Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010888702018 IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA
PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3505]
THURSDAY,THE SECOND DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO:
3062/2018
Between:
1. V DINESH REDDY, S/O V.SRINIVASULU REDDY AGED
ABOUT 21 YEARS, R/O UCHINAIDU KANDRIGA
PALLAMALA
VILLAGE,
B.N.KANDRIGA
MANDAL,
CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. VIKAS ENGLISH MEDIUM SCHOOL, REP. BY ITS
CORREPSONDENT SMT. P.RENUKA RESIDING AT
D.NO. 1-186C, B.N.KANDRIGA, B.N.KANDRIGA MANDAL,
CHITTOOR DISTRICT, OWNER OF SCHOOL BU
BEARING NO.AP-03-W-9878.
2. M/S UNITED INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED,
TIRUPATI, REP. BY ITS DIVISIONAL MANAGER,
HOLDING ITS OFFICE AT ROOM NO.7 AND 8, 1ST
FLOOR, SRIDEVI COMPLEX, TILAK ROAD TIRUPATI,
CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC praying thet the
Highcourt may be pleased toto present this Memorandum of
Motor Accidents Civil Miscellaneous Appeal, having been
aggrieved by the Judgment and Decree passed in M.V.O.P.No.
122 of 2013 dt. 10-9-2018 on the file of the Chairman, Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-X Addl. District Judge, Tirupati, for
the following
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. K MOHAN RAMI REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. SRINIVASA RAO VUTLA
2.
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL
NO: 74/2019
Between:
1. UBITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD, REP. BY ITS
DIVISIONAL MANAGER, TIRUPATI, CHITTOOR
DISTRICT
...APPELLANT
AND
1. V DINESH REDDY, R/O.BUCHINAIDU KANDRIGA,
PALAMALA VILLAGE, CHITTOOR DISTRICT
2. VIKAS ENGLISH MEDIUM SCHOOL, REP. BY ITS
CORRESPOSNDENT SMT. P.RENUKA,D.NO. 1-186C, B.N.KANDRIGA VILLAGE, CHITTOOR DIST
...RESPONDENT(S)
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Court
aggrieved by the decree and judgment passed in MVOP.
122 of 2013 dated 10-9-2018 on the file of the Motor
Accidents Claims tribunal - cum - X Addl. District Judge, at
Tirupathi
IA NO: 1 OF 2019
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the
petition, the High Court may be pleased
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. SRINIVASA RAO VUTLA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
The Court made the following:
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D. SEKHAR
MACMA No.3062 OF 2018
AND
MACMA No.74 OF 2019
JUDGMENT:-
1.
As these two (02) appeals are arising out of the
Judgment dated 10.09.2018 MVOP No.122 of 2013, on the file of
Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-X Additional
District Judge, Tirupati, there being disposed of by this common
Judgment.
2.
MACMA No.3062 of 2018 was filed by the claimant
for enhancement of compensation, whereas MACMA No.74 of
2019 was filed by the Insurance Company questioning the
compensation awarded by the Tribunal.
3.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred
to as, they were referred before the Tribunal.
4.
The petitioner filed a claim petition under Section
166(1)(a) of the Motor Accidents Act, 1988 and the Rules made
there under claiming compensation of Rs.25,00,000/- for the
injuries received by him in the accident that occurred on
08.03.2012,
in
which
the
offending
school
bus
bearing
Registration No.AP03 W 9878 was involved.
5.
It is the case of the petitioner he was studying X
standard in the first respondent school. On 08.03.2012 he
boarded the bus to go to school and when the offending reached
Arigala Kandriga Yanadi Centre, the driver of the offending bus
drove the same in rash and negligent manner at high speed,
thereby he lost control over the bus and it turned turtle on the
road. In view of the said mishap, the petitioner sustained crush
and degloving injuries on left forearm. The inmates of the bus
also sustained grievous injuries. Immediately, the petitioner was
taken to Area Hospital, Srikalahasthi for treatment, later he was
shifted to Both Hospital, Tirupati for better treatment. It was
further case of the petitioner that he undergone major surgery to
his left arm and he took treatment for four (04) months as in
patient in the said hospital. It was further stated that the petitioner
had to discontinue the studies and became permanently disabled,
which was assessed at 80%. It was further case of the petitioner
that in view of the injuries sustained by him, he is unable to attend
day to day activities and he became unfit for certain jobs and
therefore he approached the Tribunal claiming Rs.25,00,000/towards compensation under various heads.
6.
The 1st respondent remained Ex-parte. The 2nd
respondent resisted the claim, contending that the compensation
claimed by the petitioner was excessive inter alia denying the
averments made in the claim petition. It was also denied that the
driver of the 1st respondent had no valid driving license and the
offending bus had no permit and valid Registration Certificate as
on the date of accident. It was further contended that the
petitioner was not earning member and the injuries sustained by
him were in simple in nature which do not result in permanent
disability. It was also contended that the 2nd respondent would
indemnify the insured subject to confirmation of policy and the
driver had valid license etc.,
7.
In order to prove the case of the petitioner, he was
examined as PW-1 and the doctors who treated him were
examined as PWs-2 & 3. He also filed documents which were
marked as Exs.A1 to A12. On the other hand, the Insurance
Company filed the Insurance Policy, which was marked as B-1. It
had examined RWs-1 & 2 and Exs.C1 & C2 and Exs.X1 to X3
were marked through the witnesses. Considering the oral and
documentary evidence, the Tribunal by order under challenge
awarded compensation of Rs.9,55,500/- to the petitioner under
various heads together with interest @ 9% per annum from the
date of petition till the date of realization.
8.
Heard counsel for the claimant and counsel for the
Insurance Company. Despite service of notice, there is no
appearance for Vikas English Medium School.
9.
Perused the record.
10.
Though several grounds are raised in the appeal
filed by the Insurance Company, during the course of hearing, the
counsel for Insurance Company confined arguments as against
the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal by
contending that, the same is excessive and prayed to allow the
appeal filed by the Insurance Company.
11.
The counsel for the insurance company would
submit that the petitioner was not earning member of the family,
therefore the Tribunal ought not to have granted compensation of
Rs.9,55,500/-. He would further submit that the injuries received
by the petitioner were simple in nature and the Tribunal erred in
awarding the said amount. Further, it was argued that the
Tribunal placing reliance on the disability of the petitioner as 80%,
though the same is to a particular limb awarded excessive
compensation.
12.
On the other hand, the counsel for the claimant
would submit that the injuries received by the petitioner were
grievous in nature and to substantiate the same, reliance is
placed on wound certificate, which was marked as Ex.A3. He
would further submit that the petitioner underwent for several
surgeries and he was inpatient for a period of four (04) months.
He would also submit that in view of the injuries sustained by him,
he had to discontinue his studies. In support of his contention,
copies of discharge summary, a bunch of medical bills and
disability certificate were placed on record and the same were
marked as Exs.A5, A6, A9 and A10. Apart from the same, he also
placed digital photographs which were marked as Ex.A11 to show
the nature of injury sustained by him. He would further submit
that the petitioner is unable to move his left hand as he was
before. It was further argued that in view of his inability to lead
normal life, he lost the earning capacity and therefore he should
be adequately compensated for the loss suffered by him. He
would further submit that the Tribunal without taking all these
aspects into consideration, awarded a meager amount of
Rs.9,55,500/- as compensation, though he is entitled to receive
compensation as he claimed.
13.
A perusal of the evidence of Dr.P.Hari Prasad, who
was examined as PW-2, it is clear that the petitioner was
admitted in Both Hospital, Tirupati on 08.03.2012 crush and
degloving Injury to left forearm and he went surgery on the same
day, further the petitioner was also underwent surgery for
debridement and primary clousure + DLT flap coverage + split
thickness skin grafting under Anaesthia by plasting surgeon and
he was discharged on 26.03.2012. The evidence of PW-2 would
further disclose that the petitioner was again admitted on
09.04.2012 with the raw area in the left upper limb and he was
underwent surgery on the same day and the raw area is covered
with split thickness skin grafting and he was discharged on
14.04.2012. Again another surgery was conducted on 06.09.2012
for FDL release of ring and middle finger of the left hand and flap
advancement under Anaesthia and he was discharged on
08.09.2012. The discharge summary treated 05.09.2015 was
marked as Ex.C1. Subsequently, the petitioner was examined
clinically and radio logically and found that he is unable to extend
the rist and fingers and the disability was assessed as 80% to a
particular limb. The disability certificate was marked as Ex.C2.
14.
Further, Dr.R.Babu Rao was examined as PW-3,
who deposed that the petitioner having wrist drop (unable to
extend the hand) with contracture of the thumb. He further
deposed that the petitioner requires stabilization of the rist and
thumb realized. He further deposed that the petitioner suffered
disability of 80%. Though, PWs-2 & 3 were cross examined at
length, nothing was elicited to disprove their evidence.
15.
Further, the oral evidence adduced by RW-1 & RW-2
is in relation to the manner in which the accident was occurred
and with regard to the alleged violation of terms and conditions of
the insurance policy. Therefore, the evidence put forth by the
Insurance Company do not help to prove its case.
In the
circumstances, the contention of the counsel for the insurance
company cannot be accepted that the compensation awarded by
the Tribunal is excessive. Accordingly, the appeal preferred by
the Insurance Company is dismissed.
16.
As can be seen from the evidence of PW-2 & 3
coupled with the documents filed in the claim petition, there is no
dispute that the petitioner has sustained grievous injuries to his
left hand. Further, disability certificate dt.04.08.2017 would show
that the petitioner has suffered 80% of disability to his left hand.
By virtue of the said injury, the petitioner is unable to move his left
hand freely as it was before and he is facing difficulties in
attending day to day activities. From the above, it is clear that the
petitioner is not able to lead normal life as he was before and the
same cannot be restored. Therefore, the petitioner has to be
compensated adequately in fair, reasonable and equitable
manner by taking into consideration of the physical disability and
the loss suffered by him as a result of the said disability.
17.
A perusal of the order and challenge, the Tribunal did
not consider the case of the petitioner in its proper prospective
and the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case
of “Raj Kumar Vs. Ajay Kumar” 1 was not taken into
consideration. Further it is not in dispute that the petitioner was
studying 10th standard as on the date of accident and he had to
discontinue his studies.
(2011) 1 SCC 343
Further, the petitioner also lost his
earning capacity, marriage prospects etc. By taking into
consideration of all the above aspects, the income of the
petitioner is fixed as Rs.10,000/- per month and accordingly the
compensation is computed as under:
S.No.
Head
Compensation Awarded
Net monthly Income
Rs.10,000/-
Future Prospects (50%)
Rs.5,000/-
Total Income (Net monthly)
Rs.15,000/-
Multiplier
Disability
80%
Loss of future income
Medical Expenses
Loss of amenities pain and
suffering
Rs.2,00,000/-
Loss of marriage prospects
Rs.3,00,000/-
Attendant charges
Rs.2,00,000/-
TOTAL
Rs.35,87,392/-
(Treatment)
18.
Rs.15,000 x 12 x 18 x 80%
= Rs.25,92,000/Rs.2,95,392/-
For the reasons recorded supra, the appeal filed by
the claimant is allowed and the Insurance Company is directed to
pay Rs.35,87,392/- together with interest @ 9% from the date of
petition till the date of realization.
19.
It is needless to mention that the Insurance
Company is directed to pay the said compensation within a period
of two (02) months from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
20.
In the result, MACMA No.3062 of 2018 is allowed
and MACMA No.74 of 2019 is dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs. As a sequel, pending
applications, if any, shall stand closed.
______________________
JUSTICE T.C.D. SEKHAR
02.04.2026
DR
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D. SEKHAR
MACMA No.3062 OF 2018
AND
MACMA No.74 OF 2019
Date 02.04.2026
U
RMD/DR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review