Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010709872025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3603]
MONDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF AUGUST 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE D RAMESH
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 57/2026
Between:
1. V. ARFATH,, W/O. LATE V. BABA FAKRUDDIN, R/O. D.NO. 20/1049,
FLAT NO. 501, LAKSHMI SREENIVASA APARTMENT, RADHA
KRISHNA NAGAR, CO-OPERATIVE COLONY, KADAPA CITY, YSR
KADAPA DISTRICT-516001. ACTUALLY RESIDENT OF C-412, ARK
SERENE COUNTY, CHANNASANDRA MAIN ROAD, WHITEFIELD,
BANGALORE, 560067.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. N KRISHNA REDDY, S/O. N.C. VENKAT REDDY, AGED ABOUT 56
YEARS. OCCUPATION BUSINESS, R/O.
D.NO. 20/941, COOPERATIVE COLONY, KADAPA CITY, YSR DISTRICT-516001.
2. N BHARATHI, W/O. N. KRISHNA REDDY, AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
R/O. D.NO. 20/941, CO-OPERATIVE COLONY, KADAPA CITY, YSR
DISTRICT-516001.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. THOMMANDURU V SARADHI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. V R REDDY KOVVURI
The Court made the following JUDGMENT:
(per Hon’ble Sri Justice Alapati Giridhar)
1. The Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed against the Decree and Order
passed by the learned Principal District Judge, Kadapa, dated 07.10.2025 in
I.A.No.326 of 2025 in O.S.No.11 of 2025, assailing the grant of temporary
injunction restraining the Respondent from alienating the Petition schedule
property/2227.43 square yards of Plot No.193-B part of Industrial Plot till
disposal of the Suit.
2. For brevity, the parties will be referred to as the Plaintiffs and the
Defendant, as arrayed in the Trial Court.
I. CONTENTIONS:
3.
The
brief
contentions
of
the
learned
counsel
for
the
Appellant/Defendant are that the Trial Court did not appreciate the facts of the
case and failed to examine prima-facie case, balance of convenience and
irreparable loss. That the Defendant is a Widow as her husband died on
28.05.2022, the Death Certificate is also filed and exhibited as Ex.R.1. But in
the Agreement of Sale/Ex.P.1, dated 09.05.2022, husband of the Defendant is
mentioned as „Late V. Baba Fakruddin‟, which is much prior to his death,
which shows that the Agreement of Sale is fabricated but the Trial Court did
not discuss all these material aspects including the Death Certificate and
mentioning her husband‟s name as „Late V. Baba Fakruddin‟ in the Agreement
despite specific pleading that it is forged and fabricated one. That the
Defendant was in Bangalore. The Plaintiffs created a false address in Kadapa
and sent a legal notice, and also provided the false information and obtained
the temporary injunction, and sought to set aside the Injunction Order, and
remand the matter for adjudication afresh duly appreciating the material.
4. Whereas the learned counsel for Petitioners/Plaintiffs submits that
the Trial Court rightly considered the prima-facie case, balance of
convenience and irreparable loss and granted temporary injunction.
The
learned counsel admitted that in the Agreement of Sale, the Defendant‟s
husband‟s name is mentioned as „Late V. Baba Fakruddin‟ but he contends
that the Death Certificate/Ex.R.1 is suspicious as the date of registration, date
of update and other portions are not tallying. On a query by the Court as to
whether the Defendant‟s husband was alive or not on the date of the alleged
Agreement of Sale, the learned counsel submitted that he has to take
instructions. The learned counsel alternatively submitted that in the event of
remanding
the
matter
to
the
Trial
Court
to
consider
the
Death
Certificate/Ex.R.1 and the allied contentions, he sought to direct the
Appellant/Defendant to maintain status-quo till disposal of the Application.
II. BRIEF PLEADINGS:
5. The brief pleading of the Plaintiffs is that the Defendant approached
them and offered to sell the schedule property, finally the consideration was
settled at Rs.75,00,000/-. On 09.05.2022, the Defendant executed an unregistered Agreement of Sale in favour of the Plaintiffs and received an
advance of Rs.40,00,000/- and agreed to receive the balance sale
consideration on or before 13.12.2024 agreeing to clear mortgages from
APSFC, measure the schedule property and fix the boundaries, if she fails to
fulfill the terms and conditions, she has to pay Rs.80,00,000/- to the Plaintiffs
i.e., the double of the paid amount. That the Plaintiffs have been requesting
the Defendant to measure the schedule property, but she has been
postponing the same and has not cleared the loan from APSFC.
They
approached her several times, offered her to receive balance sale
consideration and to measure the schedule property.
On 04.12.2024, the
Plaintiffs issued a legal notice calling to obey the conditions of the Agreement
of Sale, but the said notice was returned willfully to avoid registration. That
they are ready and willing to perform their part of the contract as per the
Agreement of Sale. The Defendant is trying to sell away the property, if she
succeeds, there will be multiple proceedings and litigation against the third
parties and sought an injunction against the Defendant/Respondent not to
alienate the schedule property till the disposal of the Petition.
6. The brief pleadings of the Defendant is that she denied the plaint
averments that she approached the Plaintiffs to sell the schedule property and
fixed rate at Rs.75,00,000/- and they paid her Rs.40,00,000/- towards
advance sale consideration on 09.05.2022 and that she executed an
Agreement of Sale, agreed to measure the property and clear the loan of
APSFC and pay taxes to the APIIC on or before 13.12.2024. That the lies are
invented by the Plaintiffs to knock away the schedule property, that requesting
her to measure the schedule property and fix the boundaries are false. The
1st Plaintiff knows her husband, he was also one of the attestors in the Sale
Deed. The 1st Plaintiff knows about the demise of her husband and she has
been residing in Bangalore but the Plaintiffs have colluded with the scribe and
attestors and forged her signature and fabricated the Agreement of Sale. She
never executed any document including the Agreement of Sale, that she is not
residing either in the address mentioned in the legal notice nor in the cause
title mentioned in the Suit and I.A. That due to ill-health of her husband, she
used to reside at Bangalore from the year 2021 itself, where her daughter and
son-in-law have been residing. That the summon issued by the Court in the
Suit and I.A were communicated to her through phone, duly furnished by their
counsel, they all know that she is not residing at Kadapa but falsely submitted
to the Court that she did not respond to the notice.
That the Schedule
property is in Kadapa, whereas non-judicial stamp papers of the Agreement of
Sale are purchased on 09.02.2021 from Pullampet Sub Registrar Office,
appears to have been purchased for some other purpose, which is about 70
kms from Kadapa, but after lapse of nine months from the date of purchase of
stamp papers, the Agreement of Sale dated 09.05.2022 is created. That she
immediately on 03.05.2025 lodged a Report through Registered Post before
the Station house Officer, RIMS Police, Kadapa for criminal action.
The
signatures on the Agreement of Sale do not belong to her, her signatures are
forged in collusion with the scribe and attestors. That she discharged the loan
availed from APSFC in the year 2022 itself and the schedule property is clear
from all encumbrances. The Plaintiffs have approached the Court with unclean
hands by suppressing the material facts and obtained ex parte injunction and
prays to dismiss the Petition with exemplary costs.
III.ANALYSIS:
7. The Court perused the Order of the Trial Court. As rightly contended
by the learned counsel for the Appellant/Defendant, the Trial Court at Para
No.6,
extracted
the
pleadings,
Agreement
of
Sale/Ex.A.1,
Death
Certificate/Ex.R.1, disputing her signature on the Agreement of Sale but did
record what is the material that weighed the Court to arrive at satisfaction on
prima facie case and so also on the balance of convenience, further held that
the Court cannot find whether the Agreement of Sale contains her signatures
are forged by the Plaintiffs. Also held that the Appellant/Defendant did not file
any document to show that a crime was registered on the Report, if any, given
by her, and recorded a finding which is extracted hereunder:
“06.……………………………………………….........................
………………………………………………………………………
Ex.P.5 is the Encumbrance Certificate. Respondent filed
death certificate of her husband which shows the date of
death of husband of respondent as 28.05.2022 which is
issued by Kadapa Municipal Corporation. The respondent is
disputing her signature on Ex.P.1 sale agreement. Unless
and until, both the parties put their evidence at this
Interlocutory Application stage, this Court cannot find whether
Ex.P1 sale agreement contains the signature of respondent or
forged by the petitioners. Even the respondent did not file any
document to show that even the crime was registered on the
report if any given by the respondent against petitioners.
Ex.P2 office copy of legal notice reveals that within stipulated
period, the petitioner showed their ready and willingness to
perform their part of contract and call the respondent to
perform her part of contract. Under the above circumstances,
petitioners prima-facie established their case, and balance of
convenience in favour of petitioners. Affidavit averments
coupled with third party affidavit averments reveals that the
respondent is trying to alienate the petition schedule property.
If respondent alienates the petition schedule property during
the pendency of the suit and if the petitioners succeeds the
suit, it may lead to multiplicity of proceedings which is nothing
but irreparable loss to the petitioners.
07. In the result, petition is allowed without costs, by
confirming the order dated.18.02.2025 by granting temporary
injunction in favour of petitioners restraining the respondent
from alienating the petition’s schedule property which is
subsequently extended from time to time is made absolute till
the disposal of the suit.”
8. These observations of the Trial Court do not reveal the satisfaction of
the Court to record that the Plaintiffs have prima-facie case and also do not
reveal what weighed the Court to record prima-facie case or balance of
convenience as rightly contended by the learned counsel for the
Appellant/Defendant. Further, as rightly contended by the learned Counsel for
the Appellant that the Trial Court did not discuss on Ex.R1/Death Certificate of
Defendant‟s husband dated 28.05.2022 and also on the Agreement of Sale,
which is dated 09.05.2022 and much prior to the death Certificate, wherein it
is mentioned as „Late V. Baba Fakruddin‟ at her husband‟s column, as per the
Defendant‟s specific pleading that the 1st Plaintiff knows her husband, these
are very crucial. Thus, the Trial Court without recording adequate reasons to
arrive at satisfaction on prima facie case and balance convenience, this Court
has no occasion to re-appreciate them to decide this Appeal in these
circumstances, thus requires remanding the matter for fresh consideration by
the Trial Court. In the meantime, the Defendant shall maintain status quo till
disposal of the I.A.326 of 2025 as sought by the learned counsel for the
Plaintiffs, in view of law under Section 52 of Transfer of Property Act and
circumstances of the case.
9. The allegation of the Defendant is that her signatures were forged
and fabricated Agreement of Sale dated 09.05.2022/Ex.P.1 even showing her
husband as deceased, in fact her husband died on 28.05.2022, much later to
the Agreement, that she lodged a Report with the Police on 03.05.2025.
Whereas the allegation of the Plaintiffs is that the Death Certificate/Ex.R.1 is
suspicious, the date of registration, date of update and other portions are not
tallying.
10. The Court is referring to some the following legal principles as the
learned Counsels levelled serious allegations including forgery, fabrication of
the Agreement/Ex.P1, lodging of a Report, also raised suspicion on the Death
Certificate/Ex.R1, as discussed in the preceding paragraphs.
12. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Ramrameshwari Devi &
others Vs Nirmala Devi & others 1 ,dealing with suits for Partition and
Mandatory Injunction & mesne profits, held that the existing system can be
drastically changed or improved if the following steps are taken by the Trial
Courts while dealing with the civil trials, also held how unscrupulous litigants
are harassing the innocent parties, extracted hereunder:
“3. This is a classic example which abundantly depicts the
picture of how the civil litigation moves in our courts and how
unscrupulous litigants (the appellants in this case) can till
eternity harass the respondents and their children by abusing
the judicial system.”
52. The main……..xxxx
A.xxx
B.xxx
C. Imposition of actual, realistic or proper costs and/or
ordering prosecution would go a long way in controlling the
tendency of introducing false pleadings and forged and
fabricated documents by the litigants. Imposition of heavy
costs would also control unnecessary adjournments by the
parties. In appropriate cases the courts may consider
ordering prosecution otherwise it may not be possible to
maintain purity and sanctity of judicial proceedings.”
13. The Hon’ble Constitution Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in Iqbal Singh Marwah & another Vs Meenakshi Marwah and
another2, held that “if any agreement, sale deed, Will, Valuable Security etc is
out of forgery or forged document, the bar created by Section 195(l)(b)(ii)
Cr.P.C would not come into play and there is no embargo on the power of the
(2011) 8 SCC 249
(2005) 4 SCC 370
Court to take cognizance of the offence on the basis of the complaint filed by
the Respondents”.
14. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, in State of Punjab Vs Raj
Singh and Another 3 , while examine powers of Court and Police, under
Section 154 and 195 CrPC, held that “thestatutory power of police to
investigate under the Code is not controlled or circumscribed by section 195
Cr.P.C and Section 195 operates at a stage when a Court intends to take
cognizance of offence under section 190 (1) Cr.P.C, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court accordingly quashed the Order of High Court for quashing F.I.R
registered under Sections 419, 420, 467 and 468, I.P.C”
15. Further, when a Party or witness, who filed a forged or fabricated
document and makes a false statement or declaration or gives false evidence
or fabricates false evidence, they are liable under Section 193 of IPC r/w 191
or 192 of IPC as per law depending on the facts of the case.
Thus, the
Parties are at liberty to agitate all these in the Trial Court.
IV. CONCLUSION:
16. The Court, considering the submissions of the learned counsels,
material on record and Order of the Trial Court dated 07.10.2025 in I.A.No.326
of 2025 in O.S.No.11 of 2025, inclined to hold that the Order is without
adequate reasons to arrive at satisfaction on prima facie case and balance
convenience, which requires remanding the matter for fresh consideration in
the circumstances of the case, thus, the order is accordingly set aside and
remanded the matter, directing the Trial Court to dispose the matter afresh
taking into account of the pleadings and submissions of the parties, preferably
within
months
from
the
date
of
receipt
of
this
Order.
The
Appellant/Defendant is directed to maintain status quo till disposal of the
I.A.326 of 2025.
(1998) 2 SCC 391
17. Accordingly, the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is disposed of, there
shall be no order as to Costs in view of remanding the matter and the
circumstances of the case. The Court is making it clear that the Court did not
express anything on the merits of the case.
Miscellaneous Petitions, if any, pending shall stand closed.
_____________________
JUSTICE D. RAMESH, J
____________________________
JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR, J
Dt:
JKS
.
.2026
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE D RAMESH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 57 OF 2026
.
JKS
.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review