Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:545
Serial No. 22
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 82 of 2023
Date of Decision: 14.06.2024
Smti. Uttora G. Sangma
D/o Shri. Monindro Agitok
R/o Ampati, South West Garo
Hills District, Meghalaya
:::Petitioner
-Vs1.The State of Meghalaya
Represented by the Secretary to the
Government of Meghalaya, Education
Department, Shillong
2.The Director of School Education and
Literacy, Meghalaya, Shillong
3.The Joint Director of School Education and
Literacy, West Garo Hills, Tura
4.The Special Officer to the Government of
Meghalaya, Education Department, Shillong
:::Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
2024:MLHC:545
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S. Deb, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mrs. N.G. Shylla, Sr. GA with
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, GA.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The writ petitioner by way of the instant writ petition has sought for
regularization of her services and further for release of pensionary and
other terminal benefits as entitled.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner was initially
appointed as an Assistant Teacher on 21.07.1989, and thereafter, by order
dated 01.09.1998, passed by the Inspector of Schools, she along with
4(four) other similarly situated Assistant Teachers were regularized w.e.f.
28.10.1996. It appears that thereafter the petitioner was transferred and
posted as a Ladies’ Social Education Officer (LSEO) in the Office of the
Joint Director of School Education & Literacy, West Garo Hills, Tura, on
13.10.2010, and while serving the said post had applied for voluntary
retirement of service from the said post, as admissible under the rules.
2024:MLHC:545
However, the said application of the writ petitioner was not accepted, on
the ground that the petitioner was yet to be regularized and that the
voluntary retirement scheme would be applicable only after regularization
of the adhoc appointment of the writ petitioner. The petitioner then by
letter dated 01.02.2023, while her regularization was still being considered
by the respondents, resigned from service, and the same was accepted on
02.02.2023.
3.
Mr. S. Deb, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the
petitioner on entering into service as far back as in 1989, and on the
issuance of the letter dated 01.09.1998, regularizing her services w.e.f.
28.10.1996, was in the firm belief that her services had been regularized,
making her eligible to apply for the voluntary retirement. He further
submits that on being informed that her services were yet to be regularized,
and that the process was on, in view of the urgency to contest the elections,
had submitted the resignation letter. It is further submitted that the
petitioner having served for 33(thirty-three) years cannot be deprived of her
just entitlement, i.e. pensionary and other terminal benefits. It is also
contended that with the issue as to whether the resignation would amount
to her relinquishment of the rights accrued in service, the learned counsel
has submitted that, in the circumstances surrounding the entire case, the
resignation for all practical purposes should be treated as a letter of
2024:MLHC:545
voluntary retirement. In support of his arguments, the learned counsel has
placed reliance on the following judgments, wherein the other High Courts
and the Supreme Court have granted relief to persons, which he submits
where similarly situated, i.e. for grant of pension after having served for
long number of years.
(i)
High Court of Judicature at Madras, in the case of T.K.
Thanigaivel vs. The Managing Director & Ors. dated
19.04.2022 passed in W.P. No. 41096 of 2016 and W.M. P.
No. 35082 of 2016
(ii)
High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad, in the case of
Subhashchandra Chimanlal Patel vs. State of Gujarat Thro
Secretary dated 19.08.2016 in Special Civil Application No.
2593 of 2012
(iii)
High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur, in the case of Asha
Ram Suryavanshi vs. Chhattisgarh Gramin Bank, through
its Chairman, Bilaspur (C.G) dated 26.06.2020 passed in
WPS No. 1692 of 2011
(iv)
Shashikala Devi vs. Central Bank of India & Ors. reported
in (2014) 16 SCC 260.
2024:MLHC:545
4.
In reply, the learned Senior Government Advocate for the State
respondents, Mrs. N.G. Shylla, has submitted that the entire premise of the
arguments of the writ petitioner has no basis, inasmuch as, she was never
formally regularized at any point of time, and the regularization order dated
01.09.1998, was of no value as the same was made by an incompetent
authority. She further submits that by application of Rule 23(1) of the
Meghalaya Civil Services (Pension) Rules 1993, the writ petitioner having
resigned from the post and further not being regularized, has no vested
right to claim for any pensionary benefits at this stage, as by operation of
the Rules, by her resignation, the petitioner has relinquished her entire
service and entitlements. She further submits that though the petitioner was
subsequently regularized by order dated 25.04.2023, this will be of no
consequence, as by the action of the petitioner itself, whatever rights that
has been accrued were washed away by the said resignation letter. With
regard to the authorities placed by the counsel for the writ petitioner, she
submits that the same will have no application, inasmuch as, in all those
cases, the persons concerned therein, were regular employees. She
therefore submits that there being no merits in the writ petition, as VRS is
not applicable to unregularized employee, the same should be dismissed.
5.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, it is seen that in her
service, the petitioner has been caught in an unfortunate situation,
2024:MLHC:545
inasmuch as, after serving for 33 years, and in aspiring for a career in
politics, has instead been compelled to approach this Court to fight for her
pensionary and other benefits. The fact that the petitioner had been serving
on being appointed since 23.07.1989, is not in dispute, as also the fact that
by a letter dated 01.09.1998, the Inspector of Schools, had regularized her
services w.e.f. 29.10.1996, though the same at a much later stage was not
accepted by the respondents on the ground that the same had been done by
an incompetent authority. However, it is seen from the materials on record
that, ex-post facto approval for the petitioner’s regularization had been
sought meaning thereby, the matter was under active consideration. This is
evidenced from the letters dated 15.05.2017, 29.06.2017, 10.08.2021 and
04.10.2021. Other letters present in the records also show that, on
20.09.2021 and 10.02.2022, that the process of regularization was still on.
An averment has been made by the petitioner that pursuant to letter dated
20.09.2021, asking for names of adhoc employees who were appointed
prior to 2007, the name of the petitioner had been sent and her services
were subsequently regularized by the cabinet decision dated 15.03.2022.
Though this averment is noted by this Court, however, in the absence of
further supporting materials, apart from the letter dated 20.09.2021, no
reliance will be placed on the same, while deciding this case.
2024:MLHC:545
6.
Looking back at the facts, the petitioner it appears under the
impression that, she was eligible for voluntary retirement on having
completed 25 years of qualifying service, as per Rule 38A of the
Meghalaya Civil Services (Pension) Fourth Amendment, Rules 1998, had
then applied for voluntary retirement vide letter dated 01.09.2022, which
however, came to be rejected by letter dated 29.11.2021, on the
circumstances, as discussed above. This rejection then caused the petitioner
to tender her resignation vide letter dated 01.02.2023, which was then
accepted by the respondents. It is to be noted that, after the entire sequence
of events, the petitioner was then regularized by the respondents by order
dated 25.04.2023, on the special approval being received from the
Meghalaya Public Service Commission. The only issue that remains for
consideration therefore, will be to examine as to whether on the facts of the
petitioner’s case, and the surrounding circumstances, the relief as prayed
for pension and terminal benefits would be available to the petitioner.
7.
The petitioner as earlier observed, has been in continuous service
since 21.07.1989, till her resignation on 01.02.2023, which undoubtedly if
her services had been regularized, would have made her eligible to apply
for VRS, and also entitled her to all pensionary and terminal benefits. The
fact that the petitioner was under the bona fide belief that she stood
regularized by the order dated 01.09.1998, along with 4(four) other
2024:MLHC:545
similarly situated teachers cannot be ignored. It was on this belief,
notwithstanding the other communications seeking ex-post facto approval
for regularization that the petitioner it appears had put in her application for
VRS. It is relevant to note, at this juncture that, Rule 38A of the Pension
Rules, provides as follows.
“38A. Retirement on completion of twenty years
continuous qualifying service – (1) At any time a
Government employee has completed twenty years
continuous qualifying service or after he has attained
the age of fifty years, whichever is earlier, he may, by
giving notice of not less than three months in writing
to the appointing authority, retired from service.
(2) The notice of voluntary retirement given under
sub-rule (1) shall require acceptance by the appointing
authority.
Provided that where the appointing authority
does not refuse to grant the permission for retirement
before the expiry of the period specified in the said
notice, the retirement shall become effective from the
date of expiry of the said period.”
8.
The above noted rule therefore, mandates a period of 3(three)
months’ notice and that further in the proviso, the appointing authority in
the case of rejection was to communicate the same before the expiry of the
2024:MLHC:545
notice period. In the instant case however, it is seen from the records that,
there is no intimation of rejection, apart from the letter dated 29.11.2022,
which was not even communicated to the petitioner, and as submitted, the
petitioner came to learn about the same only after filing the first writ
petition.
9.
Further it is also noted that, on her attempts to be allowed voluntary
retirement, the petitioner had then resigned from service, which would in
normal course, have resulted in forfeiture of past service by the application
of Rule 23(1) of the Pension Rules, 1983. A twist in this tale, however is
with the regularization that was granted on 25.04.2023, w.e.f. 01.09.1998,
as seen in the order so dated, which in the considered view of this Court,
has altered the perspective of the case of the petitioner, inasmuch as, had
she continued in service after the rejection of her VRS application, she
would be entitled to all her service benefits. In this context, the judgments
placed by the learned counsel for the petitioner, considering the long years
of service of the writ petitioner, will have some bearing. In the case of T.K.
Thanigaivel (supra), the Madras High Court, treated the resignation of the
writ petitioner as one of the voluntary retirement, making him eligible for
pension. Paras – 17 and 18 of the judgment is quoted herein below.
“17. For all the above stated reasons, this Court is of the
considered view that fairness, equity and good conscience
2024:MLHC:545
demand that the petitioner be granted the relief as prayed for
by him.
18. Accordingly, this writ petition stands allowed. The
impugned order passed by the third respondent herein vide
his proceedings Ka.No.44111/ kuO6/ Pension/ MTC/2015
dated 10.12.2015, is hereby set aside. The respondents are
consequently directed to treat the resignation of the
petitioner as one of voluntary retirement with effect from the
date he was relieved from service under the relevant
provisions of the Pension Rules, applicable to the
Corporation.”
10.
The writ petitioner in the instant case was faced with a situation,
wherein her VRS application stood rejected, her regularization at the mercy
of the respondents inspite of her long years of service, and with the
impending elections, which she was keen to contest in, in jeopardy,
culminated in her tendering her resignation. In this context, the case of
Shashikala Devi (supra) also comes to the assistance of the writ petitioner.
This decision is relevant as, it would be unthinkable to any employee
having served for about 33 years, to throw away due benefits which would
have been granted in the usual course, especially after the formal
regularization order had been passed on 25.04.2023. Para – 17 of the
judgment which is relevant on this aspect is reproduced herein below.
2024:MLHC:545
“17. When viewed in the backdrop of the above facts, it is
difficult to reject the contention urged on behalf of the
appellant that what the deceased employee intended to do by
his letter dated 8-10-2007 was to seek voluntary retirement
and not resignation from his employment. We say so in the
light of several attendant circumstances. In the first place, the
employee at the time of his writing the letter dated 8-10-2007
was left with just about one-and-a-half years of service. It will
be too imprudent for anyone to suggest that a bank employee
who has worked with such commitment as earned him the
appreciation of the management would have so thoughtlessly
given up the retiral benefits in the form of pension, etc.
which he had earned on account of his continued dedication
to his job. If pension is not a bounty, but a right which the
employee acquires on account of long years of sincere and
good work done by him, the Court will be slow in presuming
that the employee intended to waive or abandon such a
valuable right without any cogent reason. At any rate there
ought to be some compelling circumstance to suggest that the
employee had consciously given up the right and benefit,
which he had acquired so assiduously. Far from the material
on record suggesting any such conscious surrender,
abandonment or waiver of the right to retiral benefit
including pension, we find that the material placed on record
clearly suggests that the employee had no source of income
or sustenance except the benefit that he had earned for long
years of service. This is evident from a reading of the letter
2024:MLHC:545
dated 8-10-2007 in which the employee seeks release of his
retiral benefits at the earliest to enable him to undergo
medical treatment that he requires. The letter, as seen earlier,
lays emphasis on the fact that for his sustenance the
employee is dependent entirely on such benefits. It is in that
view difficult for us to attribute to the employee the intention
to give up what was rightfully his in terms of retiral benefits,
when such benefits were the only source not only for his
survival but for his medical treatment that he so urgently
required. For a waiver of a legally enforceable right earned
by an employee, it is necessary that the same is clear and
unequivocal, conscious and with full knowledge of the
consequences. No such intention can be gathered from the
facts and circumstances of the instant case. The employee’s
subsequent letters and communication which are placed on
record cannot be said to be an afterthought. Being proximate
in point of time letter dated 8-10-2007 must be treated to be a
part
of
the
subsequent
communication
making
the
employee’s intentions clear, at least for the purposes of
determining the true intention underlying the act of the
employee.”
11.
As such, in view of the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case,
where the petitioner cannot be said to be totally at fault, the resignation of
the petitioner shall be considered by the respondents to be in effect and in
continuation of the application for voluntary retirement, and the petitioner
2024:MLHC:545
consequently, be afforded all the retiral benefits, as entitled and
permissible. It is further made clear that, the petitioner shall be allowed
pension under the Meghalaya Civil Services (Pension) Rules 1983. It is
expected that orders in this regard be passed by the respondents at the
earliest.
12.
For the reasons aforementioned, this writ petition stands allowed,
and is accordingly disposed of.
Judge
Meghalaya
14.06.2024
“D.Thabah-PS”
DARIHUN
THABAH
DARIHUN THABAH
Date: 2024.06.18 15:26:08
+05'30'
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review