The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Before parting, we deem it appropriate to deprecate the manner in which the case of the respondent has been dealt with by the authorities. The authorities ought to have taken a fair and rational decision on his claim much earlier. The respondent was allowed to work for decades and was repeatedly made to approach the authorities and the Court, while similarly situated persons were given the benefit of regular service. Such administrative callousness and failure to consider the just claim of an employee, thereby subjecting him to hostile discrimination, cannot be countenanced.
16. For the foregoing reasons, we find no merit in the present writ petition. The same is, accordingly, dismissed. Consequently, the judgment and order dated 20.03.2025 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Jammu Bench in TA No.1554/2022 is upheld. The petitioners shall comply with the directions issued by the Tribunal in accordance with law. The record of the Tribunal shall be sent back forthwith.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C ) No. 3307/2025
Reserved on 15.09.2026.
Pronounced on 21 .09.2026
Uploaded on 22 .09.2026
Full judgment is pronounced
.
UT of J&K and others
..... Petitioner (s)
Through :- Ms Monika Kohli Sr.AAG with
Ms. Priyanka Bhat Advocate.
V/s
Rameshwar Dutt and others
.....Respondent(s)
Through :- Mr. Abhirash Sharma Advocate
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Sanjeev Kumar J
The Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir and its functionaries
[“petitioners herein”] are aggrieved of and have challenged the judgment and order
dated 20.03.2025 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Jammu Bench
[“Tribunal”] in TA No.1554/2022 titled Rameshwar Dutt v. UT of Jammu and
Kashmir and others. The said Transfer Application was initially filed before this
Court as WP(C) No.1285/2021. However, upon promulgation of the Jammu and
Kashmir Reorganization Act, 2019 and constitution of the Tribunal, the writ
petition was transferred to the Tribunal and registered as TA No.1554/2022.
Vide the impugned judgment, the Tribunal has quashed order dated
08.02.2022, whereby the claim of the respondent for regularisation of his services
was rejected and he was shown to have been disengaged w.e.f. 31.03.2021. The
Tribunal has further directed the petitioners, more particularly petitioner No.2, to
regularise the services of the respondent as Junior Assistant in the Revenue
Department from the date the said benefit was given to Naresh Kumar and Anil
Kumar, who were engaged along with the respondent in the year 1993 and were
performing similar duties and were regularised in the year 1995.
The impugned judgment has been challenged by the petitioners on
several grounds. However, before considering the grounds of challenge, it would
be appropriate to notice few relevant facts of the case.
4.
The respondent, along with Anil Kumar and Naresh Kumar, was
appointed as Junior Assistant by the Deputy Commissioner, Kathua in the year
1993. The appointment was made pursuant to sanction for appointment of special
Revenue staff to attend to the work relating to requisition/acquisition of immovable
property in District Kathua for defence purposes. The engagement of the
respondent was on ad hoc/temporary basis and was extended from time to time.
Vide order dated 31.01.1994, Naresh Kumar was assigned duties in the Tehsil
Office, Kathua as Junior Assistant on ad hoc basis. Thereafter, vide order dated
27.10.1995, Naresh Kumar was assigned the charge of Nazarat Section in Tehsil
Office, Kathua, whereas Anil Kumar was assigned the work of Accountant in
Tehsil Office, Hiranagar. Vide order dated 25.10.1995, the respondent, who was
working as Receipt Clerk in the Defence Section in the office of the Deputy
Commissioner, Kathua, was allowed to continue in the said office till further
orders.
5.
Apprehending termination of his services, the respondent approached
this Court by filing SWP No.2810-A/1999, seeking, inter alia, a direction to the
petitioners not to disengage him as also to release his salary. The said writ petition
was disposed of by this Court vide order dated 01.03.2001 with a direction that, in
case the petitioner was holding the post, he would be allowed to continue. It was
further directed that the respondent would be paid salary for the period during
which he had actually worked. Thereafter, vide communication dated 10.09.2014,
the Deputy Commissioner, Kathua informed that the Junior Assistants engaged on
temporary basis were relieved from the office of the Deputy Commissioner,
Kathua and placed at the disposal of the SDM, Hiranagar. The services of the
respondent, who had been engaged in the year 1993 and had continuously
performed his duties in the office of Deputy Commissioner was, accordingly,
placed at the disposal of the SDM, Hiranagar. In the meantime, services of Naresh
Kumar and Anil Kumar came to be regularised.
The respondent also had a short
break in service from 04.10.2012 to 21.10.2012. However, vide order dated
28.03.2013, the Deputy Commissioner, Kathua allowed the respondent to continue
against the post on which he was working, excluding the intervening period.
6.
The respondent thereafter continued to work as Junior Assistant on ad
hoc basis. He made several representations to the petitioners from the year 2000
onwards, seeking the same treatment as was given to Naresh Kumar and Anil
Kumar. By then, he had rendered more than 27 years of service. His
representations, however, were not considered. It further appears from the record
that vide communication dated 15.02.2021, the Deputy Commissioner, Kathua
sought to know from the Defence Estate Officer, Jammu whether the services of
the respondent were required in future. The Defence Estate Officer, Jammu, vide
communication dated 15.03.2021, informed the Deputy Commissioner, Kathua
that the services of the respondent were not required for MoD works relating to
acquisition/requisition/hiring in future. The respondent was thereafter shown to
have been disengaged w.e.f. 31.03.2021. His claim for regularisation was rejected
vide order dated 08.02.2022. Aggrieved whereof, he approached this Court by
filing WP(C) No.1285/2021, which, upon transfer, came to be considered by the
Tribunal.
7.
Learned Senior AAG appearing for the petitioners submits that the
respondent was engaged purely on temporary/ad hoc basis for defence-related
works. It is submitted that the sanction for his engagement and the funds for
payment of his salary were provided by the Principal Directorate, Western
Command, Chandigarh. It is also submitted that there was no right of
regularisation attached to his engagement and that, once the Defence Estate Officer
informed that his services were no longer required, there was no justification for
continuing him. It is further submitted that Naresh Kumar and Anil Kumar were
never regularised by the competent authority and that the entries made in their
service records cannot give any right to the respondent to claim similar treatment.
8.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
There is no dispute that the respondent was appointed in the year 1993
along with Naresh Kumar and Anil Kumar. It is also not disputed that he continued
to discharge his duties for more than three decades, except for the short intervening
period noticed above. It is further not disputed that his services were throughout
utilized by the authorities for performing the duties assigned to him.
The contention of the petitioners that the respondent was only a
temporary employee cannot be considered without looking at the manner in which
he was treated by the authorities for all these years. The respondent was appointed
along with Naresh Kumar and Anil Kumar and was performing similar duties. The
aforesaid two persons were treated differently by the authorities and were allowed
to continue in service with the benefits of regular service.
11.
We are conscious of the settled legal position that mere continuation
on ad hoc or temporary basis for a long period does not, ipso facto, confer upon
such person any right to regularization. Regularization also cannot ordinarily be
directed contrary to the applicable rules. However, the facts of the present case are
different. The respondent has been in service since 1993. His services were utilized
for more than three decades. His engagement was extended from time to time and
he was permitted to perform the duties of Junior Assistant. He repeatedly
approached the authorities seeking the same treatment as was given to Naresh
Kumar and Anil Kumar. Instead of taking a final decision on his claim, the
authorities continued to utilize his services and, after more than three decades,
sought to disengage him on the ground that his services were no longer required.
We cannot countenance such an approach. The petitioners cannot keep the
respondent as a temporary employee for more than three decades, continue to take
work from him and then deny him the benefit of regularization on the ground that
his initially appointment was temporary when two other persons similarly situated
with him already stood regularized. The respondent has been pursuing his claim
since 1999. His repeated representations were not properly considered. At the same
time, the persons who had been engaged along with him were given different
treatment. First, they were adjusted in Tehsil offices and later regularized by
preparing their service books and granting them timely in-situ promotion.
Mr. Naresh Kumar has retired and is receiving pension.
12.
We have no hesitation in observing that the manner in which the case
of the respondent has been dealt with by the petitioners is highly deplorable. There
is no satisfactory explanation tendered by the petitioners as to why, when persons
similarly situated were accommodated and treated as a regular employees, the
respondent, who was similarly situated and was performing similar duties, was left
to continue as an ad hoc employee for decades.
The plea that Naresh Kumar and Anil Kumar were not formally
regularized by the competent authority does not answer the issue. If their service
books were prepared and they were allowed to enjoy the benefits of regular
service, the petitioners cannot now rely upon the absence of a formal order of
regularization to deny similar treatment to the respondent. The record shows a
clear lack of application of mind on the part of the authorities. The respondent has
apparently been subjected to hostile discrimination by the petitioners. It is also
relevant to note that one of the two similarly situated employees has since died and
the other has been receiving pensionary benefits. At this stage, it is not possible for
us to go back and undo the treatment already given to them. The respondent has
been pursuing his claim since 1999 and has served the Department for more than
three decades. In the peculiar facts of the case, he is, therefore, required to be
treated on a par with the similarly situated employees. Strictly speaking, it may not
be a case of perpetuating a wrong.. More so, the petitioners have not taken any
remedial measures to undo the wrong.
14.
The Tribunal has considered the facts of the present case and has
directed the petitioners to regularize the services of the respondent as Junior
Assistant in the Revenue Department from the date the same benefit was given to
Naresh Kumar and Anil Kumar. In the facts and circumstances of the case, we find
no illegality in the judgment passed by the Tribunal warranting interference by this
Court.
15.
Before parting, we deem it appropriate to deprecate the manner in
which the case of the respondent has been dealt with by the authorities. The
authorities ought to have taken a fair and rational decision on his claim much
earlier. The respondent was allowed to work for decades and was repeatedly made
to approach the authorities and the Court, while similarly situated persons were
given the benefit of regular service. Such administrative callousness and failure to
consider the just claim of an employee, thereby subjecting him to hostile
discrimination, cannot be countenanced.
16.
For the foregoing reasons, we find no merit in the present writ
petition. The same is, accordingly, dismissed. Consequently, the judgment and
order dated 20.03.2025 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Jammu
Bench in TA No.1554/2022 is upheld. The petitioners shall comply with the
directions issued by the Tribunal in accordance with law. The record of the
Tribunal shall be sent back forthwith.
(SHAHZAD AZEEM)
JUDGE
(SANJEEV KUMAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
21 .09.2026
SANJEEV
Whether judgment is speaking:Yes
Whether judgment is reportable: Yes
Sanjeev Kumar
2026.09.22 13:00
I am the author of this
document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review