Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SYED
ROSHAN
ZAMIR
ALI
Digitally
signed by
SYED
ROSHAN
ZAMIR
ALI
2026:CGHC:17320
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 7986 of 2024
1. R.K. Chalisgaonkar S/o Shri Late Krishnarao Chalisgaonkar
Aged About 72 Years R/o C/92, Shri Ji Madhuban Amlidih,
Rajendra Nagar, Raipur, District- Raipur, Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner
versus
1. Employees
Provident
Fund
Organization
Through
Commissioner, Regional Office, Block-D, Scheme-32, Indira
Gandhi Commercial Complex, Pandri, Raipur, District Raipur
(Chhattisgarh)
2. Chhattisgarh State Co-Operative Dairy Federation Through
Its Managing Director, Urla, Post Bmy Charouda, DistrictDurg, Chhattisgarh
3. Additional Central Provident Fund Commissioner (Mpcg)
Employees Provident Fund Organisation, Zonal OfficeBhavishya Nidhi Bhawan, 59 Arera Hill, Bhopal, DistrictBhopal (M.P.)
... Respondents
WPS No. 7731 of 2024
1. Pradeep Kumar Sur S/o Shri N.K. Sur Aged About 72 Years
R/o Village - Bhagutola, Kawardha Rajnandgaon Road
Kawardha District - Kabirdham (C.G.)
--- Petitioner
versus
1. Employees
Provident
Fund
Organization
Through
Commissioner, Regional Office Block -D, Scheme - 32, Indira
Gandhi Commercial Complex, Pandri Raipur District - Raipur
(C.G.)
2. Chhattisgarh State Co- Operative Dairy Federation Through
Its Managing Director, Urla Post Bmy Charouda, District Durg (C.G.)
3. Additional Central Provident Fund Commissioner (M.P.C.G.)
Employees
Provident
Fund
Organization
Zonal
Office
Bhavishya Nidhi Bhawan 59 Arera Hills Bhopal, District Bhopal (M.P.)
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 8148 of 2024
1. Bhagwati Verma S/o Chowa Ram Verma Aged About 68
Years R/o Village Kandul, Sunder Nagar Raipur District Raipur (C.G.)
---Petitioner
Versus
1. Employees
Provident
Fund
Organization
Through
Commissioner Regional Office Block- D Scheme - 32 Indira
Gandhi Commerical Complex Pandri Raipur District - Raipur
(C.G.)
2. Chhattisgarh State Co- Operative Dairy Federation Through
Its Managing Director Urla Post Bmy Charouda District - Durg
(C.G.)
3. Additional Central Provident Fund Commissioner (Mpcg) ,
Employees Provident Fund Organisation Zonal Office Bhavishya Nidhi Bhawan 59 Arera Hill Bhopal District Bhopal (Mp)
--- Respondents
WPS No. 8165 of 2024
1. Kiran Sharma S/o Shri Uttam Prasad Sharma Aged About 69
Years R/o H.I.G.- 1/1 To 11, Deen Dayal Upadhyay Nagar,
Raipur, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
---Petitioner
Versus
1. Employees
Provident
Fund
Organization
Through
Commissioner, Regional Office, Block- D, Scheme- 32, Indira
Gandhi Commercial Complex, Pandri, Raipur, District :
Raipur, Chhattisgarh
2. Chhattisgarh State Co-Operative Dairy Federation Through
Its Managing Director, Urla, Post B.M.Y. Charouda, District :
Durg, Chhattisgarh
3. Additional Central Provident Fund Commissioner (M.P.C.G.)
Employees Provident Fund Organisation, Zonal OfficeBhavishya Nidhi Bhawan, 59 Arera Hill, Bhopal, District :
Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh
--- Respondents
WPS No. 8138 of 2024
1. Komal Lal Patel S/o Shri Jhaduram Patel Aged About 68
Years R/o House No. 111, Durgapara, Santoshi Nagar, Durga
Mandir Ke Pass, Raipur, District - Raipur, C.G.
---Petitioner
Versus
1. Employees
Provident
Fund
Organization
Through
Commissioner, Regional Office, Block- D, Scheme-32, Indira
Gandhi, Block-D, Scheme-32, Indira Gandhi Commercial
Complex, Pandri, Raipur, District Raipur, C.G.
2. Chhattisgarh State Co-Operative Dairy Federation Through
Its Managing Director, Urla, Post B M Y Charouda, DistrictDurg, C.G.
3. Additional Central Provident Fund Commissioner (M P C G)
Employees Provident Fund Organisation, Zonal OfficeBhavishya Nidhi Bhawan, 59 Arera Hill, Bhopal, DistrictBhopal, M.P.
--- Respondents
WPS No. 8155 of 2024
1. Sunil Koltey S/o Shri Dinkar Rao Koltey Aged About 71 Years
R/o 204, Balaji Homes Vishal Nagar, Raipur, District Raipur,
Chhattisgarh.
---Petitioner
Versus
1. Employees
Providen
Fund
Organization
Through
Commissioner, Regional Office, Block -D, Scheme-32, Indira
Gandhi Commercial Complex, Pandri, Raipur, District Raipur,
Chhattisgarh.
2. Chhattisgarh State Co-Operative Dairy Federation, Through
Its Managing Director, Urla, Post Bmy Charouda, District Durg, Chhattisgarh.
3. Additional Central Provident Fund Commisstioner (Mpcg),
Employees Provident Fund Organisation, Zonal Office Bhavishya Nidhi Bhawan, 59 Arera Hill, Bhopal, District Bhopal (M.P.).
--- Respondents
WPS No. 7993 of 2024
1. Mahendra Kumar Bhanwar S/o Shri Ram Prasad Bhanwar
Aged About 70 Years R/o Patel Gali, Mahamai Para, Purani
Basti, Raipur, District- Raipur, C.G.
--- Petitioner
versus
1. Employees
Provident
Fund
Organization
Through
Commissioner, Regional Office, Block- D, Scheme-32, Indira
Gandhi Commercial Complex, Pandri, Raipur, District Raipur,
C.G
2. Chhattisgarh State Co-Operative Dairy Federation Through
Its Managing Director, Urla, Post B M Y Charouda, DistrictDurg, C.G.
3. Additional Cenral Provident Fund Commissioner (M P C G)
Employees Provident Fund Organisation, Zonal OfficeBhavishya Nidhi Bhawan, 59 Arera Hill, Bhopal, DistrictBhopal, M.P.
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 8139 of 2024
1. B. Bhaskar Reddi S/o B. Venkat Swamy Aged About 68 Years
R/o Panchshil Nagar West Ward No. 17, Bmy Charoda Durg
District - Durg (C.G.)
---Petitioner
Versus
1. Employee Provideng Fund Through Commissioner Regional
Office Block - D Scheme - 32 Indira Gandhi Commercial
Complex Pandri Raipur District - Raipur (C.G.)
2. Chhattisgarh State Co- Operative Dairy Federation Through
Its Managing Director Urla Post Bmy Charouda District - Durg
(C.G.)
3. Additional Central Provident Fund Commissioner (Mpcg)
Employees
Provident
Fund
Organisation
Zonal
Office
Bhavishya Nidhi Bhawan 59 Arera Hill Bhopal District Bhopal (M.P.)
--- Respondents
WPS No. 7997 of 2024
1. C.L. Suman S/o Shri Brij Lal Suman Aged About 73 Years R/o
Mig B - 03, Sahyog Park, Mahavir Nagar, Raipur, District
Raipur Chhattisgarh.
--- Petitioner
versus
1. Employees
Provident
Fund
Organization
Through
Commissioner, Regional Office, Block - D, Scheme - 32,
Indira Gandhi Commercial Complex, Pandri, Raipur, District
Raipur Chhattisgarh.
2. Chhattisgarh State Co - Operative Dairy Federation Through
Its Managing Director, Urla, Post Bmy Charouda, District Durg
Chhattisgarh.
3. Additional Central Provident Fund Commissioner (Mpcg)
Employees Provident Fund Organisation, Zonal Office Bhavishya Nidhi Bhawan, 59 Arera Hill, Bhopal, District
Bhopal (M.P.).
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 8009 of 2024
1. Dilip Kumar Khandwe S/o Late S. G. Khandwe Aged About 70
Years R/o B-6, Harikishan Kunj, Vasant Corner, Avanti Vihar,
Telibandha, Raipur, District - Raipur, C.G.
--- Petitioner
versus
1. Employees
Provident
Fund
Organization
Through
Commissioner, Regional Office, Block-D, Scheme-32, Indira
Gandhi Commercial Complex, Pandri, Raipur, District Raipur,
C.G.
2. Chhattisgarh State Co-Operative Dairy Federation Through
Its Managing Director, Urla, Post B M Y Charouda, DistrictDurg, C.G.
3. Additional Central Provident Fund Commissioner (M P C G)
Employees Provedent Fund Organisation, Zonal OfficeBhavishya Nidhi Bhawan, 59 Arera Hill, Bhopal, DistrictBhopal, M.P.
--- Respondents
WPS No. 8508 of 2024
1. V.K. Samuel S/o Shri Saniel Samuel Aged About 69 Years R/o
Plot No. 34, New Adarsh Nagar, Potiyakala, Durg, District
Durg Chhattisgarh.
--- Petitioner
versus
1. Employees
Provident
Fund
Organization,
Through
Commissioner, Regional Office, Block - D, Scheme - 32,
Indira Gandhi Commercial Complex, Pandri, Raipur, District
Raipur Chhattisgarh.
2. Chhattisgarh State Co - Operative Dairy Federation Through
Its Managing Director, Urla, Post Bmy Charouda, District Durg
Chhattisgarh.
3. Additional Central Provident Fund Commissioner (Mpcg)
Employees Provident Fund Organisation, Zonal Office Bhavishya Nidhi Bhawan, 59 Arera Hill, Bhopal, District
Bhopal Madhya Pradesh.
--- Respondents
WPS No. 8511 of 2024
1. Chhedilal Sharma S/o Gayadin Sharma Aged About 70 Years
R/o Ward No. 11, Nagar Panchayat Sargaon Tahsil Pandariya District- Mungeli (C.G.)
... Petitioner
versus
1. Employees
Provident
Fund
Organization
Through
Commissioner Regional Office Block - D, Scheme - 32, Indira
Gandhi Commercial Complex Pandri Raipur District - Raipur
(C.G.)
2. Zila Sahkari Kendriya Bank Maryadit Bilaspur Through Chief
Executive Officer Bilaspur District - Bilaspur (C.G.)
... Respondents
For Petitioner
For respective Respondents
: Mr. SP Sannat and Mr. Yogesh Sharma,
Advocates
: Mr. Sunil Pillai, Advocate with Mr. Vishal
Sahu, Advocate; Mr. Animesh Pathak,
Advocate on behalf of Mr. Amrito Das,
Advocate; Ms. Seema Verma, Advocate
SB: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Parth Prateem Sahu
Order on Board
15.04.2026
1. As the issue involved in above writ petitions are inextricably
interlinked, therefore, they are heard together and are being
decided by way of this common order.
2. Common prayer of the petitioners in this bunch of writ
petitions, who retired from service prior to 2014, is for grant of
pension on the basis of actual salary drawn by them instead
of calculating the same on the basis of ceiling fixed on the
maximum wages. For the sake of convenience, facts of WPS
No.7986/2024 are being referred hereinafter.
3. Facts of the case, in brief, are that petitioner was employee of
respondent No.2-Federation and retired from service on
08.12.2010 upon attaining age of 58 years. The employees of
respondent No.2 are covered by the Employees Provident
Funds and Miscellaneous Provision Act, 1952 (for short ‘the
Act of 1952’) and the Employees Pension Scheme 1995 (for
short ‘the Scheme of 1995’).
After retirement, pension of
petitioner was fixed at Rs.1745/- per month by respondent
No.1. Pursuant to the order passed by Hon’ble Supreme
Court in RC Gupta & Ors vs Regional Provident Fund
Commissioner Employees Provident Fund Organization &
Ors, reported in (2018) 14 SCC 809, declaring that there was
no cutoff date for exercising option for higher pension in
proviso to paragraph 11 (3) of the Scheme of 1995, as it
stood before the 2014 amendment, respondent No.1 issued
Circular dated 23.3.2017 inviting option from the members
who had contributed on higher wages exceeding the statutory
wage ceiling of Rs.6500/- to divert 8.33% of the salary
exceeding Rs.6500/- to the pension fund with upto date
interest as declared under the Scheme of 1952. This circular
further mentions about return of all such amounts that the
concerned employees may have taken or withdrawn from
their Provident Fund Account before granting them benefits of
amended Scheme of 1995.
4. Based on the aforementioned Circular dated 23.3.2017, the
petitioner applied for revision of his pension and accordingly,
pension payable to the petitioner stood revised on 11.10.2018
after obtaining additional contribution of Rs.2,01,096/- from
him, which was deposited by petitioner with respondent No.1
on 7.9.2018. Thereafter, petitioner had been receiving
Rs.22,265/- as monthly pension, however, respondent No.1
vide order impugned cancelled the revised PPO which was
issued in favour of petitioner and has reduced monthly
pension to Rs.2887/-.
5. Learned counsel for petitioner submits that case of petitioner
is covered with the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in
case of R.C. Gupta (supra) wherein Hon’ble Supreme Court
has considered that pre-amended provision under Clause 11
(3) of the Employees Pension Scheme which provides no
ceiling limit to submit option and further considered that the
Scheme of 1995 is a beneficial scheme and therefore, benefit
is to be extended. It is also contention of learned counsel for
petitioner that initially amount @ 12% is deducted from the
salary of petitioner and 12% of actual salary is also
contributed by employer. After coming into force of amended
provisions and decision in case of RC Gupta (supra),
respondent
No.1-EPFO
issued
a
circular
asking
the
employees to submit their option for pension under the
Scheme of 1952.
Accordingly, petitioner submitted option
before the employer along with declaration which was
forwarded by the employer to respondent No.1. Petitioner
was accordingly paid higher pension and arrears of pension
from the date of exit from membership. He further contended
that by impugned order/letter respondent No.1 has again
asked the petitioner to submit documents or certificates
showing that he has given option in view of pre-amended
provisions of Section 11 (3) of the Scheme of 1995. When
respondent No.1 stopped higher pension to petitioner, he
preferred writ petition bearing WPS No.1981/2022 before the
High Court, which was allowed quashing the decision of
revision of pension of petitioner and also directed respondent
No.1 to take appropriate steps after decision of review petition
filed before the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of The
Employees Provident Fund Organization and another vs Sunil
Kumar B, reported in (2023) 12 SCC 701 (erroneously
mentioned in the order as ‘RC Gupta’). He also submits that
in case of Sunil Kumar B (supra) also Hon’ble Supreme Court
has observed that exercising of option before 1.9.2014 stands
crystallized in case of RC Gupta (supra) and further made
observation that the Scheme as it stood before 1.9.2014 did
not provide for any cut off date and thus those members shall
be entitled to exercise option in terms of Para-11 (4) of the
scheme, as it stands at present. In that decision, Hon’ble
Supreme Court has extended the time to exercise option
under Para 11 (4) of the Scheme by a further period of four
months. As petitioner has already submitted option in the
year 2018, therefore, petitioner is entitled for benefit of the
observation of Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Sunil Kumar
B (supra). Hence, respondent No.1 be directed to again
revised the pension of petitioner and to pay higher pension
along with arrears.
6. Learned counsel for respondent No.1 vehemently opposes
submission of learned counsel for petitioner and submits that
on the date of decision in case of RC Gupta (supra) as also
Sunil Kumar B (supra), petitioner was not member of the
Scheme of 1955 as he exited the scheme of pension after
attaining age of 58 years much before 1.9.2014 as also
retired from service upon attaining age of superannuation,
therefore, petitioner cannot be permitted to reap the benefit of
judgment of RC Gupta (supra). Hon’ble Supreme Court in
case of RC Gupta (supra) does not contemplate exercise of
provisions of Paragraph 11(3) of the Scheme of 1995 for a
retired employee which otherwise would frustrate the real
import of the proviso to Paragraph 11(3), rendering the
proviso redundant.
Benefit of exercise of option which is observed in case
of Sunil Kumar B (supra) is only for existing members on
1.9.2014.
Referring to Para 50.7 of the decision in Sunil
Kumar B (supra), it is submitted that Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the aforementioned decision has clarified the position with
regard to status of the employees who existed the
membership/ scheme or stood retired prior to 1.9.2014.
He next contended that in Para 50 (7) of decision in
Sunil Kumar B (supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court has clearly
observed that the employees who had retired prior to
1.9.2014 without exercising any option under Para 11 (3) of
the pre-amended scheme have already exited from the
membership thereof and therefore, they would not be entitled
to the benefit of this judgment.
He also contended that
according to the scheme, employee upon attaining age of 58
years exists from the scheme and on that date he is being
paid entire deposits along with all other benefits of the
scheme. Petitioner has also been granted all such benefits
after attaining the age of 58 years and he has enjoyed said
benefits. He further submits that under amended para 11.4 of
the Scheme of Pension, it is clearly envisaged that benefit is
extended only to existing members.
Referring to definition of ‘member’ given under sub-para
(ix) of Para 2 of the Scheme of 1995, he pressed upon
explanation appended to Para-2 (ix) to submit that employee
after attaining age of 58 years ceases to be a member of
pension fund and therefore, subsequent amendment though
beneficial to employees cannot be extended to petitioner
being ceased to be member of pension scheme and the
benefit under the scheme and amended provision will be
available only to existing members as on 1.9.2014.
7. He next contended that though respondent No.1 has issued
circular and given higher pension and arrears thereof, but it
was due to mistake as decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court
could not be understood in appropriate manner. Said mistake
was subsequently corrected. He submits that misconception
with regard to the provisions as also misunderstanding of
decision in case of RC Gupta (supra) is only because the
Division Bench of High Court of Kerala has set aside
Employees Pension Amendment Scheme 2014.
However,
amendment brought in Employees Pension Scheme has been
held to be valid in case of Sunil Kumar B (supra) in Para 44 (I)
by Hon’ble Supreme Court.
8. He also contended that retired employees of the Power Grid
Corporation have approached Hon’ble Supreme Court for
extending benefit of case of RC Gupta (supra), seeking
implementation of direction given by Hon’ble Supreme Court
in case of RC Gupta (supra) and upheld in Sunil Kumar B
(supra), in the said proceeding Hon’ble Supreme Court has
observed that the claim as made therein and the arguments
to be misconceived. It is further observed that employees
therein are ineligible for the reason that they had retired prior
to 2014. It is also pointed out that in that case Hon’ble Court
has further taken note of the fact that petitioners therein stood
retired prior to 1.9.2014 without exercising option under preamended scheme and dismissed the applications. Case of
petitioner herein is squarely covered with the aforementioned
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
9. I have heard learned counsel for respective parties and
perused the documents available in record of writ petition.
10. A proviso came to be inserted in Paragraph 11 (3) of the
Scheme of 1955 w.e.f. 16.03.1996, whereby an option was
given to the employer and employee to contribute beyond
ceiling limit i.e. Rs. 6,500/- per month from the date of
commencement of the scheme or from the date salary excess
Rs.6500/-, whichever is later. Pursuant to above amendment,
when some employees covered under the Scheme of 1995
have not been allowed to exercise the option under Section
11 (3) by the provident fund authorities on the ground that the
employees who want to contribute beyond ceiling were bound
to exercise option within stipulated time and whosoever had
not filed option within time is not eligible to contribute beyond
the ceiling, they preferred a writ petition before the High Court
of Himachal Pradesh, which was decided in favour of
petitioner-employees therein, against which an intra court
appeal was filed by the Department before the Division Bench
and the order passed by learned Single Judge was set aside
by the Division Bench upholding the view of the Provident
Fund Authority that under the proviso to Clause 11(3) of the
Pension Scheme there was a cut-off date. Thereafter the
matter went up to the Supreme Court in an appeal, which
came to be registered as Civil Appeal (S) No.10013-
10014/2016 (RC Gupta and others Vs. Regional Provident
Fund Commissioner Employees Provident Fund Organization
and Others). Said appeal came to be decided on 4.10.2016
and the cut off date which was fixed by the department was
set aside. Relevant paragraph of the decision in RC Gupta’s
case (supra) is extracted herein below for ready reference:“7. Reading the proviso, we find that the
reference to the date of commencement of the
Scheme or the date on which the salary exceeds
the ceiling limit are dates from which the option
exercised are to be reckoned with for calculation
of pensionable salary. The said dates are not
cut-off dates to determine the eligibility of the
employer-employee to indicate their option under
the proviso to Clause 11(3) of the Pension
Scheme. A somewhat similar view that has been
taken by this Court in a matter coming from the
Kerala High Court, wherein the Special Leave
Petition (C) No.7074 of 2014 filed by the
Regional Provident Fund Commissioner was
rejected by this Court by order dated 31.03.2016.
A beneficial Scheme, in our considered view,
ought not to be allowed to be defeated by
reference to a cut-off date, particularly, in a
situation where (as in the present case) the
employer had deposited 12% of the actual salary
and not 12% of the ceiling limit of Rs.5,000/- or
Rs.6,500/- per month, as the case may be.
11.
Pursuant to judgment in R.C. Gupta’s case (supra), the
respondent EPFO vide Circular dated 23.03.2017 invited
applications for exercising option and the employees as per
said judgment returned contribution received from provident
fund, they also filed option, which was accepted and acted
upon by respondent authorities in terms of provision of
Paragraph 11 (3) of the Scheme of 1995. Respondent EPFO
thereafter revised pension as well as released arrears to
employees across the country. Pension payable to the
petitioner herein also stood revised after obtaining additional
contribution from the petitioner which was deposited with
respondent No.1.
12. In the interregnum, respondent No.1 vide Notification dated
22.8.2014, enhanced the wage ceiling from Rs.6,500/- to
Rs.15,000/- by amending Para-11 of the Scheme of 1995;
deleted the proviso thereto and also inserted sub-para (4) in
Para-11, which reads as under:“(4) The existing members as on the 1st day of
September, 2014, who at the option of the employer
and employee, had been contributing on salary
exceeding six thousand and five hundred rupees per
month, may on a fresh option to be exercised jointly
by the employer and employee continue to contribute
on salary exceeding fifteen thousand rupees per
month and the pensionable salary for the existing
members who prefer such fresh option shall be based
on the higher salary]:
Provided that the aforesaid members have to
contribute at the rate of 1.16 per cent on salary
exceeding fifteen thousand rupees as an additional
contribution from and out of the contributions payable
by the employees for each month under the provisions
of the Act or the rules made thereunder:
Provided further that the fresh option shall be
exercised by the member within a period of six months
from the 1st day of September, 2014:
Provided also that the period specified in the second
proviso may, on sufficient cause being shown by the
member, be extended by the Regional Provident Fund
Commissioner for a further period not exceeding six
months:
Provided also if no option is exercised by the member
within such period (including the extended period), it
shall be deemed that the member has not opted for
contribution over wage ceiling and the contributions to
the Pension Fund made over the wage ceiling in
respect of the member shall be diverted to the
Provident Fund account of the member along with
interest as declared under the Employees' Provident
Funds Scheme from time to time.”
13.
As per the amendment brought to the Employees Pension
Scheme 1995, which came into effect from 01.09.2014, the
ceiling of maximum pensionable salary provided in Paragraph
11 (3) was raised to Rs.15,000/- per month.
Proviso
appended to Paragraph 11 (3) has been deleted with effect
from 01.9.2014 and sub-para (4) is introduced in Paragraph
11 which provides that existing members as on 1.9.2014, who
at the option of the employer and employee, had been
continuing on salary exceeding six thousand and five hundred
rupees per month, may on a fresh option to be exercised
jointly by the employer and employee continue to contribute
on salary exceeding Rs.15,000/- per month and pensionable
salary for the existing members who prefer such fresh option
shall be based on the higher salary. The option could be
submitted within further period of six months, in case the
authority under the Act found sufficient reasons therefor. This
amendment also introduced a deeming clause whereby
failure to exercise the option within the stipulated period of six
months from 01.09.2014, further extended by six months on
showing sufficient cause by the existing member, shall result
in automatic exclusion from the benefit of higher pension, with
excess contribution being diverted back to Provident Fund.
14.
Issue of applicability of paragraph 11(4) of the Scheme of
1995, which came into force with effect from 01.09.2014,
came up for consideration before the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in EPFO & Anr. Vs. Sunil Kumar B. & Ors., (2023) 12 SCC
701. It was observed as under:"50.4. The members of the Scheme, who did not
exercise option, as contemplated in the proviso
to Para 11(3) of the Pension Scheme (as it was
before the 2014 Amendment) would be entitled
to exercise option under Para 11(4) of the post
amendment Scheme. Their right to exercise
option before 1-9-2014 stands crystallized in the
judgment of this Court in R.C. Gupta. The
Scheme as it stood before 1-9-2014 did not
provide for any cut-off date and thus those
members shall be entitled to exercise option in
terms of Para 11(4) of the Scheme, as it stands
at present. Their exercise of option shall be in
the
nature
of
joint
options
covering
pre-
amended Para 11(3) as also the amended Para
11(4) of the Pension Scheme.
50.7. The employees who had retired prior to
1-9-2014 without exercising any option under
Para 11(3) of the pre-amendment Scheme have
already exited from the membership thereof.
They would not be entitled to the benefit of this
judgment.
50.8. The employees who have retired before
1-9-2014 upon exercising option under Para
11(3) of the 1995 Scheme shall be covered by
the provisions of Para 11(3) of the Pension
Scheme as it stood prior to the amendment of
2014."
15.
From perusal of above quoted portion of decision in case of
Sunil Kumar B (supra) it is clear that the members of the
Scheme
of
1995,
who
did
not
exercise
option,
as
contemplated in the proviso to Para 11(3) of the Scheme of
1995 (as it was before 2014 Amendment) would be entitled to
exercise option under Para 11(4) of the post amendment
Scheme and the employees who had retired prior to 1-9-2014
without exercising any option under Para 11(3) of the preamendment
Scheme
have
already
exited
from
the
membership thereof, they would not be entitled to the benefit
of this judgment. In other words, all the employees who
without filing option under proviso to Para 11 (3) of the
Scheme of 1995 had retired prior to 01.09.2014 but have filed
option after the decision of Hon’ble Court in case of R.C.
Gupta (supra) are not entitled to revised higher pension.
16.
Relying on the observation of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Para
46 (v) and (vi) of the judgment rendered in case of Sunil
Kumar B’s case (supra), the respondent No.1 decided that
the employees who retired prior to 1.9.2014 without
exercising option under Paragraph 11 (3) are not entitled to
higher amount of pension. Accordingly, circular dated
29.12.2022 and 20.2.2023 have been issued calling upon the
employees to apply online/digitally for validation of their
option. Requirements for validation of joint option are that it
must contain the proof of remittance of employer’s share in
Provident Fund on higher wages exceeding the prevalent
wage ceiling of Rs.5,000/6500 and proof of joint option under
para 11 (3) as also Para 26 (6) of the Scheme of 1955 duly
verified by the employer.
Since petitioner-employee, who
retired prior to 1.9.2014, did not submit proof of the exercise
of joint option under erstwhile para 11 (3) of the Scheme of
1995 and also proof of remittance in provident fund on higher
wages exceeding the prevalent wage ceiling despite above
repeated circulars, respondent No.1 reopened the case of
petitioner-employee and vide impugned order reduced
monthly pension of the petitioner.
17.
Hence, the question arises for determination in this petition is
whether an employee, who retired prior to 01.09.2014,
without having exercised a joint option under the proviso to
Paragraph 11 (3) of pre-amendment Scheme of 1995, during
his/her service, is entitled to the benefit of higher pension?
18.
The Employees' Pension (Amendment) Scheme, 2014 was
notified on 22.8.2014 and brought into force with effect from
01-09-2014. Effect of the amendment in 2014 was that
maximum pensionable salary was increased from Rs.6500/to 15000/-; proviso to sub-para (3) of Para 11 enabling
members to contribute in excess of the contribution due on
the maximum pensionable salary was deleted and a new subpara (4) was added to Para-11 to deal with cases of existing
members who had been contributing on actual salary as on
01.09.2014 by providing them an option (to be exercised in
the manner prescribed) to continue to pay contributions with
reference to their actual salary.
19. At this stage, it is necessary to have a look at the definition of
‘existing member’ and ‘member’ provided in the Scheme of
1995. ‘Existing Member’ is defined in Section 2 (vi) of the
Scheme of 1995, which reads as under:“(vi)
“existing
member”
means
an
existing
employee who is a member of the Employees’
Family Pension Scheme, 1971.”
20. ‘Member’ is defined under Section 2 (ix), which reads as
under:-
“(ix) ‘member’ means an employee who becomes a
member
of
the
Employees
Pension
Fund
in
accordance with the provisions of this Scheme:
Explanation:- An employee shall cease to be the
member of Pension Fund from the date of attaining
58 years of age or from the date of vesting
admissible benefits under the Scheme, whichever is
earlier.”
21. From perusal of explanation appended to the definition of
‘member’ given in Para-2 (ix) of the Scheme of 1995 it is clear
that, an employee shall cease to be the member of Pension
Fund from the date of attaining 58 years of age or from the
date of vesting admissible benefits under the Scheme,
whichever is earlier. Thus, it is clear that amendment brought
in the Scheme of 1995 in the year 2014 by which proviso to
Clause 11(3) of the Scheme of 1995 was deleted w.e.f.
01/09/2014, was in relation to the existing members i.e. those
who were in still in service as on 01.09.2014 and not retired.
Hence, benefit of proviso cannot be extended to any
employee after 01/09/2014 if he had not exercised the option
earlier and ceases to be a member of the Pension Fund.
22.
In case of Sunil Kumar B (supra), Hon'ble Supreme Court,
while dealing with issue of applicability of amendment made
in the year 2014, has held that those employees who had
retired prior to 1.9.2014 without exercising any option under
paragraph 11 (3) of pre-amended scheme, besides had
already exited from the membership thereof, they would not
be entitled to benefit of the judgment passed in R.C. Gupta's
case (supra) nor they would become entitle to the pension
scheme (amended) of 2014. It was further held that the
existing members of the scheme or those who had not
superannuated at the time of coming into force of 2014
amendment, if they had earlier not exercised option in terms
of the proviso to paragraph 11 (3) of the Scheme of 1995,
they would be entitled to exercise option under paragraph 11
(4) of the post amended scheme.
23.
Recently, in Writ Petition (Civil) No.97 of 2025, parties being
Powergrid Retired Employees’ Association (PREA) vs Union
of India and others, decided on 19.3.2025, Hon’ble Supreme
Court has reiterated that the employees, who retired prior to
01.09.2024 without exercising their option under paragraph
11(3) of the pre-amendment scheme, are not entitled to the
benefits of amendment brought in 2014.
24.
In case at hand, from the pleadings and submissions made
on behalf of respective parties, it transpires that the petitioner
herein retired before 01.09.2014 without exercising the option
under Para 11 (3) of the Scheme of 1995. Para 11 (3) of the
Scheme of 1995 which relates to joint option for higher
contribution for pension funds stood deleted w.e.f. 1.9.2014.
Petitioner submitted option admittedly only after decision in
case of R.C. Gupta (supra), in the year 2018. Para 11 (4) of
the Scheme of 1995, introduced on 1.9.2014, provides that
fresh option shall be exercised by the existing member within
a period of six months from 01.09.2014. Petitioner also failed
to produce any material before the respondent department or
this Court indicating that petitioner submitted option being
member under the Scheme or prior to 1.9.2014, under Para
11 (3) of the Scheme of 1995 and pursuant thereto, there was
remittance in pension fund on higher wages exceeding the
prevalent wage ceiling of Rs.5000-6500/-. Thus, in the
considered opinion of this Court,
withdrawal of benefit of
higher pension of the petitioner on the ground that he had
retired prior to 01.09.2014 without filing their option, does not
call for any interference in light of decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in cases of Sunil Kumar B. (supra) and
Powergrid Corporation (supra).
25.
For the foregoing reason and discussions, in the considered
opinion of this Court, the writ petitions have no merits, the
same are liable to be and are hereby dismissed.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
roshan/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review