Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 17
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No. 3157/2026
Date of pronouncement: 05.10.2026
Date of uploading:
06.10.2026
1. UT of Jammu and Kashmir
through Commissioner-CumSecretary, Home Department, Civil
Secretariat, Jammu.
2. Director General of Police (Prisons),
Jammu and Kashmir, Govt. Jammu.
3. Senior Superintendent of Police,
District Jail, Jammu.
4. Commissioner-cum-Secy., General
Administration Deptt. Civil
Secretariat, Jammu.
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through: Ms. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
vs
Susheel Kumar S/o Sh. Parkash Chand
R/o Hakkal, Jammu
.…. Respondent(s)
Through:
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
ORDER (ORAL)
05.10.2026
Sanjeev Kumar ‘J’
1.
An order and judgment dated 09.02.2026, passed by the Central
Administrative Tribunal, Jammu Bench, Jammu [“the Tribunal”] in
TA No. 194/2020 (SWP No. 379/2019) titled “Susheel Kumar Vs.
State of Jammu and Kashmir & Ors.”, is subject matter of challenge
in this petition, filed by the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir
and three others by invoking Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
2.
In terms of judgment impugned, the Tribunal, has, while allowing the
petition of the respondent, directed the petitioners herein to regularise
WP(C) No. 3157/2026
his services as Junior Assistant on analogy of similarly situated ad
hoc Junior Assistants of the Prisons Department with effect from the
date, they were regularised with all consequential service benefits,
including fixation of pay and seniority.
3.
The impugned judgment is challenged by the petitioners, primarily,
on the ground that the Tribunal has failed to appreciate that the ad
hoc services of the respondent were not regularised as Junior
assistant for the reason that he did not fulfil the requisite eligibility
qualification as on the date of his initial appointment. It is submitted
that the respondent had failed to produce the certificate, indicating
that he possessed typing speed of 35 words per minute at the time of
his initial appointment.
4.
Before we advert to the grounds of challenge, urged by Ms. Monika
Kohli, learned Senior AAG to assail the judgment impugned, we
deem it appropriate to set out few facts, as are germane to the
disposal of the controversy raised in this writ petition.
5.
The respondent, having acquired the qualification of 10+2 from the
J&K State Board of School Education, was engaged/appointed as
Junior Assistant in the Prisons Department against the clear vacancy
on ad hoc basis vide order No. 109-A of 2001 dated 05.09.2001 by
the then Director General of Prisons. He continued to discharge his
duties of Junior Assistant and was even issued commendation
certificates by the senior officers for rendering exemplary services.
Despite rendering services for more than seven years in ad hoc
WP(C) No. 3157/2026
capacity, the services of the respondent were not regularised by the
petitioners. Feeling aggrieved, the respondent approached this Court
by way of SWP No. 379/2019, in which the respondent, inter alia,
sought a writ of mandamus to the petitioners to regularise his
services as Junior Assistant on permanent basis w.e.f. 04.09.2008
with all consequential benefits in terms of Government Order No.
1285-GAD of 201 dated 06.11.2001 or in the alternative, regularise
his services on permanent basis in terms of the Jammu and Kashmir
Civil Services (Special Provisions) Act, 2010 [“the Act of 2010”]
w.e.f. 04.09.2001 when he completed seven years of ad hoc services.
This petition was later transferred to the Tribunal on coming into
force the J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019 and constitution of Tribunal
for the UT of Jammu and Kashmir and the same was registered
before the Tribunal as TA No. 194/2020.
6.
The petition was contested by the petitioners by filing their reply
affidavit. The claim of the respondent for regularisation was sought
to be repudiated on the ground that the respondent did not hold the
eligibility qualification prescribed for the post of Junior Assistant in
the Prisons Department at the time of initial engagement i.e. on
05.09.2001, in that, the respondent was not possessing a certificate,
indicating that he had acquired type speed of 35 words per minute. It
was submitted that his case was considered under the Act of 2010
and was placed before the Empowered Committee along with three
other similarly situated Junior Assistants.
7.
WP(C) No. 3157/2026
The case of other three Junior Assistants, working on ad hoc basis in
Prisons Department was cleared and they were regularised on
permanent basis as Junior Assistants in the Prisons Department, but
in the case of the respondent, the recommendation for regularisation
of the services was made subject to relaxation of submission of
certificate of requisite type speed at the time of initial engagement. It
is the further stand of the petitioners that, though, the matter was
taken up by the Department of Prisons with the Government for
relaxation, but the same was not acceded to citing Clause (iii) of
Section 5 of the Act of 2010.
8.
The Tribunal, having considered the rival contention of the parties
and perused the material on record, came into conclusion that the
respondent, being similarly placed with three Junior Assistants
working in the Prisons Department in similar capacity, but were later
regularised, could not have been discriminated by the petitioners.
Accordingly, the respondent was also held entitled to regularisation
on a par with aforesaid three Junior Assistants. This is how the
petition, filed by the respondent came to be allowed in terms of the
judgment impugned.
9.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused material on
record, we are of the considered opinion that the respondent has been
discriminated vis-a-vis Rajesh Kumar, Harvinder Singh and Subath
Wani, who were similarly situated with the respondent, but were
regularised as Junior Assistants vide order dated 21.05.2016. It is not
WP(C) No. 3157/2026
in dispute that when the respondent was appointed as Junior Assistant
in Prisons Department, he possessed the requisite educational
qualification. It is also not in dispute that right from the date of his
initial engagement, i.e. 05.09.2001, he has been continuously
performing the duties of Junior Assistant. The only question that
needs determination in this petition is whether the respondent was
obliged to produce a certificate, indicating that he possessed the
typing speed of 35 words per minute at the time of his initial
engagement. The answer to this question can be found from relevant
recruitment rules.
10.
The J&K Jails (Sub-ordinate) Recruitment Rules were revised in the
year 1979 and were issued vide SRO 149 dated 15.03.1979. As per
the Schedule appended to the Rules, the minimum qualification
prescribed for the Junior Assistant was as under:
Matric or its equlivalent of any recognisesd University/Board.
The candidate should have knowledge of type writing of not less
than 30 words per minute.
It seems that these rules were later amended and the qualification,
which was prescribed by amendment, was in the following manner:
10+2 or its equivalent or any recognised University or Board.
The candidate should have knowledge of type writing of not
less than 35 words per minute.
11.
Needless to say that the rules have undergone further amendments
and these rules have now been repealed and replaced by the J&K
WP(C) No. 3157/2026
Jails (Sub-ordinate) Service Recruitment Rules, 1985 as amended up
to date and even in the latest rules, which are in vogue, the
production of a certificate from a typing institute, indicating that the
candidate possesses a typing speed of 35 words per minute is not the
essential requirement or condition of eligibility. The requirement of
the Rules is that a person should have a knowledge of type writing of
not less than 35 words per minute.
12.
In the given facts and circumstances, when it is not in dispute that the
respondent, right from the date of his initial engagement, has been
successfully rendering the services of Junior Assistant, it cannot be
said that the respondent did not have the knowledge of knowing the
type with the speed of 35 words per minute. There is thus inherent
falsity in understanding the eligibility requirement prescribed under
the rules and it is because of this erroneous understanding of the
rules, the respondent has been ousted from the zone of consideration
for regularisation on the ground that he failed to produce the requisite
certificate.
13.
It also needs to be taken note of that even the certificate, dating back
to the time when he was initially engaged was later produced by the
respondent and the said certificate was with the petitioners when the
case of all the junior assistants, working on ad hoc basis, was taken
up for regularisation. That apart, we fail to understand as to why the
relaxation, as recommended by the Empowered Committee, was not
considered by the Competent Authority.
14.
WP(C) No. 3157/2026
Viewed from any angle, we do not find that the respondent was not
eligible to hold the post of Junior Assistant at the time he was
initially engaged as such on ad hoc basis. His case has, therefore, not
been considered in right perspective and he has been clearly
discriminated vis-a-vis the persons similarly situated.
15.
For all these reasons, this petition is found devoid of any merit and
the same is, accordingly, dismissed.
16.
The respondent is held entitled to the benefit of regularisation with
effect from the date Rajesh Kumar, Harvinder Singh and Subath
Wani were regularised as Junior Assistants with all consequential
benefits as is held by the Tribunal in terms of the judgment
impugned.
17.
Disposed of.
(M A Chowdhary)
Judge
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
Jammu
05.10.2026
Vishal Sharma
Whether the order is reportable?:
Yes
Whether the order is speaking?:
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review