termed as Notice dated 26.02.2018 was directed to be treated as
„show cause notice‟. The learned standing counsel in W.P.No.7251 of
2018 had also undertaken to instruct his client to furnish a copy of the
survey report to the writ petitioners within three days from that day, and
the petitioners were granted time to file their explanation within two weeks
from the date of furnishing survey report. The direction was given that on
considering the explanation appropriate order shall be passed by the
Gram Panchayat and until such decision was taken and communicated to
the writ petitioners, the 5th respondent-Gram Panchayat therein shall
maintain a status quo obtaining as on the date of the order.
8. The contempt petitioners in Contempt Case No.827 of 2018
alleged willful disobedience of the Order passed in W.P.No.7251 of 2018.
Their contention was that the respondent (appellant herein) furnished a
copy of the survey sketch only on 12.03.2018. It appeared to them that
actually no survey was conducted. Copy of the survey report was not
furnished. They had time till 26.03.2018 for submitting their explanation
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
from furnishing the copy of the survey sketch. But in the meantime, on
19.03.2018 itself at about 3 p.m the respondent came on spot with 15
workers accompanied by Sub-Inspector of Police and the Police
Constables and demolished the petitioners‟ houses. They mentioned the
details of such demolition in length, width and height, in the contempt
petition. The aforesaid act was done by the respondent in spite of the
information given about the order passed by this Court in the writ petition.
9. The appellant herein (respondent in the contempt case) filed
counter affidavit and submitted that after the receipt of the survey report
on 18.10.2016 notices were issued to the writ petitioners on 01.02.2017,
21.05.2017, 17.07.2017 and 27.07.2017 asking the writ petitioners and
two others to remove the illegal encroachments made by them.
The
survey report dated 18.10.2016 was served on 10.02.2017 itself. All the
aforesaid notices and the survey report was prior to the Order dated
05.12.2017 passed in W.P.No.40019 of 2017. The stand was taken that
on the request of the writ petitioners for re-survey, a representation was
made to the Tahsildar in the last week of November 2017 to re-survey the
land, but the Tahsildar did not consider that representation made by the
Gram Panchayat on the ground that the land had already been surveyed.
It was further stated in the counter affidavit that in continuation of the
previous notices, another notice dated 26.02.2018 was issued to the
petitioner to demolish the illegal structure before 04.03.2018 pursuant to
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
the directions issued by the District Collector, Nellore on 22.02.2018.
Letter to that effect was also issued by the Tahsildar on 28.02.2018
directing the petitioners to remove the encroachments, and after receipt
of the notice, the contempt petitioners made a representation dated
08.03.2018 to the Gram Panchayat that they will remove the
encroachment before 15.03.2018, but they failed to remove the
encroachment and consequently, on 19.03.2018 the Gram Panchayat
demolished the part of the compound wall encroached by the petitioners.
But the Gram Panchayat never touched the house of the petitioners,
except the compound wall and at that time when the contempt petitioners
orally informed the respondent (the appellant herein) about the orders
passed by this Court in W.P.No.7251 of 2018, they stopped further
removal of the encroachments.
10. In the counter affidavit, the respondent (appellant herein) also
took the stand that the copy of the order dated 08.03.2018 in
W.P.No.7251 of 2018 was received by the Gram Panchayat on
01.04.2018, upon which, notice was issued to the petitioners on
03.04.2018 stating that the previous notice/order dated 26.02.2018 shall
be treated as a show cause notice. The survey report was also furnished
and the explanation of the petitioners was asked within two weeks, but
the petitioners did not file their explanation which was awaited and
thereafter, the Gram Panchayat never proceeded with any demolition of
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
the encroachments. The respondent (appellant herein) clearly denied in
the counter the receipt of the copy of the Order on 19.03.2018 specifically
submitting in para-7 that on 19.03.2018 he did not receive order copy, but
only an intimation from the writ petitioners at the time of removal of
encroachments on that day and on such intimation they stopped the work
of removal of the encroachments.
11. On consideration of the issue, the learned single Judge arrived
at the conclusions in para-14 which are being reproduced as under:
“14. In the above premise, this Court has come to a conclusion that the
Respondent herein is guilty of Contempt of this Court for the following
reasons:
i. That the Contemnor/Respondent, who is arrayed as one of the Defendant
in O.S.No.383 of 2017 is bound by the Interim Order passed in I.A.No.339 of
2017 in O.S.No.383 of 2017, which Order was subsisting on the said date.
ii. That the Unofficial Respondent No.6 in the Writ Petition by name Sri M.
Chenchaiah had also suppressed the factum of pedency of the Suit for
Permanent Injunction bearing O.S.No.383 of 2017 and also the factum of
subsistence of Interim Order in I.A.No.339 of 2017 in O.S.No.383 of 2017 and
obtained an innocuous Order to consider the Representation without impleading
the Writ Petitioners.
iii. The sole Respondent/Contemnor had made a futile effort before this
Court in the present Contempt Proceeding to raise several inconsistent and
unfounded pleas with a view to mislead this Court by showing wrong dates
instead of being apologetic and showing an element of remorse.
iv. The sole Respondent herein had furnished the Survey Report to the
Writ Petitioners without getting the Survey conducted. In any case, such
Survey Report is supplied on 15.03.2018 and without waiting for a period
of two weeks two enable the Writ Petitioners to submit their Explanation,
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
he had addressed a Letter to the Police for providing police protection and
got the properties of the Petitioners and demolished in a highhanded
manner on 19.03.2018 itself.
v. There is deliberate suppression of material facts with regard to the
subsisting Status quo order passed by the Principal Civil Judge (Junior
Division), Nellore dated 09.08.2017 in I.A.No.399 of 2017 in O.S.No.383 of
2017 inasmuch as the Respondent herein was arrayed as a Defendant.
Collusion between the Panchayat Secretary (Respondent No.5) and the
Unofficial Respondent No.6 in the Writ Petition is also evident from the
fact that the impugned Notice issued by the sole Respondent herein on
26.02.2018 did not specifically indicate the Writ Petition number or about
the order passed by this Court in W.P.No.40019 of 2017 dated 05.12.2017
which is filed by Sri M. Chandraiah.”
12. The learned single Judge passed the Order on 16.10.2025,
holding the appellant guilty of contempt and imposed punishment and
directions were also issued to restitute the loss suffered by the contempt
petitioners. The operative part of the Order in para-16 reads as under:
“16. In the above premise, the Contemnor/Respondent is held guilty and
convicted for the Contempt of Court, and therefore, shall suffer civil
imprisonment for a period of two months. The Contemnor/Respondent shall
also restitute the loss suffered by the Writ Petitioners herein (Writ Petitioner
Nos.1 & 4) by effecting reconstruction to bring the property to status-quo ante.
In the event of failure on the part of Contemnor/Respondent in effecting the
restitution within a period of three months, the Contemnor/Respondent shall
suffer further civil imprisonment for a period of four months. The
Contemnor/Respondent is directed to pay Costs of Rs.10,000/- to each of the
Writ Petitioners herein within a period of two weeks from the date of uploading
of this Order on the Web-site of this Court. At this stage, the learned Counsel
appearing for Contemnor/Respondent had requested the Court to suspend this
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
Order for some time. On such request, the present Order is suspended for a
period of two weeks from the date of uploading of this Order on the Web-site of
this Court. Accordingly, this Contempt Case is allowed.”
13. The learned single Judge after holding the appellant guilty of
contempt, also issued directions to the appellant so as to ensure that the
contempt petitioners, the victims, were compensated and the loss
suffered by them was restituted for the reasons recorded and
consideration made in para-15, which is reproduced as under:
“15. While holding the Contemnor/Respondent guilty of Contempt, it would
be the duty of the Court to ensure that the victim who suffered the loss shall be
restituted and if the same is not done, mere Order of punishment would be of no
avail for victim who suffered with the act of high-handedness of the
Contemnor/Respondent. This view of the Court is fortified by the two decisions
of the Hon’ble Apex Court, which are discussed hereunder:
a) In Amit Kumar Das, Joint Secretary, Baitanik, A Registered Society Vs.
Shrimati Hutheesingh Tagore Charitable Trust :(2024) 11 SCC 679. In Para
Nos.15 to 17, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held as under :
“15. However, in Mazdoor Sangh v. Baranagore Jute Factory Plc. [Mazdoor
Sangh v. Baranagore Jute Factory Plc., (2017) 5 SCC 506 : (2017) 3 SCC (Civ)
35 : (2017) 2 SCC (L&S) 19] , considering the aforestated precedent, a twoJudge Bench of this Court noted that the three-Judge Bench had clarified
therein that directions which are explicit in the judgment or “are plainly selfevident” can be taken into account for the purpose of considering whether there
is any disobedience or wilful violation. The Bench further held that the Court
has a duty to issue appropriate directions for remedying or rectifying the things
done in violation of the Court order and in that regard, the Court may even take
restitutive measures at any stage of the proceedings.
16. Significantly, the two-Judge Bench had merely echoed the affirmation of
the legal position by another two-Judge Bench of this Court in DDA v. Skipper
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
Construction Co. (P) Ltd. [DDA v. Skipper Construction Co. (P) Ltd., (1996) 4
SCC 622] The principle that a contemnor ought not to be permitted to enjoy
and/or keep the fruits of his contempt was reiterated therein. Reference was
made by the Bench to Mohd. Idris v. Rustam Jehangir Babuji [Mohd. Idris v.
Rustam Jehangir Babuji, (1984) 4 SCC 216 : 1984 SCC (Cri) 587] , wherein it
was held that undergoing punishment for contempt would not mean that the
Court is not entitled to give appropriate directions for remedying and rectifying
the things done in violation of its orders.
17. Therefore, the principle that stands crystallised by these judgments is that,
in addition to punishing a contemnor for disobeying its orders, the Court can
also ensure that such a contemnor does not continue to enjoy the benefits of his
disobedience by merely suffering the punishment meted out to him.”
b). In State Bank of India and Others Vs. Dr. Vijay Mallya : (2024)12
SCC 85. In Para Nos.16 & 17, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held as under:
“16. In the circumstances, in order to maintain the majesty of law, we must
impose adequate punishment upon the contemnor and must also pass necessary
directions so that the advantages secured by the contemnor or anyone claiming
under him are set at naught and the amounts in question are available in
execution of the decrees passed in the recovery proceedings concerned.
17. Considering the facts and circumstances on record and the facts that the
contemnor never showed any remorse nor tendered any apology for his
conduct, we impose sentence of four months and fine in the sum of Rs 2000
(Rupees two thousand only) upon the contemnor. The fine shall be deposited in
the Registry of this Court within four weeks and upon such deposit, the amount
shall be made over to the Supreme Court Legal Services Committee. In case the
amount of fine is not deposited within the time stipulated, the contemnor shall
undergo further sentence of two months.”
14. Challenging the aforesaid judgment, present Contempt Appeal
No.4 of 2025 has been filed.
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
15. Sri E. Sambasiva Pratap, learned Addl. Advocate General,
appearing for the appellant, submitted that the contempt petitioners had
given an undertaking on 08.03.2018 pursuant to the notices and order
passed previously that they would remove the encroachment by
15.03.2018 but as they did not comply with the undertaking given, on
19.03.2018 the demolition work started in which only the compound wall
was demolished and when the contempt petitioners informed about the
order of the Writ Court the demolition work was stopped and any part of
the house was not demolished. He submitted that the copy of the Order
dated 08.03.2018 of the Writ Court thereof was never served by
19.03.2018, which was received by Courier only on 01.04.2018.
16. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that there is no
willful disobedience of the Writ Court‟s Order.
Violation occurred on
19.03.2018 due to no service of the copy of the Order dated 08.03.2018.
So, no case for contempt was made out and the Order under appeal
deserved to be set aside.
17. Sri E. Sambasiva Pratap further submitted that pursuant to the
directions issued in the contempt petition by Order dated 16.10.2025 to
re-construct the demolished part, the appellant had reconstructed the
same and restitution has been done on the demolished part. Additionally,
the other direction of the learned single Judge to pay Rs.10,000/- to each
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
of the contempt petitioners has also been complied and a memo to that
effect, dated 15.12.2025 has already been filed.
18. Learned counsel for the Appellant placed reliance on the
following two cases in support of his contentions.
1) Salauddin Ahmed v. Samta Andolan1
2) Ashok Paper Kamgar Union v. Dharam Godha2
19. Sri Madhavarao Nalluri, learned counsel for the contempt
petitioners/present respondents, submitted that the respondent in
W.P.No.7251 of 2018 i.e., the Gram Panchayat was represented through
its standing counsel who was also heard.
So, the Secretary, Gram
Panchayat had knowledge of the Order passed in the writ petition. It
cannot be said that he had no knowledge of the Order dated 08.03.2018.
He submitted that under the Order dated 08.03.2018 the learned standing
counsel for the Gram Panchayat had undertaken to instruct his client to
furnish a copy of the survey report to the petitioners within three days
from that day i.e., from 08.03.2018. He submitted that a copy of the
survey sketch/report was given on 12.03.2018. There was disobedience
of the Order as the Gram Panchayat did not wait for the period of two
weeks granted to the writ petitioners to file their explanation from the date
of furnishing survey sketch/report, which time was available to the writ
AIR 2012 SC 3891
(2003) 11 SCC
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
petitioners to submit the explanation up to 26.03.2018, but in the
meantime, the demolition was done on 19.03.2018 itself.
20. Sri Madhavarao Nalluri, learned counsel for the respondents
submitted that the act of disobedience was willful and there is no illegality
in the Order of punishment and it did not call for any interference.
21. We have considered the aforesaid submissions of the learned
counsels for the parties and perused the material on record.
22. The ground of challenge mainly as argued is that the copy of
the Order of the Writ Court was not served. So, the demolition had taken
place on 19.03.2018.
The copy was received only thereafter on
01.04.2018.
23. In this appeal, the Coordinate Bench on 28.04.2026 passed the
Order granting time to the contempt appellant to produce proof that the
Order dated 08.03.2018 of the Writ Court was communicated to him on
01.04.2018. The Order dated 28.04.2026 reads as under:
“The order in W.P.No.7251 of 2018 directing the 5th respondent therein –
Gram Panchayat to maintain status quo obtaining as on that day was passed on
08.03.2018. Despite passing of the said order to maintain status quo, the
compound wall was demolished on 19.03.2018. Therefore, a contempt petition
was filed and it was allowed punishing the contemnor for violating the order of
the Court. Against the same, the present appeal is preferred.
2. The main contention of the appellant/contemnor is that the order of status
quo was communicated to him on 01.04.2018 and compound wall was
demolished even prior to the said date i.e., on 19.03.2018. But, no proof is
produced to show that the order of the Court was served on the contemnor on
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
01.04.2018 to buttress the contention of the contemnor that as he has no
knowledge of the order, no wilful act of contempt was committed.
3. Learned Additional Advocate General requests time to produce proof to
show that the order was communicated to the appellant/contemnor on
01.04.2018.
4. Therefore, list the matter on 23.06.2026.
5. Interim order granted earlier is extended till then.”
24.
The appellant filed memo vide USR No.61860/2026, dated
19.06.2026, submitting that the copy of the Order dated 08.03.2018 was
received by the appellant on 01.04.2018 from the 2nd respondent by the
DTDC Courier service also, annexing the copy of the courier envelop
cover.
25. So far as the receipt of copy of the Order dated 08.03.2018 in
W.P.No.7251 of 2018 to the appellant Secretary, Gram Panchayat is
concerned, we are satisfied that the copy of the order was served through
courier on 01.04.2018 in view of the Memo filed on 19.06.2026, on
perusal of the documents annexed with the said memo. The respondents
have not filed any response to the said Memo disputing the same. The
case of the respondents itself is that they received the copy of the Order
passed in the writ petition only on 19.03.2018. Their own case is, as per
the contents in the affidavit of the contempt petition that on 19.03.2018
they intimated about the Order of the Writ Court on the spot. Even in the
affidavit, the clear case of the respondents is that the copy of the Order
dated 08.03.2018 was received by them on 19.03.2018. So, it is clear that
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
they could serve the copy to the appellant only after 19.03.2018. It is
their own case that the copy was sent through post. So, it could not be
prior to 19.03.2018. We are satisfied that the copy of the Order dated
08.03.2018 passed in the writ petition was not served to the Secretary,
Gram Panchayat by the contempt petitioners, at any point of time prior to
19.03.2018 on which date the demolition took place.
26. But, the moot question is whether service of the copy of the
Order is must or intimation or knowledge of the Order of the Writ Court
would be sufficient for compliance with the said Order, and any willful
disobedience of the Court‟s Order, in spite of knowledge or/and intimation
would entail punishment for contempt.
27. On the aspect of knowledge or/and intimation of the Writ
Court‟s Order we find that the Gram Panchayat was party in the writ
petition and was heard through its standing counsel. The knowledge of
the Order dated 08.03.2018 passed in the presence and on hearing of the
standing counsel shall be imputed to the Secretary, Gram Panchayat. It
cannot be said that the appellant had no knowledge of the Writ Court‟s
Order.
28. We further find that under the Order dated 08.03.2018, the
learned standing counsel had undertaken to instruct the Gram Panchayat
to furnish a copy of the survey report to the petitioners (contempt
petitioners) within three days from 08.03.2018. The contempt petitioners
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
(respondents herein) categorically stated in the contempt petition affidavit
that the copy of the survey sketch was furnished on 12.03.2018 (para-4 of
the affidavit).
The appellant in his response (counter affidavit) in the
contempt case did not deny the contents of the para-4 of the contempt
petition (affidavit). The case of the contempt appellant is that the copy of
the survey report had already been furnished even prior to the
proceedings of W.P.No.40019 of 2017, on 10.02.2017 (para-3 of the
counter affidavit in the contempt case). The question is what was the
occasion for the appellant to have furnished the copy of the survey
sketch/report on 12.03.2018, if they had no knowledge of the Order dated
08.03.2018 passed by the Writ Court. Service of the copy of the survey
report/sketch/map on 12.03.2018 to the petitioners would certainly be
pursuant to the Writ Court‟s Order dated 08.03.2018, when the same is
read along with the undertaking given by the learned standing counsel for
Gram Panchayat to instruct the Gram Panchayat to serve copy of the
survey report.
So, from the material on record, the affidavits of the
contempt petitioners and the counter of the contempt appellant, it is very
clear that the learned standing counsel of Gram Panchayat had
communicated to the Gram Panchayat what he had undertaken in the
Order dated 08.03.2018. It is not the case of the appellant neither in his
counter to the contempt affidavit nor in the contempt appeal that the
learned standing counsel for the Gram Panchayat did not communicate
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
the Order dated 08.03.2018 or did not inform about furnishing copy of the
survey report by the Gram Panchayat, to the contempt petitioners
pursuant to the Order dated 08.03.2018. It is not the averment in counter
affidavit in contempt case that nothing was communicated to the
contempt appellant by the learned standing counsel.
There is no
averment by the appellant in the contempt appeal nor any such averment,
could be brought to our notice that the learned standing counsel for the
Gram Panchayat did not communicate the Order dated 08.03.2018 or did
not instruct about furnishing the copy of the survey report as was
undertaken by him.
29. The learned standing counsel had undertaken to do so and we
cannot assume and presume that the learned standing counsel would not
have done what he had undertaken, he being a responsible Officer of the
Court, and particularly when it is not the case of the appellant that the
standing counsel did not communicate.
30. In the reply affidavit in contempt case the contempt petitioners
clearly stated in para-9 of which the relevant part reads as under:
“9. ……… It is relevant to state that as admitted by the respondent that
before furnishing the copy of the order on 08.03.2018 itself we have informed
the passing of the order passed by this Hon’ble Court in the presence of the
standing counsel appeared for the Grama Panchayat. The Writ Petition was
filed on 05.03.2018 after serving the papers on the standing counsel
appearing for the Respondent and the matter was listed on 08.03.2018, this
Hon’ble Court was pleased to dispose of the matter at the admission stage.
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
This Hon’ble Court also observed in the copy of the order that the standing
counsel undertakes to instruct his client to furnish a copy of the survey
report to the petitioners within 3 days. The above said undertaking and
appearance of the standing counsel in the above writ petition is amounts to
getting knowledge of the respondent about passing of the order by this
Hon’ble Court.”
31. The 1st respondent (Appellant) filed additional affidavit in
contempt case dated 06.09.2024 and in paragraph No.5 stated as under:
“5. It is submitted that, only after serving the eviction order passed by this
respondent, the compound wall was demolished partly on 19.03.2018. After
contacting the learned standing counsel and after knowing the stay order
of this Hon’ble Court 19.03.2018, immediately this respondent stopped the
demolition of the wall of the petitioner.”
32. The 1st respondent (appellant) also filed an affidavit dated
11.10.2025 in contempt case and in para-7 thereof clearly stated about
contacting the learned standing counsel over phone on 19.03.2018. That
part reads as under:
“7. It is further humbly submitted on 08/03/2018, the petitioners submitted
undertaking that they would remove the encroachments voluntarily for the
subject property.
But they didn’t remove the encroachments, when this
respondent on 19/03/2018, started for removal of encroachments, the
Petitioners informed that there was a Status quo passed by this Hon’ble Court
on 08/03/2018 in W.P.No.7251/2018. Immediately this respondent contacted
the learning Standing Counsel over phone and came to know that there was a
Status quo order passed by this Hon’ble court in the above subject property.
Then immediately this respondent stopped the demolition of the above subject
property.”
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
33. From the aforesaid statements, it is evident that the contempt
appellant was in touch with the standing counsel, may be as stated, on
19.03.2018, but in the facts and circumstances, particularly, that it was
never stated that the standing counsel did not communicate, it cannot be
believed that the contempt appellant had no knowledge or intimation of
the Court‟s Order dated 08.03.2018.
34. At this stage, it is further relevant to refer to the Order dated
25.09.2025 passed in the contempt case. The same reads as under:
“Heard Sri Madhava Rao Nalluri, Ld. Counsel for the Petitioners and Sri M.
Sudheer, Ld. Counsel for the Respondent.
2. The present Contempt Case is filed complaining of highhanded manner in
which the Respondent has undertaken the demolition of the house belonging to
the Petitioners on 19.03.2018. The facts in this case would indicate that vide
Order dated 08.03.2018, Ld. Single Judge of this
Court in W.P.No.7251 of 2018 had issued the following directions.
“4. Thus, this infirmity goes to the root, impugned order is not sustainable and is
accordingly set aside. Writ petition is disposed of at the stage of admission. The
order(termed as notice) dated 26- 02-2018 shall be treated as show cause notice. The
learned Standing Counsel also undertakes to instruct his client to furnish a copy of the
survey report to the petitioners within three (3) days from today. The petitioners shall
file their explanation within two (2) weeks from the date of furnishing survey report.
5. On considering the explanation, appropriate orders shall be passed by the Gram
Panchayat. Until decision is taken and communicated to the petitioners, the 5th
respondent-Gram Panchayat shall maintain status quo obtaining as on today.”
3. The above extract would indicate that three days from 08.03.2018, the
Respondents herein were required to submit a copy of the Survey Report. This
Court had granted two weeks time to the Petitioners to respond on the Survey
Report.
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
4. It is the case of the Petitioners herein that the Petitioners have
received the Survey Report on 12.03.2018 and therefore, the Petitioners
had the time to submit a Reply to the Survey Report up to 26.03.2018.
Whereas, the Respondents, without waiting for the two weeks period to
enable the Petitioners to submit an Explanation, had demolished the
residential buildings of the Petitioners on 19.03.2018. The second
Photograph in page No.19 of this case would indicate that the demolition
was in fact done on 19.03.2018, without any manner of doubt.
5. Sri M. Sudheer, Ld. Counsel representing the sole Respondent has drawn
the attention of this Court to page No.13 of the additional Counter- Affidavit
filed by him on 06.09.2025 and would submit that the Petitioners themselves
have undertaken to remove the encroachments voluntarily. On perusal of the
said document which is alleged to have been submitted by the Petitioners
herein, it is a Letter dated 08.03.2018, which states that the encroachments
would be removed subject to the orders passed by the High Court.
6. It is noteworthy to mention that on 08.03.2018 itself this Court had passed
an order as extracted above, by which the sole Respondent could not have
undertaken any demolition in view of the order passed by the High Court on
08.03.2018. It cannot be contended by the Respondents that the Respondents
had undertaken the demolition when the order of this Court dated 08.03.2018 is
still subsisting.
7. Admittedly, the demolition was done on 19.03.2018 which fact is clearly
reflected from the second photograph at page No.19 of the Paper Book.
8. In this view of the matter, this Court is of the, prima facie, opinion
that the sole Respondent has willfully disobeyed the order of the Court. It
cannot be said that the sole Respondent has no knowledge of the order
passed by this inasmuch as the Survey Report was handed over by the
Respondent on 12.03.2018, which makes it evident that the Respondent had
complete knowledge of the order passed by the Court and thereby had
partly complied with the order of the Court by submitting the Survey
Report to the Petitioners.
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
9. Therefore, this Court is constrained to hold the sole Respondent, prima
facie, guilty of Contempt of Court. He is directed to Show Cause within one
week as to why he should not be punished for Contempt of Court for willful
disobedience of the Order.
10. The sole Respondent is directed to appear before this Court on the next
date of listing.
11. Sri M. Sudheer, Ld. Counsel representing the sole Respondent is
directed to convey the gist of this Order to the sole Respondent forthwith for
effective compliance.
12. List this matter on 16.10.2025.”
35. Then the respondent in CC.No.827 of 2018 (present appellant)
filed an affidavit dated 11.10.2025, paragraph Nos.4 to 7 of which
deserve reproduction as under:
“4. It is further humbly submitted that on 25.09.2025, this Hon’ble Court
passed an Order. In the para 4 of the order observed that the petitioners herein
have received the Survey report on 12.03.2018 is not correct. But actually
survey report was sent to the petitioners on 03.04.2018 through registered post,
the same evidence was filed before this Hon’ble Court in my additional counter
affidavit at page 17, 18 & 19. So that, the petitioners received the Survey report
from this respondent on 12.03.2018 is absolutely not correct.
5. It is further humbly submitted that actually this respondent not aware of
the order passed by this Hon’ble Court on 08.03.2018 in W.P.No.7251/2018 as
on the date of demolition on 19.03.2018. It is submitted that before demolition,
this respondent passed eviction order on 08.03.2018 and the same was
communicated to the petitioners.
6. On 15.03.2018, this respondent addressed a letter to the Station House
Officer, Muthukur Mandal, SPSR Nellore district for requesting Police
Protection for the demolition of the subject compound wall on 19.03.2018.
7. It is further humbly submitted on 08.03.2018, the petitioners submitted
undertaking that they would remove the encroachments voluntarily for the
subject property.
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
But they didn’t remove the encroachments, when this
respondent on 19.03.2018, started for removal of encroachments, the petitioners
informed that there was a Status quo passed by this Hon’ble Court on
08.03.2018 in W.P.No.7251 of 2018. Immediately this respondent contacted
the learning Standing Counsel over phone and came to know that there was a
Status quo order passed by this Hon’ble Court in the above subject property.
Then immediately this respondent stopped the demolition of the above subject
property.”
36. By the aforesaid affidavit, the appellant tried to change his
stand. In the counter affidavit in contempt case he did not deny service of
the survey sketch memo/report to the contempt petitioner on 12.03.2018.
But after the Order dated 25.09.2025 was passed by the learned single
Judge recording prima facie view, in para-8 of the Order, considering the
service of the survey sketch/report on 12.03.2018, the appellant for the
first time after about 7 years of the filing of the counter affidavit denied the
service of the survey report/sketch on 12.03.2018. In the meantime, the
appellant had also filed an additional affidavit on 06.09.2024 in contempt
case but at that time also the contents of para-4 of the contempt affidavit
were not denied.
37. Serving the copy of the survey sketch/map/report on
12.03.2018 after the Order dated 08.03.2018 and which would certainly
be pursuant to the direction under the Order dated 08.03.2018, proves
that the appellant had the knowledge and intimation of the Court‟s Order
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
dated 08.03.2018 much prior to the date of demolition and in any case
latest by 12.03.2018.
38. We are of the considered view that even if it be taken that the
copy of the Order dated 08.03.2018 could not be served by the petitioners
as they themselves received copy on 19.03.2018 and even if it be taken
that the copy of the Order was received on 01.04.2018 by the Gram
Panchayat Secretary vide courier in view of the Memo filed, the appellant
had the knowledge and intimation of the Order dated 08.03.2018, much
prior to 19.03.2018 and in any case on 12.03.2018, when the survey
report/sketch map was served to the contempt petitioner.
We cannot
accept the contention that the demolition which took place on 19.03.2018
was in ignorance of the Court‟s Order for non-supply of the copy of the
Court‟s Order or that the act of demolition was not a deliberate or willful
act of the contempt appellant.
39. In The Aligarh Municipal Board v. Ekka Tonga Mazdoor
Union3 the Hon‟ble Apex Court held that it may also be pointed out that in
order to justify action for contempt of court for breach of a prohibitive
order it is not necessary that the order should have been officially served
on the party against whom it is granted if it is proved that he has notice of
the order aliunde and he knew that it was intended to be enforced. Official
communication is not a condition precedent, provided there is no valid
1970 (3) SCC 98
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
reason to doubt the authenticity of the order conveyed to him. Relevant
part from para-5 of The Aligarh Municipal Board (supra) reads as
under:
“5. ……. It may also be pointed out that in order to justify action for
contempt of court for breach of a prohibitive order it is not necessary that
the order should have been officially served on the party against whom it is
granted, if it is proved that he has notice of the order aliunde and he knew that
it was intended to be enforced. Official communication is not a condition
precedent, provided there is no valid reason to doubt the authenticity of
the order conveyed to him. …….”
40. In Hoshiar Singh v. Gurbachan Singh4 also the Hon‟ble Apex
Court held in paragraph No.8 as under:
“8. The learned advocate for the appellants has referred us to a number of
decisions, English and Indian, relating to mandatory orders, or orders for the
payment of money, or orders which require under the rules of the Court to be
served in a particular manner. In re : Holt (an Infant) [1879 11 Ch D 168] ; Exparte Lingley [1879 13 Ch D 110] ; In re : Tuck, Murch v. Loosemore [1906 1
Ch 692] ; Dwijendra Krishna Dutta v. Surendra Nath Nag Choudhury [AIR
(1927) Calcutta 548] ; and Gordon v. Gordon [(1946) 1 All ER 246] . In those
decisions it was held that it was necessary to have the order properly served
before charging a person with disobedience of it. We do not think that those
decisions are in point, because we are dealing with a prohibitory order and
in the matter of a prohibitory order it is well-settled that it is not necessary
that the order should have been served upon the party against whom it has
been granted in order to justify committal for breach of such an order,
provided it is proved that the person complained against had notice of the
order aliunde. The distinction between prohibitory orders and orders of an
affirmative nature was adverted to in N. Baksi v. O.K. Ghosh [AIR (1957) Patna
1962 SCC OnLine SC 368
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
528] and a large number of decisions were referred to in support of the rule that
in respect of a prohibitory order, service of the order was not essential for
founding an action in contempt. We do not think that any useful purpose will
be served by examining those decisions over again. We are content to adopt for
the purposes of this case the rule as succinctly put by Oswald and quoted earlier
in this judgment.”
41. The Writ Court‟s Order to maintain Status quo in a writ petition
against threat of demolition is certainly a prohibitory order to maintain the
thing in the same status, and not to demolish.
42. Further, the stand taken in the counter affidavit in the contempt
case vide para-4 is that the notice was issued to the petitioners on
26.02.2018 to remove the encroachment before 04.03.2018 as per the
instructions issued by the District Collector, Nellore on 22.02.2018 for
which the Tahsildar had also issued the letter dated 22.02.2018 and
pursuant to the notice, the petitioners assured for removal of the
encroachment before 15.03.2018 vide their representation dated
08.03.2018.
43. The aforesaid contention and the stand of the appellant had
been considered by the learned single Judge and it was observed in
para-13 of the judgment that the representation of the contempt
petitioners, undertaking to demolish by 15.03.2018 could not be believed.
The learned single Judge expressed that the same was in different
handwriting and further that in any case, even if that representation was
submitted, that was during the course of the day on which the Order
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
dated 08.03.2018 was passed in the writ petition and therefore was under
the imminent danger of the petitioners‟ building being demolished.
44. We are of the view and satisfied that the contempt appellant
cannot take the shelter of the representation of the petitioners to demolish
by 15.03.2018 said to be given on 08.03.2018. Even if that representation
dated 08.03.2018 be there and even if in spite of such representation, the
petitioners did not remove the alleged encroachment. Once the Order
was passed by the Writ Court on 08.03.2018, the appellant could not
proceed to demolish the building or any part thereof under pretext of the
petitioners‟ representation dated 08.03.2018 or their failure to demolish in
spite of the alleged undertaking. Any action of demolition could not be
taken by the appellant on any pretext contrary to the directions issued by
the Writ Court.
45. Here, again we find that the affidavit was filed to change the
stand.
In the main counter affidavit to contempt case there was no
mention of any Order of eviction dated 08.03.2018. The only mention
was of the notices issued pursuant to which representation was given on
08.03.2018 by contempt petitioners to remove the alleged encroachments
by 15.03.2018. But, in the additional affidavit dated 06.09.2024 and the
affidavit dated 11.10.2025 the contempt appellant has stated that an
Order of eviction of the contempt petitioners was passed on 08.03.2018,
which stand was never taken in the counter affidavit in contempt case.
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
46. So, we are also in conformity with the view taken by the learned
single Judge in para-14 (iii) of the judgment, which reads as under:
“The sole Respondent/Contemnor had made a futile effort before this Court
in the present Contempt Proceeding to raise several inconsistent and unfounded
pleas with a view to mislead this Court by showing wrong dates instead of
being apologetic and showing an element of remorse.”
47. In Salauddin Ahmed (supra), upon which learned counsel for
the contempt appellant placed reliance, the Hon‟ble Apex Court held that
in order to establish that a person had deliberately and willfully committed
the contempt of court, two essential ingredients have to be proved.
Firstly, it has to be established that an order has been passed by
the Court which either directs certain things to be done by a person
or to restrain such person or persons from doing certain acts and
that the person or persons had knowledge of the said order.
Secondly, it has to be established that despite having knowledge
of such order, the person concerned deliberately and willfully
violated the same with the intention of lowering the dignity and image
of the Court.
48. Paragraph No.36 of Salauddin Ahmed (supra) reads as under:
“36. In order to establish that a person had deliberately and wilfully
committed contempt of court, two essential ingredients have to be proved.
Firstly, it has to be established that an order has been passed by the court which
either directs certain things to be done by a person or to restrain such person or
persons from doing certain acts and that the person or persons had knowledge
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
of the said order. Secondly, it has to be established that despite having
knowledge of such order, the person concerned deliberately and wilfully
violated the same with the intention of lowering the dignity and image of the
court. We have to see whether in the facts of this case the said two tests are
satisfied.”
49. There is no dispute on the proposition of law as laid down in the
case of Salauddin Ahmed (supra). Applying the said principle to the
facts of the present case, we are satisfied that both the ingredients are
proved. It is established from the record that though the copy of the
Order was not received by the appellant, but he had knowledge and
intimation of the Order of the Writ Court. The Hon‟ble Apex Court in
Salauddin Ahmed (supra) has clearly held “that the person or persons
had knowledge of the said Order”. So, mere knowledge of the Order is
sufficient. Serving the copy of the Order is not an essential requirement
to hold guilty of contempt, when despite knowledge there is willful
disobedience of the Court Order. Knowledge of the Order to the appellant
is established in view of the discussion made above. We are satisfied on
the second essential ingredient as well that there was willful and
deliberate violation of the Court‟s Order. The appellant did not wait for two
weeks to enable the petitioners to file the explanation and before expiry of
that period demolished the construction or part thereof on 19.03.2018
itself. Both the ingredients as in Salauddin Ahmed (supra) are satisfied.
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
50. In Ashok Paper Kamgar Union (supra), upon which also
learned counsel for the contempt appellant placed reliance, the Hon‟ble
Apex Court held that Section 2 (b) of the Contempt of Courts Act defines
„civil contempt‟ and it means willful disobedience to any judgment, decree,
direction, order, writ or other process of a Court or willful breach of
undertaking given to a Court. „Willful‟ means an act or omission which is
done voluntarily and intentionally and with the specific intent to do
something the law forbids or with the specific intent to fail to do something
the law requires to be done, that is to say, with bad purpose either to
disobey or to disregard to the same. The Hon‟ble Apex Court held that
therefore, in order to constitute contempt the Order of the Court must be
of such a nature which is capable of execution by the person charged in
normal circumstances. It should not require any extraordinary effort nor
should be dependent, either wholly or in part, upon any act or omission of
a third party for its compliance.
51. Paragraph 17 of Ashok Paper Kamgar Union (supra) reads as
under:
“17. Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act defines “civil contempt”
and it means wilful disobedience to any judgment, decree, direction, order, writ
or other process of a court or wilful breach of undertaking given to a court.
“Wilful” means an act or omission which is done voluntarily and intentionally
and with the specific intent to do something the law forbids or with the specific
intent to fail to do something the law requires to be done, that is to say, with
bad purpose either to disobey or to disregard the law. It signifies a deliberate
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
action done with evil intent or with a bad motive or purpose. Therefore, in order
to constitute contempt the order of the court must be of such a nature which is
capable of execution by the person charged in normal circumstances. It should
not require any extraordinary effort nor should be dependent, either wholly or in
part, upon any act or omission of a third party for its compliance. This has to be
judged having regard to the facts and circumstances of each case. The facts
mentioned above show that none of the respondents to the petition can be held
to be directly responsible if the Scheme which had been formulated by the
Government of India on 28-6-1996 and had been approved by this Court by the
order dated 8-7-1996 could not be implemented in letter and spirit as many
factors have contributed to the same. The reasons given for non-inclusion of
Shri Umadhar Prasad Singh in signing of the agreement appear to be quite
plausible. NCFL has undoubtedly not discharged its liability of making
payment of its entire liability of Rs 6 crores. However, it has come out with a
case that some additional expenditure has been incurred in running the unit. It is
not possible to get the complete financial picture only on the basis of the
affidavits filed in the present petition. On the material on record, therefore, it is
not possible to hold that the charge of having committed contempt of court on
account of alleged non-compliance with the orders passed by this Court on 8-71996, 1-5-1997 [ Under Article 32 of the Constitution of India] and 31-7-2000
[Ashok Paper Mills Kamgar Union v. Union of India, (2003) 11 SCC at p. 16,
below] has been established against any one of the respondents.”
52. In the present case, the Order of the Writ Court was to serve
the copy of the survey report within the specified time and from that date
of service two weeks time was granted to the petitioners to submit
explanation and thereafter on considering the explanation Order had to
be passed by the Gram Panchayat and to be communicated to the
petitioners, and till then status quo was ordered. The said direction as has
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
already been reproduced (supra) is not of such a nature, which was not
capable of execution. It also did not require any extraordinary effort nor
its execution was dependent on the act of some third party.
The
appellant had to serve the copy of the survey report, wait for the period
granted for explanation to be filed by the petitioners and then to proceed
further accordingly. Certainly, the appellant could have waited for that
time and if the explanation was filed within the specified time, then to
proceed further as per the directions issued by the Writ Court. All those
aspects to be considered and acted upon by the appellant did not require
any extraordinary effort to comply with the Order nor any part of the said
Order for its compliance by the appellant depended on the compliance or
the act of any third party. So, the appellant cannot have any benefit of
the judgment in Ashok Paper Kamgar Union (supra).
53. The next contention of the learned counsel for the appellant
that since the appellant has complied with the part of the Order of
payment of Rs.10,000/- as compensation to each of the contempt
petitioners and has also restored the compound wall, and so, no action
deserves to be taken against the appellant deserves rejection. In our
view, compliance with that part of the Order under challenge is no
substitute for punishment to the willful disobedience of the Court‟s Order
and committing the contempt. The directions of the learned single Judge
to restore status quo ante and to compensate the contempt petitioners
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
was not in lieu of or in substitution of the sentence. On the finding, holding
the appellant guilty of contempt the punishment was imposed and to
compensate the loss suffered or to restitute, the Order was passed to
restitute compound wall and pay an amount of Rs.10,000/- to each
contempt petitioners. That was apart from imposition of punishment under
the Act 1971. Punishment is for committing the contempt of court. The
power to order restitution as held in the cases of Amit Kumar Das, Joint
Secretary, Baitanik, A Registered Society v. Shrimati Hutheesingh
Tagore Charitable Trust5 and State Bank of India and Others vs. Dr.
Vijay Mallaya6 is for remedying or rectifying the things done in violation of
the Court‟s Order.
54. In Amit Kumar Das, Secretary, Baitanik, A Registered
Society (supra) it was held that in addition to punishing a contemnor for
disobeying its orders, the Court can also ensure that such a contemnor
does not continue to enjoy the benefits of his disobedience by merely
suffering the punishment meted out to him. Paras-16 and 17 of Amit
Kumar Das, Secretary, Baitanik, A Registered Society (supra) are
read as under:
“16. Significantly, the two-Judge Bench had merely echoed the affirmation
of the legal position by another two-Judge Bench of this Court
in DDA v. Skipper Construction Co. (P) Ltd. [DDA v. Skipper Construction Co.
(P) Ltd., (1996) 4 SCC 622] The principle that a contemnor ought not to be
(2024) 11 SCC 679
(2024) 12 SCC 85
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
permitted to enjoy and/or keep the fruits of his contempt was reiterated therein.
Reference was made by the Bench to Mohd. Idris v. Rustam Jehangir
Babuji [Mohd. Idris v. Rustam Jehangir Babuji, (1984) 4 SCC 216 : 1984 SCC
(Cri) 587] , wherein it was held that undergoing punishment for contempt
would not mean that the Court is not entitled to give appropriate directions for
remedying and rectifying the things done in violation of its orders.
17. Therefore, the principle that stands crystallised by these judgments is
that, in addition to punishing a contemnor for disobeying its orders, the Court
can also ensure that such a contemnor does not continue to enjoy the benefits of
his disobedience by merely suffering the punishment meted out to him.”
55. In Dr. Vijay Mallya (supra) the Hon‟ble Apex Court held that
apart from punishing the contemnor for his contumacious conduct, the
majesty of law may demand that appropriate directions be issued by the
Court so that any advantage secured as a result of such contumacious
conduct is completely nullified. Mere passing an order of punishment
would not be enough or sufficient and in a given case, to meet the ends of
justice, the concept of purging of the contempt would call for complete
disgorging of all the benefits secured as a result of actions which are
found by the court to be contumacious. Paras-14, 15 and 16 of Dr. Vijay
Mallya (supra) read as under:
“14. It is, thus, well settled that apart from punishing the contemnor for his
contumacious conduct, the majesty of law may demand that appropriate
directions be issued by the court so that any advantage secured as a result of
such contumacious conduct is completely nullified. The approach may require
the court to pass directions either for reversal of the transactions in question by
declaring said transactions to be void or passing appropriate directions to the
authorities concerned to see that the contumacious conduct on the part of the
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
contemnor does not continue to enure to the advantage of the contemnor or any
one claiming under him. It is precisely for these reasons that the direction to
have vacant possession delivered to the rightful claimant was passed by this
Court
in Noorali
Babul
Thanewala v. K.M.M.
Shetty [Noorali
Babul
Thanewala v. K.M.M. Shetty, (1990) 1 SCC 259] . Mere passing of an order of
punishment as stated by this Court in Pravin C. Shah v. K.A. Mohd. Ali [Pravin
C. Shah v. K.A. Mohd. Ali, (2001) 8 SCC 650] would not be enough or
sufficient. In a given case, to meet the ends of justice, the concept of purging of
the contempt would call for complete disgorging of all the benefits secured as a
result of actions which are found by the court to be contumacious.
15. In its judgment and order dated 9-5-2017 [SBI v. Kingfisher Airlines
Ltd., (2017) 6 SCC 654 : (2017) 3 SCC (Civ) 273] , this Court had found that
the action on part of the contemnor in disbursing the amount of US $40 million
was against the text and tenor of orders passed by the High Court of Karnataka
and that the contemnor was guilty of contempt.
16. In the circumstances, in order to maintain the majesty of law, we must
impose adequate punishment upon the contemnor and must also pass necessary
directions so that the advantages secured by the contemnor or anyone claiming
under him are set at naught and the amounts in question are available in
execution of the decrees passed in the recovery proceedings concerned.”
56. We are further satisfied that the appellant acted in haste
manner without waiting for the copy of the Order in spite of intimation
or/and knowledge of the Order and it appears to us from the averment(s)
in the counter affidavit in contempt case that it was all done in an effort to
comply with the directions of the District Collector, issued prior to the
Court‟s Order dated 08.03.2018, giving preference to the directions of the
District Collector over the Orders of this Court.
RNT, J & SS, J
CA. No.4 of 2025
57. We are therefore not inclined to interfere with the Order of the
learned single Judge for the reasons we have assigned. The same does
not call for any interference.
58. (i) The Contempt Appeal is dismissed.
(ii) The appellant shall surrender before the Registrar (Judicial)
of this Court within a period of one week from today.
The Registrar
(Judicial) shall proceed as per law for implementation / execution of the
Judgment dated 16.10.2025 of the learned single Judge in C.C.No.827 of
2018.
(iii) Let a copy of this judgment be served on the appellant
through his counsel within a period of two days from today.
Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed in
consequence.
______________________
RAVI NATH TILHARI, J
_______________________
SUBHENDU SAMANTA, J
Date: 16.07.2026
Dsr
Whether the order is:
Reasoned „Yes‟
Reportable „Yes‟ (LR copy to be marked)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review