Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CPLPA No. 03/2018 in LPASW No. 159/2016 c/w
WP(C ) Nos. 755/2022, 1415/2022, 1416/2022 &
1669/2022
Reserved on 17.09.2026.
Pronounced on 28 .09.2026
Uploaded on
29 .09.2026
Full judgment is pronounced
.
Kartar Chand and others
Dr. Yasmeen Ashai and others
UT of J&K and others
UT of J&K and others
UT of J&K and others
..... Petitioner (s)
Mr Z.A.Shah Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Javed I. Bhalwal Advocate in WP(C)
No. 755/2022 (Th. V.C)
Mr. Dewakar Sharma Dy.AG in
WP(C) Nos. 1415/2022, 1416/2022
& 1669/2022
Mr. Abhinav Sharma Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Abhirash Sharma Advocate in
CPLPA No. 03/2018.
Through :-
V/s
Dr. Asgar Hussain Samoon and
another
UT of Jammu and Kashmir and
others
Dr. Y.P.Kundal and others
Kartar Chand and others
Kartar Chand and others
Through :-
.....Respondent(s)
Mr. Abhinav Sharma Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Abhirash Sharma Advocate
Mr. M.Y.Akhoon Advocate.
Mr. F.A.Natnoo Advocate.
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Sanjeev Kumar J
WP(C) Nos. 1669/2022, 1415/2022 & 1416/2022 & WP(C) No. 755/2022
Facts:
A common order and judgment dated 12.01.2022 (hereinafter referred
to as “the impugned judgment”) passed by the Central Administrative
Tribunal, Jammu Bench, Jammu (hereinafter referred to as “the Tribunal”) in
TA Nos. 5796/2021, 5809/2021 and 5800/2021 is the subject matter of
challenge in these four writ petitions; three i.e. WP(C) Nos. 1669/2022,
1415/2022 & 1416/2022 filed by the UT of Jammu and Kashmir through
Secretary to the Government, Department of Higher Education, and one i.e.
WP(C) No. 755/2022 filed by Dr. Yasmeen Ashai and thirty-two (32) others.
In terms of the impugned judgment, TAs of the private respondents in these
writ petitions have been allowed and the Government Order No. 684-HE of
2017 dated 12.12.2017 promoting the petitioners in WP(C) No. 755/2022,
has been quashed. It is pertinent to mention here that the matters were initially
filed before this Court as SWP Nos. 2966/2017, 789/2016 and 1902/2017.
However, after the enactment of the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act,
2019, and the constitution of the Tribunal, the aforesaid petitions were
transferred to the Tribunal and registered as the TAs aforesaid.
Before we advert to the grounds of challenge urged by the UT of
Jammu and Kashmir and the promoted candidates, namely, Yasmeen Ashai
and others, to the impugned judgment, we deem it appropriate to set out a few
facts that are germane to the disposal of these writ petitions.
The private respondents herein came to be appointed as Lecturers in
various Degree Colleges of the then State of Jammu and Kashmir. The
appointment and method of recruitment of the private respondents and those
working as Lecturers in various Degree Colleges was governed by the J&K
Education (Gazetted) College Service Recruitment Rules, 1995, which were
later repealed and replaced by the J&K Education (Gazetted) Colleges Service
Recruitment Rules, 2004 (hereinafter referred to as the “Rules of 2004”). The
Rules of 2004 were also later repealed and replaced by the J&K Education
(Gazetted) Colleges Service Recruitment Rules, 2008 (hereinafter referred to
as the “Rules of 2008”). The private respondents holding the posts of Lecturer
(Selection Grade) were posted as In-charge Principals in various Government
Degree Colleges purely on a stop-gap basis in their own pay and grade
between the years 2010 and 2014, with a clear stipulation that their posting as
Principals in In-charge capacity would not confer any preferential right upon
them for being regularized under the rules. Recognising that the private
respondents had been performing the duties of higher posts, though in an
officiating capacity, the Government, vide its Order No. 85-HE of 2013 dated
23.09.2013, sanctioned charge allowance in favour of the private respondents.
It is claimed by the private respondents that they were posted as
In-charge Principals, though in their own pay and grade, because they were
eligible to hold the posts and their confirmation was only subject to selection
to be made by the DPC/PSC as per the Rules of 2008.
It seems that while the process for consideration of the private
respondents for their regular appointments as Principals was under way, the
Rules of 2008 came to be amended vide SRO 124 of 2014 dated 21.04.2014.
The method of recruitment to the post of Principal also underwent a
significant change. The said post was provided to be filled up by selection
through DPC/PSC from Class-II, Category (A), from amongst persons having
at least 15 years of teaching experience in Colleges, out of which at least three
years must be as Associate Professor, provided that the number of candidates
to be considered shall not ordinarily exceed five times the number of posts.
Sensing delay in considering their cases, some In-charge Principals
working in Degree Colleges of Kashmir filed SWP No. 42/2014 in the
Srinagar Wing of this Court, which was disposed of at the motion hearing
stage by a Bench of this Court vide order dated 16.01.2014, with a direction
to the official respondents therein to convene a Departmental Promotion
Committee at the earliest and consider the cases of the petitioners therein
along with other eligible candidates for their confirmation in accordance with
the Rules of 2004. The Public Service Commission initiated the process for
appointment of Principals in Government Degree Colleges by way of
selection and issued a notice dated 11.04.2016 notifying the schedule of
interviews for the posts of Principal. This notice was called in question by the
private respondents in TA No. 5809/2021 (SWP No. 789/2016). Dr. Y.P.
Kundal, another private respondent, also challenged the aforesaid notice
separately in TA No. 5800/2021 (SWP No. 1902/2017). In SWP No.
789/2016, titled ‘Kartar Chand and ors v. State of J&K and ors
(TA
No. 5809/2021), a Single Bench of this Court passed an interim order dated
20.10.2016 directing the Public Service Commission not to finalize the
selection process initiated vide its notice dated 11.04.2016. Feeling aggrieved,
the Public Service Commission filed LPASW No. 159/2016, wherein a
Division Bench of this Court, vide its order dated 16.12.2016, modified the
interim order passed in the writ petition and directed that the PSC would
proceed with the selection of Principals to be appointed by promotion to such
of those vacancies which had arisen prior to 21.04.2014, after obtaining the
vacancy position from the Department of Higher Education, as per the
procedure in vogue prior to 21.04.2014. The Division Bench further provided
that the vacancies which arose after 21.04.2014 were to be filled up by
following the procedure contemplated under SRO 124 dated 21.04.2014. The
writ petitioners (private respondents herein) were permitted to participate in
the selection process, subject to their right to seek regularisation, which was
to be adjudicated at the time of final hearing of their writ petition. The review
petition filed by the PSC for recalling of the order dated 16.12.2016 (supra)
also came to be dismissed.However, during the pendency of the review
petition, the Government issued Order No. 684-HE of 2017 dated 12.12.2017,
whereby the In-charge Principals of various Degree Colleges were appointed
on substantive basis. Only a few amongst the In-charge Principals came to be
confirmed.
Feeling aggrieved of the Government Order (supra), the private
respondents filed fresh writ petitions i.e SWP Nos. 2966/2017, 789/2016
& 1902/2017 (TA Nos. 5796/2021, 5800/2021 and 5809/2021) to throw
challenge to the selection of the candidates who had been appointed as
Principals pursuant to the recommendations of the DPC/PSC. All the petitions
came to be clubbed and disposed of by the impugned common judgment. The
entire process of selection conducted by the PSC culminating into issuance of
Government Order of 2017 was held bad and quashed. The Tribunal, while
passing the impugned judgment, also directed the official respondents to
initiate a fresh process of selection in accordance with law. It is this judgment
of the Tribunal which is called in question in the writ petitions, reference to
which has already been given in the beginning of this judgment.
Grounds of challenge:
The petitioners in WP(C) No. 755/2022, i.e the appointed Principals,
have assailed the impugned judgment, primarily,on the following grounds:
(i) That the Tribunal has misconstrued the rule position, in that, the
post of Principal, as per the amended and un-amended recruitment
rules, was to be filled up by selection and, therefore, the PSC was well
within its right to determine and adopt any rational criteria for
evaluating the merit and suitability and prepare a select list of
candidates to be appointed as Principals. It is contended that the
Tribunal misconstrued the term ‘selection’ as promotion and landed in
serious errors of law.
(ii) That the Tribunal did not correctly appreciate the import of order
dated 16.12.2012 (supra), whereby the interim order passed by the
writ Court was modified to provide that the vacancies of Principal
which had arisen prior to 21.04.2014, i.e. the date of commencement
of the amended rules, were to be filled up as per the procedure in
vogue prior to 21.04.2014 and the vacancies which had arisen after
21.04.2014 were to be filled up in accordance with the procedure
prescribed by SRO 124 of 2014. The aforesaid order, it is contended,
was only an interim arrangement made during the pendency of the
writ petition and was subject to vacation or modification by way of
final judgment to be rendered in the writ petition. The Tribunal did not
appreciate that the Division Bench, in its order dated 16.12.2016, had
nowhere dealt with the issue of eligibility of the parties before it.
(iii) That the Tribunal has also not appreciated that the petitioners,
having been appointed after facing a selection process, were, at the
time of passing of the order, at the verge of retirement and, therefore,
equity was heavily tilted in their favour.
The Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir has assailed the
impugned judgment, inter alia, on the following grounds:
(i) That the appointment of Principal by way of selection made in
terms of Government Order of 2017 was pursuant to the
recommendations made by the DPC/PSC and, therefore, ought not to
have been found fault with by the Tribunal.
(ii) That the selection process was carried out by the J&K PSC strictly
as per rules and even in conformity with the directions passed by the
Division Bench vide its order dated 16.12.2012.
(iii) That indisputably, there were 51 posts of Principal lying vacant in
the year 2012, yet those posts were required to be filled up from
eligible Selection Grade Lecturers having the requisite period of
service on the basis of selection made by the DPC/PSC. Since the
appointment of Principal is by way of selection, therefore, the PSC
was well within its right to frame a rational criterion to assess the
merit, integrity and suitability of the eligible candidates to hold the
posts. The private respondents could not pass muster in the process of
selection conducted by the PSC and, therefore, could not be
regularized/confirmed as Principals.
Submissions of the private repsondnets:
Per contra, Mr. Abhinav Sharma, learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the private respondents, would support the judgment of the Tribunal on all
fours and submits that the selection process was conducted by the PSC de
hors the directions passed by the Division Bench vide order dated 16.12.2016
in LPASW No. 159/2016 and, therefore, was rightly held bad in the eye of
law. He would also argue in the alternative and submit that the private
respondents, having been posted as In-charge Principals during the period
between 2012 to 2014, rendered decades of service before superannuation
and, therefore, cannot be deprived of the benefit of regularization by applying
selection criteria which was not in vogue at the time they were made Incharge. He would submit that had the PSC convened the DPC in time and
adhered to the mandate of the J&K Civil Service (Reference of Vacancies and
Holding of Meetings of Departmental Promotion Committees) Rules, 2005
[“the Rules of 2005”], the private respondents would have been confirmed
long back on the basis of their merit, integrity and suitability, as was
contemplated in the Rules of 2008. He, therefore, urges that since the posts
held by the private respondents in In-charge capacity remained available till
their superannuation, it would not be difficult for this Court to balance the
equities and direct the PSC and the Government to regularize their services
and hold them entitled to the benefit of the higher post of Principal. It is
submitted that all the private respondents have now retired on superannuation
and were holding the posts of Principal in In-charge capacity.
Analysis and findings:
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
on record, it is necessary to notice a few undisputed facts.
From the year 2010 to 21.04.2014, when most of the private
respondents, holding substantively the posts of Selection Grade Lecturers,
were posted as In-charge Principals, the Rules of 2008 were in vogue. As per
the Rules of 2008, the post of Principal was provided to be filled up in the
following manner:
“Principal- by selection through DPC/PSC from Class-II,
Category (A), on the basis of integrity, merit and suitability
from amongst persons having at least 10 years of service in that
capacity”.
The Rules of 2008 underwent an amendment in the year 2014 vide
SRO 124 of 2014, which prescribed the method of recruitment to the post of
Principal in the following manner:
“Principal – by selection through PSC/DPC from Class-II,
Category (A), from amongst persons having at least 15 years of
teaching experience in Colleges, out of which at least three
years must be as Associate Professor, provided that the number
of candidates to be considered shall not ordinarily exceed five
times the number of posts”.
When we compare the stipulation with regard to the method of
recruitment to the post of Principal contained in the Rules of 2008 and the
rules amended in terms of SRO 124 of 2014, we clearly find that the post of
Principal was to be filled up by selection through PSC/DPC and this did not
undergo any change. Whether the private respondents are considered under
the unamended Rules of 2008 or as per the amended Rules of 2008 in terms
of SRO 124 of 2014, the method of recruitment would remain the same, i.e.
“by selection through PSC/DPC”, though there is a change in eligibility.It is,
thus, evident that when the Division Bench, in terms of its order dated
16.12.2016, directed that the private respondents herein shall be considered
against the vacancies that had accrued prior to 21.04.2014 as per the
procedure in vogue prior to the amendment, it did not change or direct the
change in the method of selection. The PSC was, thus, under an obligation
only to ensure that the private respondents who were eligible under the Rules
of 2008 and may have been rendered ineligible as per the rules amended in
the year 2014 were not kept out of the zone of consideration.
It is not the grievance of the private respondents that they or any of
them was ever declared ineligible. Indisputably, they were all considered as
per the criteria of selection adopted by the PSC, but were not found making
the grade. It is because of this reason that they could not be recommended for
appointment as Principals. There is no challenge to the fairness of the
selection process, nor have the private respondents raised any allegations of
arbitrariness or mala fides against the members of the PSC who constituted
the selection committee.The private respondents only insist that their merit,
integrity and suitability should have been determined as per the selection
criteria which was in vogue when they were made In-charge Principals. They
may be right in saying that, had the PSC and the Government undertaken a
timely exercise for their confirmation as Principals, their merit could have
been evaluated as per the selection criteria in vogue prior to 2012, reference to
which has been made by the PSC in their reply affidavit. Be that as it may, it
cannot be denied that the PSC, which framed a selection criterion for making
selection to the post of Principal, was well within its right to change, alter or
modify it at any time, provided the altered or modified criterion was in
consonance with and in conformity with Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India.
Viewed thus, it is difficult for us to accept the contention of the
private respondents that their evaluation of merit in the selection process
conducted by the PSC on the basis of a fresh criterion laid down after the
amendment of the Rules prejudiced their right to be appointed as Principal.
The argument is too specious to be accepted. We, however, find some
substance in the submission of learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
private respondents that the Government could not have prolonged the Incharge arrangements for a decade without taking effective steps for placing
their cases before PSC/DPC. Whether or not the Rules of 2005 are directory
or mandatory, the Government/PSC cannot absolve itself of its obligation to
conduct regular PSCs/DPCs so as to consider the cases of candidates holding
the posts in In-charge capacity for their confirmation.
Technically, it may be contended that the Rules of 2005 referred to
only the vacancies to be filled up in the promotion quota, whereas the post of
Principal is required to be supplied by way of selection, yet it does not
absolve the Government/PSC to act diligently and conduct DPCs/PSCs
periodically so that the ad hoc arrangements are not stretched beyond the
permissible period. A note of caution was sounded by the Supreme Court in
the year 2000 when it rendered a judgment in the case of S.P. Gupta v. State
of J&K, AIR 2000 SC 2386, which was followed by the issuance of
Government Order No. 743-GAD of 2007 dated 28.06.2007 to give effect to
the aforesaid judgment. Despite the fact that the judgment was rendered 26
years back, yet the State (now UT) has not shunned the practice of ad
hocism.In the instant case also, unnecessary litigation was generated by the
Government/PSC due to its reluctance/inability to convene timely DPCs.
We are aware and would like to make it abundantly clear that the
private respondents, having been made In-charge Principal, did not have any
vested right to be necessarily regularized against such posts and their
regularization was subject to their confirmation by PSC/DPC, which under
the rules was enjoined to conduct a proper selection process. It took the PSC
more than a decade to initiate and complete the process of selection for
posting the regular Principals in the Degree Colleges of the UT. All along, the
posts were held and manned by the In-charge Principals. It is not the case of
the Government that the placement of the private respondents as Principals in
In-charge capacity was de hors the Rules of 2008 or that the private
respondents lacked eligibility to hold the posts. They were made In-charge
Principals on the basis of their eligibility and seniority at the relevant point of
time. It is true that had the PSC convened the DPC and made selection in
time, possibly most of the private respondents would have been confirmed
and appointed as Principals on substantive basis.
Mr. Abhinav Sharma learned Senior Counsel appearing for the private
respondents is right in saying that in the earlier selection criteria there was
adequate weightage given to seniority, which was drastically reduced in the
selection criteria that was adopted in making the selection impugned in the
petitions before the Tribunal. It is also not in dispute that with a view to filling
up the posts of Principal on substantive basis, the process was set in motion
by collecting the ACRs and other details of the eligible candidates in the year
2012 and why the said process was not taken to its logical end is not
forthcoming from the record. Be that as it may, the formal process of
selection was initiated by the official respondents only when the schedule of
interviews was notified by the PSC in terms of its notification dated
11.04.2016.
We would also like to make it clear that the order of the Division
Bench dated 16.12.2016 passed in LPASW No. 159/2016 was only an order,
supposed to subsist till the disposal of the writ petition, and, therefore, cannot
be said to be an expression of final adjudication of any question of law or fact
by the Division Bench. It seems that not only the private respondents but also
the Tribunal has taken the order dated 16.12.2016 passed in LPASW No.
159/2016 as a judgment. The aforesaid order ultimately merged with the final
judgment rendered by the Tribunal impugned in these petitions. However,
since the process is claimed to have been conducted by the PSC by adhering
to the directions issued by the Division Bench in terms of its order dated
16.12.2016, as such, we have examined the matter in that context.
Conclusion and relief:
Viewed from any angle, the selection process conducted by the PSC
in which the petitioners in WP(C) No. 755/2022 emerged successful and were
subsequently appointed vide Government Order No. 684-HE of 2017 dated
12.09.2017 cannot be said to be flawed in any manner and, therefore, deserves
to be upheld. The directions of the Tribunal quashing the selection process
culminating into issuance of Government Order of 2017 is, thus, totally
flawed and cannot sustain. However, we cannot lose sight of the fact that
those of the private respondents who were posted as In-charge Principals
between the year 2010 and up to the amendment of the Rules of 2008 vide
SRO 124 of 2014 too have suffered adversely and are required to be rescued
in the given facts and circumstances for the following reasons:
(i) That they were posted as In-charge Principals in view of their
eligibility and seniority and, therefore, this is not a case of random
picking up.
(ii) That they continued to hold the posts in In-charge capacity with
the benefit of charge allowance for decades together till they got
superannuated from service. They have undoubtedly discharged the
plenary duties of the Principal and, therefore, cannot be deprived of
the benefit of regularization.
(iii) That the DPC/PSC, which was obliged to conduct the selection
process periodically, failed to do so for years together, as a result
whereof the private respondents continued to perform the duties of
Principal, though in In-charge capacity and with the benefit of charge
allowance only.
(iv) That had the DPC/PSC conducted the selection process
periodically and at least without any undue delay, probably the result
would have been different and most of the private respondents would
have been confirmed long back, as the criteria in vogue at the time of
their engagement as In-charge Principals was slightly different, having
extra weightage to the seniority.
In view of the aforesaid, these writ petitions are allowed. The order
impugned passed by the Tribunal is set aside. The selection and appointment
of the petitioners in WP(C) No. 755/2022 and other similarly situated
candidates is upheld. The Government is directed to treat all the private
respondents who were holding the posts of Principal in In-charge capacity at
the time of their superannuation as having been confirmed on the said posts
retrospectively w.e.f. the date they were made In-charge Principals, though
without any arrears of pay. The private respondents, however, shall be entitled
to the revision of their post-retiral emoluments and pension as may be
admissible to them under the rules.
CPLPA No.3/2018 in LPASW No. 159/2016
This is a petition seeking initiation of contempt proceedings against
the respondents for alleged wilful disobedience and non-compliance of the
order dated 16.12.2016 passed by the Division Bench in LPASW No.
159/2016.
In view of the judgment rendered today in the connected writ
petitions, whereby the selection process and consequential appointments have
been upheld, no case of wilful or deliberate disobedience of the order dated
16.12.2016 is made out. The contempt petition is, accordingly, dismissed and
the proceedings are closed.
(SHAHZAD AZEEM)
JUDGE
(SANJEEV KUMAR)
JUDGE
JAMMU
28 .09.2026
SANJEEV
Whether judgment is speaking:Yes
Whether judgment is reportable: Yes
Sanjeev Kumar
2026.09.29 10:00
I am the author of this
document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review