Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No.3242/2025
c/w
WP(C) No.3230/2025
WP(C) No.3666/2025
WP(C) No.3673/2025
WP(C) No.279/2026
Reserved on: 02.03.2026
Pronounced on:12.03.2026
Uploaded on: 12.03.2026
WP(C) No.3242/2025
1.
UT of Jammu & Kashmir through Commissioner/Secretary to
the Government, Health & Medical Education Department, J&K
Government, Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
2.
Principal, Indira Gandhi Government Dental College, Jammu
Pin Code-180001
...Petitioners(s)
Through:Mr. Raman Sharma, Sr. Advocate (AAG)
with Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate
Mr. Jattan Singh Gill, Advocate in CM
No.8402/2025
Versus
Dr. Jyoti Gupta D/o Sh. Subash Gupta R/o House NO.355,
Vikas Lane No.3, Talab Tillo, Jammu, Pin code-180002
...Respondent(s)
Through:- Mr. D.S.Chouhan, Advocate with
Ms. Damini Chouhan, Advocate
WP(C) No.3230/2025
1.
UT of Jammu & Kashmir through Commissioner/Secretary to
the Government, Health & Medical Education Department, J&K
Government, Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
2.
Principal, Indira Gandhi Government Dental College, Jammu
Pin Code-180005
...Petitioners(s)
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
Through:Mr. Raman Sharma, Sr. Advocate (AAG)
with Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate
Mr. Jattan Singh Gill, Advocate in CM
No.8403/2025
Versus
Dr. Etti Shree D/o Sh. Bansi Lal Sharma R/o H.No.2, Gurha Brahmina,
Bantalab, Jammu,181123
...Respondent(s)
Through:- Mr. Mr. Rahul Sharma, Advocate with
Ms. Rupali Sharma, Advocate
WP(C) No.3666/2025
1.
UT of Jammu & Kashmir through Commissioner/Secretary to
the Government, Health & Medical Education Department, J&K
Government, Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
2.
Principal, Indira Gandhi Government Dental College, Jammu
Pin Code-180005
...Petitioners(s)
Through:Mr. Raman Sharma, Sr. Advocate (AAG)
with Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate
Mr. Jattan Singh Gill, Advocate in CM
No.8402/2025
Versus
Dr. Etti Shree D/o Sh. Bansi Lal Sharma R/o H.No.2, Gurha Brahmina,
Bantalab, Jammu,181123
...Respondent(s)
Through:- Mr. Mr. Rahul Sharma, Advocate with
Ms. Rupali Sharma, Advocate
WP(C) No.3673/2025
1.
UT of Jammu & Kashmir through Commissioner/Secretary to
the Government, Health & Medical Education Department, J&K
Government, Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
2.
Principal, Government Medical College, Doda
...Petitioners(s)
Through:-
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
Mr. Raman Sharma, Sr. Advocate (AAG)
with Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate
Versus
Dr. Atoofa Zargar D/o Mr. Mohd. Iqbal Zargar R/o Doda
C/o Gold Medical Corner, Doda-182202
...Respondent(s)
Through:- Mr. D.S.Chouhan, Advocate with
Ms. Damini Chouhan, Advocate
WP(C) No.279/2026
1.
2.
UT of Jammu & Kashmir through Commissioner/Secretary to
the Government, Health & Medical Education Department, J&K
Government, Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
Principal, Government Medical College, Doda
...Petitioners(s)
Through:Mr. Raman Sharma, Sr. Advocate (AAG)
with Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate
Versus
Dr. Dheeraj Sharma S/o Mr. Tilak Raj Sharma R/o Ward No.2,
Krishna Colony, Kathua-184101
...Respondent(s)
Through:- Mr. D.S.Chouhan, Advocate with
Ms. Damini Chouhan, Advocate
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
Sanjeev Kumar ‘J’
1.
JUDGMENT
A common judgment dated 1st August, 2025 passed by the
Central Administrative Tribunal, Jammu Bench, Jammu [“the
Tribunal”] in OA No.452/2024 titled Dr. Jyoti Gupta v. Union
Territory of J&K and another, OA No.473/2025 titled Dr.
Dheeraj Sharma v. Union Territory of J&K and another, OA
No.497/2025 titled Dr. Atoofa Zargar v. Union Territory of J&K
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
and another, OA No.403/2025 titled Dr. Etti Shree v. UT of J&K
and another and OA No.615/2025 titled Dr. Etti Shree v. Union
Territory of J& K and another, is subject matter of challenge in
these five writ petitions filed by the Union Territory of J&K and
another, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
2.
Before we advert to the common questions of law involved for
determination in these petitions, it would be apposite to narrate
individual facts of each case.
WP(C) No.3242/2025
3.
The respondent-Dr. Jyoti Gupta was appointed as Registrar in the
discipline of Periodontology at Indira Gandhi Government
Dental
College,
Jammu
[“IGGDCJ”]
vide
order
dated
24.04.2021 issued by the Principal, IGGDCJ, initially for a
period of one year further extendable upto a maximum of three
years subject to satisfactory work and conduct certificate from
the concerned Head of the Department. On completion of three
years‟ tenure, the respondent was relieved vide order dated
22.04.2024. Feeling aggrieved by denial of further extension, the
respondent approached the Tribunal by way of OA No.452/2024,
which has been decided in her favour by the Tribunal, in terms of
the judgment impugned. The Tribunal has found the fresh
advertisement
notification
dated
07.04.2025
issued
by
respondent No.2, contrary to the provisions of Jammu &
Kashmir Medical and Dental Education (Appointment on
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
Academic Arrangement basis) Rules, 2020 [“the Academic
Arrangement Rules of 2020”] and has, accordingly, quashed the
same. The Tribunal has also issued directions to the petitioners
herein to allow the respondent to continue as Registrar in terms
of Rule 4 of the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020 for a
maximum
period
of
six
years
or
until
regular
selection/promotion is made, whichever is earlier.
WP(C) Nos.3230/2025 & 3666/2025
4.
The respondent in this petition was appointed as Tutor in the
discipline of Oral Pathology for a period of one year in the first
instance further extendable on year-to-year basis up to maximum
of three years in terms of order dated 01.06.2022 issued by the
petitioner No.2. The respondent was allowed to continue for
three years and before she could be relieved on 01.06.2025, on
completion of her tenure, she approached the Tribunal by way of
OA No.403/2025. During the pendency of OA No.403/2025,
respondent No.2 issued fresh advertisement notice dated
07.04.2025, for making fresh tenure appointment of Tutor,
which came to be challenged by the respondent by way of OA
No.615/2025 and a direction was also sought to the petitioners
herein to allow her to continue up to a maximum of six years or
until regular selection/promotion is made, whichever is earlier,
as provided under Rule 4 of the Academic Arrangement Rules of
2020.
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
WP(C) No.3673/2025
5.
The respondent, Dr. Atoofa Zargar came to be appointed as
Registrar in the Department of Dentistry of Government Medical
College, Doda vide order dated 06.05.2022 issued by the
Principal Government Medical College, Doda, the petitioner
No.2, initially for a period of one year further extendable up to
maximum three years subject to satisfactory work and conduct
certificate from the concerned HOD. When she was not granted
extension beyond the period of three years, respondent filed OA
No.497/2025, which has been disposed of by the Tribunal, in
terms of the common judgment, impugned in these petitions. The
Tribunal has directed the petitioners herein to allow the
respondent to work as Registrar in the discipline of Dentistry in
Government Medical College, Doda, on contractual basis, in
compliance with Rule 4 of the Academic Arrangement Rules of
2020 for a full term of six years.
WP(C) No.279/2026
6.
The respondent, Dr. Dheeraj Sharma was appointed against the
post of Registrar in the discipline of Dentistry in Government
Medical College, Doda vide order dated 06.07.2022, issued by
petitioner No.2. The respondent was initially engaged for a
period of one year, further extendable on year to year basis up to
maximum of three years. The extensions were subject to
satisfactory work and conduct certificate from the concerned
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
HOD. The respondent continued for a period of three years, as
envisaged in the order of his engagement but was not granted
further extension. He, therefore, approached the Tribunal by way
of OA No.473/2025, which, too, has been disposed of by the
Tribunal in terms of the common judgment, impugned in this
petition.
7.
From the factual narration, which we have given herein above, it
can be seen that so far as respondent in WP(C) No.3242/2025,
namely, Dr. Jyoti Gupta, & Dr. Etti Shree, respondent in WP(C)
Nos. 3666/2025 & 3230/2025, are concerned, they have been
engaged as Registrar in Periodontology and Tutor in the
discipline of Oral Pathology in IGGDC, Jammu respectively,
whereas Dr. Atoofa Zargar, respondent in WP(C) No.3673/2025
and Dr. Dheeraj Sharma, respondent in WP(C) NO.279/2026
were engaged as Senior Residents in the Department of Dentistry
in Government Medical College, Doda.
8.
The short grievance that was projected by the respondents in
their OAs before the Tribunal was that, in terms of Rule 4 of the
Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020, all of them were entitled
to function on their respective posts/positions upto a period of
six years. It was argued before the Tribunal that in the face of
clear stipulation contained in Rule 4, the petitioners could not
have brought their services to an end prematurely, when their
performance and conduct was exemplary and it was so certified
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
by the concerned Head of the Department. It is submitted that
good performance and conduct certificate by the HOD concerned
was the only requirement for seeking further extension. It was
also pleaded before the Tribunal that the appointment of the
respondent(s) under the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020
was in the nature of an ad hoc appointment and, therefore, the
petitioners could not have issued fresh advertisement notification
for making similar arrangement to replace them. It was,
however, the plea of the petitioners herein before the Tribunal
that the posts of Tutor, Registrar or Senior Residents are fixed
tenure posts and, therefore, no person can claim to work against
such tenure posts for a period beyond the tenure of such posts.
9.
The Tribunal, having considered the rival contentions of the
parties, seems to have accepted the contention of the respondents
and having regard to the provisions of Rule 4 of the Academic
Arrangement Rules of 2020, has come to the conclusion that the
respondents are entitled to work on the academic arrangement,
which they were appointed against, for a maximum period of six
years (one year at a time and subject to good performance) or till
selection/promotion is made in accordance with the Recruitment
Rules. The plea of the petitioners herein that the post of
Registrar/Tutor is a fixed tenure position of three years as laid
down by Govt. Order No.296-HME of 2010 dated 10.05.2010
read with Govt. Order No.383-JK(HME) of 2024 dated
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
20.06.2024 has been rejected on the ground that the Government
Orders are in the shape of executive instructions and, therefore,
cannot substitute or override the statutory provisions of Rule 4 of
the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020.
10.
The Tribunal seems to have entered into discussion about the
ambit and scope of Article 14 of the Constitution of India to
reiterate that the State in the matter of employment cannot act
arbitrarily and subject its citizens to hostile discrimination.
11.
The judgment impugned passed by the Tribunal is assailed by
the petitioners, inter alia, on the following grounds:
i)
That the post of Registrar/Tutor is a tenure post and the
maximum tenure whereof is three years. The Tribunal
failed to appreciate that any academic arrangement made
against a tenure post cannot exceed the maximum tenure
of the post.
ii)
That the Tribunal also did not appreciate that at the time of
giving
appointment
to
the
respondents
a
clear
representation was given that their appointment shall be
for a maximum period of three years and that in
acknowledgement thereof, all the respondents individually
submitted an undertaking in the prescribed format. They
were, thus, estopped by their conduct to contend that they
were entitled to remain in academic arrangement for
another three years contrary to the stipulation in the
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
advertisement notification, their appointment orders and
the undertaking, which they had submitted at the time of
their initial appointment.
iii)
That Article 14, which was debated at some length by the
Tribunal, was not attracted at all in this case for the reason
that the petitioners treated all the tenure post holders
uniformly and denied everyone extension beyond the
tenure of the post i.e. maximum of three years. This
aspect, though noticed by the Tribunal, has not been
correctly appreciated and an erroneous finding has been
returned with regard to the discrimination meted out to the
respondents.
12.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents would
argue that the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020 are
statutory in nature and fix a maximum tenure of six years of such
academic arrangement, subject of course to the yearly extension
based upon good conduct and performance. The learned counsel
for the respondents would argue that the Academic Arrangement
Rules of 2020 do not make any distinction between the
appointment against faculty positions and the appointment
against so called tenure posts. The Government Orders, if any,
issued by the Government fixing the tenure of Registrar/Tutor in
the Health and Medical Education Service, are in the shape of
executive instructions and, therefore, cannot override or whittle
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
down the effect of statutory Rules like the Academic
Arrangement Rules of 2020.
13.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material on record, we are of the view that the decision of these
petitions would turn on the determination of following
questions:i)
Whether the post of Registrar, Demonstrator or Tutor in
the Department of Dentistry borne on the Jammu &
Kashmir Dental Education (Dental College) Gazetted
Service Recruitment Rules, 1993 [“the Rules of 1993”]
issued vide SRO 75 dated 15.04.1993 is a tenure post for a
maximum period of three years and, therefore, no
appointment against the said post either regular or
academic arrangement can be made beyond such tenure?
ii)
Whether a person appointed on academic arrangement
against the tenure post of Registrar/Tutor under Academic
Arrangement Rules of 2020 is entitled to work against
such tenure post beyond the period of three years and upto
maximum period of six years?
14.
There is no dispute with regard to the fact that the post of
Registrar/Tutor/Demonstrator or Senior Resident is a tenure
post. Schedule II (Clinical and Non-Clinical Wing) of the Rules
of 1993, as amended, clearly provides that these posts shall have
a fixed tenure to be determined by the Government. In exercise
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
of the power conferred upon the Government, the tenure of
Registrar/Demonstrator/Tutor, which was earlier two years, was
fixed as three years in Government Medical/Dental College,
Jammu/Srinagar vide Government Order No.296-HME of 2010
dated 10.05.2010. It is, therefore, not disputed before us that a
Registrar/Tutor/Demonstrator in the Government Medical
/Dental Colleges of the Union Territory of J&K is appointed for
a maximum period of three years. Prescription of tenure of three
years by the Government is not by way of issuance of any
executive instructions but in the exercise of the powers delegated
to it under the statutory Rules of 1993.
15.
With a view to better understand, the relevant entry in the
Schedule of Rules of 1993, as amended from time to time, is
reproduced hereunder;
Class
Subject
Designatio
n of the
post
I
Registrar/
Demonstrator/
Tutor
(i)Clinical 2200-
Grade
Minimum
qualificatio
n
Minimu
m
teaching/
research
experienc
e
Method of recruitment
..
..
(i)
By
selection from the
Jammu
and
Kashmir
Health
and
Family
Welfare (Gazetted)
Service,
for
a
specified period, on
merit
based
selection made by
selection
committee of the
concerned Medical
College;
Or
(ii) from amongst
the candidates, not
in
Government
Service,
having
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
requisite
qualification
as
recognized by the
Dental Council of
India
by
engagement, for a
specified period, on
consolidated
pay
equal to basic pay
for the post of
Dental Surgeon in
the
Health
Department as per
SRO 93 of 2009
plus the dearness
allowance].
I
Registrar/
(i) NonDemonstrator/ Clinical
Tutor
2200-4000
…. ….
(ii)
By
selection from the
Jammu
and
Kashmir
Halth
and
Family
Welfare
(Gazetted)
Service, for a
specified period,
on merit based
selection made by
selection
committee of the
concerned
Medical College
Or
(ii) from amongst
the
candidates,
not
in
Government
Service, having
requisite
qualification as
recognized by the
Dental Council of
India
by
engagement, for a
specified period,
on consolidated
pay equal to basic
pay for the post
of
Dental
Surgeon in the
Health
Department
as
per SRO 93 of
2009 plus the
dearness
allowance].
16.
The Government Order of 2010, which has been issued in
supersession of earlier order, fixes maximum tenure of such
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
posts as „three years’. The Government Order of 2010 (supra) is
also set out below for better appreciation of the issue:“Government Order No.296-HME of 2010
D a t e d: 10.05.2010
Sanction is hereby accorded to the fixation of tenure of
Registrar/Demonstrator/Tutor as 3 years instead of 2 years in
Government Medical/Dental College, Jammu/Srinagar.
By Order of the Government of Jammu and Kashmir”
17.
Once it is conceded on the basis of the Rule position, which, in
any case, is the position of statutory rules, that a person
appointed
on
regular
basis
against
the
post
of
Registrar/Tutor/Demonstrator cannot work against such post for
more than the maximum period of three years, which is a tenure
of the post, it cannot be gainsaid that a temporary arrangement
against these tenure posts can also not extend beyond the tenure
of such post(s).
18.
Even the Teachers Eligibility Qualification in Medical
Institutions Regulations, 2022, issued by the National Medical
Commission under Section 57 of the National Medical
Commission Act, 2019, clearly and unequivocally lay down and
prescribe that the posts of „Registrars/Tutors‟, now designated as
„Senior Residents‟ are tenure positions not exceeding three years
and cannot be termed as faculty positions. The Relevant entries
in the Regulations is set out below:
Table 1A.
Senior
Norms for Faculty Appointment and Promotion in Broad
Specialties (MD/MS) which are in existence for more than
10 years
Resident
Senior Resident is one who is doing his residency in the concerned
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
(Medical
Postgraduates)
Tutors (Non-Medical
Postgraduates)
department after
(MD/MS/DNB).
obtaining
Medical
Postgraduate
degree
Non-medical Postgraduates with MSc (Medical) degree shall be
called Tutors in whichever departments they are working.
The posts of Senior Resident and Tutor are tenure positions not
exceeding 3 years. The graduate must be below 45 years of age at the
time of initial appointment.
The post of tenured Senior Residents and Tutors are not faculty
positions.
All other designations practiced earlier stands deleted.
However, existing Tutors/Demonstrators/Registrars appointed on
permanent basis shall be renamed as Senior Residents and Tutors, as
the case may be, and continue to work till superannuation.
The conditions mentioned above shall not be applicable to Senior
Residents/Tutors/Demonstrators/Registrars who are appointed on
permanent basis before the notification of these Regulations.
Table 2.
Senior Resident
Norms for Faculty Appointment and Promotion in the
Department of Dentistry in Medical College
Senior Resident is one who is doing his residency in Dentistry after
obtaining MDS degree.
The post of senior resident is a tenured position not exceeding 3
years. The graduate must be below 45 years of age at the time of
initial appointment.
19.
It is a trite law after the judgment of Preeti Srivastava v. State
of Madhya Pradesh, (1999) 7 SCC 120, wherein the Supreme
Court has, in categoric terms, held that the Medical Council of
India‟s Regulations framed under the Indian Medical Council
Act, 1956 in the matter of fixing the standards of medical
education are supreme and override any contrary rule or
regulation framed by the State Government. Para 35, 36, 37 and
38 of the judgment are relevant for our purposes and are,
therefore, set out below:“35.The legislative competence of the Parliament and the legislatures of
the States to make laws under Article 246 is regulated by the VIIth
Schedule to the Constitution. In the VIIth Schedule as originally in force,
Entry 11 of List-II gave to the States an exclusive power to legislate on
"Education including universities subject to the provisions of Entries 63,
64, 65 and 66 of List-I and Entry 25 of List-III." Entry 11 of List-II was
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
deleted and Entry 25 of List-III was amended with effect from 3.1.1976 as
a result of the Constitution 42nd Amendment Act of 1976. The present
Entry 25 in the Concurrent List is as follows:
"Entry 25, List III: Education, including technical education,
medical education and universities, subject to the provisions of
entries 63, 64, 65 and 66 of List I: vocational and technical
training of labour."
Entry 25 is subject, inter alia, to Entry 66 of List-I. Entry 66 of List-I is as
follows:"Entry 66, List I: Co-ordination and determination of standards in
institutions for higher education or research and scientific and
technical institutions."
Both the Union as well as the States have the power to legislate on
education including medical education, subject, inter alia, to Entry 66 of
List-I which deals with laying down standards in institutions for higher
education or research and scientific and technical institutions as also coordination of such standards. A State has, therefore, the right to control
education including medical education so long as the field is not occupied
by any Union Legislation. Secondly, the State cannot, while controlling
education in the State, impinge on standards in institutions for higher
education. Because this is exclusively within the purview of the Union
Government. Therefore, while prescribing the criteria for admission to the
institutions for higher education including higher medical education, the
State cannot adversely affect the standards laid down by the Union of
India under Entry 66 of List-I. Secondly, while considering the cases on
the subject it is also necessary to remember that from 1977 education
including, inter alia, medical and university education, is now in the
Concurrent List so that the Union can legislate on admission criteria also.
If it does so, the State will not be able to legislate in this field, except as
provided in Article 254.
36. It would not be correct to say that the norms for admission have no
connection with the standard of education, or that the rules for admission
are covered only by Entry 25 of List III. Norms of admission can have a
direct impact on the standards of education. Of course, there can be rules
for admission which are consistent with or do not affect adversely the
standards of education prescribed by the Union in exercise of powers
under Entry 66 of List-I. For example, a State may, for admission to the
post-graduate medical courses, lay down qualifications in addition to those
prescribed under Entry 66 of List-I. This would be consistent with
promoting higher standards for admission to the higher educational
courses. But any lowering of the norms laid down can, and do have an
adverse effect on the standards of education in the institutes of higher
education. Standards of education in an institution or college depend on
various factors. Some of these are:
(1) The calibre of the teaching staff;
(2) A proper syllabus designed to achieve a high level of
education in the given span of time;
(3) The student-teacher ratio;
(4) The ratio between the students and the hospital beds available
to each student;
(5) The calibre of the students admitted to the institution;
(6) Equipment and laboratory facilities, or hospital facilities for
training in the case of medical colleges;
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
(7) Adequate accommodation for the college and the attached
hospital; and
(8) The standard of examinations held including the manner in
which the papers are set and examined and the clinical
performance is judged.
37. While considering the standards of education in any college or
institution, the calibre of students who are admitted to that institution or
college cannot be ignored. If the students are of a high calibre, training
programmes can be suitably moulded so that they can receive the
maximum benefit out of a high level of teaching. If the calibre of the
students is poor or they are unable to follow the instructions being
imparted, the standard of teaching necessarily has to be lowered to make
them understand the course which they have undertaken; and it may not be
possible to reach the levels of education and training which can be attained
with a bright group. Education involves a continuous interaction between
the teachers and the students. The pace of teaching, the level to which
teaching can rise and the benefit which the students ultimately receive,
depend as much on the calibre of the students as on the calibre of the
teachers and the availability of adequate infrastructural facilities. That is
why a lower student-teacher ratio has been considered essential at the
levels of higher university education, particularly when the training to be
imparted is highly professional training requiring individual attention and
on-hand training to the pupils who are already doctors and who are
expected to treat patients in the course of doing their post-graduate
courses.
38.
The respondents rely upon some observations in some of the
judgments of this Court in support of their stand that it is for the State to
lay down the rules and norms for admission; and that these do not have
any bearing on the standard of education. In P. Rajendran v. State of
Madras & Ors. ([1968] 2 SCR 786), a Constitution Bench of this Court
considered the validity under Articles 14 and 15(1), of district- wise
reservations made for seats in the medical colleges. In that case, the Act in
question prescribed eligibility and qualifications of candidates for
admission to the medical colleges. The Court observed:
"So far as admission is concerned, it has to be made by those who
are in control of the colleges - in this case, the Government.
Because the medical colleges are Government colleges affiliated
to the university. In these circumstances, the Government was
entitled to frame rules for admission to medical colleges
controlled by it, subject to the rules of the university as to
eligibility and qualifications. This was what was done in these
cases and, therefore, the selection cannot be challenged on the
ground that it was not in accordance with the University Act and
the rules framed thereunder."
This Court, therefore, upheld the additional criteria framed by the State for
admission which were not inconsistent with the norms for admission laid
down by the University Act. Since these additional qualifications did not
diminish the eligibility norms under the University Act, this Court upheld
the additional criteria laid down by the state as not affecting the
standards laid down by the University Act. The question of diluting the
standards laid down, did not arise.”
20.
In view of the prescription of three years tenure of the position
of Registrar/Tutor by the Medical Council of India/ National
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
Medical Commission Regulations coupled with the Rules of
1993 read with Government Order of 2010 (supra), anything
enlarging the tenure of position of Registrar/Tutor/Demonstrator
has to be held bad and ignored.
21.
We now turn to the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020.
Undoubtedly, Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020 have been
framed by the Lieutenant Governor in the exercise of powers
conferred upon him by proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution
of India. These rules have been framed in the similar manner in
which the Rules of 1993 have been framed. The only difference
is that the Rules of 1993 deal with permanent and regular
recruitment to various gazetted posts borne on the Dental
Education (Gazetted) Service constituted by the Rules of 1993,
whereas the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020 are only to
give statutory backing to the academic arrangements that may be
required to be made in the Medical/Dental Colleges of the Union
Territory till the regular faculty in such colleges is put in place.
The Rules are applicable to teaching positions, medical officers
and
posts
/technical
of
staff
Nurses/Para
in
the
Medics/Paramedical/paradental
Government
Medical
Colleges,
Government Dental Colleges, Government Ayurvedic College,
Government Unani College, Government Nursing Colleges,
ANM/GNM Schools, Medical Superintendents and Deputy
Medical Superintendents, as is evident from reading of Rule 3 of
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020. The posts of
Registrar/Tutor/Demonstrator are not per se included in the
ambit of the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020. This is so
evident from the reading of Rule 3 in its entirety.
22.
As discussed above, NMC Regulations, 2022 clearly declared
the position of Registrar/Tutor/Demonstrator as non-faculty
positions and, therefore, it cannot be said that the posts of
Registrar/Demonstrator/Tutor etc are the teaching positions and,
therefore, the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020 are
applicable to them. However, Academic Arrangement Rules of
2020 do refer to the post of Registrar and Demonstrator as part
of teaching positions, though same is contrary to the position
obtaining from the NMC Regulations, 2022.
23.
Be that as it may, Rule 4 is at the helm of the controversy and,
therefore, needs to be adverted to very carefully. Rule 4 reads
thus:“4. Appointment under these Rules.----(1) Notwithstanding anything to
the contrary contained in any rule or order for the time being in force
relating to the method of recruitment and conditions of service for
recruitment in any service, or to any post under the Government, the
appointing authority may appoint persons to the posts mentioned under
Rule 3 on academic arrangement basis initially for a period of one year
extendable up to maximum of six years (one year at a time and subject to
good performance and conduct) or till selection/promotion is made in
accordance with the rules of recruitment governing the respective posts,
whichever is earlier. The extension so granted under these rules shall not
be beyond a period of six years under any circumstances and this shall be
clearly indicated in the engagement order:
Provided that extension up to 3 years shall be made on year to
year basis by the Principal of the College concerned. For engagement
beyond 3 years, the case will be considered by the Government and
once approved, Principal concerned shall be authorized to grant further
extensions for another three years:
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
Provided further that in case of Professors and Associate
Professors appointed in new Government Medical Colleges viz.
Anantnag, Baramulla, Doda, Handwara, Kathua, Rajouri and
Udhampur, the appointing authority may appoint the persons on
academic arrangement basis initially for a period of 3 years extendable
up to maximum six years (one year at a time and subject to good
performance and conduct) or till selection/promotion is made in
accordance with the rules of recruitment governing the respective posts,
whichever is earlier:
Provided also that recruitment against the posts as may be
made on academic arrangement basis in any of the Health and Medical
Institutions, shall and shall always be on academic arrangement only
without conferment of any preferential right on the engages for regular
appointment against these posts, which shall be made strictly in
accordance with the relevant recruitment rules:
Provided also that the appointment under these rules shall not
entitle the appointee to any preferential claim for regular appointment
under normal process of selection/appointment:
Provided also that the appointment on academic arrangement basis
against the faculty posts in the Medical Colleges shall by itself stand
terminated on the attainment of 70 years of age by the appointee except
for the faculty posts of the Department of Dentistry in the new Medical
Colleges, where it shall stand terminated on attainment of 65 years of
age by the appointee. Also in respect of faculty posts of the Dental
Colleges and the Ayurvedic and Unani Medical Colleges, it shall stand
terminated on attainment of 65 years of age by the appointee.
(2) The services of an appointee under these rules shall be terminable
before the expiry of the tenure of appointment with one month's notice,
from either side, or on payment of one month's salary in lieu of notice
by the appointing authority.
(3) The appointee under these rules shall have to execute an
agreement with the Government on the prescribed form appended as
Form "A" to these rules.
(4) The appointment on academic arrangement basis against a post
shall be made only when filling up of the post according to relevant
recruitment rules is likely to be time consuming.”
24.
From a reading of Rule 4, reproduced above, which begins with
non obstante clause, empowers the appointing authority, which
is competent to make appointment to the posts under the relevant
recruitment rules, to appoint persons to the posts mentioned
under Rule 3 on academic arrangement basis initially for a
period of one year extendable up to maximum of six years (one
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
year at a time and subject to good performance and conduct) or
till selection/promotion is made in accordance with the rules of
recruitment governing the respective posts, whichever is earlier.
The Rule further makes it clear that nobody shall be entitled to
hold any post on academic arrangement basis for a period
beyond six years under any circumstances. The competent
authority to extend the academic arrangement up to three years is
the Principal of the College concerned, whereas the engagement
beyond three years has to be done by the Principal only after it is
approved by the Government in the Department of Health and
Medical Education.
25.
There are further stipulations in the Rule, which provide that a
candidate holding such position shall not claim any preferential
right for regular appointment on the basis of his/her officiation
against the post on academic arrangement basis etc etc. It is on
the strength of this Rule, it is contended on behalf of the
respondents,
a
person
appointed
against
the
post
of
Tutor/Registrar/Demonstrator is entitled to continue for a
maximum period of six years. However, the first appointment
shall be for a period of one year and that the same shall be
extendable only subject to the good conduct and performance
certificate by the Head of the Department concerned. It is the
plea of all the respondents that they all were given extension up
to the period of three years having regard to their performance
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
and good conduct and were also entitled to further extension for
a period of three years more (one year at a time) as their work
and conduct and performance, as certified by their HODs, was
exemplary. While the petitioners do not dispute the performance
and conduct of the respondents, yett they would submit that
extension beyond three years is not permissible as the
appointment of the respondents is against a tenure post of
Registrar/Tutor.
26.
We have given our thoughtful consideration to this aspect of the
matter. Although, there is no specific stipulation in Academic
Arrangement Rules of 2020, in particular Rule 4 thereof, that in
the case of tenure post of Registrar/Tutor, the maximum period
for which academic arrangement can be made shall not be
exceeding three years, yet on the reading of the Rules in their
entirety, particularly in light of the Recruitment Rules of 1993
read with National Medical Commission Regulations of 2022
and the earlier Regulations framed by the Medical Council of
India prescribing eligibility for Teachers etc, we are of the
considered opinion that as against the posts of Registrar/Tutor,
extension beyond three years, which is the tenure of such post, is
impermissible in law.
27.
We are conscious of the fact that the Jammu & Kashmir Medical
and Dental Education (Appointment on Academic Arrangement
Basis) Rules, 2009 [“Academic Arrangement Rules of 2009”],
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
which were later repealed by the Academic Arrangement Rules
of 2020, had in Rule 4 clearly provided that the appointment on
academic
arrangement
basis
against
a
tenure
of
Registrar/Demonstrator /Tutor should not exceed the tenure of
these posts. However, such stipulation is conspicuously missing
in the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020.
28.
In the light of discussion we have made above, we hold that the
aforesaid aspect does not change the legal position. It seems that
the aforesaid stipulation was not specifically embodied in Rule 4
of the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020. As per Rule 3,
these posts, which are tenure posts were not contemplated to be
brought within the purview of the Academic Arrangement Rules
of 2020 and it is because of this reason, Rule 3 does not make
any mention of the post of Registrar/Tutor/Demonstrator.
Though, there is clear reference to the post of Medical Officers,
Medical Superintendents and Deputy Medical Superintendents
etc. Simply because the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020
are loosely drafted cannot take away the effect of National
Medical Commission Regulations, 2022 and the Recruitment
Rules of 1993.
29.
Once it is not in dispute that the posts of Registrar, Tutor and
Demonstrator are a fixed tenure posts, there could be no
argument that a person appointed against these posts can
continue even beyond the tenure of such post. If a person, who is
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
appointed against such tenure post on regular basis, cannot work
against such post beyond the tenure, it is difficult to comprehend
that a person, who is appointed against such post on academic
arrangement basis has a better right and can continue beyond the
tenure of such post. It needs no emphasis to say that the doctors
drawn from the Directorate of Health Services or even medicos
drawn from the open market, on the basis of competition are
appointed against the tenure post of Registrar/Demonstrator/
Tutor so as to enable them to acquire minimum eligibility to be
appointed to the teaching faculty like Lecturer/Assistant
Professor.
30.
As per the Rules of 1993 as also NMC Regulations, 2022, apart
from the other eligibility conditions, a candidate seeking to be
appointed as Lecturer/Assistant Professor in any of the discipline
must
possess
three
years
teaching
experience
as
Registrar/Tutor/Demonstrator. It is because of this reason, these
positions are made tenure posts having a fixed tenure so that
maximum people are given opportunity to acquire experience
and attain eligibility to compete for recruitment to the post of
Lecturer/Assistant Professor.
31.
We are also not in full agreement with the Tribunal that the
Government Orders prescribing tenure of three years for the post
of Registrar/Tutor/Demonstrator is an executive instructions
simpliciter and, therefore, cannot override the statutory rules.
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
We, as explained above, reiterate that the Government Order of
(supra)
fixing
the
tenure
of
the
post
of
Registrar/Tutor/Demonstrator is not merely an executive
instruction but is an order issued in exercise of delegated powers
conferred upon the Government by the Rules of 1993, which, in
any case, are statutory rules. The appointment as Registrar/Tutor
shall be for a specified period as prescribed in the Statutory
Rules i.e. the Rules of 1993. The Government Order only
specifies the period.
32.
Non obstante clause used in Section 4 of the Academic
Arrangement Rules of 2020 gives Rule 4 an overriding effect on
any other rule or order relating only to the method of recruitment
and conditions of service for recruitment in any service or to any
post under the Government. It would simply mean that
notwithstanding that the posts named in Rule 3 are required to be
filled up through a regular selection process to be conducted by
the PSC, the appointment on academic arrangement shall be
made by following the selection procedure prescribed under the
Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020. Overriding effect is,
therefore, limited to the extent of method of recruitment. The
Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020, in particular Rule 4
thereof, cannot be construed to mean that it has the effect of even
extending the tenure of a post beyond the one fixed by the
Government under the statutory recruitment rules made for
WP(C) Nos.3242/2025, 3230/2025, 3666/2025, 3673/2025 & 279/2026
making regular selection and appointment to the Gazetted
services in the Medical/Dental Education.
33.
Viewed thus, we find merit in these petitions. Consequently, the
petitions are allowed holding that no person appointed against
the post of Registrar/Tutor/Demonstrator either in the medical
education or dental education shall be entitled to continue
beyond a maximum period of three years, which is the tenure of
such posts notwithstanding anything to the contrary provided in
the Academic Arrangement Rules of 2020, in particular Rules 4
thereof. We also hold that the position of the respondents, who
were engaged as Registrar in Government Medical College,
Doda, is in no manner different.
34.
In the premises, the judgment impugned passed by the Tribunal
is set aside and the OAs filed by the respondents are dismissed.
The applications, if any, pending shall also stand disposed of.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
JAMMU
12.03.2026
Vinod, Secy
Vinod Kumar
2026.03.12 17:08
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Whether the order is speaking : Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review