Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for orders : 30-07-2026
Date of pronouncement
: 25-09-2026
Date of uploading
: 29-09-2026
APHC010585502008
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3602]
FRIDAY, THE 25th DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUNITHA GANDHAM
FAMILY COURT APPEAL (FCA) NO: 253/2008
Between:
1. V. RAJYALAKSHMI, W/O. C. YALL REDDY, R/O. 2015-24, R.H.
COLONY, NELLIMUKK, PEDA GANTYADA,
...APPELLANT
AND
1. C YELLAYYA REDDY, S/o. Gurappa R/o. 17-44-1, Kongapalem, Peda
Gantyada, Visakhapatnam District.
...RESPONDENT
IA NO: 1 OF 2008(FCAMP 469 OF 2008)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay
of all further proceedings of order in OP.No. 593/2006, dated 20.10.2008 on the
file of the Family Court Judge, Visakhapatnam pending disposal of the appeal in
the interest of justice
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
IA NO: 1 OF 2009(FCAMP 257 OF 2009)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased vacate
the interim stay orders dated 24-12-2008 in FCAMP.No. 469 of 2008 in
FCA.No.253 /2008 in the interest of justice.
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. Y V SRINIVASAN
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. B VIDYULLATA
The Court made the following:
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUNITHA GANDHAM
FAMILY COURT APPEAL No.253 OF 2008
JUDGMENT: (Per Hon’ble Sri Justice Battu Devanand)
This Family Court Appeal is filed by the petitioner assailing the order and
decree dated 20.10.2008 passed by the learned Judge, Family Court,
Visakhapatnam in O.P.No.593 of 2006 filed under Section 13(1)(ia) and (ib) of
the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (hereinafter referred to as “The Act, 1955”),
whereby dissolved the marriage between the petitioner and the respondent dated
21.06.2003 on the ground of cruelty and desertion.
2.
The parties are being referred to as „petitioner‟ and „respondent‟ as arrayed
in the petitioner before the trial Court, for the sake of convenience.
3. Case of the petitioner, in brief, thus:
That the marriage of the petitioner and respondent was solemnised on
21.06.2003 at Visakhapatnam as per the Hindu Rites and caste customs. After
few days, their marriage was consummated.
Respondent is none other than
daughter of the petitioner‟s maternal uncle. At the time of marriage, 88 grams of
gold is presented to the respondent by her parents.
After their marriage,
respondent joined in Polytechnic diploma course and started living as free bird,
did not care anybody, developed hatredness towards the petitioner and did not
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
show any interest to lead marital life with the petitioner.
Petitioner and his
parents requested to come and join her to lead marital life but she paid deaf ear.
When they requested the father of the respondent to send his daughter to the
matrimonial house, he expressed his inability.
Therefore, the petitioner started
visiting the house of respondent‟s parents to lead marital life and for which also
respondent refused to spend time with him. Respondent deliberately proclaimed
that she does not have any interest to lead marital life with the petitioner. All the
attempts made by the petitioner become futile. Without any reason, respondent is
refusing for cohabitation.
Respondent committed the acts of cruelty.
The
respondent lead marital life only for few days and deserted him in the 1st week of
July, 2003.
When the same is placed before the elders, they advised the
respondent to join the petitioner, but she failed to join and intentionally deserted
the petitioner.
4.
While admitting the marriage, respondent filed counter refuting the
averments made in the petition, wherein, inter alia contended as follows:
a)
At the time of marriage, her parents gave dowry, gold ornaments and
lanchanams. They lead marital life for one year only. Thereafter, petitioner and
his family members started harassing this respondent demanding additional
dowry of Rs.1,00,000/- and accordingly, her parents gave Rs.50,000/- cash and
saresaman worth of Rs.50,000/- but the petitioner did not change his attitude.
Petitioner and his family members harassed the respondent mentally and
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
physically and in the year, 2005 petitioner and his family members beat the
respondent and necked her out from the matrimonial house.
b)
Then, parents of the respondent placed the matter before the elders and
they chastised the petitioner. Having accepted before the elders that he will look
after the respondent properly, he failed to mend his attitude, demanded
additional dowry, beat black and blue and did not provide food and medical aid to
the respondent. On 21.06.2025, when the respondent requested the petitioner to
give permission to go to her parent‟s house, having given permission, he
demanded to bring additional dowry of Rs.1 lakh.
She expressed inability and
then, the petitioner beat the respondent and confined her in a room without
providing food to her. In the month of December, 2005, petitioner and his family
members tried to kill the respondent by leaking the gas and thereafter parents of
the respondent took her to their house and finally, in the month of March, 2006
petitioner and his family members placed the matter before the elders, for which
they demanded additional dowry of Rs.1,00,000/-. In the month of June, 2006
petitioner came to the house of the respondent‟s parents created nuisance and
demanded to give divorce.
In the month of November, 2006, respondent came
to know that the parents of the petitioner are trying to perform 2nd marriage to the
petitioner, and then she gave report to the police and the same is registered as a
case in Crime No.565 of 2006 for the offence under Section 498-A IPC and
pending on file of Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Visakhapatnam.
After
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
marriage, respondent discontinued her studies, she never deserted the petitioner
and the petitioner himself deserted the respondent, and with other formal denials,
she prayed to dismiss the petition.
5.
During enquiry, the petitioner himself examined as PW.1 and he has got
examined two independent witnesses as PWs.2 and 3 and no documents are
filed.
As against the said evidence, respondent examined herself as RW.1 and
she has got examined independent witnesses as RWs.2 and 3 and no
documents are filed.
6.
At the culmination of enquiry, learned family Court allowed the petition
dissolving the marriage between the petitioner and respondent vide order dated
20.10.2008.
Feeling aggrieved by the decree and order dated 20.10.2008,
respondent preferred the instant appeal urging the following grounds:
(i)
The order of the trial court is illegal, arbitrary and unjust;
(ii)
The trial Court utterly failed to assign reasons for granting
divorce;
(iii) The trial Court erred in discussing the evidence of witnesses
and erred in not considering the evidence of respondent and
her witnesses,
(iv) The trial Court failed to prosecute that the petitioner failed to
examine any elder or mediator except PW.3, and with other
formal grounds prayed to allow the appeal.
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
7.
Heard Sri Y.V.Srinivasam, learned counsel for the petitioner and
Smt.Vidyullata, learned counsel for respondent.
8.
On hearing both sides and upon perusing the material available on record
including the decree and order dated 20.10.2008, the points that would arise for
consideration are:
1. Whether the petitioner had established his case to dissolve his
marriage with the respondent dated 21.06.2003 on the ground
of cruelty and desertion?
2. Whether the decree and order passed by the learned Judge,
Family Court is sustainable in facts and law?
3. To what relief?
9. Admitted facts:
That the marriage of the petitioner and respondent was solemnised on
21.06.2003 at Visakhapatnam as per Hindu Rites and caste customs.
Their
marriage was consummated. Respondent gave report against the petitioner and
his family members of the offence under Section 498-A IPC and the same is
pending on the file of I Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Visakhapatnam.
Respondent is none other than the daughter of maternal uncle of the petitioner.
They lead marital life for a short period.
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
10.
Before delving the facts of the case, it is opposite to mention that except
reproducing evidence of all the witnesses i.e., PW1 to 3 and RWs.1 to 3, the
learned judge, Family Court has not at all appreciated the evidence in respect of
the alleged cruelty and desertion and after reproducing evidence of each
witnesses till para No.12, simply allowed the petition by assigning the following
reasons at para Nos.13 and 14:
“13. The evidence on record, therefore, establishes that from
2003, the respondent and the petitioner are living separately from
each other. Though the respondent contended that the marriage
was not consummated, he did not file any document to prove his
contention. Similarly, the respondent also has not filed anything
to show that dowry and lanchanams are given to the petitioner. I,
therefore, hold that the marriage between the parties has been
irretrievably broken and as such, there are sufficient grounds to
dissolve the marriage between the parties. I find on the point
accordingly.
14. In the result, this petition is allowed and the marriage
between the parties is dissolved.”
11.Point No.1:
a)
Being this Court is first appellate Court and the fact finding Court, it is just
and appropriate to re-examine and re-appreciate the entire oral as well as
documentary evidence on record. Now, it is necessary to analyse the evidence
available on record, so as to answer the points.
b)
Petitioner filed the petition on the grounds of desertion and cruelty and as
per Section 13 (1) (ia) and (ib) of the Act, any marriage solemnized, whether
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
before or after the commencement of this Act, may, on a petition presented by
either the husband or the wife, be dissolved by a decree of divorce on the ground
that the other party, has, after the solemnization of the marriage, treated the
petitioner with cruelty; or has deserted the petitioner for a continuous period of
not less than two years immediately preceding the presentation of the petition.
c).
At the same time, the burden of establishing the grounds for divorce
remains upon the petitioner. The mere fact that the parties have lived separately
for a long period, by itself, cannot be treated as an independent statutory ground
for divorce by a High Court. Likewise, the concept of irretrievable breakdown of
marriage, though recognised in appropriate cases by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
in exercise of its constitutional jurisdiction, cannot by itself be treated as a ground
available to a High Court under Section 13 of the Act. Therefore, the decree has
to be tested with reference to the statutory grounds pleaded and proved by the
petitioner.
d).
Cruelty is not capable of an exhaustive definition. Whether a particular
conduct amounts to mental cruelty has to be determined by considering the
entire matrimonial relationship, the nature and gravity of the conduct, its impact
upon the spouse complaining of cruelty, and the surrounding circumstances. In
Dr. N.G. Dastane v. Mrs. S. Dastane1, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held that
(1975) 2 SCC 326
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
matrimonial proceedings are civil proceedings and the allegations constituting the
ground for relief are to be established on the standard of preponderance of
probabilities.
e).
Further, in Samar Ghosh v. Jaya Ghosh2, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
explained that mental cruelty has to be assessed from the entirety of the
matrimonial life of the parties. The Court observed, among other things, that
sustained neglect, indifference, refusal of conjugal relationship without
justification, and conduct which makes it extremely difficult for one spouse to live
with the other may, depending upon the facts of the case, constitute mental
cruelty. The Court also made it clear that trivial irritations, ordinary wear and tear
of married life and isolated incidents would not ordinarily constitute cruelty. Thus,
the question is whether the conduct proved on record has crossed the threshold
of ordinary matrimonial discord and has caused such mental pain or suffering
that the parties cannot reasonably be expected to continue the relationship.
f).
In the present case, PW.1 categorically deposed that, after the marriage,
the respondent did not evince interest in leading matrimonial life with him and
that repeated efforts made by him and his family members to persuade her to
return were unsuccessful. He further deposed that elders and other persons
intervened and advised the respondent to resume cohabitation, but she did not
do so. Though PW.1 was subjected to cross-examination, his evidence regarding
(2007) 4 SCC 511
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
the respondent‟s unwillingness to resume cohabitation was not materially
shaken.
g).
The evidence of PWs.2 and 3 assumes significance in this regard. They
are not shown to be interested witnesses merely because they had intervened in
the matrimonial dispute. Both witnesses stated that the respondent was residing
with her parents and that efforts were made to persuade her and her parents to
send her back to the petitioner. Their evidence is consistent on the material
aspect that the respondent was unwilling to resume the matrimonial relationship
and that attempts at reconciliation did not fructify. The fact that the witnesses
were unable to give every minute detail regarding the dates of the meetings or
the precise sequence of events cannot, by itself, render their testimony wholly
unreliable, particularly when their evidence is consistent on the material
circumstances.
h)
It is true that PW.2 stated in cross-examination that the parties had lived
together happily for about one and half year and that he did not know the exact
date on which the respondent left the petitioner. PW.3 also referred to the parties
having lived together for about one and half year. These statements, however, do
not demolish the petitioner‟s case. On the contrary, they establish that the parties
did live together for a period after the marriage and thereafter separated. The
precise date of separation is relevant principally to the ground of desertion; the
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
substance of their evidence regarding the respondent‟s refusal to resume
cohabitation remains intact.
i)
The respondent, while denying cruelty, admitted several circumstances
which are relevant to the controversy. She admitted that the parties had been
living separately for a long period. Her evidence shows that the matrimonial
relationship had not been restored despite the passage of several years and
despite interventions between the parties. Her allegation that the petitioner had
harassed her and demanded additional dowry was not supported by
documentary evidence. Had really, the petitioner and his parents tried to kill her,
she should have been given report immediately, but she didn‟t do so.
j)
The respondent‟s allegations of harassment have to be assessed along
with the entire evidence on record. The respondent did not place sufficient
material before the Family Court to establish that her continued separate
residence was compelled by proved acts of cruelty on the part of the petitioner.
Her version also does not satisfactorily explain why, despite repeated
interventions and the passage of a substantial period, the matrimonial
relationship was not resumed.
k)
The respondent‟s case that she was always willing to live with the
petitioner also does not receive complete support from the evidence. Although
she denied the suggestion that she was unwilling to join the petitioner, the
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
evidence of the independent witnesses including the witness examined by the
respondent, coupled with the circumstances emerging from the record,
establishes that attempts were made to bring about reconciliation and that the
respondent did not resume cohabitation.
l)
The petitioner has thus established, on the preponderance of probabilities,
that the respondent persistently refused to resume cohabitation and that
repeated efforts for reconciliation failed. In the circumstances of this case, such
prolonged and unjustified refusal to maintain the matrimonial relationship,
coupled with the continued separation and failure of reconciliation, cannot be
characterised merely as an ordinary matrimonial disagreement. The conduct,
viewed cumulatively and in the context of the entire matrimonial relationship,
caused substantial mental distress to the petitioner and constitutes mental cruelty
within the meaning of Section 13(1)(ia) of the Act.
m)
Coming to the ground of desertion, it involves both the fact of separation
and the intention to bring cohabitation permanently to an end, without reasonable
cause and without the consent of the other spouse. The intention may be inferred
from the conduct and surrounding circumstances. The evidence of PW.1,
supported by PWs.2 and 3, establishes that after the parties ceased living
together, the petitioner made efforts to secure the respondent‟s return and that
such efforts did not succeed. The evidence also shows that the parties remained
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
separate for a period exceeding two years before the proceedings were
instituted.
n)
The respondent sought to attribute the separation to the alleged
harassment and demand for additional dowry by the petitioner and his family
members. However, as already noticed, those allegations were not satisfactorily
established in the present proceedings. The evidence of the petitioner that he
attempted to resume their relationship is supported in material particulars by
PWs.2 and 3. The respondent, despite the opportunities for reconciliation, failed
to join the petitioner. Thus, the necessary elements of desertion, namely
separation and the intention inferred from the conduct of the respondent to
discontinue the matrimonial relationship, stand established on the facts of the
case.
o)
We also find that the reasoning assigned by the learned Family Court at
paragraph 13 of its order is not satisfactory inasmuch as the learned Judge
principally proceeded on the basis that the marriage had been irretrievably
broken. As noticed above, irretrievable breakdown of marriage, standing alone, is
not a statutory ground under Section 13 of the Act for a High Court to dissolve a
marriage. However, an appellate Court is required to consider the decree on the
basis of the pleadings and evidence available on record. On an independent
re-appreciation of the evidence, we are satisfied that the petitioner established
the statutory grounds of cruelty and desertion. Therefore, the deficiency in the
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
reasoning of the Family Court does not warrant setting aside the decree when
the material on record establishes the grounds on which the relief was sought.
p)
The contention of the learned counsel for the respondent that the petitioner
did not examine all the elders or mediators who allegedly intervened between the
parties also cannot be accepted as a ground for reversal of the decree. There is
no inflexible rule that every person who participated in a matrimonial mediation
must necessarily be examined. The Court has to assess the evidence actually
adduced. In the present case, PWs.2 and 3 have spoken about the efforts made
for reconciliation and their evidence substantially corroborates the testimony of
PW.1. The absence of evidence from some other elders or mediators is therefore
not fatal to the petitioner‟s case.
q)
The learned counsel for the respondent also contended that the evidence
of the respondent and her witnesses was not properly appreciated. This Court
has independently considered their evidence. The allegations made by the
respondent regarding dowry harassment and physical ill-treatment were
specifically denied by the petitioner. Apart from the interested testimony of the
respondent, the material placed on record does not establish, on the
preponderance of probabilities, that the petitioner‟s conduct furnished a
reasonable cause for the respondent‟s continued withdrawal from the
matrimonial relationship. The evidence of RWs.2 and 3 does not materially
displace the evidence of PWs.1 to 3 regarding the attempts made to restore
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
cohabitation. Even as per the admissions of RWs.2 and 3 who are independent
witnesses, mediators and others went to the house of parents of respondents to
join the petitioner to lead marital life.
r)
Matrimonial proceedings cannot be decided merely on the basis of isolated
allegations or on the assumption that either party is necessarily at fault because
the marriage has failed. The Court is required to examine the conduct of both
parties and determine whether the statutory requirements have been established.
In the present case, the evidence, when considered cumulatively, shows that the
petitioner made efforts to restore their marital bond, the respondent did not return
to the matrimonial home, that the parties remained separate for a prolonged
period, and that reconciliation efforts did not yield any result. The conduct of the
respondent, in the circumstances established on record, amounts to cruelty and
also constitutes desertion within the meaning of Section 13(1)(ia) and (ib) of the
Act. Hence, the point No.1 is answered accordingly.
12. POINT No.2:
The decree of dissolution of marriage granted by the learned Judge,
Family Court, Visakhapatnam, though supported by reasons which require
correction to the extent indicated above, is sustainable on an independent
reappreciation of the evidence and application of the statutory provisions. This
Court find no sufficient ground to interfere with the ultimate conclusion of the
DEV, J & SUN, J
FCA_253_2008
Family Court.
Hence, this point is answered in favour of the petitioner and
against the respondent.
13.
In the Result, the Family Court Appeal is dismissed. The decree and order
dated 20.10.2008 passed in O.P. No.593 of 2006 by the learned Judge, Family
Court, Visakhapatnam dissolving the marriage between the petitioner and
respondent are hereby confirmed. There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel thereto, pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand
closed.
________________________
JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
_________________________
JUSTICE SUNITHA GANDHAM
25-09-2026
knl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review