Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Reserved on: 23.12.2025
Pronounced on: 03.02.2026
APHC010659772025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3552]
WRIT APPEAL NO: 1342 of 2025
Uppala Ramasatyanarayana,
Vs.
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
Advocate for Appellant:
... Appellant
... Respondent(s)
**********
Mr.P R K AMERANDRA KUMAR
Advocate(s) for Respondent(s): Mr.K GANI REDDY,
GP FOR SOCIAL WELFARE
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 03rd February, 2026
ORDER: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
This intra-court Appeal is directed against the order dated
07.10.2025 passed by learned Single Judge in W.P. No.38074 of
2018. By the said order, learned Single Judge has relegated the
appellant/writ petitioner to avail alternative remedy of preferring
appeal before the appellate authority within four weeks from the
date of receipt of the order and in turn, the appellate authority
was directed to dispose the same within six months thereafter,
after providing reasonable opportunity of hearing for both parties
concerned and till such time, the parties were directed to maintain
status quo.
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
2.
The brief facts of the case in a nutshell are as under:
(a)
The subject property admeasuring Acres 0.97 cents in
R.S.No.330/1/1, Acres 0.44 cents in R.S.No.331/2 and Acres 4.46
cents in R.S.No.331/3 of Koya Rajahmundry Village, Buttaigudem
Mandal, West Godavari District, (hereinafter, ‘subject land’) falls
under notified schedule/agency area. The lands falling in the said
area are governed by the provisions of The Andhra Pradesh
Scheduled Areas Land Transfer Regulation, 1959 (Regulation
No.I of 1959), as amended by Regulation No.1 of 1970.
(b)
Initially, the subject land stated to be owned by Smt.Podium
Doolamma, a tribe community.
She stated to have secured
permission from the Assistant Agent to Government, Kovvuru,
vide proceedings in D.Dis.No.908/1943, dated 13.09.1943, for
alienation and accordingly, the same has been alienated in favour
of Maddu Pentayya, non-tribal, through registered sale deed
No.980/1943, dated 23.10.1943.
The said non-tribe, in turn
alienated the subject land in favour of Uppala Siva Ramaiah,
through registered sale deed vide Document No.445/1950, dated
27.05.1950. Since then, Uppala family has been in continuous
possession and occupation of the subject land and presently,
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
appellant/writ petitioner claims to be in possession and enjoyment
as legal heir.
(c)
Previously,
one
Smt.Punam
Pakeeramma,
wife
of
Pentayya, along with two others made complaint under Section
3(2)(a) of Regulation I of 1959 before the Special Deputy
Collector, Tribal Welfare, Eluru, alleging that the subject land has
been transferred in favour of Uppala family, non-tribe, in
contravention to the Regulation I of 1959 r/w Regulation I of 1970.
The enquiry in S.R.No.34/1978 eventually stated to have ended
in favour of Uppala family and by order dated 30.09.1978, the
Tribunal has dismissed the petition by holding that the subject
land was alienated by Podium Doolappa, Koya tribe, in favour of
Uppala family after securing prior permission from Assistant Agent
to Government, Kovvur, in proceedings vide D.Dis.No.908/1943,
dated 13.09.1943, issued under Section 4(1) of Act I of 1917.
Therefore, there was no contravention as alleged.
(d)
Subsequently, yet again second complaint came to be
instituted by the Special Deputy Tahsildar, K.R.Puram, on very
same set of allegations that the initial transfer from Podium
Doolappa, tribe community, in favour of Uppala family was without
any prior permission, the Tribunal after enquiry dismissed the
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
complaint vide S.R.No.68/2004 on 20.05.2005 by holding that it
has no jurisdiction to reopen the case once again which earlier
ended in favour of Uppala family on appreciation of the evidence
on record as the same amounted to res judicata.
(e)
That being so, in third round, the unofficial respondent
stated to have made yet again a complaint under Section 3(2)(a)
of Regulation I of 1959 with similar allegation that the subject land
has been transferred from Tribe to Non-Tribe in contravention to
the provisions. The Tribunal once again embarked on enquiry,
however, it has now allowed the complaint in S.R. No.26/2016,
vide order dated 28.08.2018.
The Tribunal has come to
conclusion that the permission stated to have been granted under
Section 4(1) of Act I of 1917, dated 13.09.1943, since has not
been produced, the sale would otherwise rendered null and void
and the certificate that was produced from Divisional Revenue
Officer, Kovvur, intimating the destruction of records which
included file in D.Dis.No.908/1943, dated 13.09.1942, would not
annure to the benefit of respondent therein.
(f)
In consequence to the said order, notice dated 15.10.2018
was issued by the 4th respondent herein directing the Mandal
Revenue Officer, Buttaigudem, to take possession of subject land
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
after conducting proper panchanama, therefore, the appellant/writ
petitioner was constrained to immediately file the writ petition
challenging the orders of the 3rd respondent.
Initially, while
issuing notices to respondents, this Court passed interim order
staying the operation of the orders passed by 3rd respondent,
including the eviction of petitioner from subject property, pending
further orders. It is also stated that the appellant/writ petitioner
preferred appeal before the District Collector, the Appellate
Authority, however, in view of pendency of the writ petition, the
same came to be withdrawn on 19.01.2019.
(g)
The appellant/writ petitioner instituted the writ petition on
the ground that when two successive enquiries in S.R.
Nos.34/1978 and 68/2004 concerning the same subject land
since ended in dismissal by orders dated 30.09.1978 and
20.05.2005, in the absence of any specific provision in Regulation
I of 1959, the third complaint could not have been entertained by
the 3rd respondent and reviewed the earlier orders, which
otherwise attained finality. Therefore, the very entertaining of the
third complaint itself is without jurisdiction.
respondent, however, opposed the writ petition.
The unofficial
(h)
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
Eventually, learned Single Judge has disposed of the writ
petition, relegating the appellant/writ petitioner to avail alternative
remedy of appeal. That is how the present appeal is before us.
3.
Heard Mr.P.R.K.Amarendra Kumar, learned counsel for
appellant, learned Government Pleader for Social Welfare for
official respondents and Mr.Sitaram Chaparla, representing
Mr.K.Gani Reddy, learned counsel for unofficial respondent.
4.
Learned counsel for appellant mainly contended that when
successive enquiries that were initiated under Section 3(2)(a) of
Regulation I of 1959 ended in dismissal by confirming that the
subject land has been validly transferred from Tribe to Non-tribe
after seeking necessary prior permission as required under
Section 4(1) of Act I of 1917, the 3rd respondent ought not to have
even entertained the third complaint at the instance of unofficial
respondent, which otherwise clearly amounted to res judicata.
He also contended that when statute does not provide or confer
any power to review the orders or decisions made earlier to, the
3rd respondent is precluded from entertaining the third complaint
and reviewing the earlier orders. 3rd respondent being creature of
a statute do not possess any inherent powers as such to exercise
review powers. Though there is an alternative remedy of appeal
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
against the impugned orders passed by 3rd respondent, learned
counsel contends that inasmuch as the order passed by
3rd respondent is clearly without jurisdiction, the appellant/writ
petitioner is justified in approaching the writ court invoking the
jurisdiction under Article 226 of Constitution of India. In support of
above submissions, reliance has been placed on the following
judgments:
(i)
Judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in
Chintalapati Ramalinga Raju v. District Collector,
Eluru, W.G.District and another1
(ii)
Order of the Single Bench of this Court in Bondala
Reddiyya v. Agent to Government, District Collector,
W.G.District, Eluru and others2
5.
On the other hand, both learned Government Pleader as
well as learned counsel for unofficial respondent vehemently
opposed the above submissions and inter alia contended that the
order of learned Single Judge does not call for any interference,
inasmuch as appellant/writ petitioner was merely relegated to
avail alternative remedy which is more efficacious. They further
contended that in earlier round of enquiries, the contesting
Uppala family never produced the copy of order dated
1 2000 (4) ALD 443 (DB)
2 2007 (6) ALD 165
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
13.09.1943, by which permission was granted by Assistant Agent
to Government purportedly in exercise of powers under Section
4(1) of Act I of 1917, which would go to the root of the matter and
mere mentioning of the same as a recital in the principal sale
deed dated 23.10.1943, ipso facto would not mean that such
permission existed, therefore, the 3rd respondent was justified in
holding that non-production of the said document would belie the
claim that there existed prior permission. Since the Uppala family
is claiming that the subject property was purchased from Tribe to
Non-tribe after securing prior permission, the burden lies on them
to prove the same. In this regard, reliance has been placed on
the order of learned Single Judge of this Court in Yandapu
Satyavati and another v. Secretary to Government (Tribunal
Welfare) of A.P., Hyderabad and others3.
6.
We have given anxious consideration to the respective
submissions made on either side.
7.
The admitted scenario of the case is that initially the subject
land was held by Podium Doolappa, who was tribe community.
He alienated the said land by way of registered sale deed dated
13.09.1943 in favour of Maddu Pentayya, who was a non-tribe
3 2007 (5) ALD 769
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
community. Smt.Maddu Rattamma, w/o.Pentayya, later alienated
the subject land in favour of Uppala Sivaramaiah, through
registered sale deed dated 27.05.1950.
After the demise of
Uppala Sivaramaiah, his wife and son stated to be in possession
and enjoyment of the property. That being so, at the behest of
Smt.Pakeeramma and two others, first complaint came to be filed
vide S.R.No.34/1978 under Section 3(2) of Regulation I of 1959
alleging that Uppala family had acquired the subject property from
a Tribe which otherwise was prohibited and therefore, such
transfer would render null and void and consequently, sought for
ejectment of the respondents therein.
8.
The competent authority, after detailed enquiry, having
considered the both oral and documentary evidence ultimately
dismissed the petition by holding that the initial sale affected by
Podium Doolappa in favour of Maddu Pentayya was with prior
permission from Assistant Agent to Government as envisaged
under Section 4(1) of Act I of 1917, therefore, the transfer was
absolutely legal and not hit by Section 3(2)(i) of Regulation I of
1959 and as amended by Regulation I of 1970.
In the said
context, it is appropriate to refer to aforesaid specific finding from
the order dated 30.09.1978, which reads as under:
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
“It is clear from the recitals in Ex.B2 that the
petition schedule land belongs to Podium Doolappa, a
Koya, who sold them to the father of RW1 on 23.10.1943
after obtaining permission from the Asst. Agent to Govt.,
Kovvur in D.Dis.No.908/43, dated 13.09.1943. Further,
the land in question stands registered in the name of
Podium Doolappa in RSR of the Village. It is therefore
clear that Podium Doolappa had a valid right and title
over the lands in question and he sold them to the
predecessor in title of the respondent after obtaining
permission from the Agency authorities, as required
under Rule 4(1) of the Agency tracks, interest and land
transfer Act, 1970. Hence, the transfers of the land in
question are not hit by Sec.3(2)(a) of the A.P.S.A.L.T.
Reg.1/59 as amended by Reg.1/70.”
9.
Nearly after about two and half decades, a second
complaint came to be made under Section 3(2)(a) of Regulation
I of 1959 bearing S.R.No.68/2004 before the competent authority.
This time the complaint was instituted by none other than Deputy
Tahsildar with same set of allegations that the initial transfer of
subject land by Podium Doolappa, a tribe community, in favour of
non-tribe, was hit by the prohibition contained under the
Regulations.
The
competent
authority,
by
20.05.2025, yet again dismissed the complaint.
order
dated
This time the
competent authority observed that it did not have jurisdiction to
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
reopen the case, which otherwise came to be disposed of by the
very same authority in first enquiry and considering that the
subject land and the respondent against whom allegations were
made being one and the same, it also observed that proceeding
with the matter would clearly amounted to res judicata. The
relevant observations from aforesaid order are extracted as
under:
“It is settled law that the Special Deputy Collector
(T.W.) has no jurisdiction to re-open case which was
disposed off by the same court previously. The respondent
and the petition schedule land are one and the same in the
present case and the S.R.No.34/78.
In the circumstances explained above the claim filed
by the Special Deputy Tahsildar (T.W.)., K.R.Puram in
respect of petition schedule land is hereby dropped to avoid
resjudicata.”
10.
Both these orders were unchallenged and attained finality.
In this admitted background, the unofficial respondent once again
makes an attempt by instituting yet another complaint. This is
third round of enquiry on the same set of allegations. The
3rd respondent though being appraised of the previous orders
passed in S.R.No.34/1978 and S.R.No.68/2004, nevertheless
allowed the petition by holding that the initial sale affected by tribe
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
in favour of non-tribe was null and void as being hit by Regulation
I of 1959 as amended by Regulation I of 1970. The only reason
assigned for coming to such conclusion was that the purchasers
have not produced the copy of proceedings vide D.Dis.No.
908/1943, dated 13.09.1943, by which prior permission as
contemplated under Section 4(1) of Act I of 1917 was secured
before the sale came to be affected. The said order has been
assailed in the writ petition.
11.
The learned Single Judge refrained to go into merits of the
matter and rather rejected appellant/petitioner to avail alternative
remedy of appeal. We are of the opinion that probably learned
Single Judge would have been justified in adopting such course
of action, had it been a case of mere first enquiry going against
the appellant/writ petitioner. Peculiarly in the present case, the
1st complaint and enquiry initiated in S.R.No.34/1978, which was
nearly after 35 years of sale, ended in dismissal by detailed and
reasoned order, which attained finality.
Nearly, after 25 years
thereafter, yet again a second complaint and enquiry was initiated
at the instance of Deputy Tahsildar, which also came to be
dismissed on the ground that continuing second enquiry would
tantamount
to
res
judicata.
Merely
because
successive
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
complaints are being made, the competent authority is not
obligated to embark on deciding the same again and again,
subjecting the parties to inconvenience, such a course of action is
permissible only in exceptional cases where plea of fraud has
been raised and that too even in such cases only a second
enquiry would probably be permissible but definitely not a third
enquiry. This issue as to whether a second enquiry with respect
to same set of allegations is permissible fell for consideration of
this Court in couple of occasions. Coordinate Bench of this Court
in W.A. No.1419 of 2008, after considering various previous
precedents of this Court, has summarized aforesaid proposition
succinctly as under:“9. It is settled, in matters concerning transaction from a
tribal to a non-tribal, based on an allegation of fraud, that
second enquiry is permissible when first enquiry remained
inconclusive or findings in the first enquiry against the tribal
were recorded due to his incapacity to produce evidence.
However, when the first enquiry did not suffer from any
lacunae, the 2nd enquiry would be barred under the
principle of res judicata. This principle has been laid down
by this Court in Gaddam Raghavulu (supra) in the
following words:
“The principle of res judicata or a principle analogous
thereto
shall
be
applied
with
caution
and
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
circumspection in dealing with a case arising under
the Regulation meant for the protection of the tribes.
If the proceedings were dropped earlier for the
reason that the 3rd respondent-tribal could not
produce sufficient evidence, it does not preclude a
subsequent enquiry. Hence, I am not inclined to
accept the contention of the learned counsel in this
regard.”
11. Although the principle of res judicata was not
specifically dealt with in the Division Bench judgment in
Chintalapati Ramalinga Raju v. District Collector, Eluru,
W.G. District – 2000 (4) ALD 443(DB), it was specifically
observed therein that when a judgment is rendered under
the Regulations, it becomes final and there is no review of
the same; resultantly, if there is no review under the
Regulations, maintainability of the subsequent proceedings
would be barred by res judicata subject to the limitations,
as held by this Court in Gaddam Raghavulu (supra)”.
12.
Even in the present case, as could be seen from the
extracts of the orders passed in S.R.Nos.34/1978 and 68/2004,
specific findings have been recorded by competent authority that
the sale affected by tribal in favour of non-tribe was with prior
permission. Nothing has been pleaded either before the
competent authority nor even before this Court, which attributes
an element of fraud for invalidating or disbelieving the earlier
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
orders on the issue. When the findings and conclusions arrived
at in earlier enquiries attained finality, unless an allegation of
fraud is made, no further enquiry would be permissible.
The
enquiry now so undertaken by 3rd respondent in pursuance to the
complaint of unofficial respondent virtually amounted to reviewing
the view earlier expressed by the very same authority, which is
clearly impermissible. For whatever reason, when successive
orders of the very same authority were staring at, the least
expected of the 3rd respondent was to just stay off from the
proceedings but rather it chose to rehear the entire issue by
appreciating the evidence on record once again which is wholly
impermissible and beyond its jurisdiction.
13.
Apparently as the 3rd respondent embarked on entertaining
third complaint on very same set of facts, despite being made
aware of the two earlier enquires resulting in dismissal, virtually
tantamounted to exercising a power of review which otherwise
not conferred on it, clearly it exceeded the jurisdiction. In that
view of the matter, we are of the opinion that the self-imposed
restriction of exercising discretionary jurisdiction under Article 226
in cases where an alternative remedy is available would not come
in way of deciding the present case. We, therefore, are not in
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
agreement with the view expressed by the learned Single Judge
in relegating the petitioner to avail alternative remedy.
14.
Though learned counsel for the unofficial respondent tried
to address the Court that until and unless the copy of the
permission granting exemption under Section 4(1) of Act I of 1917
is produced, the burden caste on appellant/writ petitioner do not
get discharged to conclusively establish that the transfer was
valid, in our opinion has no substance and it is too late to raise
such objections particularly when the issue has already been
decided by holding that the sale was absolutely in accordance
with the provisions of Regulations.
15.
The correctness or otherwise of the finding and decision
arrived at by competent authority way back in the year 1978 and
2005 cannot now be reopened by the competent authority under
the guise of further enquiry. The competent authority at the very
first instance has rendered finding that the very recital in the sale
deed dated 23.10.1943 categorically stated that the sale was
being executed after obtaining prior permission from Assistant
Agent to Government and has provided the proceedings details
by referring to D.Dis.No.908/1943, dated 13.09.1943.
Merely
because the proceedings could not be traced out at this length of
CGR, J
W.A. No.1342 of 2025
time, no presumption can be drawn that the said permission
never existed at all.
Therefore, the objection of counsel for
unofficial respondent cannot be countenanced.
16.
We hereby allow the writ appeal by setting aside both the
orders of learned Single Judge as well as the orders passed by
the 3rd respondent.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending in this case, if
any, shall stand closed.
DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
ss
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review