Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 54
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No. 136/2026
CM No. 339/2026
CAV No. 2986/2025
Date of pronouncement: 02.02.2026
Date of uploading: 03.02.2026
1. UT of J&K, through its Principal
Secretary to Govt., Forest Deptt.,
Civil Secretariat, U. T. of J&K at
Jammu;
2. Director Forest Protection Force,
Jammu.
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Vishal Bharti, Dy. AG
vs
1. Mohd Ashraf Butt, age 36 years
S/o Ghulam Hussain R/o Keshwan, Tehsil
and Distt. Kishtwar.
2. Mohd. Ayub, age 50 years
S/o Mohd. Sharief R/o Masjid Mohalla,
Bhadarwah, Distt. Doda.
3. Ahsan-Ul-Haq, age 49 years
S/o Gh. Rasool, R/o Mohalla Nagar,
Bhadarwah, Distt. Doda.
4. Annayat Ullah Tak, age 49 years
S/o Abdul Qayoom R/o Dhalina, Tehsil
Gandoh, Distt. Doda
5. Rishi Kumar, age 48 years S/o Ferol
Chand, R/o Mohalla Dhall, Tehsil and
Distt. Doda.
………And 70 others.
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Faheem Shokat Butt, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER (ORAL)
02.02.2026
Sanjeev Kumar ‘J’
CAV No. 2986/2025
1.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioners as also the caveators.
WP(C) No. 136/2026
2.
With the appearance of learned counsel for the caveators, the caveat
stands discharged.
WP(C) No. 136/2026
3.
Impugned in this petition, filed by the Union Territory of J&K, is an
order and judgment dated 01.03.2024, passed by the Central
Administrative Tribunal, Jammu Bench, Jammu in TA No. 5805/2021
(SWP No. 392/2011) in case titled “Mohd. Ashraf Butt and others Vs.
State of J&K & others.”, whereby the Tribunal has, while allowing the
petition of the respondents, directed the petitioners herein to grant
promotional service benefit w.e.f. 24.10.2000 to 07.02.2007.
4.
Before we advert to the grounds of challenge, urged by Mr. Vishal
Bharti, learned Dy. AG, appearing for the petitioners, we deem it
appropriate to notice few facts, which are germane to the disposal of
this petition.
5.
Vide advertisement notification No. 03/1996 dated 24.12.1996, a
process of selection was initiated by the J&K Service Selection Board
(SSB) for filling up of 158 posts of Forest Guards in the Forest
Protection Force in the erstwhile District of Doda. The process of
selection took almost four years to conclude. The selected candidates,
including the respondents herein were appointed vide order dated
24.10.2000. The selected candidates, including the respondents herein,
were also put to undergo requisite training in the Punjab Police
Training Academy, Phillour. While they were performing their duties
as Forest Guard in the petitioners’ department, some candidates who
failed to make it to the selection filed SWP No.
651/2000 titled
WP(C) No. 136/2026
“Bhushan Lal and other Vs. State of J&K & others” and challenged
the selection and appointment of the candidates, including the
respondents herein. The said petition was disposed of by a Bench of
this Court vide order dated 15.04.2002, with a direction to the Chief
Secretary to examine the allegations of interpolations etc. made by the
aggrieved candidates. The Chief Secretary, who was directed to
examine the allegations of interpolations in the selection record,
however, decided to cancel the selection process as well as the
appointments of the selected candidates, including the respondents
herein. This was done by an order issued by the Government in GAD
on 03.01.2003. This gave rise to a further litigation in the matter. The
respondents herein and other similarly situated persons, who stood
appointed pursuant to the selection made by SSB, filed SWP No.
384/2003, which along with other connected matters was considered
by a Single Bench of this Court and vide an order and judgment dated
15.04.2005 was dismissed.
6.
The LPAs preferred by the respondents herein and other similarly
situated persons, registered as LPA Nos. 54/2005 and 55/2005, came
to be disposed of by a Division Bench of this Court vide judgment
dated 26.04.2006 by directing as under:
“That State-respondent shall constitute a committee
comprising of Chairman, Public Service Commission, Chief
Secretary, Secretary, General Administration Department and
Chairman, SSRB within two weeks from the receipt of this
order. This Committee shall undertake a fresh exercise of
examining the selection record along with any relevant
contemporaneous record including the allegations made by the
non-selected candidates in their writ petitions as also the
WP(C) No. 136/2026
report of the Vigilance Organization. All the appellants
hereinabove shall appear before this Committee on date(s) to
be fixed by the Committee on their own for being given a
hearing by the Committee in respect of the allegations made
against them and their selection. Similarly, those non-selected
candidates who had filed batch of writ petition shall also be
asked to appear before the Committee on their own if they are
so advised for being accorded a hearing in support of their
allegations on a date to be fixed by the Committee and notified
in a public matte. If any of the appellants fail to appear on his
own on the fixed dates, the Committee shall not be obliged to
re-summon him/her for any further hearing. Such authority
shall, thereafter, proceed to pass appropriate orders in the
matter un-influenced by anything said or expressed in the
orders passed between the parties till date. This decision shall
be binding on all the parties and more particularly, the
appellants shall execute an undertaking before this Court to
abide by that decision within week. In case the Staterespondent decides to quash the selection and cancel the
appointments, it shall take further necessary steps to hold a
fresh selection for the post of Forest Protection Guard and
complete selection process within four months from the date of
decision.”
7.
It seems that in compliance with the judgment passed by the Division
Bench dated 26.04.2006(supra), a Committee was constituted to go
into the allegations of malpractices and interpolations in the selection
process. Upon receipt of report of the Committee, it was found that the
selection and consequent appointment of the respondents herein was
genuine and did not suffer from any illegality or interpolations.
However, with regard to some candidates, who were selected and
appointed, in whose case, it was opined by the Committee that their
selection and appointment was tainted and deserve to be cancelled.
8.
Be that as it may, with a view to give effect to the recommendations of
the Committee, the Government issued an order on 07.02.2007, taking
WP(C) No. 136/2026
back all the respondents in service, though prospectively. The
respondents herein represented to the petitioners for giving them the
benefit of continuity of their services. The said representation was
disposed of by the petitioners vide order No. FST/FPF/49/2007 dated
23.11.2010. This made the respondents herein to approach this Court
once again and this time by way of SWP No. 392/2011, which on
transfer to the Tribunal, came to be registered as TA No. 5805/2021.
9.
In the aforesaid writ petition, it was the categoric case set up by the
respondents that since the petitioners had themselves found their
selection to be genuine and taken them back, as such, there was no
reason or justification to deny them the benefit of appointment w.e.f.
the date of their first appointment i.e. 24.10.2000. The writ petition
was contested by the petitioners by taking the plea that cancellation of
appointment of the respondents was never set aside by the Court and
that they were appointed afresh on the basis of recommendations made
by the Committee, constituted in compliance with the judgment passed
by the Division Bench and, therefore, in terms of rule 24 of the J&K
Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal ) Rules, 1956, they
were entitled to reckon their appointment and seniority from the date
they were appointed afresh i.e. 07.02.2007.
10.
Having heard both the sides and perused the material on record, the
Tribunal came to the conclusion that appointment of the respondents,
made vide order dated 07.02.2007, was in continuation of their
appointment made on 24.10.2000 and should not be treated as fresh
appointment. However, having regard to the fact that the respondents
WP(C) No. 136/2026
had remained out of service w.e.f. 03.01.2003 till they were appointed
afresh on 07.02.2007, the Tribunal was of the view that it would serve
the ends of justice if the respondents were at least given the notional
benefit of service from 24.10.2000 to 07.02.2007. It is in this
background, the petition filed by the respondents came to be allowed
in terms of the judgment impugned in this petition.
11.
We have given thoughtful consideration to the rival contentions and
perused the material on record and are of the considered opinion that
the judgment passed by the Tribunal indeed serves the ends of justice.
It is not in dispute that the selection of the respondents, made by the
SSB in the year 2000, which culminated into issuance of order of
appointments in their favour on 24.10.2000, has not been found illegal
or fraught with any interpolations or irregularities. It is true that in
view of the dispute raised by some of the selected candidates and the
serious allegations of interpolations in case of some of the candidates
made by the Board, the litigation ensued, which culminated into
passing of the Division Bench judgment dated 26.04.2006. The
judgment was accepted by all the parties and a Committee, as directed
by the Division Bench, was constituted to look into the allegations of
manipulation and illegality in the selection process. The Committee
thoroughly went through the entire selection record and came to the
conclusion that so far as the respondents herein were concerned, there
was no interpolation, forgery or illegality in their selection and that
they had made it to the selection on the basis of their merit. This report
was accepted by the Government and vide order dated 07.02.2007, the
WP(C) No. 136/2026
respondents were taken back in service. It is true that upon reading of
order dated 07.02.2007, it transpires that this was an order of fresh
appointment in respect of the respondents. It is because of this reason
only the respondents resented and filed a representation and thereafter,
came to this Court.
12.
The Tribunal has well appreciated the controversy in its perspective
and rightly concluded that the benefit of notional service w.e.f.
24.10.2000 to 07.02.2007 cannot be denied to the respondents, more
particularly, when their selection all along has been found to be
genuine and in consonance with law. That apart, had the petitioners,
exercised due diligence and conducted the selection process in fair and
transparent manner, the innocent and genuine candidates like the
respondents would not have suffered. They would have been in service
right from 24.10.2000 without any discontinuity.
13.
Be that as it may, the selection was not conducted in a fair and
transparent manner, which generated litigation. Some of the
allegations were, of course, found correct, but so far as the respondents
are concerned, they were found innocent and their selection was found
genuine. It is because of this reason that they were appointed on
07.02.2007.
14.
For all these reasons, we do not find any illegality or infirmity in the
judgment passed by the Tribunal. We would, however, like to clarify
that the benefit of service w.e.f. 24.10.2000 till 07.02.2007 shall be
notional and only for the purpose of computing the qualifying service
for grant of pensionary benefit and for no other purpose.
WP(C) No. 136/2026
15.
Subject to the clarification made above, the judgment passed by the
Tribunal is upheld and as a consequence, this petition is dismissed.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
Jammu
02.02.2026
Vishal Sharma
Whether the order is speaking?
Yes/No
Whether the order is reportable?
Yes/No
WP(C) No. 136/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review